16 ms·
iOS 14 tracking changes sees big ad spending drop, tumbling prices
- armagon 5y ago"A new report says that iOS 14 tracking changes could cost the advertising revenue billions if an early trend in spending decline continues." Does it not follow then that advertisers are saving billions of dollars? Now, admittedly, the advertisers aren't going to be getting now what they used to get, but this Freakonomics Podcast episode, "Does Advertising Actually Work? (Part 2: Digital) (Ep. 441)" https://freakonomics.com/podcast/advertising-part-2/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/advertising-part-2/ makes me wonder how much it'll really impact the people who pay for advertising.
- bpodgursky 5y ago> Does it not follow then that advertisers are saving billions of dollars? No — if the targeting is less effective, the advertisers are not getting the same incremental value from the ads. The ads are cheap, but draw in less total revenue for the company, saving nothing. The bid prices are just lower on untargeted ad slots, adjusting to the lower CPM / lower lift. Edit: Truly, the best part of HN are the Dunning-Kruger programmers who once read a substack post about advertising, and now believe they have deep hidden insight that a hundred thousand marketing professionals, running marketing campaigns as their job, every day, have not figured out — aha, internet advertising doesn't work!
- thehours 5y agoGiven how rampant ad fraud is in programmatic, I wonder how much revenue actually drops for these companies, relative to the decreased ad spend. Uber’s [1] experience is one example: “We turned off two thirds of our ad spend – $100m out of annual spend of $150m – and basically saw no change in our number of rider app installs. What we saw is a lot of installs we thought had come through paid channels suddenly came through organic.” [1] https://mackgrenfell.com/blog/how-did-uber-waste-so-much-ad-money https://mackgrenfell.com/blog/how-did-uber-waste-so-much-ad-...
- toast0 5y agoEven without ad fraud, you have things like user wants to install Uber, so searches for Uber in a web search. First link on the page is an ad to install Uber, maybe a couple more ads, then first organic search result is a link to the Uber home page, and maybe the second result is to install it. If the ad weren't there, the user would probably install organically, but since it's there and at the top of the page, it's likely to get clicked and cost money.
- xuki 5y agoThe ad in that case is to prevent Lyft from getting that ad spot. Fucked up, I know.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoThe google shakedown- "It'd be terrible if ya know Lyft, got that top spot..."
- xxpor 5y agoHow is that fucked up? There's a certain number of slots, and someone is going to fill them. It's like in a grocery store. If Kellogg's doesn't offer Kroger a price they like, they'll just stock General Mills instead... that's just business.
- chmod775 5y ago> No — if the targeting is less effective, the advertisers are not getting the same incremental value from the ads. I mean... No again. Kinda. Advertising isn't magically gonna make money appear in the pockets of your customers. Advertising influences how people distribute their income, influencing them this way or that (at least that's the goal). If advertising becomes worse for everyone, which it did, those weights are just scaled by a fixed amount, arriving at the same end result. The only winners are those who didn't advertise at all and only competed only on value. Those may see an uptick.
- dividedbyzero 5y agoNot sure; targeted ads can work pretty well for small niche businesses, getting the same amount of conversions through untargeted ads may not be feasible. I could imagine those getting hit harder by this change than, say, Uber, so probably not quite the same end result.
- chmod775 5y agoI could see that. But you can still effectively target niches with contextual ads.
