10 ms·
> The state of Victoria announced a curfew and suspended its Parliament for key parts of the pandemic. “To put this in context, federal and state parliaments sa
by josephcsible 5y ago
> The state of Victoria announced a curfew and suspended its Parliament for key parts of the pandemic. “To put this in context, federal and state parliaments sat during both world wars and the Spanish Flu, and curfews have never been imposed,” the scholar John Lee observed in an article for the Brookings Institution.
The Spanish Flu was unquestionably more dangerous than COVID is. What changed in society that so many people are now willing to give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety?
- djbebs 5y agoThey were disarmed.
- AndrewBissell 5y agoThere are similar restrictions being imposed without much pushback in many well armed countries around the world. I think it has more to do with everyone now getting so much of their information about the world from little handheld 24/7 psyop machines. There also wouldn't have been nearly so much acceptance of lockdowns if large swaths of people weren't able to continue earning a good living working entirely from home, something which really only became possible over the past 10 or 20 years. On a deeper level, I think many people in our modern civilization are in the grip of a paralyzing denial and fear of death, which makes it easier to corral them in one direction or another by just gesturing at the possibility of it.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> in many well armed countries I assume you're referring the United States - it's worth noting that the well-armed states like Texas and Florida have rejected draconian restrictions while mostly disarmed states like California and New York might as well be Australia.
- mwint 5y agoAdd Idaho to the well-armed-and-free list. While we didn’t do quite as well as Florida on the non-draconian front, things were normal-ish here far before many other states. Though the correlation is heavily confounded, obviously. Red states by definition have a bunch of conservatives, who both despise lockdowns and are more likely to have guns. So it’s unclear how much firearms matter, strictly.
- cweagans 5y agoAre we living in the same Idaho? The governor just activated the national guard. We only have 4 ICU beds left in the entire state as of three days ago. Just today, we had more covid cases than in April, May, and June 2020 combined. “Well-armed-and-free”? Things aren’t “normal” here. Our hospitals are barely able to function because this state is full of chucklefucks who think everything is a conspiracy. This isn’t freedom. This is stupidity. But hey, at least you have your guns.
- mwint 5y agoI didn’t mean everything _is_ normal, I mean we (mostly) aren’t being forced by the government to alter our behavior on an individual level. Different things.
- cweagans 5y agoI mean, you claimed that things were normal-ish here before other states. There wasn’t much nuance there, but whatever. A government just looking the other way and letting people die for purely ideological reasons is not something to be proud of. Altering our behavior on an individual level is exactly what needs to happen during a pandemic.
- chillwaves 5y agoThey didn't reject them with guns. Also I don't believe statistics exist for which states have more guns than others. And I also don't think your comment has any kind of real basis in research as to correlation between COVID lock downs and gun ownership, other than conservative voters being anti-everything in regards to coronavirus.
- Supermancho 5y ago> our modern civilization are in the grip of a paralyzing denial and fear of death I don't believe the US version of "Modern Society", for lack of a better term, is in denial of death. There is an overblown expectation of informed consent. If I cross the street, I have been informed I might be hit by a vehicle. Look both ways, minimize the danger. It's still there though. If I have a child, they have to be educated, which generally means they have to go to a public school, where I have been informed they will get a minimal education. I was NOT informed that someone might come in and shoot my kid. Now we have drills and I have been informed, so it's all ok again. COVID was sensationalized and (in the US) people felt like they had no information, so there was no informed consent as to when and where to go out safely. This is the reason COVID has been blown out of proportion. The information was initially unavailable, then it has been changing. This fails the basic tenet of Modern Civilization. We are informed about dangers to make our own behavioral linear optimizations. Next up, vaccines and informed consent. Then people are still getting sick. There are news outlets playing it up as if the information was possibly bad and might change again. What constitutes informed consent is not uniform and people argue about it and politicize it. The problem is that the news about the virus was as direct as the WHO (it's endemic, everyone will get it eventually) a bunch of messaging gets amplified or contradicted and the political ramifications are too high now. Note, even though the messaging shifted similarly in the relatively small area of Israel, there was uniform behavior. They also don't pull punches when it comes to informing the population about dangers, which the US tends to do. This is because the media runs wild with anything they are given (how could it be worse?! is it overblown!? et al)
- jvanderbot 5y agoThis. They were politically or philosophically unwilling to push back against these measures. They were spineless and didn't use the tools of voting, discourse, or protest that are how change is brought in modern society. Instead, they accepted these measures as necessary myopically without thinking about how they could be abused. They were far too trusting and completely disarmed of healthy skepticism. So, I agree. Disarmed. Guns (which I assume you were talking about) would not have changed anything in a mentally-permissive environment in which these laws were not protested. You need a spine first, and a tool second, and a gun last.
