10 ms·
I find it morally agreeable in the small but am worried about the larger implications. Other than my agreeing with the moral position in this case, how is this
by sokoloff 5y ago
I find it morally agreeable in the small but am worried about the larger implications.
Other than my agreeing with the moral position in this case, how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer?
We can’t reasonably be making “this type of refusal to do business is okay, but that one is not” based on moral agreements of individuals, especially when it comes to utility and infrastructure providers (which arguably bakers of cakes are not).
- prezjordan 5y agoIf by "some particular customer" you mean a protected group, we've already figured out this distinction in the United States: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group#United_States
- Dma54rhs 5y agoProtected class is purely social construct.
- WastingMyTime89 5y agoSociety is purely a social construct. The fact that some things exist solely because we collectively agree they do doesn't make them less real. I still can pay my rent using money. I need a passport to enter another country. You will have issue with the authorities if you discriminate a protected group.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoThere's nothing stopping considering pro lifers or whatever they want to be called to include in that list, hell why not even under religion. Just some judge has to stamp it.
- emodendroket 5y agoIf this is your view quit worrying about precedent at all, given that it is no less a social construct.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoMaybe it's the vigilantism?
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoThe list of protected groups is written into law by the legislature, not made up by a judge.
- SantalBlush 5y agoUnalienable rights are a purely social construct. Business is a purely social construct. Property is a purely social construct. Law is a purely social construct.
- heliodor 5y agoInfrastructure: GoDaddy has plenty of competition. Facebook and Google don't.
- ericmay 5y ago> which arguably bakers of cakes are not Sure but at what point is it inconvenient enough that the bakers are infrastructure? Like if there is a single baker in a town and the next one is idk 20 miles away? “Bake a cake at home” “Buy a computer and host the website yourself”
- pavlov 5y agoDid you read the article? GoDaddy is kicking out the site because it violates their terms of service concerning collection of private data. The TOS is a contract which the Texan group had signed with GoDaddy. They can sue if they believe they’re not actually in violation. This is nothing like the case of not selling a wedding cake to someone in a protected category.
- iNate2000 5y agoAren’t political or religious groups protected?
- pavlov 5y agoGoDaddy isn’t saying “we don’t sell our service to Sikhs.” They’re selling the service to everyone with the same terms, and the Texan group’s religious beliefs are irrelevant to their violation of the TOS.
- input_sh 5y agoProtected from GoDaddy's ToS? No, why would anyone be?
- alpaca128 5y agoThis has absolutely nothing to do with religion. Unless the Texans protesting against abortion are surprisingly not Christians but members of some other faith that forbids abortion. Some may claim abortion is against some vague "christian values" but those people either didn't read their own holy book or use it as a thinly veiled excuse to oppress other people.
- rsynnott 5y agoThey may be protected from discrimination, depending on local law. They’re not allowed demand that a company sell them something that it would not ordinarily sell to anyone, though.
- d_e_solomon 5y agoPolitical groups are not a protected class. https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/can-employers-discriminate-based-on-political-beliefs-or-affiliation.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/can-employers-discri...
- paulgb 5y agoAs far as I can tell, GoDaddy did not add the section to the ToS that prohibits services from “violat[ing] the privacy or publicity rights of another User or any other person or entity [...]” in response to this site, so unless you either think that this site did not do that, or that GoDaddy does not have the right to have and enforce a ToS, I don't see what the problem is. The idea that GoDaddy should need to make an exception to their ToS when a case is politically charged is scarier, IMHO.
- pseudo0 5y agoGoDaddy also hosts crimestoppersusa.org, a site that has functioned as a similar "snitch line" for years, yet they have not been terminated for violating the ToS. The exception seems to be this enforcement action. Also, it's definitely not clear that reporting a perceived violation of Texas statute would be a violation of privacy rights.
- aaomidi 5y agoBecause these are massively different and we have to be fucking happy that when the courts have failed us there's at least some basic decency in companies. Anyone working with the abortion ban of Texas should be publicly humiliated and BDSed. This is to an extent what dual power in the US looks like.
