32 ms·
Facebook users said no to tracking, and now advertisers are panicking
- PaulHoule 5y agoI got an iPad and was shocked to see an ad load on the web twice that on an Android tablet or on an ordinary computer. For instance, two prerolls instead of one preroll on Youtube. I installed an adblocker and found that almost all sites with advertising would refuse to server content to my ipad, whereas an adblocker on my computer gets blocked only occasionally. It seems if you have a iDevice people think you're made out of money.
- atulvi 5y agoI wonder why 25% opted in. Even for accidental touches, that's way too much. Loving this. Almost makes me want to move to an iPhone.
- Ashanmaril 5y agoMy guess is that even more than accidental mistouches would just be how many users are used to blindly accepting things because it's the only way to not get harassed with pop-ups. They might automatically assume that if they don't accept now, they'll get prompted again every time they open the app. I imagine a pop-up like this would auto-register for a lot of people the same as "accept the terms of service to continue"
- inesta 5y agocant they track by just ip address? for most, the ip address is quite unique. Apple only disallowed the unique id from being passed around right?
- jaywalk 5y agoOn Wi-Fi, you're going to have multiple people sharing one IP. On cellular... good luck.
- inesta 5y agoyeah on wifi, but if your home, its only your household. i thought cellular you get a unique ip? or does the cell operator hide your ip. i'm not aware how routing on cellular works.
- umanwizard 5y ago> i thought cellular you get a unique ip? In the US at least, yes, because most cell providers switched to IPv6 long ago. In other places, carrier-grade NAT is widespread.
- jaywalk 5y agoCG-NAT is widespread in the US as well, but is only used when a site isn't reachable over IPv6.
- umanwizard 5y agoTrue, but in this particular context the IPs would be unique, as Facebook has been IPv6-native for many years.
- cm2012 5y agoI own an advertising agency. I've tracked ios impressions % over time on all of our remarketing campaigns (as a proxy), its down about 30% from peak and stabilized. Not a huge deal. LOL at this below: "Seufert estimated that in the first full quarter users see the prompt, the iOS changes could cut Facebook’s revenue by 7% if roughly 20% of users agree to be tracked. If just 10% of users grant Facebook tracking permission, revenue could be down as much as 13.6%, according to his models. The first full quarter with the prompt is the third quarter. Facebook reports second quarter earnings at the end of July." FB revenue is going to be up in Q3, not down, would bet $10k on that.
- fouric 5y agoiOS impressions down 30% from peak is "not a huge deal"? This is very counterintuitive to me, as iOS both holds the majority share of the US market, and 30% seems like a very high number. Can you explain?
- mertd 5y agoMaybe peak is Christmas?
- munchbunny 5y agoThis is key: "on all of our remarketing campaigns" The discrepancy is that a 75% reduction in users opting into Facebook tracking is leading to only a 30% reduction in iOS share on the highest ROI ad campaigns. 30% is big but not 75% big. Another possible explanation is that opting out of tracking in iOS doesn't make you invisible. It just makes it hard for Facebook to correlate your off-app/non-Facebook.com web activity, but there are ways around that. So what 30% means hinges a lot on how the 1st touch -> 2nd touch leap is done, and the data for that leap doesn't always come from Facebook.
- alliao 5y agoI think so too. Previously we have a naive model of how facebook does tracking. now that apple closed this pathway, it's pressuring Facebook to reveal how they REALLY track or hide the fact they able to do so at some financial cost.
- nobody0 5y agoWhy a webpage needs to know more than what I click? If you put legitimate ads that are relevant to the media that I am consuming per se, I guess I can bear with that.
- rchaud 5y agoReplace 'web page' with "real-time customer intelligence platform' and you'll have your answer.
- elzbardico 5y agoThis fills my heart with joy.
- jorgesborges 5y agoA lot of apps started to prime users before iOS asks to allow tracking by showing an innocuous screen that describes some "feature". It says something like hey, do you want us to enhance your experience by x, y, z? Or it's written like hey, just agree to the terms so you can use the app. It would be great if apps didn't have an option to show anything before this prompt.
- wankerrific 5y agoFacebook is probably clever enough to have optimized the layout and button placement of their initial alert to generate maximum mis-clicks on the “Allow app to track” button
- ineedasername 5y agoWe'll, so much for the myth of privacy apathy. I've seen it mentioned before that for many people, the younger the more prevalent, the sense was "well the genie is out of the bottle so who cares." Clearly that was either never the case, or things have changed. Or now there is the sense of "well maybe we can shove that genie back where it came from."
- kalleboo 5y agoIf it's as easy as tapping a button, anyone will choose privacy. If you have to leave your social circle, or try to convert them all to something else, (or in the case of all those noncompliant GDPR warnings, tapping a button, waiting 15 seconds, tapping 4 more buttons) that is too much work and you give up
- datavirtue 5y agoIt's as though they had evidence that the tracking yielded some kind of benefit.
- Workaccount2 5y agoAlright HN, so what is the end game here? I'm sure some of you have some experience working in the "ad supported" space, and obviously most of the internet and many of its services run on the ad model. So where are we going to end up if there is a full on public distrust of the current ad model?
