26 ms·
Empty storefronts are killing neighbourhoods
- chrisseaton 5y ago> mobilized a book-buying protest Consumerism as a form of protest!
- hahajk 5y ago“his new landlord told him that the store’s monthly costs—rent, taxes, insurance, and maintenance—would go up an impossible 150 percent, to $5,000 a month.” I’ve never owned or rented commercial real estate so I guess I never knew how much things cost. $2k seems cheap? I would have expected a storefront in a hip Montreal neighborhood to be much more.
- locopati 5y agoit won't be a hip neighborhood much longer if only global chain stores can afford the rent
- maxerickson 5y agoWhat do the global chain stores do differently that they can justify the rent against the store revenue?
- blevin 5y agoLarge co's play different games than mom & pop. They can afford some near-term losses if they can make the case it prevents competitors from gaining a foothold. Banks can justify rent on a seemingly empty branch in an expensive retail area if it supports catchment area of desirable clients that visit in person once every 18 months. Etc.
- seafoam 5y agoScale in distribution, especially marketing / brand / name recognition
- treis 5y agoI think people just like chain stores better. Plus they can take advantage of bulk buying for materials, services, advertising, etc.
- canadaduane 5y agoIt could simply be brand recognition. Visitors to a city will know which chain stores to visit to get what they need, glossing over (or avoiding) unfamiliar stores. So mom&pop stores get local customers, while chain stores get local PLUS just-visiting customers; multiply by months and years.
- acomms 5y agoRents in Montreal are historically cheaper than other major metros (in Canada). I am currently looking for commercial space in Toronto and despite lots of empty spaces, rates remain high.
- fencepost 5y agoLouis Rossmann's video series about his search for a new location in NYC may have a lot of relevant lessons even in a different city.
- aaaxyz 5y agoThat neighborhood is hip _because_ rent is cheap
- MichaelZuo 5y ago“ While vacancy rebates provided some businesses with a needed reprieve in fiscally difficult times, they were criticized for, in Bradford’s words, “incentivizing owners to keep stores empty while they waited for values to get high enough for redevelopment.” A review ordered by the Ministry of Finance showed that the policy had exacerbated the issue of “chronically vacant” street-level commercial real estate. A well-meaning initiative to help struggling property owners had been thoroughly negated through exploitation and speculation.” The deleterious second order effects would have been clear to anyone in the real estate industry, and I imagine the senior people in the Ontario Ministry of Finance, at the time. Catchy, feel good, measures almost always do. So the tone isn’t productive, since to expect commercial landlords from refraining from using a sizeable tax rebate specifically targeted to their needs is a bit absurd if it stays on the books. Same on the flipside with renters and rent control. Weakest link of the chain, etc. There is a good point buried in the article about the negative externality of empty storefronts collecting dust affecting nearby properties. A negative externality tax of some sort makes a lot of sense.
- newsclues 5y agoThis policy isn’t just foolish, it is horribly corrupt. “Help struggling property owners” Real estate prices in Ontario have gone up astronomically, if you are a property owner you aren’t struggling since you own an asset that’s price has gone up significantly recently.
- delfinom 5y agoPrivatize profits, socialize losses and free coke for the rich
- zihotki 5y agoThat's probably the case when local municipalities should take care of the situation by making it illegal to have empty storefronts and apartments for a long periods of time.
- another_story 5y agoNot illegal, but taxes should be higher for unoccupied buildings in commercial areas. That rate could be determined by any number of things, from the tax revenue of other nearby businesses, residential housing prices, etc...
- zihotki 5y agoWhy not? At the end, fines are another form of taxes. As I mentioned in another comment, in Netherlands there is such law in place. If the apartment is not occupied for a year then you have to report it to municipality and they will arrange something for you. Or you will be fined if you don't report. That law was made to fight with shortage of apartments as well as to prevent squatting. While it's not perfect, it seems to be working. But that is in regards with living apartments, I'm not sure how that applies for office and other business buildings.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> illegal to have empty storefronts and apartments How do you comply with such a law? If nobody wants to rent your space at any price, maybe because it's a terrible location or there isn't the demand to support any business at the moment, what are you supposed to do?
- dfadsadsf 5y agoTax foreclosure and town now owns the building? Happens all the time with abandoned buildings (both residential and commercial) all over the country. The thing though is that there are empty storefronts in very desirable locations including SOHO in NY. There is definitely lots of people who want to rent it - just may be not at 40k/month.
- 5y ago
- specialist 5y agoIIRC, North America has ~3x the amount of retail per capita compared to the EU. Prior to e-commerce, prior to the pandemic. This reckoning was a long time coming, accelerated by recent changes. The intent of mixed use was noble. But like all land use, left hand meet right hand. Today, we should be repurposing retail. Get creative. Every zip code needs more child care. Any city wanting to be more "family friendly" should do whatever it takes to seed day cares. I'm sure there's dozens of similar ideas. I know the prevailing context led to "efficiency" and big box retail. But ffs why do I have to drive to the pharmacy? To get some bananas? Etc.
- the-dude 5y ago> Every zip code needs more child care. Why is this? Are there many more children?
- bradleyjg 5y agoOn the contrary. But over the last several decades there have been two relevant culture shifts: - a strong move to professional child care over care by relatives - a dramatic increase in the age at which children are considered able to be unsupervised
- rdtwo 5y agoYeah also it’s very difficult to make a comfortable life on one income.
- bradleyjg 5y agoDuring the years when childcare is needed the numbers often work out better with one income than two. Market labor is taxed and then post tax dollars have to be used to pay for professional childcare (which is then taxed again). However, the issue comes after the need is over. The employment market heavily penalizes a decade plus gap in work history. On a lifetime basis it can make sense to work and pay for childcare even if it comes out net negative on a year by year basis. Even more important than these financial considerations are cultural and social expectations.
- Causality1 5y agoEmpty buildings should incur a tax that increases every month they remain unoccupied.
- chrisseaton 5y agoLol what would you do if just nobody happens to want to rent your unit? You have to pay an increasing tax for the rest of time? You couldn't sell it because who would want to buy it. Not a sensible idea.
- valine 5y agoIf no one wants to buy you drop the price until they do. Not saying it’s a good policy, but it would drive down real estate speculation and lower rent.
- chrisseaton 5y agoWhat if you drop the price to zero and still nobody has any use for it at the moment?
- valine 5y agoPresumably the vacancy tax would be tied to the value of the property. If the property really is worthless you won’t be paying taxes on it.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Presumably the vacancy tax would be tied to the value of the property. > increases every month It can't be both things at the same time. And who's setting this land value? If it's on the market and nobody's buying then we don't know the value.
- robinson7d 5y agoWhy can’t it be both? Could have a logarithmic scale, could have it increase by a fraction of a % of $(value - currentTax) so that it increases more slowly over time. Not saying I agree with the underlying idea, just confused about why “increases ever month” necessarily means it cannot be “tied to the value of the property” in a `calculateTax(propValue, timeEmpty)` sort of way.
- hnuser847 5y agoAnother article blaming speculators instead of central banking policy. The author never bothers to ask, why has every asset class, from residential real estate and RVs to penny stocks and junk bonds, dramatically increased in value since March of 2020?
- canadianfella 5y agoThat’s a great question. Do you know what the answer is?
- boondaburrah 5y agoThis has definitely been a problem long before last year. Heck, in 2018 Harvard Square lost a great cafe everyone liked that had been there for years because a landlord firm off in North Carolina figured they could charge triple the rent if they brought a VC-backed NYC chain restaurant in.
- freddie_mercury 5y agoIf a new tenant can afford triple the rent then they are (at least) 3x as productive. Why do you want to reward less productive businesses? Do you also enjoy working with coworkers who are have 1/3rd the productivity you?
- dan_mctree 5y agoMany of the common reasons that make companies able to pay more rent do not align well with preferences of locals. They could have higher prices, pay employees less, use lower quality ingredients, give less personal attention or externalize costs through say noise pollution. They also often have competitive advantages through brand recognition or company support, that don't actually increase quality
- jdavis703 5y agoBecause lots of less productive businesses still provide excellent products or services. I can think of lots of local restaurants, bookstores and cafes near me that are less productive than McDonalds, Barnes & Noble and Starbucks, but non the less have better food, curation or coffee than their competitors.
- fundamental 5y agoIn a similar vein Louis Rossmann has been walking through NYC showing current commercial storefront vacancies. While each video focuses on one street the rates of empty spaces seem to be higher than in the posted article. The rents do seem to be very steep as well, which you might expect out of NYC ($40,000/month is one price which stuck with me). One root cause cited in NYC, which isn't mentioned in the above article, is that commercial loans may prohibit leasing a space at a lower rate without lender approval (as it impacts the value of the building), though I do not know if the same issue applies in Canada. Most of the videos are long-form content which fits well into the background if anyone is interested: e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zjd1WNhGliY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zjd1WNhGliY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q53Wxx7aLrs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q53Wxx7aLrs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kuALRyGI3Ho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kuALRyGI3Ho
- busterarm 5y agoMy rent stabilized building in a desirable and convenient part of midtown manhattan is sitting at almost 30% vacant. This is completely unprecedented and wasn't even like this in the 80s. I'm leaving myself soon. New York is in serious trouble and everyone is acting like things are somehow normal again.
- tekstar 5y agoWhat happened? Mass exodus of people from NY due to covid / work from home? Serious question, I haven't seen any articles about this so just guessing
- g00gler 5y agoI'm from the NYC Metro. Insane pricing pushed us out initially. Philadelphia is such a horrible place, pre-covid I was longing to go back. COVID restrictions and now the fallout from that don't make it feel like a good idea. Really thinking about Florida now.
- 5y ago
- banada1 5y agoThe problem is real. Entire blocks of retail spaces in my Vancouver neighborhood stayed empty for 5 years. Now I'm leaving, it's sad to think about what could have been. Not a single mention of zoning or construction in this article.
- TazeTSchnitzel 5y agoZoning can be a problem but it's not the be-all-and-end-all of property market problems. Maybe existing landlords need to be less greedy rather than sitting on empty properties.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI am not even sure what sense does it make to sit on an empty property for five years. Lower rent income is still better than constant 0. At least it covers necessary repairs. One would expect that after some months of making nothing, the landlord would start to have second thoughts.
- MereInterest 5y ago> Lower rent income is still better than constant 0. Depends on the terms of the lease and the expected changes in the future. Suppose you're negotiating a 5-year lease. There aren't too many new businesses at the moment, and so the market price is 25% below typical rates. If you take it and rent right away, then you get 3.75 normal years worth of rent over the next 5 years. On the other hand, if you expect that things will get back to normal in 6 months, then you might want to wait and rent in 6 months instead. Over the next 5 years, you then get 4.5 normal years worth of rent. The numbers vary based on location, and what the crystal ball tells you about if/when the prices will change, but there can be a financial incentive to keep things empty until to avoid locking yourself into a low rate. I'd agree with other posters that there should be a tax on vacant commercial properties, so that it tips the equations in favor of renting now vs waiting indefinitely.
- inglor_cz 5y ago
- cascom 5y agoWhile I whole heartedly sympathize with the sentiment of the article (no one wants to see local institutions forced out, chain stores move in, or storefronts sit empty), and real estate developers and “speculators” no doubt make an easy target, it would seem that the author thinks that neighborhoods can and should keep their current character and not evolve (for the good and the bad). It somehow always strikes me as odd how some tenants think that they should not be subject to market forces, if you want to lock-in prices for more than 1-10 years, buy.
- rdtwo 5y agoThese aren’t real market forces if the properties are staying vacant. It’s likely that the tenants are getting hit by 2nd order effects of bad regulation like the tax thing or financing requirements that incentivize leaving properties empty
- xerox13ster 5y ago> if you want to lock-in prices for more than 1-10 years, buy. Many people who are tenants are tenants precisely because they can't afford to do that when speculators have manipulated market forces to artificially drive up the prices.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAmazon won economies of scale. The only thing worth selling in storefronts is services. If cities want stores that sell things, they will have to subsidize them.
- lazyjones 5y ago> The only thing worth selling in storefronts is services. The downside of Amazon is lack of selection for quality. I prefer to go to brick-and-mortar stores if I need a minimum acceptable quality of e.g. bedclothes. On Amazon you get 1000s of low quality products from China and no real help discerning better choices (reviews are fake, price is no indicator, specs/info by the seller is not reliable).
- delfinom 5y agoThis, either as I get older my demands for quality is increasing or Amazon is getting increasingly garbage, beyond Walmart standards.
- pessimizer 5y agoWalmart quality is miles beyond mean amazon quality. Walmart got where they are from brutalizing their vendors, not their customers. Their vendors are punished for excessive returns.
- cascom 5y agoSeems that from an economic perspective the “solution” might be to shorten the length of time that a storefront could be leased by statute - thereby reducing the incentive of landlords to hold out for higher rents if there is more frequent repricing.
- rdtwo 5y agoWhy not just tax empty stores at a ever increasing tax rate. If you can’t fill a property in a year taxes double till you do. They keep doubling till they hit 20% property value or till rented out. Empty stores are a Bligh and should be charged accordingly
- reidjs 5y agoI’m lucky enough to live in a neighborhood that has the following within 3 short blocks of me: Organic grocery store, park, church, dentist, urgent care, bars, restaurants, hardware store, barber, liquor store, outdoor gym, and others. The only problem? No parking. So I sold my car. I have never lived in such an amazing neighborhood and I think most people never will because they feel compelled to live miles away from cities. I think it’s because most city neighborhoods aren’t like my neighborhood where everything is so accessible.
- notsureaboutpg 5y agoPeople feel compelled to live away from cities because they don't want to pay $1 million to live in a 2 bedroom apartment with kids and rely on public transit that cuts lines because of pandemic related financial stress and have to dodge drug usage, feces, and mentally disturbed individuals on the streets (thinking about SF here). In cities that are not NYC and SF lots of families live in the city centers and love it because it's somewhat affordable and not ludicrously dangerous for children.
- opportune 5y agoExactly the same with me. I have everything I need in walking distance, the car is not necessary. I guess the problem is how do we get neighborhoods to “evolve” in this direction naturally? My neighborhood I think was essentially built in the 20s before cars were common household items. The lot sizes are small, there are no setbacks or tree mandates. It seems hard to get a suburban area to morph into a walkable neighborhood like that unless the location is highly desirable (which, to be fair, applies to huge parts of the SF Bay Area from the Peninsula to South Bay, but not the whole country), which would incentivize wide-scale new construction enough for people to put up with the short term pains of living in something built for walkability in a larger community that is still car-based.
- zwkrt 5y ago> how do we get neighborhoods to “evolve” in this direction naturally? Get rid of cars and people will quickly find they like walkable neighborhoods.
- lordnacho 5y agoWhy not just make a law that says the old tenant can keep paying until the new tenant who is gonna pay 10x arrives? Seems like there must be some other explanation as to why the landlord doesn't just keep the little guy until he finds someone who will pay more.
- juanani 5y agoGreed(capitalism) is killing neighborhoods. FTFY. Not just neighborhoods either. ThE GrEaTeSt SyStEm EvEr
- jmclnx 5y agoAs I said in the past, when a rental property goes vacant and stays vacant for more than 1 year, the property tax goes up for 5 years minimum equal to the amount of the rent that was previously paid. Increasing 15% every year until rented. This is for every unit that is vacant.
- xrd 5y agoI came here to read the inevitable second-order effects discussion, that is to say, if cities enact things like vacancy rate they will cause extra unforeseen problems. But, I've never seen anyone discuss second order effects from hedge funds, or rich developers. Can someone explain why second order effects are only relevant and as powerful when it is a government entity. Hedge funds and large corporations often seem like they have more power and often much more agility than governments. And, they have impacts far greater as well at times. Is this a relevant question? What am I missing?
- User23 5y ago> Hedge funds and large corporations often seem like they have more power and often much more agility than governments. They don’t. Hedge funds and corporations don’t have powers like eminent domain and men with guns authorized to use violence to enforce them. The vacancy rates actually are a second order effect of the banking industry. You’d think landlords would reduce rents because some income is better than none. However commercial property is valued as a function of the rent, so reducing rents 20% could reduce the value of the property 20% too, potentially leaving the commercial mortgage underwater. But leaving it empty with a rent the market can’t bear keeps that from happening. Therefore the correct solution is changing banking regulations to eliminate that perverse incentive, not to try an ad hoc fix at the city level which probably won’t work as intended.
- sokoloff 5y agoThat provision is because commercial property is often valued by reference to a cap rate (essentially a net-operating-income multiplier to get to the property value). This is not a property of the banking system but of the market for commercial property. The banking angle is to ensure that loans on property aren't durably underwater, such that the bank has a high likelihood of ending up owning underwater property. (The bank is in the money business; anytime they get into the real estate business with a REO, someone screwed up.) Preventing banks from doing this is likely to lead to a lot more bank-owned properties (REOs), which is generally a bad sign for a real estate market.
- acd 5y agoI think this is an effect of near zero interest rates from central banks. With near zero interest rate loans will rice real estate price go higher and thus rent increase
- jdavis703 5y agoThere’s also the fact that we had a pandemic. Some cities had an empty storefront problem before the pandemic, sure. But a lot of places just gave up.
- rcpt 5y agoPrices can go up but rent doesn't have to. Price to rent ratios are huge in California because speculative demand far outstrips actual demand. Most landlords are cash flow negative and own only so they can bet on equity wins.
- rufus_foreman 5y ago>> Most landlords are cash flow negative and own only so they can bet on equity wins That's the "Ponzi financing" phase of Minsky's financial instability cycle. It typically does not end well.
- rcpt 5y agoInteresting. What's a good source on this? California really does feel like 80s Japan sometimes but I can't say exactly why
- rufus_foreman 5y agoThere's an Economist summary from 2016 at https://www.economist.com/schools-brief/2016/07/30/minskys-moment https://www.economist.com/schools-brief/2016/07/30/minskys-m.... The depressing part of his theory is that in his view, stability causes instability. If something is growing predictably, people start increasing their use of leverage until even a decline in the rate of growth will cause a crash.
- Gimpei 5y agoI definitely see this in San Francisco. 24th street in Noe Valley is an odd combination of empty store fronts and shops selling hippy tchotchkies. There was a huge supermarket size space that was empty for fifteen years. They tried to make it into condos early on but the neighbors complained about "gentrification". Now it's a high end spa. Another win for Noe Valley.
- swayvil 5y agoThe recent "covid crisis" crushed several nice businesses in my town. All small businesses, locally owned. Walmart didn't even blink. The big chains are just fine. In fact, the failure of small business has provided big business with opportunities to scoop up cheap properties. Not to mention the removal of competition. And by "covid crisis" I actually mean the policy and propaganda ostensibly generated in response to the "covid crisis". Because compared to the damage done by our politicians and media, the damage done by covid was actually quite small. Put that in your pipe and smoke it.
- tacocataco 5y agoPerhaps the damage of covid was small because of the international effort to respond to it?
- georgeburdell 5y agoAre empty storefronts worse than no storefronts? My city seems to think so, and mandates all buildings in a particular area be mixed use. The developers view it as a tax to get housing units built
- Dumblydorr 5y agoNeighborhoods are communities, empty storefronts are just one symptom of community-waning overall. A lot of things are declining during covid, like social club membership, in person gaming, in person sports playing, places of worship, dance clubs, bars, restaurants, etc. Just so many institutions were battered into an earlier decline due to Covid.
- cowmoo728 5y agoEmpty storefronts were a huge issue in prime manhattan shopping areas since I moved there in 2015. At least in Manhattan it's not due to covid. There may have been a brief spike in vacancies in mid 2020 but the vacancy rate in 2019 was already extremely high. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-08-12/vacant-nyc-storefronts-prompt-council-push-to-aid-small-business https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-08-12/vacant-ny...
- m0llusk 5y agoAmazing that Henry George's proposed Land Value Tax is still the right answer to so many pressing problems.
- nostromo 5y agoOverly restrictive zoning is killing neighborhoods. North America needs more housing and less retail. But the market can’t respond because zones are too restrictive.
- herf 5y agoWe should remember that one of the problems with retail right now is wages that are too low, so low that many restaurants can't hire enough workers. These businesses are often paying for prime retail and then paying again for customer acquisition from food delivery or other online services. If property owners manage to capture such a large portion of revenue increases (or even to increase prices in a declining retail market), it is a zero-sum game with many other important parts. Apart from cute mom and pop stores being replaced by national chains, the other costs are the lack of capital for investment in new concepts, lack of funds to pay employees through fair wages, and also lack of resilience in a downturn.
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoI've thought about this for a long time. I grew up in a town that had a booming downtown strip for as long as I can remember growing up. Then around 2008 you started noticing stores closing up. Word on the street was that rent was just too high to make a profit, and a lot of the retailers who had been in the same store downtown for decades closed up shop forever. Fast forward to today, all of those stores and more are shuttered... the rent is still too damn high... and the absentee landlords that own these buildings are actually rewarded with property tax benefits for keeping them EMPTY! How crazy is that? Some rich guy owns almost every single building downtown, is asking $75/foot, and gets property tax breaks when his buildings sit vacant... slowly smothering the downtown vibe with an air of death. The value of his building's keep increasing so he doesn't care. He doesn't live here. IMHO retail properties should be taxed MORE if they sit vacant for too long, and that increased tax burden should go up exponentially every year that the building sits vacant. A vacant retail building should be the landlord's problem, not the town's.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoLand value taxes are effectively one implementation. Land value taxes necessitate that high-value land be put to productive economic use. I think this is a nice taxation strategy given that land can be considered a common good (and it's finite, and you didn't make it).
- 3pt14159 5y agoI agree, but not just on land value. If you adjust the base rate for the land by how wide the plot is on the street you end up with a MUCH more walkable city. It's like a more efficient sorting algorithm, because once you get to the store you need you can just walk right in and find everything you need. Right, like imagine how stupid it is for us to be walking by squares. We have to walk across 25% of the perimeter of every building we go by. If they're thin rectangles then you only walk by, say 5% until you get to the store you need.
- jaredklewis 5y ago
- underseacables 5y agoThis article is more about Canada, but it does have some applicability to America. The rising cost of rent, coupled with the desire for greater returns over stability, I just pushed a lot of small retailers out. I think this is also a problem of the walk-ability issue in America: it’s very hard to walk to anything. European cities Are easier to walk to the corner shop. Not so in America. If you are able to live in one of these walkable communities, it’s often too expensive to have something like a bookstore.
- epicureanideal 5y agoMake it easier to build new things, and people speculating on a nearly fixed supply of existing structures won't be able to gouge their tenants as much. As usual, the solution is the same. Let people build more.
- kgin 5y agoI’m curious how much retail space is integrated into neighborhoods in the United States at all as opposed to strip malls down a 6 lane highway set back in a sea of parking. Most of the country doesn’t even have the ability to even have this problem.
- legerdemain 5y agoThis is what laws favoring tenants do to local commercial real estate. It is more risky for a landlord to allow one bad tenant than to miss the opportunity to rent to five good ones. It's the same reality in tech hiring.
- hourislate 5y agoThere are a few incredibly wealthy family offices buying up most of the apartment building and commercial space in Toronto and across Canada. I'm not sure but the two guys mentioned (Stephen Shiller and Danny Lavy) could be the group I was told are funded by very wealthy Israelis. There is also a German family office that owns about 5 billion (in 2010 money) in commercial space in Vancouver, Toronto and Montreal. These are just two that I know of for sure through people who own large amounts of commercial real estate in Toronto. In Toronto the goal is to accumulate enough of these store fronts that you can basically demolish a good part of the street block and build a Condo. Politicians are only concerned about tax revenue and not the character of a neighborhood, a Condo brings in far more property tax $$$ than a storefront. People don't understand how a Landlord would rather leave a space empty than keep it full because 5-50k a month lease (in Toronto) or whatever they are paying seems like a lot but the reality is you're talking about billionaires who are playing a long game and are acquiring land for development and not rental money which indecently is a pittance for them and not worth the effort.
- orcasushi 5y agoThe problem is that these neighborhoods were build when the global population was half the size it is now and spending behavior was way different then it is now. It is no longer profitable to have a shoe repair shop in the neighborhood. Nobody repairs shoes, everyone buys new online. You cannot get these old times back. The solution? Look at the Asian urbs. High rise apartment buildings with the first 1 or 2 floors shops. The dense population will make these shops attractive again because dense population causes high demand for convenience-shops. The shops in turn will make the neighborhood attractive for city dwellers. The shops also cause the streets never be empty so crime / vandalism drops. Then it attracts tourists and creates jobs. Now move all the parking and roads underground and make all the roof tops green public parks and voila! But, what do we do instead? We yank car-oriented flat suburbs and shopping malls all over the place. Those will be the trash-towns of tomorrow.
