16 ms·
El Salvador Plans to Use Electricity Generated from Volcanoes to Mine Bitcoin
- pizza234 5y agoTwo questions: - will those moves make the country a good location for laundering bitcoins? - generally speaking, is there no other way of profiting from surplus electricity (which essentially, this is)?
- dadoge 5y agohttps://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2021/06/09/technology/bitcoin-untraceable-pipeline-ransomware.amp.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2021/06/09/tech... Nah. Bitcoin is actually a lot easier to trace than paper US Dollars.
- ostenning 5y agoExactly, people who claim btc is anonymous don’t know what they are talking about. You can literally trace every transaction ever made, and given nearly all on-off ramps to fiat require KYC, btc itself is not the problem. The problem comes from privacy coins like Monero, which arguably should be outlawed (if not already)
- Hendrikto 5y ago> The problem comes from privacy coins like Monero, which arguably should be outlawed (if not already) You cannot (and should not try to) outlaw maths.
- jMyles 5y agoCan you imagine the price spike the day that's announced? But also: outlaw where? Math doesn't recognize borders; the two are like oil and water.
- cinntaile 5y agoRegarding privacy coins... This sounds a bit dystopian though, why do you think the state should have a right to see your entire transaction history?
- selsta 5y ago> The problem comes from privacy coins like Monero, which arguably should be outlawed (if not already) Are you also in favour of outlawing Tor, E2EE, HTTPS? I am always surprised that some people want privacy outlawed. Disclaimer: Monero contributor
- kcmastrpc 5y ago- given the economies of scale, im guessing that the major 1st world countries will continue to be the most prolific in terms of bitcoin laundering - of course there are other ways, but given the return on kW/h, what's the _most_ profitable?
- vondro 5y ago> generally speaking, is there no other way of profiting from surplus electricity (which essentially, this is)? Making hydrogen, smelting aluminium, de-salinating water. But bitcoin can be transferred over internet, so the logistics is easier.
- conjectures 5y ago> other way Undoubtedly there is, e.g. steel making - with the attendant logistical challenges. But few ways to fairly directly convert electricity into money.
- garydevenay 5y agoIn the case of laundering Bitcoin— this seems to be a majorly misunderstood concept. Bitcoin transactions are completely transparent and observable by everyone who has an internet connection. Anyone (with an internet connection) can watch any wallet and observe any and all transactions. The notion of a country being a "good location for laundering bitcoins" doesn't really make sense, as Bitcoin are never in a location. In terms of profiting from surplus electricity, Bitcoin (or cryptocurrency mining in general) is a great option as it's exceptionally simple to scale up and down in accordance with available cheap surplus. One major benefit that miners are taking advantage of is locating in close proximity to energy stations, reducing the inefficiency of transporting electrical energy over distance. This turns effectively "wasted" energy in to a solidly efficient energy store for infinite amount of time— for example: 1 BTC will always be equal to 1/21000000 of the total supply.
- StavrosK 5y agoI agree with the rest of your comment, but there's some sleight of hand here: > This turns effectively "wasted" energy in to a solidly efficient energy store for infinite amount of time— for example: 1 BTC will always be equal to 1/21000000 of the total supply. It's not an efficient energy store if you can't get the energy back, it's just energy usage. Also, yes, 1 BTC will always be the same fraction of the total supply, but the actual value of it varies.
- garydevenay 5y agoI think that's a fair comment. Re-using the word "energy" in that sense is potentially misleading to always mean electrical energy. As for the value of 1 BTC, it's value fluctuates if you operate on a base currency which is not BTC, but that is the same for any currency exchange. (I am suggesting currency, though I also understand that BTC may not be unanimously agreed on as a currency— but in El Salvador's case it is)
- StavrosK 5y ago> As for the value of 1 BTC, it's value fluctuates if you operate on a base currency which is not BTC, but that is the same for any currency exchange. Yes but also, even though 1 BTC will always be worth 1 BTC, the amount of work it buys you won't be the same, as with any currency. In theory, you can also store USD for an infinite amount of time (assuming you exchange the paper for new paper when it decays), but it, too, won't hold its value.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoDoes a volcano have to be active to generate electricity from it or is heat sufficient?
