11 ms·
US-Canada heatwave 'virtually impossible' without warming
- aliasEli 5y ago> beating the previous national high temperature mark by more than 4C in one go, as happened in Canada last week, is virtually unprecedented. This event should be a warning call to all people who believe that a global warming of only 2 degrees Celsius will be barely noticeable. One positive effect is that scientists have collected a lot of data that will help them improve climate models.
- aww_dang 5y agoOn the other hand, proponents of climate apocalypse frequently make a distinction between weather and climate.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoThere is a causal arrow from climate to weather. It just isn't as crude as "warm planet equals warm weather". It would be closer to the truth to say "warm planet equals more unsettled weather, averaging warmer over the large scale, but including unseasonal cold as (for example) wind patterns distort".
- aww_dang 5y agoI appreciate that. From the perspective of the skeptic the Popper quote comes to mind. Karl Popper — 'A theory that explains everything, explains nothing'
- jrochkind1 5y agoIndeed. It goes both ways, I think of people saying "Well, if you admitted your theory can't explain this one particular thing, that shows that it's useless, and can't possibly be explaining the things you claim it does explain! If there's something it can't explain, that means it's unlikely to be valid!" An argument beloved by both covid and climate deniers. Nope.
- syops 5y agoWhy does that come to mind? The explanation provided does not explain everything even within the confines of climate science. When massive amounts of energy are added to a dynamical system there will be chaos before a new equilibrium is obtained. This is not controversial. It’s settled science. The heat dome in question is not just a bunch of new local high temps. That’s the wrong thing to look at. It’s a large high pressure mass doing things that the equilibrium established before the industrial revolution largely prevented.
- aww_dang 5y agoPerhaps it is a bit unfair to more nuanced proponents of climate apocalypse, but in popular discourse, every weather event is attributed to climate change. There is no observation of weather which cannot be construed as a result of anthropogenic climate change. If the conclusion opposes impending doom the popular refrain, "weather is not climate" is employed. >massive amounts of energy are added... Yes, but the claim (as presented in pop culture) rests upon the premise that the current climatic system is the standard which must be adhered to. The Earth's climate has varied throughout humanity's existence and before. Additionally, human emitted CO2 is narrowly focused upon as the sole culprit. Other potential mechanisms are dismissed or downplayed. Unsurprisingly, the conclusion is for more governance. Issuance of carbon-credits as a permission slip to consume energy. Whereas before the petrodollar has been backed by the US military. Nonviolent Solutions like reforestation are downplayed. Instead forests are mismanaged and allowed to burn. Carbon could be captured as usable wood products. Not only are there problems with the observations and questions about the premises, but the conclusions are inconsistent as well. "Settled science" was used to buttress cannabis prohibition. Today CBD is touted as a miracle cure. Pick any topic where large institutions fund research. You'll frequently (not always) find something rotten when results correlate with policy proposals.
- syops 5y agoThere are lots of examples of where science has gotten it wrong. So what do we do, philosophically, with this fact? It is possible that the 97+% of climate scientists are wrong in their beliefs. Let us ponder this possibility and assign it an unknown probability of X. Let us now ponder the following two facts. Every known example of where science has gotten it wrong is also an example of where science has corrected itself. The overwhelming majority of the people most knowledgeable about climate science believe the massive amounts of CO2 pumped into the atmosphere since the industrial revolution are largely responsible for the disruption of the weather system. Is X sufficiently high to discount the previous two facts? Scientists are studying perturbations of Earth’s orbit to see the effect that has on climate. Some study the effects of solar dynamics on Earth’s climate. It’s not that CO2 is the sole culprit. It’s that CO2 is the one we can control. It’s not that climate doesn’t change it’s that we are changing it faster than nature can change. It’s changing fast enough that there will be dire consequences to the current world political system. Of course more governance is needed. The free rider problem mandates that the solution be enforced by government.
- UncleMeat 5y agoBut it isn't a theory that explains everything. It isn't like this work is just a one sentence paper reading "climate change means more swingy weather, QED". There are cases of extreme weather where the methodology used in this sort of research does not implicate climate change.
