15 ms·
We’re no longer naming suspects in minor crime stories
- fallingknife 5y agoSo somehow the ethics change based on the severity of the crime they are suspected of?
- stevenpetryk 5y agoThe article hints that (ostensibly) the reason the policy only applies to minor crimes is that they often do not hear back on what happened with minor cases. Presumably, high-profile cases will receive lots of follow-up attention, including naming the suspects found innocent. Again, ostensibly.
- wyldfire 5y agoNitpick: in most countries, you cannot be 'found' innocent, you are presumed to be innocent and can only be found to be 'not guilty' or 'guilty.'
- thaumasiotes 5y agoBeing found not guilty is being found innocent, since those are the same thing. Having charges dropped is different; there's no finding in that case.
- Dylan16807 5y agoBeing presumed innocent is not a court finding. The bar is much lower.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoSo what? Being found not guilty is a court finding, and it is a finding of innocence. "Innocent" and "guilty" partition the entire space of states.
- Dylan16807 5y agoEven without going into nuanced situations, someone can be found criminally not guilty but civilly liable for the exact same actions, because there's enough evidence to say they're probably guilty but also reasonable doubt. "More than 50% certain of guilt" is not "found innocent".
- staticman2 5y agoIn theory in the U.S. you are not found innocent-- the charges just weren't proven beyond a reasonable doubt by the prosecution. In theory the jury could think you are a murderer, but they had a "reasonable doubt" so voted not guilty.
- jonny_eh 5y agoFrom the article: > This policy of not identifying suspects by name applies to minor crime briefs. We will continue to identify suspects by name in stories on significant crimes, such as murder, that would merit ongoing news coverage. In these cases, naming a suspect may be important for public safety reasons. These guidelines also do not include stories about active searches for fugitives.
- anikan_vader 5y ago> we now will no longer name suspects in brief stories about minor crimes in which there is little chance AP will provide coverage beyond the initial arrest .... We will continue to identify suspects by name in stories on significant crimes, such as murder, that would merit ongoing news coverage. In these cases, naming a suspect may be important for public safety reasons. These guidelines also do not include stories about active searches for fugitives. The article suggests major crimes typically receive follow up articles, hopefully including whether a suspect was acquitted.
- privong 5y ago> The article suggests major crimes typically receive follow up articles, hopefully including whether a suspect was acquitted. Maybe AP (and news outlets in general) should make a further commitment to write a "concluding" story about any crimes where they do publish a name, so that there's a news record of the outcome with respect to conviction/acquittal.
- Scoundreller 5y agoYou may notice some publications pick and choose who they’ll publish names of, and that can be a reason why: if they publish the name, it’s because they’ll be following the case and publishing its outcome, while if they don’t, it’s because they don’t intend to do so.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fitblipper 5y agoTheir excuse for this is that more severe crimes are more likely to have follow up news articles indicating if the suspect was charged, found guilty, whatever. This change is an important one to make and signals at least a recognition of the issues involved and a desire to do better. Hopefully the tides continue to shift in this same direction and fewer peoples lives will be ruined by their worst decisions or by simply being at the wrong place at the wrong time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- handoflixue 5y agoThey explain in the article that such minor stories rarely get follow-up, so you'll never hear if they get exonerated / found innocent. Whereas if, say, Bill Gates gets arrested, they'll be a lot more likely to post updates and further clarifying information. Just from personal intuition, I'd also expect that a lot of sources would be name-dropping "Bill Gates got arrested" even if the AP tried to keep it quiet, so there's less value.
- mulmen 5y agoAs noted elsewhere, you cannot be "found innocent". The accused is presumed to be innocent. They can be found guilty, subject to some standards based on the circumstances. This misconception is precisely the reason for this policy change.
- kar5pt 5y agoHey, some ethics are better than none. I'm desperate for any news company to show a sliver of integrity at this point.
- devtul 5y ago> I'm desperate for any news company I will never go back being that naive again, there are no news of consequence, only propaganda.
- contravariant 5y agoTo be fair you do have a point that in many countries it's customary to not mention the full name of the suspect no matter how serious the crime.
- mLuby 5y ago> We also will stop publishing stories driven mainly by a particularly embarrassing mugshot, nor will we publish such mugshots solely because of the appearance of the accused. Bravo!
- luke2m 5y agoThey did? That sounds very unprofessional.
- nitwit005 5y agoIt was a bit cringe inducing to read that they were intentionally publishing articles purely on the basis of finding someone's appearance amusing.
- adolph 5y agoThink of all the hot felons waiting to go viral that the AP just screwed. I think they will flip on this policy within 5 months. https://news.yahoo.com/man-apos-viral-mugshot-gets-194100321.html https://news.yahoo.com/man-apos-viral-mugshot-gets-194100321...