- JohnFen 5y agoWith a different ad model. It wasn't really that long ago when it wasn't possible for ad companies to engage in such widespread spying -- but ad-supported things existed nonetheless. It's not like nobody knows how to do this correctly.
- barnabee 5y agoHopefully purely ad supported services cease to exist. I never understood why these companies don't offer paid options with no ads or tracking, at least in adddition to the ad supported "free" version.
- tempestn 5y agoShort answer is that so few people are willing to pay for that, it's generally not worth the time. (Unless there are other premium features you can add as well, without completely hamstringing your free version.)
- rchaud 5y agoWe go back to the stone age. Me make product ('content'). You want product. You pay money. Patreon, paid newsletters and paid news subscriptions are all mature industries now. Why do we act like the sky's going to fall if the spigot of useless memes, influencer primping and political propaganda gets turned off?
- celestialcheese 5y agoWait. Influencer pimping is going to get significantly worse in a "3rd party tracking-free" world. Coupon codes and "link in bio" are one of the few channels that aren't affected by this.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoIt would be great if someone created a non-profit simple website for sharing pictures and updates with family and friends. EFF could promote it and all the smart people who hate FB could volunteer to build it. I'd donate buckets of $ to it to stick it to FB and show the world that the current model of surveillance capitalism is not the only way.
- janpot 5y agoOften I hear the argument, people saying "I prefer ads that are relevant for me over random ads". But the result of the tracking is not only that you get "relevant" ads, it's that your timelines and your feeds and your news gets tweaked in ways that makes you engage with ads as much as possible. Not only do you get manipulated in buying stuff you didn't ask for (ads in general). You're also getting spoonfed content that tries to make you as vulnerable as possible to this manipulation. Up to a point that this is downright threatening democracy and our way of life. I guess you could call this a form of censorship. Content gets suppressed, simply because it doesn't generate enough ad revenue. It's this type of censorship on "social" media that I consider much more harmful than the type that usually gets most of our attention.
- JohnFen 5y ago> Often I hear the argument, people saying "I prefer ads that are relevant for me over random ads". My response to that is "I prefer random ads, because relevant ads are an indication that I'm being spied on". My objection to ads isn't the ads themselves -- I'm going to ignore those no matter what -- it's all the spying the ads bring with them.
- threatofrain 5y agoI'm curious how much manipulation people think is involved in terms of buying things you didn't want. Enough to absolve someone of their financial responsibility for buying? Why or why not?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- long_time_gone 5y agoI think it's more enlightening to view it from the other side. If desktop and mobile advertising didn't have a material impact, why would profit-maximizing companies do it? If profit-maximizing companies are interested in this type of advertising, what is it about Facebook and Google that captures almost all their spend?
- 5y ago
- m1117 5y agoIf only facebook made an option to have a paid account ($15) or free w/ ads, people would suddenly feel better about ads.
- amoorthy 5y agoCan someone help me understand if users saying they do not want to be tracked affects CPMs on Facebook? We've seen a large increase in CPMs and I'm wondering if the two are related. Thanks.
- samizdis 5y ago[Eric] Seufert [a mobile analyst who writes the Mobile Dev Memo trade blog] estimated that in the first full quarter users see the prompt, the iOS changes could cut Facebook’s revenue by 7% if roughly 20% of users agree to be tracked. If just 10% of users grant Facebook tracking permission, revenue could be down as much as 13.6%, according to his models. If those figures are even near the ballpark, this would surely represent a significant blow to FB. If widely circulated, this could be wielded to some effect in a campaign by FB detractors/rivals.
- cfjgvjh 5y ago> If widely circulated, this could be wielded to some effect in a campaign by FB detractors/rivals. But who are the FB ads rivals that aren't affected in a similar manner by this change? Since the tracking permission isn't specific to FB, wouldn't other players with a similar business model also be negatively impacted?
- fairity 5y ago> But who are the FB ads rivals that aren't affected in a similar manner by this change? Google. Apple's privacy changes restrict tracking from within mobile apps like Facebook and Instagram. Google is primarily browser-based and remains largely unaffected.
- jensensbutton 5y agoNo they don't. They only prevent tracking _across_ apps. Facebook will track everything you do and show you just as many ads in their properties as they did before. This really does harm smaller companies more than Facebook.
- klodolph 5y agoI think this will affect different advertising platforms differently depending on how much they rely on targeting to begin with. Facebook's ad platform has some crazy tools for targeting to begin with--it's a big part of the platform's value in the first place. Less so for most competitors.
- rchaud 5y agoHow on earth did FB survive before everyone had a tracking device in their pocket? Oh right. They didn't even have an ad platform before 2008. Just bucketloads of VC money.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoListen to the world's smallest violin . I have zero sympathy for Facebook, advertisers, and businesses whose models depend on a fundamental privacy flaw in the design of the web. Business worked fine before that flaw existed and it will be fine after it's fixed.
