39 ms·
A police dog who cried drugs at every traffic stop
- ineedasername 6y agoThe dog got a reward when it signaled the presence of drugs. (before an actual search to confirm the dog's signal) That seems like a great way to train a dog to always signal the presence of drugs.
- steve_g 6y agoAnyone who knows anything about dogs would say that drug-sniffing dogs are a constitutional nightmare. They're basically a rubber-stamp. Dogs want to please their handlers. If the handler wants the dog to alert, the dog will alert. The presence or absence of drugs isn't relevant to the dog.
- moate 6y agoDrug K-9 units are right up there with polygraph tests in the "fake nonsense without enough science involved and a high-degree of abusability".
- the_doctah 6y agoPretty sure polygraphs are inadmissible in court these days and are mostly used as an interrogation tactic to elicit a confession
- moate 6y agoActually in several states they're still usable. Some as supporting evidence, others requiring double consent, and some just as evidence. Their time has not completely passed sadly. Never mind that the government itself still uses them as part of their security clearance process...
- ineedasername 6y agoYes. I train my dogs to give me its paw when I show it a cookie and say "paw". It never takes long for them to just sit down and start waiving their paw around as soon as I pull out the cookie. Or rushing to the door when I get home and doing the same thing even when I didn't present a dog treat.
- meowface 6y agoDo you have a source on this, and on how common it is? I certainly wouldn't be surprised at all if it's true, but I'm curious about actual studies.
- ineedasername 6y agoThe article for this post is a pretty good source: 100% rate for the dog indicating the presence of drugs is pretty much a rubber stamp.
- meowface 6y ago>Similar patterns abound nationwide, suggesting that Karma's career was not unusual. Lex, a drug detection dog in Illinois, alerted for narcotics 93 percent of the time during roadside sniffs, but was wrong in more than 40 percent of cases. Sella, a drug detection dog in Florida, gave false alerts 53 percent of the time. Bono, a drug detection dog in Virginia, incorrectly indicated the presence of drugs 74 percent of the time. These are concerning false positive rates, but I don't think anything in the article suggests the extent of what the parent wrote, in a universal sense: >They're basically a rubber-stamp. Dogs want to please their handlers. If the handler wants the dog to alert, the dog will alert. The presence or absence of drugs isn't relevant to the dog.
- jschwartzi 6y agoIf I took a test in college and got 40% of the answers wrong I would get an F.
- Smithalicious 6y agoIt's interesting to see the difference in testing between the US and Europe (or NL at least) - here getting 60% correct is a passing grade (usually 50% is the minimum)
- brewdad 6y agoI had a class in college where a 40% curved to a B. But yeah, the drug dogs are an end-around of the 4th Amendment.
- amalcon 6y agoIt's tricky because, while dogs can understand fairly complex vocabulary, their ability to reason abstractly about events is less developed. If the dog alerts, you spend two minutes searching, and then you reward the dog, it will have trouble connecting the reward to the alert. The obvious solution is to train the dog to search things that you know have drugs (or don't) because the trainer set it up that way. You'll need to then repeat this training often, and not always in the same environment. If you don't, eventually the dog will figure out that it will always be rewarded for alerting in the field. The problem with this, of course, is that it's expensive and cumbersome to do. You need to set up cars/bags/lockers/etc with and without drugs in them in a variety of locations, secure them (lest actual criminals steal the drugs), and bring the dogs to them (lots of time out of the handler's day). Also, even if you do this, you'll still get false positives: dogs are living animals, not machines.
- ineedasername 6y agoOr you just reward the dog when you put it back in the police vehicle whether it indicated the presence of drugs.
- walrus01 6y ago> It's tricky because, while dogs can understand fairly complex vocabulary, their ability to reason abstractly about events is less developed. dogs are also experts at picking up on non verbal body language and cues, whether you're intentionally giving them off or not.
