18 ms·
How green is blue hydrogen?
- Florin_Andrei 5y ago> The vast majority of hydrogen (96%) is generated from fossil fuels, particularly from steam methane reforming (SMR) of natural gas but also from coal gasification. That's the problem, right there. It's hard to make those processes clean. We need a different process for hydrogen. Or stick to 100% electric instead.
- justaguy88 5y agoHopefully wind/solar electric
- Robotbeat 5y agoYeah, anything but green hydrogen is just a complicated way of keeping the status quo, fossil fuel oriented system in place. There might be a small benefit to global warming (not found in this paper), but it’s using up a finite amount of capture space. I do think we can probably get a lot better at capturing methane leaks, though. It’s low hanging fruit. …and even green hydrogen is much less efficient for heating and propulsion than heat pumps and battery/direct-electric. Especially in the early days when we are still working to increase the energy payback of renewables, this is not helpful! We need high efficiency usage of electricity. Making hydrogen is something you shouldn’t do unless there aren’t alternatives. We don’t need hydrogen for heat, for transport, or for storage (possible exception being seasonal storage once you’ve surpassed 95% clean electricity… no point in hydrogen storage if you’re still only a 50% clean grid). Hydrogen trucks are more expensive (to buy and ESPECIALLY a to operate) and not necessarily any more range (possible exception if you use liquid hydrogen). We do use hydrogen industrially for all ammonia production and (believe it or not) all new iron ore reduction plants (DRI/HBI plants) in the US (they use syngas usually, a mix of hydrogen and CO, usually made from natural gas but it could be made almost entirely with hydrogen), so it’s not like we won’t find a use for the hydrogen we might produce from excess renewable power.
- shalmanese 5y agoWell, also that green hydrogen is a drop in replacement for blue/grey hydrogen. The hard part is building all the infrastructure. If we can build the infrastructure on blue/grey and then gradually transition to green over time, it's an easier feat than waiting until we have economical green hydrogen before starting to build.
- Robotbeat 5y agoExcept we already HAVE massive demand for blue/gray hydrogen (for fertilizer and steel), and the infrastructure for electric vehicles (cars, trains, and trucks) is FAR cheaper than it is for hydrogen. It doesn’t make sense to invest in expensive dead-end infrastructure when we know it is fundamentally, significantly less efficient from a physics standpoint.
- diarrhea 5y agoEfficiency is not a huge concern when highly fluctuating energy from renewable sources is involved. You either have zero efficiency because it goes to waste for lack of storage, or some efficiency through hydrogen (electrolysis).
- ben_w 5y agoThe options are not {hydrogen, waste}, they are {batteries, thermal storage, pumped hydroelectric, Sabatier process methane[0], …, hydrogen, waste}. [0] I’m not a civil engineer and I can’t estimate the costs of upgrading existing methane pipes to cope with hydrogen, but people write about it being a thing, so this may or may not be better than pure hydrogen even if it’s less energy efficient; but the point is there are many options not just two
- diarrhea 5y agoNot wrong! However: - batteries: not available large-scale - thermal storage: potentially terribly inefficient (but as I said, yes it's at least something!) - pumped hydroelectric: where I'm from, only available to a tiny fraction of the country - Sabatier process methane: that's a possibility I guess, more inefficient though My point being, yes you're right, there's many more storage solutions, but hydrogen seems to trump most. Might as well use that as much as possible. > [0] I’m not a civil engineer and I can’t estimate the costs of upgrading existing methane pipes to cope with hydrogen, but people write about it being a thing The issue is also that the recipients would need to deal with the pure hydrogen they're getting. Residential boilers for natural gas can't, for example. New models are required.
- vondur 5y agoI would have hoped that the hydrogen needed for fuel would be produced by the electrolysis of water using solar/wind/nuclear. Anything else is kinda silly.
- wizzwizz4 5y agoThat's “green hydrogen”, and it does happen – but it's more expensive, because we already have the fossil infrastructure.
- iamgopal 5y agoI think there is hope in to hydrogen that is produced as by product of carbon capture technology, especially green cement and lithium production via sea water.
- thescriptkiddie 5y agoIs there a theoretical carbon capture technology with hydrogen as byproduct? It seems to me that if anything it would consume hydrogen.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Is there a theoretical carbon capture technology with hydrogen as byproduct? Just from the elements involved, that seems possible, but only if the GHG you are capturing specifically is methane.
