19 ms·
YouTube takes down Xinjiang videos, forcing rights group to seek alternative
- ipython 5y agoAnd yet these platforms are actively disseminating Chinese propaganda about the issue: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/06/22/technology/xinjiang-uyghurs-china-propaganda.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/06/22/technology/xi...
- systemvoltage 5y agoI have a hunch that a lot of division in the US atleast has some role or interference from Russia/China. No proof, but to me it makes sense and it is so easy to do, we've seen it happen in the past (Cambridge Analytica), and if I were an adversary of the United States, I would be trivial to sow discord amongst the populace. We're currently witnessing some fractures in the US military leadership as well. I don't mean to sound conspiratory, but I guess I kinda do. We're going to have a hard time getting along with each other in the future. It is going to get worse. :-( I also fear closing down our open platforms, so it is a lose-lose situation. Reminds me of the white doves and hawks analogy from Richard Dawnkins' Selfish Gene. Until there are too many hawks, the doves suffer. Btw, this has nothing to do with good/evil, just exploitation of social settings where trust is the default state. Too many hawks and the population starves so it reaches an equilibrium, but also oscillates over evolutionary time scales.
- Enginerrrd 5y agoCan you elaborate on the fractures in militrlary leadership you mentioned? Or point me to somewhere I can learn more?
- systemvoltage 5y agoTom Cotton is challenging the CRT take in the military citing some divisions between 'conservates' and 'liberal' members of the military raised by whistleblowers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZtgnIXnvxlw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZtgnIXnvxlw Also, in the recent news, many conservates are calling off General Milley after his rather heated exchange with Gaetz. I am sure you can find the source.
- the_third_wave 5y agoI suppose the parent poster referred to the recent spat related to a navy admiral who advised troops to read Ibram Kendi's book advocating racism under the guise of anti-racism [1]. There have been more such clashes but this is one of the most visible examples. If this divisive ideology really gets a hold on the US armed forces it will be an enormous boon for potential opponents since it will demoralise troops just as effectively as it managed to demoralise police forces all over the USA. The results of the latter can be seen clearly by the number of officers deciding to quit and the increase in crime rates all over the USA. We can only hope that the former will not become apparent - and I'm saying this as a European. The USA exports its culture quite effectively to our parts of the world, both the good parts as well as the bad. The latter category includes a bevy of critical theory spin-offs which have grown like wildfire in academia from where they managed to escape into the real world where they're wreaking havoc. While it is clear that these movements are self-extinguishing due to their dependence on an ever-increasing number of identity groups vying for a position in the oppression hierarchy the amount of damage they can do - and have already done - to societal cohesion is enormous. [1] https://www.dailywire.com/news/watch-fiery-explosive-challenge-to-navy-admiral-for-recommending-critical-race-theory-book-for-every-sailor https://www.dailywire.com/news/watch-fiery-explosive-challen...
- commoner 5y agoHere's some evidence to support your hunch about Russia: > Across our interviews, our respondents [former and current RT journalists] agreed that the goals of the channel [RT] since 2008 have been and still are as follows. First, to push the idea that Western countries have as many problems as Russia. Second, to encourage conspiracy theories about media institutions in the West in order to discredit and delegitimize them. This is clearly adherent to the channel's “Questions More” slogan. Third, to create controversy and to make people criticize the channel, because it suggests that the channel is important, an approach that would particularly help RT managers get more funding from the government. -- “Anything that Causes Chaos”: The Organizational Behavior of Russia Today (RT), https://academic.oup.com/joc/article/70/5/623/5912109 https://academic.oup.com/joc/article/70/5/623/5912109
- hindsightbias 5y agoI haven’t looked at RT recently, but I didnt see conspiracy talk. I never saw a truther debate there. RT doesn’t have to lie at all to document many of the problems in the west. It was usually what should be Capt. Obvious stuff, stories not covered in the US media, Syria/Iraq/Afghanistan coverage, Snowden and Assange (take off the RT logo and the HN crowd would be orgasming to it), stories of racial inequality, financial fraud, crazy defense budgets, etc. I suppose giving Commies like Chris Hedges and Noam Chomskys of the world a platform (that they can’t get in US media) is some noxious evil compared to mainlining on MSNBC or Fox. Propaganda can be 100% true, and from what I remember, they were quite good at it.
- commoner 5y ago> The channel [RT] has provided the likes of Alex Jones, Webster Tarpley, David Ray Griffin and Jim Marrs with the opportunity to promote, to an international audience, their ideas about the New World Order, 9/11, the Bilderberg group or the climate change conspiracy, all while being treated with absolute deference by the channel's journalists. Embedded video clips of appearances on Russia Today have become a regular feature on the websites of American conspiracy theorists, where they are brandished as a sign of credibility and mainstream recognition. -- Conspiracy Theories: A Critical Introduction, https://www.google.com/books/edition/Conspiracy_Theories/e0ilsF4VcTQC https://www.google.com/books/edition/Conspiracy_Theories/e0i...
