18 ms·
What Happens to Stocks and Cryptocurrencies When the Fed Stops Raining Money?
- rvz 6y agoThis is what happens: [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27086093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27086093
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoAs far as I know Bitcoin is still an uncorrelated asset. Stocks on the other hand will have quite a bad time. https://charts.coinmetrics.io/correlations/ https://charts.coinmetrics.io/correlations/
- rabbitonrails 6y agohow could it be uncorrelated when investors are using the same source of funds (stimulus checks and low interest rates) to bid on both assets
- retrac 6y agoBitcoin is more international, perhaps? It's certainly easier for many to acquire than a mix of American stocks. Of course, the US is the largest part of the cryptocurrency market and if they thrash about in the pool, it should at least result in some ripples.
- andresp 6y agoThe entire world invests in s&p500 and global indices.
- 55555 6y agoThis simply isn't true. I live in Thailand. Most locals here don't have access to US stocks, or don't know that they do. Young people here have a Thai stock trading app (for the SET, which is the exchange) on their phone and another one for their domestic cryptocurrency exchange of choice. I think very few of them are buying AMZN or TSLA. I'd bet fewer than 3% of the population here are buying US stocks.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stewbrew 6y agoYou cannot fill two buckets at the same time. You're right though that from bird's eye view, they are both correlated with the overall amount of available money.
- cookguyruffles 6y agoBitcoin regularly moves in tandem with SPX and this effect will continue to strengthen as more ETFs become available, and futures volume (on classic regulated exchanges) increases. These instruments are gateways that enable a much larger class of investors to come into Bitcoin cheaply, but it also means Bitcoin joins their portfolios and is treated similarly to other asset classes during market events. Uncorrelated, mass adoption: pick one. During the massively undersubscribed 7 year note auction last month BTC absolutely tanked and recovered in perfect synchrony with SPX, TLT and gold. During a recent deleveraging event (last month I believe), it was possible to observe BTC following an identical path to SPX for almost the entire day.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoYou say it moves in tandem but the only time I’ve ever see it approach mathematical correlation was the Covid dump day when all markets were correlated. Play around with the link I provided and see for yourself. Watching charts we can see all sorts of things we think are correlated but mathematics provides a way to check if those things are real or noise.
- MrMan 6y agois cointegration a mathematical concept?
- plank_time 6y agoDogecoin is at $0.60. This cryptocurrency was made as a joke. That’s really all you need to know about it. The Fed and SEC etc all claim they want to make things safe for retail investors, but we are seeing the manifestation of a malicious bubble right before our eyes and they are all doing nothing. Zero. Zilch. Lots of people are going to lose a lot of money when this is over. And please remember that the government agencies that are supposed to be helping us are doing absolutely nothing. And then, once the dust settles, just like after the dotcom bust, you will see a ton of regulations coming down like SOX to “protect” investors when we could have been protected RIGHT NOW, May 2021. It’s utter bullshit. When people say conspiracies like the government is using covid to control us and try to take away our freedom, I would normally laugh. But after 9-11 and the “Patriot” act, the dotcom bust and SOX, and whatever regulations come from the fallout of crypto, I’m starting to wonder if they have a point.
- rawtxapp 6y agoPretty much all the markets are going crazy right now, people are getting 100+k all-cash offers on top of their asking prices on their houses for sale, sp500 p/e ratio average is at like 44, pokemon cards are increasing in value, etc. What's happening is not specific to dogecoin/crypto in my opinion.
- plank_time 6y agoIn fact I just sold my house in SF Bay Area last month for $500k above listing price, all cash no contingencies. We are now renting in hopes that the market cools down but we are worried that this housing mania won’t stop and we will get priced out of the market. But for 500k above list, I couldn’t say no.
- almost_usual 6y agoThis is pretty much the gist of the article. People are worried about holding cash right now because they think it’s losing value. We’ve got trillions more about to be injected. All assets are priced high because of it. If you can get a low interest mortgage right now you’re in a good spot.
- cheschire 6y agohttps://archive.is/MtAv7 https://archive.is/MtAv7
- bruiseralmighty 6y ago> "Look Chuck, I'll believe it when I see it." Fed only reluctantly raised rates several years after '08. I would be surprised if they began staking them higher anytime soon regardless of any 'strong recovery' narrative. The banks and courts still haven't dealt with a wave of evictions and the resulting property consolidation that will result when the moratoriums are lifted. Plus, if you believe in speculation, the markets are frothy right now. Survey says: S&P500 is held up by FAANG, corporate bonds 'a fiasco' [zombie companies], SEC snoozing as usual. If market adjusts, then rates will have to remain low; or perhaps go negative. If you believe speculation.
- kungito 6y agoThe problem is, this was a lunch topic 5 years ago. Some people were already then reluctant and were forecasting a crash and here we are.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoYeah, I bet a friend that the S&P was gonna crash in 2016, clearly I know nothing about the markets.
- TheGigaChad 6y agoThey roll out the FedCoin and save us from barbarism.
- okareaman 6y agoThose who do not read "Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds" by Charles Mackay are doomed to repeat it.
- bourgwaletariat 6y agoI don't think that's a reasonable expectation. There are countless books on the topic and it's unreasonable to expect they have this level of knowledge. There's a reason a we don't say, "Well, if the bridge collapses while they are on it, it's their fault for not having studied civil engineering. Shoulda known better."
- Proven 6y agoWrong question. They can't stop.
- baby 6y agoPaywall
- StandardFuture 6y agoPerhaps the only thing that actually happens is that bubbles pop (as they always have and always will) and all that remains is anything of substance? Many cryptocurrencies and stocks are garbage but quite a number of cryptocurrencies and stocks are backed by solid companies and technology. A few greedy people get lucky and pull out of the bubble with returns. Most greedy people get burned by their get- rich-quick gambling. This is not anything new or terrible. Of course, all of this craziness can be used to mask genuine scams or scamish-marketed "investments". Those are what the Feds need to chase and prosecute. There are plenty of cryptocurrencies (and inflated stock evaluations) that are genuine pump and dump scams. These pump and dumps really should be prosecuted harshly. We really need to get over this idea that we can regulate away losses and negative outcomes of basic stupid human behavior simply because it seems like an ideal that we be able to do so.
- skohan 6y agoI guess the counterpoint to this would be to say that it's policy, not human stupidity which has led to the bubble. By keeping the interest rate at almost zero for over a decade, the fed has incentivized dumping money in the market, since there's really nowhere else to put it. And dumping trillions into the economy in the past year has only added fuel to the fire. It can be argued that trying to "regulate away losses and negative outcomes" is exactly what has been happening over the past decade.
- StandardFuture 6y ago> It can be argued that trying to "regulate away losses and negative outcomes" is exactly what has been happening over the past decade. Yes, this is because we have been living in a boomer-retirement-fund driven crony capitalistic market for the past 2-3 decades. Wall Street and politicians in bed doing whatever they can to squeeze the economy of every last drop (usually through regulations + consolidations) to put in the old peoples last-wishes/bucket-list fund. We are a society that went from having too many impoverished elderly to having too many narcissistic and lavish elderly who have no idea what too even do with their 3 homes and 7 figures. Rich hippies, basically.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jopsen 6y agoIt's seems to me that as a retail investor choices are pretty limited: - keep money in the bank at negative interest. - buy stocks at high prices. - lock cash in bonds at risk of inflation. - buy real estate at high prices. And which strategy is best depends on Fed policy.
- rottencupcakes 6y agoYou forgot buy dogecoin.
- mxschumacher 6y agoyou can short equity if you think valuations are dangerously high For high inflation expectations it would be wise to own companies that have plenty of debt and sell commodities or have pricing power
- jopsen 6y ago> you can short equity if you think valuations are dangerously high But they can stay irrational longer than I can remain solvent :) But yes, I can tweak my portfolio. But for the most part we're largely left with no other option than to ride the bubble.
