17 ms·
Guantánamo survivor on the war on terror’s failure
- bayesian_horse 5y agoYou also shouldn't forget to hold the other powers to account that made it impossible to have peace in Afghanistan. Russia put out bounties on US soldiers, Iran armed the Taliban, Pakistan sheltered them and I'm sure China had their fingers in there just as well. The Taliban have never been the legitimate, much less the benevolent government of the Afghan people. If you've seen "The Handmaid's Tale" you have a general idea of what happened in the 90's and is going to happen there again.
- zozbot234 5y agoHas there been any legitimate, benevolent government there in living memory? Perhaps they're simply better off with a king, much like the frogs in Aesop's tale.
- baybal2 5y agoNo, there weren't. The one king which ran off to Italy was somewhat moderately legitimate, and moderately popular, but not enough to survive having his key people assassinated, nor to gain meaningful foreign assistance (USA denied his plea to save his ass from communists.) It were Britishers who started this mess 140 years ago, and they must be the ones to fix this.
- nradov 5y agoThe British have no capability to fix this.
- vxNsr 5y agoThe way to fix this is to return the country to city states. No central ruler.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThen the city states go fight each other. Or somebody assembles a large enough militia to loot one city after another. Or multiple city states band together and lord it over others.
- baybal2 5y ago* error above, it's been 180 years ago And since then, the country effectively had 180 years of slowly going civil war without much interruption sans for the few decades under king
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI'm opinionated in the sense that the only "legitimate" government would be one that is chosen democratically and acts in a particular manner. And I'm particularly not saying that there is or must ever have been some particular "legitimate government" for every piece of land. I'm just saying that when the US went in and kicked out the Taliban, they definitely weren't making things worse from a lot of perspectives. They ultimately weren't able to solve all the problems, but that is a different question. The 20 years have largely been better than the years under Taliban rule.
- ryneandal 5y agoIIRC, historically, the tribal settlements in the country never had a ton of interaction with each other due to the terrain. I think it's a great example of modern borders not making much sense given the interactions of the population.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThere have often been buddhist, muslim and other kingdoms or larger military organizations in power in Afghanistan. It's not that the borders don't make sense, it's that the area as a whole is hard to rule and it's hard to pay for that ruling. Currently one could argue that the medieval kind of "political technology" used by the Taliban is superior to the democratic political technology, for this very reason.
- ryneandal 5y agoRe-watched the video I was misremembering, and they're iterating exactly what you mentioned. I learned more about Afghanistan from this than anything in the news for the past two decades -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ab9zK8yT4_Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ab9zK8yT4_Y
- bayesian_horse 5y agoAlso the win condition of the government and government forces was to keep order in all of Afghanistan, guarantee the rights of women, and generally promote economic progress. The Taliban's win condition was basically to inflict just enough damage the former condition would be impossible. Their troops are not far removed from criminals themselves: they loot, rape and torture.
- ryneandal 5y agoI mean, we've seen conclusively with leaks like Collateral Murder -- there are no winners in war.
- youngtaff 5y agoOur allies in the Gulf States are also responsible too > Several Afghan and US officials have long accused several regional governments including Pakistan, Iran and Russia of giving financial aid to the Afghan Taliban, a practice they frequently deny. > Private citizens from Pakistan and several Gulf countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar are considered the largest individual contributors. > Although impossible to measure, these sources of funding clearly provide a significant proportion of the Taliban's revenue, and according to experts and officials could be as much as $500m a year. > These links are long-standing. A classified CIA report estimated in 2008 that the Taliban had received $106m, from foreign sources, in particular from the Gulf states. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-46554097 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-46554097
- pepperonipizza 5y agoRussia bounty on US soldiers story was probably fake, medias were quiet when it was revealed. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.politico.com/amp/news/2021/04/15/russia-afghanistan-bounties-psaki-481990 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.politico.com/amp/news/2021/...
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThe article you are referring to actually says the story is probably true, but that the confidence of the intelligence community in this finding is only "weak to moderate". The much bigger problem was that Trump said outright this story is fake, instead of holding Putin's feet to the fire or getting behind the issue at all.
- vxNsr 5y agoIf every US president held Russia’s feet to the fire when the CIA had “weak to moderate” intel we’d be banging two rocks together for fire because WW3 would’ve happened already. Stop pretending to care.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoBecause there is no middle ground between sucking up to Putin and going to nuclear war with him.
