16 ms·
At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed since 1521
- nanis 5y ago> To be eligible to live in the village, applicants need to meet three basic criteria: they must demonstrate financial need, have lived in Augsburg for at least two years and be of Catholic faith. ... checks church registers to ensure they're Catholic So, standard economics at work: If prices are rigidly set at a low level, there will be rationing. There is the non-price rationing. > Roughly 160 residents live in the Fuggerei ... there are about 80 people on the waiting list ... applicants could be waiting years for a callback. And there is the persistent shortage.
- simlan 5y agoAnd your point is ?
- arvindamirtaa 5y agoThings cost money. Things that don't cost to buy at least as much as they cost to make, are not sustainable by definition and will be riddled with systemic problems like shortage, rationing, etc.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chongli 5y agoI think their point is that this isn't really social housing, it's a perk for a very exclusive group of people. Not all that different from a waiting list for membership to an exclusive golf course.
- true_religion 5y agoExclusive being the community of poeple who paid taxes (i.e. the church tithe) for at least 2 years before they fell on hard times? It's hardly charity or a perk. It's basically a local government service.
- csomar 5y agoIt doesn't work even though the article is trying to portray this as a functional model and a solution to the housing crisis. > Money for maintaining the village comes from investments in forestry, real estate and entrance fees. It is just a charity with religious requirements.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoIf shortage means it "doesn't work", it's not clear to me how exclusion based on income is any better, or indeed if these are actually substantially more than just two names for the same fundamental shortage problem.
- nanis 5y ago> exclusion based on income Exclusion based on price.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoNo, when there is any housing shortage it is a matter of empirical fact that landlords select on the income prospective renters can prove.
- gruez 5y ago>If shortage means it "doesn't work", it's not clear to me how exclusion based on income is any better because it provides some sort of objective measure for how badly you want it, and incentivizes/finances more housing developments.
- cool_dude85 5y agoAh, my shortages are good, your shortages are bad. Makes sense.
- gruez 5y agoI have a feeling you're being sarcastic, but that's exactly what I'm arguing for. If your city only has enough housing for 100,000 people, but there are 150,000 people who want to live there, there's going 50,000 who can't get a house. In other words, a shortage. That's bad, but that number is going to be the same regardless of how you're redistributing it. The question then becomes, can we make the best out of a bad situation? Distributing by price has benefits that I mentioned. What benefits does giving giving it for below-market prices to people whoever's first on a waiting list provide?
- alisonkisk 5y agoNot just rationing, but discriminating based on personal benefit to the provider. This is a soul-buying operation, ironic since Catholics aren't supposed to buy and sell souls.
- javert 5y agoSeems doubtful that the patron actually believed that people praying for him would help him in the afterlife. But maybe I'm totally misunderstanding the medieval mind.
- JackFr 5y ago> Seems doubtful that the patron actually believed that people praying for him would help him in the afterlife. Why does that seem doubtful? There are many people (myself included) who feel that way today.
- javert 5y agoWell, I'm aware that there are people that believe this stuff today. But Jakob Fugger, if you actually read about his life, does not appear to have a moral bone in his body in the Catholic sense. That informed my comment. I personally suspect the village was done for show or as some sort of appeasement, not out of genuine faith. Separately, I don't think we as a society that strives to be rational, should be open to claims of belief based on faith. I think they should be immediately discarded as arbitrary claims. Just an FYI, let's steer away from that particular topic (i.e. the legitimacy of believing some part of Catholic doctrine).
- corpdronejuly 5y agoYou are absolutely misunderstanding the medieval mind, and many modern religious minds. Many people today believe in the power of prayer for the dead to help the state of the souls of the departed. Not a majority, but enough that you probably know a few who don't speak about it precisely because of the incredulity people express when people actually believe their religion, especially Christianity.
- eesmith 5y agoIs rationing ... bad? How would raising the rent change the wait time for ground floor housing? By forcing poor people to move out because richer people want to move in? That doesn't sound like a good thing. According to standard economics, since there's a demand, why isn't there other, new housing along these lines - where costs are paid for by investments and entrance fees rather than rents?
- kiba 5y agoOnly 160 residents can live there, which only helps a small amount of people.
- nanis 5y ago> Is rationing ... bad? Yes. When a good or service is always available to anyone who can pay the price, all one needs to do is find the money and one can get it. When prices are set artificially low, both current and long term go down which results in perpetual shortages. Since getting the thing now depends not just on being able to come up with the cash, but relies on the pen of a bureaucrat, corruption seeps in and becomes endemic. This charity is able to get it done by requiring adherence to a specific religion which serves both as a selection and an enforcement mechanism. If one is tempted to think of generalizing this, I would recommend reading about both Western socialists waxing poetic about USSR's "solutions" to housing shortages and the reality of housing in the Soviet Union. Unfortunately, city & urban planning programs as well as architecture schools tend to produce a lot of credentialed people who parrot the former.