- renewiltord 6y agoThis is hilarious. It's exactly the same problem as the "use AI to identify suspicious people" thing except that everyone freaks out about the former but loves this dog thing because they're fluffy. If we ever make fuzzy happy fun killbot, I think civil rights might be doomed because there'll be an army of killbot fans who will defend them even if they run internally on an API call to random.org
- elif 6y agoI think the condititoning is more like "train a dog to signal the presence of drugs _when the officer wants there to be drugs_" At least that's what happened when I was K9 nonconsent searched. The dog didn't signal for 4 laps and then the handler looked at him like i look at my dog when he eats cat food. Of course the dog then sat.
- arp242 6y agoIn the case of Wendy Farris it's actually even more blatant than that as the dog handler actually touched the car, after which the dog looks at the owner and "finds drugs" immediately in exactly that location. Surprise surprise. This is at the end of the second pass. A clue to the dog about as subtle as a brick in the face. The best possible good faith interpretation I can give to this is spectacular ignorance in understanding how dogs work.
- Johnny555 6y agoMy dog tried to train me to give him a night time treat. When I let him out at night, I give him a treat when he comes back in after doing his business outside. Then he got smart enough to scratch at the door to go out again, then came right back in and sat by the cabinet to wait for his treat. Finally he gave up on the extra treats when he found it didn't work. Dogs are very good at figuring out the actions they need to do to get a reward.
- JTbane 6y agoEven more troubling is this sort of thing could be grounds for asset forfeiture- in which you have to prove to a judge your property wasn't used in a crime to get it back.
- cwkoss 6y agoI feel like police forensic techniques are still stuck in the dark ages. I'd imagine there are similar issues with disregarding chance of false positives to make convictions easily in: - drug analysis - DNA segment matching - digital forensics - lineup identifications - police sketches
- leephillips 6y agoSome of these are well known. Also, fingerprints. And look up the Prosecutor’s Fallacy. In many cases, the forensic evidence is just theater, and the cops/prosecutors know it is meaningless. But juries and judges buy it.
- swiley 6y agoThe heavy use of fingerprints by cops and immigration bureaus feels extremely barbaric once you read a bit about them.
- ravenstine 6y agoThey haven't needed to advance that much. Shows like Forensic Files, COPS and so forth have convinced most people that the police are far more effective than they really are. Most people have no idea that the majority of crimes, including violent ones, go unsolved. (although this shouldn't be surprising to anyone who's actually been a victim of a crime) This isn't to say that policing in its current form isn't effective at all, but the media (whether intentionally or not) have done an excellent job as the propaganda department for the police. Why improve when everyone believes you're superman?
- mindcrime 6y agoShows like Forensic Files, COPS and so forth have convinced most people that the police are far more effective than they really are. but the media (whether intentionally or not) have done an excellent job as the propaganda department for the police. Personally I say "no way is this anything but intentional". There's way too much pro-cop, pro-military-industrial-complex, pro-sook-agency crap on TV for it to be just accidental. Propaganda is exactly what it is.
- throwawayboise 6y agoDog searches should require consent or a warrant, IMO. Too many cases where the dog is "alerting" based on cues from the handler and not an actual presence of any substances.
- cwkoss 6y agoDog searches should not be used as evidence unless the dog has been certified testing both false positive and false negative rates.
- minikites 6y agoWho is doing the certification? Why wouldn't they be just as corrupt as the police?
- asplake 6y agoQui custodiet ipsos custodes
- metiscus 6y agoExcellent point. For those who don't read latin or want to google translate it, the literal latin translation is: "Who will guard the guards themselves" The phrase is more commonly translated as: "Who will watch the watchers" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%...
- dane-pgp 6y agoSomeone with a good understanding of Latin could use this thread as an opportunity to make a Latin joke, by translating "Who will watch the watchdogs?" or "Who will guard the guard dogs?".
- michaelmrose 6y agoForbidding sniff tests from being used as evidence themselves or cause for further searches is likeliest to result in a just outcome. Sometimes the best answer to who watches the watcher is to simplify by eliminating the position.
- minikites 6y agoFrom the article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans >He discovered this artifact in the research methodology, wherein the horse was responding directly to involuntary cues in the body language of the human trainer, who was entirely unaware that he was providing such cues. Drug dogs are an end run around probable cause (as the article states). Modern policing is rotten to the core and needs to be abolished. An entirely different system needs to replace it, a system more focused on helping people instead of terrorizing the vulnerable.