- vxNsr 5y agoBecause while trump was increasingly trying to isolate Russia for its bad behavior comrade Biden rolled over in his first meeting and removed a bunch of restrictions. The story wasn’t that “Russia had a bounty on US soldiers” instead it was “Trump knew that Putin put out a bounty on US soldiers” neither story is true but you only really care about the second one because OMB. The point is your crocodile tears are a sad excuse for caring.
- Clubber 5y ago>Russia put out bounties on US soldiers That was BS. It's amazing what you find out when people are actually under oath. It was likely an intelligence "leak" to keep us in Afghanistan. These are the same organizations that tried successfully to convince us of "WMDs." I'm not sure why people continue take what they say at face value anymore, especially the news. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_bounty_program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_bounty_program The Department of Defense (DOD), in testimony in July 2020 to the House Armed Services Committee by General Mark Milley, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Defense Secretary Mark Esper, said that U.S. defense intelligence agencies had no information to corroborate reports of a Russian bounty program in Afghanistan[37] and lacked evidence of "cause and effect linkages to a Russian bounty program causing U.S. Military casualties."[5][38] Citing credible unnamed sources, on June 26, 2020, The New York Times reported on a Russian military program to pay bounties to Taliban-linked militants for killing American soldiers in Afghanistan.[17] Two days later, The Washington Post reported that the bounty program had resulted in the death of at least one U.S. soldier.[16]
- endisneigh 5y agoWhy are you sure China had their fingers in there just as well? Why not Japan? Germany? Italy?
- enumjorge 5y agoSaying China is as impartial as Japan, German, and Italy when it comes to foreign affairs involving the US is either incredibly naive or disingenuous. It doesn’t itself prove Chinese involvement, but there’s a clear history of tension between the American and Chinese governments.
- tg180 5y agoAt this point it's history: because China borders with Afghanistan and has a primary interest in the stability of the region. Wang Yi (the Chinese Foreign Minister) last July met in Tianjin a delegation of nine members of the Taliban. He promised support in the reconstruction of Afghanistan and asked them to interrupt links with the East Turkestan Islamic Movement, accused to have perpetrated attacks in the Xinjiang. For Beijing, some Jihadist Uiguri would be affiliated with the organization. Wang promised to make the country part of the new Silk Road, contributing with infrastructure investments (motorways, hydroelectric energy, ...). This would prevent social, political and terrorist instability, while saving an unpleasant military action.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoGermany and Italy did have troops in Afghanistan, but they worked to keep the peace. And China has not only a border with Afghanistan, it also has a history of shady dealings with neighbor countries in trouble.
- VictorPath 5y ago> The Taliban have never been the legitimate, much less the benevolent government of the Afghan people. If you've seen "The Handmaid's Tale" you have a general idea of what happened in the 90's That is because the USA armed and bankrolled the jihadists who overthrew the secular, left-leaning PDPA in the 1980s. Here is Ronald Reagan with the jihadists in the White House https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c9RWtx8myQc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c9RWtx8myQc It's inane for Americans to arm a jihadist insurgency against a left-leaning secular government, and then tear their vestments in some feigned moral superiority that the jihadists would take over the country thirty years later.
- tablespoon 5y ago> That is because the USA armed and bankrolled the jihadists who overthrew the secular, left-leaning PDPA in the 1980s. Here is Ronald Reagan with the jihadists in the White House > https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c9RWtx8myQc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c9RWtx8myQc > It's inane for Americans to arm a jihadist insurgency against a left-leaning secular government, and then tear their vestments in some feigned moral superiority that the jihadists would take over the country thirty years later. It's weird that you wouldn't mention this important context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Afghan_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Afghan_War > The foundations of the conflict were laid by the Saur Revolution, a 1978 coup wherein Afghanistan's communist party took power, initiating a series of radical modernization and land reforms throughout the country. These reforms were deeply unpopular among the more traditional rural population and established power structures.[56] The repressive nature of the "Democratic Republic",[57] which vigorously suppressed opposition and executed thousands of political prisoners, led to the rise of anti-government armed groups; by April 1979, large parts of the country were in open rebellion.[58] > The communist party itself experienced deep internal rivalries between the Khalqists and Parchamites; in September 1979, People's Democratic Party General Secretary Nur Mohammad Taraki was assassinated under orders of the second-in-command, Hafizullah Amin, which soured relations with the Soviet Union. With fears rising that Amin was planning to switch sides to the United States,[59] the Soviet government, under leader Leonid Brezhnev, decided to deploy the 40th Army across the border on 24 December 1979.[60] Arriving in the capital Kabul, they staged a coup (Operation Storm-333),[61] killing General Secretary Amin and installing Soviet loyalist Babrak Karmal from the rival faction Parcham.[58] The Soviet invasion[nb 1] was based on the Brezhnev Doctrine. Also, the Taliban started in 1994, and it's hard not to feel morally superior to people who do stuff like this: https://twitter.com/NasrinNawaBBC/status/1425139216443482112 https://twitter.com/NasrinNawaBBC/status/1425139216443482112.
