10 ms·
Tupolev Tu-144: The Soviets' doomed rival to Concorde (2017)
- dang 5y agoOne previous comment: Concordski: What ever happened to Soviets' spectacular rival to Concorde? (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19021153 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19021153 - Jan 2019 (1 comment)
- jansan 5y agoIn Sinsheim/Germany there is a Tu144 on display right next to a Concorde. It really is a sight to behold and the museum is IMO a great place to visit (if you are a nerds). Here is a photo of the beauties: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/16/Concorde_und_Tu-144_Auto-_und_Technikmuseum_Sinsheim.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/16/Concorde...
- erk__ 5y agoIf you ever get around Sinsheim in Germany I would highly recommend a visit to the Sinsheim technology museum they have both a Tupolev [0] and a Concorde on top of their roof together with a lot of other interesting exhibitions. [0]: https://sinsheim.technik-museum.de/en/tupolev-tu-144 https://sinsheim.technik-museum.de/en/tupolev-tu-144
- Tomte 5y agoAnd you can go inside both!
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoHow? They're on the roof. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/16/Concorde_und_Tu-144_Auto-_und_Technikmuseum_Sinsheim.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/16/Concorde... edit There's a metal staircase: https://old.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/btze9j/my_picture_of_the_great_concorde_at_sinsheim/ https://old.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/btze9j/my_picture...
- Kognito 5y agoThe magic of.. stairs?
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoThe HackerNews guidelines are quite clear regarding snark. The stairs aren't easy to make out from that photo. Here's another photo that shows the metal staircase: https://old.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/btze9j/my_picture_of_the_great_concorde_at_sinsheim/ https://old.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/btze9j/my_picture...
- heavenlyblue 5y agoUnfortunately your initial comment comes off as a snark. On top of that you took your time to actually find a photo supporting your argument but didn’t bother searching for a photo of the entrance to the planes?
- MaxBarraclough 5y ago> On top of that you took your time to actually find a photo supporting your argument I did not. Please assume good faith. That image was linked by someone else in the thread. [0] Why would I deliberately seek out a photo that doesn't clearly show the staircase, only to then edit my comment to link to another image that does? > your initial comment comes off as a snark I don't know how I could have phrased the question to be any more neutral. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28336561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28336561
- erk__ 5y agoThe sister museum in speyer have a full 747 on some stilts https://www.flickr.com/photos/meteorry/49653977743 https://www.flickr.com/photos/meteorry/49653977743
- techdragon 5y ago
- doctor_eval 5y agoThere used to be a tour of the Airbus factory in Toulouse, where they made A380s, and at the end of the tour we took a bus across the tarmac and were able to walk around and go inside a Concorde. It was amazing. It is a much bigger plane on the outside than you might think. That wing is huge.
- notanote 5y agoThe Airbus factory has had a museum nearby since 2015, Aeroscopia [1]. It hosts two Concordes, among others (like the Super Guppy [2]). It has a pre-production Concorde (F-WTSB), used for test flights, and an Air France one (F-BVFC). It’s worth a visit for any aviation enthusiast. You used to be able to go inside the test flight one, but it’s a cramped space, so things might be different while covid regulations are in force. [1] https://www.toulouse-visit.com/aeroscopia-museum https://www.toulouse-visit.com/aeroscopia-museum [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aero_Spacelines_Super_Guppy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aero_Spacelines_Super_Guppy
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoIf you like that, you should definitely go to the Dayton Ohio AF museum where they have a Valkyrie. You can’t go inside it, unfortunately.
- bobthepanda 5y agopart of the reason for the Concorde's decline was the fairly tight cabin, which was likened by some to be almost bus-like. With the advent of lie-flat business class seats in the late 90s and early 2000s, Concorde became much less appealing since one could just fly a redeye to London and have a comfortable sleep than be cramped for a shorter period of time.
- jeffrallen 5y agoGo to Seattle's aviation museum and see for yourself. I'd call it "swanky bus", but yes, buslike.
- doctor_eval 5y ago
- hodgesrm 5y agoYou can also see a Tu-144 in Zhukovsky, a city about an hour by train from Moscow. [1] A lot of Soviet aviation development happened there. [1] http://www.rusaviainsider.com/zhukovsky-pays-tribute-venerable-tu-144-supersonic-airliner/ http://www.rusaviainsider.com/zhukovsky-pays-tribute-venerab...
