32 ms·
The media's lab leak fiasco
- timtas 5y agoThis is pretty anemic self reflection. He never even mentions how the scientific establishment was corralled into compliance with the favored narrative by the Lancet letter organized by Daszak, who was a key player funding gain of function research that involved Wuhan and how that letter was the basis for a year of “fact checking” and cancellation. He didn’t mention how the Washington Post just changed a 15-month-old headline (of the story he links to) to make themselves look better. This reporter and his ilk are now busily ignoring or downplaying connections of the US government and Fauci to funding of gain of of function research in which the Wuhan lab was involved. (Cuz Rand Paul already made up his mind or something.) They won’t really learn anything from this sorry episode.
- OldGoodNewBad 5y agoThey are eating crow, Orange Man was right again.
- npilk 5y agoI thought this was a fascinating read. I’d love to see more analysis like this of what exactly people said, and how it was quoted and characterized in the media.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- newaccount2021 5y agoIts very simple - Trump promoted the lab hypothesis, so mainstream media immediately seized on the notion that it was a crank conspiracy
- musicale 5y agoFrom the article: "This is not to apologize for the bad coverage but, if anything, to underscore how egregious it was to lean so heavily into the Tom Cotton Is Wrong narrative"
- partiallypro 5y agoTo me what gives me credence to the "lab leak theory" more than anything, was China's behavior during and initially after the outbreak. Where they thwarted any investigations from WHO or anyone else and arrested journalists even attempting to cover it. Now we have additional information of lab workers being sick back in November...I genuinely wonder why people immediately jumped in to defend China's actions through the entire thing. I feel like it was in part because of money interests and also because it was something Trump touted as true.
- tristanj 5y agoThe biggest sign for me is how the Chinese government threatened to charge medical workers with espionage if they speak about what happened during the early stages of the outbreak. https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/11/9833532bb925-chinas-authorities-issue-gag-order-about-virus-to-doctors-in-wuhan.html https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/11/9833532bb925-chin... Consider the following: How can a medical worker speaking about their own experience working at a hospital in any way constitute espionage? If found guilty of espionage, by law they can be executed. Anyone who speaks up can be killed.
- bsder 5y agoThe problem is that this is Standard Operating Procedure(tm) for China for anything which might upset the hoi-polloi. Trying to predict what China will execute people for is like reading entrails.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> The problem is that this is Standard Operating Procedure(tm) for China When you say "China", do you mean the Department of Health, or the Department of Defense, or the Department of Trade, or the Chinese government, or the Chinese people, or some Chinese guy? It makes as much sense to attribute a Standard Operating Procedure to "China" as it does to attribute something like that to "America", or to say "Americans think...", which is not very much at all, because America, like all societies of more than one person, is a pluralist society. China is 1.3 billion people. If you treat it as a collection of different interests and points of view, your analyses and predictions will have more cogency.
- deadalus 5y agoReminder that Facebook and Twitter banned users for talking about the lab-leak theory. Youtube accounts also got demontized/banned.
- andybak 5y agoI'm generally in favour of the actions taken against misinformation but this situation surprises me. Lab leak always seemed plausible and non-crazy even if you think the odds are against it. I don't envy the task of making a call on any of this stuff.
- generalizations 5y agoIf we accept that taking action against misinformation is good, then this sort of mistake will inevitably happen. If you're in favor of taking action against misinformation, then you should be willing to accept this situation as an acceptable failure. I'm not willing to accept that.
- noofen 5y agoWho would've thought that letting billionaires with international business interests censor scientific inquiry would end badly...
- ytpete 5y agoIt's really hard to view this as suppressing scientific inquiry. Scientists don't use public Facebook posts to collaborate on their research, nor to share their final results with the rest of the scientific community. It's also very hard to picture social media giants ever blocking users from posting anything that comes from peer-reviewed published science.
- chipotle_coyote 5y ago> If you're in favor of taking action against misinformation, then you should be willing to accept this situation as an acceptable failure. We can believe taking action against misinformation is a generally good principle while still believing that both our definition of "misinformation" and the kinds of actions we take may need to be improved.
- medium_burrito 5y ago"The past never had been altered. Oceania was at war with Eastasia. Oceania had always been at war with Eastasia."
- danboarder 5y agoOne problem with politically charged issues is that one's bias can significantly color unresolved factual issues. In the article the early 'red flags' pointed out in the January 2020 study by The Lancet left clear open questions regarding the Seafood Market hypothesis, but many in the media glossed over these red flags. Now that additional facts are coming to light including the fact that multiple scientists at the lab were hospitalized with Covid like symptoms in late 2019, the facts are starting to pierce through the early dismissal of the lab leak theory by many journalists. I think this will result in a rethink of how we tag unresolved topics as "False Information" or before enough facts are gathered. Perhaps a "Controversial" tag would be preferred. I really like the site https://www.allsides.com/ https://www.allsides.com/ that provides Left/Center/Right bias indicators for any story so you can read all sides and get the gist of how politics is coloring current stories in the media. (1) https://www.allsides.com/tags/wuhan-lab?search=wuhan%20lab#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=wuhan%20lab&gsc.page=1 https://www.allsides.com/tags/wuhan-lab?search=wuhan%20lab#g...
- generalizations 5y ago> I think this will result in a rethink of how we tag unresolved topics as "False Information" or before enough facts are gathered. Perhaps a "Controversial" tag would be preferred. If anything, it will taint the credibilty of people who claim they have the insight to tag the information's credibility in the first place.
- crystalmeph 5y agoThat would actually be a silver lining in my opinion.
- cheeseomlit 5y ago>I think this will result in a rethink of how we tag unresolved topics as "False Information" or before enough facts are gathered. Wishful thinking perhaps, somehow I doubt most of the media/gov't figures who dismissed these claims did so in good faith to begin with.
- 5y ago
- Leary 5y agoThe US has intelligence that three Wuhan virologists were hospitalized. China says nobody was sick. It's quite simple, the US should release the names of those who were sick.
- cratermoon 5y agoThey never will, because there is no such intelligence, it was reported as a statement from an unnamed intelligence official. It's garbage.
- whydoibother 5y agoIt is really a shame people fall for this garbage after Iraq.
- cratermoon 5y agoah yes, the phantom yellowcake
- cbHXBY1D 5y agoMy favorite over the top intelligence claim from that era was that Saddam had a "human shredder" which he used on his enemies. Turns out it never existed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saddam_Hussein%27s_alleged_shredder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saddam_Hussein%27s_alleged_shr...
- caddemon 5y agoWhat incentive would the US government have to lie about this though? They were funding research at that lab, I don't understand why they would want people to think lab leak is correct all of a sudden - if that's what you're claiming?
- undersuit 5y agoThe US probably isn't lying, the foreign source they got the info from might be. We won't know more unless the matter is further declassified or investigated.
- nodesocket 5y agoHopefully people will start to realize that questioning norms and diversity of thought should be accepted on social media. Silencing and suppression of questions and thought by media is rampant and occurs here on Hacker News as well. The population as a whole (especially under the age of 30) feels like a bunch of sheep to me these days. They can't think freely, question things, or ask hard questions. They all just want to fit in. Ideology that doesn't align with bit tech and social media agendas is quickly dismissed as right-wing idiocracy.
