20 ms·
Germany bans Facebook from handling WhatsApp data over privacy concerns
- thamer 6y agoThis article is pretty vague. What does it even mean to ban Facebook "from using data from WhatsApp users"? Facebook "uses data from WhatsApp users" to support basic features like authentication, is that banned now? What about sending a WhatsApp message to a contact, doesn't that "use data from WhatsApp users"? Facebook has to look up some internal user ID (user data), then route the message to their devices, probably by device ID (also user data). How do you do that if using data banned? I suspect there's more to it but this particular article isn't telling the story in a particularly clear or helpful manner. Hopefully the actual injunction is not as vague.
- Barrin92 6y agoFrom Spiegel: "Am Dienstag gab Caspars Behörde bekannt, dass sie eine Anordnung erlassen hat, die es Facebook – also der Mutterfirma von WhatsApp – verbietet, personenbezogene Daten von WhatsApp zu »eigenen Zwecken« zu verarbeiten. Gemeint ist damit, dass Facebook jene Daten zum Beispiel nicht für sein Anzeigengeschäft nutzen darf. " Roughly translated as: Whatsapp is not allowed to share personal user data with Facebook for Facebooks own use, for example Facebook cannot collect data for the purpose of advertisement (and my guess is any other form of monetization). Facebook says further down in the article they currently don't share data between the services for those purposes. I also think you're confused about the scope. It's no problem that WhatsApp uses its own userdata, the problem is WhatsApp sharing data with Facebook, which is a distinct service. https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/apps/whatsapp-hamburger-datenschuetzer-erlaesst-anordnung-gegen-facebook-a-e5504670-4907-4352-a7dd-2370f39b6d92 https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/apps/whatsapp-hamburger-date...
- thamer 6y agoAh, that makes sense. Thanks for the details!
- trompetenaccoun 6y agoStill super vague. What exactly will be mandated? By what metric are they supposed to identify "German" users? And what if those German users talk to "non-German users"? Will those chats and the corresponding meta-data also be protected? Our private data leaks all over the place, EU regulation in that regard is like a game of whac-a-mole. In a globalized online world this will only work if there's international legislation.
- tchalla 6y agoAnother Source - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-11/facebook-ordered-to-stop-collecting-german-whatsapp-users-data https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-11/facebook-... > Johannes Caspar, who heads Hamburg’s privacy authority, issued a three-month emergency ban, prohibiting Facebook from continuing with the data collection. He also asked a panel of European Union data regulators to take action and issue a ruling across the 27-nation bloc. The new WhatsApp terms enabling the data scoop are invalid because they are intransparent, inconsistent and overly broad, he said.
- humanlion87 6y ago> Facebook’s WhatsApp unit called Caspar’s claims “wrong” and said the order won’t stop the roll-out of the new terms. I don't understand how Facebook says this order will not stop the roll-out. Are they implying that the authority has no power to implement/enforce the ban?
- Jonanin 6y agoThey incorrectly assumed (like much of the media) that this update was about sharing data of personal messages with Facebook, when it is in fact not.
- zwaps 6y agoIt is, but not yet in the EU. It literally says : we will share everything with Facebook as soon as the EU allows. Right now we do not. But we might. I mean it’s written there.
- tpush 6y agoWhere does it literally say that?
- zwaps 6y agoI quote from their website ——— Today, WhatsApp does not share your personal information with Facebook to improve your Facebook product experiences or provide you more relevant Facebook ad experiences on Facebook. This is a result of discussions with the Irish Data Protection Commission and other Data Protection Authorities in Europe. We're always working on new ways to improve how you experience WhatsApp and the other Facebook Company Products you use. Should we choose to share such data with the Facebook Companies for this purpose in the future, we will only do so when we reach an understanding with the Irish Data Protection Commission on a future mechanism to enable such use. We'll keep you updated on new experiences we offer and our information practices. —————— This is legalese for pretty much what I posted. In particular, the keep you update here does not necessarily mean you get to agree to a new privacy policy, as the current policy does not include a commitment not to share data (for ads etc) with facebook in the first place. This statement is deviously placed outside the privacy policy! Also further up they say that they associate the whatsapp profile with any facebook profile in the household/net/vicinity. To be clear, they do this now. Not in the future.
