27 ms·
Why does every advert look the same? Corporate Memphis
- webwielder2 6y agoTrends are trendy, film at 11.
- ConceptJunkie 6y agoSo maybe one tenth of one percent of marketing people have an original idea in their heads. This is nothing new.
- analog31 6y agoTrends serve a use, which is to remind us of exactly this fact. Whenever we paeans are told that we can't contribute a product idea, because the big ideas have to come from the big idea people, or that design concepts stem from "research," a trend comes along and reassures us that we're all equals after all.
- duderific 6y agoI think that's probably a bit harsh. Marketing is hard. Try coming up with a new idea for a car advertisement. What can you do that already hasn't been done?
- mdoms 6y agoIf you don't want to discuss the article feel free to click the little 'x' and move on.
- lainga 6y agoThe name refers to how it resembles the work of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memphis_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memphis_Group
- michaelhoffman 6y agoThanks for answering the most obvious question anyone would have about this phenomenon that was inexplicably totally missing from the article itself.
- sweetheart 6y agoIt isn’t; they mention it.
- ryanwhitney 6y agoThough, fairly buried after using the term constantly throughout the beginning of the piece! Didn't find it myself so I came back to HN and saw GP comment. Then cmd+f for "italian" to find it in the article.
- mdoms 6y ago> The name is a play on the 80’s Italian design and architecture group Memphis, which positioned itself as a garish and child-like rejection of functionalist styles. From the article.
- Pils 6y agoFor visual reference, Evan Collin's Are.na block is the most cohesive collection of this aesthetic I've found online https://www.are.na/evan-collins-1522646491/memphis-general-geo-pomo https://www.are.na/evan-collins-1522646491/memphis-general-g.... The Memphis-esque style is definitely having a moment. You'll notice that the Chillwave aesthetic borrowed a ton of visual cues as well.
- lainga 6y agoI find the "childlike" quality of it oddly appropriate for modern corps, but not in a good way, more like "we know we're infantilising you. Drink up!"
- tonywastaken 6y ago“It really boils my piss to be honest,” says Jack Hurley, a Leeds-based illustrator who says his main output is “daft seaside posters.”
- KineticLensman 6y agoIf you are a Brit (or even otherwise) I really recommend taking a look at Hurley's work [0]. The taglines for each resort are just superb - e.g. "Cleethorpes - The Final Resort" As an aside, I'm reminded of the old joke that Cleethorpes doesn't have a twin town, but is in a suicide pact with Grimsby. [0] https://www.pinterest.co.uk/christinefbosha/jack-hurley-posters/ https://www.pinterest.co.uk/christinefbosha/jack-hurley-post...
- samizdis 6y agoHe wrote an article for The Guardian a couple of years ago in which he explains his work - cracking images in it, too: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/nov/29/rubbish-seaside-a-backhanded-love-letter-to-urban-britain https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/nov/29/rubbish-seasi...
- vitili 6y agoReminds me of this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lFb7BOI_QFc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lFb7BOI_QFc
- sound1 6y agoVery close to a racist video, this :) But as a colored person, it is just a cultural difference. People just associate certain things with skin color, and depending upon geographical location it can be an advantage or a disadvantage. I was in Greenville SC and they were the warmest people I ever met, but yeah they took their own time to let me in :-) (if you must ask it was the farmer's market)
- randylahey 6y agoI too thought of this video and it is what introduced me to this particular form of "art". It's a good critique.
- EvRev 6y agoFrom a technical perspective I enjoy using graphics that are able to be rendered as a SVG. I believe that is why this style has taken off, it is able to be served and rendered with regard to performance. The article presents it as a change made by Apple, but it was really the frontend that pushed visuals like this. I support redesigns every three years and have stopped recommending the faceless images that is Memphis Group. Trends are great, regular work to purge trends is even better.
- deltron3030 6y ago> I believe that is why this style has taken off, it is able to be served and rendered with regard to performance. Bingo. This and the flexibility to compose your own scenery from those illustration systems vs. hunting down the right stock image or hiring a photographer.
- peanut_worm 6y agoReally you should blame the popularity of SVG graphics
- cashew_worm 6y agoespecially scalable SVG graphics
- lwhi 6y agoIt's not the popularity of svgs .. it's the need for resolution independent graphics.
- jollybean 6y agoI don't think this has much to do with technology or Photoshop - these memes are always he case where a few leading agencies in NYC do something for some big clients and then everyone copies. It's 'creative herd mentality as driven by generally non-marketing CEO's making the final decision on creative'.