- Moodles 5y agoThe media is so disappointing these days. A lot of people don't remember this, but the mainstream media outlets were actually playing down the coronavirus pandemic at the start. Then they attacked the travel ban to China. Then did a complete U-turn. Pelosi was dancing in the streets of Chinatown San Francisco to prove how safe and not racist she is. It seemed like they hated Trump and would fight anything he did. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/time-for-a-reality-check-america-the-flu-is-a-much-bigger-threat-than-coronavirus-for-now/2020/01/31/46a15166-4444-11ea-b5fc-eefa848cde99_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/time-for-a-reality-che... https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/02/03/why-we-should-be-wary-an-aggressive-government-response-coronavirus/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/02/03/why-we-sho... https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/18/world/europe/coronavirus-stigma-europe.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/18/world/europe/coronavirus-... https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/01/29/800813299/worried-about-catching-the-new-coronavirus-in-the-u-s-flu-is-a-bigger-threat https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/01/29/8008132... I saw a viral clip of the Kayleigh McEnany pointing out this hypocrisy and the immediate response as she dropped the mic and walked off was someone in the press shouting "you were prepared for that!". No shit she was prepared for that? That's her job? How is that a bad thing? Oh, because your gotcha question didn't work. Ridiculous.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoThis last year alone has made me lose more faith in the democratic party and the media altogether. Not only did they push a radical agenda with retribution, they did it like religious people used to do centuries ago. Don't challenge the status quo or face reprecussions (fine, demobilization, banned). Now egg on their faces.
- throwawayboise 5y agoThe media, the left, and big tech are all clearly working on the same agenda.
- HKH2 5y agoI can't see any other explanation for why YouTube would give its supposed competitors, the legacy media, prime spots on its site.
- Empact 5y agoAs for policy consequences, how about this one: The United States directly and indirectly funded the Wuhan laboratory, and so bears some responsibility for the virus. It also appears Fauci and others were aware of the deficiencies of the institution. The US should end its support for dangerous research in institutions outside of its purview.
- unyttigfjelltol 5y agoFauci would have been pushed aside, along with EcoHealth Alliance. The biggest policy consequence is in the headline-- our leaders in health and media would have possessed a lot more credibility than they do now. The consequences of 'polarization' of facts can't be overstated.
- speeder 5y agoI am not from US. Back during early pandemy when not only some US politicians blamed China, Chinese politicians blamed US, when people asked me in person about it, I would explain that both are saying the truth. Obama banned gain of function research in 2015, right after some papers about Coronavirus specifically attracted attention. The fact that US government continued not just gain of function research, but research into Coronavirus exactly, that was what caused the ban in first place, is something I think the US citizens really need to figure out what to do about it.
- louloulou 5y agoIt continued because the ban on GOF research was lifted in 2017 (https://www.nih.gov/about-nih/who-we-are/nih-director/statements/nih-lifts-funding-pause-gain-function-research https://www.nih.gov/about-nih/who-we-are/nih-director/statem...)
- Paradigma11 5y agoAfaik the US did not fund GoF research in the Wuhan Lab which is blamed. How did funding different research make the US responsible?
- aazaa 5y ago> ... Evidence in favor of leak theory lowers the status of the media and raises the status of Tom Cotton but doesn’t drastically alter the policy landscape. That's a very peculiar statement coming from someone who just admitted to missing the 21st century's biggest story to date. And I suspect he's now being too quick to discount the effect on not only the political landscape, but the journalistic landscape as well.
- nyczomg 5y agoIt's incredible. If the lab leak theory is true, then a virus escaped from a lab in China and caused the deaths of millions of people. And at the time this happened, the Chinese government did everything it could to hide that from the world. And for some reason, a large part of the US media and tech establishments went along with the ruse and were nice enough to censor or attempt to discredit/destroy anyone who suggested that the virus didn't come from a wet market, but instead possibly came from the Institute of Virology down the street. And if we somehow find that all of the above is true, there are people who say that this isn't really a big deal from a policy perspective? What in the actual fuck??
- twoodfin 5y agoIf it had been a lab in Colorado, under the nominal supervision of some Trump crony, I think it indeed would have been something of “a big deal from a policy perspective”! I like Yglesias, but it’s pretty blinkered to limit “policy impact” to “what to do about biological threat research”. Maybe this means having unanswerable autocracies around is bad and we should try (however ineffectually) to change that state of affairs?
- cratermoon 5y ago"If the question is “are both hypotheses possible?” the answer is yes. Both are possible. If the question is “are they equally likely?” the answer is absolutely not. One hypothesis requires a colossal cover-up and the silent, unswerving, leak-proof compliance of a vast network of scientists, civilians, and government officials for over a year. The other requires only for biology to behave as it always has, for a family of viruses that have done this before to do it again. The zoonotic spillover hypothesis is simple and explains everything. It’s scientific malpractice to pretend that one idea is equally as meritorious as the other. The lab-leak hypothesis is a scientific deus ex machina, a narrative shortcut that points a finger at a specific set of bad actors. I would be embarrassed to stand up in front of a room of scientists, lay out both hypotheses, and then pretend that one isn’t clearly, obviously better than the other" https://massivesci.com/articles/sars-cov-coronavirus-covid19-lab-leak-hypothesis/ https://massivesci.com/articles/sars-cov-coronavirus-covid19...
- throwaway69123 5y agoThe reality of this quote doesn’t justify censorship
- johncena33 5y agoThe author is making the "vast network of scientists, govt. officials, and civillians" argument, which doesn't even pass the BS test. Few dozens researchers in Wuhan lab and CCP officials are more than enough to accomplish the cover up.
- throwaway69123 5y agoThreat of death is also a major deterrent
- zdragnar 5y agoThe cover up didn't need to be colossal, just for everyone to point to occams razor and call anyone with a hint of curiosity a racist. The fact that the origin of the outbreak appears to be in the same vicinity as a lab that experiments on similar viruses alone is sufficient reason to want a thorough investigation. Otherwise, the odds that nature produced such a virus, in such a location, make for a crazy coincidence, given that we havent been facing this problem every year for decades.
- neither_color 5y agoThere’s a question as to why that fake consensus emerged. But I think the more troubling question is: How did people let the original story of what Tom Cotton even said go so badly awry? Essentially Cotton said something that was then transformed into a fake claim of a Chinese bio-attack, then the fake claim was debunked, and then the debunking was applied to the real claim with little attention paid to ongoing disagreement among researchers. I think this part of the text really sums up everything I hated about reading the news and social media in 2020. Each site seemed to be funneling you into a single source of truth and way of not only thinking, but FEELING about an event. I don't like being reminded of corporate sponsored social movements if I open facebook/google/amazon/twitter. I don't want my app reminding me to vote/get vaccinated(I did both btw) every time I open it without a way to dismiss and select 'I already did, stop reminding me.' I don't want reddit creating a central sub-page for discussing [Current Event] within the narrow bounds of what their moderators think is acceptable. I don't like non-dismissable context text on twitter and under youtube videos that are often off topic and triggered by bad speech detection that simply take you to a link dump of regular news articles. I don't like the idea that there's an oligopoly on "truth" and "credible sources." No amount of branding will convince me that "fact checkers" are any more objective and impartial than regular newspaper columnists; fact checkers are what editors are supposed to be. There's no academic rigor to fact checking, and the reality that so much casual skepticism on a variety of topics was suppressed and equivocated with being a flat-earther is sickening.