- SakeOfBrevity 5y agoCouple more of cracks in the online advertising industry and there will be a major pop of demand for software jobs.
- ransom1538 5y agoPublishers (people that sell adds) do not want tracking. They want to take inventory space, display an ad then charge you money per impression. They do not want tracking,reports,clicks or any accountability. IMHO fraud is a large portion of publisher business. On the other hand, ad spenders (people who buy inventory) want cost per action. You click my ad, you signup, then you purchase something, then pay the publisher a cut. FANNG pretends cost per action does not exist. The current compromise between the two is cost per click. Removing tracking on the click would be a HUGE win for publishers (Google/FB). They could increase fraud and revenues. Ad spenders would be completely screwed spending money on fraud with no accountability.
- Diti 5y agoHow delightfully ironic that this article cannot be read without agreeing to tracking (cookies), or having to pay for a membership. In the European Union this would be illegal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fairity 5y agoBe careful what you wish for. If ad publishers like Facebook generate less revenue per ad impression (which is what these tracking changes do), publishers will inevitably end up showing users more ads not less (to make up for the lost revenue).
- maybelsyrup 5y agoGreat! Maybe that'll drive people away from these platforms and we can have our brains back.
- boring_twenties 5y agoOut of the first 12 posts in my facebook feed currently, three are ads (25%). Two of those ads are for the same exact thing FWIW. How many more ads could they possibly squeeze in before people just give up using the platform?
- after_care 5y agoPeople’s attention is a marketplace. If only one platform increases their ads then likely people will move to other platforms. I think it’s more likely all platforms (or no platforms) will increase their ads because all social media will have this problem.
- sumtechguy 5y agoThis is true. Look at the TV landscape. How long is a 'one hour show'? 45 mins these days? At one point it was 55. Toss in some overlays and so on. Crush out the credits in speed and split screen it. I have been using an adblocker for a long time. But a few weeks ago I turned it off 'just to see'. The internet was a lot more 'noisy' than I remember it. I remember when one simple banner ad at the top of the page was considered 'crazy'. If only we knew.
- subsubzero 5y agoIt isn't just facebook that will see this decline, they are the bellwether in social media so to speak since they are the largest player. Expect an across the board drop in revenue for social media and any company that uses ads and tracking of users behavior as its primary form of income. Hopefully this will signal a pivot in ad tracking and lead more companies to try subscription based services.
- peakaboo 5y agoI dont think so. Users already don't want to be tracked. Companies don't care. Nothing will change.
- potatolicious 5y ago> Hopefully this will signal a pivot in ad tracking and lead more companies to try subscription based services. I highly doubt this. I suspect this will instead signal a pivot to products that are intrinsically "trackable". It's important to remember that ATT doesn't disable tracking in its entirety, it only disables cross-app tracking. It's only harmful to your business if you are reliant on tracking users while they are not using your product. Lots of products will continue doing fine - think about Google Search, where you directly tell Google what you want. There is not necessarily a huge need to track you while you are not using the product - after all, the product literally revolves around you directly telling Google what you want. The products that will benefit the most are the ones that a) shows ads, and b) where the product's functionality intrinsically collects information about the user without the need to rely on third-party data. Oddly enough FB's apps fit decently into this. Your behavior within the FB main app are still "fair game" as far as tracking goes, and FB shows ads directly in the app.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt seems like retargeting will be substantially harmed, which is surely a non-trivial portion of Google search revenue.
- saiya-jin 5y agoI've read similar comments since around 2010. Stock market doesn't seem to agree. They always find another loophole to work as usual
- sharadov 5y agoI have a friend who is a publisher and he's seeing the effect of these changes as we speak. FB allowed best user targeting. He believes the next quarter results are going to be a blow to FB.
- celestialcheese 5y agoWith how expensive the CPMs I'm seeing on FB right now, I'd be surprised if next quarter results are bad.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/8ieHp https://archive.is/8ieHp
- yumraj 5y agoWho are the 25% who said yes to tracking? People who don't know better or people who actually see value in being tracked?
- fairity 5y ago> Chief Executive Officer Mark Zuckerberg said Facebook “may even be in a stronger position” following the iOS changes if it means more businesses start to make sales directly within Facebook’s apps instead of sending users to a web address. Does anyone know what he's referring to in this quote? There isn't a way for advertisers to move their purchase flow onto Facebook's app is there?
- celestialcheese 5y agoFacebook Shops (https://www.facebook.com/business/help/2343035149322466?id=1077620002609475 https://www.facebook.com/business/help/2343035149322466?id=1...)
- elorant 5y agoProbably Facebook Marketplace
- neoCrimeLabs 5y agoNow if only there was a way to force the IOS Facebook app to use an external browser for links clicked within the app. Yeah sure, they can still track the click, but would lose visibility beyond that.