- sidpatil 6y agoA good example of this is Volkswagen's "Think Small" advertisement from the 1960s [1]. Plenty of magazine ads ripped off this style afterwards. [1] https://pages.uncc.edu/visualrhetoric/projects/individual-projects/think-small-advertising-campaign/ https://pages.uncc.edu/visualrhetoric/projects/individual-pr...
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoI think that the aim of this style is a type of corporate PR, to give off a safe, unoffensive feeling. I then think that this feeling is intended to preempt the user's knowledge that the company is doing unethical things. Either environmentally, or with the user's private data, or otherwise. A good example is Google, (see some corporate memphis here, https://blog.google/technology/health/when-it-comes-mental-health-what-are-we-searching/ https://blog.google/technology/health/when-it-comes-mental-h...), who needs to project this image in order for you to feel safe while sharing your most private details with the company.
- quelsolaar 6y agoI think its interesting that the flat look was pioneered by Microsoft going back to the days of the Zune2 and later lumia phones that had the first Metro interface. Then google and Apple and everyone else started following. People don't think of Microsoft (and especially Zune...) as a leader in design, but I think they have had a big impact on the industry, and deserves some recognition.
- Apocryphon 6y agoIt's certainly Metro-influenced, but one wishes the real deal Metro came back.
- Lammy 6y agoI think you can probably trace some influence even further back to webTV. Check out its flat "10-foot UI" from 1999: https://youtu.be/eHJN9cMo4P4?t=156 https://youtu.be/eHJN9cMo4P4?t=156 Microsoft's UltimateTV set-top-box hardware group got folded into the Xbox division in 2002: https://www.mrt.com/news/article/Microsoft-to-Eliminate-TV-Division-7722896.php https://www.mrt.com/news/article/Microsoft-to-Eliminate-TV-D... And then in 2006 (per Wikipedia), "Xbox 360 overseer J Allard ran the [Toshiba Gigabeat 1089] project, codenamed 'Argo', staffed with Xbox and MSN Music Store developers who worked on 'Alexandria', finalized as Zune Marketplace."
- sidpatil 6y ago> Check out its flat "10-foot UI" from 1999 That doesn't look flat whatsoever. There are plenty of three-dimensional layout elements in that UI.
- Lammy 6y agoAre you currently ten feet away from a fuzzy 24” consumer CRT television?
- sidpatil 6y agoNot at the moment, but the design elements are similar enough to the ones I'd see on my satellite receiver OSD menus from back in the early 2000s. I could tell that those were 3D as well at the time, and my TV at the time was a fuzzy 36" CRT from the 1990s. And I'm glad for it! 3D design elements make a lot of sense on those kinds of displays, because they work well to stand out despite the relatively low resolution and color contrast.
- nostromo 6y agoIt’s largely driven by corporations trying to be as broad and inoffensive as possible. Not sure what skin color to use? Make them blue. Are your depictions of humans too thin, or too ableist? Make them misshapen blobs so nobody can tell. Not sure how to include non-binary representation? Just make them all genderless.
- echelon 6y agoThis is so bland and dystopian. Mutated blob people make me hate interacting with corporate products. If you're going to do this, at least use creativity. Discord does a fantastic job of being inclusive and yet creative.
- genericone 6y agoCorporate culture has deemed it a better tradeoff to be called uncreative than to be called k-ist or j-phobic. Most of these people just want to do their jobs and go home at the end of the day, not thread the political needle at great expense if it goes wrong.
- Lammy 6y agoI just think of it as "Doug, but everyone has elephantiasis" https://i.imgur.com/LMqi9fp.png https://i.imgur.com/LMqi9fp.png
- userbinator 6y agoIt's so inoffensive that it has become offensive to me, with an "evil megacorp" association.
- rsj_hn 6y agoThere used to be true artistry and celebration of beauty in corporate advertising. Look at the works of Toulouse-Lautrec or Alphonse Mucha. But no college kid is going to be putting up posters of these misshapen flat people in their college dorm.
- ChrisArchitect 6y agoThis is from January, there's other articles around mentioning this trend Here's another angle: It's Killing Brands https://www.aleksandrhovhannisyan.com/blog/blue-people-illustrations/ https://www.aleksandrhovhannisyan.com/blog/blue-people-illus...
- bentcorner 6y agoSimilarly: https://eyeondesign.aiga.org/dont-worry-these-gangley-armed-cartoons-are-here-to-protect-you-from-big-tech/ https://eyeondesign.aiga.org/dont-worry-these-gangley-armed-...
- coding123 6y agoSomeone sent this around a few weeks ago - it's a lot more harsh/critical: https://www.marketplace.org/2021/04/15/a-primer-on-corporate-memphis-big-techs-favorite-design-trend/ https://www.marketplace.org/2021/04/15/a-primer-on-corporate... > Merrill: I think Facebook is probably the biggest example of it. They went through a phase where they were using this style universally. And, you know, they are one of the darkest companies as far as how they’re using that customer data. And it is all about this idea of, “Trust me. I’m a trustworthy company.” And let’s not look behind the curtain and see what’s actually going on. So I think it’s a really nefarious way to hide behind visual language.