- pwillia7 5y agoI agree but I think it has to do with credibility and authoritative sources that used to be credible within some reason no longer being so. I remember watching one of those movies like Zeitgeist 15 years ago (but it was about physics) and being enthralled by it and eagerly shared everything I learned with a bunch of people for months. I eventually learned like 80%+ of that movie was made up BS, purposefully made to look more credible than it actually was. That ruined the entire thing for me. It wasn't ethical or right to pick and choose pieces from a dishonest source -- The whole thing was thrown out much like not credible witnesses in a court case. Again, I totally agree with the consequences of this and that it's not a good thing but if you met someone who talked about the flat earth nonstop and then told you about global warming, would you listen with the same openness if they believed the earth was round?
- throwaway69123 5y agoMaybe people will start to understand that it’s very hard to be a unbiased arbitrator of truth and that beyond illegal speech the media and social platforms should let people talk. You have to wonder if the parties were reversed and it was a democrat incumbent president making these claims, would the reaction have been the same. I think if we are being honest to ourselves we know the truth.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoCall me cynical...but... What would any government do about it if it was proven to be a lab leak? They could declare it an accident (probably this would be true) and that would be the end of the story. No country would dare to impose sanctions or engage beyond diplomacy. I do not think that the Chinese governments reaction or handling of the case is suspect, they likely want to shut down potential fake news. To label it as potential espionage is an ok measure until there was a conclusive investigation. If this happened in other nations, they would just declare it as a matter of national security and incarcerate whistle blowers too. Look no further than Manning and Snowden. In other words, China will not face any harsh consequences.
- paxys 5y agoThere is no way anything can be "proven" in the first place. Does anything think China will will let international investigators waltz into the Wuhan lab and collect samples or something? There will be a ton of meaningless online speculation and people will get bored and move on.
- ratsmack 5y agoHow do you think it would play out if it is found that our government (e.g. NIH/CDC) supplied funding for research that created this virus? I suspect many countries would take notice.
- bradford 5y ago> funding for research that created this virus? The very question demonstrates part of the problem here: there are ways that it could have been 'released' by the lab without being 'created' in the lab (or any lab). It's not clear to me that people are aware of this when the lab origin theory is discussed. Please don't prematurely make an assumption about what was going on in the lab. It's possible that some researcher went into a cave, took some biological samples from bats back to the lab. Thereafter, lack of proper protocol led to an infection that resulted in the pandemic. Embarrassing for China? yes, and I'd imagine they'd want to cover it up (although such accidents have happened at other worldwide facilities).
- joeblow21 5y agoIll bet most of the country still thinks the Hunter Biden laptop story is “baseless Russian conspiracy”.
- ajcp 5y ago> “Cotton’s views should be associated with conspiracy theories and misinformation,” even though his core factual claim was not particularly different from what anyone was else was saying. Does the author not know how conspiracy theories and misinformation campaigns work? I'm not sure how useful it is doing a hotwash on how we could have been so remiss as to ignore the comments of a public official whose views are often associated with conspiracy theories and misinformation, even if this one time they were not.
- fasteddie31003 5y agoTom Cotton is an idiot and putting his name behind anything is counter productive even if he has a point.
- renewiltord 5y agoThe 'media' has a bias towards team-alignment. This makes sense. The Washington Post is more like Arsenal Fan TV than it is like The Lancet. You don't go there for truth. You go there to either yell at your team or support your team, but ultimately you go there to be with your team. This isn't because they're dumb or anything. It's just a natural result of what we, as consumers, want. It happened with masks, it happened with this nonsense, it will happen again.
- 99_00 5y agoIf it came from the wet market, and wet markets are still open in China, why would any country allow free travel to anyone who has been to China? Or, even free travel to anyone from a country that allows free travel with China? If we are to believe that it crossed species at the wet market is it too much to ask that they be shut down before free travel with China is allowed? Belief in the wet market theory doesn't square with the total lack of discussion around mitigating the risk. 3.5M dead and counting.
- cout 5y agoBy March, it didn't matter whether the virus had come from a lab or a spillover event, because a bigger, more pressing issue had emerged: what to do now that the virus was outside China. Now that that threat is starting to abate, it seems discussion has picked up where it left off.
- fsckboy 5y agoNot just the media, folks, also the rest of our "sense making apparatus". Wikipedia has been suppressing lab leak discussion, and still to this moment will not allow the old Lab Leak Hypothesis page back. It still redirects to a declared "Misinformation!" page https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=COVID-19_lab_leak_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=COVID-19_lab_leak... And guess where else lab leak was suppressed? Here on HN. Yes, dang, you suppressed discussion of a perfectly reasonable hypothesis many times. So, while I have your attention, the real problem vis a vis Covid19 is not the lab leak. The real problem is "gain of function" research, using gene splicing to make more virulent-to-humans pathogens. And don't read into anything I'm saying, please pay attention to literally what I say here; if you have to reword what I say to cast doubt, you're not playing fair. This virus was likely man-made because gain of function man made viruses are quite common in research; and this is not a coverup conspiracy caused by the Chinese tendency for face-saving, swept under the carpet, "truths", though there is plenty of that. This scandal was caused by western experts: our best virologists are themselves engaging in gain of function research right here in our very own cities. If you ask them, as the media did, "what likely happened here", their answer is not going to point the finger at themselves, too much funding is at stake. Good background and in-depth research on the gain of function and lab leak hypotheses was carried out and published on the web over a year ago by Yuri Deigin https://yurideigin.medium.com/lab-made-cov2-genealogy-through-the-lens-of-gain-of-function-research-f96dd7413748 https://yurideigin.medium.com/lab-made-cov2-genealogy-throug... and it was covered on Bret Weinstein's Dark Horse podcast https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5SRrsr-Iug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5SRrsr-Iug And surprisingly, it is easy for lay people to read/listen and follow because Yuri Deigan is not a virologist, just a really smart educated guy. and it wasn't just the mainstream media and HN and wikipedia who suppressed the information from you all; sadly it was also because of the politicization, your politicization, of this crisis. If Trump said something, to most of you it just had to be wrong, and for some reason, opening our economy to the Chinese and disliking Russia were sacred cows to the Democrats, and anything Trump did that went the other way just had to be undone. That is what covered up this most obvious and likely HYPOTHESIS from being discussed: that of a man made, gain of function virus escaping from a lab in Wuhan where the virus broke out. Was there any Chinese military goal here, as a true conspiracy theory would allege? Sadly, frankly, there doesn't need to be. That's because advanced virology research is of deep interest to every military around the world. See the history of anthrax research. It is publicly acknowledged that it's part and parcel of germ warfare research both for defensive and offensive purposes.