- pseudo0 5y agoIt looks awfully similar to me. In both cases these are private entities that allow users to confidentially submit tips about potentially illegal behavior. And the "medical procedures" bit discussed below seems like a pretty blatant deflection. If someone were doing back-alley kidney transplants, would anyone really object to that being reported to Crime Stoppers? Or perhaps more plausibly, someone illegally performing FGM on their child? https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/detroit-emergency-room-doctor-arrested-and-charged-performing-female-genital-mutilation https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/detroit-emergency-room-doctor...
- 5y ago
- JulianMorrison 5y agoOne of them is booting a site off for being evil, and the other is evil people trying to refuse service because of bigotry. It's really easy if you don't try and make perfect abstract rules, and remember that context is important.
- krona 5y agoReligious arguments about 'good' and 'evil' are exactly what the people you disagree with are doing.
- unclebucknasty 5y ago>...how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer? Yes, the argument can be made in these cases that there are two sides, so someone's rights are being violated either way. But, there does seem to be a consistent quality here that the particular "infringed" right of one side is the "right" to deny others' rights. Might that be the difference?
- emodendroket 5y agoThe ship on this sailed a long time ago. Hosting providers have refused to host content they consider objectionable for a long time. I think you could probably reasonably make a distinction between serving as a publisher for someone else and providing a service like baking.
- fidesomnes 5y agoyou have no moral position in this case because your position is not moral.
- blondin 5y ago> how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer? very interesting question! what sort of "term of services" are we implicitly agreeing on when ordering a cake or any other food?
- bobthechef 5y ago> Other than my agreeing with the moral position in this case, how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer? What this illustrates is that liberalism only "works" incidentally when people share the same ethos and moral standards or who submit to the ruling ethos and moral standards in relevant conduct, as it were. As those diverge, mutual coexistence becomes increasingly impossible. That's why libertarianism is such a joke.
- fendy3002 5y agoIMO it's closer with the blitzchung and nba controversy with china lately. They have possibility of losing other customers when they didn't do this. Furthermore I believe GoDaddy has already assessed the potential loss, made customer comparison between both parties and concluded this is better financially. EDIT: additionally, they may also compared the hosting plan with the spam attacks and PR attacks they get. Personally and morally I don't know whether this is the right thing or not, but financially I believe this is.
- nonameiguess 5y agoIt's worth noting that the US Supreme Court upheld the right of those bakers to not serve cake at a gay wedding, 7-2. Title VII protections tend to be applied to housing and employment discrimination, not restricting the general right of business owners to freedom of association with respect to who they'll take on as customers.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoThey didn’t rule on freedom of association. They ruled that the commission demonstrated anti-religious bias. It was a very narrow ruling for this particular case, and not on the larger question.
- nonameiguess 5y agoThat is true, and frankly it seemed pretty cowardly on the part of the court to do that. Nonetheless, I can't think of much in the way of contrary rulings short of forced desegregation, which was a pretty special case because black customers weren't just being denied service by one provider, but systematically by all providers in an entire multi-state region of the country. Most shops come with a sign posted saying they can refuse to serve you for any reason whatsoever, including total personal whim, and that doesn't get challenged.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoRemember that the baker in that case wasn't even refusing to sell them a cake. The couple could choose any cake in the shop, and the baker was willing to make them a cake for almost any occasion - he just objected to making a customized cake specifically for a gay wedding, kind of like if you were a baker and didn't want to make a cake for the American Nazi Party or the KKK or the pro-lifers next door or the Mayor you oppose. If they wanted a generic cake and wanted to buy icing to decorate it themselves, he was still willing to sell them one.