- chrisco255 5y agoGeothermal heat is sufficient.
- Ensorceled 5y agoGeothermal, similar to Iceland ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_power_in_Iceland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_power_in_Iceland
- dadoge 5y agoRemittances, things like wire transfers, account for 22% of their GDP. Bitcoin will give that money back to the people with the way lower cost of transfers, esp through the Lightning Network that is planned to be widely used. Elizabeth Stark boldly said 7 yrs ago and Bitcoin is like TCP and needs an http, and then built Lightning on top of Bitcoin and this is super exciting to see. EDIT: removed “fees”, it’s just remittance based
- gjulianm 5y agoIf I'm not mistaken, that 22% is not fees, but the actual wire transfers from people abroad [1,2]. IMHO, it doesn't indicate that transfers are too expensive, but that a lot of people can't find enough work or support in El Salvador and they need to rely on family/friends that emigrated. I don't know how that is going to be solved by Bitcoin. 1: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/BX.TRF.PWKR.DT.GD.ZS?locations=SV https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/BX.TRF.PWKR.DT.GD.ZS?lo... 2: https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/bop/2005/05-09.pdf https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/bop/2005/05-09.pdf
- dadoge 5y agoThey will literally have more money in their pockets. Good things happen when people have more money in their pockets - people save more, invest more, build more.
- kasperni 5y agoEvery day, this is getting more and more ridiculous.
- garydevenay 5y agoThis is undoubtably a bold move by El Salvador, but I think dismissing it at "ridiculous" isn't very productive.
- atatatat 5y agoThis is an incredible power move, have to applaud the audacity. US-protected elections in 3...2...
- fasteo 5y agoTagging it as "ridiculous" calls for a minimal clarification
- xwolfi 5y agoLike maybe there are more pressing problems than making bitcoin with this electricity supply. I dont know but it feels wasted on a fad.
- bogota 5y agoThey are doing it to make money how is making money a fad? The reality of living in a poor nation like this is that unless they take a gamble they will most likely continue with the same level of violence and poverty. Its very easy to look down on people from an ivory tower though and call it a waste.
- cratermoon 5y ago> They are doing it to make money In no scenario does "they" refer to El Salvador's poor population, especially not the indigenous peoples. The money will go to the colonizing foreign investors and circulate in things like CDOs. A few crumbs that fall off the table will go to improving the lives of the upper end of El Salvador's people, and incidentally some crumbs of the crumbs might fall down to the rest of the population. Trickle down, eh?
- hulitu 5y agoIs this paper a subsidiary of the Onion ? "100% clean, 100% renewable, 0 emissions energy from our volcano" . So when a volcano is depleted you plant another one ?
- dadoge 5y agoDo you work for the onion? You can say the same thing about the sun and solar
- StavrosK 5y agoSpeak for yourself, this is the third sun I've planted this millennium and you guys need to take it easy with it.
- hvacarchivist 5y ago>Volcanos have zero emissions Volcanos are only emissions. I would like a one-way ticket to Mars, please.
- willcipriano 5y agoIf extracting heat from the earth's core isn't sustainable, nothing is.
- drexlspivey 5y agoI hate it when volcanos are depleted and I can’t mine any more bitcoin
- hungryhobo 5y agodepleted might be the wrong word, becomes inactive perhaps? I agree with your general assessments though, volcanic activity doesn't seem like a reliable source of energy.
- graderjs 5y agoIt just gets better and better. - ES makes BTC fiat - ES taps volcanoes to mine BTC What next? - ES uses natural wormholes to plot the future timeline and win Earth?
