12 ms·
Use Pixar's story formula to win over investors
- azifali 5y ago“As a startup founder, 90% of your job is storytelling”.. No it’s not. It’s solving a real problem.
- reidjs 5y agoAnd selling the solution
- RussianCow 5y agoIsn’t sales just a form of storytelling?
- tlogan 5y agoNo - sales is much more than just nice storytelling. Much much more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjulius 5y agoHow do you get investors to fund your solution? How do you get the public to use your solution? Your solution is nothing if you can't build it, and nothing if nobody uses it.
- geoduck14 5y ago>Your solution is nothing if you can't build it, and nothing if nobody uses it. I know really smart engineers that would do well to internalize this.
- norov 5y agoThat is what we're told before entering academia and small business/non-profit ownership. But lo and behold in reality most of one's time is spent chasing grants, contracts, and other funding.
- Animats 5y agoThat's so last-cen, when stuff actually had to work. Pixar's story approach is all "I am the chosen one". It's not about someone who worked to make it happen. This came from George Lucas, whose stories are all about "the chosen one". His success changed film storytelling. Too much. Before Lucas, there were more "clawed their way up from the bottom" stories. I've seen "I am the chosen one" pitches. The CEO of Better Place (electric cars using battery swapping stations) comes to mind. He was a really good speaker, he was really good looking, he knew several national leaders, and his business plan was total bullshit. Better Place went bankrupt.
- amelius 5y agoChosen one is good enough if investors can successfully bootstrap a ponzi scheme based on your persona. The trick seems to be to create a dream, let the perceived company value increase based on that dream, and then pull out at the right moment, leaving the losses to investors who came too late.
- exhaze 5y agoI agree with you about your point. In this case it sounds more like lying. I believe that the best stories are also honest with their listeners. Solving problems is incredibly important. You can often succeed with that alone. The most successful ventures do both.
- hiptobecubic 5y agoYeah but now you're saying,"Have an actual Pixar story" not just "use the Pixar story method to spin your shitty idea into a funding round."
- rdiddly 5y agoI dunno, battery swapping sounds like a good idea actually. If only the batteries were swappable...
- petra 5y agoBattery swapping could have been a good idea, if instead of telling a story:"We'll replace all the cars in the world, we are already talking with heads of state", they've said:"As a first step, let's concentrate on a small niche best fitting for battery swapping, like Taxis[1], Build a network/business, and expand from that". [1]Taxis drive a lot, so the savings from battery swapping are much more compelling compared to the car costs. And many taxis drive only within city range, so no range anxiety.
- qwertox 5y agoIt's probably related to the Pareto principle.
- DenisM 5y agoI suspect that for every problem there are dozens of teams capable of solving it, but only one or two will receive enough funding and attention to reach the escape velocity. Investors know it so they want to bet on the team that other investors will want to bet on. Ergo your job as a founder is to convince the investors and the journalists that you are the chosen one. Either that, or bootstrap.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bobsomers 5y agoThere are plenty of "real problems" whose solutions failed not because they didn't work, but because the founders couldn't communicate effectively. A great solution without good communication is just as worthless as an aspirational pitch deck with no solution. Both result in a problem not getting solved.
- lvl100 5y agoInteresting. Please name me one great solution that failed because of a pitch.
- listenallyall 5y agoVincent Van Gogh. During his own lifetime, he failed at communicating or expressing the features and techniques and genius of his own work. But later artists and critics recognized and acknowledged it, and could effectively communicate its genius and importance to curators and the public. The work itself, obviously, didn't change, only the story around it did.
- agonmon 5y agoWhat "real problems" are these? Speaking from the side of software Product Management it is far, far harder to make a pitch deck into a solution. Orders of magnitude more brainpower, effort, discipline. Easiest thing to do is sell tech that is already working and solving a pain point.
- dreyfan 5y agoThere's a large body of people, particularly here, who measure success by how much money you can raise, and nothing whatsoever about actually running a viable business.
