13 ms·
Every thread that's ever about US housing construction, some Europeans chime in to talk about how strange it seems to them to build houses out of wood, rather t
by crazygringo 5y ago
Every thread that's ever about US housing construction, some Europeans chime in to talk about how strange it seems to them to build houses out of wood, rather than stone/brick/etc that, as you put it, will "last for a very long time".
Here's the thing, though: most Europeans seem to be suffering some pretty serious misconceptions.
First, Americans build out of wood because we have wood, lots of it. Europeans don't skip wood because brick or stone is superior -- it's because Europe is largely deforested. Europe doesn't have wood for people to use at the same scale.
Second, wooden houses last a plenty long time. "80-150+ years", as you put it, is entirely expected for a well-constructed wooden house. Neighborhoods that date from, say, 1850, e.g. in New England, have plenty of old wooden homes that people adore because of their character.
Third, wood construction has a ton of advantages. Not only is it less expensive to build, but it's tremendously more energy-efficient when filled with insulation. Brick and stone homes are absolute energy guzzlers both in hot summers and cold winters. And remember, e.g. in New York State you're dealing with 100°F (38°C) summers and -10°F (-23°C) winters. Insulation matters.
The idea that American homes are somehow lower quality or shorter-lasting because they're built out of wood is a myth through and through. To the contrary, they're built out of wood because that's the best construction for local climate and availability.
- newguy886 5y agoROTFL
- zdragnar 5y agoInsulation does matter, but American insulation is also pretty strange- it is all rated by R value, which is only meaningful if you have a really good airtight seal. Any drafting ruins the insulative value very quickly. Aerated concrete doesn't have that issue, because the concrete cells are closed and don't draft. If you end up with a poorly fitted window or 50+ mph winds, it doesn't let air through. OTOH, totally agree about wood. Cheap(er), plentiful, and most importantly, everyone already knows how to work it and has the tools to do so. Masonry work is physically harder, requires a sounder foundation that won't settle at all due to the increased weight, and there are fewer people willing to do the work. Getting anyone to do foam or aircrete is impossible- you have to watch a bunch of YouTube videos and DIY it yourself.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Insulation does matter, but American insulation is also pretty strange- it is all rated by R value, which is only meaningful if you have a really good airtight seal. You're not wrong, but IMHO the two should be handled separately. The fact that airtightness has been less stringent in the US is mostly an accident of history, which is being improved with recent building codes. It's just that in the past it was easy for people to simply buy some fluffy stuff and stuff it into the walls: doing blower door tests is a lot more complicated. Building science has also progressed quite rapidly in the last 2-3 decades, and we now 'know better' in many areas than in the past. > Aerated concrete doesn't have that issue, because the concrete cells are closed and don't draft. If you end up with a poorly fitted window or 50+ mph winds, it doesn't let air through. First: what's the carbon footprint of concrete? What is footprint of wood framing? Not letting air through (in or out) is actually what you want. The structures of buildings should not pass any air at all ideally, and all air exchanges should be done primarily via mechanical means: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIcrXut_EFA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIcrXut_EFA
- zdragnar 5y agoI should edit that- I meant that even with a poorly fitted window or 50+ mile winds, the closed cell nature of the concrete doesn't let air circulate through it, while fiberglass does. Such is, my point was that foam boards and concrete are compared to blown / rolled fiberglass, even though the fiberglass has more failure modes for insulating. A poorly fitted window will seriously compromise the R value of the surrounding fiberglass. As for the carbon footprint of cement, solid is pretty high, foam not so much. I don't know about commercial stuff, but most DIY'ers seem to use a little under 100 lbs portland cement to make a 55 gallon barrel's worth once the foam is mixed in. Rough math puts a 55 gallon barrel of concrete at about 1000 pounds. Edit: I just realized that 10% seems low, so what I saw may have used a 55 gallon barrel but not completely filled it. In any case, depending on the structural integrity that you need, the weight reduction (and therefore carbon footprint from curing) is significantly reduced.