- vidarh 5y agoES has not "made BTC fiat". It is making it legal tender. All that means is debts can be settled with BTC. As for "tapping volcanoes" it's a PR exercise - El Salvador is one of the countries in the world with largest geothermal generation capacity. "Tapping volcanoes" here in effect simply means mining bitcoin with part of their geothermal generating capacity. But "tapping volcanoes" got this a whole lot more attention than it otherwise would.
- personlurking 5y agoAn attempt to answer your "what's next?" question: "What about you guys floating $1 billion in “Volcano Bonds” (backed by future #BTC mining output) for El Salvador to pay off the IMF loan - so they can tell the IMF to beat it." https://twitter.com/maxkeiser/status/1403023717429559299 https://twitter.com/maxkeiser/status/1403023717429559299
- gjulianm 5y agoIt's a $1B loan to a country with a low debt rating. It's a risky investment already, and now you add Bitcoin with its price volatility? I don't know how that's a good idea from the investors point of view.
- oogabooga123 5y agoI would buy some bonds just because of the idea that a nation could be free from international banking debt. Like a charitable donation, almost
- gjulianm 5y agoGood luck getting $1B to El Salvador as "almost charitable donations". Not to mention the effect that trying to sell $1B-worth of Bitcoin could have on the market (even just a portion, Bitcoin is accepted nowhere for so they'd need real currency).
- lm28469 5y ago> So tell me, why did your civilisation built a Dyson sphere > BTC lmao XDDD This world is sick
- lucb1e 5y agoAlmost half the electricity produced in El Salvador is from fossil sources (they don't have nuclear power): https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.ELC.PETR.ZS?locations=SV https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.ELC.PETR.ZS?location... Option A: invest in that volcano and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Option B: invest in that volcano and mine bitcoin. B makes them richer so long as other people keep expecting Bitcoin prices to rise (increasing demand), so I can see why they do this, but I'm not sure I like it. Even if the equipment, installation, and operation are all compensated for, it's wasting renewable energy on making heat and some money by gambling on future demand of a PoW-based system. But for a poor country, making money to get up to rich country living standards makes sense so... I can't even fault them.
- deweller 5y agoThis is a false dichotomy. They can subsidize the startup costs for harvesting geothermal energy from Bitcoin mining and then use the geothermal infrastructure to produce electricity for the country.
- lucb1e 5y agoThat sounds great. Let's hope that actually happens and hope that the geothermal equipment lasts longer than Bitcoin demand lasts. Perhaps, though, if that is actually the plan, they could say as much?
- emodendroket 5y agoIt's not a false dichotomy. The infrastructure does not exist and they can't do both things at once
- deweller 5y agoA false dichotomy is when one argues that only option A or option B are available when in fact options C, D, and E also exist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma
- nonamenoslogan 5y agoSeems to me El Salvador will say anything they can to make the price rise.
- deepserket 5y agoexactly, the problem with listening who is betting in bitcoin is that they will try to pump the price almost all the times
- einpoklum 5y agoI wonder if someone called in a favor with the president in order to hike up the price of BitCoin even more before they sell theirs.
- enchiridion 5y agoSo, I'm going to choose to be an optimist when it comes to crypto energy consumption. There has literally never been a more direct reward for efficient energy production.
- xwolfi 5y agoBut it s like there's ONLY the reward. You imagine if there was a way to make gold with electricity? We d live in the dark just to get more of it...
- enchiridion 5y agoWell, not exactly. There is the utility of enabling the chain. And there is nothing stopping us from extracting gold using electricity. It's in basically all soil and sea water. Sure there are some required materials, but I'd water a guess that those materials are no harder to obtain than GPUs. The only thing that stops this reckless mining are the forces of the market, and the same is true with crypto. Crypto miners tend to be extremely frugal, and I doubt any are any who are doing unprofitable mining in expectation of crypto going up. Now from a crypto maximalist perspective, which I don't necessarily hold, isn't the cost of the electricity worth having a decentralized currency which enables all sort of different markets? Crypto is always held up as wasteful in terms of energy, but I'd be curious to see the energy cost in comparison to current payment processing systems.
