18 ms·
The Perils of M1 Ownership
- smoldesu 5y agoWell, this just about confirms the worst nightmares I've had about hardware-based TPM. This "Owner" concept in particular rubs me the wrong way, it just seems antithetical to the idea of general computing.
- mikl 5y agoWhile there are perils, there are also benefits. Organised theft of iPhones basically stopped being a problem because features like these makes the device a mostly useless brick once it’s marked in Apple’s systems as stolen. I like the idea that should anyone be foolish enough to steal my MacBook, not only will they not be able to get my data, they won’t even be able to get much useful value out of the purloined goods.
- ccmcarey 5y ago> Theft of iPhones basically stopped being a problem because features like these makes the device a mostly useless brick once it’s marked in Apple’s systems as stolen. Uhh, got a citation on that?
- foldr 5y agohttps://9to5mac.com/2015/02/11/iphone-thefts/ https://9to5mac.com/2015/02/11/iphone-thefts/
- mikl 5y agoSure, how about https://www.lifewire.com/security-settings-iphone-thieves-hate-2487730 https://www.lifewire.com/security-settings-iphone-thieves-ha... There’s more to be found on this new-fangled internet search engine called Google. You should try it: https://www.google.com/ https://www.google.com/
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoPeople are still routinely tricked to enter their iCloud credentials into fraudlent websites designed to look just like iCloud, allowing thieves to wipe the device. I've had this happen to three people I know. Works like this: they contact you via your contacts, pretending to be apple care specialists, ship a link, then social engineer you into entering credentials, then they disappear. (I don't really know how they get to contacts, but this was the case in all three instances)
- aunty_helen 5y agoCan confirm, had my XR stolen. Contacted on whatsapp via a number that I put as the lost message (displays when you turn the phone on). Story was, this girl from Italy bought my phone on ebay but then saw my message and then took it to the Apple store. Someone from the apple store would contact me to arrange recovery of my stolen phone. Couple hours later I got a message from another number asking for me to log in to my iCloud account and arrange an appointment using this link. Opened the link and about to type my details in then I saw the domain wasn't quite right. Looked into it, realised it was a phishing attempted and bailed on that. I know they can't access the phone whilst it's still on my iCloud account so it will remain there, in lost mode, until the heat death of the universe.
- mikl 5y agoIt’s not really surprising that organised criminals are trying to get around the anti-theft measures (although crazy to hear that you know that many who’ve had their phones stolen). But as you can imagine, running such social engineering schemes takes time, and success is not guaranteed, so even in this case, the anti-theft measures are making it less attractive to steal iPhones.
- badsectoracula 5y ago> While there are perils, there are also benefits Rarely are anti-features sold to unsuspecting users without having some positives to explain their existence.
- unstatusthequo 5y agoFringe use case of using multiple operating systems != peril.
- smoldesu 5y ago> These may seem elaborate and esoteric, but in the next few months we’re all expecting Apple to release more Apple Silicon Macs aimed well above the lower end of the market, where users often live more adventurous lives and have Macs which are far from vanilla. Yet as far as I can see, none of these subtleties are documented for those more advanced users. At the bottom of the article he seems to address this sentiment.
- FireBeyond 5y agoI don't think it's entirely odd. I'm still using Catalina, because Big Sur broke Display Stream Compression completely, and it's still not fixed in any of those releases, let alone Monterey. So until Apple pays attention to the hundreds or thousands of bug reports on a completely working piece of functionality they broke (although I'm sure they'd rather we all just bought Pro Display XDR monitors), I'll dutifully stick with Catalina and cross my fingers and test each new release from an SSD, so my 27" 4K HDR 144 Hz monitors aren't completely crippled.
- laurent92 5y agoThe other peril is not being able to run a docker machine because it’s not available for M1. Which is disappointing because, you know, because you can’t tell customers that your software wasn’t tested in Oracle, and we invented VMs to be able to run any VM on any other machine…
- zepto 5y agoThis is totally false. https://docs.docker.com/docker-for-mac/apple-silicon/ https://docs.docker.com/docker-for-mac/apple-silicon/
- rvz 5y agoHad to wait 6 months since launch for it to be stable. That there tells me it was not production ready for M1 Macs at the time, which isn't good.
- zepto 5y ago> at the time, which isn't good. At what time?
- rvz 5y agoSince the month the M1 Macs first launched; November 2020.
- zepto 5y agoI see you’ve edited your earlier comment so it is clearer. So your point was to complain about how Docker took a long time to update their code. I guess that’s not good.