- spideymans 5y agoThose in-app browsers are so annoying. They make it intentionally difficult to open those pages in Safari A potentially controversial take, but I believe that Apple can force developers to use SFSafariViewController to enhance privacy and UX, without too much blowback. SFSafariViewController is a privacy-friendly alternative that prohibits third parties from seeing your browsing data (unlike the custom in-app browsers used by apps like Instagram). I’ve yet to see a custom in-app browser that has ever provided a better experience than SFSafariViewController. Exceptions could be provided where it makes sense. For example, I would still permit apps to load webpages owned by the developer in their own in-app browser (this is necessary for web-based logins, for example).
- air7 5y agoI dislike being tracked as much as the next guy, but I often wonder what "our" ideal end-game goal is? By "our" I mean the typical HN crowd that understands both the technological and the economical implications of this. If we want top-grade products to remain available without a direct monetary transaction (i.e "free"), it seems we must give something that the product providers can turn into monetary value indirectly somehow. Yet it seems we are actively against any such options: We block ads guilt-free, we rally against any attempt at collecting valuable personal information even anonymously, we consider crypto mining in the background (which is basically paying via your electricity bill) borderline malware. I am part of this "we", and yet I ask myself, what am I willing to give as indirect payment? What other options are there?
- continuational 5y agoI'd simply prefer if all services became paid.
- afavour 5y agoIt’s undeniable, though, that such a limitation would shut off access for people who can’t afford it. You see it today with newspaper paywalls and the like. I suspect the vast majority of us in HN would have no problem paying for most of these services but I’m not sure how I feel about us making those choices on behalf of those that can’t.
- diamond_hands 5y agoAnd we wonder why people seem more uninformed than ever...
- KittenInABox 5y agoIf its vital enough that everyone must have access, then it should be considered a public utility like water, or something the government should subsidize like food stamps. I'd be happy for my tax dollars to go towards a well-moderated social media platform that everyone can access and by design doesn't do shit like optimize "engagement" or whatever monetizing nonsense current platforms do to try and make a buck.
- beervirus 5y agoGood. Your shitty, invasive, unethical, failing business model is not my problem.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoMore of Facebooks "Boohoo small business" spin. The #1 losing out here is Facebook. Good.
- clouddrover 5y ago> “What Facebook was great at is they were able to see who bought and find that user’s buyer behavior – what other websites are they visiting, what other things are they doing,” Stuck said. I'm not going to shed too many tears if businesses which were in the business of making my business their business go out of business. It was a bad business to begin with.
- nottorp 5y agoFrom TFA: “I don’t think anyone truly understands how many businesses in the world are 100% dependent on Facebook,” ... proceeds to lament said small businesses ... If you ask me, if businesses have come to be 100% dependent on Facebook, isn't Facebook a monopoly that should be broken up?
- syrrim 5y agoMonopolies aren't illegal. Abuse of monopoly through anti-competitive practices is illegal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fleddr 5y agoMarketing, the entirety of it, is a machine of lies. Its sole purpose is to convince me to buy a product I wasn't looking for in the first place. Marketing is arrogant (we are the best), misleading (overpromise, leave out unfavorable information), manipulative (fear of missing out, social pressure, pricing something as x.99$) and loud. Imagine the above as a person, randomly popping up in your view about a thousand times a day, screaming at you. The person also follows you everywhere, takes notes of everything you do. Marketing perpetuates consumer culture, stimulating demand that didn't even exist. Marketing lacks any form of basic human decency. It's depressing that the smartest minds in our world seem to have an existential dependency on the above.
- aspaceman 5y ago> It's depressing that the smartest minds in our world seem to have an existential dependency on the above. Not only dependent. Don't forget how many psychology PhDs get jobs at Facebook and Google instead of "helping people". Why would you work with a bunch of depressed drug addicts and wife-beaters? Why not get a joint degree in PhD and Marketing? https://marketing.wharton.upenn.edu/joint-doctoral-degree-in-marketing-and-psychology/ https://marketing.wharton.upenn.edu/joint-doctoral-degree-in... You'll make 10x as much. > For consumer researchers, psychology is one of the foundational disciplines that comprise the field of marketing. For psychologists, the marketplace is filled with questions and insights about human cognition and behavior. It's so on the nose it's painful - I truly think limiting the amount a business spends on advertising would have a net good for society.
- fleddr 5y agoExactly right. The best minds are working on algorithms tricking you to click on something. This also explains why big tech products hardly ever really get new features. That's not what the engineers are working on. They want you to click. It doesn't matter if it leads to depression, anxiety...just bloody click. Or read. Or watch that video. And then the next one.
- werber 5y agoThe article mentions influencers as a revenue stream and I personally love makeup and make purchases and recommendations based on a creator building a reputable brand. I would like to see that model in more spaces. Make up brands give influencers press kits and they give their honest thoughts. Today a TikToker “mass hole” got Kylie Jenner’s updated product and I watched 4 videos of her trying it out and the product that stood out the most was not liked by the creator (upgraded highlighter formula if you’re curious) but because I trust the channel I saw a product that fits into a niche I care about (a more subtle highlighter). Marketing might be getting meritocrized?
- dclaw 5y agoDeath to facebook/instagram. Been off them for 4 years now, and it's the best thing I ever did. They have nothing I need.