- alphabet9000 5y agoIt's interesting looking at the timeline before Western media picked it up -- in the very early stages, chatter online referencing a leak, (or there was something released deliberately) seemed to be fear of it being a SARS 'biological weapon'. there was overlap with the newly emerging health crisis and the Hong Kong protests, which seems to have fueled that speculation. A good analysis of that time period was done by the Atlantic Council [0] I have also been archiving different web findings pertaining to all forms of 'leak' speculation in the form of a timeline [1] [0] https://atlanticcouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Weaponized-How-rumors-about-COVID-19s-origins-led-to-a-narrative-arms-race.pdf https://atlanticcouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Weapo... [1] https://news.coffee/wuhan_lab_snippets https://news.coffee/wuhan_lab_snippets
- chowells 5y agoThis article correctly notices at the very start that asking this question is of no value in resolving the current situation. Then the author seems to think they've uncovered a massive secret instead of continuing the thought. Who wants this question in the public's mind? What are their goals in constantly pushing it, even though it does nothing to improve people's lives? What are the actual effects of pushing this question as if it was important? https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/04/21/one-third-of-asian-americans-fear-threats-physical-attacks-and-most-say-violence-against-them-is-rising/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/04/21/one-third-o... I think it's better to not contribute to an environment of hatred towards large groups of people. Is the question potentially interesting? Sure, I suppose. But there's a huge difference between idly thinking about something and telling everybody else that they should as well. The latter has consequences, and you can't just ignore them.
- Vaslo 5y agoSo we should hide information because it might cause people to have a negative view towards the country of China? How about this - let all information, whether it goes with your far left anti-racist view or not, be put freely out to the public and let the public decide how they want to react. Of course some people will take it to the extreme, but that doesn’t mean we aren’t entitled to this info. Anyone who lost a loved one, had their livelihoods reduced, or fell ill absolutely deserve to know what was done and what steps we are going to take to never allow it to happen again. I never need censorship of any information by anyone, no matter how noble or misguided their deed.
- RV86 5y agoIMO, determining the origin of the virus is of much more consequence than who was right and who was wrong back in 2020. If the virus crossed over naturally, it's reasonable to conjecture that this sort of thing is going to happen more and more often in the future. If it was human error in a lab, I would actually be relieved -- this seems like something that's much easier to correct. FWIW, I do think available evidence supports a lab leak more than any other hypothesis.
- dougmwne 5y agoI agree that it's extremely important. If it was a lab leak, there are many safety process and regulation improvements we might be highly motivated to make. It's a thing we can actually have some control over. If it was a natural virus, there's good reason to collect and study more pathogens so we have a head start if one of them crosses into humans. Not that both of these things aren't good responses to the pandemic, but having a specific answer will direct more funding at the problem.
- kovvy 5y agoPolitics has made it very likely that we will never know where it started, but that's okay. More important is how the next one could start, which is being investigated more thoroughly now. If we survive the current and future variants of covid we'll be better placed for the next plague. If not for the systems put in place because of SARS-CoV-1, SARS-CoV-2 could have spread far more widely before being detected. Regardless of the politics, it's likely that many labs have reviewed their procedures to be sure people won't be infected by their work/contaminate their work.
- LasEspuelas 5y agoIs it? We can assume that both things happened and prepare better for both types of development in the future. In the case of lab release, details would have to emerge to be reactive about fixing any issues with procedures. That doesn't mean that we can't be proactive in analyzing current procedures and trying to find and correct weaknesses.
- fitzie 5y agoThe media really aren't the story here. their credibility couldn't be any lower. what is interesting is how the scientists stayed quiet, how big tech continues to use fact checkers to censor, and how the Chinese communist party and their allies were able to call discussion of lab leak theory causing hate but the notion of Chinese eating bat soup would not.
- generalizations 5y agoAnd of course it got flagged. What guidelines did it break? Didn't seem like the conversation was getting out of hand.
- arduinomancer 5y agoI hate how it feels like there's such a "collective narrative" for everything now days with the internet. Whenever I talk to people about recent news stories in real life it feels like everyone is just repeating talking points they read online. Its like we've been absorbed into the internet consciousness and talking to a person is like talking to "the internet brain".
- dougmwne 5y agoThanks for speaking this out loud. I've been feeling the same thing. What's weird is I've been having identical conversations with people from multiple US states and several European countries. There used to be an enormous gap between people from different areas and countries, each existing in their own cultural bubble. Now that's changed, and I'm not talking about "closer" I'm talking "the exact same." Our opinions have always been easily shaped by the media, mass entertainment and political campaigning. But lately it seems like there's less an ocean of information and more like a small puddle we're all trying to drink from at once. At the same time, the Overton Window seems to be slamming shut. I have been suspecting this has all been a dress rehearsal for the societal changes that are coming soon to address climate change, a sort of "powering up" of the collective consciousness.
- nfoz 5y agoI agree and have experienced what you wrote, except I have no idea what your last paragraph means. What are you referring to / talking about? It feels like maybe an example of the phenomenon we're talking about lol
- dougmwne 5y agoWhat I mean is to really address climate change all 8 billion of us are going to have to come together and make huge changes to our lives and each make personal sacrifices for the greater good. There will be new government mandates and it will affect how we live and work. There will be a huge social pressure to conform and a huge backlash. But we will have no choice because our environment will have changed to be more dangerous to our survival. Sounds a bit like the last year, doesn't it?
- hjek 5y agoDidn't recognize the author until near the end: > My position on China is we need “One Billion Americans” in order to stay number one forever, and I’m not going to change that view. Current Affairs has an interesting article on the author's peculiar form of liberal nationalism[0]. [0]: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/11/why-nationalism-is-a-brain-disease https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/11/why-nationalism-is-a-...
