37 ms·
Google engineer who criticized company in viral comics on why he finally quit
- drobert 5y ago> Cornet has now begun his new job at Twitter. And while he is more hopeful about the company's ethical core, that's not prompting him to put down his pen. So in the end money and status wins? Maybe he should make a sketch about that because less than 1 in 100 people would consider Twitter to be an ethical company. All in all Google has the upper hand of good delivered to the world compared with Twitter.
- galacticaactual 5y agoApparently he has moved to Twitter due to “fewer ethical qualms.” Never mind his new employer has built one of the most polarizing and divisive platforms in the history of humankind. Sometimes I don’t know where to begin processing people like this.
- stavros 5y agoMaybe his old employer was worse?
- Loic 5y agoI will quote him directly: > "The mismatch between what they say and what they really do is growing," Cornet said. "The thicker the gap is, the easier it is to point out that hypocrisy." Maybe Twitter internally completely recognize the bad side of the platform and work accordingly. I personally make a big chunk of my money from oil & gas, I recognize that oil & gas for transportation should die, but I know we need oil & gas for materials at the moment (but should reduce, reduce and reduce the use as fast as possible). Sometimes part of your work is not all unicorns, pink and friendly, having the honesty to deal with it and not being hypocrite about it is really important.
- galacticaactual 5y agoSo your logic is as long as we are honest and authentic about our work destroying humanity, it’s all good? What drivel.
- echelon 5y ago> What drivel. Sagan says we're just a mote of dust. Jesus says throw no stones. Hate cannot drive out hate, MLK. Humans evolved as carnivores, killing to survive. Bleaker still, the universe doesn't care when the tiny speck we live on boils away. And here we are but for a brief moment. A tiny kindness goes a long way. The parent poster was being pragmatic. They're going to die, just like the two of us. Work to end the perceived problem instead of talking about it sanctimoniously. Because mimetic vitriol creates interference waves and drives us into factions. It accomplishes nothing and amplifies hate.
- zelphirkalt 5y agoIf no one or to few talk about the problem, the problem will not be solved either. So both is needed, the talk and the doing. That means the talk is legitimate as well.
- roenxi 5y agoA person could reasonably believe it won't destroy humanity. Or that expensive energy could also destroy humanity. Humanity is delicate. There are a lot of risks, and trade-offs in how to address them.
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoSanctimony doesn't work that well. Incentives do. Shaming someone into feeling like a robber baron may sting, but behind them may be a family to support, a sick partner, a struggling child, a gender transition and associated medications and surgeries, and more. The world is a complicated place and reducing it by wagging a finger can only get you so far. Changing systems and incentives is key.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- quicklime 5y agoThat doesn't really make sense to me. Isn't it better to be a hypocrite and be evil only some of the time, rather than be consistently evil all of the time? I don't believe that Twitter has worked out how to act accordingly to the bad side of their platform. There's still a ton of misinformation, it's still incredibly polarizing, and IMO it has a worse overall impact than Google.
- NotEvil 5y agoIt's better than the alternatives. Loke koo, parler, e.t.c.. at least they try to point out when a politician is spreading misinfo.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI think one of the main factors of it being polarizing is that big tech tried to kill misinformation on the internet. 10 years ago people would have laughed at the mere suggestion that everything on the net is true. There will always be misinformation, but this dogma that this is somehow even an issue is completely festered by now but still ridiculous in my opinion. Of course these rules against misinformation are not enforced equally, so people get angry at the unfairness and dig in. Not really surprising. Solution: Sit back an relax and let there be misinformation. Even 5 year olds can handle this easily...
- shadowgovt 5y agoThat solution seems less practical in an era where the misinformation coupled with rapid spread via digital media can result in attempted coups.
- raxxorrax 5y agoLet them vent their frustrations on Twitter instead of taking it to government institutions then. Are you referring to the Viking?
- pydry 5y agoPlaying censorship whack a mole on social media was one of the things that drove recruits into ISIS's arms. It didnt potential recruits from seeing the propaganda but it did quell incipient doubts in their minds that they might be the bad guys. Censorship is good at that. Censorship can work but only if you lock EVERYTHING down, north korea/china style. The more failed censorship governments engage in the more attractive this route becomes.
- dojiav 5y agoYup pointing at hypocrisy and contradictions is much simpler than resolving them. The more complex problems get, the less likely anyone in the room is going to solve them any time soon(Bounded Rationality) . So beyond a point laughing at that reality becomes counter productivs. It just gets people to spend more time and energy reacting, defending, justifying and hiding things. Bottom line - if you want to do something about a very complex problem, pick a small sub problem within it to work on. That approach has better odds of producing outcomes than poking fun at people who have bit off more than they can chew.