- harywilke 5y agoLots of people have been having fun in the parking lot. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Technik+Museum+Sinsheim/@49.2389946,8.8981662,258m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x0:0x9fb2eb226944dd63!8m2!3d49.238784!4d8.8972426 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Technik+Museum+Sinsheim/@4...
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoInteresting part of cold war rivalry between the US and USSR amusingly won by Europeans. The American Concorde never even left the design stage so at least the Tupolev got that going for itself.
- evgen 5y agoGiven how much the EU pissed away on a useless airplane that did not lead to any future orders beyond the initial set I would not exactly say that the EU 'won' this competition. The only way to win this game was not to play and earlier you bailed out on consumer SST the better off the end result.
- mopsi 5y agoThe European aerospace industry absolutely won it. Concorde established anglo-french cooperation, known today as Airbus. Many innovative features (such as electric flight controls) introduced in Concorde were further developed in the following Airbus A300 and reached their full potential in A320, which is the highest-selling airliner in the world and has exceptional safety record. A300 in particular was so ahead of its time that American airlines saw it as being too good to be true. An airliner much safer, efficient and reliable than any counterpart couldn't get a single sale for years until Airbus gave a few to Eastern Airlines for free (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ln-ffJM9sJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ln-ffJM9sJc).
- panick21 5y agoThat might be the case, but that doesn't mean the plane was a success. That means the reorganization of the industry was a success.
- evgen 5y agoThat is a nice story to tell yourself, but it is not actually what happened. Concorde was more about tying the UK into the European Economic Community and the future EU. The Aerospatiale/BAC partnership that developed the Concorde existed in parallel to Airbus and it was only much later that Airbus took over a lot of the operational maintenance of Concorde when it acquired Aerospatiale entirely in 2000. Concorde was not an Airbus aircraft. Tech developed for Concorde was not the same fly-by-wire that ended up in the A300 line. The A300 line is very good, but would have (probably) existed without Concorde and the money pissed away on Concorde by Aerospatiale and BAC did nothing for either company other than weaken them and lead to BAC disappearing into BAE. (BAE, the weakened Aerospatiale and what was left of Messerschmidt previously had been pushed by their respective governments to join into Airbus.) When BAC still existed as an independent company in the late 60s it lobbied the UK government to not support the A300 program and instead tried to push its own competing civilian airliner. Maybe if Concorde was not such a failure then Aerospatiale might have been able to continue on its own and BAC would not have been forced to be acquired by BAE and become a part of the Airbus group. In this imagined reality both would have continued as national aerospace champions in civilian planes in addition to their military work, but we will never know.
- einpoklum 5y agoThe USSR's call to develop and produce the Tu-144 seems to have been a mistake - in hindsight naturally, but also at the time: The European Concorde was targeted at the rich, whose time was so precious that they absolutely had to get across the world much faster. The USSR was a poorer country, and though it too was stratified (to bureaucrats with country Dacha's etc.) - it did not have a jet-set of multi-millionaires to cater to as air travelers. Plus, I believe international travel both within and outside of the "Soviet block" was much more limited generally. So there was simply not going to be demand for it. Combine that with the significant technical challenges and chance of accidents and I just don't see how that makes sense. But - I'm no "Sovietologist", so do enlighten me if I'm wrong about this!
- andi999 5y agoAnother aspect is that you can only fly over sea (since the sonic boom is too noisy). So the routes would have been limited probably to only go from Moskow to Wladiwostok, or best to Japan. But there would probably be no supersonic flight allowed to go across central Europe.
- azov 5y agoThere was no regulation prohibiting overland supersonic flights over USSR (and hearing sonic booms from military jets was pretty common in some areas)
- andi999 5y agoYes, but ppl wouldnt put up with it. Like Saudi Arabia withdrew flight rights after Nomads complained that it was upsetting their Camels. https://mainlymiles.com/2021/06/03/singapore-airlines-concorde-the-full-story/#2-india-refused-overflight https://mainlymiles.com/2021/06/03/singapore-airlines-concor...
- varjag 5y agoThat's about right. TU-144 was borne more of the need to keep up with the Joneses. That is to maintain technological parity with the West. Another such project was Buran/Energia, which while not a carbon copy of Space Shuttle was an outcome of matching "what the Americans have".
- baybal2 5y agoThe key flaw of Tu-144: the whole wing structure was machined from a single enormous piece of aluminium.
- avereveard 5y agoTake that, Steve Jobs.
- sonthonax 5y agoReally? Do you have a source for that? I’d like to read more.