- mseri 6y agoCNBC provides [1] links to the original source of the news [2] [1]: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/11/facebook-has-been-told-to-stop-processing-german-whatsapp-data-.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/11/facebook-has-been-told-to-st... [2]: https://datenschutz-hamburg.de/pressemitteilungen/2021/05/2021-05-11-facebook-anordnung https://datenschutz-hamburg.de/pressemitteilungen/2021/05/20...
- the-dude 6y agoIIRC this was exactly the policy the EU required for allowing the acquisition in the first place.
- annadane 6y agoRight? And then they went ahead and did it anyway
- littlecranky67 6y agoyour comment is very relevant, most other comments focus on existing regulations like GDPR. But IIRC the Whatsapp takeover was only granted from EU regulatory offices with the requirement that Facebook would not join the Whatsapp users data into their systems [0] [0]: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/facebook-whatsapp-merger-european-commission-complaint https://www.wired.co.uk/article/facebook-whatsapp-merger-eur...
- wnkrshm 6y agoFacebook even said it wasn't possible IIRC.
- cuillevel3 6y agoWhatsapp already had a separate privacy policy for the European region (https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/updates/privacy-policy-eea?lang=en https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/updates/privacy-policy-eea?la...) Apparently that was too permissive. I guess they had to try?
- zwaps 6y agoThe privacy policy mildly states that they do not share personal data with facebook for ads right now. But it also says they might do so at any time, at the latest when the EU okays it. So yeah, at the very least it is too vague to be a proper privacy policy allowing informed consent
- amaccuish 6y agoFantastic news and really ideally the whole purchase should be reversed (and obviously more ideally never allowed to happen in the first place)
- throwawaysea 6y agoTo take this further, we also need to reverse other purchases like Instagram, YouTube, Twitch, Zenimax, Doubleclick, PA Semi, and so on. We also need a new vocabulary and new concepts. We shouldn't rely on traditional notions of monopoly market share or "consumer harm" to decide when an acquisition/merger/stake should be allowed. We need a new definition to prevent gigantic conglomerates with immense market power, and then we need to enforce that law aggressively, in splitting up existing companies and scrutinizing future deals.
- arcticbull 6y agoReasonably anticipated future consumer harm sounds like a good model to me, IMO. For instance, if we can reasonably assume an acquisition will lead to the potential for future harm through accumulation of power, influence, data, etc, that should be sufficient to block it. Mergers are in and of themselves simply recognizing an efficiency of scale. It should be possible for a business to achieve success without that shortcut, broadly speaking. Once they're big enough already, that is. This seems to tie in nicely to the recent narrative that efficiency is the opposite of resiliency, and that maybe not all efficiencies are good.
- chmod775 6y agoWe need the old vocabulary back. Much smaller companies used to get split up, but with globalization our understanding of what a large company or what a monopoly is changed. When it comes to these things countries nowadays are more hands-off than they ever were. Further, advocates of these 'hands-off' approaches like to pretend we'd be returning to some ideal of old that brought prosperity and countries 'meddling' in the 'free market' is some modern fallacy, which is just revisionist history. Edit: While the above is more personal observation than based on any hard data, there appears to be research supporting my position. This is looking like a good overview: https://som.yale.edu/faculty-research-centers/centers-initiatives/thurman-arnold-project-at-yale/antitrust-enforcement-data-0 https://som.yale.edu/faculty-research-centers/centers-initia...