- nowherebeen 5y agoI think part of the problem is motivation. I equate the people that strive for VC approach just want to get rich. They don’t care about their employees or their users; they are a means to an end. Raising money assures them no matter what happens to the company they will have a payout even with liquidation preference. Not all VC raises are bad given the right motivation, but more often than not greed comes into the calculation.
- cellis 5y agoI mean, the alternative is to grind out an eking existence on nights and weekends until you're bootstrap profitable and then a "Chosen One" gets funding, or a FAANG comes along and eats your little niche for breakfast...the motivation for raising funding comes from survival instincts.
- dreyfan 5y agoAbsolutely, fundraising is often necessary. The problem is when it becomes the hallmark of success instead of simply a means to an end.
- geoduck14 5y agoThe CEO of my old Fortune 500 laid out our Foundations thusly: "Make money". This isn't the most important thing, but it is the means by which all of these other things are done... then he listed the "things that are important"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- exhaze 5y agoWhy is storytelling aka communicating not a “real problem”?
- lpolovets 5y agoIn many ways, storytelling IS a key part of a founder's job. You're often pitching your company to someone: a prospective customer or employee, an investor, a journalist, a vendor, etc. The better you are at this, the better your company will do. This isn't a hard rule, and there are lots of counterexamples on both sides, but this has been mostly true in my experience. FWIW my venture fund is an investor in ~150 companies, and I've run correlations for company success vs. a bunch of company attributes. "Founder's ability to pitch and sell" is one of a very small number of positive correlations that I've found over the last decade.
- tlogan 5y agoKind true. There are only two jobs of the CEO: hire and sell. Sure hiring and selling need some storytelling but that is just a very small part. There are things like integrity, vision, etc. So I agree but I’m concern that focusing solely on “pitch and sell” is what gave us Nikola, Theranos, …
- dfee 5y ago> Sure hiring and selling need some storytelling but that is just a very small part. I’ve always known storytelling to be fundamental to sales. So much so, that when I first went through sales training a decade ago it was predicated on “customer centrism” (as in customer centric selling) and punctuated by days worth of storytelling foundations.
- sgustard 5y ago> jobs of the CEO: hire and sell I would add identifying a market, conceiving a product and achieving product-market fit to that list.
- crazygringo 5y ago> Sure hiring and selling need some storytelling but that is just a very small part. I beg to disagree -- storytelling is the main part of hiring and selling. Hiring is convincing the employee you want why this company is the next chapter in their personal story, and how they fit into the story of the company and the product. Storytelling is the creation of meaning, and people take jobs because of what they mean for your life. For some people, that meaning is about making the world a better place, while for other's it's about how this job will generate more cold hard cash than you could anywhere else. Similarly, selling is telling and justifying the story of how this product will change the customer's life for the better. Integrity? Vision? Technical specifications? All part of the story you're telling. Not all jobs involve story. If you're building an algorithm, story doesn't really factor into it. But convincing people is always done through a story -- "here's why X is better than Y". So to whatever extent your job in convincing people, it's about communicating story. CEO's do other things too. Deciding which strategy they want to pursue isn't story, it's strategy. But then convincing everyone else to go along with the strategy -- that's story.
- goatherders 5y agoLol. Most startups don't solve any problem, and many that do are solving a problem advertiser's have (not users).
- cvwright 5y agoThe first 90% is solving the problem. The next 90% is telling the story so people can understand how you can help them.
- motoxpro 5y agoAnd this is why companies still fail because the founders think that "If you build it, they will come"
- izgzhen 5y agoBoth options work, but you have to choose one style depending on the stage and type of the startup. If you are founding a new coffee shop, or a trading company, probably you should spend more time working on the actual problem. But if you are founding a future tech (eg SpaceX at its beginning) or anything that requires huge capital or fast scaling in team size, you should spend more time on getting everyone buying the story and provides you with talent and capital to actually solve it.
- madrox 5y agoIt’s remarkable how many real problems can be solved with a good story. Storytelling is how people who don’t do things themselves can direct larger numbers of people to do what you need.
- spoonjim 5y agoProblems have lots of solutions. Often a company looking for say “SaaS application to streamline expense processing” has 50+ options. How they pick one from that 50 has more to do with how memorable the company is (storytelling) than the features (engineering).
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> No it’s not. It’s solving a real problem. Effective leaders tell the stories that attract and retain key people, enable them with resources and put their works into the world. This is a key difference between ventures and small businesses. If the CEO thinks that is beneath them, they’re micromanaging a glorified one-person shop. The technically-superior badly-coördinated solution losing to a well-communicated one is a Silicon Valley, business, political and military trope for good reason.
- halayli 5y agohow will you convince skillful and smart candidates that the problem you are solving is worth their time and risk?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 5y agoI have worked with founder-CEOs who saw their roles as solving all the problems. The message was, if anything is ever not going by the book, call me, I'll come look at it myself. Not only does this alienate smart employees, but it grinds the company to a halt once it's at a scale where two or more of these situations can happen concurrently. The best leaders I've worked with have (implicitly) spun narratives about the problems we're solving, the ways we're approaching them, the kind of people we are, etc. which lead everyone to find within themselves the (mutually agreeable) answers about what to do next.
- Applejinx 5y agoDefine 'startup' and 'founder'. These are not necessarily useful things compared to 'inventor' or 'coder'. But the job is most definitely founding a sort of cult around whatever you say you are, and getting other people to imagine pretty things about what you haven't done and maybe never will do. That's a startup founder. In a sense, this too is a real problem. People will burn a lot of money, time and resources as long as their fundamental motivation is to chase a pipe dream.
- systemvoltage 5y agoThe moment you use emojis in your article, I am instantly turned off and will stop reading.
- ash110 5y agoHow does that affect the quality of the article in any way? It's not like they're expressing through emoji, they're just there as bullet points I get that emoji get a lot of hate on reddit since emoji only comments were low effort and that's justified No emoji at all in any form, that's just a stupid ask
- systemvoltage 5y agoIn the same way if there were using a purple script font. It's just unnecessary decoration and I'll gladly pass even though the content is good (usually it's not).
- ape4 5y agoThat article does use purple text
- whatshisface 5y agoIt's annoying because it interrupts the flow of reading the text. Let me read an emojii article out loud: Today I went to RIGHT ARROW the supermarket GROCERY BAG to get some groceries VEGETABLE and I saw EYE my friend WAVING HAND.
- tchalla 5y agoHow can you read an article filled with emojis without being interrupted in the reading flow?
- whatshisface 5y agoPractically, you can get browser extensions that remove the emojis. The fact that brightly colored symbol blocks interrupt flow will not change as the culture changes because saturation = attention, contrast = attention and uniqueness = attention are all fundamental principles of perception.
- 123pie123 5y agoHumans are hardwired in to stories and story telling. they're the most effective way of communicating. I try and get a little stories into my work comms (given enough time) brief overview of how the project is going - story technical document - story It can be fun to write as well. It doesn't have to a childrens type of story either, read some short stories and get some good ideas although being too creative is sometime seen as not professional.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoFor a sales pitch it can be good for a listener to be able to anticipate a happy ending for themself before you get to the end of the story. And as you conclude, it fulfills what can be expected at that point.
- renewiltord 5y agoSomething about the images and formatting makes this look like one of those “Buy my book for $20 and find out how to be a billionaire by selling books for $20” Tai Lopez type things.
- diskzero 5y agoIt is hard on my eyes and the use of emoticons and images seems juvenille, but this type of article and formatting seems to be a popular trend on LinkedIn, Substack and Medium. As to the content of the article itself, I am curious how many of the hundreds of the founders Ashwin has worked with have used this approach to acquire funding?
- hiddencache 5y agoLooking at the pitch structure they derive, isn't it just a variation of the standard: "problem > solution > benefit" structure?
- TrackerFF 5y agoStorytelling is important, and it's a good skill to have. Just learn a template, and apply it. (Notice how almost every "success" story involving entrepreneurs, prestigious job offers, etc. seem to be some variation of the Hero's journey)
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoThere are two interesting (to me) books on Pixar - one is by the (tech) founder Ed Catmull and is good on the storytelling and hard work side, and a really good "other side of the coin" is by Lawrence Levy who Jobs brought in as "the money guy" to find a way to make Pixar profitable as they tried to land Toy Story - it goes from a little way into the pre-production of the film all the way to the IPO - and it really shines a light on the inner thinking. No one really had a clue how to monetise things, the IPO was a huge risk etc etc. Fascinating all of it, But for me the big thing to contrast is how Ed Catmull described the IPO (how did Steve plan this, how did he know? I am axed at his business acumen) versus Levy (we were all terrified, movie studios refused to give us their business models, the IPO could have failed at any moment). In short there is always several sides to a story, and if anyone is confident of a future plan but has not done it twenty times before, they are faking it !
- mandeepj 5y ago> a really good "other side of the coin" is by Lawrence Levy who Jobs brought in as "the money guy" to find a way to make Pixar profitable as they tried to land Toy Story link to book - https://www.amazon.com/To-Pixar-and-Beyond-Lawrence-Levy-audiobook/dp/B01M69IZ5Y https://www.amazon.com/To-Pixar-and-Beyond-Lawrence-Levy-aud...
- wbl 5y agoWhat is the title of catmull's book?
- grzm 5y agoCreativity, Inc. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18077903-creativity-inc https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18077903-creativity-inc It's on my list to read. Saw a talk Catmull gave on youtube (don't have a link at hand) and was pretty impressed.
- zamfi 5y agoI loved his book, but it's worth noting Catmull was pretty unapologetic for his role in the high tech employee wage-fixing scandal...
- tobr 5y agoThat way of boiling down Finding Nemo seems to miss why the story is designed that way. It doesn’t describe anything about what happens to Marlin as a character, just a few basic plot points, and then in the end he somehow learns that “love depends on trust”. Uh, ok. If you actually want to understand why Finding Nemo “consistently tugs at heartstrings worldwide”, Craig Mazin used it as his primary example in “How to write a movie”, episode 403 of Scriptnotes[1]. (TL;DR: the purpose of everything that happens in a movie is to expose the hero to as much agony as possible, so that the change they’re forced to go through feels real. I don’t know what that means for your startup pitch, though.) 1: https://johnaugust.com/2019/scriptnotes-ep-403-how-to-write-a-movie-transcript https://johnaugust.com/2019/scriptnotes-ep-403-how-to-write-...
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> don’t know what that means for your startup pitch, though The hero is your customer. If they aren’t in agony sufficient to prompt change, i.e. to your product, maybe your pitch is off. Or maybe your target market or product need tweaking.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mixmastamyk 5y agoTo my kid who was three at the time, it was a straight-up horror movie. It had been a while since I had seen it as an adult and didn't realize how scary it was.
- bgroat 5y agoFinding Nemo as as a live-action film with people would be amongst the scariest concepts imaginable. A young couple is expecting twins and moves into a respectable neighbourhood. In a home invasion the wife is killed, one of the twins are lost, and the surviving child is born physically impaired. Flash forward, the child is now ~10. He's a happy, normal child (minus the physical impediment). The father is wracked with anxiety at all times and emotionally suffocates the child. The child wants to be independent (like any 10 year old) so in an act of rebellion with his friends he goes someplace a little bit shady. He's kidnapped! All of the father's worst fears are realized. Nobody can help him except a mentally handicapped outsider
- vambllc 5y agoPlease check out our visit for the best deals https://vambllc.com/ https://vambllc.com/
- hummel 5y ago100% guaranteed success in fundraising. You only need one of these options: - Be a friend or acquaintance of the fund manager. - Be the child of an important client of the investment bank. - Study at a prestigious university together with other children of the bank's clients - You have sold your previous business or already own a very successful one. It is a fallacy to think that your pitch will be of any use in 2021. It is 90% personal relationships, 5% narrative and 5% luck. Not even the business plan is relevant anymore (WeWork and many others)
- infocollector 5y agoAny thoughts on how to fix this? Regulation will be gamed the same way the current system has a problem.
- shadilay 5y agoIt's not like this isn't a hole in the market. The problem is the incentive to invest in better ideas isn't stronger.
- sroussey 5y agoPlease define a better idea, and why that is valuable, and how much that might be worth. I’m always surprised at how much people value an idea verses making that idea happen.
- dustingetz 5y agobad investors will eventually go broke in 7 years when they have no actual exits, but what’s insane is that bad investors aren’t going broke, the insanity is insanely profitable, presumably due to the macro climate, which makes them good investors (or selection bias but what’s the difference)
- andrepd 5y agoWholesale replacement of the current way of creating and allocating capital and debt with a better system.
- turpialito 5y agoThis is bullshit unsupported by any credible data. Where the hell do they get "90% of your job is storytelling."???
- moises_silva 5y agoThey’re storytelling.
- habibur 5y agoFinding the right comment at the bottom... as always.
- kragen 5y ago> As a startup founder, 90% of your job is storytelling. How can we fix that? To the extent that this is true, startup funding will go to the best storytellers, like Stephen King or John Lasseter (or, perhaps, Elizabeth Holmes), instead of the people working on the most important breakthrough technology they could most easily bring to market. How could you run a VC firm that funds the best hackers instead of the best storytellers? Or a company that works on the best ideas instead of the ones advocated by the best internal storytellers? Or a trade publication that touts the best ideas instead of the ideas with the best storytellers? One way to think of this is that storytelling is an attempt to hack investors' evaluation function; as pg says in http://www.paulgraham.com/lesson.html http://www.paulgraham.com/lesson.html: > But wasting your time is not the worst thing the educational system does to you. The worst thing it does is to train you that the way to win is by hacking bad tests. This is a much subtler problem that I didn't recognize until I saw it happening to other people. > When I started advising startup founders at Y Combinator, especially young ones, I was puzzled by the way they always seemed to make things overcomplicated. How, they would ask, do you raise money? What's the trick for making venture capitalists want to invest in you? The best way to make VCs want to invest in you, I would explain, is to actually be a good investment. Even if you could trick VCs into investing in a bad startup, you'd be tricking yourselves too. You're investing time in the same company you're asking them to invest money in. If it's not a good investment, why are you even doing it? Investors want to invest in the companies that will make the most money. As Ashwin points out, the founders' storytelling ability is a component in making money, because it affects company morale and public relations, as well as future funding rounds. But there are a lot of other components to making money, as Theranos found out. If Ashwin is correct that 90% of a startup founder's job is storytelling, then investors are vastly overvaluing storytelling ability when they make their investment decisions, and there should be a lot of startups out there with mediocre storytelling and genuinely great technology that investors could get exposure to for a much lower price. The information asymmetry here is a real problem, though, because how do the investors find out about the great technology? The people who are working on it have to tell them about it, and if they're bad at communicating, it's going to be hard to understand what they're saying. Maybe "due diligence" should start earlier on, with proactive due-diligence teams going out and scouting out ideas that could turn out to be big. Linux Weekly News, of all things, is the closest approach to this I've seen in the real world. Sounds pretty hard. But better than investing in Theranos and passing on Dropbox.
- rishabhd 5y agoOn a different note, I like the Rick and Morty one as well. Not sure if this is going to fit investor pitches except in very esoteric cases. I used this during a cyber security session though with success. reference : https://blog.reedsy.com/guide/story-structure/dan-harmon-story-circle/#what_is_the_dan_harmon_story_circle_ https://blog.reedsy.com/guide/story-structure/dan-harmon-sto...
- macando 5y agoAs with any sensible advice about structure, the takeaway here is not that you must slavishly adhere to a set formula or risk ruining your story. This story circle, along with other popular story structures like the three-act structure, are simply tools based on observations of stories that have managed to resonate with readers over the centuries. So story theories are stories themselves. How meta.
- mostertoaster 5y agoThis seems obvious to me. I think ultimately they are choosing the story given to them. If you tell them a story and they buy that, they also don’t care about what product you make but what story your product tells. If it tells a good enough story it is a story they can then sell to consumers. Profit isn’t to be made by meeting basic survival needs, but once people have their basic survival needs met, then it can become profitable to start selling the story that this product lets you be a participant in.