- rvz 5y ago> So your point was to complain about how Docker took a long time to update their code. I guess that’s not good. Not exactly. The software was not stable for general use for M1 users at the time of its launch in November 2020. That is the point. I don't know anyone who thinks or recommends using unstable preview tools for production use is a good idea or even waiting for the software to stabilise for months on a newly unsupported machine. Means you can't use it properly for months. Might as well use an already existing computer that works well.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoThis isn’t the right solution, but I’d be curious to know if these problems disappear in Permissive Security mode (aka Secure Boot off).
- ravenstine 5y agoRight. I'm not sure we know whether the author is describing a bug or a feature.
- millzlane 5y agoMost likely a bug. If the instructions start with "Install Beta anything", with apple, this wouldn't garner support from them. Report the problem to apple on the beta channel. https://beta.apple.com/sp/betaprogram/ https://beta.apple.com/sp/betaprogram/ if you're a developer having an issue they have a support channel for that too
- Amin699 5y agoGood job
- JoshTko 5y agoIn other news, edge case use encounters edge case issues.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoIt’s almost as if Apple is building their Macs to be rogue nation-state resistant or something. Because otherwise is this almost actually security overkill? (Which does exist, we don’t want TSA Security to enter a grocery store, for example.)
- InTheArena 5y agoSee the trending top story right now as to why they are doing so.
- tomjen3 5y agoTSA is theater, the hijackers that were stopped where stopped in the air. But aside from that, looking at the threats of ransomware attacks, they probably do need to harden them that much.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWhat about device Ownership prevents an app with Full Disk Access from encrypting files as it pleases? Ruining the OS install is not the objective of most ransomware because that makes it harder to show your demands and accept payment.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI assume the idea is to prevent rootkits.
- halotrope 5y agoConsidering the recent ransomware epidemic I would not agree for this to be security overkill. Maybe this level of paranoia is the minimum required baseline in 5 years. It looks like after a decade of relatively few big and public security incidents we are starting to go downhill again.
- mikl 5y agoI think rendering stolen devices useless is also on the feature list. iPhone theft has become super rare, because a stolen device is neigh-impossible to activate and thus has little to no resale value.
- grishka 5y agoOne question: can I finish the setup of an M1 Mac without giving it an internet connection? As in, could I get it from unboxing to desktop without it sending a single network packet to Apple?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoYes, right now you can on M1. Windows 11 Home will not support that in the final release, but there are workarounds in the beta period.
- spideymans 5y agoFrom the article: >According to the small print in Apple’s Platform Security Guide, when you set up a new M1 Mac, or set one up after restoring it in DFU mode, the primary admin account created is special: it’s the Owner account of that Mac. During that inital setup, the Mac sends a request to Apple for that Mac’s signed Owner Identity Certificate (OIC). This is based on a private key generated in the Secure Enclave known as the Owner Identity Key (OIK). I'm not trying to imply that you're wrong at all, but I'm curious how the Mac goes about obtaining the OIC without a network connection.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThe OIC, if I understand correctly, is an Apple vetted OIK which is created on-device. This mainly would come into play, as the article says, if you install another operating system. By default, the OS is in Full Security mode, so it would contact Apple when installing the other OS and the OIC may come into play. But if you aren’t installing another OS, or you set your Mac to permissive security which needs no internet, perhaps the OIC is not required because you’ve downgraded the security? Im just speculating. Still, somehow, the fact remains you can fully set up an M1 Mac without internet. The technicals of how it does this while reconciling that with the security guide is unknown.
- grishka 5y agoCan you disable secure boot without Apple having a say in the process? I trust myself much more than I trust Apple.
- xrd 5y agoTrying to ship software for OSX *in general* drives me crazy, and this seems like more. This quote: "I’ve been unable to find any information provided by Apple (or anyone else) which explains what’s going on, what the errors mean, or how to address them." That's my experience constantly. My development build had weird behavior when I explicitly launch it? Oops, Apple launched a cached version of the app inside a private temp directory (thanks Gatekeeper!) associated with the protocol handler. But no way to tell until I casually check the process working directory. No documentation indicating how to troubleshoot this. Countless issues like this. Whenever I develop for JavaScript, if I find a module that just has weird undefined and undocumented behavior, I get rid of it no matter how powerful. I wish I could do that with the Mac developer ecosystem. It's closed and Apple will say that gives them a premier experience but it's the little snags that cost me 90% of my time and are impossible to troubleshoot other than grunting through it.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoCould the same not be said for Windows developers, or Linux developers? Or, heck, almost any developer?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wila 5y agoNope. Have been a developer for windows applications for 20 and some years. Software I build back then still runs fine. Have been a developer for macOS since 2013, since around 2019 I need to bring out patches for changes in the core OS multiple times per year. macOS is not a pleasant OS for a developer. Documentation is pretty shitty and the rugs that get pulled from under you all the time are frustrating.