- Zababa 5y ago> I personally make a big chunk of my money from oil & gas, I recognize that oil & gas for transportation should die, but I know we need oil & gas for materials at the moment (but should reduce, reduce and reduce the use as fast as possible). I've been thinking about that recently, and was wondering if not accepting a job in """bad""" industries (bad is a gross oversimplification here covering things like oil, gas, tobacco, weapons, these kind of things) is in fact running away from your duty. If you don't take a job in these industries, other people will, and these people may be worse than you. Maybe the best moral option is to in fact try as hard as you can to get an influencial position in the industry to promote energy transition, reduce harm from smoking, etc. I apologize again for the oversimplification of grouping together these different industries, my point here is to group what people think usually as "morally bad", not to pass judgment on people who work in those industries.
- hugosbaseball 5y ago> I've been thinking about that recently, and was wondering if not accepting a job in """bad""" industries (bad is a gross oversimplification here covering things like oil, gas, tobacco, weapons, these kind of things) is in fact running away from your duty. If you don't take a job in these industries, other people will, and these people may be worse than you One employee can not have even the slightest influence over the world's largest tech firm, even ignoring that it's publicly traded thus institutional investors are the only people steering the ship. Or ignoring that Brin and Page's research was heavily funded by the CIA and NSA as part of a program specifically designed to encourage silicon valley to develop technology and services to make it easier for them to track social connections between people. This is a bit like going to work at an oil refinery because you think it'll help climate change. Or working for Marlboro's marketing department thinking you'll help them stop marketing to children. Even top corporate leadership doesn't really get to steer the ship. It's investors - in publicly traded companies, typically institutional investors, mostly funds. Any sort of corporate "listen to the employees" initiatives are just window dressing; a tap at the bottom of the tank of "employee rabble-rousing." Just to finish driving home how little impact any worker could have on companies of this size: do you know how Walmart reacts to a store that looks like it's about to successfully unionize despite their union-busting efforts? They turn off the lights and leave. Now consider that Walmart's goal is to undercut all the small businesses in a community, driving them into the ground. Shutting down an established store leaves a huge vacuum. Walmart is capable of destroying communities at the multi-county level and they do not care.
- akudha 5y agoWe can't quit oil & gas overnight, the world will come to a standstill. But if Twitter were to disappear overnight, it would have zero effect on humanity, isn't it? In other words, he could have joined any number of good companies making good products, he chose to join Twitter. That is interesting to note.
- genghizkhan 5y agoThat's unfair. Twitter does have a huge impact on a lot of people. Twitter banning Donald Trump was a huge deal, for example. He has a smaller platform now and (imo) the world is a better place for it. The Earth wouldn't stop rotating on its axis if Twitter were to shut down, I'll give you that, but business as usual would change for a lot of people.
- realusername 5y agoI would not say "zero effects" since quite a lot of news agency relies on it but that's safe to say that the platform would be replaced by something else in less than a month.
- leesec 5y agoI think Twitter is a good company making a good product.
- Dangeranger 5y agoTwitter is not important to me personally, but has been instrumental in organizing public protests within oppressive and authoritarian countries for over a decade. I would say that has had a materially positive impact on humanity, and could continue to do so in the future, despite all the downsides of the platform.
- ksec 5y ago> Sometimes part of your work is not all unicorns, pink and friendly, having the honesty to deal with it and not being hypocrite about it is really important. Which is something sorely missing from the current discourse and media, no one is saint. But I guess the media or most public don't care, "The public aren't interested in affairs. All they want to know is who are the goodies and who are the baddies." - Sir Humphrey Appleby >"The mismatch between what they say and what they really do is growing," Cornet said. "The thicker the gap is, the easier it is to point out that hypocrisy." I mean it has been there since Day one. The first time I read about "Do No Evil" in the early 2000s was when my hypocrisy radar on red alert. And the insane amount of PR shit / submarine articles [1] that came in the next few years before they IPO. They were so righteous to the point everything that was in their way was evil. Indeed, Most evil are created by those who think themselves as so righteous. They stopped talking about it from early 2010s and stopped using the tagline in 2015. But the "Do No Evil" disease or ideology still managed to spread across Silicon Valley and Tech Industry. These PR shit managed to dialled to a whole new level, Uber, Snapchat and even Apple once Steve Jobs' RDF was no longer there to shield them. ( And became more apparent once Katie Cotton retired ) I sometimes wonder if those PR people managed to jump from one company to another. [1] http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Quequau 5y agoI once met a man who worked in oil & gas who was a pretty vocal (and frankly, unpleasant) "young Earth creationist". As he was in a relationship with someone in my professional social-circle at the time I wound up coming across him on a regular basis for a couple of years. I don't believe I have had a more uncomfortable, baffling, and frustrating conversation in my sixty years of existence than the one I had with him at social gathering where after him bringing it up, I asked him how he balanced his work and religion.