- icoder 5y agoWe're living in an airtight, concrete, triple glazed house in europe with mechanical ventilation with heat exchange, plus heat pump on a ground source for heating amd (moderate) cooling. It's amazing, temperature is great 24/7 year round. Having said that, your point about footprint holds and building with wood is coming 'back' here especially because of that, using cross laminated timber from sustainable forests.
- manmal 5y agoUnfortunately, while it’s definitely possible to insulate wood houses, it’s often not done [1]. As a result, more than half of energy use at home is spent on temperature control [2]. Yes, European homes are also underinsulated, but bricks provide better insulation per default. I agree about European deforestation. Wood from the Russian Taiga and the Amazon are illegally imported as a result, that’s so embarrassing and wrong. I did list specially treated wood in the list of building materials btw, you might have overlooked that. I agree that wood can be a great material for building modern houses, when combined with other materials. Homes purely made of wood would be too unsafe for me personally (fire hazard, termites in the US, high susceptibility to outside forces). 1: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ninety-percent-of-us-homes-are-under-insulated-300151277.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ninety-percent-of-u... 2: https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/homes.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/homes.php
- sgerenser 5y agoBuilding codes require relatively decent insulation and air sealing almost everywhere in the U.S. Builders do like to cut corners on things the homeowner can’t see, but in most areas code enforcement is not lax enough to allow insulation that doesn’t meet code.
- CapitalistCartr 5y agoAt least in Florida, modern building codes of the past couple decades requires excellent insulation. The reason for so many houses being under-insulated (a separate issue from uninsulated) is because most houses are older. For the very reason you started with, houses last for many decades. It also matters how one determines under-insulated. Energy here is cheap; we use big trucks as commuter cars. Using half our electricity for heating and cooling didn't matter until CO² usage became important; now it's huge.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Unfortunately, while it’s definitely possible to insulate wood houses, it’s often not done [1]. "Ninety Percent of U.S. Homes Are Under Insulated" Yes, because Ninety Percent of U.S. Homes Were Built With Old(er) Building Codes. > Yes, European homes are also underinsulated, but bricks provide better insulation per default. A lot of Europe is a lot more temperate than the US and Canada, so it didn't make much of a difference. I'm in Toronto, Canada, and we regularly get -15C winter weather as well as >30C (>80% RH) summer days too. To stay comfortable you really need heating and cooling. Many buildings in the EU don't have cooling (which has caused all sorts of problems during heat waves). The US has eight climate zones (AK not shown): * https://www.ecohome.net/guides/3521/climate-zones-map-usa-canada-construction/ https://www.ecohome.net/guides/3521/climate-zones-map-usa-ca... And while a lot of the construction techniques would be the same regardless of location (e.g., air tightness), other things would not (insulation, HVAC equipment).
- sgerenser 5y agoWish I had more than one upvote to give. There’s a definite trend of Europeans looking puzzlingly at things that Americans do differently and assuming it must be due to some combination of stupidity and greed. Admittedly somethings may fall under that umbrella but homebuilding with wood is not one of them.
- joe_the_user 5y agoThere’s a definite trend of Europeans looking puzzlingly at things that Americans do differently and assuming it must be due to some combination of stupidity and greed. I'm an American and I look at the things we do and they seem to be a combination of stupidity and greed. You can look at strongtowns.org and many other places for a summary of the illogical, unsustainable and short-term-greed fueled quality of American urbanism.
- icoder 5y agoMany will see there are differences, there will be some puzzledness involved by part of those but I think there's little % left that then jump to conclusions about stupidity and greed.
- eloff 5y agoIts not just the insulative value, stone and concrete also have thermal mass, which can keep you cooler in summer and warmer in winter. Some types of construction like rammed earth or hempcrete exploit this on purpose. Wood frame houses don't have that.
- dahfizz 5y agoThermal mass is not always a good thing. High thermal mass is helpful in a temperate climates where winter nights are chilly and summer days are warm, but the average temperature all year is comfortable. We don't have that in most of America. Having a high thermal mass in New England just means your heater has to work harder in the winter to heat your thermally massive house. Ditto for Arizona during most of the year.