- emkemp 6y agoYou can also buy TIPS and Series I Savings Bonds.
- ArtTimeInvestor 6y agoThe article makes it sound like stocks are high because of low interest rates. But the main reason that stocks are high is probably that there is so much money out there: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren... I think the fed would need to take back money to reverse the inflation. I don't know via which mechanisms they would do this. Does anybody here know? It is important to remember that this would bankrupt the government unless the government finds ways to raise capital elsewhere. So we will probably not see any de-inflationary actions unless we also see higher taxes. My feeling: We will see a fast rise in taxes and a slow rise in interest rates. In other words: Governments will try to take away peoples money and only afterwards slowly make money more valuable again. Maybe. Maybe they will just keep the value of money at the current level.
- cookguyruffles 6y agoThey have tens of knobs, some strange and esoteric, targeting specific corners of the banking system, but I believe if they want to control inflation they simply need to cut back on bond purchases. As they buy less bonds, their price drops, as the price drops risk-free yields drift higher. As risk-free yields drift higher, consumer credit becomes simultaneously more expensive and less available, as lenders allocate less of their capital to risky lending and more to risk-free (government) lending. This credit shrinkage causes the deflationary effect. The trouble is that every time the fed has even hinted at this on past occasions (stretching back a decade), an immediate violent market event has usually followed. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/taper-tantrum.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/taper-tantrum.asp
- CyberRabbi 6y agoTo take back the money they would need to sell the assets they bought to inject money into the economy in the first place, then they would need to pretend the money gained in that sale never existed. Usually those assets are bonds so it’s unlikely they can call in those bonds before they are due and hopefully when they are due the bond debtors are able to pay.
- 6y ago
- young_unixer 6y agoAnyway, I bought some Monero. I think its price going to increase when governments start to attack crypto.
- betwixthewires 6y agoThis is not really very easy to predict. It will definitely rise from it's bottom because it has some utility even when illegal, but what that bottom is and how high it will go is the question. Will a government be capable of stopping its use? The DoD could 51% attack monero with 0.1% of it's yearly budget. But say they couldn't stop it, the next question is, is there a use for it for people who aren't engaged in black markets, for example, is it made illegal in a pending currency collapse? There are a lot of variables that affect the value of an asset, particularly currencies, and particularly when they're made illegal.
- young_unixer 6y agoThat makes sense if the policy change is instantaneous, but if they decide to boil the frog slowly, people are going to progressively adopt Monero.
- 55555 6y agoI was a huge believer in Monero. Maybe I still should be. I invested heavily into it years ago because most of the actual uses of cryptocurrency benefit from the privacy advantages of Monero. I've sold out now. The truth is that since Monero came out, it has become much, much easier to wash or launder all other coins. I think long-term this is going to hurt its value. We're going to see long-term consolidation into a few main cryptocurrencies and there will just be a button in the wallet software that swaps all your coins or washes them using some crazy cross-chain technology or something. As an example, you don't really need to hold monero to benefit from its privacy advantages. Just sell your ETH into monero, move it between a few wallets, then sell it back into ETH. This could be done automatically. So idk, I'm less bullish on it now even though I used to be a diehard fan.
- CyberRabbi 6y agoOh please, less than 3 months ago outlets like the WSJ were openly denying asset inflation was being caused by the Fed and the Treasury’s actions. Now that Dogecoin is getting lots of attention they want to pretend like a big crash is coming? FUD plain and simple. The market will fluctuate, then it will adjust, life will go on. Ignore.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Hnrobert42 6y agoYeah. I subscribe to WSJ. Their reporting is usually pretty good. But their editorials and even pieces like this are driven by a capitol-over-labor ideology. They had no problem with massive corporate tax breaks. Large scale spending on the other hand is a boogey man. The government has had its foot on the gas for a long time. The economic engine meat indeed be about to overheat. But this article is more a reaction to which gas pedal is being pressed not the risk of overheating.