- TheRealDunkirk 5y ago> I asked him how he balanced his work and religion. When I see personally-baffling worldviews in other people, I try to remind myself that there are 7+ billion people on the earth. Someone, somewhere, believes anything you can think of. And now the internet and social media helps them get together and reinforce their beliefs.
- taneq 5y agoGod put the oil into the ground for us, right next to those novelty dinosaur bones that He put there for us to find.
- ergocoder 5y agoThis is like saying human traffickers use phones to organize their crimes. Apple and iPhone is the most evil company of humankind. They invent a device that helps facilitate human trafficking. Coming next: road and electricity!
- foepys 5y agoI get your point but there is definitely a difference between creating a platform where everybody is the same and a platform where engagement algorithms and recommendations push certain messages (or hashtags) to the top to be seen by millions.
- jjcon 5y agoTwitter didn’t just make a simple communication platform, they made a platform and wrote algorithms that (intended or not) elevate extremist and divisive voices. If they just made a simple chat app your metaphor would hold but they are directly responsible because they choose which content is shown and which isn’t.
- raxxorrax 5y agoTwitter was far more interesting when trends were actually real instead of prescriptive topics someone wants you to show interest in. Now it is a mix that many regard as repulsive by default.
- loopz 5y agoThe problem is many get hooked and duped by manipulators of the platforms. That's self-destructive.
- raxxorrax 5y agoAgreed. It is one of the worst types of scam and people get taken advantage off. But if you exile Alex Jones, you also exile its users and their ability to get out of there is severely dimmed. "There must be some truth to what he says if he gets that much backlash" is always a convincing argument. I don't even mean that ironically. Better have that in the open because on the internet there will always be at least one person that disagrees with any view that is espoused.
- malwarebytess 5y agoI don't know where to begin processing people like you. Your goal isn't to understand, but to criticize; and from a perspective of superiority no less.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- the_dune_13 5y agoThey were first social media to respond to January insurrection. The key word is fewer, not zero.
- formerly_proven 5y agoI don't like Twitter but I suspect the effects of Twitter are often exaggerated because everything is public by default, whereas in other networks a lot of stuff happens in groups/channels by default, where it is not immediately visible, so it is simply less amenable to OSINT, scraping and media analysis. In any case, between Twitter and Google it is quite obvious who is doing more harm to more people in more places and more ways. Twitter may still be a net-negative overall (in fact I believe it is) - a lot of stuff is.
- concordDance 5y ago> it is quite obvious who is doing more harm to more people in more places To me it's "obviously" Twitter, so I'm quite curious how you came to the conclusion it's Google.
- riffraff 5y agoGoogle's search bubble is arguably more impactful than Twitter's social bubble due to reach, imo.
- makeitdouble 5y agoIn many ways Google is on the same playbook as Microsoft's Embrace/Extend strategy, but perhaps in slightly more creative and net positive way. Google embraced search, and they're basically the only one left. They embraced email and their free offering distorted the market to enough extent to make most other providers also-rans, except a few key players. Youtube is the only viable player left in the video sharing field. RSS readers are recovering but it also was a blood bath. I could go on for long, Google coming and leaving(or not) markets has huge negative impacts that I don't see Twitter having in general.
- jsbdk 5y agoSome people are absolutely rotten and obsessed with politics.
- billllll 5y agoI'm always a bit baffled at people ascribing morals to these big companies. I'd be willing to bet that many Twitter execs would kill to switch places with Google, ethical quandary and all. In that case, it's not that Twitter is more "ethical" than Google because of superior morals, it's because Twitter has not had the same opportunities to trade morals for profit. I'm not saying this out of moral superiority (I worked for Google), I just think it's silly to expect companies to do the right thing without a strong incentive to.
- mns 5y agoBecause these companies are pretending to be moral, usually until it affects the financial side of things, after that, anything goes, if people don't find out.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bjourne 5y agoIt seems to me that this guy has spent years thinking about ethical and moral workplace questions and that you have spent a whole two seconds coming up with a sappy zinger. He may have had good reasons to prefer Twitter over Google, these reasons may have been clearly explained, and they may have been glossed over by you.
- Mentoio 5y agoFrom an ethical point of few, twitter doesn't matter and didn't add anything real to our socieity. Google did: Maps, Android, gmail (yes gmail gave free https email accounts when others not even enforced https), skin cancer research, Alphafold, co2 neutral datacenters, pushing now for 24/7 reneweable. Google literally changed the world. In my personal opinion, Google would be worth to stay and try to change google 'back' or whatever is going wrong. What has twitter changed for anyone? Srsly? The reacted when Trump became president they didn't forsee or work on mechanism to fix sharing and multiplying fake news. Other companies like Facebook for example are a global net negative as well. I'm seeing much more fakenewes and uneducated people on facebook commenting as antivaxer than anything else. I can't understand why you would go to twitter and rant about ethical and moral workplace questions.
