7 ms·
America’s government comes clean on UFOs
- pmoriarty 5y ago"The report amounts to a giant shrug. The evidence is "largely inconclusive", it says."
- tazjin 5y agoThis article shows the biases of the author. The actual report makes no judgment that amounts to "shrugging", it concludes that the vast majority of observed phenomena have no explanation and asks for more funding for figuring them out.
- jjulius 5y agoIs it possible that you're being a little too judgemental about the author's biases? A shrug can often be used as a physical way of saying, "Huh, yeah, I have no idea," which as you say is basically what the report says.
- brayhite 5y agoDefinitely seems like a difference in interpreting “shrugging” here; basically “not sure” vs “not a big deal”.
- crazygringo 5y agoI can't figure out where you're getting that. A shrug literally means "I don't know". If the evidence is "largely inconclusive" that literally means "we don't know". Where on earth are you finding bias in that?
- IncRnd 5y agoA shrug can mean "I don't know", but it's primary meaning is indifference. Just prior to "The report amounts to a giant shrug" the article said, "Few in the Pentagon seem worried about extraterrestrial invaders." It is just as likely, if not more so, that the writer meant indifference and not "we don't know". We'll never know, however, since the word isn't clear from the context.
- newsbinator 5y agoWhat are some uses of funding that would help figuring out the previously observed phenomena? I'm thinking most analysis you might do has already been done, and probably wouldn't be too costly anyway? Basically showing it to experts and asking what they think?
- gregw2 5y agoFunding is being requested both for collecting new observations more systematically (not just prior ones, reasonable since the phenomena appears ongoing), and then for tooling to analyze it.
- pkaye 5y agoOne of the things they are considering is upgrading radar and other sensor processing to better track/identify this phenomena.
- MattGaiser 5y agoShrugging can mean not knowing the answer to something. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrug https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrug
- Tijdreiziger 5y agohttps://archive.is/yRrPH https://archive.is/yRrPH
- axutio 5y agohttps://archive.is/yRrPH https://archive.is/yRrPH
- 0des 5y agoIs there a plugin that filters HN links for websites that commonly throw up a paywall screen? I know Archive.is exists and a slew of other tools, but I'm finding that I rely on these more and more. I think I'm done browsing websites that gate content this way. While I appreciate that these other services exist to let me still read the content, I think this friction is a personal compromise that I should cut back on and evaluate whether this is content worth paying for or if I am better served just passing it up.
- Tenoke 5y agoIf you're going to install an extension you might as well just install one that removes the paywall.
- ada1981 5y agoSuch as?
- Tenoke 5y agoDepends on the browser but the one I use (and which works here) is https://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-chrome https://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-chrome.
- makeworld 5y agoI've found this extension to support more sites: https://gitlab.com/magnolia1234/bypass-paywalls-chrome-clean https://gitlab.com/magnolia1234/bypass-paywalls-chrome-clean
- moneywoes 5y agoAny options on an iPhone?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- simonh 5y agoCameras, sensors, tracking systems etc have never been more sensitive, complex and ubiquitous. As a result I would expect to see plenty of marginal, unusual or transitory signals that are hard to identify. I think that's perfectly normal.
- gtilman 5y agoThat's a really good opinion. Thanks for sharing it!
- amelius 5y agoYou'd expect more sightings with multiple recordings, so better to identify.
- Sharlin 5y agoThe GP’s point was, presumably, that more and better sensors = more data = more detections of tail-end phenomena that simply wouldn’t have been recorded in the past.
- XorNot 5y agoSpielberg more or less called it: if aliens were routinely visiting us, the rise of the camera phone should've made it obvious.
- ipaddr 5y agoThe Orb photos seemed to increase.
- TheFreim 5y agoOr maybe now that phones are here the extremely advanced aliens are more worried about opsec.
- ryantgtg 5y agoI took a picture of a hawk the other day with my phone. It was a horrible picture. These phones don’t seem to excel at capturing small objects that are far away. Anyway, I had that assumption, too. I’ve been seeing lots of photos and vids of UAP (because I frequent a forum that shares this stuff). And they’re always low quality!