- orwin 5y agoOr you know, the refutability criterion. The denialist theory is that CO2 have no impact on temperature. So let's build two closed of greenhouses with the same sun exposition, fill one of them with old ambiant air with 450 ppm of CO2 and one with current/predicted ambiant air (750 ppm of CO2), same humidity (or rather, a bassin with the same quantity of water). After a day under the sun, check the temperature of both greenhouses (well, actually, the energy contain in the air of both greenhouses would be better). If one of them have more energy than the second, this "CO2 have no impact on the climate" theory should die and his proponents shut up.
- aww_dang 5y agoThere's a wide gulf between, "CO2 has no impact" and, "Humanity is responsible for climate and weather". Your experiment would be better formulated as such: 1) Establishing the optimal climate and weather. 2) Create two entire solar systems. 3) Place humans on the Earth of one solar system* 4) Observe the climate of both Earths 5) Decide which one best meets your standard of the ideal climate As with any scientific experiment, you would want to conduct it multiple times to ensure the results are reproducible. Measure the deviation of each climate and count the number of experiments to determine your degree of certainty. *3. Make sure humans don't appear (naturally?) on your non-human bearing earth. The question of if humans are a part of nature and therefore part of the ecosystem will arise. If humans are part of nature, you may then ask if any changes they may or may not contribute are therefore natural.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoThe averaged temperature anomaly, relative to pre-industrial temperatures (or even relative to a few decades ago), as measured by various scientific means, is hot and getting hotter. That isn't an explains-everything theory. That's prediction and confirmation.
- BobbyJo 5y agoLet's say alcohol didn't exist. Then, one day it gets invented... Traffic deaths would rise because people would increasingly drive under the influence. In this situation you could say: "This crazy unusual number of traffic deaths near this bar is obviously the result of drunk driving." In this situation you could not say: "My town had the lowest number of traffic deaths ever recorded last year, so alcohol has not increased accident rates."
- read_if_gay_ 5y agoWhy? Both are just equating correlation with causation. Of course we know drunk driving increases deaths, but if that wasn’t obvious then you couldn’t say either of these statemens.
- BobbyJo 5y ago> Of course we know drunk driving increases deaths, but if that wasn’t obvious then you couldn’t say either of these statements. And we know that climate change causes more drastic heat waves. If that weren't the case, you'd be correct, but alas.
- read_if_gay_ 5y agoClimate change produces heat waves by definition. If we're going to take a heat wave as hard proof for climate change, then climate change is a valid theory by definition, and that's not exactly scientific. > If that weren't the case, you'd be correct, but alas. Why so snarky?
- BobbyJo 5y agoWasn't trying to be snarky. And you're inverting my statements. I'm saying, precisely, that heat waves are not definitive evidence of climate change, the same way colder than average weather is not hard evidence against it. The evidence in my analogy would be blood alcohol tests of the people who crashed, and the evidence in the case of climate change is the measured/calculating heat trapping ability of the atmosphere. My point is, we have evidence enough that is is valid to say the former, and that is what differentiates it from the latter.
- ALLTaken 5y agoWasn't the Trump administration in effect ordering the deletion of all climate data [1]? I remember there was a very hefty reaction amongst scientists. I was also furious about that, even as a european. That data was gold. - [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-web-pages-erased-and-obscured-under-trump/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-web-pages... I'm sorry, I really don't touch politic topics and don't want to limit my thinking to binary left/right leafs of thinking, so regardless who ordered this, it was a fatally wrong and inhuman decision.
- pjc50 5y agoIt was mostly a political change rather than really impacting data collection and actual science, but it was still a hugely wrong decision by the right.
- ALLTaken 5y agoI wasn't there and could inform myself only through media. So no climate data wasn't actually deleted? That'd be a big relief =)
- dghughes 5y agoIt's the high above freezing temperatures at the 3300m level that's even more concerning it's so hot so high up!
- macinjosh 5y agoNot peer reviewed.
- the-dude 5y agoThank you.
- Mordisquitos 5y agoNot peer reviewed yet.
- refurb 5y agoExactly, not peer reviewed.
- fabbari 5y agoAn interesting thought on peer reviews: https://alexdanco.com/2020/05/28/lets-just-get-rid-of-peer-review/ https://alexdanco.com/2020/05/28/lets-just-get-rid-of-peer-r...