- ottomanbob 5y agoThis generally makes sense to me, but what signifies "significant crimes" besides murder, which is mentioned in the article? I had a friend who was all over the news after being charged with multiple counts of rape and sodomy. He was completely acquitted and the case never went to trial. Still, he'll never clear his name online. That being said, I'm not saying I know what the rules should be.
- e40 5y agoOther countries have laws that prohibit suspects from being named. I wish we had those laws because the follow up is never going to happen. You can't unring a bell that someone is a rapist, when they are found to be innocent or the charges are dropped.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> laws that prohibit suspects from being named The downside of these laws is, in the case of arrests, it makes disappearing people easier.
- maest 5y agoYou mean by the state?
- uuidgen 5y agoNot really. If police is corrupt and want someone to disappear they just won't create arrest records. US police was using black-sites where people disappeared without problem. On the other hand public arrest record put a great opportunity for malice and blackmail - do what I want or I'll arrest you for allegedly molesting a minor. Charges will be dropped but good luck clearing your name ever. Now pay up.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> If police is corrupt and want someone to disappear they just won't create arrest records Departments routinely doing this get caught. (They have.) Of course if it’s corrupt all the way up you’re screwed. But the aim is to create grappling points for the Feds and state Attorneys General on e.g. city cops. Showing a pattern of undocumented arrests or of the arrested going missing is easier when arrest records are public. It’s a tradeoff between the power of the state over the public versus the power of the public over itself.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- koreanguy 5y agoWhy we’re no longer naming African American suspects in minor crime stories there you go
- joshmn 5y agoAs a former felon, I've learned first-hand the fallout from being named in crime stories. The AP has it right in that a lot of it isn't realized by readers or society. Upon being charged with crimes, I had to make my way through the court system. As a consequence of my actions, the courts punished me. Once I had showed that I was not a serial offender but instead someone who had moments of weakness, lost identity, and subsequently poor judgement, the courts let me go. Once I paid my debts to the court — figuratively and literally — I was free to live my life without the government watching over my shoulder or further being a burden to my future. My dealings with them had a fixed amount of time attached to it. Once that time limit expired, I was free. Society was far less kind, and hardly as forgiving. No, I'm not talking about employment — I am and always have been very gainfully employed. No, I'm not talking about renting an apartment, or getting a loan, or opening a bank account. I'm talking about new acquaintances. As we have seen over the past 5 years, in the minds of many a website is a single source of truth. To a large number of people, simply having a website is enough to give confidence to the reader that what's written is an absolute and authoritative source. It is only correct, completely unbiased, and contains 100% factual sourcing. When there's a webpage with dirty laundry on it, it rarely gets updated to say "later, Judge Judy found suspect to be of good character, and they've since paid their debts to the court." No, it just has absolute worst moment on repeat, leaving out all the context and any depth that goes into a legal proceeding. It's entirely the worst part of a nightmare. I've personally had a number of articles written in addition to a 15-second segment on the local evening news. Getting a call from a partner who is sobbing, "my parents Googled you." is absolutely stomach-turning. Knowing my little sister had to go to school the day after the clip played next day was something I am more ashamed about than I can put into words. Thankfully she was too young for a cell phone and social media was still in its infancy. My partner very privy to my dirty laundry. When they first learned of it they were actually surprised. It didn't bother them though as they knew who I was as a person and that my days of making mistakes were behind me. Their parents were less understanding. They didn't know me like my partner did. They just saw a series of mugshots and some local news articles from mistakes I made as a young adult. It wasn't the first and it wasn't the last time it happened, either. I have always been transparent and forthcoming with mistakes I've made. I'm just as candid with friends as I am here on HN. Hell, my profile even says I'm a former felon! One point does not make a pattern. Many minor crime stories are just a point. That point, on the internet, is a scar, and those who come across them out of curiosity, suspicion, or nosiness re-open the wound. Since my bad decisions, I've had success in contacting the authors of the articles highlighting my worst-moment-kept-in-a-non-governmental-database asking if they'd consider removing their article. I mentioned I had completed probation and was doing something with my life, and that the article was hurting me and my relationships with people. They obliged. Edit: This isn't the first time I've mentioned I'm a felon in a comment. I've received a surprising number of emails over the years from other felons (or felons-to-be) asking "how did you reintegrate into society?" or "do you have any advice?". If you're one of them and reading this, you're more than welcome drop me an email.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoAs long as they still continue to name politicians doing something illegal or stupid.
- underseacables 5y agoIf it clicks, the media will print. Sounds like the right step but I doubt it will hold.
