8 ms·
China is not "smashing its tech industry". It's cracking down on private Internet companies that acquired too much power through network effects. This is comple
by Animats 5y ago
China is not "smashing its tech industry". It's cracking down on private Internet companies that acquired too much power through network effects. This is completely consistent with CCP doctrine. Anything that central has to be state-owned.
Xi declared this year that while digitization is important, “we must recognize the fundamental importance of the real economy… and never deindustrialize.” Right. China, remember, has a national industrial policy. It's expressed in the national 5 year plan, which is taken seriously and used to set priorities.
What those priorities are is no secret. The current 5 year plan, the 14th, lists them.[1] Specific technology goals are in blue boxes. Semiconductors, gas turbines, biotech, new energy vehicles, robotics, advanced agricultural equipment. Internet services are mentioned in the Plan. One key line section out here: "We will strengthen the economic supervision of internet platforms in accordance with laws and regulations, clarify platform enterprise positioning and regulatory rules, improve the laws and regulations concerning the identification of monopolies, and crack down on monopolies and unfair competition. ... We will intensify anti-monopoly and anti-unfair competition law enforcement and judicial efforts and prevent the disorderly expansion of capital."
If you think this isn't to be taken seriously, go back and look at the 13th 5 year plan and check off the completed items.
[1] https://cset.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/t0284_14th_Five_Year_Plan_EN.pdf https://cset.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/t0284_14th_Fi...
- lasagnaphil 5y agoMaybe the headline's a bit misleading, but what you're saying is almost exactly what the article is talking about. (The article immediately refutes the notion of "smashing its tech industry" right away)
- xchaotic 5y agobut they're 'smashing' the likes of Ant Financial who were doing predatory, unsecured lending on an unprecedented scale. So IMO the thesis of smashing 'Internet' companies is incorrect - they're just making sure economy doesn't go into bubble territory (lending fuels spending) and the likes of Jack Ma, who are detached from the party don't get too much power/money.
- viscanti 5y agoOr Didi who had the nerve to IPO outside of China on the NYSE on a date the CCP thought was too close to a party anniversary.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe Chinese central government was always really ambivalent about foreign IPOs. DiDi has too much control over domestic markets for the Chinese to be comfortable with foreign influence. I don't think it has anything to do with the anniversary. Actually, the CCP never formally accepted the foreign stock ownership structure, for example. It was always a grey area.
- polote 5y ago>Maybe the headline's a bit misleading Nah, a lot of people just don't read the articles before commenting, whether it is on HN or anywhere else
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThe article is mostly weird kremlinology of what the chinese leadership are up to. Which seems unnecessary if they're widely publishing 5 year plans that tell you what they're doing. Similar to Tesla's secret plan to produce cheaper and cheaper vehicles at larger scale, the boring truth isn't a big click winner.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoMost people, especially in the west, aren’t reading Chinese 5 year plans very closely.
- viscanti 5y agoWhat part of the 5 year plan outlined the strategy behind why the CCP went after DIDI? I'm genuinely curious and it might be more useful to link to the relevant parts. Some people might actually be interested in reading those and better understanding this.
- thujlife 5y agoanti monopoly?
- ghomrassen 5y agoDidi doesn't have a monopoly in China. Meituan is also a large player in the space along with hundreds of tiny ones.
- beaunative 5y agoMeituan has only just entered the market. Where did you get your information from?
- danieltanfh95 5y agoDidi was caught selling user data without prior consent. Think if Equifax got pulled for "leaking" user data
- majormajor 5y ago> “we must recognize the fundamental importance of the real economy… and never deindustrialize.” This hasn't been really put to the test yet, has it? What's the cost of labor delta compared to the places where outsourcing from China would be attractive currently?
- Theodores 5y agoIn the West the accounting means you can't invest in robots that take years to pay for themselves. It is therefore more profitable to outsource and not have the capital investment on the books. The Germans do it differently and can get a better return investing in themselves. In China they have invested heavily in the robots that make the robots. Sure they are playing catch up in some areas, for instance, chips where they don't have a TSMC yet. Even farming, where do those green and yellow tractors go? Cotton picking in China. Some China tech is way ahead of the rest of the world. The difficulty of competing is getting really hard hence sanctions against Huawei. They had got 5G and The West didn't even know what it was for. We have seen it before, Japan was way ahead with electronics and commodity cars. But China has a vast internal market and can proceed without making cheap goods for the West. If Western companies want to outsource to Burkina Faso then fine. Also into the mix is that Chinese brands are desirable in China and increasingly abroad. China has barely got started.