- skybrian 5y agoIt seems like this shouldn't be a problem when the insulation is outside the the thermal mass? Once it's warmed up it will stay that way.
- Valgrim 5y agoInsulation should absolutely be kept outside the vapor barrier and well ventilated for better performance, but thermal mass is less important than building super-airtight walls, with lots of insulation, good quality windows and controlled ventilation.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoHigh thermal mass is very much desirable in Arizona. Adobe pueblos are used for traditional housing because they remain comfortable throughout summer without air conditioning due to the high thermal mass. A rug and some mild heating is sufficient to keep them tolerable even in extreme winters.
- mcguire 5y agoThe desert is typically cold at night.
- jimnotgym 5y agoPerhaps I can correct some misconceptions. I know mostly about the UK rather than central Europe. 1) New houses in the UK are very well insulated indeed. Walls are commonly of cavity construction with 'lightweight' thermal blocks or timber on the inside skin, and insulation in the cavity. We also indsulate the floors and roofs. Our building code is pretty strict about insulation and I believe that is also true in Germany for instance. 2) We use brick on the outside because the UK climate makes external wood rot very quickly in normal circumstances. Cedar cladding can work if left to 'silver', but you have little chance of keeping paint on anything. Exterior woodwork also has to be treated with fire retardant if used as cladding. Roof coverings are normally clay tiles or slate. There are buildings in my town that are 600+ years old, built out of oak framing with wattle and daub infills...but this is a very expensive way to build.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoWe generally do not clad our houses with wood in the US either. We're mostly clad with brick, vinyl, or stucco. Roofing is occasionally wooden shake in dry climates like California. But asphalt and clay are by far more common.
- jsight 5y agoAlso cement siding (hardiplank).
- rootusrootus 5y agoI was going to say. In the PNW at least, probably 99% of all new construction uses cement siding for the lion's share of the exterior.
- jsight 5y agoI feel like it is becoming more common here in the southeast as well. I don't particularly like it, tbh, though it does have some advantages. It seems to block noise pretty well.
- gumby 5y agoWood can also be good in an earthquake (the "willow vs oak tree" principle). However modern low-cost manufacturing means you'll still suffer various damage due to things like gypsum wallboards which are less compliant than the wood framing. But those failures won't be fatal.
- Spooky23 5y agoI think modern American houses are lower quality and shorter lasting, but more because of shitty building techniques and poor finish materials than wood framing. I worked in a wood barn in my youth that was built in 1680 in upstate NY, and will remain standing as long as the roof is maintained. My current home is a circa 1910 wood frame house that is in great shape and should be for years to come. There’s nothing wrong with wood.
- peteradio 5y agoMy own home is 121 years old 2x4 framed, with a well frequented railroad track within a stones throw. Wonder how well a stone home would hold up to that constant mild tremor.
- simonjgreen 5y agoAbsolutely fine. It's common for train lines to run straight through the centres of cities and towns in Europe including very densely packed industrial revolution era areas all made from stone.
- canadianfella 5y ago> Brick and stone homes are absolute energy guzzlers both in hot summers and cold winters. What the heck are you talking about?
- fy20 5y ago> Not only is it less expensive to build, but it's tremendously more energy-efficient when filled with insulation With modern buiding techniques - building an air tight home and then ventilating with mechanical ventilation, and taking into account thermal bridging - that's no longer true. If anything the extra thermal mass, compared to a wooden framed house, helps to keep it more comfortable and reduce energy consumption during day-night temperature swings. Some bricks, e.g. clay blocks with air pockets inside [0], are both structural and somewhat insulating - you could use them for something like a garage without any other insulation. If you are cheap you don't even need a facade :D A lot of Central Europe has similar climates to NY - my area had -25C in the winter and 36C just this week. We usually don't even turn on the heating until it gets below 0C outside, as our home is more than comfortable enough (above 21C / 70F) inside until then. Not gonna argue with the expensive part (there's a reason why people don't build 5000sqft homes here), however it is worth mentioning in most desirable places to build, it is often the land that is the most expensive part. [0] https://www.wienerberger.com/en/brands-and-products/wall.html https://www.wienerberger.com/en/brands-and-products/wall.htm...