- blunte 5y agoKey figures in US military and US leadership need to be held accountable. Same as with CEOs, if you only punish the organization and not specifically the leaders, there is no disincentive to doing it again. Clearly the US is exempt from the war crimes laws, and that needs to change. But it would require leaders of other major powers/countries to push for this. But… this will never happen because almost no leader wants to be held accountable, and thus they will never vote against their peers.
- croes 5y agoThe US even sanctions investigators of the International Criminal Court if they try to investigate US war crimes. https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/12/14/us-sanctions-international-criminal-court https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/12/14/us-sanctions-internation... *Correction ICC not ICJ
- dragonwriter 5y agoThe International Criminal Court; the ICJ is a different court with jurisdiction over nations, not individuals.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kodah 5y agoUS troops are held accountable for "war crimes" if that's what you're wondering. https://www.rt.com/usa/180692-marine-taliban-urinating-video/ https://www.rt.com/usa/180692-marine-taliban-urinating-video... In that specific incident, such a degree of accountability was desired to be held that the Commandant of the Marine Corps is said to have attempted an influencing campaign around their trial: https://www.marinecorpstimes.com/news/your-marine-corps/2017/11/09/marine-who-urinated-on-dead-taliban-wins-in-court/ https://www.marinecorpstimes.com/news/your-marine-corps/2017... I'm sure there are things the military does that go untracked, however, deploying troops are heavily trained on the Law of Land and Warfare, the Geneva Convention (which only applies to how they treat citizens of a nation and the terrorists they're fighting, not to how they will be treated.), and various others. So, what war crimes are you wanting them to investigate that their own governing bodies have not chased?
- beckman466 5y agoAbby Martin from Empire Files made a beautiful video about the war in Afghanistan: https://youtube.com/watch?v=C3LFbOSPfrE https://youtube.com/watch?v=C3LFbOSPfrE
- thejackgoode 5y agoGoogle wants me to submit my passport (“age check”) to watch this video (despite being registered there since 2008). Any other links to it?
- La1n 5y agoI don't have a link, but I've noticed that quite a few videos in the similar corner of topics need an "age check" (e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2khAmMTAjI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2khAmMTAjI , the creator of which was (according to them) visited by DHS for "anti-american sentiments" [1] ) [1] https://twitter.com/_secondthought/status/1332746158947635202?lang=en https://twitter.com/_secondthought/status/133274615894763520...
- beckman466 5y agoSo glad you mentioned this, I've also noticed this. Agreed, it's scary and crazy what happened to JT Chapman/Second Thought. This 'age check' is also a pretty convenient way for Google to 'passively' create a list of people who watch "anti-american sentiment" videos.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoI was able to watch it on a mobile just yesterday, in the browser.
- detritus 5y agoYea, I've been seeing this more and more on what seem from the outside like fairly innocuous vides and was yesterday accomanied by a prompt on my mobile that I 'need' to add my age. Nope. Go away, Google.
- rkachowski 5y ago> One shocking parts of the book is learning about proven terrorists get released before Adayfi I know I shouldn't expect more from the grauniad but this is pretty hard to parse.
- eunos 5y agoWill not, because that makes US (or specifically Biden's admin) looks weak, not good when the theme of the new admin is "America is back!". I even consider the possibility of next conflict will be higher, US needs to shed its "Vietnam syndrome" swiftly and they need some quick victory similar to the 1st gulf war.
- throw13579 5y agothey could have won the war in 2 years instead of losing the war in 20. all they had to do was target the taliban leadership in pakistan instead of their foot soldiers in the vast mountains of afghanistan.