- tiahura 5y agoOf course Russia and China are spreading it. If they’re not spreading disinformation in the US, then what in the world are their intelligence services doing to earn their paychecks? The US needs to IP blacklist Russia and China. If you do business in the US, you shouldn’t be able to connect to a network that is connected to Russia or China. Let the European and Asian backbone providers choose, do business with US businesses or Russia / China.
- DubiousPusher 5y ago> Of course Russia and China are spreading it. You know the US has and does do this too right?
- tiahura 5y agoOf course - I’m not making any sort of moral declaration. I’m just amused at those who aren’t sure if Russia and China are poisoning Facebook - if they aren’t some apparatchik should be getting fired.
- DubiousPusher 5y agoFor sure. Facebook is like the Dulles brothers' wet dream.
- bassman9000 5y agoChina has literally a separate Internet, and fines/jails those who use it w/o permission; Russia crushes dissent, to the point of assassinating opposition leaders and incarcerating journos. The US doesn't seem to be as effective in brutal opposition to infiltration. There's no moral equivalent.
- wincy 5y agoIt would be a real bummer to not be able to talk to my cousin in China for the high crime of teaching English in a foreign country.
- 5y ago
- nexus2045 5y agoAll it took to "debunk" the lab leak hypothesis is to call it racism. So easy. I'm sure someone from China must have realized by now how convenient of a "get out of jail free card" this is.
- 8note 5y agoReally it's a classic boy who called wolf situation. If you blame everything on china, people won't want to believe you when there are legitimate things
- _-david-_ 5y agoSurely journalists and fact checkers shouldn't claim something is fake just because the person making the claim has said fake things in the past. If they do then they should be fired for completely failing at their job.
- justicezyx 5y ago> I have a hunch that a lot of division in the US atleast has some role or interference from Russia/China. Haha I have evidences that US interference causes a lot of division inside China. Not a hunch at all. NED, one of the famous 3 letter group. Then you can imagine, China will do the same to US, eventually... But rest assured, China have not mastered the tactics yet.
- unishark 5y agoWhat agenda is the US interference pursuing? Some agendas could be positive things for the country, like supporting pro-democracy movements. Meanwhile, as for mastering tactics, all China has to do is similarly support activists and opposition groups financially by funneling them cash. It's quite likely they do so in all their rivals. There was a scandal decades ago with China giving campaign contributions to US politicians.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoThis is my unscientific hunch as well. It's easy for hordes of fake accounts to add gasoline to hot issues online and people fall for it. Get things trending that otherwise wouldn't. It's cheap as hell too compared to a military industrial complex. It's interesting you're being downvoted along with the parent post about foreign propaganda.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIn 2018, I was one barraged by about 200 comments in the span of less than an hour in reply to my reply to a story on r/news about someone hitting a protestor with their car. For reference, I objected to violence against protestors. The hundreds of replies were a variation of about three talking points: that people should be afraid of protestors, that the protestors will kill you, and that killing them first is justified. They were posting things like "What if the protestors drag you out of your car?", "If protestors bang on my windows trying to kill me I'm going to run them over" and or "If you stop your car, the protestors will kill you" etc. They also replied to other posts about the same topic on Reddit with the same talking points. The posts used the same few phrases and the same punctuation and style. They would delete their comments if a comment's karma went negative and then reply to me again. Many of the accounts had similar naming patterns, and no other comments in their history, as well. r/news requires a certain amount of karma in order to comment, so they had to have deleted their old comments before replying in that subreddit. I revisited the post and accounts a few days later and saw that some of the account owners had deleted their accounts entirely, and a majority of them had deleted (and not removed by a moderator) their violence-instigating replies to my comment, too. I figure some of them did this to keep the karma and recycle the accounts, and deleted the comments so they can be used in the future without it looking weird or getting banned. I suspect it was coordinated in some way, even if it was just a bunch of people in a Discord chat. But what stuck with me was that there is a somewhat large group of people who want (other) Americans to die. They want people to respond to free speech and dissent with murder. They want people to be afraid of what other people will do to them if they speak up and organize. They want people to fear each other so much that they can justify murder with that fear.
- 5y ago
- bassman9000 5y agoYour hunch is right https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/report-blm-co-founder-lobbying-wing-funded-by-pro-communist-china-group/ar-BB194KVe https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/report-blm-co-founder-l... The co-founder of Black Lives Matter, Alicia Garza, partnered with a pro-Chinese Communist Party group to fund its lobbying operations in the United States.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoThis is a good article. Thanks for sharing.
- jimbob45 5y agoI can understand the copyright stuff because Google can’t possibly afford the fight against the MPAA/RIAA. Why wade into politics though? What gain does Google obtain through political censorship?