- nescioquid 6y agoMy immediate thought was of rhetorical training in the ancient world. On the one hand, training in rhetoric will help you persuade, and on the other, will also help you become aware when someone else is using those techniques. One of the five parts of rhetoric was called "ethos", which is concerned with how to establish yourself with your audience as trustworthy and sympathetic. In advertising, lots of elements beyond mere words are employed to establish ethos, visual style, sound, editing. But I suppose I never explicitly considered the visual display of an application as an exercise in rhetoric, though upon reflection, it certainly can be. Perhaps we all need visual-rhetorical training.
- blululu 6y agoThe trend is real but it is also pretty innocuous. I know that design people think that these things influence collective consciousness in a deep way but really it is just another cog in the wheel. In my personal experience, the primary reason that design teams prefer this style is that it is able to clearly represent a diverse and inclusive audience. Inclusivity and diversity are very important goals for most American companies. Part of this may be related to certain liberal ideologies but most of this is just about capitalism. America is a diverse country and most American companies also harbor aspirations to serve global markets. Having a simple way to show that your products can solve problems for everyone is just good for business.
- Lammy 6y agoIt lets companies look diverse without being diverse, yeah.
- blululu 6y agoA subtle distinction here: The goal is not for the company to look diverse but rather for the product/service to appeal to a diverse customer/user base. This is a formidable design challenge. Depicting the full range of human life is not really possible with half a dozen images. The solution that everyone has landed on is to lower the fidelity of the representation. If we get rid of photorealism, 3d features, texture and other high resolution features, then a single illustration can encompass a much greater slice of humanity than a photograph could. I'm sure that there are other solutions to this design problem but I don't think that anything will replace the Memphis aesthetic until people understand the needs that led to its ubiquity. Any alternative aesthetic will need to satisfy the same basic business requirements.
- lghh 6y agoChicken and egg. If you're a company that isn't very diverse but is trying to change that, a good first step is to present diversity. If that's the ONLY step, then sure go ahead and drag them, but it's not bad on its face.
- mattkevan 6y agoHad a discussion about this style with an illustrator friend a few months ago. Illustration is genuinely better at conveying concepts than photography, and everyone is tired of lightbulbs, puzzle pieces, people in suits shaking hands and other stock photo cliches. Problem is, commissioning an illustrator, especially a good one, is expensive and time consuming and takes excellent art direction to get right.[1] This style however, is cheap, easy (anyone with a bit of drawing ability can do it), it’s sort of cozy and friendly, and doesn’t have any real negative cultural associations. It also wasn’t, until about six months ago, so totally overexposed it’s become a cliche in itself. Now, there’s no excuse to use it - just betrays a fatal lack of originality. Might as well include an image of someone reaching up to a blue wireframe globe superimposed with zeroes and ones and @ symbols. [1] Original illustration isn’t used nearly as much as it could or should be in digital products. Nautil.us do it well, but they are a magazine. Seriously, commission more illustration, it’s great.
- ok123456 6y ago> Might as well include an image of someone reaching up to a blue wireframe globe superimposed with zeroes and ones and @ symbols. I'd prefer that.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> This style however, is cheap, easy (anyone with a bit of drawing ability can do it) Hey, speak for yourself. That's more drawing ability than *I* have. :p
- edgartaor 6y agoI feel this style have the same infamous reputation as Comic Sans font. It isn't a bad style, it's just overused.
- cm2012 6y agoI do a ton of direct response ad creative. Generally stock photos work really well if chosen with care, but brands shy away from them due to perceived cheapness. Their loss.
- axguscbklp 6y agoReminds me a bit of the infamous Grubhub ad that came out a few months ago[1] - similarities include the color scheme, the checklist approach to racial diversity, and the attempt to project generic inoffensive "fun". The Grubhub ad, at least, is so bad that it's entertaining. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-T3qKl6y-c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-T3qKl6y-c
- TchoBeer 6y agoPerhaps, in being so widely shared, it has in fact achieved a level of success that is incredibly rare for an advertisement.
- mbesto 6y ago> “From a design point of view, it’s pretty lazy,” says Hurley. I love designers criticizing design used for business. It rarely incorporates any perspective on business objectives. As long as the design is achieving its goal then who cares?
- asperous 6y agoBecause they are professionals. Software engineers, lawyers, doctors... skilled people who have creative control often put pride into their work as a means of expressing their talent and enthusiasm, even if it doesn’t make a direct tangible difference.