- dividedbyzero 5y agoDefinitely. Is that something you can buy right now? I was under the impression there was little to nothing substantial in between untargeted and programmatic these days
- danShumway 5y agoMaybe you're right. But if less advertising means that less money is going into businesses, then ads don't make products free, because they increase consumer spending and decrease the efficiency of consumer spending. If what you're saying is true, then advertising has a tangible cost for consumers. There are three possible theories about how advertising works: A) Advertising increases consumer spending and makes consumers spend dollars less efficiently based on attributes like branding that are unrelated to quality. In which case, all of this "advertising makes apps free" talk has been really deceptive, because consumers who are viewing ads are spending more money for worse/inflated products to compensate. In this world, it's worth asking what the costs of advertising are and whether we want it to be the primary way of funding the Internet. OR B) Consumer spending/efficiency doesn't change, consumers are smart enough to buy the best product anyway, and the only thing that changes is which companies get that money and have brand recognition. In which case, it starts to become difficult to argue that consumers opting out of ads they don't want to see is particularly harmful. In the world where advertising is just making people aware of new information and helping them make informed purchasing choices, then it's probably a good thing that across the board everyone is being forced to cut down on the pointless noise that amounts to companies trying to scream over each other and increasingly hyper-target people in creepy ways. If advertising does not increase consumer spending, and if everyone is reducing spending and effectiveness by the same amount on iOS, then this should be good for advertisers -- they'll spend less money on ads, and consumers will still spend the same amount of money themselves. The only reason that wouldn't be the case is if highly targeted ads actually changes consumer behavior and spending habits in meaningful ways -- but if we admit that, we need to admit that the advertising industry is a lot more problematic and a lot less "free" for consumers than it likes to claim. OR C) Advertising is a public good, and consumers actually want to know about these products, and ultimately people want targeted ads. But this is obviously not the case for the majority of advertising. If it was the case, than iOS's changes wouldn't be a big deal. If consumers want targeted ads, they have the option to keep allowing them in iOS. The whole reason we're in this situation is because consumers have overwhelmingly demonstrated that they do not want targeted ads. So at best, the advertising industry can position itself as a kind of metaphorical "vegetable", claiming that everyone hates them but ultimately the world would be better if more things were commercialized. But it's just not a realistic theory, the data is pretty clear that consumers don't like ads and it's very hard to argue that unrestrained commercialism and forced targeting is good for society. There are more efficient ways we could be doing this if our goal was really just to make it easier for people to compare products and learn about new solutions to their problems.
- stingraycharles 5y agoOn the other hand, for the publishers this may be a net win. I’ve always argued that very narrow targeting mostly benefits the advertisers, and the publishers are left with a very small audience that yields a lot, and a very large audience that is difficult to sell. Of course, this may not be the case for Facebook et al, but it’s definitely the case for a lot of apps and websites that live off advertising. Now, without super narrow targeting, they are suddenly able to sell a lot more inventory.
- gleb 5y agoUnlikely. You make more money by breaking a beef into multiple cuts for different customers than grinding the whole thing and selling burgers only.
- thebean11 5y agoAssuming you can find a buyer for enough of those individual cuts yes. If most of them have no buyers you're better off selling burgers which I think was the point.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIt annoys me beyond belief that every single digital ads HN thread this is the most upvoted hot take and it rarely comes from someone working in buy side let alone ads in general. Good or bad or neutral, FB's targeting specifically works amazingly well and better than anything else for many buyers. Especially for direct response ads. If you can't make money selling your product from digital ads, you're not saving dollars you're losing revenue. This is true especially for 'internet only' upstart products, for example everyone who gets stuck in for instance a $60 athletic short ad loop as an example!! Sometimes you hear examples here about a new product or kickstarter who pre-this type of digital would probably not be able to launch or it would be much harder. Brand advertising is different and targeting can definitely argue doesn't matter as much. But these changes has already changed how we spend money, and we're tiny in the grand scheme. The other point that always gets thrown out: It's also incredibly simple to measure effectiveness or lift. Staying with FB as an example, if you are selling a product it can be as simple as using a unique link for your FB ads. ROI = Purchases with that link / FB spend. FB also has a large set of conversion tracking JS and offline like loading your retail conversions to the platform to match. But given the new rules FB is now 'modeling' ROAS and it has decreased accuracy for us from something like previously capturing 80-95% of conversions to sometimes less than half. This makes a big difference in auto-optimizing on their end and thus our ROAS. And again sure, it gets complicated and definitely more snake oil to buy some 3rd party ad tech which claims to model across all your channels online and off. A lot of times that's gamed or just a bunch of BS. But another way to measure is say you're a larger brand buying TV, digital, OOH etc the works. You can simply control by making only one single change segregated to a control and treatment geo/group before and after, measure delta.
- rubyfan 5y agoI’m not deep in this space but was thinking something along the lines of your response. If I understand it right, advertisers will lose efficiency here but I’m skeptical that it’ll cost ad networks much because advertisers will still need to reach an audience but will now suddenly be less effective at targeting.
- nojito 5y ago>Good or bad or neutral, FB's targeting specifically works amazingly well and better than anything else for many buyers. Especially for direct response ads. A recent study says otherwise. https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/pdf/10.1287/mksc.2019.1188 https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/pdf/10.1287/mksc.2019.118... Do you have any studies supporting your claim that it "works amazingly well"?
- yohannparis 5y agoI agree with you, I hate when news report as "cost", a loss of revenue they never going to get is not a "cost". They just need to adjust to the market.
- tormeh 5y agoThe blanket statement "Advertisement does not work", which I really hope is a strawman, is trivially wrong. If you start a new B2C business the only way to do inbound sales is advertisement, as by definition no one knows about your company/brand/products/services. Outbound sales is (usually) impossible in B2C for cost reasons. Almost every successful B2C company is evidence that advertisement works. There are some exceptions like banking and utilities, where the LTV of a retail customer is high enough to do outbound sales, but most B2C companies can't afford this.
- iwitaly 5y ago+1
- amelius 5y agoOnly under the assumption that no alternatives to advertising exist. Ban advertising, and suddenly this statement is not true anymore: "If you start a new B2C business the only way to do inbound sales is advertisement, as by definition no one knows about your company/brand/products/services." ... for the simple reason that people will look for other means to find products online. For example non-biased search engines, product catalogues, review sites, etc. etc. And no, listing your product with objective info is not the same as advertising.
- tgv 5y agoAnd then those other means will become commercially very interesting and you'll have to buy your way into them. But let's assume advertising doesn't work. Two companies start with the same product and same market at the same time. One advertises, the other doesn't. According to you, the former one should lose, because it wastes money on ads. I'm betting that (on average), the latter will lose, though. I know, it's a very black-and-white hypothetical situation.
- nlh 5y agoHeh we wrote basically the same reply at exactly the same moment. Cheers :)
- megaman821 5y agoI wonder what this means for free apps. * Will they simply disappear from iOS? * Will new subscription options appear? * Will they remain free but require users to enter a 20 question demographic survey to continue?
- bilal4hmed 5y agoYou simply start charging a subscription for your app
- lwansbrough 5y agoWhich is subject to a 15-30% fee, unlike ads. And assumes users want to have a subscription to my app (they don’t.)
- a4isms 5y agoWorth noting that unless you’re personally selling advertising (which only a few people can do), ads are subject to a fee as well, by the broker/network. You don’t collect 100% of the money paid by the advertiser. What you avoid with ads on iOS is paying twice: Once to the broker, and again to Apple.
- bilal4hmed 5y agoso then how do you plan on making money without privacy offensive ads ? Without charging your customers, there is no way
- lanstin 5y agoSounds fine to me. The problem with apps is not quantity but quality. If we had ten percent as many and they were twice as good, I would be happy. Even if they were basically the same but didn’t constantly put click here to go to the App Store screens, I would be happy.
- muro 5y agoSubscriptions to apps to will work about as well as subscriptions to news sites.
- marvel_boy 5y agoWell done Apple. A little step to improve privacy.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoIt will decimate the ecosystem and have no impact on users. Meanwhile a world of premium-priced alternatives or subscriptions remains out of reach because of Apple's 30% commission and $0.99 minimum charge, and lack of support for upgrade pricing (although Apple will happily launch competitor apps and take 100% of the proceeds, as well as giving itself premium search positioning). Some of the biggest companies (eg. Facebook) might just buy carrier user data directly, actually worsening privacy.