- chrisco255 5y agoNot only is it possible but the worst heat waves on record were experienced in the 1930s: https://www.weather.gov/arx/heat_jul36 https://www.weather.gov/arx/heat_jul36
- jameshart 5y agoThe dust bowl heatwaves are not a good argument against the idea that human activity can have dramatic climate impacts in a short time, though.
- monkeynotes 5y agoYou should probably give some sort of reasoning behind your comment else it's just the opinion of a random stranger.
- anothernewdude 5y agoJustify yourself.
- user-the-name 5y agoHis argument was that the dust bowls themselves were a dramatic climate impact, caused by human activity, in a short time.
- jaz2130 5y agoIt is, however, a good argument against this article.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ipaddr 5y agoI don't the parent is attacking global warming. The headline doesn't lineup with past temp records. Is there something in a dust bowl heatwave that could help explain why it is virtually impossible when it clearly isn't? When something like global warming become a religion any comment perceived as attacking itself no matter how innocent and truthful will bring out zealots looking to defend their faith. I think we should keep religion out of science.
- sadmann1 5y agoShould I trust the science here as well or are questions allowed?
- FpUser 5y agoThey have picture of Lytton that was destroyed by fire. Did anyone notice that the trees that were close to burnt houses still have green leaves? I know nothing about subject but it feels a bit strange how the leaves can survive when the houses are burning in such close proximity.
- mshron 5y agoAt least in California wildfires, houses often burn down from random hot embers landing on the roof, not necessarily a giant whoosh of flames engulfing everything. Could be the same here.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoThere's better pictures and video here: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-wildfires-lytton-july-1-2021-1.6087311 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-wildfires... Sounds like a fire started in town and spread to everything flammable, as opposed to the town being engulfed in a forest fire. Trees may not have been dry enough to catch fire.
- jokoon 5y agoI'm starting to think that governments and people will be unable to fight CO2 emissions for several reasons: * Reducing living standards is counter intuitive when consumerism is the norm, in France the Yellow Vests movement showed that it's very difficult to tax carbon if it punish poor people. Inequality and carbon emissions are deeply intertwined. * People will just consume, feel guilty, maybe take some individual "steps", but there is too much behavior inertia and dependency. Nothing changes because everybody feels responsible and thus feel unable to protest since it would be hypocritical to do so. * Companies will keep causing emissions unless those companies disappear A french think tank called "Shift Project" is writing a public plan, hoping to attract attention during the 2022 presidential elections. It looks like that any real step would result in additional precarity and poverty, which makes it very difficult to act for other political reasons. Sometimes I think that convincing conservatives of taking action, disregarding inequality, would actually be good enough, considering the situation. I'm part of the poorest 20% in my country, and honestly I'd rather have more poverty and solve climate change. It's a price I'm willing to pay.
- nickd2001 5y agoFor the reasons you state and more, I feel that developing a carbon capture technology that people have an incentive to install (e:g, end product from reacting something with CO2 is commercially useful in some way), is the best hope. People are just determined to maintain their lifestyles. Covid taught us how little quite a number of people are willing to moderate their daily life to save others' lives. So it seems to me if we can side-step this problem by making people want to extract existing CO2, then there's hope. But as for how realistically achievable that is... answers on a postcard please. I'm not a chemist. I do wonder is there a place for software experts to assist with this endeavour in some way, but how to do it is not yet obvious to me
- bavell 5y ago> I feel that developing a carbon capture technology that people have an incentive to install [...] is the best hope. People are just determined to maintain their lifestyles. I agree, trying to force change on people which they think is against their own comforts, interests or beliefs is almost always a losing proposition. Providing incentives for desirable outcomes and letting people choose is much more effective in the long run and doesn't breed nearly as much resentment (they feel they retain their agency). Our best hope is a play into people's own selfish desires and channel that into a productive outlet (e.g. "install this CO2 scrubber on your roof and make passive income!") Climate change is an issue that needs to be addressed immediately but unfortunately it's an uphill battle with human nature and the status quo of our culture/society working against us.
- minikites 5y agoWe're not going to solve climate change because no amount of evidence will convince people to act less selfishly. The human race isn't going to save this planet and we're not going to leave the planet either. The best outcome I can think of for the future is a managed decline where hopefully too many people don't die in the coming climate-caused geopolitical instability and resource wars.