- HWR_14 5y agoYou left out the other advantage of wood - it's environmentally friendly. Instead of mining stone (releasing greenhouse gasses), sustainable wood growth sequesters CO2 inside your house.
- icoder 5y agoThis is the important part in my opiniom! And it's why Europe is warming up again to wood based construction (cross laminated timber from sustanaible forests). All the other differences (ie isolation) can be achieved (or messed up) with either form of construction.
- simonjgreen 5y agoI think it's important to caveat that wood CAN be friendly, but to imply all wood building materials come from sustainable sources is a leap
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoDoes anyone know how sustainable lumber is now? I hope empress trees become usable in construction, they grow insanely fast.
- HWR_14 5y agoI mean, in the US housing is built using SPF (spruce/pine/fir) lumber that is grown for the purpose (whichever of those variants grows close by). If you say your endangered whatever hardwoods aren't environmentally friendly because they're old-growth, sure. But no one is framing a house in that or putting it anywhere it's not visible.
- reportgunner 5y agoWait I thought chopping down trees was environmentally unfriendly.
- empiricus 5y agoPlant trees, wait 20 years, then chop and use them for building (a form of carbon capture). Repeat.
- flexie 5y ago36 percent of the US is covered by forest (1). 38 percent of the EU is covered by forest. That's EU with Britain. Without Britain, the percentage is higher (2). I realize I use different sources, and that maybe all forests are not equally good for lumber production. But Europe has as much forests as the US. Yes, a lot of it is concentrated in Scandinavia and Eastern Europe, so traditionally, that would have been less accessible to most central and western European countries. Also, traditionally, there was far more farm land. But nowadays, Europeans could access lumber as easily as Americans. 1:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_the_United_States#:~:text=As%20of%202016%2C%20roughly%2036.21,of%20its%20old%20growth%20forests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_the_United_States#:.... 2:https://www.forestresearch.gov.uk/tools-and-resources/statistics/forestry-statistics/forestry-statistics-2018/international-forestry/forest-cover-international-comparisons/ https://www.forestresearch.gov.uk/tools-and-resources/statis...
- adolph 5y agoUS: 818,814,000 acres (3,313,622 square kilometers). EU: 161,000,000 ha ha = ac / 2.4711 818,814,000 / 2.4711 = 331,356,076 Ok, the US has roughly double the forested surface area. EU pop is 448m compared to US' 328m. So with 30% more population and half the forested surface area wood does seem scarser in the EU. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=EU-US-CN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=E...
- dmichulke 5y agoDidn't check the numbers but I'd guess including European Russia or non-EU Balkans or Norway would totally change your results. Then again, including Canada would probably as well.
- adolph 5y agoI just used the parent comment numbers converted to same unit with the first DDGed population result. Comparing pct land forested seemed an odd ratio to me. Population seemed to be a better proxy for housing demand. Pop density and other factors would probably confound but tree per capita seems to matter than tree per surface area.
- turtlebits 5y agoThe problem is that in the US, house structures are built as large and cheaply as possibly, with all the spending in finish and features. The US is in the stone age when it comes to wall construction (for longevity and energy savings), vapor control, doors and windows. I have a small project and I am having to order my windows, house wrap/wrb and tape from European suppliers.
- erentz 5y agoWhat’s different about US and EU house wrap?
- seb1204 5y agoSome time ago I spoke to an architect from Europe who was living and building in New Zealand. He said that good quality double glazed window are not available. Her ordered them from Europe. (I'm curious is I remember this correctly or maybe the situation has improved now). In Australia there certainly are no double glazed windows in most single home buildings.
- maratc 5y agoThe reason might be that there is no need in double glazed windows in AU/NZ.