- xrd 5y agoGlad to know it isn't just me. Same general developer history, same experience. Windows has its quirks and bad decisions they made over the years but the developer experience is consistent, even when bad. Apple's experience is like being in an Arabian desert: sometimes you see a mysterious oasis that wasn't there before, but mostly it is shifting dunes that cost days or months.
- dlevine 5y agoIt seems like these changes have good intentions (i.e. improved security), but introduce a lot of complexity that can have unintended consequences for end-users. This reminds me somewhat of my process setting up UEFI Secure Boot on my Windows PC that wasn't originally configured for it. Not in the exact steps, but in that there is a ton going on behind the scenes and the UX is horrendously bad. Unfortunately, vendors haven't really thought about how to explain these changes to end-users. They are trying to make them fairly transparent, which probably works at least 95% of the time, but for a small percentage of people, becomes a big PITA.
- TranquilMarmot 5y agoI wanted to try out Windows 11 on my desktop, and one of the requirements was that UEFI secure boot is turned on. Took me the better part of a day to figure out how to turn it on, which required deleting some random partitions that had been created on my drive when I had upgraded from Windows 8 to Windows 10 because the tool to enable UEFI requires a _very specific_ number of partitions in the drive that it's being set up on. The error messages to figure out that was the problem were incredibly frustrating. The BIOS UI to turn it on was also so confusing; everything seems to be named differently in different places. The kicker was that the Windows 11 install was borked and I had to wipe everything and reinstall. Ha.
- blibble 5y agosomething I found really handy for testing/retaining windows installs was a $30 external USB SSD (not a flash drive, a "external drive" that is flagged as "non-removable") you can install windows directly on it and tell the UEFI to boot off of it with absolutely no fuss
- depressedpanda 5y agoHow do I flag a drive as non removable? This is from years back, but my experience is that running Windows from an external drive isn't really easy. I hardly use the OS any longer, but I'd like to keep it around on an external drive if possible.
- kartayyar 5y agoYou don't buy a Mac (M1 or otherwise) to live an adventurous life. You get it because it has really well executed take on an opinionated computing platform that just works for normal people.
- FireBeyond 5y agoThat's completely orthogonal to Apple's take. They talk about how much your development efforts will speed up, your creative production. So on, so forth. Not "it's to be an unadventurous consumer of product".
- GayforMoleman 5y agoWho they market their users are != who their users actually are. Obviously all the marketing will focus on creative uses because it makes it a lot easier to sell to people on a 1500$ machine. The truth is 95% percent of people are using their computers as glorified web browsers and the computers are built to do that extremely well.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoFor a lot of normal people, Mac is what you buy if you want to work with your computer, but it is not what you buy if you want to work on your computer.
- robertoandred 5y agoDo you work with your screwdriver or on your screwdriver?
- samatman 5y agoWith my screwdriver. Unless you're a blacksmith who makes his own drivers or a wordworker who makes her own handles, the same is true for you.
- 5y ago
- rStar 5y agoapple doesn’t care about technical users, they sell a product designed to be of use to the most people who can pay. They are trying to move towards an IOS security model while preserving most of the features of a general purpose computer. we’ll see where it’s headed. in my use case, I dual boot and am the only user of my machine. If this ever becomes untenable I’ll switch mainly linux and dual boot windows, until and unless windows stops letting me dual boot, at which point I’ll have to reevaluate.
- foft 5y agoInteresting. I just bought an M1 Mac mini. I added a nvme m.2 ssd (Samsung PM9A1 + Orico SCM2T3-G40) over thunderbolt 3 and moved the admin user over. Unfortunately I had to send back the ssd and adaptor since it was reading at only 75MB/s for some reason. Anyway I created a new admin on the internal ssd before deleting the external ssd. If I understand this article correctly it’s saying that I will no longer be able to update since I now only have a secondary admin user. Is that correct?
- 70rd 5y agoWere you getting those speeds with random reads or sequential? I have one of the Orico enclosures and it works great.