- rimliu 5y agoThe only thing worse than climate change is the number of misanthropes.
- NiceWayToDoIT 5y agoIt is interesting tone of this article, even now scientist are struggling to convince wide public and policy makers, that global warming is real. Outcry of desperation. I see in that parallel with Covid pandemic: - "not it is not real" - "it is just a flu like any other" - "all things will be ok" - "oh sh* it is real" - "f** it is real" - "we are screwed run for your lives" - "..." - "no we have not said it is not real, we ..." Point being, just shut the fork up and listen scientist in the first place not wasting time. By the way when down vote could you at least comment :D Edit: Sorry for misunderstanding now I see multiple ways how what I said may come out wrong. Dialog was meant to be voice of non-believers. Global warming science is settled and it is real and may be a threat for all life on planet. What I find strange is struggle smart people need go through to convince people without knowledge that what they say is truth. Like frustration person with vision (scientist) would experience trying to convince blind person about the look of the reality. It is not about knowledge it is about trust. And in this case it seems oil money was blinding factor for many for very long time.
- bserge 5y agoJust look at how hard they try to convince themselves that it's just temporary. This is the same part of the mind that rejects any thoughts of death, even though we know it's certain for everyone. Tell me with a straight face all the human industry doesn't affect the weather.
- umanwizard 5y agoI downvoted you because it’s just not true that being against covid lockdowns means one is scientifically illiterate or doesn’t care about climate change, so it’s a bad analogy. Covid is much less serious than climate change. I believe the scientific consensus on the seriousness of Covid (death rate of 1 in 100-200, nonzero but unquantified risk of long-term side effects), and I think our measures to combat Covid were an extreme overreaction. I also think climate change is by far the most serious problem facing humanity and that no reaction would be too extreme.
- NiceWayToDoIT 5y ago
- sgpl 5y agoI've been cranking up my AC and adding ice to my water to combat the heat but I recently read an article about sea-life [0] boiling to death in their natural habitats (oceans, seas) which made me realize that animals in the wild increasingly don't have this option. It made me really sad to think about the fact that we'll probably see mass-extinction events (for animals, etc.) in the near future or at least within my lifetime because while we all 'care' there's no political will or consensus to combat climate change; it's also not a one nation issue. I've also been religiously recycling in my personal life but every now and then I read articles about even recycling from a lot of places ending up in landfills which really frustrates me as it takes away any agency I really have on this action. [0] https://www.complex.com/life/bc-heat-wave-cooked-more-than-a-billion-seashore-animals-to-death https://www.complex.com/life/bc-heat-wave-cooked-more-than-a...
- JulianMorrison 5y agoIt already is a mass extinction event, globally, by any historical standards. But yes, it could get worse.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> But yes, it could get worse It will. It is.
- rinze 5y agoAnd no one could have foreseen it.
- drclau 5y agoIt's been happening for a very long time. Some put it back to the times when humans left Africa. It's known as the Holocene Extinction [0]. Though, it has never been as bad as these last couple of centuries. I think the fact that people don't seem to be aware of this is a massive failure of our society and in particular the education system. I do not know, but I would like to believe that it would have made a difference if we were all aware of how huge our impact is on the biosphere is. Refs: [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction
- irthomasthomas 5y agoI thought we where not supposed to conflate weather and climate change? https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/noaa-n/climate/climate_weather.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/noaa-n/climate/climate_we... https://www.science20.com/news_articles/stop_conflating_weather_and_climate_consider_macroweather-104689 https://www.science20.com/news_articles/stop_conflating_weat... https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/hot-planet/dont-be-fooled-weather-is-not-climate/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/hot-planet/dont-be-fool...
- UncleMeat 5y agoIt isn't being conflated. The way this sort of research works is by modeling weather under different conditions and determining that certain weather patterns are statistically more likely under conditions consistent with global warming. This isn't just "it is hot for a week so that must be global warming". It is "the air patterns that are required for this sort of thing to happen are highly associated with higher average global temperatures". The causality is going in the other direction.
- rimliu 5y agoThe models are useless. Or very useful: you can choose any you like to prove a point.