- tpmx 5y agoPretty sure they're still trying really hard to get GCP functional in mainland China, somehow. You know, like how Amazon/AWS made it: https://www.amazonaws.cn/en/ https://www.amazonaws.cn/en/
- LordOfWolves 5y agoI’m going to take a guess that perhaps it has to do with Google’s ability to continue to commercially operate in China. Perhaps X leadership from Google spoke with Y leadership from China and reached this compromise in order to avoid a potential all-out ban of Google’s services in China, similar to - though nowhere close to the same reasoning behind - the US’ ban of Huawei telecommunications equipment. PLEASE NOTE that this is purely conjecture. I am not affiliated with Google or China, in any way, shape, or form. This should not be taken as fact.
- DubiousPusher 5y agoI would guess also that it has to do with "normalizing" relationships with China as well. Every country has skeletons in its closet. And every government seeks to rationize and minimize those skeletons as much as possible. As a country gains stake in mefia institutions, those institutions internalize some of the propaganda of that country.
- kmonsen 5y agoThis skeleton is not in the closet, it’s on the front yard and still being punched in the face every day. Meaning they have not stopped oppressing which is needed for it to be a skeleton in the closet.
- 5y ago
- mc32 5y agoI'm sure YT is going to trot out some stock reason for not re-instating the videos. But this is pathetic. When YT goes on a bandwagon for some cause or other, this doesn't happen, but it appears to happen when the politics don't align with either their own politics or may offend one of their markets or their sponsors. So, I guess it's their platform and they can do what they want, but there is a danger that this will tilt one-way and leave no room for this kind of dissent. And that is a great loss. I hope they grow a conscience but I rather doubt it.
- imglorp 5y agoThis is kind of a new thing for society though. We used to have many media outlets, corporations, and governments. Now most media outlets are owned by a very few corporations, and they are tightly entangled with government interests globally.
- tehwebguy 5y agoYouTubers have no alternative platform for their content if they want ads but advertisers have new options every month when another TV network drops a streaming app. The incentives are super clear.
- codeecan 5y ago> it's their platform and they can do what they want this is not true for monopolies, AT&T can't disconnect your line because they don't like what you're saying on your calls.
- azinman2 5y agoI’m certain they can for your Internet if they don’t like your packets. But in either situation, phone calls are not analogous because they’re 1:1. YouTube is about public broadcast. You also don’t pay for their service to host your videos.
- adventured 5y agoIdeally the parent's comment is forward hopeful. As in, in the near future big tech will be shackled as Ma Bell was, and then carved up. Several of the big tech monsters started a fight they can't win with half of the country that now absolutely hates them (and will at one time or another control vast amounts of political power), and the other half which still wants to see them restricted anyway. The question is how far the Feds and states will go in curbing big tech's abuses on eg cancel culture and content censorship, given the various monopoly positions of these companies. Florida's law on deplatforming is a small, correct first step. Texas is guaranteed to follow, and a lot more restrictions will follow after that. The notion that they can do whatever they want with their monopoly platforms, is already probably not an accurate premise. In the near future, it will definitely not be. We're in about inning one of laying down innumerable restrictions on what big tech can do with their platforms. The odds are quite high the regulators will in fact go further than they should over time, severely damaging the US tech economy. The free-run days for big tech are very clearly over. They're merely too arrogant to recognize it. What was the last major acquisition by Facebook? There are three other prominent US social networks out there with a collective $200b in market cap now. Everything Facebook has is very stale, boring. Instagram is a giant yawn at this point, it's old, increasingly boring and lame. Which is why young people flocked to TikTok so quickly. Facebook has been de facto barred for a long time from eating any of their major competitors. All that money piling up to the ceiling and FB can't even use it to further their monopoly, and they know it. The party is largely over, although big tech will continue to drift for a while on enormous momentum. If Amazon were smart, they'd be in the process of spinning off AWS right now, to unshackle it from so much anti-trust attention that the parent draws, to get far out in front of that. That's guaranteed to happen within the ten or so years after the Bezos era regardless. Google could probably do the same with YouTube, but they'll aggressively fight against that (Amazon will willingly spin off AWS as their stock stagnates, in the typical unlock shareholder value move).
- kemonocode 5y agoConspiracy nuts and other unsavory members from fringe communities do make for odd bedfellows when one is being actively censored, thus why I am loathe to promote Bitchute et al. Best second alternative would be their own Peertube instance, but that of course requires them to put up their own infrastructure.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoDo you want freedom or authoritarianism?
- briefcomment 5y agoWhat about Odysee (LBRY) [1]? Seems promising. [1]https://odysee.com https://odysee.com
- devetec 5y agoAlso filled with many nuts, though I wish more people would actually use it. It's a very good alternative to YouTube though.
- HNfriend234 5y agoThe conspiracy nuts are crazy, I agree, but they are also opposed to oppression so they are our allies. Be wary of the "divide and conquer" strategy when it is being used by oppressive regimes and various governments.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoIt's not a conspiracy, if they're really out to get you.
