6 ms·
California family dies under mysterious circumstances
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoIs the hypothesis that there was toxic algae present in the water that the family presumably only filtered before drinking, not boiled?
- nradov 5y agoIn a few rare cases people and dogs have died from just swimming in water contaminated by toxic algae. So not intentionally drinking it, but it's easy to accidentally swallow a little bit.
- ceejayoz 5y agoBoiling doesn't help with cyanotoxins. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2016-11/documents/harmful_algal_blooms_and_cyanotoxins_frequently_asked_questions.pdf https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2016-11/documents/ha... > CAN I BOIL MY WATER TO MAKE IT SAFE TO DRINK? > No, boiling water will not remove cyanotoxins and may increase toxin levels.
- daveslash 5y agoThank you for the information. Though, I do wonder: how can boiling increase the toxin levels? Or does it simply increase the concentration because some water has evaporated?
- dmoy 5y ago> Or does it simply increase the concentration because some water has evaporated? Yes, this.
- xNeil 5y agoWill increasing the concentration matter? Obviously I know nothing on the subject, but drinking 10ml of poison in 100ml of water must be as harmful, and thus toxic, to me as 10ml of poison in 50ml water, right? Or we're assuming they don't drink all the water, in which case 20ml of the first solution will be less toxic than 20ml of the second.
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoHigher concentration may mean higher rate of absorbtion. If detoxification happens at a constant rate, then a quicker accumulation of toxins may bring you over a threshold you would not’ve gone over had you consumed a poison of lower concentration.
- undersuit 5y agoYou are seasoned drinker or scientist.
- ceejayoz 5y agoI need to drink 3-4 liters of water a day. That's fairly fixed. If I'm drinking water with twice the concentration, that's twice the poison.
- vanattab 5y agoI might be wrong but I don't think boiling would work for chemical toxins ether. Unless it's life and death you should avoid collecting drinking water from stagnant sources always look for flowing water. If you have to collect water try and collect it from deep bellow the surface and far from the bottom.
- hangonhn 5y agoIs the idea behind this recommendation that these algae blooms have a harder time to grow on moving water? Or that moving water upstream will dilute any concentration of toxins? Thanks!
- iudqnolq 5y agoBroadly speaking algea wants to be stationary. You see it floating on the surface in stagnant water, or sometimes attached to rocks in moving water. Dilution is also a factor, but if at all possible you want to avoid taking from anywhere with significant algea even if the water is flowing. Prominent algea likely indicates high level of agricultural runoff (maybe fertilizer, maybe manure). If you have to and you can afford to spend ~$30 buy Aquamira. It's mainly advertised for reducing the oder of stored water, but it's also commonly used by backpackers to purify water. Anecdotally I've used it to drink stagnant water (when no better options, of course) repeatedly with no issues, whereas I and others I know have gotten sick from clean moving water we put through a filter (Sawyer squeeze). Aquamira is just a way to make bleach on the spot in the right concentration. If you can't afford Aquamira or don't have access to an outdoors store that sells it you can get the same effect with household bleach. It's crucial you buy bleach that only contains chlorine, not any scents or additives (for example to make it thicker and stick to walls). See https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/emergency/making-water-safe.html?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fhealthywater%2Fdrinking%2Ftravel%2Femergency_disinfection.html https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/emergency/making-water-safe...
- shkkmo 5y agoAFAIK, neither bleach nor boiling help with cyanotoxins in the water from algea.
- MagicWishMonkey 5y agoI doubt they would have given a 1 year old water from a stream.
- anonAndOn 5y agoHypothermia overnight may have taken the child if it was waiting for the parents to wake up.
- MagicWishMonkey 5y agoIt's so sad to even think that's a possibility :(
- legohead 5y agoIf they are "avid hikers" like the article suggests, they would have brought water. Also doesn't explain why the baby died (don't think you'd give a 1 year old stream water).
- seattle_spring 5y agoBeing an "avid hiker" is open to interpretation nowadays. A lot of my coworkers would call themselves "avid hikers", but they only hike stuff like Mount Si and Lake 22. For those unfamiliar with Seattle area hikes, those 2 are way more crowded than city parks and are in no way risky for anyone less than grossly unhealthy. I've been on hikes with them and their preparation involves bringing a single nalgene of water. They had never heard of "the 10 essentials."