- Clubber 6y agoI have no idea why this was downvoted. Lots of people have made livings showing illegal arrests, illegal searches, police lying (which is legal but a crime the other way around), coerced false confessions, and police brutality on YouTube because there's just so much damn material. It's right out of 1984. Here's one of many channels on the subject: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMCSd9ZNL0nshOhXwtfIJBA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMCSd9ZNL0nshOhXwtfIJBA All this is emboldened by the drug war. If it wasn't for that, most of these police departments would be well overstaffed (if they aren't considered that already). The US justice system is a farce.
- unxontuesnt 6y agoI don't downvote but I can speculate. As technology oriented website users, I think it's likely most of us are familiar with Joel Spolsky's advice to never do a big rewrite [0]. Regardless of the faults of current policing practices, the fact is that they represent centuries of judicial, legislative, and social work by many thousands of individuals. It is dishonest and absurd to believe that such a system can be adequately replaced by "something new I dunno lol". Cultures and traditions embody solutions to problems you don't know exist. "Cultural revolutions" have always and everywhere exposed the gaping wounds of the past and revived ancient problems that were once solved. The difficult and tedious work of persistent mutations and small improvements is historically the most reliable method to improve the lot of humanity. But it's not as exciting or sexy as "burn it all down" rhetoric, and people do want to get laid. [0] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-never-do-part-i/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-...
- leephillips 6y agoThis is something any US citizen should be concerned about, if not outraged. There is no 4th amendment if a cop can just have a dog with him, or say "I smelled weed", etc. The cops even joke about it, referring to the dogs as “probable cause on four legs”. The root problem is credulous or complicit judges who let this evidence be introduced. We need them to throw out these cases.
- namelessoracle 6y agoThe judge issue is understated. Local judges who can throw out this evidence get elected without challenge and often by relatively small numbers of voters. Judges are often voted in during an off season so voter turnout is tiny. But i used to joke that if about 50 percent of a local university turned up to vote for a judge they could easily de facto make marijuana legal in their area.
- samatman 6y agoIt's no joke! Ann Arbor Michigan had the most liberal cannabis laws in the United States for a couple decades running, it was a $5 fine for personal use quantities. In the late 80s (IIRC) a Republican on the city council tried to change this, campaign promise or something. The council said "hmm, yeah, it costs us more to process this paperwork than we get in fines" and raised it to $20 or $25.
- mhh__ 6y agoIn the UK we seem to have similar problems where what is considered personal use and not worth enforcing seems to be suspiciously dependant on the users societal class. I know people literally growing the stuff next to their house, but because they have a nice big garden and some local stature they'd face no consequences, whereas in the same county I'd never get away with that because I live in a suburb. Legalise it and tax it folks.
- lifeisstillgood 6y ago>>> Legalise it and tax it folks. Can't we just enforce the law equally without fear or favour?
- smt88 6y agoAnother anecdote: a friend of mine had weed in his locker in high school, and a random search by drug dogs didn't find it. The locker was vented, so it wasn't an airflow issue. A huge proportion of popular forensic techniques are BS, including "psychological profiling" that has been glorified on many TV shows.
- jfrunyon 6y agoTBH the drug dog searches at schools are more about getting dumb kids to go grab it to try and dump.
- Lammy 6y agoAs well as training kids that it's normal and expected to be searched by the police without warrant.
- smt88 6y agoWell, maybe the lesson there is that you are subject to warrantless search when on other people's (or govt) property. I don't think kids are under the illusion that they own their lockers...
- lacksconfidence 6y agoPerhaps not own in the "i can sell it" way. I think some number of high schoolers that have never had their lockers searched, including myself many years ago, assumed their lockers ensured a level of privacy.
- jfrunyon 6y agoSo... if I leave my house, am I subject to a warrantless search? (The road is government property, after all.) The answer is no, I'm not (at least in theory; there are so many exceptions that you really are). Moreover, you're not required to enter "other people's (or govt) property". Kids are required to go to school. The reality is that students have been shafted by the Supreme Court ignoring what the Constitution says.
