18 ms·
Father builds exoskeleton to help wheelchair-bound son walk
- caturopath 5y ago> "Ten years from now, there will be no, or far fewer, wheelchairs," he said. I wonder how much money he'll put on that.
- theslurmmustflo 5y agoif battery technology keeps improving, I'm not sure why that wouldn't be the case for people with long term disablities
- wizzwizz4 5y agoIf you're using a wheelchair due to a joint issue, as opposed to paralysis?
- bredren 5y agoTen years seems fast, but I foresee a revolution in local micro manufacture that is a mashup of 3d printing as we know it and local assembly of off the shelf parts. This will lead to a revolution of generic complex product availability that ignores patents and trademarks. An exoskeleton may not be the first type of product to be ordered and assembled from a few blocks away. The amount of QA for safety would need to be high. However, if the price of such things is 1/10 or even 1/20th that of the branded, official version people will continue to turn to hyperlocal, small-run manufacture for even the most safety-critical products.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoI share your skepticism but I wouldn't question the conviction of a guy who built a company and worked on this project for 10 years to help his son walk again.
- rhino369 5y agoI hope he's wrong since my brother is quadriplegic, but I wouldn't bet on it. Either way, this guy is an inspiration.
- gattilorenz 5y agoMe neither, but that's only true for the richest part of the world, while a majority of the population will still have to deal with wheelchairs (and in many places I imagine self-built ones). Not being snarky, I appreciate a lot what he's doing, and I hope he will succeed in his quest. There's just a glimpse of sadness when I realize that solving the problem in the first world doesn't mean it will be solved for good (same with vaccines, we hope/expect to have solved the COVID problem soon, but it won't actually be the case for a majority of the world population).
- caturopath 5y agoI don't question his conviction, dedication, or cause, just his prediction, which I believe is extremely unlikely.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoI've been making my own, purely as a pipe-dream to have some hope of walking again, it's not easy but I'm hoping it'll be a better fit than consumer ones, and probably cheaper. I feel like we've made leaps and bounds in prosthetics this past decade but orthotics and exoskeletons haven't been following the trend for some reason. As an engineer I imagine there are some significant design constraints that make it hard but seeing what we're capable of doing in any other industry I can't help but feel the problem has to be something other than purely technical limitations. The price is also a big issue, 10k for the cheapest exoskeletons, 150k for the one in this article.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoI worked in a logistics operation that explored exoskeleton options deeply in 2019. Options were shockingly limited and the best products were not powered in any way - essentially just frames to bolster your body mechanically. Compare to the massive, extremely precise, and power-efficient automated storage and retrieval systems and it just seemed like stone age tech. My takeaway was that powered exoskeleton tech must be vastly more difficult to implement than I'd expected. The financial incentives are there for warehouse and logistics applications, but the tech just isn't.
- michaelt 5y agoWhat sort of power sources do current powered exoskeletons use, and what sort of runtimes do you get? That's where I'd foresee the limitations - that you'd end up hefting 80 lbs of battery for 20 minutes of operation.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoI haven't been in the industry for a little bit, so I'm sure the tech has evolved, but the versions we evaluated used battery hot-swapping to extend use time. I honestly don't recall how long a single battery ran for. We primarily evaluated them for use for loads that were too light or unwieldy to necessitate a vehicle but which were too heavy for a human worker to regularly lift without risk of injury (so the 75-200lb range)
- runawaybottle 5y agoThis is kind of dangerous. Something like this that is not tested can pretty much kill you if it fails in anyway. You’ll just fall to the ground from about 5 ft, which is often enough to do something bad to your skull.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoThe medical device industry in France is heavily regulated and products are audited before they reach the market so you can be sure it's a risk that's been identified and remediated.
- crummybowley 5y agoYeah, I think the OP was really talking about this individual case. Eg, this guy put his kid in a device that could kill him (maybe). Looking back at the videos from Boston Dynamics, a ton of effort is put in to the failure mode testing. I highly doubt 1) this is dynamic, 2) failure modes were considered much.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoThis individual case is a medical device company in France, not some garage hacker as the title might imply. No human (except the engineers on the down-low) will have stepped foot inside the device before a very late stage in the design, possibly requiring approval for human trials, at which point all those risks will have been assessed.