- afavour 5y agoFrom the other point of view: through Maps, Android and Gmail Google has absolutely dominated the ad marketplace to a point where only Facebook can compete (and even then, weakly). They’ve built out incredible, unprecedented datasets of user activity online. If Twitter is polarising then YouTube is hyper-polarising. Twitter, I agree, is too insignificant to have done any of those things. So I can see how working there would feel a lot less morally compromising. > stay and try to change Google They’ve been at Google for 14 years. I think at that point you probably have a pretty clear idea what you, as an individual, are going to be able to change in the place.
- Mentoio 5y agoMy argument was and still is, that Google as a company has and had such a positive impact, that in my opinion it is worth to stay at Google while there is no real sence of pride or anything beeing part of Twitter in comparison.
- thinkingemote 5y agoTo understand it just look at the complaints of tech workers. The majority of them consider internal actions as grossly more important than any outside effects. Thus, if the hiring policy is progressive and if they have good HR, and a happy working life and if the managers don't trip up with certain internal political issues this far outstrips any negative actual real world effects. Walk outs of employees happen due to internal drama, not any external actions. Twitter therefore is a great, comfortable, safe and inclusive place to work even if history might prove it to be more damaging to mental health and physical security of the world than Google. Now, the new tech unions that are occurring in a few companies give some hope against this hypocrisy as they all seem to have a line or two in their mission statements which speak up about shaping the direction and action of their employers. I hope they live up to their promise.
- djanogo 5y ago"if the hiring policy is progressive" What does that mean? be racist/sexist and hire less white males or any males in general?
- afavour 5y agoIf your concern is polarising and divisive platforms I don’t know how you could ever give Google a free pass for YouTube. Its recommendation algorithm is a radicalisation program that targets divisive videos by design because they get higher engagement. It’s not something they intended but they’ve done near nothing to stop it. And in terms of number of people it reaches YouTube eclipses Twitter easily.
- thwower234234 5y ago> Never mind his new employer has built one of the most polarizing and divisive platforms in the history of humankind. Pretty much all the FAANGs operate in pretty much the same way. Google just has a very benign image, even while they ban people left, right and center on Youtube, censor search results, and delete adsense accounts of inconvenient news orgs. It's a bit ironic that I've to now use Yandex, from "repressive" Russia no less, in order to access sites and information not approved by the Ministry of Truth in the "freedom-loving" lands of the yee United States. If you know your "banned, unapproved, history" (the kind even Chomsky would admonish you for), you'd also know this is not new for either the US, or its predecessor, the British Empire. Hypocrisy, you tempt us, and protect us so.
- peteretep 5y agoHow do Apple, Amazon, and Netflix operate like this?
- pdimitar 5y agoSimple, he doesn't want to let go of a big wage so makes some ethical compromises. As if we all don't do the same, and I am not sure what value does your comment bring to the discussion because almost none of us can afford to bring 100% of their ethics into their work. If you actually can, I am happy for you, but do recognize that then you'd be in a tiny minority.
- viztor 5y agoThere is a huge gap between building weapons and building conversational platform...
- pessimizer 5y agoTwitter is just a bad website. Google terrifies me on surveillance, freedom of speech, and the general destruction of the internet. Twitter just annoys me. The problem with twitter is too much freedom of speech, and that's not a problem that I'm concerned about. If your ethical compass is just bad/good, I could see how this would be confusing.
- sebzim4500 5y agoI think the impact of Twitter on public discourse is massively overstated. Facebook and Youtube are both way more significant. In general I think platforms where you the user explicitly indicates their interest are less socially destructive than ones where an algorithm guesses. At least that way you are aware of what bubble you are in, and can relatively easily see what other people are seeing. On Facebook there is basically no way to do this. Unfortunately social networking sites in the latter category are much more profitable, hence why e.g. reddit is moving in that direction.
- leesec 5y agoSometimes I don't know where to start with people assuming outright that a social media platform is evil.
- ryan93 5y agoA lot of people in this sub thread who feel entitled to only speech they like being on the internet.
- radmuzom 5y agoDown-voted. Twitter has built a platform which has allowed me, a nobody, to connect with people who are famous or experts in their field and directly interact with them. Earlier efforts to use e-mail had 0 success as most likely my mails would go to their spam. It has allowed me to discover people who would find it very difficult to make themselves heard if there was no central platform where they could post their views and allow any random person on the internet to follow them. Using Twitter, I have discovered a lot of communities which I did not know even exist. It is probably the only useful platform in existence today. Just because some people use it for hate means nothing to me.
