18 ms·
Scientist finds early virus sequences that had been mysteriously deleted
- pitched 5y agohttps://www.printfriendly.com/p/g/hGqAvT https://www.printfriendly.com/p/g/hGqAvT
- codeulike 5y agoArticle is Paywalled but its basically about this twitter thread from Bloom Labs: https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1407445604029009923 https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1407445604029009923 This technical bit is interesting - although the data had been 'deleted' from the Sequence Read Archive* web app by the original submitter, this tweet explains that they were able to recover the data via storage.googleapis.com: https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1407445615248691201 https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1407445615248691201 I discovered that even though the files were deleted from archive itself, they could be recovered from the Google Cloud at links like https://storage.googleapis.com/nih-sequence-read-archive/run https://storage.googleapis.com/nih-sequence-read-archive/run... (5/n) ... So technical question for HNers - what lives at storage.googleapis.com usually? Was that like a cloud mirror or was it more like the 'delete' function in the web app was only removing things from the index but leaving the deleted stuff accessible? * Sequence Read Archive seems to live at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra
- colechristensen 5y agoThey were supposedly storing artifacts publicly available on GCP's object store, an efficient way to do things for distribution of non-secure large pieces of data. "delete" deleted the reference to these objects but the objects were kept around. (This is a not-so-bad practice, if you're hacked and somebody tries to wipe everything, or some bug or fat finger deletes everything, you've deleted references to data not actual data)
- geoduck14 5y agoYou really should clean up your soft deleted objects. They are a perfect place for hackers to get data that you thought was gone.
- colechristensen 5y agoIf you are in the business of publishing scientific data, maybe you want people to be able to find "deleted" data, or at least you're not too concerned with really intensely enforcing people's abilities to delete something they have published.
- ve55 5y agoMost likely the latter: the server-side code in charge of deleting data did not make a call to their storage api to also remove the object itself. There's a good chance that is intentional and serves as a soft-deletion function, such that it could be reverted (or the data otherwise used) if needed.
- pitched 5y agoThat was my read on this too and Dr. Bloom accidentally hacked the NIH. The next question though is whether they’ll change this or not? Is the guarantee that anyone can retract at any time important enough to make the db useful? Will the Chinese government mandate no one there ever use it again now?
- nitrogen 5y agoDr. Bloom accidentally hacked the NIH. In case this is why this comment was downvoted, it's worth remembering that others have been charged with CFAA violation for basically the same thing.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoReminds me of this guy that got fined $4k by the court for something similar ? https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/02/french-journalist-fined-4000-plus-for-publishing-public-documents/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/02/french-journalis...
- jimmyswimmy 5y agoActing in the sense of as a devil's advocate here, but this guy went and rooted around a data repository for stuff that wasn't his... there was a case a few years ago of a guy who scripted the AT&T site to download similarly accessible data [0] and got 4 years jail for it. We can trot out the well-known Swartz story [1] here as well. Though I'm happy to have the information available in this particular case, I can't really say this is different in terms of either the letter or spirit of the law. So: when should we expect to hear this guy being charged with CFAA violation? I'm not holding my breath, and I hope he doesn't, but what he did seems as clear a violation of the law as the two examples listed here. [0] https://www.wired.com/2013/03/att-hacker-gets-3-years/ https://www.wired.com/2013/03/att-hacker-gets-3-years/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz
- 22c 5y agoIt was also discussed here yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27598222 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27598222 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.18.449051v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.18.449051v1 Unless this is a new instance of mysterious sequence deletion.
- bigpumpkin 5y ago"Dr. Goldstein noted that the testing paper listed the individual mutations the Wuhan researchers found in their tests. Although the full sequences are no longer in the archive, the key information has been public for over a year, he said."
- wallacoloo 5y agoNot to mention it was deleted in June 2020. I have to imagine many researchers had already downloaded the data by then and that there are a number of local copies that could be shared out if there was compelling reason to do so. If it was a coverup it was a rather poor one. It’s hard for me to think this was nefarious, unless the intention was just to delay (in a plausibly deniable manner).
- mrkstu 5y agoIt isn't, by itself, conclusive at all, but the amount of smoke China generates around this whole thing, vs transparency, screams that there is fire in the middle of the smoke.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoIs this amount of smoke uncharacteristic for China?