- tuatoru 5y agoIt (the reason) is not. Most of NZ gets cold enough to need (at least) double paned windows, and all of NZ needs low-emissivity glass to reduce heat gain in summer. I believe the same is true of Australia. NZ's current building standards are state of the art for the 1970s. As gp said, specifying ordinary modern designs, materials and and fittings (by European standards) gets you looked at as though you're from outer space. NZ's housing stock is cold, damp, and mouldy inside for the most part. Not coincidentally NZ has one of the highest rates of asthma in the world.
- aledthemathguy 5y agocan't tell u how many times I asked American construction workers/contractors about this, and none knew the answer. Glad to finally have an answer. thx. Site note: can't stand the amount of noise(!) going throw the house as opposed to concrete.
- brtkdotse 5y ago1) You can insulate stone houses as well 2) I spent a year working in D.C. and watched 4-5 houses come up in the neighborhood during that time. The amount of insulation used was _laughable_. Watching builders on YouTube I get the same impression. In Sweden 99% of houses are wood, but all have at the very least the double amount of insulation, often more.
- aktuel 5y agoUS wood supply is currently largely diminished and lots of wood is being imported from Germany.
- splittingTimes 5y agoThis statement is odd given the fact that the US (and China for that matter) are gobbling up all the European lumber as it is cheaper than in the states, leading to ridiculous price increases over here.
- Nasrudith 5y agoSocietal inertia and tradition can be powerful forces. Look at all of the people going with green lawns in the desert.
- OJFord 5y agoTermites though? Those tent things and fumigation companies are just a 'television thing' to me; when I was young I thought it was some sort of cleaning thing.
- icoder 5y agoYou're saying it like rhe chiming in is bad or at least tiring. But that's how we come to insightful discussions like this one. Plus there IS a difderenc which does make articles like this at least different to interpret for the non-US crowd.
- glogla 5y agoAmerican houses aren't really built from "wood" as in directly from trees - they are build from "engineered wood" like fiberboard and particleboard. That's a lot of industrial processing with a lot of oil-based glues and so on. By weight, the houses are almost more oil than wood. Here's an enlightening chapter of "Well there's your problem" podcast about this with actual civil engineers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVodkE47aLw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVodkE47aLw
- hef19898 5y agoThe reason why us Europeans are so confused is, that over the last couple of years we started to see beyond the American Dream. And it feels like every time the US is having a problem it fails to find a solution for some country in Europe or Asia already has one. Not the perfect one, and maybe not one that can be copied, but one that works. Examples: Health care, elections, public transportation, guns, infrastructure, house construction... Not that I would expect Americans to just copy what we do, but the outright refusal to acknowledge that someone else is doing things that seem impossible is at times hilarious. All that with the obvious exception, everything military. Edit: American houses are lower build quality because of lower build quality. Not because they are build out of wood. They are also considerably cheaper.
- 1123581321 5y agoLikewise, some of us are a bit tired of the myopia coming from some Europeans. I’m writing this from an old brick home in the US, one of hundreds in my neighborhood. They’re not as old as the ones in your neighborhood since this area was only settled 150 years ago, but they’ll get there. We’re not asking you to believe in some “American Dream,” just notice that we also have hundreds of millions of people who make highly varied decisions that conform to natural environments and resources, historical contexts, cultural preferences and financial limits.
- tails4e 5y agoI'm not sure I get the insulation aspect. Sure when compared with concrete block wood is better, but wood is still a thermal bridge. In parts of Europe a cavity between two block walls is filled with insulation, so no cold bridge, and it means the structural materials inherent insulation value does not matter. An inner leaf of block also has a thermal mass which means the walls maintain the house heat better in summer / winter. So we have outer leaf for structure / weather resistance, insulated cavity with excellent u values, inner leaf for structure and thermal mass. It's a lot thicker wall, but serves multiple purposes very well, and better than wood frame with insulation between studs.
- biztos 5y agoThere are very good prefab houses made of wood in Europe. A relative of mine paid 600K EUR for one. Also, while there is more wood in North America, it’s not like there are no forests in Europe. Take a look at Romania or Bosnia if you want to see big wild ones.