- jorvi 5y ago> Yes. When a good or service is always available to anyone who can pay the price, all one needs to do is find the money and one can get it. This sounds nice but breaks down because shelter is a human need, it is not a new iPhone. I am aware that the solution to housing crises is build build build, and that the more profit is in developing housing the more there is being built, but pretending a place to live is like any other common good is cold and wrong.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kiba 5y agoYeah. This is not really social housing. It does makes me wonder how low the price of social housing can go while still being sustainable either to be subsidized by the government or payable by tenants. Land use policies, that is transportation and housing makes up about 30% of the cost in the average American budget, which suggests living in America is pretty expensive.[1] 1. https://www.valuepenguin.com/average-household-budget https://www.valuepenguin.com/average-household-budget
- cies 5y agoCame to the same conclusion that "catholics only housing" cannot be social housing...
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoI wonder how strictly they check up on your mass attendance. I'm not sure the ethics of lying to pass an unethical religious-based test for housing, but it strikes me that there must be at least one resident that is not as dedicated to the church as most.
- tsbischof 5y agoIt could be as simple as checking tax records: in Germany, tithing is incorporated directly into tax declarations and payroll systems.
- cies 5y agoStill not very social if its "catholics only". That they're checking on your church attendance makes it all feel very bigbrothery to me. Non the less cool they manage to keep prices down: much lower than actual social housing operated by govt.
- nanis 5y ago> Social worker Doris Herzog is the first point of contact for most applicants. She checks church registers to ensure they're Catholic and interviews them on their living situation.
- jka 5y agoAre there any statistics on the number of units of livable accommodation in the world, per country?
- nanis 5y agoDefine "livable accommodation". That aside, in the U.S., there is https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/ahs.html https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/ahs.html
- jka 5y agoThank you very much - I think that shows that (for the US): - in 2015 there were an estimated 118,290k housing units - in 2017 there were an estimated 121,560k housing units - in 2019 there were an estimated 124,135k housing units (note that the majority of these -- more than 70,000k in each case -- are single, detached houses) Those are quite useful starting factors - roughly one housing unit per three persons in the population, and roughly 5% growth in capacity over four years. The next few steps would be to match those against population and property price trends, check for correlations, and perhaps narrow and regionalize the data to look for any notable outliers. (not sure when I'll get to those, but it'll be a good learning experience I'm sure)
- dbingham 5y agoThose things happen in markets with price signals too. Rationing and persistent shortage are happening in housing markets around the world broadly. It's kind of a given that any social housing like this is going to have a limited number of rooms. And as a result, only so many people will be able to live there. That's not some clear proof of market theory. Because the other half of market theory - about how price signals drive behavior of rational actors - doesn't hold up.
- thebean11 5y agoDo you have an example where rationing is occurring without price controls? I don't have experience outside of the US, but in the two US markets with probably the biggest housing shortages (SF, NYC, maybe Austin nowadays?), if you give me 8k a month I'll find an apartment tomorrow.
- syshum 5y agoIt is also unfair to blame market prices for the situation in NYC and SF as largely the price increases and shortages are driven by insane zoning and other regulations that makes building, maintaining, and turning over housing near impossible. That is not market forces, that is government controls
- lakis 5y agoGood luck going to Mount Athos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Athos#Access https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Athos#Access Money is not an issue. But unless your a man, you can't get in, period. Oh, you mean you want to live there. No problem, just change your religion. "Residents on the peninsula must be men aged 18 and over who are members of the Eastern Orthodox Church and also either monks or workers"
- nanis 5y ago> Good luck going to Mount Athos OK, so here we once again have a situation where the price mechanism is not allowed to operate. For a moment, I thought this was a private gated community in San Fransisco. > Mount Athos (/ˈæθɒs/; Greek: Άθως, [ˈa.θos]) is a mountain and peninsula in northeastern Greece and an important centre of Eastern Orthodox monasticism. It is governed as an autonomous polity within the Hellenic Republic. Mount Athos is home to 20 monasteries under the direct jurisdiction of the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople. Oh, another religious membership test. How is this at all pertinent to the functioning of the price mechanism? Especially when it is government enforced? > Although Mount Athos is legally part of the European Union like the rest of Greece, the Monastic State of the Holy Mountain and the Athonite institutions have a special jurisdiction which was reaffirmed during the admission of Greece to the European Community (precursor to the EU).[5] This empowers the Monastic State's authorities to regulate the free movement of people and goods in its territory; in particular, only males are allowed to enter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Athos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Athos
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoAh, Mr. Fugger, richest man in the world, the Catholic Church borrowed so much from him (and fleeced their followers so much in order to pay him back) that Martin Luther got so mad and nailed his manifesto to a church door and created Protestantism: https://nypost.com/2015/07/26/meet-historys-richest-man-who-changed-christianity/ https://nypost.com/2015/07/26/meet-historys-richest-man-who-... I wonder if his name is the origin of the swearword...