- crummybowley 5y agoI stand corrected.
- Blackthorn 5y agoA lot of things are dangerous. Some people would be quite willing to accept that risk so they can walk again.
- 5y ago
- elisee 5y agoVideo of the exoskeleton in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yBfUcFRZ-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yBfUcFRZ-I
- SamuelAdams 5y agoThis is really cool! See to me this is what hacker news should be all about. A group of people facing some problem and hacking something together that works really well.
- samstave 5y agoOne of my favorite movies "Edge of Tomorrow" has dope exoskeletons, and while its a movie - thats where this is heading... I am surprised Boston Dynamics hasnt made one! If you converted the agility of Atlas into an exoskeleton, that would be pretty interesting...
- baby 5y agoReminds me of matrix as well
- nzeribe 5y agoAliens, 1986: "I have a class-2 rating." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YPMk-EEyOpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YPMk-EEyOpE
- nanodeath 5y agoSimilarly I thought of Death Stranding :) Though I guess exoskeletons are not uncommon in sci-fi.
- justinclift 5y agoTried that game out, but found it to be realllllllllly tedious. eg initial missions took walking, while carrying some person's body over the shoulder, for "miles". Urk. Did it get better after those early missions?
- capekwasright 5y agoThey actually did, as part of DARPA's Warrior Web program [1]. They ultimately spun off the program to Ekso Bionics as a consequence of the Google acquisition back in 2014 [2]. [1] https://www.army.mil/article/125315/darpas_warrior_web_project_may_provide_super_human_enhancements https://www.army.mil/article/125315/darpas_warrior_web_proje... (the first image is of BD's system; you can just make out "BOST" around the center of the left thigh) [2] https://www.globenewswire.com/fr/news-release/2014/10/02/670258/29945/en/Ekso-TM-Bionics-Selected-by-Google-s-Boston-Dynamics-to-Execute-DARPA-Project.html https://www.globenewswire.com/fr/news-release/2014/10/02/670...
- xor99 5y agoThis is inspiring. The cost can be brought down through use of soft and/or lightweight materials. For example, the use of textile based actuators. Good examples in link below: https://biodesign.seas.harvard.edu/soft-exosuits https://biodesign.seas.harvard.edu/soft-exosuits These things are not for the near term so really impressed by this story.
- samstave 5y agoDope. You know what I am wondering, the accelerometers in phones are super small, cheap and there are some sensor systems that incorporate a ton of other sensors (whatever happened to Google's smart jacket they were making with Levis) Anyway, it would be very interesting to have a textile with a fabric of accelerometers woven into the fabric... Solar panels on the thighs and what not to power the sensors... with a compression-heel in a shoe / boot to ad more power with every step. Anyone know how much power an accelerometer takes and if you can wire a matrix of them together to a set of controllers that all they do is capture the telemetry from the sensors? Check out this video on the making of accelerometers https://www.engadget.com/2012-05-22-the-engineer-guy-shows-how-a-smartphone-accelerometer-works.html https://www.engadget.com/2012-05-22-the-engineer-guy-shows-h...
- beeskneecaps 5y agoThis is incredible! There's something really appealing and enabling about becoming an "exoskeleton pilot".
- imglorp 5y agoI feel like it's time to take back the term "walker" from the last century.
- manmeet 5y agoThis is amazing. I built one to help my nephew walk, and now selling commercially ( http://trexorobotics.com http://trexorobotics.com ) I am fed-up at the lack of options available to individuals. People thought that everyone will get an exoskeleton and be able to walk with it everywhere. But the industry ran into many challenges. A big one that many dont understand is getting insurance coverage. The way the US healthcare system is designed, it will only cover restoration of mobility, not a restoration of function. So, from their perspective, a wheelchair and some pain meds can do the job easily. I believe that they key is to start with children, this is where you have families desperate for a solution, higher costs due to them growing and spending their entire life in a wheelchair, and the option to truly have a life changing impact. But things are changing, people are starting to notice the work that we are doing. We need a lot more people building exoskeletons and similar powered orthotics!!