- foft 5y agoI used initially 'Blackmagic disk speed test'. This tool seems to only have an option for 1-5GB. I did not find a random or sequential option. I've definitely seen screenshots of this tool giving high read speeds using the Orico. Then I tried 'ATTO disk benchmark'. This tool tries a variety of read and write I/O size ranges. The results I got here were strange. As expected as the I/O size range grows, the read bytes/s increase. Then it hits 1MB I/O size and the throughput drops to almost 0. Write was consistent across the range, perhaps since it simply hits a buffer on the SSD to be processed later. With dd I achieved good performance transferring a 5GB file, after a reboot to ensure the file cache was definitely flushed. Perhaps it was an issue with the firmware version for the Orico or the SSD itself. Unfortunately I was unable to update the latter since the 'Samsung Magician' software is windows only. On my windows devices I have no thunderbolt ports.
- 70rd 5y agoBizarre. I'm on Linux and only really ever tested it with dd (use it for backups/installing Windows on metal so I don't have to deal with PCIe pass-throughs with a VM), but the results have been great for me.
- foft 5y ago
- GekkePrutser 5y agoWow I'm so happy I'm moving away from Mac administration. I currently manage a big userbase but we still don't have M1s in our environment as our antivirus solution (Cylance) is really slow in supporting it. Apple is introducing more and more mechanisms in the name of security but they keep access and information very close to their heart. All us Mac admins have struggled with SecureToken in combination with AD accounts and it took two major releases for Apple to actually introduce a way for us to manage these properly through MDM. In the mean time most information had to be gathered through blogs such as this one. Another issue is that more and more enterprise management features are becoming dependent on managed (federated) Apple IDs. But Apple requires that the email and identifying account address (UPN) are the same which will never happen in our 200k user environment. So we're stuck with more and more things to work around. This is really something that should have been considered from the start. And this owner key thing sounds worse. Security is good but the end user or corporate admin should have the keys to every lock. Not just the vendor. Now my successor can deal with this stuff. I used to be a big fan of macOS personally too but I moved over to FreeBSD 2 years ago and I'm glad I did. I really want an OS that answers to me.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoYou could just set security to Permissive. It’s as secure as any Windows machine and disables this, even though the only time you’d ever run into this would be if you ran 2 Mac installs on the same machine, which surely a corporate deployment isn’t doing.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoYou'd be surprised. Macs for us are only half a percent of our userbase (yet still many hundreds), and are mainly used by app developers and graphical design roles. Especially the app dev guys tend to have fairly nonstandard usecases. However most of it happens in labs firewalled off the company network. Anyway, I'm glad I'm not the one having to figure out how to work around these things with very limited documentation from Apple, like I have before ;)
- 5y ago
- blunte 5y agoThis is worth knowing about, but it is really a distant edge case. Calling it a peril of M1 ownership is a bit dramatic when you consider how few people it will affect.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThis blog is well known for both deep original knowledge, and extreme hyperbole. There was a post about MacOS update size that compared the size of the updates to beating the backs of Mac users raw and ignoring their pleas.
- blunte 5y agoOk then. Literary license :)
- addicted 5y agoI am not sure which specific article you’re talking about, but MacOS update sizes were a massive issue. The real problem wasn’t the update size itself. The real problem was the updating through the Mac store, which would invariably fail to properly download the update if you were on anything outside a several hundred mbps connection, and even if you did successfully download it, would potentially fail to install and/or give really poor progress updates where it looked like it hadn’t installed. All the while eating up many gigabytes of space for I don’t know what.
- philistine 5y agoThe problem is still persistent now, I wouldn't talk in the past tense. Update sizes are positively ginormous.
- jfarmer 5y agoI think the title was meant to be wordplay: the perils of the M1 "Ownership System" and the perils of owning an M1 Mac.
- sylens 5y ago
- m_ke 5y agoThe logic board on my M1 failed after 2 months of very light use. Was also surprised when it wouldn't let me use an external webcam while connected to an external monitor.
- danieldk 5y agoWas also surprised when it wouldn't let me use an external webcam while connected to an external monitor. What do you mean? Using an external webcam while connected to an external monitor works fine. (Source: I have been using such a setup in a course for the last few weeks.)
- Nextgrid 5y agoThe other peril of M1 ownership is the lack of alternative operating systems. The other way I reinstalled an older Macbook through "internet recovery" and it downloaded the version it was originally shipped with - macOS Mojave. The UI was a breath of fresh air compared to Big Sur. Despite the screen being smaller than my M1 the information density was higher and it felt more like a tool than a toy. The lack of bullshit apps such as Apple TV, News & co and useless "widgets" was also good (for all of iTunes' flaws, it's still better than its modern successors), and it somehow felt faster despite being less than half the processing power of the M1. I now wish I could run this on my M1 but alas I can't. At least with PCs and older Macs you could always switch to Windows or Linux, but with the M1 you're currently screwed - if Apple drops the ball or decides to take their OS in a direction you don't like you currently have no alternative (and all the "security" around locking out the user from their own machine doesn't bode well for alternative OSes).