- stanford_labrat 5y agoDid you mean little Si? Mt Si proper is a pretty tough hike with a scramble at the end that can be somewhat tough/dangerous depending on conditions.
- msftie 5y agoIt’s a train of people up Si with a slammed parking lot… I think that’s the point. It is difficult, but it is also highly pedestrian as far as trails go in WA. We are lucky to have such high standards here where even the most accessible and trafficked trails are incredible
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Also doesn't explain why the baby died (don't think you'd give a 1 year old stream water). A one-year old is going to be heavily reliant on its parents actively taking care (in the short-term, most critically) in of hydration and heat management in the wilderness. If they are incapacitated by a toxin, that's quite plausibly fatal for the baby.
- hughrr 5y agoAvid hikers are more likely to travel light and source water on the way. Me I’d rather lose a couple of kg of weight and carry it in water instead.
- greljk46 5y agoJust shut the fuck up you fucking liberal fucks. Don't you all have better shit to do? Go back to work you fucking lefty scum.
- sharadov 5y agoSo tragic and heartbreaking. I read that they were doing an overnight hike in a remote part of Yosemite called Devil's Gulch. With a 1 year old? I love the outdoors too, but why take that kind of risk with a child?
- adventured 5y ago> I read that they were doing an overnight hike "The family's Sunday hike was intended to be just a daylong hike, which prompted concern from multiple family friends when they didn't come back home." https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/John-Gerrish-Ellen-Chung-Sierra-Forest-deaths-16398167.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/John-Gerrish-Ellen-Ch...
- sharadov 5y agoI read another article which mentioned "overnight hike". Thanks for clarifying that.
- smhinsey 5y agoAs someone who lives nearby part of the year, I really think this story has taken on a life of its own. It's true that there is some gross algae in the South Fork Merced but from all of the public info, they didn't even make it that far. If you look at where they started and where they were recovered, you'll see that in between is a fully exposed descent down a series of switchbacks. It was extremely hot that day. They probably died of heat exhaustion. It's unusual for it to get the dog too, but if they didn't have water for themselves, they probably didn't for the dog. It's not hard to imagine getting to the bottom and realizing you're in serious trouble. This family closely mirrors mine, so I've followed the story closely, and it seems like they just made a grievous error in judgment in an area they weren't familiar with.
- encoderer 5y agoWouldn’t it have been obvious that they had no water with them? Did I miss that detail somewhere?
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI am not familiar with that area, but when hiking, I try to map out natural springs. You won't need them going in, but it's coming back. I once went through a gallon of water on a hot day, and that spring I found earlier saved me. (I haven't been on a long hike since that day though.)
- NelsonMinar 5y agoI hope you bring purification equipment too. Giardia blows.
- ArchOversight 5y agoBetter than being dead.
- Scoundreller 5y ago“ Symptoms usually begin 1 to 3 weeks after exposure” Water now will let you get to treatment next week.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 5y agoDon't know about the weather at the time, but a lightning strike would be a possible explanation.
- pugworthy 5y agoQuoting from an NPR article... "This is a very unusual, unique situation," said Kristie Mitchell, a spokesperson for the sheriff's office. "There were no signs of trauma, no obvious cause of death. There was no suicide note." From https://www.npr.org/2021/08/20/1029582815/california-family-dies-under-mysterious-circumstances-toxic-algae-may-be-to-blam https://www.npr.org/2021/08/20/1029582815/california-family-...
- sschueller 5y agoLightning leaves a mess and can be easily determined.
- nate_meurer 5y agoNot true at all. Lightning strikes often leave very little evidence. In particular, if the ground was wet and rocky, a strike some distance away could easily have electrocuted the family with no or minimal burning, and the actual strike location could be nearly impossible to find. I've seen this with my own eyes. A couple of years ago I watched lightning strike a tree in the park across the street during a rain storm. Afterward the tree showed no evidence of the strike except for some bark blown off. There was no visible burning on the tree or the surrounding ground, but I guarantee that anyone standing near that tree would have gotten zapped.
- wishinghand 5y agoDoesn't being electrocuted leave a weird scar with the paths of least resistance the electricity takes?
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoYou can get a sufficiently large shock to stop your hearth without any tissue damage.
- aaron695 5y agoIt will be suicide. It will not be toxic algae. It won't be gasses. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean you shouldn't say it. Suicides happen all the time. Post Covid over the next decade you'll see a rise so get used to it. There's a chance it's heat exhaustion but it seems very unlikely.