- blairbeckwith 5y agoJust wanted to say thanks for building this.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoTalk about impactful work. I wonder how many lives you've changed. Well done. This is something close to miracle tech, at least for the people wearing it. I can't help but feel curious whether they're a viable alternative to wheelchairs, or if it's a temporary feeling (kind of like riding on a rollercoaster, in that you go and do it for the experience and then return to your normal life). But that's just my ignorance talking. Also, fuck the US insurance system. You won't find many topics that make me talk that way, but as I get older it feels something closer to pure evil. I've met so many people who have been screwed over by that system (and personally experienced my share of it). There's a woman I've been texting with who I met at a gas station. She was clearly in distress, so my wife and I offered her a ride home. To cut a long story short, she spent her fourth of july miserable, and when I raised the idea of getting prozac or some sort of antidepressant (my own "miracle tech"), she said "Oh, I used to be on that. I can't afford it because no insurance" and I practically flipped my phone onto the concrete. She could be living a normal and happy life. I can't imagine how much worse it is for parents who otherwise need to spend $thousands for alternative solutions like this. If you can make it in any way affordable, it'll change countless lives, I'm certain.
- chris_va 5y agoI am not a robotics expert, and I've always wanted to ask one... Why do these designs always have the actuators mounted directly at the joints? Why not have some high modulus yarn transfer the joint loads (ala a bike brake cable, say with high modulus aramid?)? One could keep the actuators near the center of mass (or a trolley that follows it around), and keep the suit fairly minimal.
- jcun4128 5y ago> bike brake cable Funny you mention that, this guy [1] made an actuator/arm recently doing that technique. Does work but accuracy/flex can be a problem. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahSS5HUylT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahSS5HUylT8
- parsecs 5y agoCurious, could one apply fancy control theory and modern computing at the problem and fix most of the accuracy and flex problem? Position feedback with integrated sensors can be very compact and highly accurate, and human muscle seem to also use feedback control for holding position..
- tremon 5y agoThe human system doesn't use single-muscle feedback for holding position though; it requires flexing both the push and pull muscles and coordinating the strength between them; positional information is relayed not just from the muscles, but the surrounding skin as well.
- TheAdamAndChe 5y agoThe constant muscle tone is largely to help bones stay in ball-and-socket joints. Presumably, such tone wouldn't be necessary with other kinds of joints.
- aeneasmackenzie 5y agoRather than control theory you can use geometry to reduce the problems with cable driven robots. There are more but I like the Ambidex: https://youtu.be/aLaqMreVj9o https://youtu.be/aLaqMreVj9o
- nemo44x 5y agoIn today's culture wouldn't this be considered "ableist"? Aren't we internalizing the idea of being "disabled" to this kid and thus dehumanizing him by building a machine that "corrects" his inability to walk? I've seen similar arguments from the deaf community about hearing restoration as "correcting" something when nothing is "wrong". FWIW I think this invention is awesome.
- MitPitt 5y agoBy this logic, any medicine is ableist. Are we dehumanizing people with flesh wounds by sewing them up and stopping the bleeding?
- nemo44x 5y agoI don't think so, and I think that's sort of a different thing. I believe the original ideas around this go back to when a child is born with ambiguous sex organs. Parents and doctors would then choose to "correct" the issue to ensure the baby is either a boy or a girl, when in actuality it may have chromosome's that are not XX or XY. So then this (which is actually a really interesting debate) has cascaded into the greater world of disabilities. So there are currently critical theorists in the universities "theorizing" that looking at disabilities as something that needs to be corrected and not something that is normal puts people with them on the margins of society. So there is well regarded (by some) literature that fixing deafness is wrong and that society shouldn't see it as a disability - that society should adapt to be seamlessly inclusive for deaf people. And this goes on and on. In essence, science is racist and it has been white men who have classified what is normal and what is not and who is to say that everyone is normal and "correcting" these things is actually, well, "ableist". It can get pretty crazy (whoops, that's a naughty word) out there.