- jackfoxy 5y agoQ: What's the difference between fake news / conspiracy theories and the real news? A: About 8 months. Sure this joke is an exaggeration, but occurrences like this seem to be getting more common. Sometimes it's much longer than 8 months. The informed reader can fill in the blanks. One very big problem is YT and other content providers intentionally provide recommendations to reinforce confirmation biases of the viewer. If you click a few wacky conspiracy videos you will start seeing more in your feed. If you click fact and logic based alternate videos, you will start seeing confirmations of this particular view point, but no factual/logical discussions from opposing viewpoints. What's worse, inevitably you will start seeing references to censorship in your favorite topics. This feels very much like a political agenda on the part of big tech content providers. In any event it is clear the algorithm is not interested in healthy reasonable discussion and debate to further democracy.
- economusty 5y agoAll Google and Alphabet current and former employees and investors are the creators of these tools used by evil.
- contravariant 5y agoI imagine some of them (though not all) would be quite upset about that. That said this looks like a mostly manual act, so if you seek to assign blame then you should look elsewhere.
- marcinzm 5y agoYour point being? In the end anything and everything you do may end being used for evil by someone else. Even if you're a hermit in the woods, one day someone may use your old discarded axe to kill someone.
- perihelions 5y agoRemarkable that they're migrating to a decentralized video host: >"Fearing further blocking by YouTube, they decided to back up content to Odysee, a website built on a blockchain protocol called LBRY, designed to give creators more control. About 975 videos have been moved so far." I think this is them? I can't readily verify this (and also everything's written in Kazakh). https://odysee.com/@ATAJURT https://odysee.com/@ATAJURT [late edit] Related HN discussions about the protocol: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12418081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12418081 "LBRY – A decentralized YouTube alternative" (2016) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13928774 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13928774 "Lbry.io – decentralized digital library" (2017) https://hn.algolia.com/?q=LBRY https://hn.algolia.com/?q=LBRY
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoOn one hand, I hate Google for the obvious bullshit they pull and not only get a pass on but are celebrated for typically. On the other hand, they’re accelerating what we all know should happen. Decentralization, restoration of privacy, data freedom, and maybe subscription based moderation and filtering (although to be fair, I’m not sure how that last one doesn’t make a worse echo chamber than we have now over enough time).
- busymom0 5y ago> worse echo chamber Fair criticism however as someone who uses several alternatives to YouTube regularly (Odysee, Rumble, Bitchute etc), I think Odysee has so far been the best in terms of variety of content. Odysee has decent growing number of non-political content which is exactly what's needed to fight YouTube's video monopoly. Also their UI is much better than Rumble and Bitchute. The way to prevent them from becoming echo chambers is by contributing ourselves - upload non political content for variety of topics - cooking, pets etc.
- badsectoracula 5y agoThere isn't much info about LBRY outside of LBRY itself, though the few links i could find didn't paint a good idea. The most concerning is this: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/50tyub/were_the_nerds_behind_lbry_a_decentralized/d76wxv0/ https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/50tyub/were_the_nerds... I wonder why they didn't just go with some Peertube instance.
- ralph84 5y agoNo worries, Google will just sponsor a human rights award and award it to themselves to help them feel better about enabling human rights violations. They have the playbook perfected. [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26880262 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26880262
- DSingularity 5y agoWar is peace.
- maerF0x0 5y agoquote from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four for those unaware
- unanswered 5y agoIgnorance is strength.
- busymom0 5y agoFreedom is slavery.
- yumraj 5y agoOr blame on human error like Microsoft did after the Tank Man/Bing issue.
- gentleman11 5y agoIf anybody wants there to be desktop OS options, they should consider donating to Debian, the fsf, gnome, and/or some other foss project
- 1MachineElf 5y agoHuman error is the default behavior now.
- 5y ago
- nomdep 5y agoFucking cowards
- zarkov99 5y agoSo glad YT keeps protecting me from all the disinformation out there.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoWe're back at the platform vs. publisher debate... I think this should be a either-or thing, that every webpage chooses. Then, you're either a platform, and can only remove directly illegal stuff (or when told by the courts to do so), or a publisher, decide what content you publish and what you remove, and then carry the full responsibility for that content. The current situation, where pages like youtube can act as publishers, and cherry pick what they keep/promote and what they remove, and still keep all the platform protections is really bad, mostly for the users.
- chrischattin 5y agoCompanies that do business with the US .gov should be req’d to apply 1st amendment rights to their users. Much like public universities who receive taxpayer funding.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoPublic universities can kick you out for expressing your 1st amendment right based off of whatever bs reason they want to give just to expel you. Likewise also, teachers can fail you just because they don't like you or you hold certain views. Public universities are as fair about granting your constitutional rights as the US government. At that is, only when you beat them in court.