- caymanjim 5y agoThe AP isn't the NY Post. I take them at their word that they'll stick to this policy, because they're not sensationalists or click-baiters. The stories they're talking about aren't even news, so they shouldn't pick them up at all, but this is a good initial step. Other platforms will still run the garbage in all its naming-and-shaming glory. I admit I click on all sorts of "Florida man" stories for a good laugh, but I never care about the perpetrator.
- busymom0 5y agoAP made a policy that they would capitalize one race and won't capitalize the other. So putting AP on the moral high ground is silly. They are being run by racists who lack self awareness.
- wcarron 5y agoMy interpretation of their intent is they will no longer name suspects in "florida man" style stories. Like, really, nobody needs to know that it was specifically 30 year old resident Pimble McGringleberry who lives on 1234 S Main St, nowheresville, arkansas was the lady who was throwing office chairs off the top of the target parking structure. The person is presumably dealing with the aftermath of whatever caused them to be in the news in the first place. There is no reason to give internet users a rope, or 6 lines by the hand of the person to hang them with. I think this is a positive move and hope to see more of it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pokstad 5y agoThe press should also commit to not naming and showing the face of mass murderers to prevent glorifying their crimes and encouraging copy cats.
- bigiain 5y agoThe New Zealand Prime Minister gained (even more) respect from me for this: “He sought many things from his act of terror but one was notoriety, that is why you will never hear me mention his name,” she said of the gunman. “He is a terrorist. He is a criminal. He is an extremist. But he will, when I speak, be nameless." -- https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/19/new-zealand-shooting-ardern-says-she-will-never-speak-suspects-name https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/19/new-zealand-sh...
- 0xy 5y agoShe did exactly what he wanted to happen as written in his manifesto, so it doesn't matter that he's nameless. She gave him everything he wanted, which was more gun control. For those unaware, the shooter explicitly stated that his goal was to radicalize more people by forcing the government to take their guns. The government complied.
- stubish 5y agoIf a terrorist wants you to do what you determine to be the right thing, there is little more you can do except do the right thing, and try not to give them credit encouraging further terrorism. The alternative is known as cutting off your nose to spite your face.
- 0xy 5y agoWho determined it was the right thing? The US has had declining gun homicides for 30+ years despite record breaking gun sales. It's hard to square that with the narrative. Over the last 30 years, there has been a correlation between increasing gun sales and declining gun homicides in the US. Additionally, not only are gun homicides down per capita over that time frame, they're down in real numbers. You can ignore this, and claim it was the right thing anyway, but then it advertises to terrorists that violence is an acceptable way to reach your goals. The terrorist was validated and his agenda was hurriedly rolled out.
- xibalba 5y agoThis is an interesting (and confounding) topic. On a corollary note, Austin recently experienced a mass shooting in a popular Downton area. 14 people were shot. One died. Another is paralyzed. The local paper of record explicitly declined to publish the description of the suspects as released by the police so as to not "perpetuate stereotypes". The question I have is, what is the obligation to report the facts of a story, regardless of consequence? My belief is that reporting should report all the facts and let the chips fall where they may. But I also understand that reasonable people can disagree. (In this case, it seemed unreasonable to me as one shooter was still at large.)
- dwaltrip 5y agoThere are an infinite number of facts. There always is a decision made about which particular facts to include and how to frame them. One can’t simply “report the facts”. That being said, with difficulty, journalists can make an effort to minimize the amount of “story-telling” that occurs in a news article. I appreciate that the AP seems to be better about this than many other sources.
- xsmasher 5y agoWithholding the description reasonable if it is so vague as to be useless. "Black male, 18-35" is not useful or actionable information. If it's a more detailed description, and the shooter was still at large, then I agree with you.
- sunstone 5y agoI think it's in France where names are not published until after the person has been found guilty. If you're innocent until proven guilty then your name should be withheld until then as well. Imagine the guys who are maliciously fingered for sexual child abuse and end up being entirely cleared but their life is screwed from then on.
- Archelaos 5y agoIn my country, Germany, the media are only allowed to publish the name of a convict in cases of grave crime or when the crime is of special concern to the public. In minor cases the right of personality outweighs the public's right to information.
- gwbas1c 5y agoIn the US, the constitution guarantees freedom of speech. It's very difficult to legally prohibit anyone from publishing anything. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_... This why, btw, US news has so many lies. It's nearly impossible to regulate the media unless there is a constitutional change.
- konaraddi 5y agoGermany’s constitution also guarantees freedom of speech. Both the US and Germany have exceptions. For Germany - https://www.loc.gov/law/help/freedom-expression/germany.php https://www.loc.gov/law/help/freedom-expression/germany.php For the US - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exceptions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_ex...