- ironmagma 6y agoWho cares is the people who have to experience the design which doesn’t stand on its own (i.e. customers or users).
- RobertKerans 6y agoBecause design/illustration can be demonstrably meaningful and/or useful and/or informative &c. Whereas this is a nullification: at this point in time [as it reaches a kind of saturation point] it's a mass-produceable toolkit for generating inoffensive fluff to fill space. In the sense that it cannot fail at doing nothing much, then sure, it has succeeded. But the goal is to...do what exactly? It's kitsch. Good design tends to take quite a bit of thought: this takes very little. Hence, lazy.
- saagarjha 6y agoI hate Corporate Memphis as much as the next person but > “Isometric perspective is interesting, because nothing recedes to a vanishing point,” Rudnick says, “and therefore it also eliminates the variable of time.” He points out that this type of design is particularly popular with fintech and mortgage companies – playing down the passage of time is particularly advantageous to firms selling financial products that you may end up paying off for years. seems like it’s reading a bit too much.
- Karunamon 6y agoI'm glad I wasn't the only one who detected the scent of what I call "arthouse wankery" here. This is popular for the same reason flat UIs are popular - they're easy to create, blandly inoffensive, and convey "modern" to the viewer.
- jsonne 6y agoSeriously. It has a lot more to do with the idea too that if you look similar to other big companies who are using it then you'll get a modicum of a trust factor out of the gate than some nefarious psy op.
- RobertKerans 6y agoIt can be, and generally is, both (if by "arthouse wankery" you mean design theory).
- daaang 6y agoCool to see Humaaan mentioned. They were one of the first successful startups from Tommy Schlaaang and the Schlaaang Corporation.
- k12sosse 6y agolayered jungle noises A tad ironic, as I'm actually browsing this from my schlaaang superseat.
- kingsuper20 6y agoThanks for the link, I had no idea that it had a name. The folks on the site that starts with 4 and ends with chan have done some funny parodies of it. You know, it takes some real work to do a Fitzpatrick and Van Kaufman ad. There's a kind of artistic malaise in the modern era. Admittedly, you see that kind of look in vintage travel and airline posters.
- userbinator 6y agoThe folks on the site that starts with 4 and ends with chan have done some funny parodies of it. Thanks for the tip, I rarely visit that site but the parodies (while NSFW and not politically correct, in the usual manner) have been thoroughly, hilariously, entertaining. I think the fact that a style meant to be ultra-politically-correct getting turned into the exact opposite greatly added to the humour.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/QnhXE https://archive.is/QnhXE
- olivermarks 6y agoA lot of the reason for these design trends is that no one has the courage to think differently, so you get huge numbers of companies all looking virtually identical. It's a bit like 'nobody gets fired for buying IBM/McKinsey' etc...no one challenges product managers and marketing when yet another adobe illustrator generated Memphis style brand identity & UI is unveiled, complete with multi cultural inclusive visual banality. At some point this will suddenly be deader than an animated gif of a flame and the next trend will quickly become ubiquitous.
- Guest42 6y agoI wonder perhaps too if the more prestigious resumes start coming from companies that embrace these trends, further reinforcing them across industry.
- lwhi 6y agoI think it's more ultitarian than that. Companies have traditionally got what they need by using these conventions. Hopefully that will change, because it sure is boring.
- thisCtx 6y agoWhen I’m trying to do computer tasks, I want to get them done, not decipher some design wonks metaphor and hyperbole. You want thinking different? Try trotting out a line that doesn’t start out like an old man pissed at them kids for not being as competent as folks were “back in his day.” The whole point of modern logistics is to simplify them so we can maximize time for ourselves instead of flogging the profit chant of last generations rubes seeking Valhalla.
- strict9 6y ago>with multi cultural inclusive visual banality Lumping in cultural inclusivity with your critique is quite revealing. There's nothing in the article or about this style of illustration that hints at cultural values, why include it in the tirade?
- jjoonathan 6y ago
- grouphugs 6y agoin the commercials you get cheap xanax and life is awesome, in real life you get rape and death
- Animats 6y agoInterestingly, this has spread to second-tier virtual worlds. Decentraland, Sominium Space, and Facebook Horizon all have that look. It's the opposite of the realistic, gritty world of AAA game titles. It's safe and banal. Facebook is very concerned about "safety".[1] By which they mean "no sex", not "no scams". Their solution to this in Horizon is that their characters have no body below the waist. [1] https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw https://youtu.be/Uf_9J_EdzZw
- pmoriarty 6y agoBetter question: Why are you even watching ads? Due to my ad blockers and not watching TV or listening to the radio, I almost never see or hear ads, so didn't even know that many ads looked the same. I wish more people used ad blockers, so we can wipe out the cancer that is advertising.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDo you ever go outside?