- fuj 5y ago"viral"
- jmcgough 5y agoAs mentioned in the article, they're available on https://goomics.net/ https://goomics.net/ Super cute comics, though there's a lot of references to internal Google culture or figures that I had to look up at times to get the joke.
- jrhouston 5y agoI like how it starts out as quirky jokes about tech minutiae and slowly mutates into bitter social criticism directed at the company and its leadership, presumably as the old systems of power crept in and eroded the idealism that was present when they joined the company.
- allenu 5y agoI would love if it was possible to just track general industry sentiment over the same time period. As someone who was working at another big tech company nearly over the same duration he was at Google, I myself noticed it became "less fun and exciting" to be in tech within that large company. However, some of that is undoubtedly just a part of getting older and becoming less naive about the world.
- raxxorrax 5y agoHeh, it certainly visualized his decline in hope very well. Google was a cool company once and some of its products and tech still are, but you simply have to manage your expectations when a companies goes public. It stops belonging to the people working there. Also, companies have proven to be inept to tackle social problems, even if they genuinely wanted to.
- shadowgovt 5y agoFor me, the beginning of the end of my enchantment with the company was when one of the founders responded to a major internal scandal at TGIF with the thought that he didn't want to deal with this distraction; he just wanted to make cool things. And my internal response was "Friend, you manage a ten-thousand-person company. Garage tinkerers have the luxury of their job being 'make cool things.' Your job is people."
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoMaybe Google (and other companies in general) should take better care of checking for cultural fit before ending up with those "timebombs". There are plenty of Google level engineers out there who'd be proud to work for the military, consider strong border protection a good thing for themselves and their country and don't view everything from the gender angle.
- akomtu 5y agoFor a reason unknown to me, Google (and other big tech firms), has to pick a political camp and strictly follow their agenda, key points of which you've just enumerated. I don't really know what would happen if Google said "we support strong borders and military from now on", perhaps an antitrust suit?
- knownjorbist 5y ago"Strong borders" aka "preserve the needlessly byzantine immigration process". Untold suffering has been imbued upon those lacking the fortune to bypass it and we are all poorer as a result.
- corty 5y agoYou can have strong borders without a byzantine process. For example: Just stamp any entry application with "nope". Predictable, fair, strong, easy, cheap.
- knownjorbist 5y agoOf course, that'd be moving in the wrong direction entirely. It should be easy to immigrate.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> needlessly byzantine immigration process Maybe better technology could improve it?
- 5y ago
- kr1t1kal 5y agoWhat a horrible site! I shouldn't have to scroll to view the whole comic. Images aren't text. They are supposed to be consumed as a whole.
- tayo42 5y agoI wish I was ballsy enough to criticize my employer and workplace like this.
- premium-gecko 5y agoIf you feel any need to do that, you should probably consider looking for some different job. There's a karmic burden for making a living in an immoral way.
- VRay 5y agoYeah, man, fire up the last "Who's Hiring" thread and jump ship. This industry is so friggin hot, it doesn't make any sense to stay in a job you hate Talking shit about management and rousing the rabble isn't really a great move in any case. They might have legitimate reasons for doing what they're doing, and you're just going to hurt everyone's morale
- pksebben 5y agoeh, some morale needs hurting. If I somehow suddenly found myself working for the reichstag, it would be a moral injury to simply find a new employer. Whistleblowing at all levels is important. Whether reasons are legitimate is something of a judgement call in any case. That doesn't mean you can't leave a nice little desk fire on the way out, though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kosirich 5y agoSorry if it's not thread related, but a while ago someone posted some kind of "comic" where the author tried to explain all the elements a good project visual/war room should have. If someone has a link I would really appreciate it.
- dshpala 5y agoI'm interested to know about his engineering contributions.
- shadowgovt 5y agoHe worked on Gmail at one point. https://gmail.googleblog.com/2011/03/faces-of-gmail-manu-cornet.html https://gmail.googleblog.com/2011/03/faces-of-gmail-manu-cor...
- everyone 5y agoI'm frankly amazed he quit and wasn't fired, and that google allowed him to be openly critical. I guess he already had a following early on? and if they dissapeared him later it would have looked bad? . It's like there is literally no developer support from google when your app gets taken down for no reason, unless you have a big twitter following and complain there, then they fix it.
- billllll 5y agoFrom my experience, there is plenty of room for open dissension at Google. One of the reasons they stopped doing all-hands (aka TGIF) is because people kept bringing up unrelated controversies in protest (Maven, Dragonfly, etc). The flip side is the execs are really good at dodging and ignoring you. It doesn't matter if it's an ethical decision or if it's something as simple as "why the hell are we making another messaging app?" you will be allowed (within reason) to scream your head off because you will be ignored.