- soco 5y ago"have already seen a decrease in effectiveness of their ads" I take it rather they cannot tell anymore what's going on. Maybe the ads are less effective but maybe they are more effective. They just can't reliably tell anymore.
- danbruc 5y agoThat sense of entitlement makes me sick. Tracking users is necessary, otherwise we would have to spend way too much on ads. Tracking users is necessary, otherwise my small business can not survive. Tracking users is necessary, otherwise we can not understand who our customers are. Tracking users is necessary, otherwise we can not identify new customers. Tracking users is necessary, otherwise we can not evaluate the effectiveness of our ads. If your business success relies on tracking everyone all the time, then you have no fucking business and should go out of business.
- adamsvystun 5y agoI would personally not agree to tracking, but who should be and shouldn't be in business based on tracking is not for you (or me, or anyone) to decide. If there are people who are fine with tracking in exchange for services, then they should be able to make that exchange.
- danbruc 5y agoIn principle I agree. On the other hand, are people agreeing to be tracked really aware of what they agree to and what the value of the resulting information is? Would they still agree if they knew? And this of course also requires that my choice is actually honored and I currently have very little trust in this respect, after all we already had Do Not Track and nobody cared.
- bilekas 5y agoThis is fine, and I know some people who are aware and are happy with the ads they recieve. I do personaly have a problem with not being given the choice, also it should be an opt-in option. Privacy shouldn't be compromised and then restored after the data is already gone.
- deagle50 5y agoOk, how do you suggest we achieve this? It's been over two decades now and the US govt hasn't done much.
- salawat 5y ago
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoGod damn, why remove the punctuation mark for the HN title...
- junon 5y agoChances are HN did it. It also capitalizes titles by default (each word) which also annoys me.
- amelius 5y ago"Falsehoods programmers believe about headlines" https://github.com/kdeldycke/awesome-falsehood https://github.com/kdeldycke/awesome-falsehood
- dazc 5y agoI think it was Ogilvy on Advertising where I read that titles shouldn't have full-stops (periods).
- imvetri 5y agoI don't think they need tracking anymore. IF a model is trained with historical data, that would be good enough to track without actually tracking.
- blackbear_ 5y ago> In predictive analytics and machine learning, concept drift means that the statistical properties of the target variable, which the model is trying to predict, change over time in unforeseen ways. This causes problems because the predictions become less accurate as time passes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concept_drift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concept_drift
- eropple 5y agoThis is true, but...meh? OK? Perhaps there are places where inefficiencies are not a bad thing, and perhaps advertising is one of them. Perhaps, even, we should require people to think and empathize and communicate rather than feed a pile of unvariegated data into a black box and do what it tells us to. I'm shockingly OK with having to make a connection with people to try to sell them something, and to have that be an upper limit on a company's reach.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bilekas 5y agoIf advertisers put in the effort and allowed for an opt-in only option. They would realise that the quality of their audience is far more interested in the advertisments being shown than those that are thrown into peoples faces, tailored or not. If I want to see ads, and I select "tailored ads on" my value as an audience should be far higher.
- mrweasel 5y ago> If advertisers put in the effort I'd go so far as to say that for a decade advertisers and social media experts have been given a more or less free ride. It's often not the companies themselves who manages the ad buy, it's agencies who only knows how to click around in Facebook or Google AdWord. They have NO IDEA how to run an effective ad campaign or how to buy ad space. The advertisers just see the numbers the agencies gives them, and in self defence user privacy is attacked and not the competency of the ad agencies.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoEven with all the tracking, the generated ads still suck, showing things already purchased. This reminds me of the overhyped lead generation tools out there, they do not work as expected. Someone's financial interest is the root cause here, someone is making good money with ads. The ones who sell ads? For sure. The ones who buy adds? Not many success stories out there.
- Engineering-MD 5y agoThe explanation I have heard previously is that people have bought an item are actually more likely to buy another: unhappy with the current purchase, or people who need multiple items. Sure, for most people it’s irrelevant as they are happy with their purchase, but most ads are ignored anyway.
- bobthepanda 5y agoat the same time it's very easy to run into anecdotes people have like "you bought the 5th edition of this college textbook? do you want to buy the 3rd edition in Spanish?"
- Engineering-MD 5y agoYeah, that sounds like a flaw in the methodology! And quite a funny one too.
- Pick-A-Hill2019 5y agoOne of the other things to consider* is that the details of person X that is looking to buy item Y are a snaphot at the time that information was brought/sold. When person X buys item Y from company Z, company Z is unlikely to broadcast that fact. Ergo, the 'system' doesn't know that you have now brought item Y and that you no longer have an active interest in purchasing Y. *Things may have changed in 20 years so the above is just an outdated observation based on a brief stint at a turn of the century B2B marketing start-up.
- 5y ago
- tomelders 5y agoAdvertising used to be a creative industry. Online advertising has pretty much destroyed that. Perhaps anti-tracking measures will put the focus back on quality in advertising.
