13 ms·
BioNTech has a lot of potentially groundbreaking mRNA therapies in its pipeline, some of them against various forms of cancer. https://investors.biontech.de/ne
by inglor_cz 5y ago
BioNTech has a lot of potentially groundbreaking mRNA therapies in its pipeline, some of them against various forms of cancer.
https://investors.biontech.de/news-releases/news-release-details/biontech-announces-first-patient-dosed-phase-2-clinical-trial https://investors.biontech.de/news-releases/news-release-det...
https://biontech.de/science/individualized-cancer-medicine https://biontech.de/science/individualized-cancer-medicine
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03072-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03072-8
I am really looking forward for such solutions, fuck cancer.
That said, the economic impact of such cures isn't clear to me. If your population gains, on average, say, a year or two of life, the pay-as-you go pension systems that are already under strain in greying Europe will come under even bigger strain.
So it seems that each discovery like that will be balanced by us working longer. Personally, I as a 42 y.o. in Czechia, do not expect to get any meaningful state pension ever. There will be just too many of us.
- oaiey 5y agoI am not worried only about better healthcare. Population growth, climate change, waste, .. so many more thing to worry. For me humanity is up for a massive shrinking. Either because we do it or (some decades later) mother earth does it.
- nyx-aiur 5y agoNothing better than waking up and reading wishes for a mass extinction event on hackernews.
- programmarchy 5y agoWhat do you make about Elon Musk's prediction that the biggest threat in the future may actually be population collapse [1], rather than overpopulation? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44Klhl81K7g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44Klhl81K7g
- te_chris 5y agoWorth checking out the book The Great Demographic Reversal
- programmarchy 5y agoThis looks very interesting, just picked a copy on Audible. Thank you for the recommendation.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoI would say that while it is a plausible hypothesis, Elon Musk has no particular reason to be seen as a credible source in this space, and that opening with that citation feels like its asking for discussion on the merits of Elon vs. the idea itself.
- programmarchy 5y agoFair enough, I'll refer to his most salient point: A dwindling youth essentially enslaved to take care of a burgeoning aging population is pretty dystopian. So if life extension technology gets implemented with something like mRNA technology, then it seems like that would have to be balanced out by higher birthrates.
- inglor_cz 5y agoPersonally, I think that artificial wombs will be operational before widespread aging reversal.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoWe don't need to worry about mRNA vaccines doing this. You'd need to actually reverse aging. Stopping diseases one by one will never work. They're simply not preventable in the long term. The population dynamics of such a situation would be dwarfed, imo, by the political and wealth inequality problems. Society is structured firmly around an average human lifespan.
- whatshisface 5y agoIt depends where in life you gain those two years. Two extra years of being 20 is a lot nicer than two extra years of being 99.
- inglor_cz 5y agoTrue, but cancer is typically a disease of the old age. I do not remember it exactly, but your chances of developing cancer at 70 are several thousand times higher than at 20.
- adventured 5y agoIt's not quite that dramatic. Globally [1] it's closer to 100x-200x for an early 20 something vs early 70 something. For the US [2] it's 3.4 per 100k at 20-24 years of age, and 659 per 100k at 70-74 years of age (call it 200x). A large number of people 50-70 die of cancer however. For the 60-64 group, the rate spikes to 331 per 100k. 50 to 70 can be high quality years for a person. In response to the parent comment that mentioned solving cancer only adding a few years, the lives to be saved in the 50-70 group is a very potent counter argument for the economic value and considerable high-quality years that can be added rather than dying at eg 55 or 63. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cancer-death-rates-by-age?country=~OWID_WRL https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cancer-death-rates-by-age... [2] https://rivercountrynews.com/an-update-on-cancer-deaths-in-the-united-states-p10169-293.htm https://rivercountrynews.com/an-update-on-cancer-deaths-in-t...
- munk-a 5y agoNot enough people realize this early in their life and spend their youth toiling away for some imagined perfect retirement life - only to reach it and have their pensions disappeared by their company's management firm gambling it away on the stock market, being struck with disease and mobility issues that prevent travel, and losing their loved ones early on into their imagined golden years. Life doesn't last forever; keeping your head down and being a "good worker" doesn't get you shit. You need to actively fight to make sure those years in your youth are worth it - since it's always quite possible that cancer strikes you down in your thirties.
- candiodari 5y ago> That said, the economic impact of such cures isn't clear to me. If your population gains, on average, say, a year or two of life, the pay-as-you go pension systems that are already under strain in greying Europe will come under even bigger strain. And the alternative is? I mean people keep doing this "A is bad" ... okay what's B? Sometimes there's this implied, horrible option B. Sometimes there's just nothing. Never mind that there is still pretty decent child mortality from cancer. And if you count every disease that mRNA can fight ... there's a few really bad ones in there. > So it seems that each discovery like that will be balanced by us working longer. Personally, I as a 42 y.o. in Czechia, do not expect to get any meaningful state pension ever. There will be just too many of us. If medicine can keep us in a fit enough state, physically and mentally, I say bring it on! If not, there isn't a discussion to be had, because it won't happen.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoChild cancer treatments are going to be driven by fundamentally different causes and require totally different treatments, fyi.