- _hl_ 5y agoWhich is why, for this type of research, you use an ensemble of multiple competing models, which also helps with extracting probabilities. If you think their methodology is flawed, then have the decency to respect the enormous amount of effort that goes into this kind of research and point out actual, specific flaws.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThey won't. An old friend of mine is a professor who studies climate change. They fairly consistently get hate mail from people who insist that computer modeling as an entire discipline is utterly worthless and should be dismissed without any investigation. There are no reasoned criticisms coming from the denier community.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThe actual paper: https://www.worldweatherattribution.org/wp-content/uploads/NW-US-extreme-heat-2021-scientific-report-WWA.pdf https://www.worldweatherattribution.org/wp-content/uploads/N...
- hanniabu 5y agoLooks like I need to move to a cooler area. Is there anywhere that has maps with projected yearly temperatures in different regions of the US? For example right now Boston is miserable in the winter, but it'd be nice to see projections or at least a historical trend of what the average monthly temperatures would look like 5-10 years from now. If they looked better then I'd look to moving up there. If they're too cold maybe I find somewhere more south like New Jersey, or if too warm somewhere more north like Maine.
- _nalply 5y agoIf you can, move to Scandinavia or UK, I think. An alpine valley would also be nice like Davos in Switzerland, however with climate change alpine regions experience disruptions like mud flows which can be deadly.
- nickd2001 5y agoLapland (Finland) has had record heat of 34 C this year. UK is regularly getting well into the 30s now. Hit a record of 38.7 C in Cambridge a couple years back. Not quite the current N America heat dome temps, but given that hardly anyone living in Seattle in the 2000 would've ever imagined they'd see 42C just 21 yrs later, I think the lesson is nowhere is immune.
- lamontcg 5y agoUK could get freezing cold in the winter if the Atlantic conveyor belt slows down due to Greenland melting.
- NiceWayToDoIT 5y agoIs there any study that gives a model what happens during summer time when entire albedo effect of the northern cap is lost?
- ghastmaster 5y ago> If humans hadn't influenced the climate to the extent that they have, the event would have been 150 times less likely A change in odds by a multiple of 150 does not equal "virtually impossible". Imagine 1/1000 vs 1/150,000 odds for a multimillion jackpot. Our weather and climate system is unfathomably complex. The odds that a compter model is correct is "virtually impossible".
- mjburgess 5y agoIndeed, one has to scale that probability by our confidence in the model itself -- so the probability itself has a wide confidence interval. Ie., a more accurate claim is something like, `15x to 1500x`, with `150x` the best mean according to the model. (Or even `1.5x to 15,000x` -- it would be useful to know).
- schnebbau 5y agoI feel like I've gone through the five stages of grief with climate change, and I'm finally at acceptance. There are too many forces pushing it further than to prevent it, and governments won't come together to actually do something about it until it's too late. Everything that has a beginning has an end, and maybe this is ours. Over time the earth will heal without us, so instead of worrying about something out of our control (as individuals), how about we just live our short meaningless lives as comfortably as we can and do whatever we want until we die.
- zivkovicp 5y agoRegardless of whether climate change is real or this is all a "green wash", the logical choice is to support ecological preservation and clean air initiatives BECAUSE it's nice to breath clean air and drink clean water. I think it's really that simple. There is very little incentive for us regular people to support heavily polluting industry unless it's required for self preservation in some way. Technology will also find good solutions for reducing the impact if industry is forced down that road.
- umanwizard 5y agoClean air and water have nothing to do with climate change. Climate change is caused by relatively tiny concentrations of CO2, which is perfectly safe to breathe, and not “dirty” or a pollutant in any traditional sense. If you think of climate change and imagine superfund sites, factories dumping sludge in rivers, etc., then you are conflating two concepts that are only tangentially related.