- renewiltord 5y agoAdvertising is a super creative industry. One time we targeted people who worked at a particular (large) company in a certain capacity with ads that were specific. This is just standard Account Based Marketing, but we had great conversion rates and one of them was like "I saw your guys' product advertised to me between Words with Friends turns like 'This is how [our company] can help [his company] with [problem we anticipated they'd have]' and I was like woah this is cool, is it kinda creepy? I don't know. But it's cool!". That needed some pretty clever set up from the marketing folks, company-specific graphics and stuff, and the pipeline to be per company. It was cool, man. I mean, yeah, sure, lots of you guys would be like "OMG I would hate your company for that" etc. etc., but it turns out that's not how directors at big firms think.
- xemdetia 5y agoA campaign who's willing to do the legwork to actively identify potential customers/decision makers and advertise to them in innovative ways is perfectly reasonable. The issue is always going to be how they identified the targets and if the sources of data are ones actively consented to, which is different than what Facebook are collecting and providing. A lot of these firms are assuming consent and then reaching as far as they can, and that's always been the problem. I consent to plenty of sources of advertising data through contests, conferences, newsletters, accounts and actions on a particular service, public social media, and so on. If you want to aggregate that consented to information from multiple providers it is fine as long as their privacy policies make that clear. What I don't consent a single provider assuming they can just leech off other providers through device snooping/super cookies/other shenanigans. When some of these inputs are coming from these shady or overreaching sources the campaign itself and anything that's an outcome of that becomes fruit of a poisoned tree. If you look at it from that perspective what becomes 'good' compared to 'bad' becomes straightforward. If facebook wants this correlating data for outgoing traffic they should be asking to buy it from individual providers instead of assuming consent and scraping it via a side channel on your phone.
- helsinkiandrew 5y ago> Media buyers who run Facebook ad campaigns on behalf of clients said Facebook is no longer able to reliably see how many sales its clients are making Not sure I get this. Presumably an e-commerce site knows it’s been clicked from an ad due to the url. This must be referring to sites that aren’t recording that and relying on some Facebook pixel in the checkout or aren’t handling cookies themselves to remember when people have visited before.
- rgavuliak 5y agoThe sites are recording the sales, but in order to optimize advertising you would want to know which of the advertising channels (google/fb/etc.) is the most efficient or even which campaign (or creative) on a given channel works best. What facebook tracking did is connect a given marketing campaign that a user saw to the purchase they've made. Without allowing FB to track you on a vendor's site you don't get that information. There are ways to approximate it (see Market Mix Modeling), but those are statistical models that have mostly been the domain of big companies as opposed to SMEs that could afford them (even though now with the proliferation of ML it's getting better).
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoAh yes so the e-commerce site knows purchasers come fro FB but FB doesn’t know the purchase was successful so can’t how the ad to more similar people.
- tyre 5y agoCouldn’t Facebook include a parameter in the url that ties back to the click? Then the destination site just calls back to Facebook with that unique event id.
- celestialcheese 5y agoThis is tracking within iOS apps, not the browser.
- teekert 5y agoScrew them, really, these advertisers are super nontransparent, to us, humans, while our very attention is their product. And when we don't like it, they come up with dark patterns that shove it down our throats using pure confusion. I still cannot imagine that it is more effective to completely get to know me and subsequently serve me Makita ads for weeks because I looked for and bought a cordless drill months ago, then to serve me a context relevant ad. Like an SSD ad next to a benchmark article on SSDs. And that is on them, because they don't communicate. We should all try to make those companies fail. Our collective human attention is not something to be taken lightly. It was about time some company made a move that is pro their own paying users. Reading this article also makes me feel like FB orchestrated this whole privacy horror, using consultants and lobbyists to convince the world they need tracking for good ads, because tracking is what FB does. But maybe we don't. I really wonder what happens if all these companies tell FB and the trackers: Let's see where this ends up, it may well be proven that they didn't need FB and its inane tracking in the first place. If you sell Mountain Bikes, just pay a website owner that lists MTB trails when you want some ads on their site. Disintermediation, it's what the internet is about. Sure there can and will be third party advertisers, but they could focus on site content rather than site visitors. And who knows, maybe I'll come to your site more often when I don't see that I blocked 79 trackers, downloaded 3 MB for some text and had to dig 3 pages into "options" for disabling tracking cookies finding out that I actually really can't. You know who is a lookalike? All those other visitors on that site that targets a certain demographic. “I don’t think anyone truly understands how many businesses in the world are 100% dependent on Facebook,” I think you have more problems when you are one of those companies, what's your plan B? Evidently you are not just dependent on FB, you are also dependent on something that the majority of your users really don't like.
- _Understated_ 5y ago> Losing the ability to re-target products to customers after they viewed them online but didn’t buy hurts businesses trying to sell more expensive products, advertisers say How is this the case? If I have an online shop using any of the major tools and platforms out there, they all have the ability to tell when someone puts something into their carts and did or didn't buy it. They can all send an email to say "oi there, you forgot to buy <thing>. Here's a 10% discount if you buy it". In addition, I do know that there are addons in Shopify that will re-target stuff along the lines of "customers who bought X bought Y". It sounds like advertisers are the ones losing out and crying here, not the shop owners!
