9 ms·
High-Speed Internet at a Crossroads
- TripleH 5y ago"And quite frankly, I hope I don’t have to give another live lecture ever again. I’ll tape it; I’ll have them watch it — I know most of them are going to watch it at 1.5 or 2x speed. I’ll sound like Alvin and the Chipmunks, but that’s OK. Then we can spend the time in class actually working on problems or discussing some of the issues that I brought up." Beside the joke, I find the concept of ingesting content at your pace and then talking about it in class very interesting. No idea if the knowledge will stick in mind as well as classic lectures, but I would definitely have been seduced by this proposition when I was a student.
- yeigfepuih 5y agoThe best class I ever had was one where the teacher explained things for half the time and then we worked on homework for the other half. I think that is probably the best model. Letting students watch lectures on their own time is hardly better than expecting them to read on their own time.
- corysama 5y agoYears ago I heard of experimental elementary/high school classrooms where students were expected to watch lecture videos at home and what would be “homework” would instead be the focus of the whole time in the classroom. Students were expected to help each other with the material and only go to the teacher if they were collectively stumped. I can imaging all kinds of bad scenarios were someone tried to switch a disruptive class to this routine overnight. But, with good onboarding and ramp up, that plan sounded like a dream to me!
- ghaff 5y agoThere is a forcing function to in-person lectures; I can't tell you how many events I've basically skipped in the past year because I can catch up on the videos anytime--and, of course, I mostly don't. But, in principle, depending upon the size of the class there's a lot to be said for watching the lecture on video and using class time for discussion, project work, etc.
- wongarsu 5y agoPre covid, we had one professor who did lectures with videos (of him presenting) combined with in-person tasks and discussions. Each week you had to take a 10-minute test on the content of that weeks videos. It worked quite well. The biggest disadvantage was that with a live audience the professor got cues from the audience if we understood him or if he had to slow down. In his videos he constantly assumed he had to repeat everything slightly differently, so you had to watch at 1.5x speed to get to something bearable.
- ghaff 5y agoYeah, particularly with a smaller audience that can definitely be a problem. I'm better at it than I was a year ago but I still find doing a video without an audience can be a bit challenging. And I definitely can't course correct the way I can if I see a bunch of puzzled expressions in the front row of a room. On the flip side, you can redo sections and easily insert multimedia and just mix up the talking head format.
- curriculum 5y agoThere's also something ritualistic about in-person lectures -- in a good way, like having a morning cup of coffee. We know that humans are not good at multi-tasking, so there is tremendous value in a dedicated time and place to think about one thing only in the presence of other people who are also thinking about that one thing. Of course, it's easy to squander that opportunity by delivering a rote, feelingless lecture. And if you're just going to lay out the facts, why not record them? In that case, videos have many advantages. But a live lecture is also an opportunity to get people excited about what you're teaching. Post-pandemic, my plan is to take a hybrid approach. Technical details, like proofs, belong in pre-recorded videos watched out-of-class. But the main conceptual thread should be delivered in live lecture, where I can give it the energy and life it deserves.
- Grakel 5y agoAnyone speaking improvisationallly (not from a script) can be listened to at 1.5x at least. I get through a lot of tutorials at 2x.
- ghaff 5y agoI may be in the minority but I really don't care for listening to things sped up. If it's really just about maximizing data transfer, I'd probably rather read a good transcript at that point.
- Syonyk 5y agoUnfortunately, as I'm sure you've discovered, "good transcripts" don't exist unless someone puts in the effort. :( I don't mind audio, but I definitely don't understand the value of "talking head" style videos. They're, if not the worst possible information density possible, pretty darn close. A couple hundred megabytes to see someone speaking a few dozen kilobytes of text, and I still can't search it or skim it to see if it covers what I want.
- ghaff 5y agoA good transcript isn't really that hard. You just need to pay someone--the ML ones just aren't good enough to publish--and do some light editing. I usually do them for my podcasts. (Though the ML transcripts are good enough for skimming content and I use them if I'm just going to be using some excerpts from the audio.) I actually find that, for talks with slides, I do like having the inset speaker video. What I tend to do is to start off with a full screen talking head intro with mostly the slides/multimedia and a small speaker video.