- bavell 5y agoOnce we're gone we'll be just another evolutionary dead end and join all the other extinct species while the earth continues happily orbiting the sun for another ~5 billion years... One of my favorite George Carlin bits on this subject: https://youtu.be/BB0aFPXr4n4 https://youtu.be/BB0aFPXr4n4
- nickd2001 5y agoNo offence intended, but that seems to me like defeatism, and precisely what no-one must do. While there's any chance to fix this problem, IMHO everyone should do the little they can. e:g, never get in an aeroplane again and tell people why. Buy local food / grow your own, refuse to purchase products shipped from far when there are local alternatives. And tell people why. Ensure any investments you have are not in fossil fuel companies. And tell people why. Drive far less, or not at all. Red meat far less, or not at all. And tell people why! History teaches us there were plenty of totally unacceptable things that have happened and eventually people against the odds stopped this . To pluck a random example, there was a time in the UK for example when women weren't allowed to vote. That got fixed. ;) There must have been some very strong vested interests at the time that didn't want women to vote but it got overturned by strength of public feeling. I really hope this year's weather in N America will be a wake-up call.
- maest 5y agoAre there any good models of how regional climate will look like in 10/20/30 years given the current rate of change? I suspect the housing market in most places hasn't baked that information in (with the exception of e.g. property on the coastline that will be under water in the near future)
- hntroll1443 5y ago> Are there any good models of how regional climate will look like in 10/20/30 years given the current rate of change? No. The climate is a complex system. We can't predict what's going to happen two weeks from now, never mind decades in the future. But that won't stop lots of people from telling you they can do it with their crappy, buggy, closed-source program that prints whatever they want.
- DarkmSparks 5y agoBBC in ice age still ending shocker. Absolutely no one (afaik) disputes there was once an ice and now there isn't. But there is a long way to go to prove there is anything we could have done about it or that if we should even try and get back to that climate.
- trabant00 5y ago"When will people wake up?" "Politicians don't care!" "Rich people are just greedy!" "Animals are dying!" "Science deniers!" What are those but moral and/or intellectual superiority declarations? And they're false too! We historically never cared or done as much for the environment as we do right now. Cars are getting stricter pollution norms on a schedule. Home appliances are rated by efficiency, we even banned some things like traditional light bulbs. Vacuum cleaners have a maximum draw power by law! Garbage collection is more expensive if not sorted. We pump money into renewable energy. We banned plastic cups and bags and even straws. Industry besides being regulated and checked is economically incentivized to consume as little energy as possible. We have naturally protected areas and species, we regulated fishing, etc, etc. We even have some clear positive results like pollution going down in big cities compared to last century. Maybe it's not enough right now. But it's downright dishonest to say we don't care or do. The solutions left to be found are nowhere clear or easy. We don't have infinite resources to do things, we can't force every country to do the same, change takes time, etc.
- minikites 5y ago>But it's downright dishonest to say we don't care or do. If I exercise once a month and spend the other 29 days sitting around, is it dishonest to say I care about physical fitness? >The solutions left to be found are nowhere clear or easy. They're very clear, they're just not easy, because they're unpopular, because they involve people being less greedy and selfish. We could tax pollution and punish polluters far more than we do now. We could take some of the unimaginable wealth away from billionaires and use that money to improve infrastructure and other parts of society to be more green. But we won't, because greed and selfishness are virtues of modern life and we believe that a single person should reap all of the benefits from the work of the thousands of people below them.
- umanwizard 5y agoIt’s also a tragedy of the commons problem. If one country does the right thing, it doesn’t stop everyone else from carrying on as usual. There are debates right now in Germany about how German steel producers could become uncompetitive internationally if stricter emissions requirements come into force as planned. I assume the same sort of debates crop up anywhere that makes any attempt to address climate change.
- Proven 5y agoSo what if it's virtually impossible without warming? There's no proof that any countermeasures might work, or that they can be applied cost effectively (that is, that benefit would outweigh cost).
- hellothere1337 5y agoEverybody is thinking about how tech will save us again from this conundrum. About how we will science the shit out of this. But of course nobody wants to talk about how we have added 1 billion people in a decade. People that will want living standards similar or better than ours and who will fight to get them. Will you science the shit out of them as well? Maybe with some drone based genocide?
- RickJWagner 5y agoIf covid didn't make a dent in global warming, then I don't think there's much hope. Nearly everything shut down, commuting stopped, people worked from home, etc. etc. It's hard to imagine any sort of voluntary program that would bring bigger behavioral shifts.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoPrepare for ARkStorms coming this winter... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARkStorm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARkStorm