15 ms·
WordPress 18
- gogopuppygogo 5y agoI am getting old. I remember when b2 forked to b2evolution and Wordpress. I remember when cpanel started allowing for installations. I’m glad they are doing so well.
- rxsel 5y agoI personally think it’s cool you got to see all that in real time OG :)
- chx 5y agoFor those who were not around that long, here's a brief summary from the b2evolution site https://b2evolution.net/about/b2evolution-vs-wordpress https://b2evolution.net/about/b2evolution-vs-wordpress I haven't been around the open source CMS world this long, I only started with Drupal 17 years ago (to the day as of yesterday) https://i.imgur.com/TsNTYqZ.png https://i.imgur.com/TsNTYqZ.png
- edgyquant 5y agoI remember CPanel and having to set up Wordpress installations or using it to create MySQL databases and install phpmyadmin + setup FTP accounts so I could deploy PHP applications I had written myself. I got into programming during this era to create a website for my uncles store and “share” his hosting to run a forum I built dedicated to Ocarina of Time. I definitely look at those days with rose tinted glasses and had basically forgotten about the time before I used VPSs and knew enough of bash and Linux to set all these things up myself. And even that was quite awhile ago now I write frontend and back ends and deploy them to AWS or Heroku. I guess it just shows how much the web has changed and matured compared to using shared hosting from websites that only a few hundred people max used. This thread is a giant bucket of nostalgia for me and I’m not even 30 yet. Crazy to imagine what the web will be like when I’m 50 longing for the days of React and Flask.
- fogihujy 5y agoWell, cPanel hosting and shared hosting is still a thing. There's a LOT of such hosts around much thanks to WordPress.
- egypturnash 5y agoI think I’ve been using it for my personal site for most of Wordpress’ life, wow. Certainly at least half the project’s life.
- AngeloAnolin 5y agoWordPress is synonymous with the progression of the web. It has allowed a lot of people and businesses to have a digital presence on the web and will likely continue to do so in the coming years. Here's looking for more innovation and possibilities ahead!
- geocrasher 5y agoI left the web hosting business in 2008 and came back in 2013. Prior to 2008, there was a little wordpress, but there was b2, b2 evolution, MovableType, and a lot of the landscape was Perl based. I rejoined the ranks in 2013, and holy smokes. WordPress. WordPress everywhere. It's even more so now. These days, to be in Web Hosting is to be in WordPress Hosting.
- iJohnDoe 5y agoThere are many critics, but WordPress was an integral part in shaping the web today and the blog era.
- gentleman11 5y agoBlogs have gotten worse recently. It was nice for a while, so many people with little hobby sites. Not it’s all content marketing and people branding themselves as experts for career growth. It’s hard to find those old blogs now, they are buried 3 pages deep in search results
- jonny383 5y agoAm I the only one that doesn't like WordPress anymore? The concept was great, but it has basically become a "website builder" and not really a piece of blogging software anymore. Throw on top of it the architecture of plugins (no sandboxing!) and the culture this has developed for websites being "built" with a combination of 50+ outdated plugins and it frankly becomes a nightmare. Of course this can occur with any huge software project, so I somewhat concede this point. The real turning point for me was the push to move to the "block" editor and effectively turn WordPress into Wix or Squarespace or whatever
- acomjean 5y agoI’m newish to wordpress. The Gutenberg block editor is really word presses answer to squarespace( they said so at a talk word camp Boston a couple years ago). But it still has the ability to just type away and write stuff without ever leaving the keyboard. I think it’s not bad. And it gives the graphic designers some control. It’s a weird ecosystem though, you need a solid theme to start and finding those is a little hit or miss. Same with plugins, it’s hard to tell the great from the ok sometimes.
- kijin 5y agoApparently, lots of people want a website builder. We in the startup culture often forget that the market for building bespoke webapps using the latest and greatest frameworks is only a tiny part of the web. The vast majority of people who order websites just want something that works out of the box, and they want it yesterday. I don't think anybody is particularly fond of WordPress's medieval internal structure or its byzantine plugin ecosystem. For the time being, though, I'm glad that there exists a well-known, open-source, self-hosted alternative to Wix and Squarespace. There was a time when lots of people wanted something bloggish. Now that time is over, and WordPress has pivoted accordingly.
- aphextron 5y ago>The concept was great, but it has basically become a "website builder" and not really a piece of blogging software anymore. You can definitely turn it into practically anything, and it quickly becomes a mess due to the fact that it was never meant to be an application platform. But WordPress is still best in class at what it was meant to do; a simple self hosted blog.
- drdavid 5y agoI recall installing it when it was still pretty new, freshly forked from another application. The last time I looked, WP was running ~1/3 of the public-facing web. I use it for all sorts of things, as it makes a perfectly usable CMS. It's easy to keep it updated and secure these days, plus they've had an emphasis on security for a while now - or at least a better attitude with regards to security.
- paxys 5y agoIt's actually 40% now. "Running the web" might be stretching things a bit though, because a ton of sites use it just as a CMS layer for their existing front end or to host their blog subdomain.
- jbergstroem 5y agoDuring the early 2000's I was part of creating a competitor to Wordpress and Pyra labs (blogspot) in Sweden called blogg.se. The reason it succeeded (read: outgrew both at the time, at least regionally) was two-fold: 1) The platform was available in a language the users preferred and 2) there was a human support crew that answered to questions. Many years later, I'm happy to see Wordpress thrive – the power of one person's voice is more important than the platform itself. This is how any platform should work: empower their users, not control them. Localization is mostly a solved problem today but empowering the user and respecting their rights isn't. I hope us developers can help pushing the ball in that direction.
- webmobdev 5y agoWordpress made a great impact on the net, and I was happy when clients liked its ease of use and relieved from the burden of making content changes. (Though, I've always felt that https://textpattern.com/ https://textpattern.com/ was more secure and better than Wordpress).
- ehnto 5y agoI think that's the remarkable thing about wordpress. There have been better engineered platforms consistently, but WordPress wins because it's got a diverse long-tail module ecosystem, an enormous developer pool, and a self-perpetuating userbase.
- throwaway77112 5y agoFun fact - Textpattern and WordPress are both 18yrs old, PHP and GPL.
- ericls 5y agoI still remember the first Wordpress installation, I was in high school, China still had decent connection to outside world, I rented my first VPS, in west coast US, even tho the domain was eventually blocked by the great firewall after a year due to some personal thoughts I posted. But I learnt a lot from it, it’s the first time I tried to read and modify actual code to make things work the way I wanted. Oh and there was a huge community for Wordpress in China, they’d hold those events in top universities in China to talk about Wordpress, PHP, web and technology in general, always wanted to attend. I think things changed now. Exchanging links to each other’s blog was also a huge scene, I still know some of the people, some of them are still blogging, about their lives, kinda like diary, from high school to graduation from college to getting married and having kids.
- Ayesh 5y agoFrom what I see PHP is still very strong in China. There are even frameworks like Swoole, with majority of contributors from China.
- ericls 5y agoI wouldn’t doubt it about PHP, it’s just the fact people gather together to actually discuss and appreciate technology for the sake of it, not wanting to sell something is becoming rare. Or it could be my perspective have changed, and I didn’t realize people were selling things. And the whole blogging community was so great, people exchange links not for SEO, but from appreciation of content or styles.
- aleku 5y agocongratulations! WP has indeed come a long way, I was just checking up on what happened to Mambo, another CMS, and it seems to have fallen off the internet around 2008.
- robjan 5y agoiirc Mambo was forked into Joomla which is still used but nowhere near as much as WordPress
- danellis 5y agoGreat, maybe now it can get fucked! (This is a joke. Please don't respond with the useful applications of WordPress.)
- qshaman 5y ago“Do you know 1/3 of the web runs in Wordpress?“ should be it’s first tattoo
- techdragon 5y agoDoes anyone have recommendations for learning Wordpress if you already experienced with modern practices like GitOps and immutable deployment artefacts (containers/VMs) using more fully featured frameworks like Django and Rails, which have abstractions like ORMs and Migration frameworks to look after all your database changes (within reason obviously since we all know these tools aren’t one size fits all) … I know there’s value in Wordpress even if it’s just potential future revenue supporting a subset of the 1/3rd of the web running on Wordpress. So I’ve pushed but when I loose spend twelve hours over a whole week trying to work out how I’m supposed to manage my database (don’t even get me started on how frustrating it is that you are basically forced to use MySQL) and basically giving up because there both appears to be nothing other than do it yourself with SQL DDL if you don’t want the plug-ins doing it for you, and the fact the web is full of SEO for how to “migrate” your content from one Wordpress site to another hosted somewhere else… Id love some recommendations as it feels like I’m making an uphill slog through a river of 18 years worth of outdated info posted by users and decaying SEO bacon written by developers.
- ebcode 5y agoGet your local environment set up (Linux, nginx, PHP, MySQL), then configure Netbeans with xdebug, and start stepping through the code. I think this is probably both the most painful and most useful way to learn how Wordpress works under the hood. It will probably take you another 12 hours (and another week), but at least those hours won't be wasted. Edit: oh, and take notes while stepping through with the debugger. Having a document you can refer to later that has some kind of outline with your own ideas and opinions is a huge help.
- dawnerd 5y agoUse the official docs instead of going off what people say to do on stackoverflow and the other wp seo spam sites out there. The snippets are often not optimized correctly, using an outdated method, or just insecure. I suggest going through the VIP docs as well as they have some really good advice on securing and speeding up wordpress along with what to avoid. https://docs.wpvip.com/technical-references/ https://docs.wpvip.com/technical-references/ Also just a tip: https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress-Coding-Standards https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress-Coding-Standards
- Nic0 5y agoHate this kind of new, it make me feel old. It's like someone saying to you "Did you know <some child you still see in diapers> is now 18.
- dang 5y agoYes, it's brutal. Other people's kids grow so fast.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoI handled the inherent security risk of WP's plugin architecture by meticulously monitoring the plugin-code/plugin publisher, Firewall, File changes, 2FA Auth etc. I handled the performance drawbacks with best hardware, cache etc. I even accepted the premium for above activities. But random database errors was the final nail in the coffin. After a decade of WP usage, I have ditched it for good. My current web stack for the past 2 years has been - Simple websites- Vanilla HTML, CSS, JS. Blogs - Hugo. Complex Web Applications with CMS - Custom Go framework. I understand that none of the above is applicable to someone who doesn't have web-development experience, Even in that case website-builiders[1] are a better option than WP. At this point, the only reason I'm not nuclear on WP is because I believe there's a thriving economy based on WP especially from developing countries. [1]https://startuptoolchain.com/#website-builders https://startuptoolchain.com/#website-builders (Disclaimer: Mine).
- MangoCoffee 5y ago> there's a thriving economy based on WP a lot of digital marketing/service company use WP to quickly setup a website for their client. my current employer's website is a WP site build by a third party.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoYep, But I really don't know whether that's for good or bad overall. Good for that 'digital marketing/service company', But there are better options for your employer in terms of cost/performance/security; Better options have been available for over past 5 years.
- aik 5y agoI’m curious what options you are considering here that are comparable and don’t take 10x more technical skill and time? Sites like Squarespace or Wix? Or Webflow?
- Abishek_Muthian 5y ago
- ramphastidae 5y agoDoes it make anyone else nervous that 40% of the web is run on software with such a poor track record when it comes to security?
- Andrex 5y agoAnything highly-used will be a larger target by default I'd guess.
- mrweasel 5y agoIsn’t just the “Windows” of the internet? It’s heavily used, directly exposed to the internet, so it’s a bigger target, hence more bugs a found (and exploited).
- mekster 5y agoIf you'd have ever looked at the WordPress source code, you know why it's been having a crappy track record. It's one of the easiest example of "don't code like this".
- ipaddr 5y agoThose issues went away with the automatic updates feature.
- photomatt 5y agoRCEs are rare enough now that the price has grown to 300k for a zero day: https://wptavern.com/zerodium-temporarily-triples-payout-to-300k-for-wordpress-exploits https://wptavern.com/zerodium-temporarily-triples-payout-to-...
- neurostimulant 5y agoNot if you choose your plugins and theme carefully.
- rchaud 5y agoThe 'poor track record' reputation comes from the giant number of mom-and-pop sites that got compromised. I imagine 40% of the web is really just a handful of massive commercial websites that have developers on hand to take care of security, backups, devops etc.
- wimagguc 5y agoTrying to decide between these: (a) Wordpress (b) SquareSpace (c) https://strapi.io/ https://strapi.io/ (d) https://prismic.io/ https://prismic.io/ (e) https://www.contentful.com/ https://www.contentful.com/ The output will be a simple website, we already have all pages in HTML, and from the tech perspective we could use any of the above. What I've seen was: SquareSpace is still rather limited, Prismic and Contentful are around $500 per month in their non-free-tier, and Strapi is just too expensive to find devs for. Plus their editor looks the same as Wordpress's if I'm honest. On the other hand, Wordpress has a massive community of reasonably priced freelancers, has updates many times a year, and most things you want out of the box (such as SEO, or easy hosting on Heroku or elsewhere). The only thing it doesn't have is the excitement to work with it :) Is there a good business case for any of the competitors?
- raffijacobs 5y agoMy current headless CMS choice is sanity.io. you'd still need a dev for the frontend and sanity schema setup probably.
- fake-name 5y agoSquarespace has somehow managed to make <img> tags require 3rd party javascript to work. I cannot take them as anything other then grossly incompetent.
- cstuder 5y agoChoose boring technology. WordPress is 18 years old, there's a good chance that it will be around for quite some time longer.
- john-shaffer 5y agoConsider a static WordPress site via the WP2Static plugin: https://wp2static.com https://wp2static.com Going static solves most of the performance and security problems with WordPress. There's a prebuilt Docker setup at https://lokl.dev/ https://lokl.dev/ and an AWS template at https://staticweb.io/open-source/wordpress/ https://staticweb.io/open-source/wordpress/ There are also commercial hosts (with their own plugins) at https://www.strattic.com/ https://www.strattic.com/ and https://www.hardypress.com/ https://www.hardypress.com/ I've worked a bit with Contentful, and it seemed like a pretty good CMS, but pricey. The client was moving off of it because they wanted the more familiar WordPress UI.
- JakeNm 5y agoPretty awesome for a guy who studied jazz saxophone and political science. You may have to say a lot of things about Wordpress etc but I know a lot of arrogant computer science people with Phds who think they are programmers but have created nothing in particular.
- Hard_Space 5y agoI wish WordPress would bake a flat site exporter directly into an install, instead of forcing folks to mess about with plugins.
- runningmike 5y agoSimple in use and simple to extend. Still powerful and showcase for continuous innovation without large disruptions. The example that gpl software can be very successful.
- ilaksh 5y agoPersonally I think despite being unpopular with many developers (I dropped PHP/WP for most purposes many years ago due to the amount of hate it was getting and general poor reputation) and the problems of the past, the concept of plugins and what you can do with WordPress is terrific. And not something that anyone who really understands software engineering should scoff at. I would go so far as to invite the downvotes with a comment like this: WordPress may now be the most powerful (low-code/no-code) application development platform ever created. What is the WordPress of the 2020s? Something built on web assembly or TypeScript or Python or whatever maybe?
- rchaud 5y ago> I would go so far as to invite the downvotes with a comment like this: WordPress may now be the most powerful (low-code/no-code) application development platform ever created. And you would be correct. The WP API is mature and stable, so much so that tools around fast WP scaffolding are already available. You can create a site in Webflow, export the HTML and use a tool like Pinegrow Theme Converter to attach WP functions to HTML elements, such as Posts loop, ACF fields, WP Customizer, etc. No PHP knowledge needed. Pinegrow will export a fully featured WP theme to your site folder, and handle enqueuing the functions and stylesheets. You never have to open functions.php again. Add to that the vast library of plugins for things like Ecommerce, online courses, appointment scheduling, user accounts, social networking etc. and you can create a pretty complex prototype.
- mbgerring 5y agoWordPress is like Craigslist in that software engineers hate it, but everyone else happily uses it, and both are thriving businesses providing a sustainable livelihood to their employees and owners instead of trying to take over the world. You should be so lucky to invent something as well-loved and as useful as WordPress, and to stick to your principles for as long as Matt has.
- musicnotwords 5y agoThe headaches are simply not worth it. No designer should be using WordPress for client websites in the age of squarespace/wix. It is just irresponsible to build something for a client that is going to break itself within 1-2 years max.
- weird-eye-issue 5y agoIt completely depends. I think building a site on Squarespace/Wix can very easily be considered irresponsible. edit: For Wordpress only install reputable, necessary plugins. Turn on auto-update. Keep backups. Things should be just fine. Now you aren't locked into a single platform and you can extend your website as much as needed (unlike Squarespace/Wix which severely limit what you can do).
- Hard_Space 5y ago> Turn on auto-update Having been paid quite well to migrate to and from WordPress, and to help maintain the WP sites of major publishers, I have to say that this is questionable advice. In most cases in my experience, the publisher has employed third-party providers (at huge cost) to develop frameworks and custom plugins that can easily be broken by automatic updates. Updates need evaluation and testing in staging sites before they can be rolled out. For publishers, the first install of WP is free - everything after that costs plenty.
- weird-eye-issue 5y agoLike you said, "major publishers" will have those problems due to custom code. Not the sort of websites where Wix or Squarespace would have ever even entered the conversation. You need to keep context in mind.
- strzibny 5y agoI used WP for various sites and blogs, and now I am left with one last instance, which I refuse to babysit, and will just turn it off. I had enough.
- maxgashkov 5y agoWhile WP's ecosystem is nothing less than impressive, but I'm still in shock to this day, how cumbersome is site migration. For me and I guess for many other engineers it's quite normal to develop a site locally (or at least on a staging non-public domain name) and then move it into production under the final name. In Wordpress, the site name is baked in all over the place — in config, in database, in generated stylesheets and so on. In theory, this should not be like this (if you use barebones install w/o plugins), but then you buy a theme or some less-than-perfect plugin and boom, you need a separate plugin just to handle migration (which may or may not work 100% of the time).
- dragosmocrii 5y agoInstalling a WordPress site is actually very straightforward, in fact the platform is famous for its 5 minutes install. What you are describing as hard to achieve is copying state that is kept in the database, but I don't think this is an inherent issue to WordPress. But if you are creating the entire site locally and want to deploy it to production, it seems that WordPress may jot be the right solution in your case, instead a static site generator would be more appropriate.
- akie 5y agoThat's categorically untrue. Almost all websites are first developed by a developer on his local machine, and then when it's ready to showcase or put online, it will move to the 'real' domain. It is no different for WordPress, and it's true that moving a WordPress site from one domain to another is a bit of a headache. It should be "gather all things, move it to another place, change the domain name somewhere", but instead it's "gather all things, move it to another place, change all the links, change the domain name in two different places, hope you didn't forget anything or made a mistake somewhere". There are plugins to help you do this though, but all-in-all it's an annoying inconvenience.
- michelb 5y agoMaybe, but I do this on a weekly basis and even with complex custom sites/apps it takes me less than 10 mins to change the urls everywhere throughout the site/database. Decent plugins indeed exist to make this super simple.
- nodex-alex 5y ago18 years of polluting the planet with bloated and bad code, breeding insecure developers writing insecure plugins and themes. Kudos!
- codeduck 5y agoI run a small website on wp. Every time I update it I take a backup first. One every couple of days on average I think about replacing it with something custom. But the sad thing is that I don't know enough of the CSS side to make the site look good without some sort of theme support like wp has.
- forgotpwd16 5y agoHow the three big CMS (WordPress, Joomla!, Drupal) compare nowadays?
- edtechdev 5y agoDrupal has become more targeted to enterprise. For sites you're developing yourself, wordpress can do the same stuff as drupal now, especially with advanced custom fields (ACF). Another alternative is Statamic.
- bacheson1293 5y agostatamic is incredible...I can't recommend it enough...such a breath of fresh air
- jackmcdade 5y agoThanks for the kind words!
- open-source-ux 5y agoHaving never peeked at WordPress internals, can someone give examples of what they see as poor code at the heart of WordPress? It is 18 years old, is the code really still a mess? WordPress alternatives like Wix or Squarespace are closed-source, but the HTML/CSS generated by these services is simply dreadful. As for Static Site Generators (SSG) - liked by developers but by no-one else - they are particularly unsuitable for non-technical users and lacking in features (by design). They are certainly not a serious alternative to WordPress.
- mpol 5y agoIt has a very different architecture from what web developers are used to. It has an event driven architecture, somewhat like C. During the process of running the code on a HTTP request, there are multiple hooks (actions and filters) that get called, where you can attach your own function in a plugin or theme. About 5 years ago I saw a lot of requests like "When will WordPress move to MVC?", but those questions seem to have died out mostly. Then there is the OOP architecture of data and communication that is loved by a lot of developers. I think Joomla and Drupal have moved into this direction. This makes the code in WordPress look oldfashioned, it is partly still procedural code, with some classes added into it. WordPress community very much wants things to be backwards compatible, and so far that works out.
- michelb 5y agoBeen working with it for the past 15 years, and made a good business on it. It's relatively easy to create a hardened install that will -most likely- not get hacked. Slap a caching solution on it and performance is not a problem. Name me an alternative CMS frontend that any client can use to update/create content (without learning Markdown) and visually design a page with pre-defined blocks, that doesn't cost $200+ a month. If only they would include a localisation solution, I could say goodbye to slow and cumbersome WPML.
- andrei_says_ 5y agoCraftcms is excellent.
- michelb 5y agoCraft is indeed a decent alternative. I haven't tried v3 but v2 was horribly slow on sites with a lot of custom fields.
- andrei_says_ 5y agov3 is snappy and the built in caching mechanisms can help a lot with performance. It is flexible, fast, and secure - especially on a host that specializes in craftcms - like Fortrabbit - and combined with cloud flare.
- pembrook 5y agoWebflow, squarespace, etc will do that for 1/10th that price.
- rchaud 5y agoBoth have vendor lock-in though. A WordPress site is portable, it runs on anything with PHP and MySQL. SQspace and Webflow only run on their own servers.
- 5y ago
- dmje 5y agoEvery time there’s a WP post on HN, there’s the inevitable haters. The ones who say things like “just setup a static site with a CI pipeline”. The understanding of audience here is pretty bad. Your average business owner wants to focus on the important thing: their content. They want to type in a box and push publish. End. They don’t care about how crap (or not) the code is. They don’t care about performance too much. They do want to have the extensibility that is offered. They don’t want to get locked in (cough, Wix, Squarespace). The thing is, of course you can fk this up. Install Wordpress on crap hosting, install 100 plugins, fail to keep them updated - things are going to go badly. But now think about what happens if you do the same with literally any bit of software, even the hip jamstack stuff doing the rounds right now. There is good. There is bad. There are people who claim they “do Wordpress” when in fact they can just install plugins and a builder theme. There are people who do it well, with good deployment, repo management, backups, updates. But the end thing is always the same. Your site owners / editors just want something flexible where they can make content changes. They want familiar. They want flexible. There are times when Wordpress is the wrong solution. There are bad ways of doing it. But, really, you can’t argue with 40% of the web.
- loloquwowndueo 5y agoWhile I agree with this, careful with the “can’t argue with LARGE_PERCENTAGE of GROUP”. Windows is used by 95% of desktop computers and yet is really crap. Or - “eat crap - 75 billion flies can’t be wrong!”
- dmje 5y agoYeh, sure - but two things come out of this "dominance". One: the enormous quantity of support online. Have a problem with littleknownbutcoolcms? You're stuffed. Have a problem with WP? 10 gazillion people have written about it. Then two: clients want it because it's familiar, they've used it before, they've got another site using it, etc etc. So yeh, I take your point, but it's the peripheral stuff that makes this important IMO.
- robjan 5y agoWindows is crap because of, not in spite of, it being used by 95% of people and therefore has to be compatible and backwards compatible with everything.
- modernerd 5y agoI'm glad WordPress is 18 and successful. I wish it had stronger open source competition. WP is ripe for disruption in so many areas: ||| Price ||| WP succeeded in part because it was cheap and easy to host. This is still true to an extent but the story is weaker than it was. WP hosting is a race-to-the-bottom market, but hosting secure, fast WP sites with good backup and support remains valuable. The WP hosting market matured and there are enough customers who won't pay for cheap hosting because they've seen their sites get hacked or experienced performance and reliability issues. This supports an industry offering expensive managed hosting at a high markup tiered by monthly visits. So it's not surprising that Squarespace/Wix/Shopify price points are no longer the turn-off they used to be for many at the low to mid end, and that larger businesses are looking at Jamstack and static sites for the potential cost savings at the mid to high end. Takeaway: A CMS built for “start for free” hosting platforms like Cloudflare Pages and Netlify could provide an even more compelling story than WP, reignite the DIY open source site building movement, and be a more natural fit for enterprise customers. The “Jamstack” movement is the closest thing we have to this, but there's no strong frontrunner that includes both a modern and compelling admin area for publishers coupled to the mechanisms for previewing, building, and deploying a site out of the box. Devs still have to cobble pieces together into a semi-coherent whole. This is currently touted as a strength because you can “use the best tools for your unique scenario”, but it might be healthier for the Jamstack community to start treating this as a major flaw blocking wider adoption instead. That way they could just build a good apple pie instead of asking everyone to first create the universe. ||| Deployment ||| When technical users in a company get to pick the stack, it is easier, cheaper, and faster to deploy to Netlify/Cloudflare|GitHub Pages/Vercel using modern deployment practices (like the ability to preview multiple deployments — one for each PR) than it is to ship updates to a WP host. Cloudflare Pages pricing is also tiered on deploys/month instead of visits/month or bandwidth, which is more palatable for most. Takeaway: A headless CMS that deployed the admin app and website to an edge network could outperform WP for ease of deployment, performance, affordability, and access to other built-in perks of edge hosting platforms that are hard and expensive to get right with WP today (caching, security). ||| Marketplace ||| WP.org offers free plugins and themes, but it still does not (and may never) offer paid themes and plugins. This makes commercial WP options decentralized, but it provides users with a poor experience: comparing, purchasing, updating, and getting support for paid themes/plugins is a wild west that is still harder and more frustrating than it should be. It also means anyone who wants to sell themes or plugins has to manage their own sales infrastructure. Takeaway: A CMS platform with a built-in marketplace could be more compelling than WP for end-users. It could also pull plugin and theme developers away from WP — most plugin/theme devs would probably prefer to spend their time making themes and plugins than figuring out how to sell and deliver updates securely. ||| UX and ease of use ||| WP can be overwhelming for new users, in part because of the disconnect between the promise on its homepage (“the freedom to build anything you want“) and the journey people have to go on to achieve that lofty goal. The main issue is that there is no real guidance — you can build an ecommmerce site or a podcasting network or a gated content blog or a newsletter or even just a simple blog with WordPress, but in all cases you're basically on your own to figure out how to achieve those things. Yes, there