- an_opabinia 5y ago> It will decimate the ecosystem I agree it's hard to say how reducing income for app developers of free apps helps users.
- akmarinov 5y agoThey'll finally start charging proper money for apps. We can buy $3-$4 cups of coffee every day, but $0.99 for an app is too much? Come on.
- bilal4hmed 5y agoUsers have to learn to pay, just like I said in my comment. You pay for things in real life, have to do it online too.
- yoz-y 5y agoMaybe, but this will be very, very, very hard. I'd love to be able to make a paid-front app rather than freemium, but the current habits make that impossible unless you are an established brand or have a huge marketing budget.
- AgentOrange1234 5y agoIt seems somehow just right that an article about this has a super annoying video playing above the content, scrolling with you as you read.
- bilal4hmed 5y agoThis is awesome news. We need the web to not be reliant on ads and also build the expectation amongst users that they need to pay for articles/services etc. just like how they would in the real world. This is the first step in doing both
- baby 5y agoCan’t wait for gmaps, gmail, facebook, twitter, hackernews, reddit to have paywalls
- bilal4hmed 5y agoif you want privacy, you gotta pay. Thats how ads disappear. People have to charge for services and people have to pay to access them.
- Marsymars 5y agoI would gladly pay monthly to receive Google Maps without ads.
- warkdarrior 5y agoThey'll charge a fee and offer paid placement to brands. The ads will not be obvious, will just show up as prioritized over other listings. Maybe even routes will adjust accordingly to put you closer to advertisers. And you'll pay for the honor.
- beagle3 5y agoOpenStreetMaps doesn’t have paywalls. In sone things it is worse, in my day to day use it is better, the only thing I use gmaps/Waze/Amaps is for live traffic. HN has neither paywalls nor ads. Fastmail has a paywall compared to gmail - and I gladly pay it. There’s no ad supported option ttbomk. The only two that don’t have a real alternative are the metcalfed Twitter and FB (and the live traffic feature in maps)
- bilal4hmed 5y ago
- eddieroger 5y agoFor uninteresting reasons, I had to wipe settings on my iPhone this weekend, which meant re-approving everything, including the do not track setting mentioned here. When 14.5 came out, I updated faster than apps like Instagram could, so I missed their "please approve" screens that I got to see now. It's not strange to see an app explain why it is about to prompt for permission to do something, but posing for better personalization in the ads I'm going to see anyway really didn't land with me. I fully admit that I was never going to approve this setting, but I still find it surprising that they think I would be happier with more specific ads. Does that work for some folks? I guess I can understand that if I have to see ads at all, may as well make them personalized, but I'd still rather not see ads, to the point of blocking them when possible.
- peterhi 5y agoI've never found a benefit in "Personalized ads" because they have never been something that I am interested in, it seems to really mean "we can charge the brands more for this ad". There is a ton of stuff I would willingly pay for but it never seems to be what people want to advertise to me
- lanstin 5y agoThis was always true for me until recently the Instagram ads (I use Instagram to see what my kids and their friends are up to). Those ads are all very much in the sweet spot of my weaknesses. Haven’t bought from them, but I still watch more than halfway in fascination before I realize consciously what has happened.
- _game_of_life 5y agoI opt into personalization and am constantly getting ads for tampons (not a woman), essential oils (yuck), iced tea (I only drink water), chinese clothing (lol), and then sporadically... 100k+ metal 3d printers and other industrial engineering equipment. I am a disabled, unemployed student. I also have serious doubts that "personalized" ads even really exist. It's like they're trying to show me the least applicable products to my life.
- 5y ago
- bigyikes 5y agoThis will bring only good things to the ecosystem. Your app can’t support itself without tracking, and your users don’t want to pay? Maybe your app doesn’t provide as much value as you think. Advertising is a race to the bottom, so kudos to Apple for raising the bar for everybody.