- pwdisswordfish8 6y agoHighlighting this part, which might otherwise go unnoticed: > Instead of birthday cake and ice cream, she got jail food and a bill for hygiene supplies To spell it out, although she wasn't charged in the criminal sense, she was "charged" financially—for the privilege of experiencing false arrest. There are other states with extremely messed up legal processes, such as those where not only convicted persons receive a bill for their public defender (which at least makes some sense, logically) but states where you are on hook for thousands of dollars even in the event that you are never tried or you are tried and found not guilty.
- moshmosh 6y agoSome relatives of mine got to experience a fun little hostage situation with, "either you pay [absurd figure] per month for a couple years for drug rehab at a facility we chose, for your adult kid, plus smaller amounts of money for other stuff pretty much indefinitely, or or they rot in prison rather than getting out on probation". On the one hand, the guy definitely did something bad. On the other hand, gee I wonder how generational cycles of poverty, driving future crime rates, happen. No mystery that the effects of criminality seems to afflict entire families when the justice system is actively contributing to that. And no, it's not like they only got charged that much because they're flush with cash. I'm pretty sure the courts didn't give a damn whether they could afford it (technically, yes they could, but in anything resembling a financially-responsible sense, god no, not at all, they weren't starting from a great spot and it basically ruined them—the bread-winner will now work until he dies or gets so sick he can't anymore)
- plank_time 6y agoI don’t have much sympathy for people that commit actual crimes. There are too many innocent people being arrested to worry about the guilty ones. They chose to spend their money to keep their son out of jail. Thats was their choice. That’s the consequence of the son committing what appears to be a major crime. Hopefully the son learns from that and he should be working to help repay that debt.
- 6y ago
- paulpauper 6y agoSmell should not be used as probable cause. You cannot take a picture or document smell.
- iso8859-1 6y agoWhy not? You can jam electrodes into the dog skull and log its brain state.
- klyrs 6y agoYou can quite literally "take a picture of a smell" with a mass spectrometer. But that's expensive kit that needs training to use and experts to maintain. Justice isn't worth as much as a year in prison costs, apparently
- plank_time 6y agoThere needs to be accountability. If a dog is poor at sniffing drugs, it needs to be taken out of service. I don’t know what anyone hasn’t thought about that except because everyone who decides on these processes don’t care.
- michaelmrose 6y agoIt was only briefly touched on but this is the candidate for Governor of Washington State who lost by over half a million votes in an election with fewer than 5 million votes. This is to say he lost by a city not a country mile because he was very popular in Eastern WA where around 25% of the population lives but a dud elsewhere. This is pretty much par for the course in a state divided by both a mountain range and political ideology but what was unusual is that along with Trump Culp promoted the big lie that Trump had only lost the election because of rampant cheating and rolled Washington State into this perverse narrative with a side order of immigrant hate by making them the villains that stole WA from both Trump and Culp. According to Culp he and Trump were the proper inheritors of power in Washington and the nation. He even promised to uncover and reverse the fraud through lawsuits although he lacked the money to go through the show of reclaiming his "rightful place" via lawsuit he still fund raised off it as if he was going to and his fan club crowed about how great it would be when our actual governor was perp walked to depending on whom you asked prison or execution for treason. He is a disease right up their with the eastern Washington congressman Matt Shea whom we somehow just recently got rid of who published a paper on the biblical basis for war wherein it discussed the creation of an ISIS like biblical state following the fall of America in which wrong thinking women would be subjugated and wrong thinking men would simply be murdered. From Matt Sheas writing Under one heading, “Rules of War,” it makes a chilling prescription for enemies who flout “biblical law.” It states, “If they do not yield – kill all males.” https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2018/oct/26/rep-matt-shea-takes-credit-criticism-for-document-/ https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2018/oct/26/rep-matt-shea-... Even in our relatively liberal states the right is breeding ideologues, traitors, and terrorists who make real and solid the claims and fears that proponents of the red scare imagined. It turns out their fan fiction was written while looking into a mirror.