- morpheos137 5y agoSt. Peter's Basillica wasn't cheap. What Luther was specifically mad about was selling indulgences (certificates of forgivness for certain sins) to pay off Church debt.
- throwaway14356 5y agoare those transferable assets? i want one to mix in with the framed diplomas
- coldcode 5y agoIndulgences were not the big money maker for people at the top, it was selling benefices that made Popes and other church leaders rich, i.e. selling Church offices for huge sums (hey you want your nephew to be a Bishop or Cardinal, sending in X ducats). Why fleece poor people when you can fleece the rich, they have all the money.
- dmurray 5y agoWell, yeah, but you wanted your nephew to be a bishop or a cardinal not just for the prestige, but because he could sell or rent lower positions in his own diocese, or collect indulgences himself. It's feudalism all the way down.
- belter 5y ago"To be eligible to live in the village, applicants need to meet three basic criteria: they must demonstrate financial need, have lived in Augsburg for at least two years and be of Catholic faith." Is this legal? I mean the faith part...
- ginko 5y agoWhat's with all the completely unrelated keywords in the article link?
- Tomte 5y agoMy guess: the poster did a copy&paste mistake (the URL up to the last / is valid and shows the Afghanistan article), but the CMS used by CBC only looks at the last part, so it's still successful.
- Bootvis 5y agoIt's just how the site works, not a mistake by OP. If you go to the Afghanistan article and click to the link to the article you'll get the link that was posted to HN. I'm not sure why the previous page is tracked like this but I guess they have their reasons.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dansky 5y agoI walked around at the Fuggerei when I was in Augsburg back in 2019. Here is a video forwarding to the entrance: https://youtu.be/cECanw-2SQw?t=3100 https://youtu.be/cECanw-2SQw?t=3100
- IkmoIkmo 5y agoIn a world with ubiquitous housing, there is no need for social housing, because that which is ubiquitous (oxygen) is affordable. In a world with scarcity, social housing protects the poor against unaffordability. That's commendable. However, scarcity also means there is not enough for everyone. Inevitably that means you get a group of poor winners (who obtain a social home) and a group of and poor losers (who remain on a waiting list for a social home). Those on a waiting list are relegated to the non-social sector: paying market rates. The more social housing there is, the smaller the private housing market is, the higher the rent prices. Thereby, the scarcer the situation is, the more unaffordable housing is, the bigger the calls for social housing, and the more the differences between winners & losers is exacerbated. That's what we see develop in many cities . Some pay absolutely nothing, others pay way too much. The winners and losers group is often partially arbitrary. The benefits of rent-control are distributed unequally, some receiving rent-controlled benefits for decades, others remain on a waiting list for decades, while earning just as little. In many European cities waiting lists are >10y, in Amsterdam for example it's about 14y. Second, the benefits of rent-control take away various healthy market-based incentives. My dad for example lives on welfare in an apartment with 3 bedrooms, by himself in the capital city, and pays 1/3rd of the market rate. He has no incentive to seek out smaller housing which suits his needs just fine. Similarly, he does not make much use of the cultural offerings in the capital city that makes this place popular and expensive: theatre, bars, cinema, restaurants etc, he would be fine living in a smaller town without them. Yet, he has no incentive. A market based rent for my dad would indeed make it unaffordable for him. At the same time, the market price is a way to allocate supply & demand efficiently. My single retired dad has no demand for the size and location of his home, yet it is in extreme demand by others. The high market rate rent of say $2k a month, if applied, weeds out those who're unwilling to pay the price of $2k worth of opportunity costs (high value for my dad) in return for 3 bedrooms in the capital city (low value for my dad, who'd decide to move in), and lets those who's calculus is different (high value for young urban professionals) move in. Rent-control destroys that efficiency. Second, it obviously puts a cap on prices and rental returns. Price elasticity of supply is at least somewhat elastic (more in the US than say, the Netherlands, but still). If industry X has fixed prices and industry Y doesn't, ceteris paribus you'd expect most investments in production/supply of industry Y because the returns aren't capped. Rent-control in this sense can limit housing construction, exacerbating the problem further down the line. (This is less applicable to Europe which has more high-density built up areas that are more land-constrained than the US. As such, higher prices don't always translate into more construction, which means the downsides of rent-control are smaller in this respect). I'm a big fan of rent-control, but it has to be balanced with (partial) incentives. There seem to me some easy mechanisms that should be applied to bring more balance. 