- gpapilion 6y agoSomehow a fund I’m holding returned 36% in the last year, and a new one reached 10% in 4 months. I have a lot of questions about what’s about to happen.
- zxcb1 6y ago“What Happens to Stocks and Cryptocurrencies When the Fed Stops Raining Money?” Even asking the question is evidence of failure; the economy and its participants should have been robust enough to withstand this kind of shock. Instead there is an inverted economy where irresponsible and indebted risk takers are bailed out with money from those who trusted the system, while amongst other things saving for a rainy day. This bankrupt philosophy ends with social credit and cast-like systems with printing and debt at their core. It seems that those who love freedom and responsibility have attempted to build a safe haven from all this garbage, let's hope that crypto survives.
- lifty 6y agoIt is the systematic breakdown of trust. High trust societies like USA take trust for granted and don’t consider how difficult it is to rebuild that fabric of trust once it has been deteriorated. It affects everything from institutions to the individual economic transactions between individuals. Because of this, I’ve always thought it’s better to allow bigger economic downturns but don’t mess with that fabric of trust.
- greendesk 6y agoPeople lose money on buying trophy cars. People buy stamps to collect as a memorabilia. We lose health due to inaction on climate change and pollution. Should the government fix those by heavy-handed restrictions on public’s actions first? It is up to WSJ to raise awareness on those issues first.
- ojhughes 6y agoWhat do people think is a smart way of saving money in the current bubble market? Globally diverse ETF? Pay off mortgage? Hold cash?
- LeCow 6y agoEverything is over inflated at the moment so it's a dammed if you do dammed if you don't kind of situation. However, a global ETF is going to return the highest yield for minimised risk, and even if the world markets crash. You're still holding something of value.
- ojhughes 6y agoYeah that’s my current strategy long term
- Havoc 6y agoEverything is jacked up. This one is a full send for better or worse. I don't think there is a good way to diversify that way - short of maybe crypto if you're a believer
- LeCow 6y agoEither, The markets will crash to reflect their true monetary value. Or, we will see the ultimate effects of hyperinflation outside of the equity markets. Your potatoes and carrots will start costing $50 a piece.
- koonsolo 6y agoOr a third, more boring option: the world just continues as it does right now.
- beiller 6y agoIt's a good point what if the governments and fed just continue on this path forever. Is there any downside? I guess no one can purchase homes and live in cities anymore. But rent is still cheap. I guess it would create this sick twisted landlord / tennant distopoa where the top 1% own all the real estate and the rest of humanity must continue appeasing the landlords or be evicted aka terminated.
- arisAlexis 6y agoI think stocks and cryptocurrencies should not be grouped together
- Adrox 6y agoI believe that some cryptos have some innovation and bring some utility (Ethereum smart contracts for example) BUT most of it is just a huge Ponzi scheme derived from cheap and abundant money (low interest rates and easy credit). I remembered about +- 10 years a go in Portugal, everyone started talking and participating in this Pyramid scheme game, called "The Bubble/Ball Game" with the only difference in being presented as concentric circles instead of a pyramid: https://i.servimg.com/u/f44/12/54/78/75/folha_11.jpg https://i.servimg.com/u/f44/12/54/78/75/folha_11.jpg I went to check the exact dates that this happened and was reported by newspapers: 16 June 2008: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=pt&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.dn.pt%2Farquivo%2F2008%2Fjogo-da-bolha-ja-movimenta-milhoes-993463.html https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=pt&tl=en&u=htt... 20 June 2008: https://www.publico.pt/2008/06/20/jornal/o-jogo-da-bolha-a-falencia-da-justica-e-as-causas-do-atraso-265757 https://www.publico.pt/2008/06/20/jornal/o-jogo-da-bolha-a-f... Boom! Right at the same time the last big bubble in US (subprime crisis). This proves not only that low interests and easy credit spreads between asset classes, but also between geographies. Each day it passes, the worst the burst of the bubble will be for EVERYONE. Of course the most difficult part is to guess when, it can be tomorrow or it can be in 2 years, and knowing that the latest stages the most outrageous are the returns, we still could be 50%/100%/200% from the top. For me, I'm almost all invested in S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100, they would also be affected when the bubble burst, but at least I will have productive assets generating cash-flows and selling actual things that people want and need, instead of gold-like (or with even less utility than gold) "tokens".