- pmoriarty 6y agoYes, but I listen to music or podcasts on headphones so don't hear adverts that might be playing on a radio in stores and avert my gaze from billboards and ads on monitors.
- chrisseaton 6y agoOk well most people don't want to go to that kind of excessive effort to avoid seeing an advert, so that's why they're seeing adverts.
- motohagiography 6y agoThe point of these design languages is to affect a sense of power. One of the funniest versions of this was 1990's tech aesthetic that was pure (Italian) Futurism, without any sense of irony about its origins. Corporate Memphis looks like a variation of it. There is a word I can't seem to find, and it's for when you take a font or an image and round it to make it seem softer, safer, and less assertive, and so-called "feminine." The Corporate Memphis designers have essentially taken the aesthetics of both futurism and "Naive Art," to create this new language of patronizing global banality. It's not about adding or emphasizing diverse elements, it's about homogenizing them, which captures the whole purpose I think.
- dexwiz 6y agoI saw a piece in a SF-based Italian art museum that was four panels, each with about 20 small cubbies. In each cubby was an individual abstract, brightly painted wood shape (carving?). If you squinted even a bit, it was indistinguishable from a list of modern corporate logos. Not the same as futurism, but I could see the artistic lineage.
- TchoBeer 6y agoBecomes especially funny when you consider the ideological origins of Italian Futurism. Hint: What was the dominant ideology in Italy in the 1930s and 40s.
- frostburg 6y agoIt's even more problematic. The relationship is more accurately understood in the opposite direction: fascism in some ways grew out of futurism (a lot of important exponents of futurism loved action and violence and speed enough to volunteer and get themselves killed in airplanes etc. in the first world war).
- defen 6y ago> There is a word I can't seem to find, and it's for when you take a font or an image and round it to make it seem softer, safer, and less assertive, and so-called "feminine." I don't know the word either, but this reminds me of the concept of "elevator music"
- Disruptive_Dave 6y agoAn element not mentioned much in this thread is the significant challenges in using actual photography/people: expensive and time-consuming for custom work, super choppy legal waters (can't tell you how many times the subject of a photo pulled from Unsplash reached out asking how we got their pic), and paltry options for online buying ("free" sites like aforementioned Unsplash or expensive Getty and their craptastic library).
- dale_glass 6y ago"a few years ago he might have been complaining about the glut of owls and foxes wearing monocles" foxes with monocles? When was that a fashion? In what context? I am most curious.
- lwhi 6y ago'Folk naivete’ definitely seemed to be a cliche style employed to disarm the consumer thinking of themselves as 'individual'.
- swearwolf 6y agoIt was a cutesy art trend. This is the first artist I noticed doing it: https://berkleyillustration.com/ https://berkleyillustration.com/ It spread from there and became ubiquitous, at least in the Pacific Northwest.
- lwhi 6y agoReally? I think this might be known as spam.
- lwhi 6y agoIf your company's reach is limitless, you need to appeal to everyone. If your company's offering is wide and disparate, you need a visual brand that offers cohesion. If you want to fit in and belong, you need to employ the same visual vocabulary as everyone else. This trend is a symptom of the system business currently operates within.
- vmception 6y ago> When you see the CEO of tech companies talk in private or to one another, the way that they frame their view of the world is fascinatingly opposed to the world depicted in a Corporate Memphis illustration I see a CEO who won’t squirrel away over details that are irrelevant to making money, isn't married to a company as their baby, and has in particular let go of the design process and given it to designers or design firms because that CEO doesn't actually care. And that’s perfect. I think of companies as short expeditions to the New World to get the gold, return, and everybody disbands and never talks to each other again. Imagine if Columbus instead told the Queen of Spain that he wanted frills on the sails of the Nina, and that the typography needed changing. Would be absurd. Same for companies. This view of reality has been a highly effective for me.
- knolax 6y agoProducts made by people who take no pride in the product are rarely good. It's the difference between enterprise slime and the software that you actually use on your personal computer. Most software really doesn't exist in a competitive market, it's naturally monopolistic, so you can't just rely on market forces to ensure it isn't shit.
- vmception 6y agoAnd the counterpoint is that Instagram is great. A dozen people got the $1bn buyout, a few years of Facebook vesting and moved on. The general distribution of all products suck. Has nothing to do with the speculators that consider their $0 par value shares to be part of their portfolio.
- lwhi 6y agoIt's the world we live in. But to say the situation is perfect, is quite simply a lie.