- grumple 5y agoAs put succinctly by the character Malcolm Reynolds on the tv show Firefly: "'Bout 50% of the human race is middlemen, and they don't take kindly to being eliminated."
- _Understated_ 5y ago> [Disruptive Digita] is also looking into technology that would let Facebook deliver personalized ads based on targeting data stored on the user’s device, meaning Facebook wouldn’t need to access it. Anyone know how this would work? My spidey-sense is tingling here at the thought of apps scanning data on my phone!
- a-dub 5y agoprobably just like google's federated learning of cohorts thing. they still cluster you, but instead of collecting your browsing activity from partner websites, they do it locally using browser history that doesn't leave your device, and the net effect is that you have an equivalent of a browser cookie or additional http request header that doesn't identify you, but does identify your cluster memberships. some people are still not ok with this, i'm on the fence.
- wcarron 5y agoMy idea? FB app stores data locally, uses this local data to pull ads onto your phone to be served/rendered. Don't need to send user data out. Just identify the ads this phone should be targeted by and render them as needed. Good point about the scanning, though. These scumbags certainly would try to pull something like that off.
- astuyvenberg 5y agoThe only aspect of this story which surprises me is that 25% of iOS users opted in to tracking.
- tomjen3 5y agoThat seems high to me, but there are plenty of people who do not value privacy and who would rather want ads that are tailored to them.
- sidlls 5y agoI’m surprised it’s so low. These sites are used mostly for indulging in narcissism, and people who tend that direction generally prefer to have their lives be less private.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoThey want their lives to be public to the masses that matter to them, not an evil corporation.
- sidlls 5y agoEven if they make that distinction I don’t think they care.
- kgwxd 5y agoI doubt most of it was on purpose
- overgard 5y agoProbably just people mashing "ok" without paying attention.
- Tenoke 5y agoPlenty of people find value in things like better ads or more connectivity across sites. Tracking can imrpove some services (I let maps keep my location history) and while I always use adblocks on PC, I admit to have found interesting relevant to me stores on instagram presumably because they keep data about me.
- nrclark 5y agoGood.
- niksmac 5y agoI would call it a huge success
- gerikson 5y agoFacebook: “We believe that personalized ads and user privacy can coexist.” No-one else does.
- csilverman 5y agoAlso Facebook, silently: "Please, please don't ask us how 'personalized ads' actually work."
- uvesten 5y agoHow would this even be theoretically possible? I mean, if you know someone’s personal details, they per definition has lost that privacy towards you.
- jabroni_salad 5y agoPerhaps facebook could advertise to me using the data that I have put into their site directly rather than snooping on me on other websites through cookies.
- nickthegreek 5y agoExactly. On instagram, I follow and like content on the d&d and 3dprinting hashtags, so show me related ads. But don't try and follow me around the internet to see what other sites I visit. This allows them to still personalize ads without me feeling that there is a private investigator tailing me everywhere I go.
- Workaccount2 5y agoAllow facebook into your private circle of trust and boom! personalized ads and privacy!
- uvesten 5y ago:facepalm: Why didn’t I think of that?
- 5y ago
- allenrb 5y agoIt’s almost as if, given information and a choice, people prefer not to have their eyeballs monetized. Of course, if this catches on (and I hope it does), we ultimately run up against “people prefer not to pay for things.” Will be fun to watch.
- umanwizard 5y agoWell, of course. But there's a free-rider/tragedy-of-the-commons problem here: people might reasonably think the monetization of their eyeballs is an acceptable cost to be able to use something like Facebook, even if they choose not to be monetized when they get to use Facebook either way. However, if nobody could be monetized, then Facebook couldn't exist, making those people (for whom monetization of their eyeballs is an acceptable cost in exchange for Facebook) to be worse off. The only reason piracy and ad-blocking haven't totally killed for-profit media is because most people don't use them (either because they don't know how, for legal or ethical reasons, or because it's a hassle).
- Zababa 5y agoIt's a bit of a cynical take, but maybe it'll help cut useless apps and help people focus on what matters a bit more. A good thing about paying for something with money is that it makes you conscious of what you're doing. When you're paying with your data, it's harder.
- csilverman 5y agoAgreed. And I have to wonder if online extremism would be less of a problem if sites like Facebook switched to a payment model. State-sponsored troll farms might be willing to pay for access, but most regular-Joe crazies/griefers probably would not. (Making social media harder to access cuts both ways, of course; it's entirely possible that limiting social media to those who can pay would only amplify the voices of bad guys with money. Does make me wonder how much social media toxicity is related to these sites being totally free, though.)
- meepmorp 5y agoYeah, but facebook would just take the money and still harvest your data.
- qwerty456127 5y agoHow in the world can this be considered reasonable for them to track you across other apps and sites? This like if the local grocery store owner would install hidden cameras to spy on me at home and at work and in the car and one day somebody forced them to ask if I'm sure that's what I want them to do. This all makes me start feeling like I might finally want an iPhone...