- tux3 5y agoEstablishing a pattern of shiftiness would not make the actions in question less questionnable. If I hear a surprising claim from a pathological liar, I'm also less likely to believe it, not more!
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoTrue, but saying that doesn't actually give it weight. And they aren't making a claim here, they are denying an accusation. My saying "Hey, pathological liar, I think you're Santa" and them denying doesn't make it more likely they are Santa.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/kbqdB https://archive.is/kbqdB
- 0-_-0 5y agoIf I remember correctly, the disappearance of these sequences was discussed more than a year ago in Bret Weinstein's podcast, among many other indicators of a lab leak: https://youtu.be/q5SRrsr-Iug?t=1843 https://youtu.be/q5SRrsr-Iug?t=1843 He's been the canary in the coal mine on numerous issues surrounding COVID. edit: listen from 30:43, also from 25:11: https://youtu.be/q5SRrsr-Iug?t=1511 https://youtu.be/q5SRrsr-Iug?t=1511
- cma 5y ago>He's been the canary in the coal mine on numerous issues surrounding COVID. He's also been the carbon monoxide in the coal mine, steering people away from vaccines
- DiffEq 5y agoNot all vaccines are created equal.
- peter4123 5y agoGreat point - The COVID19 Vaccines, particularly the mRNA ones are some of the best ever made, ~90% effective at preventing disease and ~100% effective at preventing death.
- presidente20 5y agoDo you have a source for those numbers?
- simonh 5y agoI use Google, but there are alternatives. OP is obviously using very round numbers, but given that is not wrong.
- presidente20 5y ago
- bgentry 5y agoThere was some prior discussion on this submission from yesterday, though it fell just short of the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27598222 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27598222 The source paper (https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.18.449051v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.18.449051v1) or Twitter thread (https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1407445604029009923 https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1407445604029009923) are probably better sources than the New York Times article based on them.
- Bayesian_bro 5y agoI don't see good enough evidence to show the zoological origin yet. I don't see good enough evidence of a lab leak origin yet either. I do see good enough evidence for a Chinese coverup. I can say for 100% certainly the Chinese are not being upfront with their data. What scenario would hiding data benefit? Cui bono?
- AdamN 5y agoThey might just want to protect other secrets about the lab and keep everyone at arms length. My bet is that even in China (which is not monolithic) different stakeholders are not so sure and there's major CYA between the scientists, the local managers, the Beijing-based leadership, senior leadership at all levels. Nothing good can come for any of these people if they allow the investigation to proceed smoothly. What if it's discovered that some totally unrelated incident happened years ago or that somebody was embezzling or did shady land deals with Wuhan lab accounts? The truth only helps people who are not involved. Everybody involved is best served by keeping their mouth shut and blocking any investigation.
- plank_time 5y agoSorry but China is about as monolithic as you can get. The CCP had an incredibly tight control over the entire country. It doesn’t allow anything except for a monolithic view.
- ta2346788 5y agoIt's funny you should say this because the truth is different, it's a lot less monolithic and centralized than you think. Here is a report titled "Understanding china's political system" https://fas.org/sgp/crs/row/R41007.pdf https://fas.org/sgp/crs/row/R41007.pdf
- simonh 5y agoThat’s not how China works. Source, my Wife is Chinese and her father is a retired CCP member. Local officials are highly corrupt and also are terrified something they are responsible for will come to the attention of the central leadership in a bad way. Thus they will bodge things for personal gain against the policies of the central leadership, and will try to ensure the central leadership don’t hear about things they very much want to hear about. This is a terribly high risk strategy, but it’s the only one that actually works. That’s the problem with corrupt bureaucracies. Of course once central leadership is aware of a situation they can mobilise vast resources and have absolute power to impose whatever strategy they choose. Anything or anyone in the way gets flattened. This is now happening in Hong Kong.
- S_A_P 5y agoCan someone explain in non charged terms why its 'bad' to investigate and or ask the right questions regarding whether or not the virus was leaked from the Wuhan lab? Im genuinely curious here. Thinking hypothetically here, if it were leaked wouldnt we all want to do a post mortem and figure out how to prevent it from happening again?