are a huge number of blog posts with titles like, “9 Best WordPress LMS Plugins to Sell Courses” and “We Pretended to Test the 46 Best WordPress Contact Form Plugins and Then Just Recommended the One that Gives us the Highest Affiliate Commission” that you can sift through, but WordPress itself gives you very little help. Takeaway: A modern CMS or user-friendly application platform that claimed you could “build anything you want” would actively help you to do that. It could perhaps offer starter templates for different scenarios, tutorials, or _basically anything at all_ that didn't just dump you into an admin area that was last refreshed in 2013 containing some vestigial apparatus for blogging but no real clues as to how to even succeed with that goal let alone anything more complex. ||| Localization ||| It's 2021 and you still need plugins to translate content in WordPress. Naturally there are a lot of localization plugins that you'll have to compare and experiment with first, and you'll find that all of them offer a worse experience than you can get with a hosted CMS like Contentful or GraphCMS. The good news is that built-in content localization is on WP's product roadmap, so this should eventually improve. The other positive is that while content localization is pretty bad in WP right now, plugin/theme localization is generally quite good. Takeaway: there's a small window of opportunity here to present a more compelling content localization experience than WP does by default. ||| PHP and the developer experience ||| A large number of developers who use WordPress would rather not. (WP was the “most dreaded platform” in Stack Overflow's 2020 survey with 67% of developers who are using it not expressing an interest in continuing to do so.[1]) Of more concern for the health of WordPress is that new web developers generally aren't picking PHP. It's not even that PHP is especially bad these days, and even WP APIs are gradually improving — it's just that new developers targeting the web as a platform are probably writing JavaScript or TypeScript. And, because they're not writing PHP, they might not choose WordPress if a compelling alternative existed in the language they prefer. Yes, Headless WordPress is a thing, and every WP host is jumping on that boat because they can see the writing on the wall. But WP is going to be tightly coupled with PHP for a long time, and that may be an opportunity for a CMS that can attract new blood simply because “we use your favorite language instead of PHP” becomes a competitive advantage. ||| ECommerce ||| WooCommerce is used for a huge volume of transactions ($20 billion a year was mentioned in State of the Word 2020). But if you need to build an online store today, Shopify is in most cases a quicker and more stable path that will let you focus on your business and products, simply because it's built for commerce out of the box. If you need to sell products casually, Gumroad/Stripe Payment Links[2] are probably a better choice than WooCommerce. If you need to gate content behind a paywall on a multi-author content site, Ghost is increasingly a more compelling choice than WP, since it includes subscription commerce as well as audience building and outreach features by default: https://ghost.org/features/ https://ghost.org/features/ WP can be an ecommerce platform, but it isn't one by default. Making WP do ecommerce feels very much like any other form of digital alchemy or contortion. A CMS built from day one with commerce and monetization in mind would look quite different to WP. It could be all the more compelling for users who want those options out of the box. [1]: https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology-most-loved-dreaded-and-wanted-platforms-dreaded5 https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology-mo... [2]: https://stripe.com/en-at/payments/payment-links https://stripe.com/en-at/payments/payment-links
- CaptArmchair 5y agoI've used WordPress for a personal blog since 2005. Over the years, I switched hosting, different versions of PHP / MySQL, upgrades to WordPress,... But one thing I've never done was exporting all my content and then importing it in a fresh installation. Yes, I tinkered with SQL statements and I went through manual cleaning if an overzealous plugin didn't clean up properly after itself. But I never ran into the wall where the entire database got into an irreparable, unusable state. It's a simple blog. So, I've always tried to use plugins sparingly, and avoided massive database model changes if I could help it. But I like to think it wouldn't have been possible without the care put into WordPress upgrade path. At the same time, the focus on backward compatibility, to my mind, has held it back. Sure, innovation happened at the visible level, the surface level. New themes, new administration UI, Gutenberg, Blocks,... all of that have improved the author experience. But looking under the hood, the codebase simply isn't in line with modern PHP practices adopted by major PHP framework communities. Which leaves quite a lot to be desired for. Granted, part of the appeal of Wordpress is simply being able to grab the PHP files and (S)FTP them to a shared hosting. No need for complex CI, no need for composer, no need for complex configuration. That's what lowers the bars for many people who simply wanted their own self-hosted space on the Web. My other major gripe is how WordPress authoring experience evolved over time into a direction which I don't agree with. The editor in modern WordPress feels heavy handed: every item you add to an article morphs into a distinct component accompanied by a contextual menu with myriad options. I feel that this just gets in the way of what's actually important: writing. Personally, I like(d) the terseness of a simple textarea form element with limited affordances as to what you can add in terms of markup. Then again, the ambitions of Automattic are beyond simple writing and moved even beyond authoring and publishing. I think that's just par for the course and I don't fault them for that. It just has made WordPress less of a good fit for me over the years and that leaves me some with a sense of saudade. Either way, I owe a lot to WordPress. And I'm curious to see how it will evolve in the years to come.