- mikewarot 5y agoWe've had electronics that can survive 20,000 Gs since the 1940s. (Using vacuum tubes!) There's no reason these couldn't be some highly advanced drones from a skunkworks somewhere. The behavior of the top brass in regard to the Navy incidents seems to suggest they knew what the UFOs were, and weren't overly concerned as a result. [Edit] The Proximity Fuze was screwed on to the front of artillery shells, and had to deal with 20,000 G of acceleration. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proximity_fuze https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proximity_fuze
- wyager 5y agoWhat electronics could survive that much sustained acceleration? 20kG stretches my sense of plausibility.
- dahart 5y agoI’d guess the parent is referring to airline flight recorders, aka the “black box”.
- pdoege 5y agoRadar sets in anti-aircraft artillery shells, laser terminal guidance in artillery shells.
- mikewarot 5y agoThe proximity fuze, one of the technological secrets which helped win WWII. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proximity_fuze https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proximity_fuze
- hourislate 5y agoHere's the issue I have with that. We have some of the greatest minds on earth working for institutions like NASA,etc. Then we have private industry like SpaceX, etc pushing the boundaries of what was thought possible with Space flight and Rockets. You can even go further and include Russia and China in this equation and what they have learned throughout the decades. And yet there seems to exist some very special "Organization" that can develop and implement things that we can't even explain, the disparity is crazy to even consider. It's like developing a F18 Fighter during the time of Ox carts. Doesn't make sense to me.
- mouzogu 5y agoI thought all of these cases, like the tic-tac, flir, gimbal ufo's had already been debunked
- jodrellblank 5y agoI tried linking the debunk videos to someone in a HN thread, and they dismissed them and did the "do your research like I did ;) ;)" thing. I asked for any research links and read the single one they offered and argued it, but they preferred to take the authority of trained Navy Pilots to some internet rando. Neither of our opinions changed. Their position is roughly "it has been seen by competent people, and mechanisms speculated about by competent people, so it exists, so there must be holes in our understanding of physics / future tech which makes it possible to exist, just imagine what they might be". My position is "I as a layperson can't imagine how it could work, therefore it can't work even though I have no qualifications to declare that. Instead just imagine the ways qualified people are wrong about things all the time".
- skinkestek 5y ago> but they preferred to take the authority of trained Navy Pilots to some internet rando. That is the only reasonable thing to do IMO. Besides some of them are verified by multiple independent sensor systems. Does this mean I think we are visited by extraterrestrials? No. Edit: Or rather, I don't have any strong opinion on it but I that would not be my best guess. Only that I find some "debunking" claims as convincing as the end of a Scooby-Doo episode: The monster on chicken legs turns out to be not the prime suspect but someone else and there is no way he could have fit into that costume.
- hackerNoose 5y agoHave you actually listened to the interviews with the pilots? The debunking videos offered do not explain what they saw or experienced. Choosing the debunking guys explanation means that you basically have to believe in a conspiracy involving the pilots. So you're back to square one.
- 5y ago
- Larrikin 5y agoI assume the government is hyping up these UFO sightings in public because it gets the public wildly speculating about aliens, interested in looking for them and most importantly filming them. But nobody at the Pentagon actually believes their aliens and they all know they're some kind of drones from China or another adversary that are actually more technologically capable than current US drones. They just want more data on them so they can start building their own.
- amelius 5y agoOr maybe they want to justify spending more on R&D.
- krapp 5y agoThe US military industrial complex never has to justify spending more. They have a guaranteed infinite blank check until the heat death of the universe, no matter what party is in power.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 5y agoThe government isn't hyping anything. All of this is well, UFO-conspiracy theorists hyping things, and the media going for easy clicks (which is why you're reading this now). In reality, all of this is because it was a weird line-item added to a COVID-19 relief bill that nobody was going to bother fighting about at the time [1]. [1] https://edition.cnn.com/2021/01/10/us/ufo-report-emergency-relief-bill-trnd/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/01/10/us/ufo-report-emergency-r...