- waiseristy 6y agoIt is very typical of Western WA residents to blame the East side for voting red. King, Pierce, and Snohomish had more votes for Culp than the entire east side of the state combined. The Cascades are a mountain range, not some magical political wall
- 6y ago
- ineedasername 6y agoWe already have technology that can do this job: https://keprtv.com/news/local/new-technology-can-sniff-out-drugs https://keprtv.com/news/local/new-technology-can-sniff-out-d... Hopefully it's just a matter of time before we can replace owner-pleasing dogs with something that won't give a false positive in order to get a pat on the head and a treat.
- Forbo 6y agoThat's assuming they keep up on any necessary calibration and maintenance, as well as proper training. Just seems like another potential avenue for abuse and/or false positives.
- wahern 6y agoCalibration and maintenance of electronic devices is much more transparent. Defense attorneys successfully challenge breathalyzers and similar instruments all the time. One reason dogs are unlikely to be replaced by a device is precisely because 1) dogs are opaque instruments not readily susceptible to critical analysis, and 2) have long been given the benefit of a doubt--much like cops' famed mind-reading faculties. From the perspective of the police, it's a don't break what isn't broken situation.
- heavyset_go 6y agoCops will only buy and use them if it gives them the results they want. It's the same reason the field drug tests are designed to give false positives[1], and why body cameras can be turned off at-will and are advertised to police departments as devices that keep cops safe from the lying public. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/10/magazine/how-a-2-roadside-drug-test-sends-innocent-people-to-jail.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/10/magazine/how-a-2-roadside...
- nyhc99 6y agoHow do we the people fight these drug dog abuses? Politicians generally aren't interested in touching something like this. I'd love to put some money to work on the issue. Is there a foundation dedicated to suing police departments? Is that even a viable avenue to make a change?
- staplers 6y agoThe ACLU or National Lawyers Guild have a pretty solid reputation for taking action against unlawful policing. Links: https://www.nlg.org/defunding-the-police/ https://www.nlg.org/defunding-the-police/ https://www.aclu.org/news/criminal-law-reform/reimagining-the-role-of-police/ https://www.aclu.org/news/criminal-law-reform/reimagining-th...
- tehwebguy 6y agoVery good question with a very short answer: by asserting your rights and sticking to the script. It won’t stop you from getting railroaded but it could save you in court if you end up there: 1. When they pull you over: Why did you pull me over? 2. When they ask you questions: I’m not talking about my day 3. If they keep asking questions: Am I being detained or free to go? 4. If you are detained or arrested: I plead the fifth 5. Stop speaking [0] The supreme court decided that a traffic stop is just that, it’s not a license to hold someone on the side of the road and wait for a drug dog beyond the time it actually takes for the traffic stop + ticket. If there is probable cause / reasonable suspicion, vague but important concepts, the officer will not need a drug dog to search your car. But if you fail to assert your rights you may unintentionally consent to wait around for a dog you have no responsibility to wait for. This won’t stop you from having your rights violated in the moment, but failing to assert your rights (or worse, waiving them) will ensure that you don’t have them later in court if that’s where things head. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ajherrington/2021/01/22/the-only-four-things-to-say-if-youre-stopped-by-the-police/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/ajherrington/2021/01/22/the-onl...
- Johnny555 6y agoDon't talk to the police: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE Regent Law Professor James Duane gives viewers startling reasons why they should always exercise their 5th Amendment rights when questioned by government officials
- emj 6y agoLetting the Police take the money from Civil Forfeit is bonkers, John Oliver has an entertaining take on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks
- miesman 6y agoWho’s a good boy!
- benatkin 6y agoMore like a "good old boy". https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/good_old_boy#Noun https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/good_old_boy#Noun
- waymon 6y agoAny positives from the "war on drugs?"