- toss1 5y agoTotally agree that a good transcript is way better in almost all cases (except where actual moving visual demo actually helps). However, are there any good automated transcription tools that can make a good transcript from an imperfect YouTube video? Most of what I've seen is good for humor, and I've even seen some used in a legal deposition context that are downright dangerous (inserting most likely word or phrase in place of what was actually said, so actively decreasing and corrupting info content). This might not be as disastrous for a lecture where there are also office hours, but... anything good out there?
- jon_richards 5y agoCollege classes are often split into lectures and precepts/discussions/office hours. I think the thing holding back your idea is the expectation of being taught in-person by a professor. For large classes, that’s only really possible in a lecture format. My personal favorite method of learning was a TA that went through the material, meticulously calling on each person in order. You could skip, but it was still obvious if you were playing a game or browsing Reddit. Eventually you learned that you really didn’t have all the answers and that paying attention was probably a good idea. It also got people comfortable giving a wrong answer and that really helped everyone with the learning process.
- volta83 5y ago", I find the concept of ingesting content at your pace and then talking about it in class very interesting." It's called a "flipped-classroom". The teacher gives you material to read or watch at home before the class, and then in the class it just asks if anyone had any questions, and they can go over these together. As a teacher it is super useful because you get to learn first hand which concepts the student didn't understand. And as a student you can read or watch something whenever you want at the speed that you want, and if you don't understand something you can ask about it in class. With some experience, teachers can also use the flipped-classroom model to focus only on the hardest part of a particular lecture. You can rely that some student is going to have trouble with it at home, so you can prepare before hand to the lecture to how to address that particular question (and once you have done the class a couple of times, you get pretty good at it). There is no need to waste teacher and student time during 1:1 interactions on "easy" stuff that everyone can just read at home.
- fuzzer37 5y agoHow do you deal with shy students, or ones who don't like to participate? This model sounds interesting, but I can't imagine exclusively using this method.
- trobertson 5y ago> How do you deal with shy students, or ones who don't like to participate? With students who aren't participating in the current model? They will (have the opportunity to) do better than they are now, as when they watch prerecorded lectures they can skip back to parts they didn't understand. As opposed to their current behavior of not speaking up and, therefore, not being able to go over the content again.
- volta83 5y ago> How do you deal with shy students, or ones who don't like to participate? This method allows students to learn at home at their own pace, and use face-time with experts to asks questions. Just learning at home at your own pace is a net win for all students. Those who are a little shy, come to class, and learn something from the questions of others. Those who are more shy, don't even come to class. They can read the stuff at home, and have ~2 hours extra per week to do other stuff. We have 1:1 tutoring 2 per week (students have to get an online ticket), and they can also ask us privately per email, but in my experience, students that are "too shy" to go to class and ask questions in front of others are also often "too shy" to asks questions privately. The other aspect of these is homeworks. Our homeworks allow groups, but they are thought of as "individual homeworks". We recommend people do them on their own. This means that non-shy people as a group get them done faster and often better, but it also means that shy people doing them on their own, end up learning more and performing better in the exams. We don't grade homeworks, just pass or not pass, but passing them is required to be allowed to take the exam. Still, we do internally grade them, and people that do them well alone do perform better in the exam. --- In my opinion, the only "downside" for "shy" students, is that since we give them the freedom to not attend _any_ classes, they might decide not to do so. That means, no access to new friends, new colleagues, in person learning groups, isolation, and well understanding the hardest parts of the material might cost them more time if they are "on their own". Most still make it. Some do find learning groups or new friends in the class forum, some do better than many students that do attend classes, etc. Having taught many flipped and non-flipped (classic) classes, I never had the feeling that forcing people to attend class fixed any issues related to "shy-ness". Students are how they are, I'm neither their parent, nor counselor, nor psychologist, nor am I qualified to do any of these things. I'm their teacher for a specific kind of content. I want the content to be useful and applicable to them, so that they can use it in their careers to be successful, whatever successful means to each of them. I also want them to enjoy the content, so that they can learn it easier. For me this means giving them as many options as possible, so that they can master the content in whatever way makes the most sense to each of them.