- eqvinox 6y agoThe aspect I find most interesting and internationally relevant is that as these local rulings proliferate, they kinda make it visible to what degree companies finance their operations by selling user data. The more the business model relies on this, the more likely companies are to get hit with a ruling like this — and it's not just the ruling that's interesting, but also what Facebook's reaction will be. If they stop offering or reduce WhatsApp services in Germany (or India), that's a great indicator that the service isn't profitable without the sale (or other commercial exploitation, Facebook is an ad company after all) of large amounts of user data.
- vineyardmike 6y agoReducing service can also be a strong-armed way to force customers to advocate for them. "Want to keep talking to grandma? Better tell your government to leave us alone"
- leipert 6y agoI am actually using this argument in the inverse: “hey grandma, do you still wanna see baby pictures, please install <other-messenger>”
- behnamoh 6y agoIf only grandma could use Signal, etc. The problem is that Telegram has by far the best UI and UX IMO, and yet we cannot trust it. Then there are applications which we could trust more (like Signal) but they are ridiculously hard to use and lack many features. Actually, I would say FB Messenger also sucks a lot and apparently FB does not care.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agonot accurate. I was able to get grandma on Signal precisely because it was the little secret between us. She knew that a signal coming in was from me, and only me. I was using it to talk to her. And she thought it was cool that we talked via signal to her before any other family member caught on the signal craze. I was able to get my SO to use signal on the same principle. Pick the people in your life that care about you - and care back. You are available via signal, while you ingnore whatsapp et al. You answer right away on signal whereas on other stuff, you wait. Its funny how far along you can take a feature-lacking app provided its simple for others to use, and there is an emotional attachment in its use.
- FridayoLeary 6y agoUnless we have German police personally looking over shoulders wherever WhatsApps data is handled, i don't see how this exchange of information can be prevented.
- fishmaster 6y agoI think it's more that they can be fined heavily should it ever be found out.
- nr2x 6y agoSo is this is the start of finally bypassing Ireland?
- saos 6y agoWondering what the UK will do..
- noja 6y agoWhat can Facebook argue against here? They are going back on what they guaranteed to allow the acquisition.
- annadane 6y agoThe same bullshit they usually do to make them look like the poor victims
- ohthehugemanate 6y agoThis works in WA's favor in some contexts. I have a fresh wave of friends who tell me I should reinstall WA, because they "don't do data sharing in Germany". I note that their terms still say that they do share data; they just have a PR line outside the terms that says they'll do it as soon as they "reach an agreement" with regulators. I further note that their entire business model for WA depends on sharing data for advertising. Trusting them on their PR agent's word not to share data is the fox guarding the hen house.
- phito 6y agoWhy do people insist so much about using Facebook's apps? This reads just like an addict giving bad excuses for their relapse...
- mds101 6y agoThe problem is Whatsapp has strong network effects unlike Facebook itself. Most people would be able to quit Facebook and it wouldn't make much of a difference to their lives, whereas cutting off Whatsapp would mean a daily inconvenience when you want to talk to the people closest to you.
- midasz 6y ago> would mean a daily inconvenience when you want to talk to the people closest to you I did exactly that and it wasn't hard at all. I still have a phone number which they can call or text. I let them know the alternatives I was reachable on, and they installed them. My family group chat is now on Telegram, my wife who still uses whatsapp says the WA family chat is basically dead. Even when I was in contact with a recruiter for the job I'm currently in it wasn't that hard. She said I'll 'App you' which means to send a message via WA. I quickly said something like ah sorry I'm not on WA but you can Telegram or just text me instead. And you know what she said? Ok. And then we texted. If it's really that big of an inconvenience for those closest to you, you have to wonder how close they really are.
- 6y ago
- holoduke 6y agoEU should completely ban Facebook and WhatsApp entirely. EU should say fuck that rotten person called Zuckerberg. From tomorrow all ISPs will block all Facebook products.
- ranguna 6y agoPersonally, I'm already blocking Facebook through nextdns.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> From tomorrow all ISPs will block all Facebook products. That actually happened in my country. Lasted a few days, nothing of substance happened in response. Few people installed alternatives.