- slipframe 5y ago> Public universities can kick you out for expressing your 1st amendment right based off of whatever bs reason they want to give just to expel you. Yeah, and a company can fire you for being black if they give a bs excuse for it too. In both of these cases your rights are being violated and you can sue them for that. What's the alternative? I can't conceive of a system where it's impossible for your rights to be violated; giving legal recourse to the victim seems like the best we can do.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago
- 8458e112e7b2 5y agoTheir platform, their rules. If the rights group needs to publish videos, they should create their own platform.
- gspr 5y ago> Their platform, their rules. Sure. Doesn't make them immune from criticism. So here's criticsm: go to hell you fucking apologists for genocidal maniacs!
- hyperdunc 5y agoThey shouldn't have this much power in the first place. The fact they have a platform that captures basically an entire market is a feature of corporate-applied technology and a failure of the political system. But that's where we are, and after this incident we'll merely negatively adjust our perceptions of Google and continue to use their services.
- Gustomaximus 5y agoUnder this logic should we remove regulation from banks? Should companies not be subject to workplace rules? Companies that interact with society need regulation as does YouTube. Its going to be hard to balance the freedom of expression vs what is harmful. In what is a grey zone I feel encouraging violence is the best line, and letting the courts sort out defamation.
- ALittleLight 5y agoWhen I think of moral dilemmas I think of hard problems like "Would you stand up to the Nazis even though they might execute you?" or "Would you escape North Korea though they might punish your family?" It's depressing to realize how weak the dilemmas need to be in real life to get almost everyone to go down the immoral path. "Would you tacitly support genocide if your employer bought you lunch?"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jlawer 5y agoHow long until google’s PR team is replaced by an AI
- tomcam 5y agotoo late
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Aunche 5y agoPredictable outrage towards big tech is predictable. HN doesn't care when YouTube host thousands of videos from a human rights group with over a hundred million views. However, when they remove a dozen of them and promise to reinstate them if they blur out some PII, HN treats it like it's 1984.
- strangeattractr 5y agoWhat a completely facile comparison. They earn money by plastering ads over user submitted content. Hosting those videos is hardly some act of social conscience, why would they be owed praise in addition to the advertising revenues they receive. It's hardly prescient to predict outrage when one of the largest companies in the world that wields almost unparalleled control over the information consumed by people decides to censor content about human rights abuses.
- Aunche 5y ago> Hosting those videos is hardly some act of social conscience, why would they be owed praise in addition to the advertising revenues they receive. If you treat them as neutral pursuers of profit for doing something "good", then, it's only fair to treat them as neutral pursuers of profit when they do something "evil". Let me remind that that early on, internet companies were all almost completely pro-free speech. It's the viewers that demanded that YouTube censor things or else they would tweet bomb companies into pulling ads from them. They wanted a nanny, so they shouldn't react surprised when Google acts like a nanny.
- strangeattractr 5y agoYes exactly, they are pursuers of profit. When they host the videos it merely aligns with their profit motives. When they block something it is because it interferes with their profit motives. I have no issue with this whatsoever, it's what I expect. I'm curious how this negates the criticism of them rather than enhances the case for it? We cannot trust Google to behave in the public interest (information about human rights abuses qualifies in my mind) when it conflicts with their own interests. Hence people's dismay over the amount of control they wield over the distribution of information. Do you think a news org that wiped coverage of Uighur repression from its site to protect its business in China wouldn't face similar outrage? And they wield significantly less power than Google does. Tech companies in particular like to present themselves as enlightened and socially conscious. Hardly surprising that when the mask slips people are outraged.
- catillac 5y agoI’m kind of curious here: if I were creating any service or running any group that had any chance of getting taken down completely from my provider (versus in the SRE sense of high availability), I would have multiple options on standby at the ready at all times, ready to deploy. This seems obvious, am I missing something here?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoSome groups are further along in their operational model and opsec journey than others.
- clarkmoody 5y agoImagine the dirt the tech giants have on all government officials on the planet. Imagine if the tech giants went on a human rights offensive against the state.
- slipframe 5y agoI hope they don't get into the habit of blackmailing politicians when the cause is just. For one, because Google's perception of justice may not always be right. For another, because once they get into that habit, once they have established the methods and procedures for doing it, could we really trust them to not abuse this tool simply for their own profit?
- mylons 5y agoBREAK UP GOOGLE, FOR FUCK’S SAKE. The censorship power they enjoy, and the knee bending to the CCP is unreal. They roll over faster than Hitler appeasers pre WW2.