- kalleboo 5y agoYou're basically describing Apple's latest privacy ad https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8w4qPUSG17Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8w4qPUSG17Y
- csilverman 5y ago...and then, when finally prevented from doing so, they issued a quavery-voiced lament about how not being able to secretly film people without their consent will "hurt my ability to run my camsite efficiently and effectively."
- gruez 5y ago>This like if the local grocery store owner would install hidden cameras to spy on me at home and at work The more accurate analogy would be the grocery store owner teaming up with other local businesses to aggregate your shopping habits across stores into a central database. What you're describing would be if facebook installed a RAT on your computer after visiting it.
- sp332 5y agoExactly. All those other sites voluntarily send your data to Facebook. Edit: although they do track your physical location in real time through the app. That's more direct spying.
- gruez 5y ago>Edit: although they do track your physical location in real time through the app. That's more direct spying. But for that to happen you need to explicitly gave consent?
- csilverman 5y agoIf people opt out of what you're doing to them as soon as they're made aware you're doing it, then perhaps that's a sign that you shouldn't have been doing it in the first place. I don't even believe that 25% of users actually wanted tracking. I think a lot of people just blindly tap buttons to make annoyances go away, and these guys just hit the wrong button.
- aviraldg 5y agoAs soon as ad supported free services start shutting down because of ad blocking and lowered clickthrough rates on ads because of targeting being blocked, most people will probably start changing their minds. (The alternative being maintaining 10-20+ paid subscriptions.) For now, all this change means is that users who are opted-in to tracking are subsidising those who aren't.
- suction 5y agoAt least then they'll be aware of the deal they're agreeing to.
- shadilay 5y agoOr people will realize the service isn't as valuable as what's being charged. No one asked for 80% of facebooks features, it could be run/maintained by a much smaller team.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoSo much this. All I wanted was a simple way to share pics and updates with family and friends. Instead, I got an anal probe and mind control. Seriously, it is harder and harder to actually find my family and friends on their convoluted mess of a site.
- ggggtez 5y agoThe problem with this kind of thinking is that if Cable TV is any indication, things that start as subscription services will slowly begin to double-dip and you'll be paying money upfront and watching ads anyway.
- mariusor 5y agoFor the past year I've had this ritual of clicking on every advertising tile as soon as it appears and mark it as irrelevant and that I don't want to see any more from that company. Currently this happens for a couple of days at the start of some months. So far I feel like this strategy has worked fine, 90% of the time I don't get served any unwanted content and I can view a decent timeline.
- artursapek 5y agoOn Twitter, I've been blocking every account that pushes ads. Slowly I think I've gotten most of them lol. I don't see as many now.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoAnecdotally, this strategy does not work on Reddit: I've blocked u/madebygoogle and still get shown ads by that user account all the time. Gonna try it on Twitter though since you say it works...
- devb 5y agoI've been doing this for several years, and it doesn't seem to reduce the number of ads I get. I just start getting absurdly irrelevant ads. A memorable one was for @7Up_Nigeria. I live near NYC.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>I just start getting absurdly irrelevant ads. I'd count that as progress as they are easier to ignore. The ones I don't want are those that are relevant enough that they might prompt a change in my behaviour.
- derwiki 5y agoIs that a list that can be easily exported/imported?
- artursapek 5y ago
- HeckFeck 5y agoMakes you wonder how the web would be if 'Do Not Track' and other standard methods of signalling user preference were enforceable.
- xg15 5y agoI stay with my rule of thumb: Any corporate press release that contains the words "we believe that" is trying to bullshit an unethical business practice into something positive.
- randomperson_24 5y agoI mean this is amazing! But, doesn't this increase competition for any other advertiser who doesn't have all historic data and algorithm Facebook has had.
- deregulateMed 5y agoI couldn't actually find a source on this. The Bloomsburg article doesn't talk about any companies in panic.
- celestialcheese 5y agoBrowse /r/ppc or /r/adops on reddit, or browse the big slack and discord channels for marketers and there's a lot of panicked posts.
- deregulateMed 5y agoI wouldn't say lots. I could only find 1 post and it wasn't panicked..
- sam_goody 5y agoThe article spins it (towards the end) as though this is a bad thing. Ridiculous.
- SakeOfBrevity 5y agoI'd wager that 2/3 of software industry jobs market (number of positions and compensation figures) are built on online advertising industry. Now you tell me what is good or what is bad
- kaminar 5y agoGood, glad to hear this is happening. FB is much too entwined in the operating systems.
- literallyaduck 5y agoIf Facebook and its child companies blocked users who opted out, users would eventually opt in, they could even do it in rolling waves to prevent a mass exodus. Facebook and Google would likely be able to beat Apple and both depend on Ad revenue.
- jaywalk 5y agoAnd Apple could then decide that the Facebook SDK is banned from their ecosystem due to abusive practices, and require any apps incorporating it to submit a new version with the SDK removed or face delisting. This is an arms race.
- tedd4u 5y agoApple says that’s not acceptable. See 3.2.2(vi) here: https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/