- cryptica 5y agoWhy is it that whenever there's something wrong with the US economy, the media starts talking about aliens and UFOs. I remember similar stories from 20 years or so ago when the media claimed to have photos of an alien. Is this a joke? Do people really buy this nonsense? Are they planning to use drones to kill their own citizens and then blame it on aliens? Or they want to blame COVID on alien bioweapons to shift blame? I can't figure out what the point is but it's retarded. Clearly there is no intelligent life in the universe.
- newacct583 5y agoSorry, what's wrong with the US economy, exactly? We had a devastating pandemic over the last 16 months from which we're recovering rapidly (c.f. yesterday's really quite good jobs report), inflation seems to be a bit high though still historically low, credit markets are loose, investment rates remain extremely high historically, unemployment remains under control, wages seem finally to be moving upward after decades of stagnation... I mean... where's the bad news here?
- cryptica 5y ago>> I mean... where's the bad news here? Crime at all time highs. Homeless people. Rampant inflation. Censorship. I'm consuming multiple US media sources. My acquaintances in the US seem to support this narrative.
- newacct583 5y agoSigh. Of that list, only one is even plausibly an "economic" indicator, and it's laughably wrong. Even squinting and spinning as hard as you can, you'd say that current inflation might be as high as 5% at this very moment. Which while higher than it's been in a decade or two is hardly a historical outlier. But then you have to conveniently forget that over the pandemic we experienced quite high deflationary pressure which is merely being eaten up. So in fact CPI and similar metrics are up about... 2.5% per year since 2019. Which is to say, business as usual. I'll ask again: which specific US media sources are telling you there is "rampant inflation"? They're lying to you.
- relax88 5y agoI think my biggest problem with this article is the idea that the government is “coming clean” on the issue. An unclassified report on UAPs does in no way confirm that some subset of these sightings aren’t advanced military aircraft of some kind, or even something else. Like I’m sure the majority of it is anything from sprites, balloons, sensor artifacts, sensor spoofing, foreign drones, etc. But the idea that the USAF et al don’t have any secrets to keep here is naive.
- eckza 5y agoIt's very naive! "We were hiding the truth then... but we're TOTALLY not now." Mmhmm. Sure. For my part, I find it best practice not to trust government any further than I can (over)throw them.
- deregulateMed 5y agoHey but government healthcare totally wouldn't be corrupt at all, and the last 140 years of government regulations in healthcare are not an indicator of the future. Sorry I'm always a bit mind boggled the way people both don't trust government and want more government.
- oh_sigh 5y agoI'm not even a huge government-run-healthcare supporter, but if you look at the health outcomes of Americans + the percent of the GDP which goes into healthcare, it should be fairly clear that corruption is already rampant. I'd honestly be impressed if the government could grift more than the private healthcare industry already has.
- Dylan16807 5y agoYou're combining too much into "trust". I'm not worried that the military is being corrupt when it hides this kind of information. And I'm allowed to want less of some parts of government and more of others, and to think that some parts are effective with money while other parts aren't.
- 5y ago
- bsd44 5y agoGood, now if only people understood what UFO stands for and that "unidentified" doesn't imply "alien". Imagine admitting an unidentified object flying over your soil and your defence system not being able to force it down, what consequences that would have for your military, intelligence agencies and your government in general should the object belong to a foreign military. Unless someone has actually seen an alien fly one of these things, it's safe to assume that the unidentified objects are likely to be part of covert operations of either one of the competing powers or the United States military itself. Either that or the aliens really do perceive the entire world to be United States.
- TheFreim 5y ago>Good, now if only people understood what UFO stands for and that "unidentified" doesn't imply "alien". It is my perception that most people know that UFO doesn't mean alien but willfully suspend disbelief, similar to when watching a fictional movie, in regards to them because they enjoy the mystery of the whole deal. >Either that or the aliens really do perceive the entire world to be United States. There have been UFOs over the years all over the world. South American countries have also had a lot of reports. The United States has a lot of reports but after filtering the outlandish stories its probably similar to other countries.