- walshemj 5y agoNot in the experience of Harrods and Burberry in the UK
- fennecfoxy 5y agoSanctions against Huawei were for malware + ties to the CCP, not because the west "couldn't compete".
- p_l 5y agoIf you think the part where they blitzed 5G so hard that a) you could build 5G network using only Huawei b) it was effectively impossible to build 5G network without Huawei, didn't have impact on USA push to sanction Huawei... I have few bridges in Brooklyn to sell, good price.
- itmayno 5y ago“ It's cracking down on private Internet companies that acquired too much power through network effects.” Sounds like smashing to me. Smashing down on private companies and innovations. Smashing down on private wealth and power. Smashing down on freedom and growth. You can tell the dictator is getting desperate if he stops the train of innovation.
- mcguire 5y agoThat makes the assumption that "innovation" is consumer facing internet technology.
- itmayno 5y agoAlibaba isn’t just consumer facing internet technologies, look up the vast b2b stuff it does. And other types of companies have been smashed as well like evergrande or Wanda. Also, do you really think innovation will come from state companies? In that case, why didn’t 1980 China or 1980 Russia thrive?
- TheDong 5y ago> Also, do you really think innovation will come from state companies? In that case, why didn’t 1980 China or 1980 Russia thrive? You need a stronger argument to prove that state-associated companies can't innovate. There's also plenty of counter examples too. The internet itself was largely created via DARPA, a US state-sponsored research agency. Ditto for the space station and most other space-related achievements prior to SpaceX. I think the more nuanced, and boring, view is that a well functioning state can innovate, and so can well functioning private companies. This comment probably isn't the place for it, but I do think for-profit companies will tend towards different sorts of innovation than for-the-public-good government agencies... but yeah, not for this comment.
- vajrabum 5y agoDARPA doesn't do research or development. They fund it.
- endymi0n 5y agoWow, it‘s actually public… in hindsight, I should probably not be surprised, but it has the same eery feel to me like when I learned that Hitler had actually written down all of his plans around eradicating Jews and Germanic world dominance in his book „Mein Kampf“ a decade before he put it into reality — it was just that nobody took it seriously since they thought he was a lunatic. Maybe it‘s about time to read the Chinese 5 year plans in depth.
- mrkramer 5y agoYea Hitler wrote in Mein Kampf that he hated Jews and Communism so it should've been taken very seriously since a person like him(German nationalist and fanatic) became a chancellor. I don't who expected different behavior than what was written in Mein Kampf. Holocaust and WW2 War could've been prevented if Allies(US, UK and France) invaded Germany in 1933-1939 time period. But they expected Hitler to be European shield against Communism and geo-politic partner.
- hunglee2 5y agohttps://www.chinalawtranslate.com/ https://www.chinalawtranslate.com/ - does a pretty good job of translation of Chinese law. Another part of the problem is the language barrier - not many China commentators in media mainstream actually understand Mandarin or read Chinese - and end up recycling the interpretations of the very few that can
- vikiomega9 5y agoI'm still reading up so looking for resources. What's a good introduction that talks about how the Chinese state is looking at individual choices? 5 year planning makes sense but the implementation is key (India for example had similar planning processes). Is there writing on how Xi or the CCP thinks about incorrect choices in the planning or a fail-safe that prevents what happened to the Soviet Union? Have they ever talked about getting things wrong?
- estaseuropano 5y agoBasically, its just antitrust which for a decade or two has not really been enforced in the US, which in turn might be a reason for many of the ills we see in economy and society today.
- telxos 5y agoGreat point. Even to take it down a notch, what has happened in the US is just boring. You almost can't have a conversation without one of 5 of the same companies coming up.
- hintymad 5y agoI think you're spot on, and the author's assessment is accurate: "China may simply see things differently. It’s possible that the Chinese government has decided that the profits of companies like Alibaba and Tencent come more from rents than from actual value added" In the perspective of Chinese government, it is simply unacceptable that a toilet ordered by the air force cost more than $20k, or the number of ship manufacturers diminishes over years, or the average age of NASA engineers went from below 36 to above 55, or the best minds of the country spends their prime time figuring out how to increase CTR for ads revenue. Manufacturing and advanced research is a key to a nation, and China recognizes it.