- baybal2 5y agohttps://testpilot.ru/russia/tupolev/144/tu144_1.php https://testpilot.ru/russia/tupolev/144/tu144_1.php > Крыло самолета (удлинения 1,74 и сужения 7, многолонжеронной конструкции) состоит из основной и отъемных частей и имеет кессонную конструкцию с силовой нагруженной обшивкой в виде фрезерованных крупногабаритных панелей вафельной конструкции из высокопрочных алюминиевых сплавов. "The wing consists of the main, and detachable part, and has a caisson construction with load carrying honeycomb panel skin machined from high strength aluminium alloy" So, a correction there. The wing is made of two ennormous machined parts: the main wing, and the wing extension.
- the-dude 5y agoI don't speak Russian, but your claim does not follow from your translation. It could still be made from numerous honeycomb, machined parts.
- nzmsv 5y agoThe Russian does in fact say the skin is made from large machined honeycomb panels (панели).
- bserge 5y agoI read it as "big machined honeycomb panels made out of high strength aluminum alloys"... So no mention of the actual size of a single panel. Крупногабаритных just means "large/big sized".
- ulzeraj 5y agoOne of my favorite electronic bands has an album entirely dedicated to communist era transports and there is a track dedicated to the TU 144 The videoclip has lots of footage of the plane. https://youtu.be/t09R_uTrvlw https://youtu.be/t09R_uTrvlw
- dmz73 5y agoUSSR back then and all the currently "democratic" societies now are more than happy to support projects that show everyone how much better they are than the "other guys" but when it comes to actually improving the life of non-elite, all the elite-led societies (all of the current and past societies) seem to fail for some reason. I wonder why.
- nicbou 5y agoIt always reminds me of Eisenhower's famous chance for peace speech: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chance_for_Peace_speech https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chance_for_Peace_speech
- adventured 5y ago> when it comes to actually improving the life of non-elite, all the elite-led societies (all of the current and past societies) seem to fail for some reason They haven't failed, it has been exactly the opposite. Which is of course why the global immigration magnet is so incredibly strong toward those nations. Those societies, the more affluent democratic ones you refer to, have been hyper progressive and prosperous for the average person since the WW2 era. A middle class person since ~1950-1960 in Austria, Germany, France, Britain, Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Norway, the US, Canada, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Belgium, Ireland, Slovenia, Japan, Singapore, Australia, New Zealand (and numerous others) - have largely led quite comfortable lives compared to what it was like in the past. Life has gotten better in most every regard if you're in those nations vs pre WW2. You can even watch this progress happen in rapid fashion, in eg the Baltics or the former Czechoslovakia, as they're quickly joining the more affluent tier post Soviet rule. The same is true in South Korea, China, Taiwan in terms of non-elite progress. The progress by the non-elites in those nations has been breathtaking over a very short period of time (30-40 years).
- m0zg 5y agoGotta give it to the Soviet party apparatchiks - they've actually flown in these, I believe several times. Or maybe underlings just didn't tell them how dangerous that was.
- rossmohax 5y agoNew take on a supersonic travel: https://boomsupersonic.com/overture https://boomsupersonic.com/overture
- olympusultra 5y agoWestern propaganda is so boring... Yes, Tu-144 wasn’t the biggest success story of the Soviet civil aviation, but it gave birth to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-160 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-160 And 35 years later the West is still unable to match Tu-160. The wise would say that every coin has a flip side, and every story about a Soviet “failure”, however one-sided coverage it usually receives in the Western propaganda, normally has too...
- evgen 5y agoThe equivalent match on the western side was the B-1, which was built earlier and served a roughly similar role until it was mostly replaced by the B-2 and now both are being retired in favour or the upcoming B-21.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe B-1B was not an equivalent to the Tu-160. One could go above Mach 2, the other could barely go above Mach 1. The B-1A would have been a match if it wasn't a failure.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adventured 5y agoBy your premise any plane that flies even 10% slower doesn't match up, even if it's superior in every other way. You don't have to match exact speeds to match outcomes when it comes to bombing. What matters is what the platform is meant to achieve and how effective is it at its mission. A slower supersonic plane may be the superior overall platform, depending on the other aspects of the plane. Russia made a hyper expensive show pony, when they could have built a cheaper, more effective platform at a lower speed. That's usually the kind of mistake the Americans make. The relatively high max speed of the TU-160 turned out to be entirely meaningless, they would have been better off building a different plane. The TU-160 has a $200m+ price tag. That's $1.2b scaled to the US economic terms. It's something beyond hyper expensive for the Russians in relation to their economic capabilities and military spending. The B-1A was cancelled. The TU-160 should have been cancelled.