- dang 5y agoRelated threads: Wuhan lab staff sought hospital care before Covid-19 outbreak disclosed - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27259953 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27259953 - May 2021 (343 comments) How I learned to stop worrying and love the lab-leak theory - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27184998 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27184998 - May 2021 (235 comments) More Scientists Urge Broad Inquiry into Coronavirus Origins - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27160898 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27160898 - May 2021 (341 comments) The origin of Covid: Did people or nature open Pandora’s box? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27071432 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27071432 - May 2021 (537 comments) Scientists who say the lab-leak hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 shouldn't be ruled out - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26750452 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26750452 - April 2021 (618 comments) Why the Wuhan lab leak theory shouldn't be dismissed - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540458 - March 2021 (985 comments) The Lab Leak Hypothesis - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25640323 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25640323 - Jan 2021 (229 comments) Israeli startup claims Covid-19 likely originated in a lab, willing to bet on it - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25585833 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25585833 - Dec 2020 (351 comments) Wuhan lab did research on bat viruses, but no evidence of accidental release - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23070031 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23070031 - May 2020 (76 comments) Experts disagree on whether Covid-19 could have leaked from a research lab - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22695825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22695825 - March 2020 (6 comments)
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere were also a number of HN stories posted early in the pandemic concerning the lab-leak hypothesis. These paint a ... complicated ... picture of that theory and those who advocated for it. Few of the submissions had any significant discussion, I'm simply going off what was submitted to HN. Search, bound from 2020-1-1 to 2020-6-1: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1593475200&dateRange=custom&dateStart=1577836800&page=0&prefix=false&query=wuhan%20lab%20virus&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1593475200&dateRange=custom&... 26 March 2020: Experts disagree on whether Covid-19 could have leaked from a research lab https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22695825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22695825 https://thebulletin.org/2020/03/experts-know-the-new-coronavirus-is-not-a-bioweapon-they-disagree-on-whether-it-could-have-leaked-from-a-research-lab/ https://thebulletin.org/2020/03/experts-know-the-new-coronav... (Note this was from a modification of the above search) 28 March 2020: Scientific community MUST rally to expose likely leak from a Wuhan lab https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22710662 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22710662 (no link) 6 April 2020: Trump says U.S. investigating whether virus came from Wuhan lab https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22886182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22886182 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-trump-china/trump-says-u-s-investigating-whether-virus-came-from-wuhan-lab-idUSKCN21Y01B https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-trump-... 30 April 2020: Nobel Prize winner who discovered HIV says covid19 is from Wuhan lab,has HIV DNA https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23037036 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23037036 https://www.cnews.fr/france/2020-04-17/le-coronavirus-est-un-virus-sorti-dun-laboratoire-chinois-avec-de-ladn-de-vih https://www.cnews.fr/france/2020-04-17/le-coronavirus-est-un... (Said Nobelist is an anti-vaxxer.) 1 May 2020: No evidence that deadly bat virus escaped Wuhan lab https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23041789 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23041789 https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/No-evidence-that-deadly-bat-virus-escaped-Wuhan-15238789.php https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/No-evidence-that-deadly-... Original source is a Washington Post article from 30 April (https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/chinese-lab-conducted-extensive-research-on-deadly-bat-viruses-but-there-is-no-evidence-of-accidental-release/2020/04/30/3e5d12a0-8b0d-11ea-9dfd-990f9dcc71fc_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/chinese-lab...) 4 May 2020: Australian intelligence knocks back US government's Wuhan lab virus claim https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23074121 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23074121 https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/australian-intelligence-knocks-back-us-government-s-wuhan-lab-virus-claim-20200504-p54pk3.html https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/australian-intellige... 10 May 2020: Germany Doubts US Claim of Wuhan Virus Lab Leak https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23130107 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23130107 http://www.courthousenews.com/germany-doubts-us-claim-of-wuhan-virus-lab-leak/ http://www.courthousenews.com/germany-doubts-us-claim-of-wuh... 18 May 2020: Busted: Pentagon Contractors’ Report on ‘Wuhan Lab’ Origins of Virus Is Bogus https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23223986 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23223986 https://www.thedailybeast.com/pentagon-contractors-report-on-wuhan-lab-origins-of-coronavirus-is-bogus https://www.thedailybeast.com/pentagon-contractors-report-on... (Note that there may well have been other submissions which were flagged and killed, or which don't match my search terms --- I included one such addition based on a variant of terms.) In general the early claims of a lab leak: - Lacked any specific proof. - Came from sources with questionable credibility. - Were rejected by others with no specific allignment to those claiming the leak, and with general credibility. I'll note that the leak hypothesis remains unproven, though the evidence supporting a serious, independent, and pointedly, non-Chinese-led investigation is mounting. I found the Bulletin of Concerned Scientists article a week or so back persuasive. But the point remains that attributing an original cause to some event is complex, and requires a reality-based investigation grounded in facts rather than ideology or motivated reasoning. Much (though not all) of the lab-leak advocacy has been lacking in this objectivity, and even the most persuasive arguments to date make a case for the possible origin, not a certainty. I'd argue that for the current outbreak the origin all but certainly does not matter in terms of steps taken to contain and end the outbreak. Preventive measures (themselves reflecting an evolution of understanding over time) and vaccines (rejected by a disappointing fraction of lab-leak enthusiasts) remain the most potent tools we have. Consideration for costs, and prevention (or early alerting) of future outbreaks do depend in part on determining ultimate origin. That's something to keep an eye on, but not the principle concern of the moment.
- svara 5y agoThis story is a real clusterfuck and really hammers home the point that humans are bad at dealing with probabilities and uncertainty. You mix some nationalism in and it becomes completely impossible to have a reasonable discussion. This article already starts with a false dichotomy: "I missed the furious initial skirmish in what’s become the Long Discourse Wars over the idea that the SARS-CoV-2 virus came from the Wuhan Institute of Virology rather than originating naturally in bats." Those aren't conflicting hypotheses. If you're having a "war" over that question you need a cold shower and to go offline for a bit. If the institute was somehow involved in spreading the virus, the simplest story is still that they got it from bats. No matter what anyone tells you, there is zero evidence that any part of the virus is engineered (and it isn't even entirely clear what such evidence would look like, in general!). Either way, no new hard information has become available. The only thing that has changed is we've gone from pure, wild speculation based on the mere existence of the Wuhan virology institute, to wild speculation paired with some suggestive, anecdotal reports that need to be investigated further. I would agree that this has somewhat changed the probabilities that we should assign to different hypotheses about the origins of the virus, but it's way too early to have strong convictions. In the absence of any evidence, and in the heated climate of early 2020, it was and will always have been the correct call to ignore the speculation about how the virus might have come from the Wuhan virology institute. At the present time, there's nothing you can do except hope that more facts will come to light at some point in the future, even if that's somewhat disappointing. Jumping on the story because it's so juicy and fits so great with "China bad" preconceptions is totally unnecessary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roca 5y agoWe haven't found an animal host for SARS-CoV-2 yet, after more than 12 months. It took six months to find an animal host for SARS and less than a year for MERS. The incentive for the Chinese government to find a SARS-CoV-2 animal host is much much higher than for either of those viruses. Failure to find the host is not proof of lab origin, but the longer the search goes on unsuccessfully, the more the probabilities shift. > it was and will always have been the correct call to ignore the speculation about how the virus might have come from the Wuhan virology institute. No, it was not the correct call, because it means that possibility was not investigated when it should have been.
- uvesten 5y agoWhat the article forgets to mention is that there is a world power (cough China cough) which would use all its (social-) media manipulation skills and influence to make sure that the lab leak theory was written off as crazy conspiracy talk… Under those circumstances, and without a concerted effort by the US and other democracies to counter China’s preferred narrative, no wonder that the debate turned very lopsided.
- coffeefirst 5y agoNot to mention many of the early proponents were notorious conspiracy theorists, racists, and nut jobs who spoke with absolute certainty, cited virtually no evidence and clearly had no idea what they were talking about. Could they, in their wild speculation, been right about a few things? Sure, that’s always possible, but they didn’t actually know that at the time. This isn’t a science or mainstream media problem; both require something resembling empirical evidence to make factual claims. It’s a problem of bullshitters, who can just stay stuff. If you want to be clear that they’re full of it, you run the risk that they actually guessed right.
- the_optimist 5y agoThis is an interesting way to evaluate ideas. Where did you learn this technique?
- tux1968 5y agoIt's very common and easy to learn these days. It's everywhere.
- coffeefirst 5y agoNot the ideas. This entire thread is about public discourse. It's completely independent of whether the virus actually escaped from the lab.
- no-dr-onboard 5y agoWhenever we empower someone/something to moderate anything we should see it as allowing the entity the to misuse whatever power we give them. Ultimately responsibility is on us for allowing something like this to happen.
- pedalpete 5y agoAm I the only one who feels like this is mostly a non-issue. I feel like the case of if this came from a lab for from a market is mostly taking a political side against China - if it came from a lab, or for China - if it was naturally developed. If it came from a Chinese lab as part of a conscious effort of weaponizing a virus, sure, that's important, but I don't think anyone is saying that. If it came from a lab accidental breach, it is important that the parties involved are aware of that, and steps are taken to improve security. However, this is an event that happens every century. It's not a one-time thing. We had been warned it was coming. So now it's here. If the source had been Belgium (just as an example), would the source be covered by the media at all? Does anybody else feel this way? Yes, the WHO etc needs to continue researching to understand the source. But I don't believe the amount of energy the average person is expending on their "thoughts" really amounts to much at all. It's just the story of the hour.