- neilv 5y agoIf Cornet has spent 14 years at Google, his basis for comparison might be mainly to time earlier at Google. While perspectives on change over time can be very valuable, is it harder to assess where the grass is greener? Industry outside Google isn't the same as when he left. And he's also been at one place long enough, that some goodness might be so familiar that he doesn't realize it.
- mft_ 5y agoHis point about the hypocrisy of leaders strikes a chord with my experiences of my employer. It almost seems like an unavoidable aspect of seniority: as though one day after a promotion you get taken into a dark room and taught the new corporate language, and how to not answer questions directly.
- raxxorrax 5y agoPeople think CEOs are kings of publicly traded companies. They aren't, they are employees themselves that are most exposed to market and government demands. You have the responsibility for economic success in the name of all other employees. That severely limits your ability to just be nice for a moment.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoKings are generally much less free in their decisions than most people think. Even the absolutist monarch like Louis XIV had to consider a lot of factors in his decisions to simply keep his head on the shoulders. Being king is dangerous: his grandfather was assassinated, and his grandson's son literally lost his head on a guillotine.
- raxxorrax 5y agoTrue, that was a bad juxtaposition. Lack of responsibility can offer a lot of freedom in many cases.
- zigman1 5y agoThis is a fact that is often absolutely overlooked. History class does not give you space for proper historical, sociological perspective or mostly anything broader than sheer facts and narrative. I can not recommend this book enough: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Political_Survival https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Political_Surviva...
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoAn absolute monarch governing with God’s own authority on Earth can only do what he pleases so long as what he pleases is aligned with society’s expectations for an absolute monarch ruling on behalf of God.
- rutierut 5y ago> While Cornet's comics included plenty of critiques, he also found they were sometimes a way to have a positive impact within the company. After Google employee James Damore circulated his memo that included many sexist statements about the "natural abilities" of female vs. male engineers I think this is misleading and to me makes it sound like James Damore is some sort of male supremacist, memo here: firedfortruth.com
- realslimjd 5y agoThat's exactly what James Damore is.
- corty 5y agoDamore is a taboo topic, just leave it be. Discussing it will only hurt your karma, on HN and even more so out there.
- blacktriangle 5y agoPretty sure the whole point of imaginary internet points is so that you can pop people's happy little bubbles of denial when a chance comes along, and James Damore's letter is spot on in that regard.
- d3ntb3ev1l 5y agoTwitter cares and is honest about fixing a very hard problem. He’s right for moving. Google only cares when people call them out on it
- jensensbutton 5y agoA problem of their own making.
- everyone 5y agoHe comics seem to criticize giant wasteful stupid evil bureaucracies... But he worked for google for years and now moved to twitter.. If he's genuinely critical why does he continue working for mega-corporations?
- andi999 5y agoThey pay well?
- draw_down 5y agoTo feel better about being inside of one, of course. See, if I criticize the machine then I’m not just a cog in it. What truly matters isn’t what I wake up and do every day, it’s what’s in my heart that counts. My soul is pure, don’t look at my hands. He’s a long time employee with a presumably significant amount of equity. Significant at an individual level, I mean. He’s fully imbricated and implicated in what he portrays as so horrible (see the ICE comic if you think I’m exaggerating). Truly acknowledging this would likely be traumatic. I mean, shit, he’d have to do something about it! He’d have to live a totally different way, for just one thing. He’d have to divest... all of that is not gonna happen. So, comics.
- notacoward 5y agoTwitter's visibility might be high, but as a company they're tiny compared to Google (about 1/20 by headcount). They're also several years younger as a company. Those differences could have a pretty big effect on how far down the "mega-corp bureaucracy curve" they are, so maybe compare Twitter today to Google in 2013 (less than half way through Cornet's tenure there). Or maybe he sees a genuine difference in corporate culture, or in technical content, or in work from home policies, etc. How you feel about any one thing at a company can color how you feel about it in general, even if other aspects are actually the same.
- jatins 5y agoWhat I admire about Google is that you can openly publish these without fearing retribution (or at least the old timers could) At most places I have worked, you'll be fired for this kind of snarky criticism.
- commandlinefan 5y agoWell, they did fire Damore for what amounted to a lot less actual criticism. It seems like he just got away with offending the "safe" targets.
- noisem4ker 5y agoIt seems to me the author's divergence of views may be due to his increasing focus on politics, with a particular orientation that explicitly shows through the comics. It may just be a reflection of what's happening at scale in Silicon Valley's tech world, a movement which Twitter, which the author joined most likely not coincidentally, is at the forefront of.
- proto-n 5y agoAs someone from a different continent and not really familiar with the topic, are you willing to be a bit more specific? What particular orientation?