- throw_m239339 5y ago> Germany’s constitution also guarantees freedom of speech. Both the US and Germany have exceptions. No it does not. > Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. There is absolutely no equivalent to this in the German constitution or anywhere else on the planet, the way it is phrased, applied and uphold by the US supreme court.
- beervirus 5y ago>We are abdicating our responsibility to report on the news, because doing so might cause harm to criminals. :-/
- pessimizer 5y agoBecause everyone arrested is guilty, therefore a criminal.
- busymom0 5y agoIf that was really the reason, then this policy would be generalized to all topics and all "alleged crimes/allegations". Clearly that's not the reason.
- ffggvv 5y agosociety today is moving more and more to protecting the perpetrators of crimes and away from protecting the victims. this is somehow seen as more humane, because as we all know the perps are the ones who are actually the victims. (not the people the beat or rob, as long as its under 950 its "minor") https://twitter.com/LyanneMelendez/status/1404574079156318210 https://twitter.com/LyanneMelendez/status/140457407915631821...
- chmod775 5y agoThis is a good first step. You shouldn't ruin people lives just to provide the rest of the world with some morbid entertainment, but this really should extend to homicide as well, at least until someone has been found guilty. None of these stories are important or 'newsworthy', they are purely entertainment. "Yesterday 31112 people died of cancer, 9346 people fell and broke something vital, 15012 people poisoned themselves, and a handful of people got shot in a really exciting manner somewhere in central Europe."
- ggggtez 5y agoI think the only concern around homicide and "serious" crimes, is that maybe society does have a public interest in knowing who the murderers in society are. Who are the rapists, etc. I'm not a legal expert, and I don't know what categories of crimes are in the vast public interest to know about, and which are trivialities best left between you and the judge. But I can imagine there is a level of crime which is of the public interest to be aware of. Maybe the line is if you are convicted of a crime with a high recidivism rate, like Fraud or robbery. Or maybe it's impact based, such as violent crimes. I'm not sure, but I don't think I could see it being in the public interest to never publish any information about any crimes that are done by people in society. I remain open minded to evidence to the contrary, though.
- cwkoss 5y agoIs anyone taking a crack at redundant but relevant "news" like this? So much of news seems focused on sensationalism. Would be interesting to read a paper that chose stories based on relevance to keeping readers informed, healthy and alive independent of recency: - Heart Disease continues being the leading cause of death (We interviewed 3 cardiologists and reviewed studies to find what lifestyle changes most reduce this risk) - US Annual car accidents increase 3% YoY (Talk to civil engineers about where or in what conditions accidents occur most frequently and thus people should be most careful. What other factors make certain people safer drivers than others? What is the relative risk of driving 0, 5, or 10 mph over the speed limit on the highway?) - Amazon rainforest deforestation continues (show graphs of rates, discuss causes) - America is using more plastic than ever (show breakdowns of how plastic is used, which uses have the worst ecological impact, etc) Interestingly, a lot of this content could be "re-runs" - take the same article, maybe add updated data if available, and republish it. Cost of producing content could be reduced.
- balozi 5y ago> We also will stop publishing stories driven mainly by a particularly embarrassing mugshot, nor will we publish such mugshots solely because of the appearance of the accused. Until this confession any accusation that such practices were part of AP report would have been vehemently rejected.
- akomtu 5y agoImo, name and pictures of someone are a clear cut of intellectual property that belongs to that person and thus distributing such photos is copyright infringement. Well, that would be the case if the intent of IP laws was fairness.
- scotty79 5y agoIn Poland media are not allowed to give a full name of the suspect or show the face. They can publish first name and first letter of family name. So they can say John G is suspected of rape. This ban lasts till the suspect is convicted or cleared of charges. Sometimes it's a bit funny when suspect is a public person. You wouldn't have a hard time to figure out who Keanu R is, especially with huge media coverage, but in general it's a good rule that protects falsely accused or innocent people being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
- theBobBob 5y agoAnother related American tradition that I think is really wrong is the "Perp Walk". For the police to purposely work with the media to cause as much public humiliation for a presumed innocent suspect as a form of pre-conviction punishment is really twisted in my opinion.
- cafard 5y agoWhy is an international wire service even carrying minor crime stories? The Washington Post doesn't write up anything less than a violent crime. Once a week, the local supplement will have a list of reported crimes, but all you get is the crime (homicide, assault, robbery, theft), the block (3200 block 16th St. NW, say), and the date and approximate time.
- modeitsch 5y agoTotally agree! They can Destroy someone life in a minute