- dundarious 5y agoI think further public and political pressure is still needed to ensure a proper investigation occurs (I'm not confident one is ongoing). There is an inflection point at which more pressure becomes actively unhelpful of course. But I also think the current evidence for a lab leak is far weaker than proponents claim (2 somewhat contradictory unnamed US intel sources saying WIV staff were sick in Nov '19, haven't found the reservoir animal yet, closest match is far away, lab exists in part of Asia where such viruses are known to emerge and also where it would be a good place to put a lab...)
- fsckboy 5y agono, the choice is not as you put it, "weaponization vs lab leak of virus that happens to be under study". The likely scenario that's being proposed for the lab-leak is a man-made virus that is quite routine to see in labs like this, in every advanced technology country in the world. The making of dangerous viruses for the purposes of research is quite common, and in order to take steps to improve security, we need openness and transparency about what is going on. China does, though, very much lack openness and transparency when it comes to owning up to mistakes.
- kyrra 5y ago
- wuwuno 5y agoAnother political article about how it's not possible that the Chinese were studying the virus and some underpaid lab tech screwed and and exposed himself and then did what humans always do, the tech tried to cover up the mistake. Nobody has still explained how the Chinese knew they had a problem in early December when they only had a handful of cases, like less than 100 cases. This is the question that needs to be answered. Until this question is answered satisfactorily the lab leak is the most reasonable explanation. The normal ways you detect a new virus is because: a) you have novel symptoms, COVID presents as the flu and early on tests didn't exist. b) you have a statistically significant number of cases, early on the number of cases didn't exceed the seasonal variability of the flu. c) you have a statically significant number of deaths, early on the number of death's didn't exceed the seasonal variability of the flu. When the Chinese knew they had a problem, there was NOTHING that would indicate anything out of the ordinary was taking place, so then how did the Chinese know they had a problem? If the virus really jumped species in the wet market, the Chinese wouldn't have known they had a problem until either the cases or the death totals started to exceed the normal variability of the flu. If that had happened we wouldn't have know about COVID until Late Jan or early Feb, and then it would have been really, really ugly. But that's not what happened, the Chinese knew about it in early December. The only way they could have known is if they had prior knowledge.
- quag 5y agoIsn’t the article about misreporting by multiple organisations? Rather than about the source of COVID-19?
- zozbot234 5y agoCOVID was detected as SARS when Wuhan doctors started harboring suspicions and requested analysis of some patient samples. So it was immediately known that a SARS outbreak or something very much like it was in progress.
- fsckboy 5y ago"Another political article about how it's not possible that the Chinese were studying the virus and some underpaid lab tech screwed and and exposed himself and then did what humans always do, the tech tried to cover up the mistake." no, you're wrong. You need to focus attention not on the lab-leak, which could be small mistake by an underling, but instead on the gain-of-function research that is the goal of labs like Wuhan and likely created this virus with approval of the highest levels of the lab.
- lettergram 5y agoWuhan discussing "synthetically derived viruses": https://web.archive.org/web/20200212011902/http://english.whiov.cas.cn/News/Events/201512/t20151204_157114.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200212011902/http://english.wh... 2017 conference at (Wuhan Institute of a virology) with gain of function research being top priority: http://english.whiov.cas.cn/Exchange2016/International_Conferences2017/201712/t20171215_187977.html http://english.whiov.cas.cn/Exchange2016/International_Confe... Ecohealth Alliance partnership: https://web.archive.org/web/20210323171425/http://english.whiov.cas.cn/International_Cooperation2016/Partnerships/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210323171425/http://english.wh... US Gov from state department: http://web.archive.org/web/20210116001621/https://www.state.gov/fact-sheet-activity-at-the-wuhan-institute-of-virology/ http://web.archive.org/web/20210116001621/https://www.state.... EcoHealth Alliance Peter Daszak discussing gene editing in coronaviruses in december 2019 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-Y843FFJvI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-Y843FFJvI Note: The documentation isn’t even new... all those people banned and censored via Facebook, Twitter, Google, etc [1], have been saying this the entire time. Its kind of amazing to watch both realities (left wing media va alternative media) collide. Gives me hope to be honest. [1] https://www.projectveritas.com/news/breaking-facebook-whistleblowers-expose-leaked-internal-docs-detailing-new/ https://www.projectveritas.com/news/breaking-facebook-whistl...
- DanielBMarkham 5y agoOver the last several years, it's become clear to me what the large social media companies want to be: de facto world governments. They won't admit that, and you'll hear a lot of gab about algorithms and cooperation with various governments, but at heart it appears to me that this is cooperation with various governments as a government themselves. It's a negotiation among equals. We can provincially argue about who can say what in the US on which platforms, or what the rules _might_ be to demonetize and/or kick people off platforms, but at the end of the day, the platforms themselves, through means mostly opaque to us, are negotiating as if they were our local tyrannical government with complete control over the public square and public places. I understand that for many this is completely far-fetched and I'm making a mountain out of a molehill. This is a difficult thing to freely admit and grasp. It's also very difficult for those that are currently happy with whatever the most recent decisions are. Yes, the net is still (mostly) free and open, and competitors _might_ come along and take the place of the current major social networks, but at heart this is a problem based on generalizing and universally abstracting social interactions. You could split up and/or dismantle every major player today and be in the exact same spot five or ten years from now when the next ones come along. I am happy that more and more people are finally waking up to the danger here. If we are allowed to adequately describe the nature of this problem, we might have a shot at fixing it.
- Breza 5y agoI also yearn for more competition in social media. It's wild to think that Facebook has been a huge player for most of the history of the web.
- User23 5y agoThe US federal government is basically a giant case of regulatory capture so many people understandably confuse power and influence. However the distinction remains and it is of essential importance. None of the big tech companies have any real power, all they have is influence. In countries where they don’t have politicians under their influence they are helpless.
- DanielBMarkham 5y ago
- cassac 5y agoWasn’t this all just to be contrarian to Trump? Trump says lab leak? Can’t be lab leak! Trump says travel ban? Travel bans are racist! Now that Trumps out the lab leak is something to look into and everyone has done some level of travel ban without being labeled racist.
- cassac 5y agoMy guess is people who downvote without a comment still really hate trump.
- RickJWagner 5y agoSo Tom Cotton is owed an apology, and the American people can stand to remember they were badly misled by 'scientists' and the media just before a presidential election. It's not like people are allowing themselves to be led around and told what to think or something.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hubadu 5y agoJust a reminder that a lab leak of SARS had already happened in Beijing in early 2000s, and for which Chinese CDC officials were publicly punished. It was even reported in CCP owned China Daily: https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/english/doc/2004-07/02/content_344755.htm https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/english/doc/2004-07/02/content...
- DarkmSparks 5y agowhat happened to those scientists/lab reports saying their were fatalities in California as early as August/September 2019? The youtube accounts that mirrored it were all deleted and I've not seen a word on it since.
- hubadu 5y agoThere has been an attempt by some researchers to determine when the first cases of covid were detected in wastewater samples. There are three known studies so far. December 2019 in Italy: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7428442/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7428442/ November 2019 in Brazil: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.26.20140731v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.26.20140731v... March 2019 in Spain: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.13.20129627v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.13.20129627v...