- ransom1538 5y agoSuicide involving guns? Drowning with bricks? Suicide is not easy - curious how you think they commited suicide. Suicide of a whole family is complicated. "Under Mysterious Circumstances" - means to me the investigators are: wtf.
- aaron695 5y ago> Drowning with bricks? I think you should read the article again. > "Under Mysterious Circumstances" - means to me the investigators are: wtf. They will have a very good assessment of the situation. They are not "wtf" They were/are missing something from their normal patterns. They had to react to protocol on the day. Now they will want something solid. They will know how heat exhaustion looks, they will see all water bottles are empty for instance. It also is/isn't normal for that to happen within 2 miles of the car. Deputies also would not call them experienced hikers if they ran out of water. Nor would you expect people with their world travel and older age to hike with a baby with too little water. The police know a lot more than what we know and I'd find it unlikely from here the outcome will be different to what the police suspect.
- ransom1538 5y agoSorry so you think it is suicide? I don't understand your comment.
- mazlix 5y agoHow would you explain the suicide? What method and how was the dog also killed? There are valid reasons suicide isn’t suspected here.
- slownews45 5y agoToxic gases from a mine? Is this a joke? On a day trip you bring enough water and some crackers / snacks and you are fine. On long hikes you can do filtration on the way, but a day hike not too bad to put the 2L camleback bladder in the daypack, I usually do a hard nalgene on the side if I'm hiking with others (always seems to get used). Seriously, if you don't like drinking stream water, bring water. They even sell a 3L camelback. https://www.rei.com/product/108365/camelbak-crux-3l-reservoir-3-liters https://www.rei.com/product/108365/camelbak-crux-3l-reservoi... If you don't like the weight (longer overnight trips) amazing options these days in terms of water purification (vs what we used to do with the filter pump / boiling). At least for me for a day trip 3L (2 in pack, 1 in bottle) has worked fine. Now toxins from water would be very interesting - so be interesting to see what comes back from that testing. Do they know how hot it was? A big brimmed hat on everyone does wonders in the heat. I see folks out with no hat, almost no water fairly often - Ok if you can stop and call for help, not so great if you don't have cell service.
- s5300 5y agoNo, it's not a joke https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/gas-cloud-kills-cameroon-villagers https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/gas-cloud-kills-... Here's a singular example of hundreds of strange ways people have died from natural yet potentially hard to believe expulsions of toxic gases.
- fnord77 5y agotoxic gas is also a known natural hazard https://i.imgur.com/F1Y2rbW.jpg https://i.imgur.com/F1Y2rbW.jpg
- staunch 5y agoIt's very sad that this couple died but extra sad because they also killed their child in the process. Taking a baby on a remote hike, merely for pleasure, with no cell service/satellite phone is parental negligence in 2021. There are many ways to spend time in nature, even remote nature, without excessively risking the life of a child. My point is not just to blame the parents, they're already dead. I mean to point out the mistake they made for others. If other people disagree, I have no problem with that. Hopefully at least some people view this as a cautionary tale.
- robbrown451 5y agoThey didn't "kill" their child. This is a freak incident. If they just packed up their child in their car and drove on the freeway, and they all died due to someone slamming into them at high speed, it wouldn't even be national news.
- staunch 5y agoSomeone crashing into your car is not something one can easily mitigate the risk of. But had they driven with a baby into a remote area, like a desert, without cell service, and they all died in some "freak incident", that would also be negligent in my book. I'm not suggesting they did anything illegal. And if anyone wants to take their children into remote areas without a backup plan, that's their choice, I just think it's bad parenting. No baby needs to go on remote hikes when there are much less risky hikes to be had. The parents were doing this for themselves. It was risky and selfish behavior.
- robbrown451 5y ago"Someone crashing into your car is not something one can easily mitigate the risk of." You can absolutely mitigate it by deciding how much time you spend on the freeway. I don't think sharing a love of the outdoors with your kid is selfish at all. It's also keeping the parents in shape, which the kid typically benefits from. The fact that a freak occurrence happened makes it easy to judge, but this situation is not at all typical of families that do similar things with their kids (even babies).