- Havoc 6y ago>, everyone started talking and participating in this Pyramid scheme game, called "The Bubble/Ball Game" So everyone knew it was a ponzi scheme and participated anyway?
- banbanbang 6y agoPeople have leveraged into crypto. Some funds as high as 10-20x. Then came 2021. They took their leveraged crypto holdings and leveraged into meme stocks. It doesn’t take an idiot to figure out how that’s going to end. Jerome Powell is a massive idiot. Everyone at Fed thinks this is their Great Depression moment. And every single scholar to date has essentially said the G.D. could have been avoided if the gov’t drowned it out with liquidity. And this is exactly what they’re doing right now. Imagine being taught this for decades. Literal monetary economist echo chamber. Do you think you will ever change your mind mid way through? No. They will go down with it. Then came Joe Biden. He thinks he’s going to be FDR. COVID is nothing even remotely close to the Great Depression. Not even the Financial Crisis. Yet the central banks around the world are making this into one because that’s all they know from their academic obsession with depressions.
- terminalserver 6y agoHyperinflation is here already. Houses hyperinflation Stocks hyperinflation Crypto hyperinflation
- jessaustin 6y agoThis seems backwards? In all three cases, the dollar is experiencing inflation, since over time it takes more and more dollars to buy each asset.
- machinebun 6y ago1) Neither houses nor stocks actually qualify for hyperinflation (50%+ rise per month); crypto is the only one that potentially could, though again, hyperinflation is generally not a concept applied to assets - it's specifically for consumption goods. If hypothetically the U.S. government announced that they are banning cryptos tomorrow and the value crashes, what happens to your hyperinflation? (The FED has the lever to control "inflation" - or rather asset price appreciation in all three of the above by controlling the interest rate and rate of bond purchases, so talking about inflation in them is kind of useless. The FED could crash all three markets (stocks, crypto & housing) tomorrow if they wanted to) I can live my life just fine without owning a house, stocks or crypto, and in fact many people do.
- pentae 6y agoI've always wondered why someone doesn't come out with a disruptive lighting company that doesn't do planned obsolescence, build a reputation for your bulbs lasting 10-20 years, charge the same price as your competitors, and get all the free PR from being the most eco-friendly company out there so you dominate the market while actually providing some real value.
- jchonphoenix 6y agoIsn't it obvious? There's no profit here. Model out the math and you'll immediately see this is a horrible company to start economically
- noxer 6y ago>Cryptocurrencies now equal the value of U.S. dollars in circulation. NO, the market cap is not the value of something real. If the author doesn't know that hes already disqualified to make any useful comment on the matter. Market cap simple explained: https://coil.com/p/XRPFax/Understanding-the-Crypto-Market-Cap-and-why-it-does-not-limit-the-Price/eKrRCJ2Pc https://coil.com/p/XRPFax/Understanding-the-Crypto-Market-Ca...
- pjdemers 6y agoWe will never know because they aren't going to stop raining money. Specific stocks, bonds, cryptos, properties, and currencies will go down, some to zero, but, the sum of all assets will keep going up for a very long time.
- gencial 6y agoبرقرار بت https://cutt.ly/sbSEwNg https://cutt.ly/sbSEwNg
- jl2718 6y ago> When if it was inevitable, there would be no bubble to begin with. Crypto is not a hedge against inflation; it’s a hedge against collapse.
- 0x000000E2 6y agoI'm a cynic, but rich investors will be bailed out like in 2008. Crypto will be allowed to crater since it's owned by small holders. If you want to be protected when the bubble pops, buy what rich companies do. Real estate and blue chip stocks
- gencial 6y agoبرقرار بت https://cutt.ly/sbSEwNg https://cutt.ly/sbSEwNg