- justicezyx 5y agoI have issue with the laziness of the report regarding the Xinjiang genocide reporting. The whole article is centered on this statement: """ where UN experts and rights groups estimate over a million people have been detained in recent years. """ The UN experts and right groups are not named. But I assume it was Adrian Zenz who was throughly discredited in [1] and the so-called evidences are from satalie images analyzed by non professional intelligence analyst like Ms. Xu Xiuzhong [2] who by all means have good faith but seriously lacking the credit to command such a large scale political crusade against China. Disclaimer: I was born and raised in China and live in silicone valley for the last 10 years. And I think the current political narrative is from fear of unknown, and CCP needs to adjust it's policy to be more open. But I cannot see any serious evidence of large scale concentration camp. Everything so far presented are no where close to the scale reported, aka 1 million. [1] https://thegrayzone.com/tag/adrian-zenz/ https://thegrayzone.com/tag/adrian-zenz/ [2] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UDkC1ZMFBCg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UDkC1ZMFBCg Edit: > Zenz isn't discredited, it's just the PRC propaganda apparatus is trying its hardest to smear him as part of their coverup. Grayzone has no connection with CCP. And AFAIK, none of the CCP propaganda apparatus actually did any original research to attack Adrian Zenz. All I read is from Grayzone and Daniel Dumbrill, both are providing fact-checked new reporting. Zenz is discredited by Grayzone report. And TBH, I dont think Zenz should be treated as authority in the first place. This guy has not set foot on Xinjiang in his lifetime...
- seppin 5y agoAdrian Zenz has not been "throughly discredited" as you say, quite the opposite. The ad hominem attacks from Chinese bots/trolls (apparently he's a Christian fundamentalist/extremist now) are a pretty good sign that he is reporting on exactly what they don't want reported on. Also please don't link to thegrayzone if you want any further argument to be heard with an open mind. They have a terrible track record of defending authoritarians for political reasons.
- jokethrowaway 5y agohttps://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/meghara/china-new-internment-camps-xinjiang-uighurs-muslims https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/meghara/china-new-inter...
- MangoCoffee 5y ago>The group, credited by international organizations like Human Rights Watch for drawing attention to human rights violations in Xinjiang, has come under fire from Kazakh authorities since its founding in 2017. it seem like a legit group. do Youtube even talk to the group about their video so they have a chance to redo/review the videos? what's the rule here?
- Causality1 5y agoYouTube doesn't care. If society decided to start hating left-handed people YouTube wouldn't hesitate to remove left-handed content. If rape porn was legal and advertiser-friendly YouTube would put it on the front page. It's a perfect sociopath.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoStrange coincidence but I was joking to myself today about how the next woke identity would be left handed people… then I remember Simpsons did it already.
- toomanyrichies 5y agoHonest question- what is Google's exposure here? Both Youtube and Google (Youtube's parent company) are blocked in China; those revenue streams were cut off a long time ago. What does Google have to lose by letting Youtube keep the videos up? I'm sure the exposure exists; I recognize that Googlers aren't stupid. I honestly am just curious what that risk is. Having lived in Shanghai for 5 years, I don't see China reversing their ban on either company anytime soon, so I'm curious what carrot and/or stick China has left. So far, the one thing I can think of is their physical office presence in Beijing / Guangzhou / Hong Kong [0]. That risk is non-trivial- China could simply swoop in and arrest employees, either specific individuals or en masse (neither would surprise me). But are there other risks I'm missing? 0. https://about.google/intl/en_us/locations/?region=asia-pacific https://about.google/intl/en_us/locations/?region=asia-pacif...
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoWant to bet that China has hired Google or their services beyond the ones we’ve been told about previously?
- nom 5y agoThe answer you are looking for is: 1.5 billion people and a GDP with a hockey stick curve
- xkcd-sucks 5y ago"The Industry feeds on biomass"
- paulryanrogers 5y agoManufacturing capacity for Pixel phones?
- echelon 5y agoOnshore it. The government should fund massive investment in factories, then through immigration, bring in lots of labor. Give incredible tax incentives to devices manufactured in full (no loopholes) in the US. Increase the total population of the US. Increase our domestic output.
- gameswithgo 5y agoive canceled my youtube premium
- sprusemoose 5y agoit's generated a lot more press for the videos.. maybe it was a judo move by google
- html5web 5y agoI had to edit my comment
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoWe ban accounts for taking HN threads into flamewar like this. Please either make your substantive points thoughtfully or don't post here. (No, I'm not defending Google. I'm defending HN. Please do better from now on.) https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- LarryEt 5y agoI think the only way to really fight this is to take it to a stupid level. Something like try to take down all videos about aliens on the platform as misinformation. I mean how can we take down all these videos but let videos about aliens be fine with zero proof for the existence of aliens? It is clearly conspiracy theory and misinformation.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoIt's sad to see big tech aligning more and more with this generation's nazis. I guess nazis have more money this time?
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar. I'm sure you can express your substantive views thoughtfully, or your thoughtful views substantively; comments like this are the opposite of that, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- rguiscard 5y agoSo the censorship on China is fine on HN while censorship on Palestine is flagged? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27638871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27638871
- dang 5y agoThat article has been on HN's front page for hours: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27645282 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27645282. Just to be clear, [flagged] on a submission means users flagged it, not moderators. This is in the FAQ: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html. Users flagged your submission (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27638871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27638871), then someone else reposted the article. We turned off flags on the latter. Since yours was the earliest submission of the article, we'd normally have preferred to restore that one, but by the time we saw it that thread was such a wretched tire fire that it was unsalvageable. I explained that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27646075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27646075. Generally it would be best not to rush to dramatic conclusions like "So the X is ok while the Y is Z?" without having all the relevant information. It makes for dramatic internet comments, but they're nearly always wrong.