- egypturnash 5y agoOh god the Gutenberg editor, ugh. The day they EOL the “use the old editor” plugin is the day I finally consider moving to something else to run my personal site. I do not need that shit and I do not want to crack open the multiple custom styles involved in my site to make them work with that shit.
- ddon 5y agoNew page builder just came out, may be someone will be interested in trying - https://bricksbuilder.io https://bricksbuilder.io Looks like a combination of Elementor + Oxygen, and looks like it is producing very clean HTML and some how compatible with Gutenberg (haven't tried this yet)
- rchaud 5y agoI've heard good things about it as well. Interested in trying it out.
- iamkdev 5y agoIt's empowered the web and countless people able to feed themselves. Yes, WP works does leads to messy code, but that's also how people learned what's makes things messy. Thank you WP
- deltron3030 5y agoI've switched from the Jamstack/static site generators to nocode WordPress for content sites, to focus my coding more on app UIs in the long term. Jamstack is nice, but it's either for personal developer blogs or larger teams. Outsourcing is too expensive with coders being in high demand. Everything WP can be easily outsourced when needed, and there really isn't much of a speed benefit with Jamstack sites if you cache your WP site on the edge (e.g. with Cloudflare APO) and use a fast DNS. Security of the origin server isn't a problem with a good host or going static. You can generate static sites from a local WP install if you find secure hosting too expensive, here's a nice docker based tool for this: https://lokl.dev/ https://lokl.dev/ WP is really as hard, ugly fast or slow as you make it, you have to find the right theme and plugin ecosystem within WP. I don't have to and don't need touch the code building sites with it, so all those weird WP code conventions don't really bother me.
- alberth 5y agoI wonder what the exit strategy is for the VC's behind Automattic. It doesn't seem like Matt has any intent to go public, yet he's raised $700M+ [0]. I've heard anecdotally it's a profitable company but not sure if that's still the case after the Tumblr acquisition. [0] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/automattic https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/automattic
- indymike 5y agoSoftware lasts way longer than you expect it will when you write it. WordPress is one of those apps that continues to endure despite lots of criticism: bad license, insecure, badly engineered have all been lobbed at it... and here we are 18 years old, 40% of websites use it... So, congrats to Matt and really, the entire WP community.
- hahahasure 5y agoWhat bad license?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- daitangio 5y agoMy humble experience with Wordpress is very good. I used it for my blog and decided to not write a single line of code, because I would use my time to write articles: https://gioorgi.com https://gioorgi.com I started using it on 2004 about 17 years ago. I migrated about 4-5 times my VM provider, doing backup and never lost a bit. After moving to a fast provider, my machine works fine, and I find out JetPack is quite a CPU eater; now I prefer a more huge set of plugins and avoid JetPack. I used it sometime for building customer's Web Site, and, yes, Drupal was better for general purpose CMS at least on 2009. But Ghost did not buy me and I think WordPress is still a good tool.
- baby 5y agoI wish more people used wordpress instead of medium or stacksomething or whatever is trendy. Wordpress works, it has an rss feed, it doesn’t have a paywall, it really is all about content.
- rchaud 5y agoMedium offers an audience, and it's human for people to want their work to be read and feel validated. I have friends who share their blog posts and social media and have it read that way. Unfortunately my own blogs are quite niche in topics, and there wouldn't be much value in sharing socially as my network wouldn't really get it.