- bwilli123 5y ago"The Taliban has fought against the US and the Kabul state for two decades in the face of casualties that would have shattered the morale and recruitment of almost any other army. The Vietnamese communists are the only parallel I can think of – and indeed, the Taliban may have learned the importance of discipline and organisation indirectly from communism. There are provinces in Afghanistan where five Taliban governors in a row have been killed – and yet a new volunteer for the position has always stepped forward. This marks a striking contrast with all previous religiously inspired Pashtun tribal uprisings, which grew rapidly but also collapsed quickly after the first major defeat." https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00396338.2021.1930403 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00396338.2021.1...
- trhway 5y agointeresting that even the North - ethnically different, ie. Uzbeks, led by General Doustum, and which has been anti-Taliban for decades - fell without fight, and Doustum had to run into Uzbekistan. According to Nur, the [former] Governor of Balkh, (translation of translation) "it was a deep and widespread treason as all the government objects and forces were just simply transferred to Taliban".
- Expirat 5y ago> After 20 years during which he was routinely tortured, Mansoor Adayfi, who now lives in Serbia, asks: ‘What if that had been American boys?’ Well judging by the way the regime changed its tune from war against terror to war against white supremacy, it will probably be the turn of the american boys to suffer
- mrtksn 5y agoThis implies the US population being held responsible because the US is a democratic nation. The idea is, every 4 years the highest position of governance is put on a trial and the population votes if they approve or disprove the way things are done and reconsider alternatives. Besides the 4 year period for the evaluation of the highest ranking officers, there is an ample opportunity for direct intervention through other elections and NGOs. The burden is on the US citizens but other nations holding the US nation accountable is unrealistic. The Germans were held responsible for Hitler but they lost an open war to a greater power. The US is not facing such a power. Whatever happens is up to the US internal politics and the culture of the US nation. The best the external powers could do is to push for events that change the US populations feelings, thus affecting the judgement of the periodic reviews.
- La1n 5y ago>Whatever happens is up to the US internal politics and the culture of the US nation. If only the US would live by that when looking at other countries. Sanctions, embargos, trade-restrictions, threats are used against other countries by the US, why should they be treated any different themselves?
- mrtksn 5y agoThe US is powerful and can do that. Well, at least up to some extend but even then it turns to be ineffective but as we see with the recent developments.
- ta_20210816 5y agobecause for the US, to sanction basically any country is a blip on their economy, but for any other country, indeed blocs of countries to reciprocate that means not only losing your second or third largest trade partners but also shutting you economy off for electronics, software, international financial services, etc
- forz877 5y agoBecause US is hegemon and can essentially do as it pleases without immediate consequence. This is why Russia and China have been focusing on destabilizing the US and minor geopolitical moves to chip away as opposed to directly challenging US authority.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoAs harrowing as his story is, remember that he is one of the "lucky" victims of the War on Terror. If our success rate in imprisonment was 8%, how high was our success rate for the 800,000-3,100,000 killed in the War on Terror?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sschueller 5y agoWhat the US is doing to Assange at the moment is a war crime in itself.
- md_ 5y agoThese kinds of comments detract from the horror of the crimes in Guantanamo. It reminds me a bit of when Americans opposed to mask mandates liken them to having to wear yellow Stars of David. Guantanamo detainees were tortured with stress positions, sexual abuse (including simulated rape), simulated executions (including being taken out to sea and told they would be thrown overboard), held in cold rooms, and told their family members would be arrested and put in prison. This includes detainees who were later exonerated. In comparison, Assange has been...in British custody pending the results of an extradition hearing? While contesting credible (be they right or wrong) charges of rape? There's something deeply unjust in making this a discussion about Assange.
- sofixa 5y ago> This includes detainees who were later exonerated That's one way of putting it. It would be more accurate to say for the vast majority of the detainees, there was never any tangible proof of crimes and they were fully innocent.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoI think it provides a worthwhile perspective as to the motivations of the US and what actions it considers to be important enough to put non-trivial effort and resources towards the pursuit and punishment of. ie. Not the doing of the things, but the public revelation of the doing of the things. I think it's entirely pertinent to the discussion.
- md_ 5y ago> I think it provides a worthwhile perspective as to the motivations of the US and what actions it considers to be important enough to put non-trivial effort and resources towards the pursuit and punishment of. "The US" is not a monolith. Guantanamo--both the rapid expansion and ingestion of likely-innocent bystanders and the torture program--was an effort of the Bush-era Defense Department, specifically with high-level support from Donald Rumsfeld and legal cover from the Office of Legal Counsel (John Yoo). The Assange extradition was a project of the Obama-era Justice Department. It's hard to see any commonalities (in terms of goals or decision-making) at the implementation level, and whatever else you think of Assange, the US's extradition requests have, essentially, followed both international norms and American and international law. You can try to see some sort of historical through-line here about American imperialism (and you might be right), but, as with my above analogy, that's like saying "the Star of David analogy is pertinent because it relates to the abuse of government power." At a sufficient abstraction that's true, but it still doesn't shed a lot of light.