- kemotep 5y agoIf anyone is interested, Visa reports that their payments network (and supporting infrastructure) uses 740,000 Gigajoules[0] in a year. Can’t quite find a one for one measurement for Bitcoin, but due note this is the energy needs of all of Visa’s operations and they process in excess 100 billion transactions a year and Bitcoin (in 2020) averaged around 300,000 transactions a day[1]. If interested there is this[2] digiconomist article with more numbers (no clue as to the veracity of them). [0]: https://usa.visa.com/dam/VCOM/download/corporate-responsibility/visa-2019-corporate-responsibility-report.pdf https://usa.visa.com/dam/VCOM/download/corporate-responsibil.... [1]: https://www.blockchain.com/charts/n-transactions https://www.blockchain.com/charts/n-transactions [2]: https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/
- bluetwo 5y agoWrite the New York Times headline on this whole affair in five years:
- danbruc 5y agoHow much money is there to be mined per year? On the order of 10 billion dollar? What share of the total hash rate could you realistically buy and power with your volcano? One percent? Probably not ten percent. What would the investment for the hardware be? I have a hard time imagining that you could make a noticeable difference this way even for an economy like Salvador's. And there are probably many better ways to spend money than buying mining ASICs.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoMining more bitcoin won't make its market capitalization go up.
- mtalantikite 5y agoI think this is only one part of the story for them. If 70% of their country is un-banked, many transactions are probably in cash, and there probably are a lot of undeclared sales and income that is not being taxed. If they can really get their population using tools that would make it easier for the government to collect taxes, make it easier for tourists to visit and spend money, etc then the mining rewards are only one small part of their plan. Of course none of this really needs to happen with crypto, they certainly could solve these problems in other ways, but I can't really blame them for trying this out.
- sanderjd 5y agoEven if crypto is a good solution for all this, bitcoin is a bad one.
- defgeneric 5y agoI understand this argument, but if I had to choose right now which coin would be the best for my country, I would still go with Bitcoin. You don't get to choose which coin has the most backing, or the most diverse set of players from around the world.
- 5y ago
- thehappypm 5y agoOne interesting thing to me is that Bitcoin is a lot easier to steal than money in banks. A bad actor can steal your private key and take all of your BTC, and it's gone forever. Try doing that with a bank account -- the bank will back you up, there are transfer limits.
- ipaddr 5y agoHow does this apply? This makes it easier for others to steal all of the money? I would think they would be selling those coins after mining them not holding on to them as some future investment. Nevermind that banks in smaller countries can be a huge source of thief.
- defgeneric 5y agoThe whole point of Bitcoin is that the bank itself cannot steal your money.
- thehappypm 5y agoCoinbase or any other exchange can certainly steal your coins, just like a bank can steal your money. Hosting your own private key is like having your money in your mattress -- it's as secure as you allow it to be, and once stolen it's gone forever.
- leesalminen 5y agoTell that to my brother-in-law who had his identity stolen and several lines of credit taken out in his name. He’s spent the past 2 years working to resolve it with limited success. His credit score is still trashed and can’t buy a car nor house.
- cs702 5y agoThe country is already going all-out in its adoption of Bitcoin, so sure, why not go from "ludicrous" to "plaid" by bringing volcanoes into the mix?[a] For those not living in El Salvador, it will be fascinating to see how this unorthodox approach to monetary policy works out in the end. [a] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO15qTiUhLI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO15qTiUhLI
- beiller 5y agoYeah. How can a country survive without unlimited QE? The poor residence will see their buying power constantly rise against all other currencies as the other countries of the world follow in USA's footsteps of unlimited manipulation. Realistically that might actually be tough for any of their exports however and may make everyone unemployed as their "currency" rises in value, but will they also all be rich? Frankly I think it is an amazing experiment.
- whereistimbo 5y agogoblok. I feel relieved, even though Indonesian President is still Jokowi, he isn't as stupid, hippie dumb like El Salvador's president.