- wccrawford 5y agoAnother comment here suggested that non-free social media would see rich people getting wider distribution. And I think that's exactly what would happen. Freemium dating sites let you use the most basic features for free, but to actually reach more than a few potential dates, you have to pay. Freemium social media might also do the same. For free, maybe you get sent to just a few of your closest friends. For money, you can be sent to all your friends and random strangers. And perhaps you have access to flashier messages and better icons. Perhaps meme/picture posting is limited for free. It's easy to think that the users would just go elsewhere, but if Facebook can't afford to operate without tricks like that, smaller sites have even less chance. And once that door is opened, it quickly gets wider and wider. Look at DLC and IAP in games now. It used to be non-existent. And then "horse armor" appeared and sold like hotcakes, despite all the protests. From there, we ended up with gacha games that absolutely abuse people with certain mental instabilities, often when they have money to burn, but often even when they don't. As much as I hate ads, I'd hate to see social media get worse.
- manquer 5y agoLinkedIn has this setup for years . It has not impacted anyone all that much. Only professional influencer would need to pay in this kind of model that doesn't seem all that bad to me.
- xwdv 5y agoStop conflating someone paying for digital goods as being a “rich person”. If you’re serious about dating, you could afford to spend $10 a month. Most people can make $10 in less than an hour of work. You could probably afford $40 dollars a month easily. Don’t worry, your actual dates will probably cost you more than that and often you’ll get nothing in return... People have been sucking on the teet of free social media for so long that the thought of even paying a couple dollars for something makes them feel they are buying a luxury good, when you are literally just giving up some pocket change. Meanwhile, they buy $5 lattes and $10 burgers a few times a week and pay god knows how much for a myriad of streaming services, without a second thought.
- iLikeFreeData 5y agoAds arent going away, at best you are going to get generic ads that are not relevant. At worse Apple is ramping up their own tracking/ad service.
- kevinventullo 5y agoThere’s a sense in which free ad-supported apps are “redistributive”. Whether you’re rich or poor, Facebook costs the same and the experience and features you have access to are identical. Effectively, the rich users are subsidizing the app for the poor users (the rich users’ eyeballs being worth much more). I personally view that as a strong upside compared to paid models. I’m not sure where I’m going with this. What does paid social media look like? Perhaps more like traditional media: only deep pockets will have access to “virality” and wide distribution. I could certainly see a market for that with the Instagram crowd.
- supernovae 5y agoIt's been years since there was organic viral videos... that ship sailed - we're at the point of pay for play, sex or extremely high risk/danger/endangerment content for eyeballs..
- hedora 5y agoIn the past, we had paid social media (kind of) with services like CompuServe, AOL, etc. People tended to self-segment by demographics. Also, there was more than one network to choose from, since things were segmented by which internet connection you had. (This was also the heyday of BBS’s and Usenet, which probably wasn’t a coincidence.) Maybe having N vertically integrated communities with different norms is better than what facebook, twitter, etc built via their horizontally-integrated services.
- specialist 5y agoMost (all?) prior mediums were initially pay to play. Print, radio, telegraph, TV, cable, fax, ATMs. Then there's some kind of phase change. Like maybe when costs reduce enough for Metcalfe's Law to kick-in. [I don't quite recall what some other theorists have said. Shirky's observations about cost of coordination. McLuhan's distinctions between passive and active engagement (aka push vs pull).] Apple's privacy power play may be the first time someone manages to put the toothpaste back into the tube, for an entire medium and by extension ecosystem. Some mediums, like rail and phones, manage to remain pay to play. Maybe there's something to be learned by compare and contrast.
- tfang17 5y agoNew change has been a huge pain for developers. Apple makes these new privacy announcements and takes all the credit, but pushes work to iOS devs to actually implement.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- schleiss 5y agoMeanwhile, Google's and Facebook's market caps are near all time highs. The invisible hand dictates that the impact may very well be insignificant for those two.
- llIIllIIllIIl 5y agoExcellent
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoWhile I am not a big fan of advertising in some cases it may be a necessary evil. If I was going to see ads, I would prefer that they are: A - generic as to my identity attributes B - Not personalized in any way, except to the site Basically, much closer to the ads back in the 90s. If it works for TV for decades, it can work for the web.