- nonameiguess 5y ago
- roenxi 5y agoHeh, I find it morally disagreeable in the small but I agree with the larger implications. Businesses don't have to do business if they don't want to. Tough for this website, sucks to be discriminated against for a political belief. It isn't like there is a shortage of domain registrars in the world. If there is a legal technicality where someone has to vote Democrat to start a domain registrar then there is a problem here. VeriSign doing this would be a concern. Unless I'm misreading this it isn't troubling; GoDaddy is not that important. It'd be sad if the DNS system becomes political. But at this point we should be bracing for it, there aren't a lot of future paths where it stays neutral.
- skohan 5y ago> It'd be sad if the DNS system becomes political There's already precedent for this. Cloudflare de-listed a major neo-nazi website a few years ago if I recall correctly. As much as I might loath one website or another, I think basic web infrastructure, from DNS to certs to even cloud services should be treated as common carriers, and it should only be by legal order that they're allowed deny services to a particular site. There's so much consolidation going on that we're not so far from a situation where a hand-full of corporations are the defacto gatekeepers of online life.
- arwineap 5y agoI agree with you to some extent, but we have to agree on a line somewhere. For instance, I don't think cloudflare is required to host a site. Millions of entities online are able to function without cloudflare or godaddy. So where do we draw the line for basic web infrastructure? To me it seems like the ISP is a good place to start. If you have internet, you could host a site on hardware yourself, or with a minor hire
- skohan 5y agoYeah I don’t think it’s quite good enough. In the 19th century we could have let railroads play favorites, because after all it was still possible to transport goods by canal or by wagon, but it was much better for the growth of the US for everyone to have a fair shot at the best form of freight transit available. Sure it’s possible to get your own fiber connection, manage your own hardware and host a web company, but you’re never going to be able to compete with another party who has access to AWS or GCP to run on top of.
- whateveracct 5y ago> Other than my agreeing with the moral position in this case, how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer? > We can’t reasonably be making “this type of refusal to do business is okay, but that one is not” based on moral agreements of individuals We actually can. And the difference between this and the baker is in the details you omitted. The actual baker situation was denying a customer based on their sexual orientation. That type of refusal is not okay and the reason why is pretty well-established in the law. Sexual orientation (like religion, race, sex, etc) is protected from such discrimination. And the baker was allowed to not serve the gay wedding anyways! Despite that! Being pro-life is not a protected attribute. You could argue these pro-life beliefs are due to religion..but this isn't about Jesus Christ Himself. This is a political opinion derived from the church that plenty of Christians don't have.
- _dain_ 5y ago>The actual baker situation was denying a customer based on their sexual orientation. That type of refusal is not okay and the reason why is pretty well-established in the law. Sexual orientation (like religion, race, sex, etc) is protected from such discrimination. This is not true. They were perfectly happy to bake a cake for gay people; they objected to baking the cake specifically for a gay wedding. The cake was to have wording which the bakers disagreed with for religious reasons.
- waterside81 5y agoYour clarification is important and I've seen all too often these past few days a critical misunderstanding of the case. The baker offered the couple any other cake in the shop and offered to bake any cake they wanted - other than one specifically for a gay wedding.
- whiddershins 5y agoThis is a misunderstanding. Being gay is protected, as is being Christian, both. Demanding a cake that expresses certain beliefs such as celebrating gay marriage or trangenderism or any other thing may not be protected by law. Just as demanding to be sold hosting services for your anti-abortion hotline based on your Christian beliefs probably isn’t protected by law.
- chrsig 5y agoI think it's worth considering that this isn't just any particular customer or individual -- it's a state government. I don't think private businesses should be obligated to work with any government for any reason.
- PEJOE 5y agoWhere is the line? The defense production act?
- chrsig 5y agoI think that'd be a ripe thing for SCOTUS to determine (though, I personally don't trust them to determine much right now, so ymmv) There's probably a good argument that the government should have to invoke eminent domain and proceed with manufacturing themselves. I can't say that I've put an excess of thought into the matter, though.
- philipov 5y agoThe difference is that political opinions are not a protected class, while race, gender is. What is the justification for having protected classes? You can pick your opinions, but you can't pick to be a different gender.