- ridgeguy 5y agoAny chance they died because they walked into a carbon dioxide accumulation? CO2 is heavier than air and can accumulate in natural hollows. I've read about game animals suffocating rapidly when they walk through CO2-filled hollows, but can't immediately find a link. Natural CO2 emission does kill trees [1]. [1] https://pubs.usgs.gov/dds/dds-81/Intro/MonitoringData/CO2/CO2.html https://pubs.usgs.gov/dds/dds-81/Intro/MonitoringData/CO2/CO...
- drzoltar 5y agoDidn’t know this happens outdoors. Does the CO2 rise well above the surface though? I’ve heard there are “Dog Caves” [1] around the world where CO2 is low in the cave and will kill short animals but spare adults. [1] https://www.amusingplanet.com/2018/03/why-dogs-cant-stand-cave-of-dogs.html?m=1 https://www.amusingplanet.com/2018/03/why-dogs-cant-stand-ca...
- adamredwoods 5y agoThere was another article that stated the police were treating the area with hazmat suits because of possible carbon monoxide suffocation. https://www.sacbee.com/news/california/article253588249.html https://www.sacbee.com/news/california/article253588249.html https://www.fresnobee.com/news/local/article253577919.html https://www.fresnobee.com/news/local/article253577919.html In 2018, there was the family that died in Tulum, Mexico from CO poisoning as well: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/iowa-family-four-found-dead-mexican-resort-town-n859671 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/iowa-family-four-found-de...
- pomian 5y agoVery good proposition. This can happen next to old mines, waste rock piles especially. Not so much that the CO2 kills you, but it displaces the oxygen. You enter an oxygen deficient environment. Suffocation can happen almost instantly. Similar to confined spaces. However with weather changes, lets say a low pressure system moving in, the CO2 exhales from the surrounding porous rock. You starve for oxygen, almost immediately. And even the oxygen in your body gets sucked out. It has happened before, it took a long time for coroner's to figure out. Mine rescue personnel even get killed, thinking they can hold their breath. Have often wondered why this is isn't presented more to the public, so they can be warned. Avoid hollows, low spots, etc, especially in old mining country. (The reactions in the rock use up the oxygen pricing CO2 - But that's a longer discussion...)
- Zigurd 5y agoLightning can kill without obvious marks, and it can kill several people at once. Not uncommon on a mountain. Poisoning or dehydration would not have happened to a group all at once.
- jimhefferon 5y agoPlease, everybody, speculating about this very, very sad event is not helping anyone. Only the authorities can work out what happened. Let it alone, please.
- nate_meurer 5y agoRelax, it's just a discussion, one among countless other discussions around the world about all kinds of topics that may or may not be offensive to you. Personally I find mysteries like this to be riveting. I'm sad about the family, anxious to find out what happened, and I'm interested in peoples' ideas here. Nothing wrong with that. EDIT: I'm going to be really unhappy if this turns out to be poisoning by algae. That's a risk that I've never had to account for in life, and it's why I'm particularly interested in this incident.
- junon 5y agoIt's not hurting anyone. Let people discuss things. I'm learning a lot, personally, and I'm sure others are as well.
- rufus_foreman 5y agoI read the journal "Accidents in North American Mountaineering". I'm not a mountaineer much, but most of it applies to hiking. I don't read it to speculate on anything. I read it to learn from other peoples' mistakes. A family went hiking and ended up dead. They made a mistake. So if I go hiking again, how can I avoid that particular mistake?
- chasd00 5y agoi feel like the common denominator between all four would be consumption of water (edit: well and the hike itself). My first suspicion is some kind of poisoning.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 5y agoCanoeing and hiking away from habitation and livestock I regularly drink from lakes and streams without without worry or intestinal consequences so so far. My doctor sister took a fright when I told her I make a point of bringing back water from glacial streams for mixing with single malts.
- diebir 5y agoIf they were backpacking, I'd say carbon monoxide from a stove most likely. Otherwise maybe only lightning makes some sense. All this "toxic gasses" seems way too unlikely.
- diebir 5y agoSimilar case in Colorado 5 years ago: https://denver.cbslocal.com/2015/07/28/father-and-son-were-killed-by-carbon-monoxide-in-tent-not-lightning/ https://denver.cbslocal.com/2015/07/28/father-and-son-were-k... Canister stoves that produce a small amount of carbon monoxide have an unfortunate feature of making more CO with increasing altitude. Watch out: a stove in a tent that was perfectly fine at 5K feet becomes a source of CO at 8K feet.