- rguiscard 5y agoI did not mean to complain the moderators. I just want to draw the comparison to readers. I understand your points and know it is flagged by readers. It shows people intrinsically view things differently, thus, there won’t be fair view in real and virtual world. HN has done a better job than most of platforms already.
- uyghur_rights 5y agoWe archived most of these videos a few months ago fortunately [1]. I used youtube-dl at the time. Anyone who wants to get more involved on this issue, or view primary evidence / testimonials (that weren't taken down), please visit http://shahit.biz/eng/ http://shahit.biz/eng/ [1] https://twitter.com/shahitbiz/status/1405361123931656192?s=19 https://twitter.com/shahitbiz/status/1405361123931656192?s=1...
- zucker42 5y agoSo the stated reason for taking these down is they include the IDs of people who agreed to have their IDs shown in the video? Sounds sort of like some overzealous content moderator misapplying rules, though it could be more malicious. It's pretty bad that YouTube's policies allow this type of stuff to happen.
- SheinhardtWigCo 5y agoA lot of commenters here are suggesting Google took down these videos maliciously, as a conscious political act, or something along those lines. I don’t think so. I think they built a social network that is too big for human moderation, so they opted to do moderation by applying statistical models to user reports. That works great until malicious users work out how to game the system and take down videos they don’t like. So, here we are.
- leeoniya 5y ago> I think they built a social network that is too big for human moderation poetic
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/Vy3Tk https://archive.is/Vy3Tk
- aliyfarah 5y ago>Following inquiries from Reuters as to why the channel was removed, YouTube restored it on June 18, explaining that it had received multiple so-called 'strikes' for videos which contained people holding up ID cards to prove they were related to the missing, violating a YouTube policy which prohibits personally identifiable information from appearing in its content >YouTube asked Atajurt to blur the IDs. But Atajurt is hesitant to comply, the channel's administrator said, concerned that doing so would jeopardize the trustworthiness of the videos. I'm not sure what the issue here is. I don't think Youtube's policy of not allowing PII content is unreasonable.
- vgaldikas 5y agoYeah but what's the issue of posting your own PII? I mean I understand that probably you shouldn't, for various reasons. And posting someone else's PII should absolutely be banned. But if I want to post my ID online, what harm can I make to anyone else?
- nine_k 5y agoNot their own, but that of their missing relatives and friends.
- ByteJockey 5y agoThe only concern I can think of would be holding up someone else's id/a fake id and getting that person arrested by the CCP. It's closer to swatting than PII leakage, but it's the only thing I can come up with.
- jeswin 5y agoI doubt this was YouTube policy, or that it was driven from the top. If it was, we'd have seen a few leaks. This is more likely mass reporting of such content (perhaps organized by State apparatus), exploiting the automated flagging algorithm. In any case, I hope Google takes a stand now.
- 2939223 5y agoIt doesn't require top-down capitulation to the CCP. Much cheaper to infiltrate from the bottom-up. How heavily vetted are those filling the ranks of YouTube's Community Standards teams?
- mylons 5y agoi witnessed the hiring of CCP sympathizers at Twitch. it’s certainly happening at youtube
- jimmydorry 5y agoCare to elaborate any more on the Twitch situation? This is certainly an alarming inditement, as I was not aware of Twitch being big or eyeing the China market.
- dang 5y agoSince it looks like you've created this account just do to political battle on HN, I'm banning it. We ban such accounts because they're not compatible with the mandate of the site. No, it has nothing to do with which particular politics or ideology you're battling for...we really don't care. We just want to have an internet forum that doesn't destroy itself. Please don't create accounts to break HN's guidelines with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sneak 5y agoGoogle wants back in to China, antagonizing the CCP is not on their agenda. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragonfly_(search_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragonfly_(search_engine) > The Dragonfly project was an Internet search engine prototype created by Google that was designed to be compatible with China's state censorship provisions.[1][2][3] The public learned of Dragonfly's existence in August 2018, when The Intercept leaked an internal memo written by a Google employee about the project.[4][5] In December 2018, Dragonfly was reported to have "effectively been shut down" after a clash with members of the privacy team within Google.[6] However, according to employees, work on Dragonfly was still continuing as of March 2019, with some 100 people still allocated to it.[7] > In July 2019, Google announced that work on Dragonfly had been terminated.[8] This project even included a weather widget that took the AQI from a special government server in Beijing instead of the usual sources, so Google would be disseminating the state lies about air quality. Google engineers in the US worked on this, even after Google claimed to have shut down the project.