- staunch 5y ago> ...now if only people understood what UFO stands for... Now if only people would stop saying this like anyone hasn't heard it :-) > Either that or the aliens really do perceive the entire world to be United States. Alternatively, detecting/tracking/intercepting these alien craft may virtually require the capabilities of a fully modernized nuclear aircraft carrier strike group. Not a lot of these just floating around...
- willis936 5y agoThat's why the term UAP is so good. Calling the source of the observation a phenomenon rather than an object highlights the fact that there might not be anything present in the air at all. That's really an important point. The very brief recent report said there was ample evidence that the recent observations have been physical phenomena but then failed to show any of that evidence. There was a vague statement about multiple sensors measuring the same phenomenon simultaneously, but it's so flimsy and unsubstantiated that I can only assume it was a lie to keep the project funded. They aimed for the bare minimum and it's not clear that they even hit it.
- staunch 5y agoIt's plausible that: 1. Some kind of alien probes have been visiting Earth for millions of years. 2. These probes are very hard to detect/track/capture on camera, leading to lots of unconfirmed rumors since the dawn of modern aviation in the 1940s. 3. U.S. DoD advances over the last ~15 years have made it possible to regularly detect/track/capture them on camera, at least to some degree. 4. Stigma around reporting/acknowledging these craft as alien has stifled the ability of the DoD to investigate them properly, and they're not really sure what they are. 5. Or the DoD has identified them as likely being alien probes of some kind, but have no ability to interact/interdict/intercept them, and so are struggling with the how/when of explaining this fact to the public. Of course, it's more likely that there are no alien probes visiting Earth. This could be next-gen submarine-launched drone technology with radar spoofing and whatever else. The UAP report itself seems to be written by people without without sufficient access to classified information, rendering it totally insufficient.
- neom 5y agoI would also say, one would expect "alien" technology to progress over time. If you agreed with that, it's not inconceivable they would become more and and more difficult to observe as they observe us. You'd also have to think about distances and time passed, I'd imagine if you can travel with extreme competency in space, you're probably also able to use time in some interesting ways? Of course, it's more likely that there are no alien probes visiting Earth.
- spywaregorilla 5y ago> I would also say, one would expect "alien" technology to progress over time. No it's not. An alien civilization that can travel across galaxies to send probes to observe humanity is already hugely more advanced than ours. Modern civilization is only a couple thousand years old depending on your definition. A random alien civilization that is more advanced than us is likely to be thousands of years more advanced. Are they really going to develop new tech that beats our advancements that they didn't already have, over the course of 50 years, that they didn't capture in the 3,000 year headstart? Sounds doubtful.
- wydfre 5y agoI think UFOs are a symptom of a stratocracy gone rampant. In this book[0] it details the Tehran incident[1] where one of the pilots describes the UFO moving almost 'telepathically' out of the way of his sites. Gives me hope that it's an autonomous control system America developed. If it's still 'people-in-the-loop' I might as well shoot myself; I seriously think my only hope for a better life (and for a lot of others who complain about psychotronic things) depends on a nation-state artilect having either pity for me or curiosity about the sorbid motives of others. [0]: UFOs: Generals, Pilots, and Government Officials Go on the Record [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1976_Tehran_UFO_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1976_Tehran_UFO_incident
- nabla9 5y agoNo matter how many leaps sensory technology makes, no matter how many more satellites, SAR radars, IR sensors, amateur astronomers able to count meteors the size of tennis ball entering the atmosphere, mobile phones, outside cameras in wide-body aircraft ... you will never seem to get get a clear picture of UFOs. They will always be just a smudge or there will be an alternate explanation. Decade after decade. Amazing.