- AdamN 5y agoSome/many people can't separate the accusation from it being shown to be true. During that period of time (years??), it's a distraction for those people from the other problems like handling vaccine distribution, relations with China independent of COVID19, etc... Yes, if this were a narrow academic research project looking into the origin that was left de-politicized until there was an outcome that would be great. Unfortunately this whole thing was born political and China hasn't done itself any favors by always being so hush hush.
- soperj 5y agoIt's not bad, it's just the reason people are doing it have nothing to do with preventing it form happening again.
- FriendlyNormie 5y agoThe fucking fact that you felt the need to even ask this. Jesus christ.
- legostormtroopr 5y agoThere are only 2 reasons I can think of: 1. Because Trump called for an investigation into the Lab Leak Theory. Since Trump is bad, everything he says and does is always bad. This meant that everyone who was anti-Trump said that the lab leak theory was 100% false, definitely a consipracy theory and hence.... bad. 2. Because the Chinese government have used the modern political environment to deflect all critism as racism. Because people often shorten "Chinese Government" to "China" in news (much like the US), they take it that attacks against "China" aren't really attacks against the country but instead racist attacks against the people. Since racism is bad, criticism of China is racism, and investigating the Lab Leak leak is criticism of China - it stans to reason that the Lab Leak theory is racism, and hence.... bad.
- femto113 5y agoThere's no obvious reason to believe this is nefarious or even "mysterious". From the WaPo article[1] on the subject here's the statement from the NIH (which maintains the database) “These SARS-CoV-2 sequences were submitted for posting in SRA in March 2020 and subsequently requested to be withdrawn by the submitting investigator in June 2020. The requestor indicated the sequence information had been updated, was being submitted to another database, and wanted the data removed from SRA to avoid version control issues" [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/coronavirus-origin-nih-gene-sequence-deletion/2021/06/23/186e87d0-d437-11eb-a53a-3b5450fdca7a_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/coronavirus-origin-nih...
- SiempreViernes 5y agoThe good bit is author of the preprint apparently knew this reason the same day he posted his draft, but the draft doesn't mention it.
- philprx 5y agoSoft delete villain hit again
- dilawar 5y agoArticle behind the paywall. Can someone post the gist?
- jb775 5y ago> intriguing new information for discerning when and how the virus may have spilled over from a bat or another animal into humans....linked to animal and seafood markets in December 2019 Amazing how the NYT is gripping onto this "bat origin" conspiracy theory for dear life. They present this as fact, then casually mention the actual cause is being investigated. You'd expect the primary focus of this story to be the fact that virus sequences were "mysteriously deleted"...but instead it focuses on pressing a deceptive dialog that aligns with NYT political agenda. Shows you the current state of the media. Cancel your subscriptions. I guess we'll have to rely on those crazy Q-anon people to actually investigate why these went missing in the first place.
- jlduan 5y agoBecause of the highly politicalized nature, some Chinese scientists begin to deposit SARS-CoV-2 sequences to their own databases (hosted in China). https://ngdc.cncb.ac.cn/ncov/release_genome https://ngdc.cncb.ac.cn/ncov/release_genome https://db.cngb.org/ https://db.cngb.org/
- jlduan 5y agoit is possible they changed mind and chose to deposit there.
- ketamine__ 5y agoWhy? They are worried about American scientists chasing after them?
- jlduan 5y agoIt is a political thing. Japan has DDBJ (https://www.ddbj.nig.ac.jp/index-e.html https://www.ddbj.nig.ac.jp/index-e.html). EU has ENA/EBI (https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ena/browser/home https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ena/browser/home). Maybe China wants to have its own. More Chinese institutes are encouraging their scientists to deposit human bio-sample data to their own servers. Some grants even require them to do so.
- dang 5y agoPlease keep nationalistic swipes out of HN comments. They only make things worse. Your post would be fine without the first bit. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jlduan 5y agoi agree. sorry.
- raphlinus 5y agoAnother good analysis, by Jon Cohen of Science: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/06/scientist-s-hunt-covid-19-s-origin-finds-early-virus-sequences-chinese-team-deleted-nih https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/06/scientist-s-hunt-cov...