- noisem4ker 5y agoSure. Referring to the topics mentioned by the article: the one that is anti-military, pro-labour, anti-sexism/misogyny, pro-migration. On the 1-bit political spectrum of the USA, this would be the left. I'm convinced, though, that this is a special breed of progressivism and political activism, especially popular on the west coast. I'm not from the USA either and this is just what I understand from the outside of it.
- sentinel 5y agoSurprised they didn't fire him.
- trhway 5y agoNot about that specific case. If i remember correctly some people mentioned what Google may not give a refresher, and that is like cutting your comp several times down, a very clear message removing the reason to stay there without any need to actually fire.
- sentinel 5y agoMakes sense. I guess from a legal standpoint that's less risky than outright firing someone and getting slapped with a "retaliation" lawsuit...
- teddyh 5y agoHis comics: https://bonkersworld.net/ https://bonkersworld.net/
- wombatmobile 5y ago> Software engineer Manu Cornet says Google went from being "like Disneyland" to like any other profit-driven company. Presumably he means the fantasy of Disneyland, and not the corporation that owns it. He raises a larger question, which is how these soulless, ethically barren profit seeking entities are able to take over everything we value as human beings, and turn them into something else.
- NoblePublius 5y agoHow much of his unethical Google stock did he donate to charity?
- cauliflower99 5y ago'After Google employee James Damore circulated his memo that included many sexist statements about the "natural abilities" of female vs. male engineers...' Really? Do people (who actually read the study) really think it was sexist? It stated the obvious - that there are differences in interests in men compared to women by aggregate.
- elzbardico 5y agoWe are not supposed to discuss this. Please just accept it as a taboo topic, not only here on HN but elsewhere too. Probably even Damore would like to be forgotten
- sanity31415 5y agoI read his study at the time and it said no such thing, he was vilifed for questioning an orthodoxy that said any difference in representation must necessarily be caused by discrimination. Respected psychologists like Steven Pinker agreed with Damore. This guy either didn't read it or he's easily influenced by cancel mobs.
- mStreamTeam 5y agoHe left Google to go to Twitter, the HQ of cancel mobs
- strangecyan 5y agoYes, both the tone and the words on paper were sexist. I would give it another look and try and read it in the most empathic light you can, you might reflect on it.
- sanity31415 5y agoI assume you don't mean empathy for its author. Can you quote the sexist part? Please be specific. Here is the original memo for your convenience: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-Ideological-Echo-Chamber.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-I...
- potamic 5y agoI'm sure it was a massive decision after 14 years. I wonder if he thought about whether his comics have surpassed his career in importance. He was in a unique position to criticise and publicise mis-doings of the most powerful company in the world and he appeared to have the patronage to do so. It's a very privileged position with the potential to really influence many things. In a way, I feel sad for this loss, but it is a very personal decision in the end and one must respect it for whatever it is. Hope someone else will continue the torch because - "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to say nothing."
- pdimitar 5y ago> "Maybe we were just a bit naive," Cornet said. They likely were, and think of me what you like but I've noticed the same with most Americans I've known. Not sure why that is but apparently there's some good amount of propaganda going on in the USA and people apparently believe it. Meanwhile people have to pay $5000 after an ambulance picks them up. Or $90000 for semi-trivial medical procedures. I believe asking yourself "is my country really like I believe it is?" is a good food for thought even it's a bit sideways to this here topic at hand. -- On topic: I can sympathize with the author. I know what it is to have been a long time in a company; it becomes much more than a workplace. You have friends, you even have people you invite to your Sunday barbecues. It's also very likely that a number of internal processes are going smoother for you because you know whom to ping and what exactly to write in a form so your stuff gets done quicker. You have job stability and unless you are rocking the boat too much your seat is likely 99% safe. All of those become true stoppers when you start pondering leaving. They pull you back and make you doubt yourself and your idea of switching company. But unlike a number of commenters here I find nothing hypocritical about the decision to go to Twitter. We don't know how Twitter operates internally; maybe it's still better than Google. Or maybe they are still after FAANG level of wages so are ready to make some ethical compromises for them? In any case, immediately discounting somebody's opinion on a corporation because they joined another corporation misses a lot of context, is flamey and non-constructive and almost smells like a paid troll, and is something I don't expect HN to condone. But sadly, here we go, it's the top comment here.
- prions 5y agoYou are not immune to propaganda
- pdimitar 5y agoOf course I'm not. I realized this some years ago and started actively trying to prevent it. But I'm sure I'm buying a propaganda that I shouldn't, even today.
- fffffssssss 5y ago>apparently there's some good amount of propaganda going on in the USA and people apparently believe it. >Meanwhile people have to pay $5000 after an ambulance picks them up. Or $90000 for semi-trivial medical procedures. Ironic
- teameat 5y agoHe reminds me of Scott Adams, Creator of the Dilbert Cartoons started with PacBell way back and got a lot of early inspiration from that experience. Maybe this guy should consider becoming a full time cartoonist as well instead of going to work for another "evil tech giant" ?