- klyrs 5y agoBy and large, they disarmed themselves. To say "they were disarmed" glosses over the overwhelmingly voluntary nature of the reduction in gun rights.
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y ago“Voluntary” can also mean compulsory. Unless you’re willing to risk going to prison or having your livelihood destroyed by not turning in your weapons.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eplanit 5y agoAustralia and Venezuela are the 2 best most recent examples of why the 2nd Amendment is so unique and important.
- handrous 5y agoI'm on the look-out for examples of private firearms preserving liberty and democratic government. Have any? Post-WWI strongly preferred. (serious question)
- eplanit 5y agoBoth of those countries disarmed their citizens relatively recently -- and now, neither is an example of liberty.
- handrous 5y agoNegative examples don't work too well, since I can point at, say, the US at many points and say "doesn't look like a great example of liberty"—meanwhile, progress toward such doesn't seem to have had much to do with our having lots and lots of private firearms. Meanwhile, there are plenty of relatively "disarmed" countries that remain quite free. So what factor, if any, do private arms play in the preservation of liberty and democracy? That's what I'm trying to get at. We take it as true that the 2nd amendment is absolutely vital to maintaining freedom, but... is there any reason to think that's true? I'm genuinely trying to figure that out.
- linksnapzz 5y agoAfghanistan.
- handrous 5y agoUm. > examples of private firearms preserving liberty and democratic government.
- 5y ago
- im_down_w_otp 5y agoI assume it's the difference in what one felt like they had to lose from the perspective of any random person in 1918 and any random person in 2021?
- CJefferson 5y agoPerhaps, people didn't fully understand how much their safety could be improved by avoiding contact?
- Sevii 5y agoIn 1920 people would have starved if we tried to do lockdowns like we have done in 2020.
- AndrewBissell 5y agoIn the developing world millions are in fact being pushed into starvation as a result of the Covid lockdowns.
- betwixthewires 5y agoPeople did starve from lockdowns in 2020.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoWhere?
- nradov 5y agoLockdowns have caused a huge increase in food insecurity and chronic hunger. https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/agriculture/brief/food-security-and-covid-19 https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/agriculture/brief/food-se...
- zo1 5y agoFood from school lunches are a big one that got impacted. https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/nutrition-crisis-looms-more-39-billion-school-meals-missed-start-pandemic-unicef-and https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/nutrition-crisis-looms...
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThats a political choice, in the first world we could make sure every homeless person gets 3,000 calories, and not spend 1% of gdp
- therealdrag0 5y agoI would guess the practical inconvenience. There is a much larger part of the labor force now that can work remote. And with electronic entertainment and deliverable goods, the burden of a lockdown is much less on much more people than 100 years ago. Also I don’t know how the safety net compares to back then, but unemployment etc softens the blow even more.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoAntibiotics hadn’t been invented in the 1910s, so there were quite a few untreatable potentially deadly diseases in circulation. In the modern era, rightly or wrongly, a lot of people see it as a good and achievable goal that they shouldn’t ever get an infectious disease more serious than the flu.
- iammisc 5y agoLack of religion. To my religious parents, everyone dies someday and you live a good life. If it's God's time to call you home... You go. For my atheist in laws (same generation), death is terrifying. Every decision must be made around maximizing total number of years of their life at any expense to their children Edit: why is this flagged? Reasoned discussion of the effects of religious beliefs in after life is on topic, especially how it relates to covid.
- wmf 5y agoWhat Australia purchased was human lives, and not temporarily if the vaccines hold.
- himinlomax 5y agoWhat liberty are you talking about? You don't have the liberty to drive drunk; is this unacceptable for you as well?
- josephcsible 5y agoDriving kills people even when the driver isn't drunk, but we do have the liberty to drive in general.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- refurb 5y agoAs society becomes more wealthy and tackles the big health issues, they move down the list to the next one, and so forth. When I was growing up seat belts weren't mandatory and oh boy did people protest that change in the law. Not long ago I visited a developing country where nobody even thinks about wearing seatbelts. And I was aghast. How can they not take such a simple precaution. And child seats? They ride on motorbikes with their kids on the front with no helmet! The answer obviously is there are a lot more things that they worry about than getting into an accident. Things like losing their job and having to beg because there is no safety net. Things like getting sick and affording healthcare. And as medical treatments advance even further you'll see even more resources thrown at even smaller problems. That's just how it is - we tackle health issues at the margins and as we become more wealthy we're willing to sacrifice more resources to tackle smaller problems.
- hkai 5y agoIf cars and planes were invented today, they would be banned.