- msisdead 5y agoThis is one more reason it is great that Trump has been kicked out of presidency even if some conspiracy theorists claim with absolutely no proof that elections were rigged. The scientific community was feeling stifled and not being able to do their work. Trump made the same claims and the scientists earlier categorically denied, not out of malice but because he was such an inhibitor. And now they are able to work freely and do their best work.
- base3 5y agoMany people falsely assume that anything leaked from a lab was made in a lab.
- ctrlp 5y agoThat's not why people think the virus was made in a lab. The reason people think it was man-made have to do with strangely well-adapted protein sequences found on the virus with no known natural ancestors. Virus evolution requires hosts and time. The nearest common ancestor to this virus is not a good candidate for SARS-COV2 and there are no known intermediate ancestors in the thousands of animals tested.
- ikt 5y ago> The reason people think it was man-made have to do with strangely well-adapted protein sequences found on the virus with no known natural ancestors. I was under the impression it was a natural sequence, I read about it way back in the beginning: https://www.labmate-online.com/news/laboratory-products/3/breaking-news/is-covid-19-man-made-or-natural/51980 https://www.labmate-online.com/news/laboratory-products/3/br... They found that the spike protein, a receptor-binding domain (RBD) that hooks onto host cells, had evolved to target ACE2, an enzyme founded on the outer surface of human cells that helps to regulate blood pressure. The team say the COVID-19 spike protein is so efficient at binding to human cells that it could only be a result of natural selection, not artificial engineering. Another tell-tale sign of natural origins is the molecular structure of COVID-19, which is substantially different from other known viruses. Rather than mimicking other viruses known to cause severe illness in humans, COVID-19 more closely resembles strains of coronavirus found in bats and pangolins. "These two features of the virus, the mutations in the RBD portion of the spike protein and its distinct backbone, rules out laboratory manipulation as a potential origin for SARS-CoV-2" says Andersen.
- sterlind 5y agoI don't understand that argument. Wouldn't serial passage through human lung cells produce efficient bindings? Is that sort of artificial selection not what they meant by "laboratory manipulation?" If they mean it's not the product of genetic engineering then sure, but leaving out the possibility of serial passage is misleading at best.
- twobitshifter 5y agoI would be interested in knowing what other sequences were deleted and how common it is to delete from this DB.
- dpbriggs 5y agoAnyone else here incredibly disappointed in the discourse around the lab-leak hypothesis? I'm not even talking about the truth of it. Instead the way the discussion has occurred and changed over time. In the earliest days it seemed implausible but possible, to suddenly fringe and impossible, then recently to something that _could_ occur. At some point there was this weird, almost intentional, conflation of the idea the virus could have escaped in some way related to the labs in Wuhan with some sort of nationalist, uneducated caricature blaming the Chinese. Worse still is the weird apologia, or cope, around the topic in these threads. People recognize the political reality, and it's easy to get distracted in threads tossing links around. But we still see weird arguments like: - Oh there _was_ nothing wrong with it, but /most/ people were using it to be xenophobic or racist (QED). - There was never anything really against the idea, but instead new evidence came out! - Some flunky 'Bayesian' argument clearly proving one way or the other. There's probably merit to each point above, but is that really satisfactory in light of how discourse was shaped? It actually feel likes gas-lighting. I don't track every comment, every article, and every casual conversation I have. But it has changed, the media has softened, the hostile atmosphere of the last four years is dissipating. Before anyone starts screaming for sources - this is just some free-form thoughts on the subject. I'm a regular Joe. My contribution to this topic is hoping someone more qualified is able to look deeply enough into it. I'm also terminally online, and have read several hundred comments every day over this pandemic, and observed general trends.
- cyanydeez 5y agowelcome to the backlash to the backlash to conspiracy theory culture. its not a wonder why we cant have rational discussion when theres a constant reverberating noise of irrational conspiracy theories. anyone who really considers the global propaganda should understand by now thst this is intentionsl. degrade scientific rationality, democracy and good governance by pumping FUD into any critical corner.