- rchaud 5y agoNewspapers are dead. They syndicated Adams' comics throughout the 90s and 2000s. There's no compensation and distribution model that can replace it as yet. Probably won't ever be, the future is all video.
- Apocryphon 5y agoMaybe he’ll become a resident cartoonist, documenting the inner life of these tech giants through his work.
- SavageBeast 5y agoThe greatest rebuke one can give to an employer is to stop taking their money. If all the sudden Company X woke up to find 30% of its staff was officially resigning at noon the same day ... well now things just might change. I've never heard of this happening.
- phpnode 5y agoBasecamp came pretty close to this recently, I'm not sure whether it had a material effect on their business or future direction.
- amachefe 5y ago"The mismatch between what they say and what they really do is growing" So folks, Keep doing evil, but keep your mouth shut.... Like Twitter.
- justinclift 5y ago> Now that Cornet has left Google, he has made his archive of Goomics available to the public online for free ... Not sure why the article author thinks its free. The linked page has a sample PDF of each volume, with a bunch of Amazon "Where to buy" links under it.
- lucaswoj 5y agohttps://goomics.net/ https://goomics.net/
- markus_zhang 5y agoAll companies are profit seeking so I don't really know where his original idea came from. I might be disillusioned by other things (e.g. did not expect a very stringent device policy) but not that. I'm glad that he moved on but I'm afraid he will be disillusioned again.
- rossdavidh 5y agoSo, Google does a lot of good, and a lot of harm, because it's a huge company with a lot of power. Twitter, his new employer, does essentially no good. It provides nothing that email didn't give us, except a lot more screaming and incentives towards polarizing behavior that makes us collectively stupider. That he thinks Twitter is ethically superior to Google is mind-boggling to me.
- eljimmy 5y agoI don't think it's fair to compare the users of Twitter's service with Google as a company. Those are two very different groups of people. One are users, one are employees. I feel it's also worth mentioning, focusing only on the small negative groups of Twitter's public users reminds me of this comic here: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-04-07 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-04-07
- mandmandam 5y agoTwitter has certainly done a loooot of harm, but to be fair it has done good as well. It wouldn't have grown like it did if people found no use for it.
- rossdavidh 5y agoSometimes, people use something, even though it does them no good.
- tolbish 5y agoFor a second it seemed like you were about to list the good Twitter has done.
- blackbrokkoli 5y agoAre you seriously implying that "people finding a use for it" is somehow proof for doing good? Like, that's such a giant leap I struggle to even call it leap. If someone would give the perpetually drugged up guys in front of my local McDonald's a bunch of Semtex-H, I am sure they would find it quite useful, but I also doubt that the world will become a better place.
- MSM 5y agoI have no connection to Google, but I'm really, really, impressed that Google was okay with him sending these comics, internally, to upwards of 15 THOUSAND employees. Some of these are pretty scathing- drones in Google colors, the repeated suggestion (acknowledgement?) that the ethics are less and less of a concern, etc. If I posted something along these lines internally at my company, which I think is quite open in the grand scheme- I'd be out the door or given a stern talking to a minimum.
- pumaontheprowl 5y agoInteresting. My stack ranking of unethical tech companies would have Twitter at the very top. None of the others have caused as much societal harm as Twitter. I saw research recently that as much as half of all trending topics in Turkey were manufactured by malicious actors to spread propaganda. Also, it's just an endless pit of addictive negativity. I once had a girlfriend who would browser Twitter for hours on end and was perpetually angry. Not a good way to live. Google, on the other hand, has a bunch of products like Maps, Drive, Docs, and Meet that are legitimately helpful and useful. I would have no ethical qualms about helping to make Docs better. This is not to say Google is an ethical company in the aggregate, but there are certainly a lot of roles you could take there that would not require you to question your morality every time you start a new task.
- antonzabirko 5y agoYou shouldn't rank negativity as more degrading than funding war and genocide
- jtmlis 5y agou can kill blow up civilians all day long, but as long you don't say the wrong word (n bomb or something else) your career will prosper. clown world.
- antonzabirko 5y agoIt really shows how confused folks are when stuff like my comment is downvoted. Oh well, you can't really do much about it.
- skrtskrt 5y agoFacebook recommendation algorithms have been shown over and over to lead users toward further and further into violent right wing content and user groups. I use Twitter a lot and my opinion is that it is a complete free for all. Misinformation yes, reinforcing your bubble if you choose to, but also getting things outside your bubble if you choose to. Blasts of information from all over the spectrum, and you kind of get to chose your own adventure, as opposed to Facebook and YouTube where the only way to go is pretty much "more right-wing, more hateful, and more violent"