- rsynnott 5y agoThis is completely different. The baker bakes cakes for some people. GoDaddy presumably doesn’t support the non-consensual collection of private information for vigilante harassment for _anyone_. Not that the weirdos behind this site are a protected group, but even if they were, they couldn’t demand that a bakery, say, sell them plastic explosives, only things that it sells to other people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- StephenJGL 5y ago"morally agreeable in the small" is complex phrasing for "aligns with my bias"? Yes?
- koonsolo 5y ago> how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer? This is not refusing a customer, but more refusing an ingredient on customers request: "I know you request to have shit in your cake, but we're not going to do that."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whiddershins 5y agoThat was exactly the situation of the baker, despite much confusion around this topic.
- dubcanada 5y agoIt's a business, they can refuse who ever they want (same as the cake business). Sure a bunch of people might get angry, but if GoDaddy disagrees with the business, kick them off. It's always been this way, I am not sure why people are caring about it now. GoDaddy has kicked thousands of sites/customers off their platform for a variety of reasons. It's not like GoDaddy is the only option.
- adventured 5y ago> It's a business, they can refuse who ever they want (same as the cake business). No they can't. There are plenty of restrictions on denying service. An obvious example: you can't refuse to serve people based on their race. And since the door is open on disallowing such, a lot of other arguments are made and will be made in regards to who it's ok to not serve. Which is what's going on here with regards to GoDaddy's actions. Since the US is rapidly shifting to a hyper tribal, protected classes system of rule of law (different laws for different people), you can expect the rules/laws pertaining to situations like this in business to get more complex over time.
- verall 5y ago> There are plenty of restrictions on denying service. The restriction, is literally, "You cannot refuse service to people in a protected class." The burden of proof is on the person who was refused to show that, beyond a reasonable doubt, the reason that they were refused was due to them being within a protected class. It's not a low bar to clear. It has been this way since the civil rights movement. > Since the US is rapidly shifting to a hyper tribal, protected classes system of rule of law (different laws for different people). You don't have any understanding of the jurisprudence here, this is embarrassing.
- dubcanada 5y agoYou can and people do it all the time, what you are not allowed to do is say "sorry I can't serve you cause you have a different skin color", but you can certainly say "sadly due to our terms we cannot serve you because we cannot serve people who are born in North Colorado because we get to much fraud from North Colorado". There is tons of ways to "not serve" people. Just try not to be an outright racist and you're fine. A business with a terms of service that you signed always says "Random Business has the right to refuse service for blah blah".
- pyuser583 5y agoThe new law lets anyone sue someone (other than a medical staff) who “abet” an abortion. So the “reporting” would be on someone other than the person having an abortion. Let’s say, a boyfriend who pays for an abortion. The person doing the reporting is someone other than the “abettor” or the person getting an abortion. Let’s say the boyfriends ex-wife. Once a certain number of people know about something, it’s not private. Even current medical privacy laws, and including abortion laws, don’t create any privacy obligations for non-commercial third partied, much less fourth parties. If my ex-boyfriend tells me he helped his girlfriend get an abortion, I have no obligations to keep this secret. As it should be. This website allowed fourth parties to communicate with fifth parties (Texas Right to Life). Think about this: someone is informing an anti-abortion organization about an abortion. At this point the cat is out of the bag. It’s not a secret. It’s in the open. It’s public. Imagine if social media organizations decided to treat abortions the same way they treat CSAM, revenge porn, the identity of intelligence officers, nuclear secrets, copyright violations, and misinformation about COVID. Is that what we want? Some people do. I’m sure there’s a constituency for that. But notice how the we are descending down a slope. Maybe we should be doing that. But let’s do it with our eyes open and with rigorous debate that results in action. That’s not how GoDaddy approached this.
- TchoBeer 5y ago>We can’t reasonably be making “this type of refusal to do business is okay, but that one is not” based on moral agreements of individuals I totally disagree, that seems completely reasonable to me. Are we not allowed to say that doing something moral is okay but doing something immoral is not ok?