- macawfish 5y agoAbsolutely! 5g is another area where this is happening. If you read literal industry whitepapers and peer reviewed articles about mm wave antenna arrays, the biometric sensing applications and corresponding privacy concerns are quite literally spelled out. There are entire industries being built around these applications and hosts of highly qualified researchers openly collaborating with corporations. Meanwhile these towers, which are effectively biometric radars, are going into cities across the country with zero informed public conversation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dsign 5y agoThis is such a "funny" mess! In computer security, if obscure researcher Bob discovers that a few instructions can theoretically be used to steal Joe's passwords at the random location in memory where they are by burning the CPU using some webassembly, we make a huge deal of it. We slow down all CPUs in the world overnight to cope with that thus-far _theoretical_ attack, threaten the CPU designer with class action lawsuits, and hail Bob as a hero. With this virus, we are doing the opposite: we are distributing the patch (vaccine) at glacial speeds (while our economies burn). No "hardware hardening" is being discussed and we are not bringing a class-action lawsuit against God for all His vulnerabilities. All we are saying is "This is your fault Bob, we are going after you!"
- sgt101 5y ago>we are distributing the patch (vaccine) at glacial speeds (while our economies burn). Be fair - the vaccine development and distribution program is by far the fastest in history and has wildly exceeded even the most optimistic predictions at the beginning of the pandemic. Also, consider how long it took Amazon to build a global distribution system for things like books and cheap gifts. 10 years? Maybe more... Now "hardware hardening" - what would that be in your analogy?
- dsign 5y ago> Be fair - the vaccine development and distribution program is by far the fastest in history and has wildly exceeded even the most optimistic predictions at the beginning of the pandemic. Maybe so, but what would happen if bad actors had the capability to create viruses easily? My understanding is that the tech for it is already around the corner, if not currently available. Are we just going to trust that bad actors won't have the motivation to use them? Returning to my compsec analogy above, Bob and the rest of the compsec good guys don't care about any possible motivations, just that it is possible. For the record, I'm not 100% for that approach, but it seems to be the way things work. > Now "hardware hardening" - what would that be in your analogy? We have an immune system that--for the most part--works. It does cause terrible diseases in most people[^1] , and there is a bunch of things that it's not very good at, specially for old folk. Maybe it, and the rest of the system, needs some "technical love"? Honestly, we are technologically far from being able to completely fix it, but I would be happy if we had the same heated and open discussions about that backlog --and what can be done with it--the same way we have about practically anything else. [^1]: https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/autoimmune-diseases https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/autoimmune-diseases
- legulere 5y agoNo matter what hypothesis you find most likely it is a shame, that the Chinese government hinders proper free scientific research in the origins. Chinese scientists should be free from censorship.
- pvaldes 5y agoThere are several, perfectly legit, possible reasons for that DNA databases are known to have a small percentage of corrupt data, specially early data. There is not anything strange in modifying or deleting an item in a database. Database managers do it all the time when finding an error. Maybe those sequences were duplicated. Maybe they were wrongly translated but nobody noticed it until the covid suddenly became very popular. Maybe the publication that provided this data were bad science and retracted later. Fixing a bunch of mistakes in taxonomy that sleep for years until a specialist came and reviewed the old material is not uncommon in biology.
- HeleGomez10 5y agoshould delete it because once it is released to the outside, then it will be very dangerous to human life:https://www.couponxoo.com/400-robux-gift-card-code https://www.couponxoo.com/400-robux-gift-card-code
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- leviathanch 5y agoFollowing conspiracy theory: Google and the rest of the deep state originally wanted to develop a bio weapon, for which bats are perfect as incubators, while using Chinese labs, because it's illegal in the US to do so (also in China BTW), but it never was successful because they were using equipment from TaoBao. When some lab assistant didn't wash his hands properly before going for lunch at the wet market down the street, the virus leaked, but it's only a bit more aggressive than its original form, which was basically a mild cold. Now they blame China for it, using all their psyops tactics, mainly their mind control project Blue Bird (https://mind-control.fandom.com/en/wiki/Project_BLUEBIRD https://mind-control.fandom.com/en/wiki/Project_BLUEBIRD), also known as project ARTICHOKE or Twitter, because some insane elites think, the world would be better off if most people would die from a thermo nuclear WW3, while China really would like to avoid a war if possible. When China realized what the US was doing in their labs, they panicked and started trying to do damage control, not realizing that all their P&R attempts at face keeping are futile, because everyone thinks they're the embodiment of evil, not matter what they're doing.