- flyinghamster 5y agoAn amusing anecdote (disclaimer: not sure if true), was that the Soviets were having trouble making tires that were durable enough. The KGB tried to hire a French runway worker to collect rubber samples. The runway worker went to the French authorities, and a phone call to Michelin was placed: "Give us the very worst tire compound you can come up with." A batch was whipped up, and our runway worker sent some samples of it on to his KGB handler. Needless to say, their tire problems persisted.
- Zenst 5y agoVery probably and I had heard of some plans taken that were doctored so they got flawed plans. Also espionage spying was common then (probably still is today) http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/447464.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/447464.stm
- zepearl 5y agoAs well funny, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-144#Early_flights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-144#Early_flights : > ...an alarm siren went off immediately after takeoff, with sound and volume similar to that of a civil defence warning. The crew could not figure a way to switch it off so the siren stayed on throughout the remaining 75 minutes of the flight. Eventually, the captain ordered the navigator to borrow a pillow from the passengers and stuff it inside the siren's horn.
- perl4ever 5y agoIt's often mentioned how the US covertly imported titanium, I think, from the Soviet Union for use on advanced aerospace projects.
- dghlsakjg 5y agoNot just any project, the A-12/SR-71 spy-plane project which was specifically designed to penetrate soviet airspace.
- kilroy123 5y agoAmazing, I hope this is true.
- guilhas 5y ago*the Soviet's doomed rival to the doomed Concord
- fredoralive 5y agoThe plane uses the French spelling with an e, even in English (although it appears there was a bit of back and forth on that back during the 1960s).
- johnwalkr 5y agoIt was actually really controversial at the time, at least for conservative English newspapers. I stumbled upon old news footage of it on YouTube once. I remember an English worker with a rough accent saying something like “I don’t care if they put three es on the end, just let us keep working on the bloody thing”.
- nicbou 5y agoThe Soviet scored another first by dooming its plane before the West
- mhh__ 5y agoTo use more creative language: If Concord was doomed, then the Tu-144 was completely fucked from day 1.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> French President Georges Pompidou, foregoing nationalism, called it "a beautiful plane." For a brief moment I imagined a different world to the one I experienced in my youth, in which the Cold War, with all its cliched animos stereotyped rivalrous ranting that filled every newspaper and news bulletin for three decades, was replaced by a good faith chivalrous respect. It felt good. The world was a better, more interesting, more productive place.
- sgt101 5y agoAnd yet one half of it lived under a dark tyranny.
- kgeist 5y agoUSSR officially congratulated USA on the moon landings, for example. People rarely talk about things like that, sadly.
- 908B64B197 5y agoIt was also one of the only country with the ability to confirm that the USA did go to the moon, and had every reason (politically) to call it a hoax and didn't. That's why I still don't get moon landing conspiracy theories.
- wolfgang42 5y agoI accidentally got into a debate with a moon landing conspiracy theorist about this once. Their claim was that both space agencies were tacitly colluding to sponge budgets off of their respective governments. I dug into this further and after a couple of rounds of back-and-forth the answers they presented effectively required the entire Soviet political and ideological system to be a sham. I pointed this out and commented that, if true, this would be a conspiracy theory that makes a bit of NASA trickery pale to insignificance in comparison, and never heard from them again. I’d like to think they changed their mind, but I don’t think it's likely. My (uncharitable) explanation is that it gives a comforting sense of control and understanding of the world to be part of an in-group that has simple explanations for every outsider’s (potentially complicated and technical) objections.
- adventured 5y ago> A Tupolev Tu-144 in flight over Moscow as part of a NASA-sponsored research project in 1998. Photo five, featuring a Tu-144 with a US and Russia flag on it. Ah the brief optimistic days before the Cold War resumed. There are even a smattering of Hollywood movies over that span of time where the Russians and Americans work together in friendly fashion. When you view those movies now (eg Air Force One 1997), it seems entirely bizarre, from some fantasy world. Movies before: Soviets, Cold War, enemies; during the thaw: yay, Russia, democracy, friends, hugs all around; after: Putin, Cold War, quasi-enemies.
- nimbius 5y agoNowhere in the article does it say doomed. Its 2021, can we stop flogging the commies yet? The Tupolev was an absolute engineering masterpiece given the constraints it operated under. This thing had to transport regular people and land at practically any airport, something Concorde never did.
- thrwway34 5y agoYes, it was doomed - it operated for less than a year. No, it wasn't a masterpiece - it was plagued by usual Soviet issues: poor quality and bad engines. And no, it wasn't intended to transport regular people and land at practically any airport.