- brianzelip 5y ago…and Mojave is EOL this year, so here comes Catalina, with the shit show that was that experience which kept me on Mojave so long.
- salamandersauce 5y agoT2 Macs are still handicapped when it comes to Linux. It can run but with too many caveats. Needs special kernel versions with custom modules to have working keyboard/trackpad and at least last time I looked couldn't have both audio and sleep. Too big of a compromise on a laptop for me to use it. Wish I could. Seems like M1 Macs are going to have better Linux support than the T2 ones where BridgeOS throws a bunch of complications into the mix.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWell, in Apple’s defense, backporting old versions of MacOS makes no sense and would cause developers much headache, Linux already boots to a GUI on the M1 Mac mini (just no HW acceleration), and the list of available operating systems will grow each year there is a MacOS release. Just like you can’t run MacOS 10.6 Snow Leopard on the MacBook you restored.
- 5y ago
- jarym 5y agoThe lack of documentation is concerning, it makes me wonder why Apple are rushing the rollout since they could have provided a lot more technical info in advance to prepare users. Aside from that, with all these security features I'd be quite content if there was a way to setup an endpoint at *.myco.com instead of *.apple.com for the 'calling home'. I just don't want my hardware being so tied to the network services of one vendor. Is it too much to ask?
- my123 5y agoNote that the BootPolicy mechanism changed quite a bit in macOS Monterey betas, and will continue to do so within the beta cycle. Installing betas tends to come with caveats...
- zohch 5y agoI personally would be more concerned that it was made by a company that uses slave labor in collaboration with an authoritarian state that is perpetrating a genocide on a minority religion. But I guess if you are okay with that ... then maybe this will bother you.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoSo is your PlayStation, your Nintendo Switch, your Surface Laptop, your Lenovo desktop, your Pixel phone…
- zohch 5y ago> So is your PlayStation, your Nintendo Switch, your Surface Laptop, your Lenovo desktop, your Pixel phone… Not things I own. There are other places that manufacture electronics than China. And "everyone does it" does not a justification for being complicit in genocide. Here are good places to start looking: - https://notmadeinchina.directory/ https://notmadeinchina.directory/ - https://chinanever.com/ https://chinanever.com/ - https://bestfreereviews.com/best-laptops-not-made-in-china/ https://bestfreereviews.com/best-laptops-not-made-in-china/ - https://www.republicworld.com/technology-news/gadgets/non-chinese-laptop-companies-non-chinese-laptops-made-in-india-laptop.html https://www.republicworld.com/technology-news/gadgets/non-ch... Maybe if Europe stopped colluding and glad handing with Tyrannical governments like China and Russia they too could offer up some alternatives. Doubtful though, Germany is all about double speak, saying that they are against genocide while doing everything in their power to prop up genocidal regimes to maintain their regional hegemony.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI get despising the CCP, but your sources are significantly flawed. For example, best laptops not made In China showed a Surface Pro 7. Which is Made in China.
- randyrand 5y agoWill Macs still work in 15 to 50 years if Apple goes out of business?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jonwinstanley 5y agoAnyone hanging on to a computer for that long will have found a workaround
- bruce343434 5y agoThe oldest computer I have is a 2009 mac mini, which still works, but it gets hot and it's pretty slow. The second oldest is a 2011 fujitsu esprimo e900 which has unreliable capacitors, and has to be plugged in for a while before it can boot up without shutting down randomly. My point is, computers are fragile, even more so the newer one with smaller parts with tighter tolerances. And with the quick advancement of the technology, I think 15 years is already an excessive lifetime.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoFor most (almost all) Mac users this will not be a problem. For me, it was a problem when installing the beta macOS Big Sur a few months ago. For a while I was worried that I may have bricked my fairly new MacBook Pro laptop, but I eventually got it sorted out. I don't like that you apparently can no longer boot into the setup tools and reset a Mac to factory new condition. I had wanted to do this when I could not get LispWorks running with the newest beta macOS - I ended up just deciding to use SBCL until this gets sorted out.