- walrus01 6y agoPolice dog aside, Loren Culp is a highly problematic individual: https://www.google.com/search?channel=fs&client=ubuntu&q=loren+culp https://www.google.com/search?channel=fs&client=ubuntu&q=lor... Am I surprised that he would intentionally choose to use a method like this, that guarantees a search? Absolutely not. In the 2020 WA state governor election he ran on a very hard right platform. My personal opinion is that he knew he didn't have much chance of winning, due to population balance on the west side of the state, so he decided to double down on all the things his hard-core supporters loved most.
- mLuby 6y ago"highly problematic individual" is as lazy as saying someone's "bad" or "evil" just in more modern wording. Be more specific please. And that link doesn't help either: it's just a picture of the guy and a bunch of links to his twitter and some bland news headlines about his political run. No smoking gun that I can see.
- walrus01 6y agoIf you want specifics, he's given credence to qanon conspiracy theories, antivaccine and covid19 conspiracy theories, and parroted the same rhetoric as alt-right racist ideologues. And then, after he lost the election by a very wide margin, followed the example of Trump by spouting baseless conspiracy theories that the election was a giant fraud and stolen from him, despite no evidence of such appearing. Is that problematic enough for you? https://www.kxly.com/hundreds-defy-covid-19-restrictions-to-turn-out-for-loren-culp-rally-in-liberty-lake/ https://www.kxly.com/hundreds-defy-covid-19-restrictions-to-... https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2020/oct/07/inslee-culp-spar-over-covid-19-protests/ https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2020/oct/07/inslee-culp-sp...
- baobabKoodaa 6y ago> Is that problematic enough for you? I don't think this snarkyness is warranted. Your parent poster didn't argue against your claim, they simply asked you to present a coherent claim with references.
- antattack 6y agoThis reminds me of ADE_651, fake bomb detector, except the part of someone going to jail for fraud: "It was widely used in the Middle East, and may have led to numerous deadly bombings in Iraq due to its inability to detect explosives. Its inventor, James McCormick, was sentenced to 10 years in prison in 2013 for fraud. " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ADE_651 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ADE_651
- walrus01 6y agoThe BBC published a fascinating article on that: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-29459896 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-29459896 Longer form article: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2015/06/fake-bomb-detectors-iraq https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2015/06/fake-bomb-detectors-...
- ezoe 6y agoI don't get why US police use dog to catch the illegal drug. Dog is an natural animal whose behaviour we cannot reason with. It can train to sniff certain chemical, but it can also train to bark whenever police officer order to do so. It shall not be trusted for criminal investigation. Oh and the false positive rate is so high and it's practically same with coin toss. >But was wrong in more than 40 percent of cases. Sella, a drug detection dog in Florida, gave false alerts 53 percent of the time. Bono, a drug detection dog in Virginia, incorrectly indicated the presence of drugs 74 percent of the time.
- Sargos 6y ago>I don't get why US police use dog to catch the illegal drug. Dog is an natural animal whose behaviour we cannot reason with. It can train to sniff certain chemical, but it can also train to bark whenever police officer order to do so. It shall not be trusted for criminal investigation. This is not meant as a snarky comment but the negatives you listed are the actual reasons US police use them. It makes their jobs easier. They don't care about justice in the end.
- Tabular-Iceberg 6y agoThe problem isn’t using dogs in criminal investigations. It’s just police officers engaging in plain, old-fashioned racketeering. Otherwise why would the officers even put up with a dog that’s clearly just wasting their time and preventing them for doing their jobs? Why would they go out of their way to rig the training procedures to make their real jobs harder? Put the racketeers and perjurers behind bars where they belong and the dog reliability problem will solve itself.
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoI've seen dogs at border control checkpoints alert to vehicles and the police decide not to check the vehicle. It really does seem that the dog is used as an excuse when the police already wanted to check a vehicle. It seems the whole thing is a charade.
- mrslave 6y agoSensitivity vs specificity. The dog that always indicates drugs is always right when drugs are subsequently identified.
- whatgoodisaroad 6y agoIf a dog gave a positive result 93% of the time, but it was a false positive 40% of the time, does that mean 63% of suspects were carrying? Maybe I'm square, but that seems absurdly high to me unless the dogs are only used when there is already suspicion otherwise.