- vmception 6y agoI know plenty of people that squirrel away over irrelevant details for new businesses and can’t distinguish between relevant and irrelevant I specifically didn’t say perfect I said ‘effective’, and ‘for me’: The executive, board member, and advisor for various ventures.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoFind it weird how similar this is to 90s era software box art, things like Adobe Acrobat 5.0 [1] [1] https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/adobe/images/d/da/Adobe_Acrobat_5.0_box.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20200123190949 https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/adobe/images/d/da/Adobe_Ac...
- makeworld 6y agoWorking link: https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/adobe/images/d/da/Adobe_Acrobat_5.0_box.jpg https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/adobe/images/d/da/Adobe_Ac...
- lykahb 6y agoWhen paging the old magazines, I noticed that until about the mid-eighties the focus of an ad was on a product. An ad would even boast of the technical specs of a car or an audio system. A prominent display of people in the process of consuming, or even just people, puts the marketing focus on lifestyle, brand identity and the alignment with some values. I hate Corporate Memphis the same way I hate the other attempts to hack my reptilian brain and build an emotional connection with a brand.
- throwaway98797 6y agoMarketing checking accounts is hard.
- jdjkckfkrrn 6y agoThis style is also called in a derogative way "humans of flat". It's quite controversial in the design world. Critique of it can also be a bad career move, so people are a bit hush about it.
- mattkevan 6y agoHere's a good selection of Corporate Memphis, for your reference. https://www.are.na/claire-l-evans/corporate-memphis https://www.are.na/claire-l-evans/corporate-memphis The 80s Memphis style was like Bauhaus but with more formica, but this new style is more of an attempt to make rapacious startups funded by vulture capital/rapacious megacorps intent on destroying the fabric of society (delete as appropriate) feel like warm, fuzzy friends. Hello fellow humans, aren't we all friendly, human and fun, etc.
- fidesomnes 6y agoI work with people who seemed to have watched Silicon Valley's Hooli and thought "wow what a great company, I want to work at a place like that!"
- knolax 6y ago> multi cultural inclusive visual banality > It lets companies look diverse > Not sure what skin color to use? Make them blue Seeing cartoon SVGs of brown people really hits a nerve for some people. IMO if you walk around the Bay Area the racial distribution is more or less the same as these graphics, so there's really nothing to complain about in that regard. Go buy Russian software if you don't like it.
- vehemenz 6y agoIt’s a valid observation. Don’t you think it’s a bit cynical and calculated to include “diversity” on every single advertising graphic?
- knolax 6y agoOnly if you think that "diversity" is somehow abnormal. Why is it a calculated move for companies like Google, whose CEO has brown skin, to have some of their advertisements include brown skinned people? The real cynical move would be to make them all white to appease middle America. Why do you feel the rest of us have to hide our existence to appease you?
- vehemenz 6y agoI too use my identity as a cudgel, except I am a philosopher. > Only if you think that "diversity" is somehow abnormal. I don't, and you chose the value-laden term "abnormal" instead of "demographically atypical". Convenient that you chose the term that I would never use and that makes your argument look less preposterous. > Why is it a calculated move for companies like Google, whose CEO has brown skin, to have some of their advertisements include brown skinned people? This implies that brown skin is an indicator of diversity. To use your method of reductio: ...only if you think that diversity is determined by superficial attributes like skin color. > The real cynical move would be to make them all white to appease middle America. You one-percenters in the Bay Area must be very insulated; appealing to "diversity" does appease middle America. You could never get away with all white characters now, and I'm sure you know that. > Why do you feel the rest of us have to hide our existence to appease you? False attribution.
- executive 6y agohttps://knowyourmeme.com/memes/subcultures/corporate-art-style https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/subcultures/corporate-art-sty...
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe irony is that there's nothing Memphis here. It's all corporate. Original 80s Memphis was migraine-inducingly Weird As Fuck. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memphis_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memphis_Group A very heavily watered down version influenced MTV and an even more neutered version was splattered across numerous corporate brochures and reports in the 90s. But it was only Memphis in the most superficial sense, riffing off bright colours, geometric squiggles, and a few stock Memphis textures like zebra print. This doesn't even have that. It's just bland, cartoony, sometimes literally faceless, and flat - visually as well as emotionally.
- jjeaff 6y agoI can see some similarities. There are lots of geometric shapes as well as bright pastel colors used in this new "corporate Memphis".
- emptyparadise 6y agoLosing all identity is the final fate of anything that becomes corporate.
- TchoBeer 6y agoMaybe this is a hot take, but I actually love this artstyle. I love minimalist art/clean vector art in general, and this is more of that, so I'm a big fan. I'll be sad when it stops being trendy.