- MitPitt 5y agoIf by adapting (for example) blind people into society they mean writing in braille everywhere and so on, then it's the same as if correcting their disability. An exo-exo-skeleton, extended to the whole society. So it's just demagoguery.
- ryeguy_24 5y agoI have a 3.5 year-old and just had twins. A story like this makes me feel very warm inside. Being a relatively new father, I'm beginning to understand the unconditional love and sacrifice that grows when you have kids. I commend this father for doing this. He is a modern day hero.
- throwaway69123 5y agoIt got me good.
- zapdrive 5y agoStarting an exoskeleton company: 10 years + $$$ Smile on father's face watching his son stand upright: priceless!
- mrfusion 5y agoHow come they don’t open source this?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- skinkestek 5y agoAll I can see is another dark pattern in GDPR avoidance (note, doesn't help a bit, this is still illegal since it is opt out instead of opt in and doubly so since it is next to impossible to opt out).
- joshtam 5y agoIt is amazing how we can go about our life without any strong motivation, and when something tragic happens, people often comment "This was the best thing that's ever happened to me". As it turns out, lack of success is just a lack of genuine purpose.
- Gabriel_Martin 5y agoI know this is unrelated, but the closed caption's text accuracy is embarrassingly poor for an organization of Reuter's stature.
- mtwittman 5y agoThe research and engineering of new mobility aids is fine, but the inventor/CEO's quote, "Ten years from now, there will be no, or far fewer, wheelchairs" belies an attitude strongly criticized by many in the disability community. And in the video footage he says, "wheelchairs are an anomaly, men and women, human beings are meant to be upright". Imagine saying "Bicycles an anomaly—humans are meant to be upright, not in some aero-dynamic tucked position." Deriding one form mobility tech (an asset to more than 10,000,000 people) to promote another potential one is disappointing. The Exoskeleton's Hidden Burden [0] is a good article that includes the history of exoskeleton development (goes back to 19th c. Russia): [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/08/exoskeletons-disability-assistive-technology/400667/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/08/exosk...
- playpause 5y agoHe’s not deriding wheelchair tech. He’s saying wheelchair tech is not good enough, disabled people deserve better, and he’s doing something about it. I’m not convinced wheelchair users would be better off if he embraced the wheelchair-positive attitude that you are arguing for.
- nobody_nothing 5y agoJust want to flag that, in addition to all this fun and exciting new tech for disabilities, we really do just need better basics. As the partner of a wheelchair user, these exoskeletons are a great toy to have on the horizon – but the promise of this has been around for a long time, and while the hope of a better future is exciting, we need change on a much quicker time scale than this. (Not saying people shouldn't be working on this – it's rad that they are). On a day-to-day level, my partner would much more benefit from: - A better wheelchair (this will mean something different for every body – for them, someone who uses a wheelchair for chronic pain, an exoskeleton wouldn't even help – much more useful would be a wheelchair where every bump of pavement doesn't rattle your whole body). - More accessible shops and public spaces. We don't really get to go out much – most often blockades include cracked sidewalks, friend's houses that require a step (or stairs), and inaccessible shops. - Better safety nets for those with disabilities (it's VERY expensive to be disabled in America – consider how much more these exoskeletons will cost than already expensive wheelchairs). tl;dr These technologies are exciting and deserve attention and energy – just keep in mind that the notion that these emerging technologies will someday wipe out all of wheelchair users' problems in one fell swoop is both false and does nothing for the many millions prevented from participating in society right now. We need better access today.
- pomian 5y agoI agree. I think the problem is that most people don't see (why would they?) the problem areas. Wheelchairs! What a pain. Try find one that answers a different need? It's impossible or super expensive. I have been pushing and pulling family members for years, across gravel, snow, rocks, stairs. Idea! Mountain bike. I wanted to find one with mountain bike tires. Seems easy. Not at all. I finally bought a cheapo fat bike mountain bike, removed the wheels with the axles, and mounted them to a normal wheelchair. It's amazing. We go off road. Across rocks and gravel. Into creeks. But you can't buy one.
- Kye 5y agoThis is cool, but it's better to just build with accessibility-first thinking. We'll all be disabled some day. Better to self-advocate now rather than when we need it. How many buildings could you make wheelchair accessible for the cost of one robot suit?
- sonicggg 5y agoThat's a father threat really loves his son. 99% of other parents do nothing to get their handicapped child out of their chair.
- Iv 5y agoWhat I don't understand is why this is not more common. I plan to build one for when my parents are unable to walk around independently. Who wants to call a nurse everytime they need to go to the bathroom? An exoskeleton gives you some autonomy and dignity. The fact it is so uncommon despite a growing aging population with stash of money is a mystery to me
- pabs3 5y ago> has a genetic neurological condition that means his nerves do not send enough signals to his legs I wonder if anyone has tried amplifying those signals.
- sizzle 5y agoThe father in the picture at first glance gave me Tony Stark with an iron man suit prototype vibes. Anyone else?
- trailmonster 5y agoA few years ago when I lived in Seattle, this guy was working on something similar. I'm not sure how it turned out, but he had a stand at the Ballard farmer's market that caught my attention. Maybe 2015 or so. http://theyshallwalk.org/about/ http://theyshallwalk.org/about/
- m0rphy 5y agoBoston Dynamics should be making one of these. It fits really well with their expertise and is much better for them to be making these rather than robots that get sent to wars.
- throwaway-571 5y agoMore money in war than in peace application.
- arpafaucon 5y agoI'd love to see that! I tend to think that some of their technical choices on Atlas would have to revised, though. Having hydraulic actuators (very good power/weight ratio) makes the robot quite noisy, which is fine for a robot, but less cool if there is someone stuck inside it a whole day
- Kosirich 5y agoAre there any global crowdfunding projects that try to bring tech like this to more people?
- perilunar 5y agoJust by the way, the EduExo folks have a kickstarter that closes in 25 hours and is $1000 short of their funding goal: "EduExo Pro: A Robotic Exoskeleton Kit for STEM Education The EduExo Pro is an Arduino-powered educational robotics kit that enables you to build your own wearable robotic exoskeleton." https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/auxivo/eduexo-pro-a-robotic-exoskeleton-kit-for-stem-education https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/auxivo/eduexo-pro-a-rob... They had a previous kickstarter that did quite well: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1485976654/eduexo-the-first-robotic-exoskeleton-kit-for-stem?ref=discovery&term=eduexo https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1485976654/eduexo-the-f...
- Diannarose 5y agohave been a client of HARRY RAYMONDS CREDIT REPAIRS for about 2weeks now. I have 6 negatives items, some collections foreclosure on my report after I contacted them concerning my problem they gave me a couple of days to wait and after then when I checked my report I couldn’t believe my eyes all negatives entries collections including the foreclosure were completely cleared and I also got an amazing scoreof 810 excellent.They are very friendly and caring about helping me in fixing my bad credit and I got approved for the mortgage I applied and got my First Home. You can contact them on Email: hraay25@gmail.com +1 (213)295-1233 Call or (Whatsapp) to get your credit fixed. I HOPE THIS HELPS OUT.
- waybaily 5y agoWhat a commendable act made by the father. He didn't settle in making his son sit on a wheelchair throughout his own life. Instead, he built an exoskeleton to let his son experience how to walk.
- kaminar 5y agoTo be frank, you used the "deductible" as a lie, to make people believe it's for the wheelchair and insurance is evil. In fact, the annual deductible is part of every health insurance policy and has nothing to do with the wheelchair. Btw, you're pretty darn lucky to have such a low deductible, especially for a married couple (or family). P.s.: insurance companies are pretty evil, but that's another story