- Zababa 5y agoI don't think it's fair to put brick and stone together like that. I personally live in France, where we have lots of old house made of stone, and they have a way better thermal insulation that houses made of brick, at least on my subjective "is it fresh in summer inside?" scale. > Brick and stone homes are absolute energy guzzlers both in hot summers and cold winters. That is not my experience, but a difference is maybe in how we heat things. This article about local heating explains my philosophy pretty well: https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/03/local-heating.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/03/local-heating.html When it's cold, I tend to stay in the room where my computer is and wear a jacket. I do think that it's possible due to how Europe and especially France has a more temperate climate than the US though. > wood construction has a ton of advantages. Not only is it less expensive to build The comparaison doesn't really hold as in Europe it's easier to leverage old houses, due to the history of Europe. I don't think any new houses are made of stone. It's really nice to have people like you point out misconceptions that Europeans can have, but please remember than you can have misconceptions too, and that Europe as a whole (like the US) is very large and has different climates. Not everything you said will hold in France, Spain, Ukraine, Greece, Norway.
- SergeAx 5y agoBy "brick" and "stone" you don't mean literally bricks and stones, right? Because modern houses are constructed with cinder blocks[0], foam concrete[1], polystyrene concrete[2] and composite blocks. And using mineral wool as an insulation is, well, not the best idea construction engineering came to in last 50 years. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_masonry_unit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_masonry_unit [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foam_concrete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foam_concrete [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expanded_polystyrene_concrete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expanded_polystyrene_concrete
- valdiorn 5y agothere's plenty of new builds in the UK using mostly red brick construction methods. Just plain old brick and mortar. In fact, if you google "uk new builds" almost every image that comes up is a red brick house.
- SergeAx 5y agoComposite block may look like bricks from the outside. Or there may be a decorative single brick layer around foam concrete walls.
- cienma 5y ago> Here's the thing, though: most Europeans seem to be suffering some pretty serious misconceptions. Hi there, I'm a civil engineer from the EU who specialized in building structures and was trained in masonry and timber structures. None of the concerns you mentioned feature as a design constraint. There is no shortage of building materials in Europe, and is indeed cheaper than the classical building materials. We do use a lot of concrete, masonry, and steel, none of which grows on trees. The main factor is population density, and the ultimate and serviceability state that buildings need to comply with in order to be assuredly safe to be habitable by people. It's fine if you wish to build a single-family home with a timber structure from top to bottom, provided that you do all the work to ensure that expected win loads are not able to blow out your home. There are homes being built like that around here. But those are indeed rare, because of cultural differences. The everyday joe around here looks at modern timber homes and, when compared with masonry, concrete, and even steel structures, immediately perceives it as low-quality work. Think McMansion. Prefabricated homes in general suffer from that prejudice, including light steel frame homes. That in turn leads to a market where most offerings target the low-end. On higher density residential buildings things are quite different. most residential buildings have 4 or 5 stories and thus structural soundness starts to be harder to ensure. You no longer are able to meet safety requirements by having a low-skilled carpenter randomly nailing together two boards. Moreover, the loads are more demanding, both dead loads and live loads such as wind Here the problem lies in the need to put together building structures that is verifiably safe involving cases where the minimum prescribed values in building standards don't cut it anymore. More importantly, you start to need to design specialized structural elements that can easily need to span over 6 meters. This is engineered timber territory, and one which can involve designing specialized structural elements. To add to the complexity, this technology introduces problems in complying with serviceability limit states that don't pose as big of a challenge with other technologies such as vibration limits and sagging. Consequently, we do see engineered lumber structures in long span structures and even foot bridges, but in general it's more cost effective, simpler, durable, lower-mainrenance and higher-quality to just build with other building technologies.
- mcswell 5y agoQuestion: aren't lots of commercial buildings in the US built with steel (or aluminum??) studs? What are the advantages/ disadvantages? From observation, the metal studs are about the same size as a 2x4, but constructed like an I-beam, with open parts. I don't know how they're joined--bolted? Riveted?
- baybal2 5y ago> I don't know how they're joined--bolted? Riveted? For black metal, it's the most obvious method — welding. For sheet metal, it's clinching, snaps, or, more rarely, threaded fasteners.