1) Rent-control is not enjoyed permanently, such as in many countries is the case. Instead, one gets 8 years of rent-control, after which you must move, or pay market rate. This brings balance to the current situation where one person has a rent-controlled apartment forever, and another is on a waiting list for 16 years. While de facto forced eviction after 8 years is obviously bad, it's a lesser evil compared to the above distribution of scarce rent-controlled units. 2) If a rent-controlled unit has 3 bedrooms and you live there alone, you lose some of the rent discounts. It's okay to live as you like, alone or with others. It's not okay to live alone in a home that can house multiple people, and expect others (the government/taxpayer or landlord) to subsidise you, while there's people on waiting lists for decades. We actually have a lot of real estate, in almost all countries the number of people per home has been dropping for decades, while the average home size has been increasing for decades. Yet there is a scarcity of housing, in part because people occupy larger homes than they need. Particularly if the home is subsidised and rent-controlled, that shouldn't be acceptable. 3) Rent-controlled rates should have market-based foundations. In the Netherlands for example, a rent-controlled unit in Amsterdam or a shrinking village of 500 people, is governed by the same maximum rental rates. Despite the fact that market rates might be 4-5x as high in Amsterdam. It's important to subsidise the poor. It's also important not to take away every single incentive, and create 1 price for a thousand different locations which are all in wildly different demand. If homes in city A and B are priced similarly due to rent-control, but many want to live in A, those who're indifferent to living in city A will occupy homes unnecessarily. If minor price differences are allowed and A is slightly more expensive than B, it'd incentivise those living in A who're indifferent to A or B, to move to B due to the lower prices, freeing up in-demand homes in A. Rent-control is commendable but it should allow for some level of market rates, still. Hope the post makes sense as some of it is written from an EU and even national/city-level perspective that doesn't apply everywhere in the same way.
- OneTimePetes 5y agoOne requirement is to do a "Fürbitte" aka a prayer for the fugger so he can get forgiveness and remain in heaven/ leave purgatory. At least that is what i ve heard.
- loeg 5y agoIt covers this in more detail in the article. > Original residents of the Fuggerei were asked to offer three prayers a day for Jakob Fugger and his family. … > "Jakob Fugger says they have to pray for him. Our administrator always says he is in heaven and will see if you do that. You are responsible for that," said Herzog. > In other words: that part of the deal is between residents and God.
- h0nd 5y ago1€ to live there for a year. 6.5€ to visit once. What is going on there?
- martin_a 5y agoThe Fuggerei is really nice to visit and walk around. There's also a little museum house so you can have a look inside one of the rather small houses and a permanent exhibit in the old bunker of the Fuggerei. Keeping it up and running is cross-financed by the entry fees. Also the 1 Euro is not the whole truth. Residents will have to pay so called "Nebenkosten" (auxillary costs) for electricity etc. like with any other flat. Compared to Augsburgs rent levels it's still very cheap to live but I'd prefer not to do so. Source: Lived down the street for a few years.
- ajay-b 5y agoIt is always helpful when you have a wealthy supporter.
- orblivion 5y ago> Residents pay about $1.30 — or 0.88 euros — per year for their apartments The Euro didn't exist in 1521. Wikipedia doesn't even list what the currency was back then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_of_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_of_Germany I suppose it would have been priced in some sort of metal back then, and the first official currencies would have been on a metallic standard.
- pweezy 5y agoFrom the original article: > Fugger charged residents one Rheinischer gulden a year, the equivalent of one month's salary at the time.
- orblivion 5y agoAh, sorry. I tried skimming and searching for some specific like that.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoNo shit sherlock...
- zaarn 5y agoBack then Germany didn't exist quite yet as country. Fugger charged people in Augsburg in Rheinische Gulden.
- orblivion 5y agoI was still expecting that Wikipedia would list the historical currencies in the area, and they did list some. Presumably there was continuity of culture over the centuries despite political bodies and boundaries.
- zaarn 5y agoHey I live just a street down from there. It's an interesting place and Fugger was certainly one of the more interesting people to grace the face of the earth, though it looses it's charm if you see it on your daily commute.
- peterburkimsher 5y agoLike happened with the Doom port to desk phones, this is being discussed over on the BeWelcome forums! https://bewelcome.org/forums/s23259/ https://bewelcome.org/forums/s23259/ BeWelcome is like CouchSurfing but free and open-source. I heard about the Fuggerei from Paul, a guy in Singapore, a few months ago, who I met at the Asia-Pacific weekly meetup (every Thursday, 23:00 NZDT = 6 pm Jakarta = 7 pm UTC+8). https://bewelcome.org/activities/3343 https://bewelcome.org/activities/3343 It's so interesting to hear the same topics coming up. Although I'm not Catholic, and the idea of segregating housing based on religious views bothers me, I like the idea of investing in a community by sharing freely. The Fuggerei outlasted several political forms in Germany!