- romanovcode 6y ago> From tomorrow all ISPs will block all Facebook products. This is not how EU does things.
- tgragnato 6y agoThe way EU does things is getting tiresome. I'd love if we could blackhole their ASes. > “As the Hamburg DPA’s claims are wrong, the order will not impact the continued roll-out of the update.“ ... blocking the assets of criminals does not impact civil liberties
- hrbf 6y ago> A spokesperson for WhatsApp said: “As the Hamburg DPA’s claims are wrong, the order will not impact the continued roll-out of the update. The amount of Facebook’s arrogance at play here is just staggering.
- ab111111111 6y agoQuite. Who are mere German public officials to question the rectitude of an organisation as august as Facebook?
- Graffur 6y agoTo be fair, it seems like the German public office have not done their work and have some thing incorrect. As such, it doesn't apply.
- mrjin 6y agoThat's simply because the penalty of violating the law is no more than a breeze in comparison to their revenue.
- klaustopher 6y agoThe fee is up to 4% of facebooks annual worldwide revenue ... That would be ~2bn $
- qznc 6y agoSo far the responsible DPC just ignores the complaints though: https://noyb.eu/en/irish-dpc-handles-9993-gdpr-complaints-without-decision https://noyb.eu/en/irish-dpc-handles-9993-gdpr-complaints-wi...
- jazu 6y agoThat German authority interprets the law in some way, Facebook interprets it in some other way. i assume the courts will decide. Seems reasonable to me.
- rubyist5eva 6y agoWhat kind of wannabe authoritarian regime bans a company from using data it owns?
- akie 6y agoA "regime" that values the privacy of its citizens over the profits of a multinational?
- rubyist5eva 6y agoAh yes, just like the vaccine passports they will be implementing because they value "privacy". Sure.
- robin_reala 6y agoThe legal situation is that Facebook doesn’t own any of this data. It has collected it, but the data is owned and controlled by individual users, and they have the right to say what Facebook should be allowed to do with it.
- CRConrad 6y agoA legitimate democratically elected national government in a continental union that conditioned its anti-trust approval of the acquisition of WhatsApp by Facebook precisely on personal data not being used in that way. That "kind of wannabe authoritarian regime". HTH!
- rubyist5eva 6y agoJust because you were legitimately elected doesn't make you not authoritarian. Plenty of authoritarian regimes came into power legitimately, and then abused that power with popular support because the people thought it sounded like a good idea at the time. Anti-Trust is generally smoke and mirrors anyway - I can't think of any antitrust that actually did anything useful. AT&T was broken up, and then 5 of the companies merged back into it over time. Standard Oil was broken up and now we have Exxon (yay...). Microsoft was hit because they bundled IE with Windows but now they have IE, and Edge still bundled with Windows 10.
- jokoon 6y agoIsn't that like a huge news? By reading the article it seems like it's not such a big deal... On the other hand, facebook seems like it's deader than dead, it's just the agglomeration of whatsapp, instagram and occulus now. I'm curious if the Trump election problem is one the reason why facebook is dying.
- noisy_boy 6y agoThis cat and mouse game will continue forever as I don't expect governments that give Facebook a clean chit in exchange of data sharing to do much policing. The only real power lies in our hands. Many of us change/mute the channel when the ads come on, do the same effectively online by blocking ads and if that is not possible, by _never_ clicking on ads. The whole point is to sell and if we ensure that we don't pass any signal back in terms of how we are deciding, the point of ad spends themselves will be in question. The only effective wakeup call for such scum companies is their revenue taking a hit.
- mectag 6y agoIf German users would switch. WhatsApp is the main Messanger in Germany, and a lot of the people who live here are not that interested in privacy (although there is still a relatively large piece who is). It‘s too abstract for some people how their data is used. The Government needs to explain more and not just create rules which people find annoying to follow.