- linsomniac 5y agoI can only imagine how much the Pandemic stretched the average home Internet. We had pretty good Internet, ~300Mbps in, maybe 15Mbps out, $100/mo, and when my wife and I and both the kids were on video meetings, it just couldn't keep up. I'd have to turn off video on my meeting to keep from losing audio. Upgraded to gigabit (30Mbps upstream?) and that helped, but it still struggled. Might have been at Xfinity... About 6 months into it, we got hooked up for the municipal fiber network, we were not in the first batch deployed but were fairly early. Symmetric gigabit for $60/mo, and it's been working amazingly! But, as the article says, "haves and have-nots". Our entire city should have the municipal network in a year or two. So the whole city will have it, and I think they'll be offering some incentives for people who can't afford the $60/mo. But nationally, and even in the rest of Colorado, there are still a lot of "have-nots".
- cratermoon 5y agoI noticed what you describe at work, too: families with kids in school and both parents working had the most difficulties. In places where home internet speeds are marginal for pre-pandemic usage, it was absolutely garbage.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoNon fiber upload is a farce. I assume when they sell you more upload, they’re just placing you in a higher priority in the 30Mbps they have allocated for the whole neighborhood. It is a hardware limitation as far as I know, so unless you see utility workers running new fiber, I would not expect much.
- katbyte 5y agoI have 1000/100 cable and my upload is consistently 110-120
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI have never seen a cable internet provider even advertise upload bandwidth, much less actually deliver it. They don’t even bother promising 2Mbps. Check Comcast/Spectrum/Cox/etc websites. I assume the only reason they do not is because that is how little upload capacity they have.
- JTbane 5y agoIt's ridiculous that this is still an issue- cheap fiber optics have been around since the 80s. The blame rests on the ISPs for their monopolistic behavior.
- Bayart 5y agoThe problem isn't the ISPs, it's the regulation and the arcane onion of overlapping jurisdictions. Places where infrastructure owners are legally bound to share with third party network operators don't have that problem.
- williesleg 5y agoGet off the internet and go outside. Sunshine is proven to fight off Covid. Harvard study.
- Syonyk 5y agoIt would be really nice if those designing technology systems for the web would spend some time using the stuff they design on lower speed connections. There's no excuse these days - the Chrome web inspector lets you simulate network profiles if you want (though I wish they'd add "Rural WISP" options by default - say, 5/1 with some random latency spikes and a few dropped packets every now and then). I've been on a 25/3 (that mostly delivers 20/2 during the day, and "a connection" during the evening that... varies wildly) for about six years now, and I've been working 100% remotely that entire time. It means I have to think about some of my transfers and let them run for longer periods, but I've had no trouble doing video conferences and other things on this connection. I just have to pay attention to what I'm doing, and I might need to cancel or pause a transfer if I'm jumping on a video call. If it works for the meeting, I tend to use a cell phone for audio - most video conference bridges support this method. But we've also generally designed our life around the fact that we're not on super fast connections. We cache content locally (I tend to rip DVDs to the server so I don't have to deal with the physical disks), and while streaming works if we let it, I'm certainly not streaming high bitrate 4k content... but we also don't have a large enough TV that it really matters at our viewing distances. Also tend to cache other stuff - I'm running a local Ubuntu repo, because I have a lot of VMs that do various things, and sucking down updates over the LAN is far faster than running over the WISP. None of us play extensive computer games, and while I do game a bit, it's things like Minecraft or Kerbal Space Program that are offline/local, or at least not latency sensitive. I hear lots of complaints about how bad consoles with online-only games are on slow connections (especially the update game), so we just don't have one. We game quite a bit, but it's board games, tabletop games, etc. If stuff were designed for "something slower than gigabit," it would certainly improve the experience on slower connections, but literally making a living on something a lot of people barely even consider broadband, I've not found it to be an actual issue if you just work within the limits. Now, the usual answer for this is "But Starlink!" - and I have it. It's a secondary connection, because it's not actually usable as a primary connection for much beyond casual web browsing and file downloads these days. I know it's a beta, and I'm certainly putting traffic through it to help with their testing, but it's just not a good primary connection if you have alternatives yet. The bandwidth is fine, the latency is good, and the rest of it is just annoying. It's really prone to breaking long running connections (CGNAT and it seems like my public IP changes halfway