- nanomonkey 5y agoGasification of woody biomass produces Carbon Monoxide, Hydrogen (a.k.a. syngas) and Biochar (Ash minerals and Carbon). If you bury the biochar then you are essentially reverse mining carbon. Biochar is stable in the soil for hundreds of years.
- iamgopal 5y agoSearch green cement and lithium mining from sea water, there are technologies that produces hydrogen as by product , also I think future of mining is from sea water and sea bed , and those technologies most likely will produce hydrogen ( electrolysis ) .
- boyadjian 5y agoDecarbonized world does not exists. It's an invention of self-righteous/do-gooders/right-thinking people. Every human activity will generate CO2, it's inevitable
- Manuel_D 5y agoDecarbonization can largely be achieved by replacing electricity production and fuels with carbon neutral processes. Nuclear power for power plants can do the former effectively anywhere where there is demand for power. The latter is trickier. Batteries work for things like cars, but don't have the energy density required for applications like transoceanic transportation. But that's where the prospect of hydrogen fuel comes into play. Industrial applications, like smelting, is another big application of fossil fuels that hydrogen can supplant.
- spfzero 5y agoIf generating electricity could be done carbon free via nuclear/solar/wind, and that electricity used to produce hydrogen via electrolysis, you'd have something for industrial/transportation uses.
- ancientworldnow 5y agoElectricity production is only 20-40% of carbon generation (depending on what stat you're looking at and where). Nuclear power emits only a little less co2 than "clean" combined cycle nat gas when you account for the massive amount of concrete and energy for construction and decommissioning (aka lifetime emissions which is a stat rarely used for this reason). Dirty electricity production (coal primarily) also has an aerosol masking effect the latest IPCC report estimates to be 0.5-0.8C in cooling - an effect we lose when we switch to renewable (which we should do anyway as this bandaid will need to be ripped off eventually). The post you're replying to is exaggerating but a decarbonized economy will look nothing like what we have now.
- Manuel_D 5y ago> Nuclear power emits only a little less co2 than "clean" combined cycle nat gas when you account for the massive amount of concrete and energy for construction and decommissioning (aka lifetime emissions which is a stat rarely used for this reason). This is far from correct. Yes, concrete production releases CO2, but that only happens once over the 50-80+ year lifetime of a nuclear power plant. Carbon emissions from nuclear are a fraction of fossil fuels [1]. They need to have a separate magnified section to meaningfully show them on the graph: https://www.carbonbrief.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Screen-Shot-2017-12-08-at-15.30.38.png https://www.carbonbrief.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Scree... 1. https://www.carbonbrief.org/solar-wind-nuclear-amazingly-low-carbon-footprints https://www.carbonbrief.org/solar-wind-nuclear-amazingly-low... And as mentioned earlier, fuels and industrial processes are where hydrogen comes into play: nuclear can produce hydrogen without C02 emissions through thermal generation.
- dTal 5y agoHydrogen is a stupid fuel. There, I said it. It's hard to store. It leaks away. It has poor energy density by volume (and much of the energy simply goes to compress the damn stuff) - only 3x li-ion, for your trouble. It has a crappy round-trip efficiency - only 50% for water -> electrolysis -> fuel cell. It's just a shitty battery. The only thing it's got going for it is that it's a way of greenwashing fossil fuels.
- HWR_14 5y ago50% round-trip efficiency and 3x the density of li-ion sounds pretty good, actually. Assuming your efficiency number is the entire cost of water -> compressed H2.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoToyota's hydrogen tanks looked promising: 300mi range and 3 minute refill time. It's disappointing it never went anywhere.
- s5300 5y ago>It's disappointing it never went anywhere. There's probably a sound reason for that
- Tade0 5y agoIt's 3 minutes assuming the fuelling station is at peak pressure - 700 bars. After the first fill up it needs several minutes to pressurize. Also such a facility costs at least $1mln and is unlikely to ever get much cheaper.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> Also such a facility costs at least $1mln and is unlikely to ever get much cheaper. How much does a conventional gas station cost? I would expect several hundred thousand, at least.
- ipspam 5y agoAm I correct in assuming that energy use, period, is the problem? I would love to see how many KWH per person on the entire planet are generated every year by legit clean sources. Solving global warming = destroying life as we know it.