- greycol 6y agoIt's around 15% of the population (48 mil) of us population for marijuana. So yes the traffic stops were positively correlated with drug possesion. NB: The most optimistic reason for this correlation would be: 'Drug possession' correlates with 'drug use' correlates with 'driving while impaired' correlates with 'driving in a way that gets you pulled over'.
- loeg 6y ago> the dogs are only used when there is already suspicion otherwise. That is more or less exactly what the article says, yes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- open0 6y agoIs it known that in many American high schools the police will routinely search the halls, lockers, parking lots, and even force students to stand with their stuff placed on their desks while they walk around the classroom searching? Or how about that starting in 4th grade we had D.A.R.E., where they regularly bring in actual cops to teach a "class" during which they attempt to coerce students into snitching on their families? This is when they're not busy teaching us about drugs that 95% of the students had never even heard of. How about that it's very common for the police, if they find someone with a larger amount of drugs, to rob them rather than arrest them? This happens all the time with cops learning the license plates of particular dealers, although most drug dealers that I know have preferred this eventuality even if they lost a larger amount. Another friend lost 2 pounds of weed and a lot of money over a random noise complaint. These American institutions, the schools and the cops in this case, are a total failure and need to be completely reworked.
- giantg2 6y agoI recently had an experience with the system. Literally every person we encountered as a part of that system make mistakes, were incompetent, or committed misconduct. I'm talking about 3 magistrates (who aren't even required to be lawyers!), court clerks, a trooper, the SGT that approved the citation, the ADA, the second ADA, the DA clerk, a judge, court reporter, president judge, and I'm sure I'm forgetting others. It's an absolute shit show that only cares about money. I was even told by a civil rights lawyer that we had a case, but that the judges don't care unless we sustained substantial monetary loss (more than the $2k plus of handling the case pro se).
- AmVess 6y agoSearch dogs simply do not meet even a minimum requirement for probable cause because their accuracy is poor at best, yet they are widely used and accepted by law enforcement and the courts. Law enforcement agencies across the US still use lie detector tests, despite their efficacy having been determined many decades ago to be exactly nil. DNA evidence is infallible they say, yet an entire state( NY) screwed up their test procedures to such a degree that they are essentially trash. The system knew this, yet proceeded to use those tests because telling the truth was deemed too costly. They deemed it better to send possibly innocent people to jail than admit their mistake. Fingerprints are another area where law enforcement regularly screws up. They try to glean useful information from a partial print, in many cases so partial as to be laughable. I know of two cases where someone was arrested for a crime, even after having soundly proven they were not in the same state and even in the country at the time of the crime. Further, most of the tools in an arson investigator's toolkit are no better than using a divining rod to find water, yet they are accepted by the courts as valid. There are tens of thousands of cases where prosecutors proceeded with pressing charges in the face of overwhelming evidence to a suspect's innocence. The police are given tools that they do not understand, nor care to understand, and cannot employ with any reasonable amount accuracy. The courts nearly universally side with the police on these matters. These are simply facts, and should make everyone's hair stand on end, because the police are using what amounts to voodoo to determine the guilt of a suspect, and the courts go along with it.
- 6y ago
- giantg2 6y agoSomewhat of a tangent, but I think is worth mentioning. In many states, police dogs are given the many of same protections as police officers. If the dog attacks you without reason (happens more often than you would think), you can't defend yourself. Essentially, police dogs recieve more protection under the law than most people do.
- duxup 6y agoI wonder about your right to question your accusor. You can ask the cop, but all he has to say is the dog signaled. That seems kind of unfair.
- why55 6y agoDeprivation of rights under the color of law is a hell of a thing.
- didibus 6y agoInteresting how the two examples of false positive had large sum of cash in the car. Could the money have drugs or other bacteria in it that causes the false positive?
- tempodox 6y agoThe dog optimizes a metric it's rewarded for. The police using that dog optimize a metric they're rewarded for. The victim's actual guilt doesn't enter the equation.
- KingOfCoders 6y ago"Despite the frequent errors, courts typically treat certified narcotics dogs as infallible, allowing law enforcement agencies to use them like blank permission slips to enter vehicles" The article gets it wrong, this is the idea.