often), so SSH tunnels and VPNs get broken constantly. They tolerate some packet loss just fine (just pause for a moment and then resume when the packets start again), but over Starlink, they get reliably broken. I've not poked around enough to figure out why. The bandwidth is also hugely variable (both upload and download). Sure, you see 300-400Mbit at peaks, and I often see north of 200Mbit... briefly. Then it slows down, drops to less than 10Mbit, pauses, goes back up, etc. It doesn't show in random speed tests as much, but if you scp or rsync a big set of files over, you can watch the speed rise and fall. I can't imagine bandwidth estimation algorithms are able to make much sense of this for things like video calls, and the quality of video calls on Starlink isn't great yet. It's also prone to plenty of "micro-drops" where it simply stops passing traffic for 5-10 seconds. Not normally a huge deal, but very, very disruptive for video calls. I still use my 25/3 for any sort of video conferencing, because it's slower, but more consistent. (One may safely assume I'm pretty rural)
- hyko 5y agoWe decided almost a century ago that universal telephone service was something that we wanted to have. We need to make that decision about the internet now. YES!
- lstodd 5y agoYeah, sure. Then Bell System had to be broken down, and even that wasn't enough. The whole mess with internet access in US is due to local monopolies held up by idiotic regulations. More regulations won't ever solve the problem.
- extra88 5y agoRegulation is what connected every home to electricity and telephone service, it could do the same for quality broadband service.
- supertrope 5y agoRural America would still be without phones and electricity without subsidies and universal service mandates. Privately owned businesses are not going to invest $50,000/mile to gain a customer who pays $50/mo.
- lstodd 5y agoThat's the point - why it costs $50K/mile? Regulations, that's why.
- vlan0 5y agoMost folks don't realize this, but many issues are actually due to bufferbloat. Get a powerful router that runs CAKE and you'll be amazed at how little jitter will be seen while maximizing available bandwidth. Also, if you live in a dense urban area, you'll also likely suffer from issues with available wireless spectrum and have to compete with everyone's router blasting as loud as possible. https://www.bufferbloat.net/projects/ https://www.bufferbloat.net/projects/
- gruez 5y agoBut isn't the problem at every level, including the modem? Having a powerful router wouldn't help if the modem it's connected has bufferbloat as well.
- Syonyk 5y agoIf you've profiled the system and rate limit bandwidth to what's below the "steady state flow" of your network (including modem), then you never have buffers. It's usually only one or two layers you have to worry about before you get into some higher bandwidth backbones and the problem largely goes away. If L3's main links are buffering, the internet has some larger problems. As a concrete example here, I run networking for our church, and we've had to make a facility that really wasn't designed for livestreaming into something that can toss out a tolerable stream. We've got... no idea what we pay for, actually, but it reliably measures about 70/15 on Sunday mornings with nothing restricted. However, due to some various quirks of network naming, there are a lot of other devices on the network, some of which only get woken up for Sundays, and they like installing updates. Plus cell phones that recognize "Oooh, wireless!" I need to split the network up, but I also hate rejoining "things" to networks, and we have a few more of those than I really care to deal with. Experimentally, while our max upstream is about 15Mbit, things start to get erratic beyond about 10 - latency starts getting inconsistent and we start having stream issues. I've capped the livestream bandwidth at 8Mbit (we hardware transcode on site from the Main profile h.264 coming out of the switcher to High profile, at a lower bitrate), and that gets first priority - I'm using Mikrotik queues, so any packet coming out of the server on Sunday goes first. I played around with what everyone else gets, and eventually settled on around 2Mbit - that can mix in with our livestream and still not impact anything outbound. But I also had to cap our download. While the connection can do 70Mbit, I reliably saw upload dropping (even from 10Mbit) if something had pegged out download in the morning. So that's capped to a conservative 20Mbit, which is enough for most things, and is low enough to not interfere with the higher priority upload. This is all on timers, and the limits kick in Sunday before the services, and drop off afterwards. You can also find a lot of gains if your router prioritizes acks outbound. DSL modems were often so badly asymmetrical (think 25Mbit down, 768kbit up) that your upstream acks would end up in queues and not get through for a while (buffer bloat, though I didn't know that term at the time). You could radically improve a DSL modem's connection by putting some queues in to manage upload. Prioritize acks, and then limit your total upload to about 750kbit (on that example 768k modem) so that you weren't buffering in the modem. And all of this is entirely in the scope of the router, even if it's working around issues further upstream.