- HWR_14 5y ago> it is simply unacceptable that a toilet ordered by the air force cost more than $20k Why do people get hung up on this? Specialty parts cost a lot.
- hintymad 5y agoFrom what I learned, it’s not specialty. Congress has a law that certain percentage of military provisioning must be domestic. The military had to meet the quota by buying toilets, and someone set up a factory in the US just to supply the military, so the unit price was through the roof. This became an example of how the US manufacturing has weakened so much.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe example I'm aware of is that the toilet seats needed to be a specific shape to fit in a specific aircraft, and that they only needed 1XX of them. The $20,000 price tag is because they had to pay for molds, testing, various other fixed costs required to operate, etc.
- aaron695 5y agoThis article talking about this sells it as they managed to get the cost down through 3D printing, I'm absolutely willing to bet it cost the Airforce way more than contracting it out. The cost of a commercial 3d printer with security, to autocad it up, training staff, sending people into the field to measure it. To have a trained air force employee designing toilet seats is questionable, is that what the military should do? Maybe and the air force should explore 3D printers, so it's a waste that might be worth it. But lets not pretend $10,000 went to $300. The Air Force’s $10,000 toilet cover - https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/capitalbusiness/the-air-forces-10000-toilet-cover/2018/07/14/c33d325a-85df-11e8-8f6c-46cb43e3f306_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/capitalbusiness/the-... I wonder if there are any follow ups on what else they 3D printed?
- HWR_14 5y agoFrom my understanding, Jack Ma was allowed to own whatever toys and mistresses he wanted. He could even have some outside of China so he feels safe. His mistake was thinking that the American dynamic of "money equals real power" held true in China.
- Decker87 5y agoYou're agreeing with the author in a rather disagreeable tone.
- refurb 5y agoAgree with your overall assessment, but the 5 year plans are certainly "flexible" and not all goals are consistently met. Often goals will changes mid-5 year span to accommodate reality. Think about your own personal development plan at work, but not that bad. I do agree that "power" is the issue here. It doesn't take much for China to look at how Bezos or Elon act and say "yeah, no, we're not going to have corporate leaders challenging the Party publicly".
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe five year plan is interesting, because I was born in a country that worshipped its five year plans ("pětiletky"). It was the Czechoslovak Socialist Republic. Now the thing about five year plans was that they worked rather well at the beginning, so approximately until 1960. Back then, the economic power of a country was measured by its heavy industry, and in a post-WWII world where there was war damage to be fixed, an entire eastern part of the country (Slovakia) to be modernized from its earlier rural state, and new housing stock to be built, concentration of our five year plans on heavy industry made sense. But slowly the world development started to diverge from the coal-and-steel line. And our central planners didn't take notice, or rather underestimated the significance of that development. They had, after all, a lot of success earlier with coal and steel, so they continued to plan for more coal and steel. Also, a lot of workers in those industries were card-carrying members of the Communist party, so it made sense to reward them for their loyalty. We slowly lost our development edge, fell behind the West in automation, computer technology, semiconductors. The overemphasis on industry led to major ecological problems and pollution, and the emerging ecological initiatives proved to be a fertile ground for opposition. In 1989, the regime fell, and we were left with a huge, absolutely bloated, but mostly obsolete coal and steel industry that could not compete anymore. And its subsequent collapse was a source of significant societal disruption. I saw the collapse of that industry first hand, growing up in a coal and steel city (Ostrava; just take Google Maps and look at the enormous chunks of industrial structures located literally inside the city, with residential buildings right next to the factories). Now China does not seem to fall behind yet, they also allow a lot more capitalism than Communist Czechoslovakia did (in our country, even a private café was a rare sight; the regime was so ideologically pure that it purged even most self-employed people from independence into formal jobs). But I can see a similar "it-must-stay-the-same-itis" in their proclamations that the country must never deindustrialize. Never is a bad word in mortal's mouths. If they fixate on industry at the cost of all other developments, they may go down the same route as Czechoslovakia eventually.
- rini17 5y agoMy dad worked in Tesla Elektroakustika Bratislava manufacturing electronics and often recounted that a member of Politbyro said "Prečo vyrábate polovodiče a nie vodiče?" "Why do you make semiconductors instead of conductors?" There isn't such kind of boneheaded inertia in China. Yet.