- bambax 5y agoTrump wasn't the worst US President. Bush2 was. And he is still a guest at late-night TV shows. Incredible.
- rbanffy 5y agoWorth noting Trump ordered the release of their leader, Abdul Ghani Baradar, from prison.
- dragontamer 5y agoMore importantly: Trump negotiated that release without consulting the Afghan government last year, while also setting a May deadline for US forces to leave. The Taliban used that as a recruitment call. We're months late on the original timeline, and they knew we were leaving last year. Of course the Taliban would surge in this timeframe. The question now is: is it worth to counter-surge to hold back the tide? It seems like the overwhelming opinion is that we should leave, so we're leaving.
- rbanffy 5y agoThe US failed to create the cultural change that would allow Afghanistan to be a westernised democracy. That’d take decades of building schools and hospitals and teaching every kid those western values until there is nobody who remembers the Taliban. Sadly, it looks like this was never the plan. At least, some people profited from weapon sales.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoYou could argue Trump didn't have the wits, opportunity and time to do as much damage.
- lukifer 5y agoThe Bush administration did plenty of damage in the first two years. (Although by all accounts, he was largely rubber-stamping the initiatives of his VP and "advisers".)
- md_ 5y agoAmong the key figures in the design of American torture programs during the War on Terror were American psychologists James Elmer Mitchell (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Elmer_Mitchell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Elmer_Mitchell) and Bruce Jessen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Jessen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Jessen), who were paid $81m for their work. Irony upon ironies: "Mitchell, who is retired and lives in Land o' Lakes, Florida, spends his free time kayaking, rafting and climbing.[14] He describes himself as an atheist and a supporter of Amnesty International.[10]"
- trasz 5y agoThis is another example how the US society frankly doesn’t care. There are plenty of ways the local citizens could organize to make life hell for people like those. Yet it doesn’t happen.
- Clubber 5y agoLike what? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rc_BlwbmUNY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rc_BlwbmUNY
- sofixa 5y ago> He describes himself as an atheist and a supporter of Amnesty International That's a funny one. Someone should interview him and see how he sees himself and his role, and does he consider himself to be a war criminal.
- md_ 5y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/18/james-mitchell-cia-torture-interview https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/18/james-mitchell... This also contains this amusing aside: "He also criticized Obama’s healthcare policy – a 'shit sandwich' – and his administration’s approach to global warming. Mitchell believes it’s a myth."
- cutemonster 5y agoNot impossible that he describes himself in ways he thinks make better impressions of him in the media, and that it's unrelated to his actual opinions
- spodek 5y ago> Adayfi has huge sympathy for the guards who lived through Guantánamo with him, even though they played nasty tricks on the detainees – carting them around in aircrafts telling them they were going home, only to subject them to further interrogation; hiding their correspondence from their families; and throwing their Qur’an in the toilet. > “We were all following orders, we were all victims of the same machine,” he says. Echoes of Nelson Mandela.
- ordiel 5y agoWhy not ask Obama instead of Biden? ... It was his campaign promise... Twice... I mean Trump was an idiot and all but at least a part of the wall he promissed was build
- bayesian_horse 5y agoObama held a lot of his promises and he cleaned up much of what went wrong in the war on terror. He was kept from closing Guantanamo Bay by factors beyond his control.
- bilvar 5y ago> Obama held a lot of his promises and he cleaned up much of what went wrong in the war on terror. How exactly did he do that? By arming ISIS and destabilizing a few extra countries around the region in the name of "Democracy"?
- VSerge 5y agoI do not understand the initial statement that an 18 year old from Yemen, that they mention was preparing to start college, was "conducting research in Afghanistan", until he was arrested in February 2002. So this is research by at best a high-school kid in taliban-ruled and/or US-occupied Afghanistan, and it seems like a bizarre claim. This article also conflicts with the birth year on his wikipedia page, according to which he would have been 22/23 in early 2002. This birth year estimate comes from the Guantanamo authorities however, so not sure whether that is very credible either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mansur_Ahmad_Saad_al-Dayfi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mansur_Ahmad_Saad_al-Dayfi
- throwawaycities 5y agoPerhaps there would be a shift in the domestic populace. For example, that segment of the populace that championed waterboarding and defended it as a legitimate interrogation method involving a little discomfort, and believed it wasn’t torture, have come to show their true colors and believe they can’t breathe and are being tortured by wearing a mask.
- lukifer 5y agoI think Terror Management Theory [0] explains this contradiction fairly robustly: Sheldon Solomon found that reminding people of their mortality, even subtly, increased their support for hostility to out-groups, military intervention, etc. When it comes to COVID, anti-masking is arguably a form of coping with a reminder of mortality, by "minimizing one's perception of the threat" [1]: that the virus is "not nearly as contagious or lethal as health experts claim it to be" or "originating in a politically motivated conspiracy". [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_management_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_management_theory [1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0022167820959488 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/00221678209594...
- platz 5y ago> He had just been conducting research in Afghanistan, and was expecting to begin college at the end of the year. Instead, he was accused of being an al-Qaida leader, kidnapped by Afghan warlords and handed over to the CIA this is the only information information in the whole arricle about why he was sent there, and it is pretty sparse information. If i were to put on my critical thinking media hat, this gives the impression that its not the whole story, or at least an idealized version of it. Also its not explained his connection between Yemen and afganistan. (this isnt to validate the practices at guantanamo, however)
- raxxorrax 5y agoI think there indeed needs to be more story to detain him but it isn't up to him to provide a defense. It is well known that Gitmo contains people without any legal instrument. Of course a state should be held accountable for imprisioning people without accusations. Although that seems to be a pattern of the United States if you look what the attorney general in Missouri does with innocents. There probably are bad people among those imprisoned and there just isn't enough evidence to convict them. The damage they can cause isn't on the level to committing treason towards your own alleged values. The US also has spawned a lot of defense contractors the last 20 years that now will look inward to find business opportunities if no other external threat can be summoned. That will probably not be pretty.
- stephen_g 5y agoIt mentions that 86% of prisoners there were handed over by locals as being “suspicious” when offered very large bounties by the US Government (apparently up to millions of dollars). The article also links to this report of an ex-Bush era official saying most detainees were innocent [1] and the ALCU has some more info and numbers [2]. 1. https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/most-guantanamo-detainees-are-innocent-ex-bush-official-1.804550 https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/most-guantanamo-detainees-are-... 2. https://www.aclu.org/issues/national-security/detention/guantanamo-numbers https://www.aclu.org/issues/national-security/detention/guan...
- platz 5y ago
- yawaworht1978 5y agoStrongly against gitmo on every level, but good luck getting anyone accountable on the matter. Within the US , the corresponding laws have been passed prior to action, so it's "legal". For other countries, all they can do is issue an arrest warrant, which will never be respected by the US government, unless someone radically different assumes POTUS position some day. Interesting that the guardian is reporting on this as if their very own government consists of angels and saints on these matters.
- dgellow 5y ago> Interesting that the guardian is reporting on this as if their very own government consists of angels and saints on these matters. It's The Guardian US reporting about the United States. The Guardian UK is also generally very critical of the UK government, so I don't get your point. You don't need your government to be made of saints to criticize war crimes.
- fogihujy 5y agoHolding the U.S. accountable for the war on terror isn't going to happen. The rest of us need to hold our own politicians accountable for collaborating with the U.S. though.
- sumedh 5y agoThe problem is that US is like a 800 pound gorilla, you cannot afford to piss of the US.
- fogihujy 5y agoWell, that why U.S. politicians won't be held accountable. That doesn't stop the rest of us from holding our politicians accountable, though.
- sumedh 5y ago> That doesn't stop the rest of us from holding our politicians accountable, though. So your country goes against the US, the US retaliates by stopping trade. People in your country lose jobs, people demand the govt to fix things, what is your govt going to do then? It easy to say our politicians should be accountable, real life is more complicated though.
- fogihujy 5y agoI honestly doubt the current U.S. administration would do anything if say, Denmark started internal inquiries about whether their politicians' decision to participate invade Iraq was made on false grounds. If they did, the EU would probably not be happy about trade sanctions. Denmark was obviously just an example, but there are a lot of U.S. allies, trading partners and so on, that all have assisted or participated in the war on terror. Besides, the Democrats could probably just blame it on Bush anyway.
- sumedh 5y agoYou gave Denmark as an example, sure they can do it. Denmark's trade with US is very tiny but lets say Russian submarines start showing up near Greenland, what is Denmark going to do, they will go to NATO where you have US calling the shots. Once Russia starts making some noise, all European countries will need US protection.
- sajithdilshan 5y agoI guess the important question is that who is going to hold US accountable and make sure that the resolution is carried out. IMO there is no other powerful entity in the world to impose restrictions against US yet.
- Tepix 5y agoMurat Kurnaz was also held and tortured for four more years at Guantanamo, even after it was clear that he was innocent. The person responsible(²), Frank-Walter Steinmeier, is now Germany's president. There is a repeating pattern here: Governments, officials and people in power are not held accountable. -- (²) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank-Walter_Steinmeier#Murat_Kurnaz_torture_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank-Walter_Steinmeier#Murat_...
- sofixa 5y agoI'm not sure I'd hold him responsible. He isn't the one that ordered the torture, and we don't know what he was told ( did he know the guy was getting tortured? did he know he wasn't any threat?)
- JasonFruit 5y agoThat's part of the point of the system: it makes blame hard to assign.
- bserge 5y agoThat's the beauty of any complex system made by humans. The system decides, no human is responsible (except for the occasional scapegoats). Society is built on systems and everyone submits to them. If it works for the majority, it's good enough. The sad part is that it is possible to change the various ancient systems into something better, more dynamic, more responsive, that would work for more edge cases. We just... don't. Few dare question the status quo and even fewer try to change it.
- woodpanel 5y agoAs much as I dislike Steinmeier, I agree. We also don't know how much pressure was exerted on him.
- chopin 5y agoThat does not exonerate him. He could have stepped back and make the pressure public. Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger did step back when she did not agree with a legislative proposal.
- ostenning 5y agoMeanwhile the US knew fully well that the Taliban would claim power over Afghanistan if they withdrew their military. The US behaves like a deranged abuser in a codependent relationship. Destabilise the region, exploit it, nurture dependence on western military and then abruptly leave. The TV series Always Sunny In Philadelphia did a skit on this, its called the DENNIS system.
- mimd 5y agoYou know this is an antiwar puff article by the guardian being posted to HN for propaganda purposes right?
- lukifer 5y agoFun fact: propaganda used to be a morally neutral term [0], which we now call "public relations", after the word took on connotations with Nazis and Soviets. Everyone who is advocating for a policy, moral position, etc., is putting out "propaganda"; by any objective measure, MLK and Thomas Paine were extremely effective propagandists, and we (rightly) celebrate them for it. The real question is, what one is advocating for, and whether one does so honestly. And while there are certainly circumstances for justified violence, "antiwar" seems like a pretty good thing to advocate for, all else being equal. And I fail see any blatant dishonesty or bad faith in this piece, whatever the shortcomings might be of The Guardian or the mainstream press in general. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_(book)
- rob74 5y agoUnfortunately the article is only about Guantanamo and the human rights abuses committed there on people who were largely innocent (which is bad enough, of course), but not about the wider failures of the "war on terror", the most current of which is the appalling way in which the so-called democratic administration and army of Afghanistan has failed after the NATO withdrawal. I suspect there were similar mechanisms at play there as with the way suspects were "recruited" for Guantanamo...
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI'm amazed at how many people still see the Iraq and Afghanistan interventions as correct moves. Just last week I was having a friendly mostly non-political conversation with two of my coworkers and then the topic verged to the military and then to the Iraq wars. (For context, I'm Canadian and they're both US ex-pats in Canada.) Both had the opinion, still, that the Iraq war was the correct move at the time. But couldn't really coherently describe why. I changed the topic rather than get into a controversial argument. I guess I find this shocking, because it feels to me like the "just cause" reasons for scenario the US got itself into Iraq have been repudiated entirely at this point and the fallout has been pretty much entirely negative and led to some long term rather terrifying dysfunctions. I feel like the arguments made by those of us who protested the onset of the war made have been proven historically correct. I struggle to understand the opposing opinion? Afghanistan we can make somewhat separate arguments about, for sure. But Iraq... Someone on the conservative side of the spectrum, please enlighten me what the reasonable argument for justifying the past military action there is at this point...