- cratermoon 5y agoKey takeaways - asymmetric broadband (high download speeds, low upload speeds) won't work in a world where people are doing real work "in a world of Zoom conferences, we need something that is more symmetric in download and upload — or at least upload speeds need to be a lot faster than they were when it was mostly Netflix and HBO Max" - rural/urban divide is real and a severe problem "for the most part, cities have done reasonably well, and rural areas have done reasonably badly. So this divide is really economic and population density" - the free market has few, if any, incentives, to build out to rural and low-density areas "If you are running a wire, whether it be cable or fiber, it costs the same amount per mile pretty much no matter where you put it. So if you can put it someplace where you can service 100,000 people, it’s a lot more economically advantageous than if you’re going to be serving 20" - there isn't any real free market anyway, since most locales have a single provider, maybe two "while there may be multiple internet providers, there are very few internet providers at any single place. So we essentially have, at least in regions, de facto monopolies that have very little reason to increase their offerings, at least from the sense of competition. - jobs will not be completely unconnected to location "It’s still going to matter that you are in the same area so that on occasion, you can come into the office and meet physically together. But I think there’s going to be much less of the five days a week on campus sort of work. People will be able to work two to three days a week at home, without any loss of productivity or loss of culture within their group."
- Dah00n 5y agoI'm constantly baffled at how the US can be stuck in this situation, being a country known for high tech businesses like Google etc. Especially when well-tested and proven solutions are readily available if politicians were interested. For example the problem with only one ISP is easy to fix (in theory, I know it isn't politically): Force infrastructure providers to open up for competitors. All electricity companies can be picked as a provider on the local infrastructure where I live and the same with internet. Even very rural areas have fibre (though there's nothing as rual as rual America of course). In my opinion all these problems stem from the two party system where nothing really changes so everything becomes inefficient in the long run.
- 5y ago
- padobson 5y agoOne of the interesting things about the infrastructure bill that has been proposed in Congress is it talks a lot about universal high-speed broadband access in the same way that, back in the ’30s, the recovery bills from the Great Depression talked about telephone access for everybody. Does anyone know about how this legislation worked out? Did it really get more people telephone access? I'm skeptical of any praise toward the New Deal, because it's almost universally praised by just about everyone, but then you dig into it and you find out that agencies like the NRA[0] were so bad that even their proponents had to admit they were a failure, and the "successful" programs that lasted, like Social Security, pale in comparison to more modern programs like Australia's Super. I don't hate the idea of the government delivering internet, but more like they deliver water or electricity, at the municipal level, rather than some set of national, overarching subsidies and regulations that will probably create perverse incentives all over this very large country. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Recovery_Administration#:~:text=The%20National%20Recovery%20Administration%20(NRA,fair%20practices%22%20and%20set%20prices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Recovery_Administrati....
- extra88 5y agoYes, I think the Communications Act of 1934 (and the Rural Electrification Act of 1936) was successful. The Communications Act established a Universal Service Fund that used long-distance charges to subsidize phone service for low-income households and expanding service to households that would not be profitable to serve. The Telecommunications Act of 1996, meant to be sort of a digital update, has clearly not been successful.