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoIs it not immoral to break the law even if the law is immoral? What if said policy makers believe what you consider "not immoral" to be just that, immoral? Wouldn't they be on the side of correct morality? This is why the logic of "who is more moral" fails because someone believes they're safeguarding "true" morality. Hence why we are a nation of laws and institutions that upholds or challenges them. Which is why I disagree with you, it is unreasonable (even though it's not why GoDaddy dropped them). If the law is immoral/unjust, take it to court. Otherwise shut up and deal with it. That's what civil rights leaders did back in the 60's. They didn't just whine on twitter.
- Falling3 5y ago> Is it not immoral to break the law even if the law is immoral It is not. > If the law is immoral/unjust, take it to court. Otherwise shut up and deal with it. That's what civil rights leaders did back in the 60's. Have you really not heard of civil disobedience?
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoMaybe the conservatives are civilly being disobedient to a law they consider immoral. See how your logic can be turned against you?
- notafraudster 5y agoI'm not sure it's accurate to say that civil rights leaders "shut up" and didn't "whine". Most of their work was public issue advocacy in the form of marches, boycotts, speeches, news communication, media advocacy, op-eds, etc. I tend to think of the Birmingham Bus Boycott, the March on Washington, and the Selma March (Bloody Sunday) as probably the single most crucial acts of civil rights leaders. I'm also not sure it's accurate to say people aren't taking this law to court. In fact, they did that before the law became law. Then the Supreme Court declined to enjoin the law. Then they managed to enjoin literally this group from enforcing the law, as part of the legal process that's currently unfolding.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> Other than my agreeing with the moral position in this case, how is this different than a baker not making a cake for some particular customer? You can refuse service to someone because you don't like the color of their shirt, but it's illegal to refuse service to someone belonging to a protected class because they belong to a protected class. "Abortion reporting form operators" are not a protected class, and they aren't being denied service because they belong to a protected class.
- whiddershins 5y agoTo be clear the cake maker didn’t refuse to bake a cake for gay people. The cake maker refused to bake a cake depicting a gay wedding. Regardless of the protected class status of whoever was ordering it. People get this wrong all the time about this story.
- Retric 5y ago[edit:] The depiction was never discussed, it was about the wedding not the cake. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colorado_Civil_Rights_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colora... informing the couple that he did not create wedding cakes for marriages of gay couples owing to his Christian religious beliefs, although the couple could purchase other baked goods in the store. Craig and Mullins promptly left Masterpiece without discussing with Phillips any of the details of their wedding cake. In other words he was unwilling to provide any cake for this purpose regardless of what was shown on it. The law isn’t that literal for good reason. Put another way saying it’s ok to reject a mortgage because it’s a black mortgage rather than a black applicant is silly. It’s clear in the case the rejection was based on sexual orientation. A bakery can’t reject an order because it’s for a religious ceremony due to the religion associated with that ceremony. However, it’s likely a bakery could reject being part of any wedding independent of religion or sexual orientation. Anyway, the same baker is in court over refusing to make birthday cake for transgender woman.
- gmadsen 5y agoim not following the analogy. What is a black mortgage?
- tw04 5y ago"I disagree with abortion" isn't a protected class. That's how we reasonably make the distinction.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoIt's okay because the private company is supporting liberal theology. When it's a conservative decision, it's evil and should be abolished.
- Riverheart 5y agoThis wasn't about being pro/anti abortion, this is about them violating GoDaddy's ToS. Although I'm sure they weren't heartbroken over enforcing it. "You will not collect or harvest (or permit anyone else to collect or harvest) any User Content (as defined below) or any non-public or personally identifiable information about another User or any other person or entity without their express prior written consent"
- amalcon 5y agoThis is a refusal to participate in a process explicitly designed to make it harder for people to assert their Constitutionally-protected rights, by arranging such that there's nobody to take to court to protect those rights. That's how it's different. The cake-purchaser is not a government trying to use the cake as a shield against civil rights litigation.