- zenyc 5y agoI’m the opposite. I hate ads that have nothing to do with me. I value my time and I prefer that if I’m going to see an ad, then that ad be something I would find interesting.
- doobeeus 5y agoFollow the money - Apple's "privacy" initiative is just about Apple ensuring that every dollar spent in an iOS device sends 30 cents to Apple. That isn't the case with ads not served by Apple. So Apple is making themselves the only viable way to serve ads on iOS (https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205223 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205223) and encouraging in-app purchases for everything else - problem solved. Also, isn't it convenient that Apple is only concerned about their customer's privacy for business conducted outside of China and Russia?
- vmception 5y agoAs it should and I don’t care. Advertisers and data brokers get no sympathy from me. An Apple ad venue allows for some more uniform controls as well, such as tracking revokable consent of a user’s data, even if you found a way to pay the user for their data at some point.
- doobeeus 5y agoI agree Apple has the right to run the lawful aspects of their business as they see fit but I'm a little concerned about those that think Apple has their back with this privacy scam.
- nojito 5y agoWhy would you be concerned? Going against Facebook/Google and other ad giants is in their DNA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39iKLwlUqBo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39iKLwlUqBo
- vmception 5y agoNow allow us to share only some contacts! And don’t approve apps that use our phone numbers as authentication and to build a social graph with people that uploaded our contact prior.
- nchrys 5y agoI am really puzzled by the negative sentiment around adtech on Hacker News, especially since I would guess that a lot of people here have a salary that depends directly or indirectly on advertising. "Tracking" gets a lot of bad press, so much so that I sometimes wonder if this is not organized by the tech giants (Apple, Google, Facebook) who have access to their own first party and who thus have much less to lose when cross site tracking disappears. Adtech providers only have access to products you buy/see, for a limited time and without any personal data, meanwhile Google and Facebook know everything about you, your friends, your center of interests the places you go to, along with your name but somehow everyone seems hell-bent on abolishing 3rd-party cookies. Apple's own apps are not subject to this change, and as noted by other commenters this will probably shift budgets to subscription of which Apple takes its cut. All this will further the supremacy of walled-gardens and big tech, at the expense of smaller independent players. I'll be honest, there is a creepy feeling when being tracked cross-site, and adtech providers have collectively failed at providing explanations, and a transparent account of how this works and why this is useful. They have also relied on fingerprinting, which has hurt the credibility of the field. The issue is that the replacement that are currently in the works (https://github.com/WICG/floc https://github.com/WICG/floc and https://github.com/WICG/turtledove/blob/main/FLEDGE.md https://github.com/WICG/turtledove/blob/main/FLEDGE.md) are extremely complex, will still dramatically impact adtech performance and only improve privacy for a very contrived definition of the concept which incidentally benefits once again big tech vendors... As to the effectiveness of advertising, removing tracking will have a huge impact. And this affects all players in the value chain, not only adtech providers but also publishers and more importantly advertisers which will see their return on ad spent severely impacted. There is a real of loss "social welfare" (I mean in a game-theoretic sense, but also for real if you believe in capitalism) if tracking is disabled. The freakonomics article gets cited a lot but the industry as a whole is moving forward with a greater emphasis on proving incremental sales. Advanced clients (who can spend billions per year) have real statisticians doing permanent randomized control trials proving that every dollar spent is providing incremental sales. I work for an adtech company and we have automatic RCTs for every single client, and guess what, advertising works for most clients. This is on top of fact that we are measuring the effectiveness of dollars spent on us, in addition to the dollars spent on competitors/other channels on which we have no control of course. The fact that Uber could see no impact when going from 150m to 50m is a testament to the incompetency of their CMO, which could not be bothered to actually measure and pilot the campaigns correctly, not the effectiveness of adtech as a whole. Thoughts are my own not my employer's.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]