- inglor_cz 5y agoOf course we won't stop medicating people who can be saved just to protect the pension systems. At least democratic states won't, the politicians would be eaten alive by the grey voting bloc. And in this case rightly so. But that means that we really need to push with certain research forward. If you can live to be 90 and in good health, you won't mind working longer. (Though some people may mind if that means that, say, judges stay in their offices for 60 years). It is the intermediate stage that is bad. In that stage, people suffer from chronic diseases and bad health for decades, unable to enjoy life fully and work. I know that this isn't easy to solve. Biology of aging is complicated like hell, to the degree that not too long ago, aging was considered inevitable, untreatable and incurable, thus attracting almost no funding and scientific attention. This has been changing lately, but it will take some time before we see results in humans and not just in mice.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago
- Jach 5y agoThe cost savings in medical expenses can balance out a lot, this becomes even more apparent as aging itself is cured and the costs associated with diseases brought on by aging, especially expensive end-of-life care, disappear. Since your attitude is already set, there's less resistance to ending such pension plans for younger people now even as they continue paying in to support their elders. The sentiment with social security in the US is the same. If an administration ever actually tries to gracefully end it, I think it will be easier to pull off than they expect.
- systemvoltage 5y agoModerna as well: https://www.modernatx.com/pipeline https://www.modernatx.com/pipeline
- Mikeb85 5y ago> BioNTech has a lot of potentially groundbreaking mRNA therapies in its pipeline, some of them against various forms of cancer. This is good news. In the last year I've lost 2 close ones to cancer.
- inglor_cz 5y agoFor me, too. In my family, we rarely suffer from heart attacks and we only had one dead in last 40 years or so that died from cardiovascular disease. He was a heavy smoker and his non-smoking brother outlived him by almost thirty years. But cancer is our faithful family enemy, even though it mostly comes late in life. Every tool against it will meet my approval.
- Mikeb85 5y agoThankfully cancer doesn't run in my family, but somehow (bad luck I guess) I have lost a shocking amount of young friends or acquaintances to cancer now (all 40 years or younger). All were very healthy too (none were smokers, heavy drinkers, etc...). I'm dreading hearing about more cases since Covid restrictions included delaying a lot of cancer screenings.
- jdavis703 5y agoWe should be increasing the retirement age for public pensions as quality-adjusted life years increase. Unfortunately people don’t want to spend extra years working, or contribute more to pensions during their working years, so we wind up in this unsustainable system.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoIf there is actually productivity growth (which I strongly believe there is) - then this can be shared between 4 groups - the workers, the non-workers, the retired, and the capitalists. I think most workers would like to see 100% of these gains go to workers. I think most shareholders would like to see 100% of the gains go to them. I think it'd be fair to share these evenly - and so higher taxes could make it so that the non-workers and retirees get some of the benefits of productivity increases.
- Traubenfuchs 5y ago> don't want to spend extra years working How many 60+ people do you know? Do you honestly think they should still be working?
- jazzkingrt 5y agoBoth my parents are 60+, my father is in his mid seventies, and they are as productive as ever.
- smcl 5y agoCongratulations to them. My dad has worked manual labour since he left school aged 15 - first as a shipbuilder and then in the oil industry. My mum retired from teaching a year ago then developed lymphoma. Both of these people are in their 60s and have earned their retirement - we need not extract any more "productivity" from them. Leave them be.
- kiba 5y agoWe don't need to extract more productivity, sure, but it would lead to decreased medical costs.
- oblio 5y agoJust the pension plan? Imagine a world where 50%+ of the people voting were born 1 century ago.
- oblio 5y agoTo the downvoters: if we don't also manage to improve neuroplasticity decrease in old age as well as breaking generational cultural norms, we're doomed, don't fool yourself. Especially since older people are politically more active, as a group.
- inglor_cz 5y agoEverything is a trade-off. On one side, old people are less likely to support new trends, starting with fashion and ending with political causes. On the other side, they carry a lot of experience. If a sizable minority personally knows the misery of war or hyperinflation, repetition of those miseries becomes less likely. Plenty of political criminals built their careers on naivete of the young. I think that we will end up with the best of both worlds eventually. If longevity tech succeeds, brains will stay young, but memories will accumulate regardless.
- briffle 5y ago> . If your population gains, on average, say, a year or two of life, the pay-as-you go pension systems that are already under strain in greying Europe will come under even bigger strain. But if these tools can also dramatically lessen the cost for medical care, wouldn't that more than balance out?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Salgat 5y agoSimilar to how smokers actually cost the healthcare system less, since they get cancer early and die closer to retirement age, which is cheap compared to long term care spanning an extra decade or two before a major illness sets in.
- stncls 5y agoIf you can actually cure some cancers, it will probably be a net positive economically. For example, in medical circles in my home country, smoking-related cancer prevention campaigns are widely believed to pay for themselves easily, despite low efficacy. (Sorry, I have no citation for that, but it is what is taught to students in medical school.) In countries where the social safety net fully pays for such health issues (this includes Germany), the cost of cancer patients is itself a tremendous strain on the system. Additionally, the decision for social security to reimburse (i.e. cover) such drugs typically involves long term economic impact computations. Access to such treatment is almost surely a win for everyone.
- Arrath 5y ago> In countries where the social safety net fully pays for such health issues (this includes Germany), the cost of cancer patients is itself a tremendous strain on the system. This is a great point, and there are also knock-on effects to consider. Say, the parent, child or sibling that removes themselves from the workforce to give daily care and ferry a patient to and from treatments.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- snarf21 5y agoThis is the problem, all pension systems are pyramid schemes. Plus you add extra overhead to administer over direct benefit contributions. You can claw some back by keeping the shares of those who die early but it isn't enough. Additionally, dying early should still benefit your family and would do so under direct benefit schemes. You mask ask "what happens when people run out?" and the answer is the largely the same, it becomes a social program that is needs based just like it does for all the people today who have no pension.
- 7952 5y agoSurely the economic impact is mainly in providing thousands of jobs in the health industry. We may be able to afford less in others areas.
- peakaboo 5y agoDon't worry, they are working on population reduction... I think it's more likely most of us are not around in 20 years. So we don't have to worry about it. :)