- georgeburdell 5y agoReddit is doing the same thing. I tried to post this (apparent) forced marriage video, between a Uyghur woman and Han man, to a number of subreddits and it's been auto-removed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lFy5K2NFNlE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lFy5K2NFNlE I'm happy to entertain alternative explanations *I should point out the obvious that this video has remained on Youtube
- samspenc 5y agoReddit has been removing posts critical of the CCP for a while now, in their case, Tencent did do a massive investment in them in 2019: https://techcrunch.com/2019/02/11/reddit-300-million/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/02/11/reddit-300-million/ ("Reddit confirms $300M Series D led by China's Tencent at $3B Value")
- strogonoff 5y agoI'm glad BBC perseveres reporting on Xinjang, paying no mind to the armies of troll commenters. I imagine YouTube can't be as easily coaxed into taking down a video by a more established outlet like that.
- gre 5y agoThere's a statistic that polled Americans with 83% "approving of action against China" [1] if covid was made in a Chinese lab. This story was floated early during covid and rejected, but because the US is trying to manufacture consent for action against China it's gotten a second wind. Also the Adrian Zenz "genocide" is part of the same attempt. Don't fall for it. [1] https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/556740-poll-83-percent-support-us-action-against-china-if-wuhan-lab https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/556740-pol...
- elefanten 5y agoAdrian Zenz’s work is a generation-leading project in uncovering human rights violations and promoting human freedom. Your empty pot shot notwithstanding.
- gre 5y agoRead some of this stuff and report back! https://www.hexbear.net/post/2361/comment/17793 https://www.hexbear.net/post/2361/comment/17793
- elefanten 5y agoI’ve seen this kind of crap all over Twitter and other social media. Always these galaxy brain compilation threads that rely on the reader not clicking any links. It’s loosely cobbled together, spurious trash. Eg- first section, the “investigations” are heavily stage-managed by CCP guides, just like WHO/Wuhan. They usually look at some one specific place, like the World Bank covering it’s ass on a particular vocational school project it funded. These threads are always full of holes, broken logic and twisted context. But Zenz hardly matters. There’s far too many sources and data streams from others for this to hinge on Zenz.
- TheWill 5y agoEveryone on YouTube should migrate over to https://odysee.com/ https://odysee.com/
- sneak 5y agoDon't save your outrage here until they start taking down videos of human rights abuses in the USA, too. Google delenda est
- nomoreplease 5y agoGoogle is known for its activist employees. Will they stand up to fight this? Will they demand the leadership reverse this?
- bamboozled 5y agoLikely, most of the activist employees have moved on, or been moved on by now.
- npv789 5y agothis is so wrong!! fcuk google
- bamboozled 5y agoYoutube is absolutely on fire lately. This and banning information about proven lifesaving treatments for Covid19 such as Ivermectin [1] and suppressing information about unintended side effects of Covid19 vaccines is pretty freaking scary. Actually makes me feel quite threatened and uneasy. [1] https://covid19criticalcare.com/ https://covid19criticalcare.com/
- mkolodny 5y agoIf you work at YouTube/Google, and you have the opportunity to do something about this, I hope that you get those videos back up on YouTube. The Uighur people need our help. That's one way you can help them.
- n_ary 5y agoThis is really sad. Google wants in on China, so these kinds of things build "good will"(??) for Google with China government. However, it is most unfortunate for the video authors as most alternatives are practically useless(for intent): - filled with spam, fake news, fluff[1] - no audience[2] - no moderation[3] [1] is due to [3] as moderation is tough. The important videos need [2] to have maximum outreach, but due to [1], they get mixed up and dismissed as other conspiracy theories posted on most alternatives that YT kicked out. Building a proper audience for alternatives is tough, as there is no momentum. We live in a dystopia already, to average joe, internet is FB, Google, TikTok(?), Instagram, Twitter, Whatsapp, Skype, Chrome and those few government websites they need to fill forms now and then. The monopoly capital has been built, people are now stuck. We have plenty great alternatives, but first mover's momentum is of epic proportions. [Edit: Found contents on Odysee]
- rutherblood 5y agoHonest question: is everyone a bitch of the CCP these days?
- EMM_386 5y agoIt seems highly likely that these videos were "reported" to YouTube (this could have been from a state initiative or otherwise) and the videos were reviewed by a human somewhere whos job it is to read a rule book and see if it applies. And they get removed because they broke one rule or another. This is the same as the process for any other video. > it had received multiple so-called 'strikes' for videos which contained people holding up ID cards to prove they were related to the missing, violating a YouTube policy which prohibits personally identifiable information from appearing in its content.
- joelwat 5y agoGoogle has come a long way since their "Don't be evil" days. Google is evil now. They have no morals anymore. They don't care about people. Only money, which is all too common.
- kderbyma 5y agoI have made it my goal to stop using Google services as much as possible. I will never buy another Google product. they have lost my trust completely.
- powerapple 5y agoI love how journalists choose pictures for their article, always so intelligently done.
- amai 5y agoWhy does Google have an office in Beijing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RhodoGSA 5y agowhat happened to larry page and brin? Have they been pushed out?