- vishnugupta 5y agoI began noticing a pattern in recent popular startup founding stories. It goes something like this. Protagonist is the founder here. 1. I wanted to do X. 2. But I couldn't Or it was an extremely frustrating experience. 3. So I took a step back and thought, f***k it I'll build it myself. 4. So here we are; our vision is to democratise X and uplift millions out of their misery. Examples of the top of my head: 1. The concept for Uber was born one winter night during the conference when the pair was unable to get a cab. [1] 2. ....they were having trouble paying their rent and were looking for a way to earn some extra cash. They noticed that all hotel rooms in the city were booked, as the local Industrial Design conference attracted a lot of visitors.[2] 3. The idea for ZopNow came when founder Mukesh Singh was standing in a queue at a grocery supermarket. The idea flashed in his mind that something could certainly be done to save people from the hassle of waiting in long lines at grocery supermarkets [3] 4. He was motivated to start OYO Rooms so that he could be in control of the TV remote, which wasn’t possible when he stayed with relatives when he was a child.[4] [1] https://www.uber.com/en-IN/newsroom/history/ https://www.uber.com/en-IN/newsroom/history/ [2] https://getpaidforyourpad.com/blog/the-airbnb-founder-story/ https://getpaidforyourpad.com/blog/the-airbnb-founder-story/ [3] http://www.newspatrolling.com/zopnow-company-profile/ http://www.newspatrolling.com/zopnow-company-profile/ [4] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/company/corporate-trends/how-ritesh-agarwals-oyo-conquered-china/multitasker/slideshow/65795183.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/company/corporate-...
- 411111111111111 5y agoIs that surprising? Basically everyone says that you should solve a problem you yourself have if you want to start a business, as that's basically already validated from the start. This is just a consequence of people taking that old adage to heart
- alisonkisk 5y ago> you yourself have That's the myth. The reality is "a problem you see some people have" (where problem is defined as "anything real or imagined or incepted need that someone can be persuaded to pay for").
- seanhunter 5y agoI don't buy the whole premise about storytelling being the big thing. In particular I think doing the thing is much much much much much more important than telling the story. If you do the thing then the story tells itself. I was 1 of a team of 2 or 3 on every pitch in 2 or 3 separate processes to raise over 1bn dollars and make the company I worked for (OakNorth) the most valuable fintech in Europe at the time. We did about 30 investor meetings covering everyone in the PE world, some of the big tech investors, some key VCs, some family offices etc. We ended up massively oversubscribed so and picked the investors we thought were the best fit. In every single pitch the most important things were: 1. your company should actually do something important/valuable. Solve an important problem etc. 2. you should have a plan for a future where the unit economics work, and you should know the plan inside and out 3. you should have thought through something about how what your company does intersects with *this particular investor's* interests, and be able to articulate that clearly 4. You should have clear asks - not just money for valuation but what else you're looking to get from them (strategic advice, intros, synergies with other companies in their portfolio etc). The deck, pitch itself etc are much less important than doing something important and actually knowing what you're talking about. In particular, avoid the thought that you can hack the process with a slick pitch and a cool-looking deck. It may take you to a first meeting, but it's not going to get you to close with anyone of substance.
- jacquesm 5y agoA good pitchdeck condenses a complicated subject to its essence, just enough text to convince and short enough to avoid wasting time. It informs rather than overwhelms, and stays clear of hyperbole. It's the equivalent of a telegram, it conveys information, and every word has a cost. A bad pitchdeck is one that focuses on form over function, wastes the readers time with unnecessary detail and extrapolates into an unknowable future with too much conviction that things will really play out that way (they won't).
- jollybean 5y agoThose are good points, which would usually not be communicated outside the context of a specific VC pitch after which the 'story' has already been told as an introduction. The 'narrative' is something that you tell to partners, customers, on the speakers panel at the tech show, in articles. In a nutshell, the 'story/narrative' is the foundation of the pitch, which can be expanded from 10 seconds, to 2 minutes, to 5 minutes to 1 hour, with varying levels of detail. The CEO, or 'someone' at the company will be telling this story over, over and over, and this is how the company is communicated. The 'VC Pitch' is just one small part of telling the story.