- dTal 5y agoNo, you aren't correct. Most energy, globally, is indeed generated in ways that are not environmentally friendly - but that's not an axiom. It's entirely possible to build a house with all the modern conveniences that's not even connected to the power grid. Solar packs a surprising punch - a panel 2.5m square, in full sunlight, can run a microwave.
- spfzero 5y agoNo, because pollution (CO2, etc.) is the problem. Energy use would be irrelevant if it did not harm the environment.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Am I correct in assuming that energy use, period, is the problem? No, greenhouse gas emissions are the problem.
- megaman821 5y agoNo, the Earth reflects more waste energy back into space in a few minutes than we use all day. Nearly unlimited renewable energy is available with today's technology but there are political and economic problems to solve first before that can become a reality.
- lancemurdock 5y agoor we could just go nuclear
- mullingitover 5y agoNot or, and. The only way hydrogen even makes sense is if you build so much nuclear power that your baseline generation is peak electricity usage, and you use the extra generating capacity during low demand times to split water.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou can't really compare hydrogen with gas and coal. Gas and goal are (fossil) fuels, hydrogen is a battery, or more accurately, at best an energy storage medium. Yes, you can use it for rockets, but you first have to separate it out from water using the same energy that later oxidization will return.
- analog31 5y agoRight now the cheapest source of hydrogen is producing it from gas and coal. Using it as a portable storage medium for green energy is still the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, but then really coal and probably either oil or natural gas are the fuels. Hydrogen is then an intermediate product, a bit like running your electric car on electricity made with a coal or a gas plant. The real fuel is coal or gas, not hydrogen. Of course in the most abstract form of the argument all but nuclear fission is ultimately derived from fusion, but I think you get what I mean.
- xnx 5y agoSounds like the ethanol of hydrogen.
- meristohm 5y agoWhile it doesn’t make anyone rich, a culture/lifestyle shift towards doing more with our bodies, instead of converting other energy so that we have more free time (in which to convert even more resources), might enrich us in other metrics than money. What will it take for more people to meet their exercise needs without having to make time to exercise? Barring one or two funerals, I’m done with air travel, and long-distance travel in general; one small step for a man, and it could be giant if we agreed on regulation that limited the amount of fuel we collectively convert.
- imtringued 5y agoThe idea that money is wealth isn't just bad for our wellbeing, it's bad for the economy because money is meant to circulate. It's a means to an end, not the means. True wealth only exists in the real world. That includes our bodies and the environment around us, not just our material possessions.
- letitbeirie 5y agoUnless we figure out a way to reverse entropy, hydrogen is going be less efficient than any feedstock we make it out of. If/when we achieve direct solar separation at scale hydrogen might start to make sense for transportation/portable applications at least.
- ThinkBeat 5y agoMy ex wife worked at a large international airport. They converted their entire fleet of cars, trucks, into hydrogen. (Yes, it is inaccurate there were still some normal fossile fuel vehicle around). From her perspective it was great. No emissions at the airport. No waiting to charge the truck, filling it up was comparable to putting gas in the tank. The vehicle could run 24/7 as their old fossile fuel counterparts. I understand that the production of hydrogen may not be good at the moment, but I hope it changes. I would prefer to have a hydrogen car to a Li-ion battery, if and only if it became a majority platform. Every winter, tons of people want to go up to the mountains. Given it is in the middle of winter the weather can change and roads closed. Sometimes the wait can be several hours before the snow plows arrive and arrange slow column driving. It is easy for the snowplows or other rescue vehicle to provide diesel and petrol and in sone version of the future hydrogen. It is not easy to charge a lot of electrical cars. I an sure you can make trucks with huge batteries, but it will still take considerable time to charge them all, in if it is done in parallell. One truck charging 30 cars in 30 minutes or however long they will need to reach a level where they can run the heat at max and drive behind the plow. Until they figure all this out, I feel safest with a plug-in hybrid.
- salamandars 5y agoCould hydrogen electrolysis be viable as grid or building level energy storage? Round trip efficiency is bad of course, but I (naively) wonder if it wouldn't have a lot of the downsides fuel cells have for vehicles? You could bury a huge volume of tanks beneath new buildings and store the gas at a lower pressure than we see in hydrogen car tanks - wouldn't that make the whole system simpler and more economical?
- pfdietz 5y agoYes, grid is a big use case. Hydrogen can be stored in salt domes for maybe $1/kWh (energy capacity cost). This is two orders of magnitude cheaper than batteries, and could be used for seasonal load leveling.