- aaron695 5y agoNeil deGrasse Tyson @neiltyson - "How to turn most UFOs into IFOs: Take one course in Stargazing, another in Atmospheric Phenomena, and a third in Cognitive Bias." > “probably do represent physical objects” I simply do not believe this. I'm happy to believe the one case of a balloon was true, I believe there could be a few other cases like plastic bags. But it's almost always optical illusions with stars and man made lights. There's no other secret aircraft, there's mostly no X-Files 'weather balloons', there's no St. Elmo's fire or drones. It's stars and satellites and ship lights and far away aircraft lights and house lights and car lights. We will have to see if they release the data claiming they have 'multiple' sources confirming physical objects. If you want to 'believe' the government they are 'physical objects' I guess that is more fun. Report - https://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/reports-publications/reports-publications-2021/item/2223-preliminary-assessment-unidentified-aerial-phenomena https://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/reports-publications/...
- api 5y agoWell hey, one possible answer to the Fermi paradox is that there isn’t one.
- jedberg 5y agoI'm glad they were keeping these secret. Some of these have to be advanced technologies from foreign forces. By releasing the footage and saying "we don't know what these are" they just confirmed to the creator that their craft is indeed fooling our sensors. That's not a great thing to share with your adversary.
- ericmay 5y agoMore likely to be advanced technologies from U.S. forces than it would be adversaries. My own hypothesis is that until I get evidence otherwise I’m going to assume that this is U.S. military capability being shown off to other world powers.
- jedberg 5y agoPerhaps. It would be an interesting subterfuge.
- aww_dang 5y agoIf you want to go down this road, it is also worth considering it as a bluff. Inventing a spectacle is just as good, if not better.
- ericmay 5y agoYea you're 100% right. I would say if I could take what you said and what I said, it's most likely to me to be some kind of operation by the U.S. military to some end. Possibilities include (but not limited to) self-testing, maybe a bluff, maybe a psy-op, or maybe an advanced capability demo.
- blhack 5y agoOr: these are advanced drones from a foreign adversary, and we want them to think we have no idea what they are. It’s just unreasonable to guess intentions here without the full picture (which we don’t have).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- akyu 5y agoWith things like these I think it's helpful to look at what is being done, not just what is being said. In line with the provisions of Senate Report 116-233, accompanying the IAA for FY 2021, the UAPTF’s long-term goal is to widen the scope of its work to include additional UAP events documented by a broader swath of USG personnel and technical systems in its analysis. As the dataset increases, the UAPTF’s ability to employ data analytics to detect trends will also improve. The initial focus will be to employ artificial intelligence/machine learning algorithms to cluster and recognize similarities and patterns in features of the data points. Maybe leaning into the aliens angle a little bit is just a way to get funding for this type of thing. "AI surveillance grid" is probably a bit of a hard sell to congress without the added threat implications. That said, if it really is aliens, you'd probably want this same kind of technology all the same, so it doesn't strictly rule anything out. Overall I have to say I'm undecided for the moment, but it certainly is interesting. If I'm going to speculate though, I think the most likely scenario is there is some really advanced capabilities in the US arsenal, and this is a pre-emptive measure to anticipate adversaries playing catch up. If you have craft that can do what is being asserted, or even just a healthy fraction of those capabilities, it really becomes an information and surveillance game.
- blocked_again 5y agoThe biggest argument against Aliens is that, any civilizations which has technology capable of travel at the speed of light, would have developed almost real life like VR. And no point in traveling all the way physically to another planet when you can experience it in VR from your home planet. Also there would be so many artificial worlds that are way too interesting than the physical universe. Plus by that point the civilization would be so advanced, the beings would no longer be tied to legacy biological physical bodies. They would be living in the "cloud". And would probably does not give a shit about Physical beings like us.
- gentleman11 5y agoThere would never be any need to expand for resources, or flee from environmental damage? Or study alien civilizations? Maybe the ufos are just grad students
- Fej 5y agoThis video cemented my skepticism on the topic: https://youtu.be/Hv-sbtCAz9Y https://youtu.be/Hv-sbtCAz9Y Regarding one of the phenomena, > So the options are this object has the ability to warp the space around it, which admittedly would be really cool, or the camera rotated.
- pmkiwi 5y agoWas reading this article recently -> https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/05/10/how-the-pentagon-started-taking-ufos-seriously https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/05/10/how-the-pentag... and as always with The New Yorker, it is very interesting and informative.