- anigbrowl 5y agoCapitalists love quoting Adam Smith until they encounter someone familiar with his views on usury and landlords, at which point they want to drop him like a hot potato. https://www.barrons.com/articles/the-trouble-with-adam-smith-1471670360 https://www.barrons.com/articles/the-trouble-with-adam-smith... I'm broadly in favor of a land value tax, think landlords deserve no special protections, and generally have a 'use it or lose it' attitude. I strongly support the idea that squatters can gain tenancy and even property rights through mere occupation, and reject the notion that landlords should be able to have court decisions enforced by police. Though no doubt a small number of decent and kind small landlords exist, they are outnumbered by the much larger number of rent seekers.
- barnesto 5y agoguess we're not going to talk about the effect of e-commerce? it's nothing but hot takes about property owners around here. it costs less money to have an online store than a brick and mortar. the pandemic has brought about a permanent work from home mentality, leaving office space vacant. people make more from the gov't than working in retail or hospitality - businesses are going out of business at the highest rates we've ever seen as a country. but it's the landlords.
- yeuxardents 5y agoIts anecdotal of course, but many people in my age bracket 20-40 would much prefer to be able to say FU to amazon and walk to the local downtown and be able to peruse physical shops. They understand the socialization and 'home town support' that the loss of these shops and the rise of ecommerce begets. eg. I know many people in this age bracket who would love to take a chance on one of these empty shops and create their own inspired shop of some kind, but the costs are absurdly prohibitive, namely rent and taxes, so instead, the downtown area of so many towns remain empty and desolate. startup capital costs even in semi middle of nowhere are too high to even create a 10 seat specialty cafe or anything like that
- longtimegoogler 5y agoAmazon...
- bluedino 5y agoPicture your main drag coming out of town. It has the big stores, chain restaurants, etc. the older stores, closer to town, have been closing for the last twenty years. Kmart, Family Video, Value City, Circuit City… The buildings sit empty. Forever. One might briefly become a Halloween store, or a cube storage place. Instead, new stores are added to the end of the road. Causing the end near town to become abandoned.
- hakfoo 5y agoIf there's a fear that lowering rent would cause a problem (by letting others demand the same, or by lowering the assessed value of the property), what we need is model "turn-key" regulations to let them put the land to use without touching the shared lies. "Yeah, this normally vacant 400-square-foot unit in the Junkie District is worth $8250 per month, but we're donating use to a local non-profit, and when someone is ready to spend $8250 per month, we can boot them with X days notice." Plenty of groups (budget-constrained charities, maker spaces, educational programs, hobby organizations, political groups) could make use of idle retail spaces, even with the weight of a "we can drop a 30-day eviction notice on you at any time." And then when people walk down the street, they see "Oh, it's the Libertarian Party HQ and the local woodworking club's workshop, what a vibrant neigbourhood!" rather than "Here's a vacant store and you can still see the outline from the sign when this was a Fazoli's!"
- chrismaeda 5y agoProperty tax laws cause the empty store fronts. In Ontario (as with most places in North America), commercial property is assessed on its highest and best use (ie potential use), not its current use. So if a parcel has a low-rise building with some bookstores and cafes, it will be assessed at the same value as the high-rise condo tower next door. This "highest and best" assessment rule means that in a rising market, the landlord must raise rents to cover rising property taxes. In addition, a landlord may apply for a property tax rebate if a commercial or industrial property is vacant. So there is zero incentive for landlords to accept below-market rents for small businesses: if the property is vacant, they don't pay property taxes. If the property is rented at below-market rates, they lose money because they still have to pay property taxes at full-market rates. Even if the small business owner also owns the building, the rising property taxes may make the small business uneconomic and force them to move.
- Merrill 5y agoMaybe the US and Canada have too much retail space per person. The US has 23.5 square feet per person, Canada had 16.8, Australia has 11.2 and the rest of the world has less than 5 square feet per person. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1058852/retail-space-per-capita-selected-countries-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1058852/retail-space-per...