- Componica 5y agoQuoting Wikipedia: "As of 2020, the majority of hydrogen (∼95%) is produced from fossil fuels by steam reforming of natural gas, partial oxidation of methane, and coal gasification" "As of 2020 most of hydrogen is produced from fossil fuels, resulting in carbon emissions." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production
- elil17 5y ago> [The GHG footprint of blue hydrogen is] more than 20% greater than burning natural gas or coal for heat and some 60% greater than burning diesel oil for heat Totally apples to oranges comparison - heating is and always will be way more energy efficient than electricity generation on a per-watt basis because you eliminate the inefficiencies inherent in the compressors and turbines. You have to compare hydrogen to what it’s being used to replace - internal combustion engines, which are wildly inefficient.
- aardvarkr 5y agoThanks for pointing this out! That nuance seems to have been completely left out of the conversation
- diarrhea 5y ago> inefficiencies inherent in the compressors and turbines This is not why such thermal engines/plants perform (well below) 100% efficiency. You could have isentropic (i.e., ideal, working losslessly) components and will probably still land below 50% thermal efficiency, limited simply by the Carnot efficiency. That is to say, it's a fundamental physical limit, not an anthropological limit (e.g. component quality). I also don't understand the point you're making. If you burn these three fuels, they have certain carbon footprints. What's wrong with that comparison? You cannot "compare hydrogen to internal combustion engines" --- that's apples and oranges, comparing a fuel to an energy conversion machine. You can compare hydrogen and fuel cells to gasoline/Diesel and ICEs, which gets closer to the whole chain (but still ignores how the fuels were procured). Lastly, ICEs are not "wildly inefficient". Large-scale maritime Diesel engines are some of the most efficient machines we have in this sector. It's not about what's lacking to 100% --- 100% is physically unobtainable. It's about the delta to Carnot efficiency, which gets very small for these. It's important to regard energy qualities and types, since you are comparing apples and oranges otherwise. With energy, there's no free lunch, and a number like 90% efficiency might be entirely meaningless, e.g. for electric water kettles (doesn't stop advertisers).
- alvah 5y agoWhy wouldn't you just use methanol, which can be synthesized from CO2 and hydrogen, and can be used in existing internal combustion & turbine prime movers?
- csours 5y agoThese results look marginal, as in, if you tweak the assumptions slightly you can get a net positive. I'm not saying they're wrong, but there are quite a few results in the green economy that look like this from the outside and it's hard to tell how things will turn out before you try them. To be clear: I think batteries are a much better choice than hydrogen for consumer applications at this point in time. It is unclear what will happen with Over the Road long haul trucking and airplanes.
- fnord77 5y ago> Hydrogen is often viewed as an important energy carrier in a future decarbonized world. by who? (other than japanese car makers)
- toomanybeersies 5y agoCummins has been investing significantly in hydrogen technologies as a replacement for diesel and natural gas power systems.
- adrianN 5y agoIt's quite popular with conservative politicians in Germany too.
- coderenegade 5y agoMaersk and the Viking Energy project are developing the technology to use it in shipping as ammonia. The first hydrogen-fueled commercial passenger flight has already flown, and there are a number of conversions of existing aircraft happening. Airbus is also looking into it. I think for these types of applications, ammonia makes more sense, especially if you can get away with high temperature fuel cells that can use ammonia directly. For drones, hydrogen is proving to be better for aircraft needing long endurance, and is likely the future of the industry -- at least for platforms above a certain weight class.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoAny kind of carbon capture system that is intended to enable the continued burning of fossil fuels is an obviously bad idea. We need the tech in general, so we can for example extract carbon from methane we capture from landfills and find some kind of use for it, but anyone talking about fitting it to a coal or gas power plant is attempting a greenwash. Taxing gray gas usage for carbon and putting the money towards green hydrogen and enforcing some minimal but rising percentage of green hydrogen in the mix to bootstrap the industry is obviously better long term. Also, that green hydrogen has many cool uses but anything that can run on mains power or batteries is probably not a good fit.
- dan12ha 5y agoThis company is claiming to replace the steam with a plasma beam and turns the carbon into a solid so no co2 emissions. The process creates hydrogen on site so just pipe natural gas no distribution problems. https://hiiroc.com/ https://hiiroc.com/