- WalterBright 5y ago> its rushed development made it notoriously unreliable and unpleasant to fly. Apparently taking away the profit motive didn't work.
- monocasa 5y agoThe Boeing 2707 had the same complaints. And the closest to successful version, the Concorde, was never profitable but propped up with heavy .gov funding from the French and British governments.
- WalterBright 5y ago> The Boeing 2707 had the same complaints. It could hardly be unpleasant and unreliable, because it never was completed and never flew. As for uneconomic, sure. That's a common result of it being a government project, just like the Concorde.
- monocasa 5y agoThey had two prototypes and enough simulations to know that it was unpleasant and unreliable. That's why .gov dropped their funding and cancelled it.
- WalterBright 5y agoNo support for your contention in the wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_2707#Government_funding_cut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_2707#Government_funding... The funding was cut because it was uneconomic and environmentally damaging.
- monocasa 5y agoIt being obvious that people wouldn't want tickets because it's unpleasant, and operating being expensive because it's unreliable were contributing factors in it being uneconomical. The env damaging part was only over land and there were plenty of niches for it. It could have done just fine over oceans. Late 70s/early 80s would have loved an SST going west coast to Japan and Hawaii.
- rkagerer 5y agoThere are videos of the tragic crash on YouTube, but this one of the aftermath is quite something: https://youtu.be/rPyvuBbhAAs https://youtu.be/rPyvuBbhAAs
- RegBarclay 5y agoOne of the best Soviet airplane rivalry stories is the Tupolev Tu-4 - a bolt for bolt copy of the US B-29. A good telling of the story here: https://wwiiafterwwii.wordpress.com/2019/06/29/b-29-to-bull/ https://wwiiafterwwii.wordpress.com/2019/06/29/b-29-to-bull/
- diskzero 5y agoThe Monino Airfield [1], north of Moscow, has a Tu-144 [2] on display. You can walk right up to it, but can't physically get in it. Monino is one of the more amazing aviation museums I have seen. There are some extremely rare aircraft on display, including my favorite, a Mil V-12 [3] You can hire a former pilot who was stationed at the base to give you a tour. They can speak some English, but if you speak a little bit of Russian the stories become a lot more interesting! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monino_Airfield https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monino_Airfield [2] https://www.google.com/maps/place/55°50'12.0%22N+38°10'12.0%22E/@55.8320744,38.1833044,92m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x0:0x0!8m2!3d55.836667!4d38.17?hl=en https://www.google.com/maps/place/55°50'12.0%22N+38°10'12.0%... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mil_V-12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mil_V-12
- mixtur2021 5y agoSomewhat related. While Concorde flew supersonic, the air which entered the engine needed to enter at subsonic speeds. They needed to slow the air using flaps in a very short distance. This was done by the Air Intake Control Units (AICU). Originally Concorde used an analogue computer in the prototypes. The analogue computer wasn't accurate enough for smooth flight. In the end, a fully digital solution was created at short notice by the rather grandly named "Guided Weapons Division" of the "Electronics and Space Systems Group" at BAC. Here's a pic of the unit: http://images.yuku.com/image/pjpeg/4df3652018ef41c9e9669a5eac9ab52bcc6b12c3.pjpg http://images.yuku.com/image/pjpeg/4df3652018ef41c9e9669a5ea... All done in the early 70s. These units started to fail in the 90s and they had to bring folks out of retirement to produce new units. The Soviets struggled to crack this aspect and apparently approached UK Gov to license the tech. Unsurprisingly UK Gov said no as the tech was classified as it could be used by military aircraft too.
- dfsegoat 5y agoThis account reminds me of the same issue that Lockheed faced in the design of the SR-71 Blackbird. They had to figure out the design of the 'spikes' and engine inlet systems that controlled inflow to the engines for the aircraft that still holds many speed records (Mach 3), to this day [1]. It was an enormous engineering challenge. I think this work was all done in the 60's. 0 - https://internationalaviationhq.com/2020/08/29/ben-rich-father-of-stealth/ https://internationalaviationhq.com/2020/08/29/ben-rich-fath... 1 - http://www.sr71.us/srrcd~1.htm http://www.sr71.us/srrcd~1.htm
- publicola1990 5y agoUK however has licenced Aircraft technology to Eastern Bloc countries. BAC One Eleven, jetliner was licensed to Romania by the UK, and several aircraft were made in that country in the 80s. Canada even built nuclear reactors in Romania during the Cold War years.