- bishoprook2 5y ago> Someone on the conservative side of the spectrum, please enlighten me what the reasonable argument for justifying the past military action there is at this point... I'd say that it's possible (quite possible) to be conservative and to be against foreign adventures. It's probably better to view a country as being occupied by multiple cohorts of political thought, one of which is a ruling class that likes to play Risk. That ruling class has shifted party allegiance and probably will do so in the future. In any case, from my uninformed armchair, it seems pretty obvious that it's easier to run foreign policy by attempting to influence the existing dictator (whether it's in Iraq or Libya or Syria) rather than install a new one with the attendant cost in blood and treasure.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI don't disagree. I'm not saying all conservatives support(ed) the Iraq war in retrospect. But there are some who do and I'd like to understand why.
- iJohnDoe 5y agoA must watch movie related to this topic. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Report_(2019_film) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Report_(2019_film)
- danielschonfeld 5y agoThere seems to be a general case of amnesia about the way the Iraq war was sold and I'm not quite sure why. While the fairy tale of WMDs was a multiyear effort the US has undertaken, first and foremost as a response to 9/11, Saddam was painted as the leader harboring terrorists and aiding public enemy number one, Osama Bin Laden and his then suddenly sprung into public attention group called Al Qaeda. It's only later on that Powell was sent on a mission by Bush/Chaney/Rumsfeld to tug on the world's and American's heart strings by producing laughable evidence of WMDs. Not dissimilar to how they sold the original Iraq War with babies in incubators being thrown. During that first year and all the way to March 2003, endlessly bush has used 9/11, and anybody who is 'harboring terrorists' cough cough Saddam Hussain cough cough to justify anything and everything America wanted to do. And Americans stood behind him, blind and proud with our American flag.
- Clubber 5y ago>Saddam was painted as the leader harboring terrorists and aiding public enemy number one, Osama Bin Laden and his then suddenly sprung into public attention group called Al Qaeda. I believe this was debunked before the war started, as was WMD's (remember Hanz Blix).
- danielschonfeld 5y agoIn case it wasn't evident enough from this and my historical comments, I obviously whole heartedly agree. But that doesn't change the fact, this is who he and his regime was marketed as to Americans in the 2.5 years post 9/11 as the basis for war. For Americans, and especially the military, this guy helped cause 9/11, therefore he should be hunted and die. All the others... collateral damage.
- reallyagain 5y agoSo, you make repeated insinuations in your comment history about the "authenticity" of 9/11. Perhaps you could share with the class what you believe is inauthentic about 9/11?
- hamsterOnWheel 5y agoThe leaders who sell us and the world on these terrible interventions need to have a personal stake in their outcomes. If they want to nation-build, they should have to move themselves and their families to the new nation. If they want to topple a government, they should have to live in the capital afterwards. No more ruining the world and walking away rich afterwards. The same goes for our business leaders, by the way. Personal results should align with the business and social results. There shouldn't be wealthy Purdue pharam execs or McKinsey consultants after oxycontin wrecked the health of Americans.
- Anthony-G 5y ago> But in Serbia, where he lives, he is still considered a terrorist, and his ambitions have been thwarted. He has found it hard to make friends because people fear associating with him; a tabloid ran a two-page spread calling him a terrorist, and his acquaintances have undergone interrogation just for knowing him. > He can’t get a job. He can’t leave the country, or drive. He has no healthcare. His relationship with a woman he loved ended after he was denied a travel document to visit her. Does anyone know how or why Mansoor Adayfi ended up living in Serbia? I would have (naïvely) thought that Guantanamo prisoners would be repatriated to their homes or home countries. Does he have family living in Serbia? I also haven’t paid attention to the political situation in Serbia in recent years but it used to be within the Russian sphere of influence so I’d be surprised that the US would choose Serbia as the site of his new “prison”. Edit: this report¹ from 2016 explains that > Transfers have been slowed because many inmates were from war-torn Yemen, and so had to be returned to a third country that can provide rehabilitation and monitoring. The report also seems to indicate that Serbia volunteered to “assist” the US and that that the Guantanamo detainees were being “transferred” (rather than being released). So, it seems that, despite not having ever been convicted of a crime, the torture survivors are still incarcerated under a form of “house arrest” by a third country – rather than directly by the US military. 1. https://web.archive.org/web/20160805071557/https://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-07-12/us-transfers-two-guantanamo-detainees-to-serbia/7588240 https://web.archive.org/web/20160805071557/https://www.abc.n...
- detaro 5y agoThe US didn't want to send people back to Yemen due to the "unstable" (=war zone) situation there and fears they'd (re-)join terrorist groups, but rather in places that could do some monitoring and rehabilitation (but not US soil of course!). Serbia offered to take a few prisoners on humanitarian grounds.