- oseph 6y agoLong-time illustrator here who has worked for various clients such as WIRED, Slack, etc etc. Here are my two rambly cents: Firstly, I think this article is almost spot on. One of the major culprits behind this issue of "flat illustration" as I've seen it called is that there is usually a lack of originality being forced onto the illustrator from the hiring companies. Usually this is in the form of "we love what Company X is doing and would love to have something visually similar," and by visually similar, usually what they want is something that's pretty much the same but with a different colour palette. Boo! But hey, if you're the illustrator here and they're not going to credit your name (which is generally the case with branding related work, such as this flat stuff) ... who gives a shit, right? Take the money and run and watch the world burn with flat illustration. /s I said "almost spot on" earlier because one thing not mentioned in this article––and this has been my "theory" and those of my illustrator colleagues for years-–is the economic side of it all, and how it has affected illustrative output: Firstly, know that illustration rates have been pretty stagnant since the 90s and deadlines are getting shorter and shorter due to the demands of real-time publishing. No more waiting for something to go to print, you just schedule a blog post. Back in the dying era of print (mid-00s), even small illustration gigs could come with generous turnaround times of 3 or 4-ish weeks if you were lucky. Usually a week or two to figure out rough sketches and get approval from the client, and then a week or so to crank out the final art. Maybe you're painting or drawing this on physical media like paper, gouache, watercolour, etc, which comes with fantastic built-in features like texture and brushstrokes, where honestly flat is HARD to pull off. But today it's more likely you get an email and the client wants sketches for Friday, and final art the following Wednesday. You simply don't have as much time to work on polishing up a nice sketch to turn into a painting; sometimes this stuff just needs straight-up time to massage into place. Instead, you can use the old bucket fill in Photoshop or flat fill in Illustrator, copy paste a few pieces from your own collection of past work perhaps, adjust a few colors and call it a day. I admit when I first saw this stuff 10 or so years ago, I thought it was bold and graphic and honestly I wouldn't have had the courage to do something so simple; it's a nice shout out to the digital painterliness that is flat vector shapes. But when it becomes this common place ... well, it just looks boring. Anyway, as much fun as it is to dump time and energy into a drawing, if the requested content is fucking lame and generic and the deadline is short, have fun getting nice original work out of it. Instead, maybe hire an illustrator on the long term and have them develop something truly unique that no one would want to be caught dead copying because it would just look like plagiarism. It's not all doom and gloom though. Some of this flat stuff can be good! For example, many illustrations on the Apple App Store (on macOS, depending on the day) have a nice level of polish to them that push them past the generic flat style and can feel fresh and new, at least to me as an illustrator, while still satisfying some obvious corporate requests for something safe and predictable. *edit*: spelings and puncs *edit edit*: Corporate Memphis is such a dumb name for this. just call it Flat Style as all of the illustratorverse has been calling it for years.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 1cvmask 6y agoIn the old days smaller companies were confined to commonly used stock photos. Is there nostalgia for those days?
- kgin 6y ago>Rudnick says that what makes Corporate Memphis particularly insidious is that its worldview is designed to be misleading. “It depicts a world whose problems are already solved, built out of complementary components” I'm not defending the style but this really seems like a stretch too far.
- shp0ngle 6y agoI think it's really just "pattern matching". All design after a while is an obnoxious copy of what is popular. Remember when what used to be popular were giant auto-play videos on the background of Bootstrap/Foundation websites? Or before that, all the rounded corners and color gradients? Fads will pass, corporations will soon change to something else.