- CharlesW 5y ago> I don't like that you apparently can no longer boot into the setup tools and reset a Mac to factory new condition. I recently did this on an M1 Mac mini (wiped boot drive + did a clean install of macOS via the internet), so unless I'm misunderstanding what you mean this is definitely possible. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201255 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201255
- mark_l_watson 5y agoThanks Charles. So, you installed meta macOS Big Sur, then wiped from there? Good to know.
- CharlesW 5y agoI did this on a Mac Mini M1 running a production version (I can't recall which version exactly) of Big Sur.
- MarkusWandel 5y agoI'm with Richard Stallman on this one, even if the machine isn't quite free of binary blob (management engine if applicable, wifi drivers). How much longer? Will Windows 11 finally choke off the supply of perfectly good, cheap, secondhand Linux capable hardware (by no longer requiring an unlockable bootloader)?
- heavyset_go 5y agoStallman[1] and others[2] have talked about this 15+ years ago. [1] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/can-you-trust.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/can-you-trust.en.html [2] https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/tcpa-faq.html https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/tcpa-faq.html
- maxfromua 5y agoSo, one of the conclusions should be “don’t buy used M1 Mac”. Do I understand this correctly?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoAh, no. This is an extremely niche situation when dual-booting multiple versions of MacOS that could possibly just be a bug.
- fortran77 5y agoWow! A good reason to hold off until all the kinks have been worked out. Even with "secure boot" and "UEFI", I have no trouble installing other OSs on the latest Intel hardware from Microsoft, Supermicro, or Dell.
- Kenji 5y agoPeople who use modern Apple computers are not "hackers". They are hipsters, slaves to the system. They are people who would sell their soul for a few more FLOPs or a few more square pixels of resolution. They hate exploration, tinkering, general computing and freedom. The devil comes and tempts you with a CNC milled chassis, another millimeter shaved off in thickness and magnetic gadgets. And you will take his gift for you know: Your soul is already worthless, it is already corrupted and compromised.
- perryizgr8 5y ago> During that inital setup, the Mac sends a request to Apple for that Mac’s signed Owner Identity Certificate (OIC). What happens in the case of offline setup?
- MMMMuysicJu 5y ago> peril That's it. I'm done with HN. You people wring your hands over everything like it's a direct assault on your personage. Top comment had to add a "peril" about the lack of alternative operating systems. It's brand new tech and your favorite OS isn't written for it? Boo-frickin-hoo. Don't buy that tech if it's not going to work for you. The entire article is based on the premise of running a second operating system, but that didn't stop the top comment from putting a glass to their rear end to capture that sweet smell that comes out the stinkhole for later inhaling.
- leucineleprec0n 5y agosomeone get this guy a meta brownie
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- underdeserver 5y agoInstalling beta OSes side by side with your main OS is standard practice for app developers. This is not some arcane niche use. Also, yes, people on HN will continue to demand products and companies do better. You can call it whiny if you want. I call it insightful and try to learn whatever lessons exist in those comments, so I can apply them to my products.
- gcatalfamo 5y agoDemanding a product to get better by saying that owning it might be perilous because of some missing feature IS kind of whiny, tbh.
- underdeserver 5y agoAgreed, "perilous" is a gross exaggeration.
- ribit 5y ago> Installing beta OSes side by side with your main OS is standard practice for app developers. This is not some arcane niche use. The problem is not a multi-OS environment, but multi-admin setups on secondary partition (which are extremely niche). It's obviously a bug.
- ribit 5y agoThe most likely explanation for the behavior is that creating multiple admin users on a secondary partition is such a niche use case that Apple simply didn't test and/or consider it. This is a bug, report it and it will be fixed eventually. Most of the reactions here are overblown to a worrying degree. Surely an average HN consumer should have more common sense than that.
- ohazi 5y ago> Yet as far as I can see, none of these subtleties are documented for those more advanced users. This is the real problem. You can concoct whatever inscrutable secure boot + firmware attestation scheme you want, but if you refuse to provide technical documentation for how it works, then this outcome is guaranteed. It doesn't have to be beautiful long-form prose, just a block diagram and a README level description of how it's supposed to work. Apple is really bad at this. You might be tempted to argue that Apple doesn't care about alternative operating systems and shouldn't waste resources documenting this, but this argument is flawed. As the author states, Apple's M architecture will end up in their high end systems, and those users are going to have crazier setups than a typical consumer laptop. It costs Apple next to nothing to let the Linux nerds figure this stuff out now and find bugs faster than Apple can, but the result for Apple is that the products they release next year and the year after will be more reliable. Basically for free. Shouldn't they want that?