- dukeofdoom 5y agoGeorge Hotz attempted to reverse engineer the virus. His attempts at doing so can be watched here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=StGm-m1EUgk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=StGm-m1EUgk
- postalrat 5y agoWith about as much success my sock had reverse engineering George Hotz's code.
- ineedasername 5y agoI think there's a difference between making an extreme claim in the early days of this thing without giving evidence to back it up, compared to now where there's been a year's worth of putting the pieces together. And even now we don't know-- it's just better informed speculation (although the intelligence community may have more to go on that we don't know about.) The media isn't great about reporting science, but I don't fault them for being critical of an unsupported claim made at a time when it was in the political interests of a person's party to cast blame in China's direction. Calling that a fiasco is itself ignoring the contexts involved as reporting changed. Making an unsupported accusation that turns out to be correct doesn't mean it was right to make the accusation at that time.
- jay3ss 5y ago> Making an unsupported accusation that turns out to be correct doesn't mean it was right to make the accusation at that time I agree with this and thanks for expressing what I was thinking, but didn't really know how to say it
- websites420 5y agoThis is a the consequence of having an administration that transparently lied at every turn. Even if they were right, no one would believe them.
- the_optimist 5y agoYour statement follows a pattern of, ‘the person was doing X therefore the unjustifiable response was justified.’ This fails the commonly adopted Rawlsian theory of justice (Veil of Ignorance), and it is known as victim blaming.
- websites420 5y agoI made no statement about whether anyone's actions were justified, only that they made sense given the state of affairs.
- the_optimist 5y agoIf you're not trying to justify it, then no, it doesn't make sense at all. The media failed (or purposefully sought not) to deliver information in a useful form. Delivering such information is supposedly the reason the media exists. There's no merit or utility in extending that abject failure to the information source or destination.
- bannedbannedb 5y agoHN fails yet again. All the supposed intellectuals caught with their pants down. Of course you all will rationalize away the error, doublethink your way to some new comfort. Go on and continue to believe the next lie told by big tech, medi, government officials. Was the 2020 election fraudulent? Oh wait I can't say that, that's fake news right? Just like covid being from a lab? Oh wait? No,no don't worry, I'm the crazy one not you, you all are the very best and brightest tech minds to ever exist. Your controls were just a little imperfect, next time there will be no mistake.
- bannedbannedb 5y agoOh and I'll be auto dead. Can't let people who don't align to group think on HN express themselves. Be sure to destroy everything that doesn't align with your perfect world view.
- Wowfunhappy 5y ago"The boy who cried wolf", comes to mind. If you spout a bunch of nonsense about Climate Change being a hoax, don't be too surprised when a lot of people start ignoring or even deriding the things you say. Even if the wolf does eventually show up.
- lawnchair_larry 5y agoThis is the opposite lesson you should be taking away from this.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoWhy? I think that politicians have a responsibility to not tell obvious lies. If they do, then I'm going to stop paying attention to the things they say, and I'll tell everyone else to do the same. If they eventually say something insightful, well, that's a shame, but they no longer have my attention.
- iammisc 5y agoAll politicians tell obvious lies. It's part of their career. Biden tells obvious lies. Trump told obvious lies. So did Obama. So did bush. Part of critical thinking is determining which statements are lies and which are not.
- lawnchair_larry 5y agoBecause it’s irrelevant and assumes that anyone participating in the discussion was listening to any politician of any kind to begin with. The problem isn’t with ignoring the politicians - something that is nearly always prudent - it’s assuming that we weren’t also completely ignoring Trump. This investigation was happening among scientists regardless of whatever Trump or Biden or Cotton or Paul or whoever else had to say. But the mainstream left treated them as though they must be dumb backwards thinking Q anon Trumpers who got this idea from him or Alex Jones or some conspiracy nut. The way that people following this were treated was bad enough, but the most worrisome part is the reputational attacks, largely coordinated by Peter Daszak of the EcoHealth alliance, that these scientists faced. It was a huge risk on their part to challenge someone of his standing in the community, and he was relentless in spreading the meme that these were fringe quacks deserving of nothing but derision for their “conspiracy theories”. In another massive media failure, they were happy to use him as their subject matter expert without bothering to disclose that he’s the one who ran the very same program. And to a lesser extent, Fauci as well. To be clear, no one suspects that Daszak and Fauci were anything but well-intentioned in their original pursuits when starting and funding this research program. But it’s obvious why anyone faced with the possibility that their decision may have been the reason that this all happened in the first place. And the implications - that their entire organization and much of their life’s work will be shut down immediately - may put even the most reasonable mind in an extremely difficult position. How would you react upon realizing that your program may very well have killed millions around the globe and destroyed economies? I’d imagine that must be quite a burden on the conscience for anyone who is not a completely sociopathic murderer.
- llsf 5y agoNo sure why it is a big deal? Some people (like Cotton) said that the virus escaped a Chinese lab, but had not hard proofs. Lots of scientists said there are no hard proofs. Then we moved on... until we get more proofs. Anybody can claim anything including truth, but until it is proven to be true, it would be discredited. In this case, finding the truth with hard proofs is not trivial. If we find out tomorrow that it was indeed a virus escaped from a Chinese lab, then so be it. I expect from media to find the truth among the sea of noise and misinformation. Sometimes it takes time. Even if the US gov knew about the source of the virus, back in Feb. 2020, I can understand that they decided to sit on it. Fighting the pandemic was the priority, before pointing fingers. It would be interesting to see, if the virus was indeed escaped from a Chinese lab, what would be the consequences ? Will all countries would come to some kind of agreement to stop playing with bioweapons ? Or they would double down on bioweapons (e.g. with a vaccine before being released) ? Or do like before, and hoping for the best ?... we gonna wipe us out of this planet !
- DaniloDias 5y agoThis is a post mortem for a corpse that was already dead. Trump derangement syndrome guaranteed this outcome. Reap what you sow. American mainstream media is pure propaganda, full stop. The national voice is the pr teams of our most valuable corporations. The patient is dead. When was the last time you thought about what Julian Assange is going through?
- Glyptodon 5y agoI thought much of how it went was driven by a seeming confusion between "escaping from a lab" meaning "created or otherwise altered in a lab."
- nraynaud 5y agoWhat all those Wuhan lab story miss is a good explanation as to why the oldest cases are outside Wuhan.
- Drunk_Engineer 5y agoThank you. Had to scroll to the next page to find this comment. The lab leak theory never made any sense, because it does not fit the timeline of the viral spread. Nor does it explain why some countries already had T-cell immunity to the virus.
- nraynaud 5y agowell, it could make sense, but it's not the simplest scenario because the first cases were outside. It would be more reasonable if the earliest cases were actually close to it. And as far as I know there is no suspicion that it comes from another lab.
- christophilus 5y agoYour conclusion is correct, if the premise is true. Do you have a source for this? (Asking sincerely, not cynically.)
- amoorthy 5y agoOne of the reporters Matt Yglesias mentions as having done a decent job of reporting on covid-19 in the early days is Julia Belluz at Vox. My startup rates how informative news stories are and we found that Julia was among the top 10 reporters on covid in the early days. https://blog.thefactual.com/credible-journalists-covid-19 https://blog.thefactual.com/credible-journalists-covid-19. I don't know if all the reporters on our list parroted the same narrative on covid's origins but I suspect they collectively remain a generally reliable source of information on healthcare issues.