- pocoloco 5y agoAs a Salvadoran living abroad but keeping an eye on politics there, I feel the need to comment given the amount of skepticism shown here, which is understandable given the history. I believe that what the president, Nayib Bukele, and his team have done is monumental. The reason is that I also believe that the financial system crashed back in 2008 and has been kept alive by central banks worldwide. Last summer we saw how Lebanon banks reneged to pay back their customers their holdings in USD. This seems to be increasing. The thirst for USD around the world is increasing and all the so called printing by the FED is not getting to the other countries and international companies fast enough. El Salvador is in a though position since it does not control its main currency. The other one, the Colón, while still legal tender is for all practical purposes unusable. It would take too long to grow the economy enough for it to be valued appropriately against the USD. Mandating BTC as legal tender is an awesome move. To me the most important benefit is that the 70% of the population which was excluded from banking and relegated to use physical currency will now be included. If the economy is an engine and money is the oil, El Salvador, which had only some drops of oil, will now get a complete oil change with synthetic on top of that. Lets remember that the law obligates the government to instruct all citizens on the use of the technology and to provide the means if necessary. This means that the government now has to provide connectivity to all citizens and teach them. Nayib has shown that he’s up to the task. For example, El Salvador is providing every child in the public school system with a laptop and free internet connectivity. So I think this is beyond if BTC goes up to 200k. It doesn’t matter. If it goes back to 10k is OK too. What matters is that every citizen will now be included as equal in this new financial system.
- fnord123 5y ago> Mandating BTC as legal tender is an awesome move. To me the most important benefit is that the 70% of the population which was excluded from banking and relegated to use physical currency will now be included. If the economy is an engine and money is the oil, El Salvador, which had only some drops of oil, will now get a complete oil change with synthetic on top of that. You are 100% incorrect. Bitcoin is wildly deflationary. Therefore it does not encourage an economy to function, it encourages people to hold onto it with white knuckles. It's not oil for the economy, it's sand. > This means that the government now has to provide connectivity to all citizens and teach them. And when they don't provide connectivity and teach citizens?
- helaoban 5y agoCan we all take a moment and appreciate this headline.
- silentsea90 5y agoGlorious! We're living in a super cool sci fi storyline.
- cartosso 5y agoI can't believe people still don't see the obvious issue that PoW has no sense and it's impact gets progressively worse as the market cap of BTC increases. The more adoption BTC will have, the more incentive will powerful entities have to take part in mining (obvious analogy: US dollar, the people who control it have the most power in the global financial system). Also, the more valuable BTC becomes, the more new miners will join in the mining race, since the average payout per kWh spent should stay at a relatively constant % of market cap. Both of this observations lead to the clear conclusion that energy spent on useless hash cracking will continue to increase, which is just plain stupid. Humanity cannot afford to waste energy in such an obviously non-nonsensical way; if you want to keep the crypto train going, fine, but at the very least switch to PoS.
- iabacu 5y agoThe argument about POW energy is overblown. There's an exponential decay of rewards of mining BTC (50% every 4 years). Do you think the price of BTC will increase exponentially, faster than the decay over the long term? I don't think so. This implies that the energy consumption of bitcoin mining will eventually decay exponentially too.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoAt what point do the Bitcoin bros notice the company they keep is getting more and more ridiculous?
- defgeneric 5y agoWhat exactly is ridiculous about El Salvador? What an ignorant and racist comment.
- kragen 5y agoI wrote a couple of comments yesterday exploring the environmental questions related to Bitcoin in depth: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27450417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27450417 The short summary is that the environmental effect of Bitcoin mining is very small at present (12 GW consumption out of the world's 18 TW), but probably positive, because it slightly accelerates the renewable transition. But this could change.