- crazygringo 6y ago> the trend has started to consume the visual world at large. It’s also drawing intense criticisms from those within the design world... “It really boils my piss to be honest,” says Jack Hurley, a Leeds-based illustrator... “From a design point of view, it’s pretty lazy,” says Hurley. Advertising has followed trends for many, many, many decades. There's literally no point in time where it doesn't look "all the same". Corporate Memphis isn't "lazy", nor does it deserve "intense criticim". It's simply a style that lends itself well to the moment -- it's fresh, innocent, inclusive, simple, positive. And like all trends, it'll be replaced with the next new trend in advertising soon enough. This article seems to be reading waaay too much into it.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agopersonally I think one of the reasons why it's popular is it is reminiscent of the style of the 1920s, and can thus, with a few tweaks be used to connote a connection to the past as well as implying modernity. https://www.illustrationhistory.org/images/uploads/held-Life.dancers26.jpg https://www.illustrationhistory.org/images/uploads/held-Life... https://hprints.com/s_img/s_md/58/58883-lillustration-des-modes-1920-n1-pierre-brissaud-maggie-salcedo-benito-paul-poiret-polo-doeuillet-8797b088f0b9-hprints-com.jpg https://hprints.com/s_img/s_md/58/58883-lillustration-des-mo... I can think of lots of reasons why using the 1920s as a visual source would be interesting for designers in this period, so a few people did it and others jumped on (my feeling when I started seeing it around)
- constGard 6y agoWhile the article is heavy on philosophical extrapolation, it's pretty light on facts. The original example of this art style was commissioned by Facebook and is called alegría: https://jsweisart.com/facebook-alegria https://jsweisart.com/facebook-alegria
- rawoke083600 6y agoMy trick for writing/making ads (mostly GoogleAds, FB Posters etc) is to do the following litmus test: Let say I'm creating an advert for a 'Real Estate Agency'. We will call it 'LINDEX', when I'm done with the text, visuals msg etc, I ask myself: Litmus Test: "If I exchange another company's name and logo (in the same sector) in the ad will it still make sense ? If the answer is yes, then I know my ad is TOO GENERIC/ LAME Example: "Real Estate Agency, "LINDEX" we give personal service and listen to the buyer and put you in your dream home." Now the above is way too generic if I replace our company 'LINDEX' with say "Tom & Jerry Agents" name and logo the ad will still make sense and is the same amount of boring to be honest. If I change the ad now to: "Real Estate Agency, 'LINDEX', the only agency that does a lifestyle assessment and put you with-in 10km of 80% of your monthly travel." Now that is 'unique`ish' and no other agency can just copy our ad and replace it with their name + logo Tip 2: I saw it on some Youtube video and If I recall the Youtuber got the idea/tip from his graphic design mentor. I"m not doing the explanation justice but I will try. When creating posters/ads: Remember the rule of 3. You should have 3 different 'levels of read' (text+intensity) Example of a "good" poster about a Jazz Festival: I'm using HTML convention to illustrate text size + intensity. * = h1 * = h2 * = h3 * JAZZ MUSICAL * * LIVE CONCERT * <pictures/visual> * WHEN: 30th of Feb at PowerRanger Stadium ** <pictures/visual> ** Tickets are $100 and children under 12 is free ** Explanation: The first and foremost text "JAZZ MUSICAL LIVE CONCERT" is aimed at drawing the attention of anyone interested in JAZZ and has the most intensity/size. You should not be able to read the H2/H3 (When/Where/Costs/Details) from far away.. Once we got the Jazz enthusiast hooked and they see the poster and start to walk towards it. Only then will they see the H2 and H3 text,"When/Where" and how much. The customer should first be filtered through the H1 as a Jazz-Lover of sorts... The point is there is no use to focus the attention(use up poster-real-estate) on the When/Where/Cost if we haven't first filtered out the "Non-Jazz-People" PS. All companies, names and examples are fake :) Bonus Tip: Funny sells: but you are probably way less funnier than you think to a broader semi-unknown audience.
- garganzol 6y agoI like this style but in a twisted way. It allows me to immediately detect a low quality stuff produced by numerous (tasteless) companies. This is a strong signal I just cannot ignore. If a company chooses to blindly copycat the templated low quality crap, this says a thousand words.
- adam0c 6y agoanswer: because deep down the majority just want the same bullshit repackaged over and over, look at game franchise it's never as good as previous games ;D
- andrepd 6y ago> The style coincided with an increasingly data-driven and hyper-personalised tech world, while also having a nostalgic, cartoony feel. “I think it's desperate. It's a desperate attempt at trying to be human,” he says.
- Thorentis 6y agoHere's another perspective: this type of art style is in my opinion, quite childish and immature. It lacks detail, uses limited colors, and most often depicts people playing, or having fun. To me it represents the on-going "dumbing down" of tech. It shows how tech companies view their customers/users - children who need to be told what to think, what to buy, and how to behave.
- whall6 6y agoContrast this with S&P ratings’ website. Just feels so much more human. Here’s their careers page. https://www.spglobal.com/en/careers/overview/ https://www.spglobal.com/en/careers/overview/
- vander_elst 6y agoWhat I miss a bit in the article is the acknowledgement that me might have found a simple, efficient and effective communication medium that could be used in several contexts. Although it might be far from perfect and have several drawbacks, I like that we don't need to reinvent the wheel from scratch every single time we have to craft a visual message.
- A_non_e-moose 6y agoI was under the impression that Alegria was the name of this latest iteration on flat design: https://buck.co/work/facebook-alegria https://buck.co/work/facebook-alegria Sure Zune and Material were there before, but I only remember feeling alienated by so-bland-it's-unrelatable designs since I started seeing all those Alegria iterated synth-cartoons everywhere. Alegria or Corp Memphis, seem to have overflowed into children's cartoons, probably for the same reasons, easy to pump out designs, hard to be offended at, generic enough to fit most needs. I find this one particularly flat and bland: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PBE-W1TMeXI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PBE-W1TMeXI