- doggodaddo78 5y agoSo I can wave the red, white, and blue all day with my TXSSAR membership, 2 flag triangles, and good life.. but still there are deeper, fundamental, metastasized cancerous problems with the shining city on the hill that have tarnished it. Greed. Corruption. Apathy. Ignorance. Narcissistic self-absorption (hyperindividualism). Unfocused leadership. Under such conditions of weak debate ethics and sensible balance, democracy gives oxygen to the crazies and drives policy and attention to satisfy the conspiracy theorists who demand a particular investigational outcome. It's not that free speech needs to go away, but that the leadership shouldn't kowtow to idiocy or even consider what's popular if it's existentially-vital. This can only be accomplished with ethical leadership, which I don't see happening anytime soon since celebrity straw puppets are typically installed to continue serving the interests of the 1%. If it were possible, leadership means putting on the Big Boy™ pants and not bending and shifting focus on the whims of idiots. There are no political figures anywhere that I've seen who aren't duplicitous, have a backbone, and are empathetic and sane individuals. Perhaps political parties and elections should be disbanded and revert to "jury duty" public administration for a fixed term (1 year) from a pool of random, qualified, competent professionals. Remember what a democratic idiocracy did to Socrates. "Democracy" is another word for "mob rule." Combine mob rule with vulture capitalism selling off public infrastructure to corporations and corruption, then you have basically the recipe for a third-world country fighting over the last scraps of what was once a nearly shiny city on a hill (minus the genocides, training of death squads, banana wars, and Monroe doctrine). The only way for the human species to survive is to crawl-out from under greed, dogma, conflict, laziness, material comfort, and ignorance and do many thing to defeat the threats to our very survival.
- chmod600 5y ago"Suppose the media had been more open to Cotton’s point" I sincerely have trouble imagining such discourse taking place. Isn't that sad? Seriously, which mainstream media personality would actually entertain an idea from Tom Cotton long enough to seriously consider whether it's true or not?
- c01n 5y agoAnarchists are right. F#ck these governments and corporations destroying the earth and trying to shape reality.
- trhway 5y agoIt isn't media fiasco. Media is a business, and they have been selling what has been selling well - i.e. people were buying it very well. It is fiasco of people believing media without applying basic reality check. In this particular case, the people would easily believe in the coincidence of a very low probability that a virus would jump to humans at the same time and right near, yet without any connection to, the lab where the virus was being bred to do exactly that (the "gain of function research") while dismissing outright the much more probable no-coincidence version of events. Pointing that more than a year ago cost me some karma, and will probably cost me today too :) After such profound failure of the basic thinking, the people instead of recognizing the failure on their part are still and again blaming media. And the next time the media comes with a well selling, yet failing basic logic/probability/reality/etc check, story the people would again believe in it whole heartedly. Ad infinitum... Btw, how is that for conspiracy theory - associating the lab leak idea with conspiracy theorism, right wing nut-jobbery and racism was just a successful "damage control" PR operation by China government (and probably by some actors in US as US was partially funding that research in the Wuhan labs after closing such research in US because of the dangers of that research).
- tilolebo 5y agoThis article explains in very detailed, yet understandable way why the lab leak is a serious hypothesis: https://nicholaswade.medium.com/origin-of-covid-following-the-clues-6f03564c038 https://nicholaswade.medium.com/origin-of-covid-following-th...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- misja111 5y agoIn 2017 Marc Lipsitch, a leading epidemiologist at Harvard, warned already for the risk of a pandemic caused by gain of function research: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-017-08837-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-017-08837-7 (end of article) That same Marc Lipsitch was one of the scientists that signed a letter in May that asked for a deeper and objective investigation about the origins of Covid-19: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/372/6543/694.1 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/372/6543/694.1 He explained his motivation for the letter in an interview: https://www.wbur.org/commonhealth/2021/05/16/scientists-investigation-origin-coronavirus-pandemic https://www.wbur.org/commonhealth/2021/05/16/scientists-inve... In this interview he also expressed his regret that the discussion about the COVID origin had become so polarized. The man was right in 2017 but sadly most people didn't hear him ..
- aliasEli 5y agoActually I believe it would be better if we never find the true origin of COVID-19. It has drawn attention to: - Improving handling of live animals - Improving lab procedures for biological materials If we would know the true origin, less attention would be given to other scenario's that are also quite possible for other diseases. Also, the current attacks on China will only cause it to be even more suspicious about foreign contacts, and that could hurt international cooperation in future pandemics.
- Flatcircle 5y agoThis article encapsulates the problem with modern media. Yglesias spends a large portion of the article debating the finer points of Tom Cotton's take on the lab leak theory. As if a junior senator from Arkansas, who's not on any relevant committees (aside from maybe intelligence) is some kinda Rosetta Stone for understanding the media's lack of pushback on the lab leak denials from China and the WHO. Yglesias labels senator Cotton a "China Hawk," as if that's enough for the story to live and die on his thoughts and quotes. To examine the lab leak hypothesis through the lens of a Republican senator under the pretext of blaming the senator for the media's assessment of a possible lab leak, turns this article into just another liberal think piece masquerading as objective journalism with irrelevant timelines and a puffed up word count.
- taylodl 5y agoTom Cotton has made bombastic statements for years. He makes a another seemingly bombastic statement and rightfully gets ignored, ridiculed, or scorned - and now I'm supposed to be concerned that happened? Tom Cotton is the boy who cried wolf. He has earned the privilege of being ignored. I'm not going to blame the media for ignoring him. Now a year later and we still haven't determined where this virus came from. People who haven't earned the privilege of being ignored are now starting to present evidence that perhaps the Wuhan Lab was involved in some way. The media is paying attention to those people. They're also paying attention to Beijing being less that forthcoming in helping to get to the bottom of the issue. I honestly don't see a big smoking gun with the media's coverage of this issue. Certainly nothing warranting the term fiasco.
- stevenicr 5y agoSurprised to see people really tackling this and reflecting. including: from the Hill / Rising with Krystal and Saagar https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeuwqHDIRSQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeuwqHDIRSQ Media’s Lab-Leak Failure Is [like ramifications from] Next Iraq WMD [brackets words added by me, not in original title, also uncapped some words]
- busymom0 5y agoGood article but author is wrong about "Cotton attributed this to malice". That's not what his statement said. He simply stated that there is a level 4 super lab in Wuhan which works with similar viruses. That alone is not malice. The virus could have leaked from the lab by accident because of poor practices - that's not malice. Malice would be if it was intentionally leaked. The intention is what scientists and intelligence is supposed to do. One could also say that China banning on national flights and closing off areas while allowing international flights and not providing correct info/warnings to other countries is what real malice is. > But Cotton did one thing that those other sources didn’t do — he speculated a little. At the end of that clip he says “we still don’t know where coronavirus originated. Could have been a market, a farm, a food processing company. I would note that Wuhan has China’s only biosafety level-four super laboratory that works with the world’s most deadly pathogens to include, yes, coronavirus.” > Where Cotton differed from the consensus is that he attributed this to malice, which is not what the scientific articles said (but also isn’t a scientific question) and was not the NYT’s preferred interpretation of events.