- ende42 6y agoTurns out, Karma isn't a bitch after all.
- macawfish 6y agoReminds me of how they're using machine learning these days.
- YeBanKo 6y agoIt sounds like if we applied the same statistical tools that we use elsewhere to estimate performance of a binary classifier: confusion matrix, AUC - ROC, F score and on top of that considered conditional probabilities when multiple test are applied (having dog sniff after applying "prior knowledge or suspicion") then we would discover that dog sniff test at large is unable to distinguish between two groups. They preferred a 2014 study from Poland, which eliminated the potential for false positives. Rather than simulating real-world conditions, researchers ensured that every test included measurable quantities of narcotics. This study's design seems malicious, you don't even need to be a data scientist, but merely have a tiny bit of curiosity, to at least wonder how does it do on tests without narcotics and include it in the test.
- lifeisstillgood 6y ago>>> drug detection dog in Illinois, alerted for narcotics 93 percent of the time during roadside sniffs, but was wrong in more than 40 percent of cases. Wow - ignoring the point of the article, that still means police officers were pulling over people to search at better than 1 in 2. Cops were good enough to look at a car and get it right that often. I mean what are the odds of randomly pulling a car and getting drugs in it? 50:1? 20? 100?
- mulmen 6y agoDrug dogs are not called in on every stop.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoThe point is, the cop with the dog stopped a selection of cars. The dog "found" drugs in 93% of cars, but was wrong 40% of the time. Roughly speaking, out of every 2 cars the cop stopped, 1 had drugs in. Unless this was a main gate at Glastonbury, that means the cops is amazingly good at choosing cars likely to be containing drugs. It does not matter if the dog is any good or not, the cop is. (plus if you can find out what "tells" the cop is using, you can stop giving off the tells - unless its really dumb like clouds of sweet smelling smoke pouring out of the windows) Edit: Or do you mean the cops pull over lots of cars, and then only sometimes decide to use the dog? Well, the same applies, only this time its less impressive as the cop gets to lean in the window, look over the occupants etc etc. But still, a 50/50 decision to call in the dog is a very high hit rate.
- mulmen 6y agoNot all cops have drug dogs.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoI am not sure you are reading the comments and applying yourself to understand the point being made. When a decision is taken to use that dog (no matter who or where), the decision was 'right' 1 in 2 times. This is way better than random searches of a car population.
- throwawayffffas 6y agoWhat I found surprising is the the actual prevalence of narcotics. > Lex, a drug detection dog in Illinois, alerted for narcotics 93 percent of the time during roadside sniffs, but was wrong in more than 40 percent of cases. That means that the dog was right 60 percent of the time or that 55.8 percent of the people stopped actually had drugs in the car. Unless I am missing something.
- codeulike 6y agoSomewhat related: this tweet from anonymous confession twitter account 'fesshole': I train & handle drug sniffer dogs for the Navy. Once spent several days turning over a battleship from top to bottom after the dog kept giving clear sign. Truth is I'd realised a couple of hours in I'd brought the explosives dog by mistake but it'd gone too far by then https://twitter.com/fesshole/status/1344741374957129749 https://twitter.com/fesshole/status/1344741374957129749
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- airhead969 6y ago"I smell marijuana. Step out of the vehicle, sir, while I scratch your doors and tear up your seats."
- jenkstom 6y agoWhile I'm all for fixing bad policing (very, very much so), I have a hard time dealing with reason.com. They wrote an article on a medical condition I have (MCS) repeating "research" by a chemical industry shill group and made it that much more difficult for people like myself to figure out what is going on and how to treat it. I'm referring to the "Environmental Sensitivities Research Institute" that promoted "crazy" as a diagnosis rather and conflating it with other conditions like electrical sensitivity than the now well-accepted "inflammatory disease". The ESRI is long gone, but the reason.com article (https://reason.com/1996/06/01/sick-of-it-all/ https://reason.com/1996/06/01/sick-of-it-all/) is still there - from 1996 - making it just a little bit more difficult for people like myself to function in the world.