- jerry1979 5y agoI read through your answers in that thread and really enjoyed them. Thank you for taking the time to do that work. Have you considered consolidating those ideas into a blog post or similar? It sounds like you have some expertise in this area or maybe just like to research. Either way, I think others would really enjoy having access to your seemingly well thought out analysis in a place that isn't the HN comment section.
- kragen 5y agoThanks! Yeah, I've been thinking about that, especially because of the profoundly unrewarding nature of that conversation. A number of my previous HN comments are in Dercuano, Derctuo, and Dernocua, though those mostly consist of things other than HN comments, and some of the HN comments they contain are pretty embarrassing. Generally I feel like the HN comments section is pretty aggressive and conformist, and there's a lot of people trolling. The social dynamic rewards rapid reaction, trolling, and conforming to the popular opinion (and especially cheering for it and denouncing those who disagree with it), and punishes the kind of careful investigation and thoughtful conversation that I value. I think it brings out the worst in me. http://canonical.org/~kragen/dercuano http://canonical.org/~kragen/dercuano http://canonical.org/~kragen/derctuo http://canonical.org/~kragen/derctuo http://canonical.org/~kragen/dernocua.git http://canonical.org/~kragen/dernocua.git
- lucasnortj 5y agoLooks like El Salvador is on a mission to make itself the world's fool. crypto "currencies" have no use case except for gamblers, stop wasting everyone's time. There is literally nothing more useless that this electricity could be used for
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoFrom what I've heard about Salvador, investors who plan to mine cryptocurrencies in El Salvador should include an armed to the teeth private army in their projected expenses, or else their mining equipment would soon change owners.
- defgeneric 5y agoIf you want to opine on a country at least learn its name: "El Salvador".
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoIt does not have 'El' in my native language, just Сальвадор. Also, if salvadorians want english speakers to call their country with 'El', they should probably start using 'THE Estados Unidos' and 'THE Gran Bretana'.
- defgeneric 5y agoIn English the name of the country is "El Salvador".
- lowbloodsugar 5y ago(noob here) How does this work from a key security perspective? Can one person just walk off with the country's entire wallet? Does an HSM become the thing in the vault where the gold used to be?
- runbathtime 5y agoThe El Salvador government is directing a state run energy company to provide 'cheap' (does that mean free?) energy to those mining bitcoin in El Salvador. Are these miners even locals or are they Americans? The miners will be getting cheap energy at the expense of the local population/ country. Maybe the miner's profits will be taxed and go back to the government for a return on investment. The thermal energy from the volacano is being pursued not because it is more efficient, but because it is more green and more moral. El Salvador making bitcoin legal tender, and forcing it to be accepted in payments, is the best thing to happen to bitcoin. The only way this can work is if the government buys the bitcoin from merchants and give them dollars, so the government is the buyer of last resort for your bitcoin. No where in the world can a bitcoiner force anyone to accept bitcoin for goods/services or exchange for dollars but El Salvador. El Salvador receives millions of dollars in aid from the US. The US tax payer is funding bitcoin mining (through energy subsidy) and funding the El Salvador government trading facility of converting bitcoin to dollars. The government bears the transactions costs/ and the volatility risk. El Salvador shouldn't receive a cent of US aid to support this, only private contributions. If the El Salvador government has enough money for bitcoin projects, they don't need US aid for humanitarian reasons. Bitcoiners who support this can no longer claim to be about freedom, as this is coercive, and is only possible through massive government spending to subsidize it that El Salvador is doing. This is only a victory for the miners being subsidized, and the bitcoiners who have a buyer of last resort. Is it really a medium of exchange if statistics show that 95% of merchants convert to dollars immediately? Is it really a victory if you have to use government force to get people to accept it?
- pocoloco 5y ago> El Salvador receives millions of dollars in aid from the US. This has been true for decades. Not anymore. A couple of weeks back the US gov said that it would stop all USAID funding and give it instead to ONGs in El Salvador which are basically the opposition or anti-Bukele. I assume that there are other ways that the US gov sends "aid" but I'm sure these will also stop soon enough.
- neither_color 5y ago