20 ms·
Google is saving $1B per year as a result of employees working from home
- ggm 6y agosavings of $268m from company promotions, travel and entertainment so.. thats a combination of unnecessary spend, and cost-shifting: some of this, the employees now "self fund" as well as avoid.
- eli 6y agoAt google in particular isn’t the on-site food and entertainment a big perk? Seems like even a slightly worse employee retention rate could really cut into this savings.
- jeffbee 6y agoThis is what I wonder about Dropbox. There wasn’t really any particular reason to work there except the food. The RSUs weren’t going anywhere, the technical culture wasn’t amazing, but the food was incredible. In a 100% remote Dropbox, did they bump everybody’s comp by 20%?
- tdeck 6y agoThey gave them a debit card that covers $1.75k in expenses (groceries, meals, exercise equipment, etc...) every 3 months. Or at least that's what I heard from my brother who works at Dropbox.
- baetylus 6y agoWhat constitutes an excellent tech culture in your view? Just curious
- jeffbee 6y agoEh, I could complain about it at length if you get me started but the root cause is they have a process where you have to take all your ideas before a committee of senior engineers and get permission to do anything, and the people who are on the committee are unfortunately not qualified for that purpose, they just happened to have been early employees who blundered into fancy job titles. Aside from that there's also a special clique who do whatever they want to do without regard to that process and the existence of the clique is incredibly corrosive to morale within engineering. Coming from Google, where you definitely do not need to bow and scrape before Jeff and Sanjay, and even if you did they are both gods who are more than qualified to comment on your ideas, the Dropbox system was a big shock.
- baetylus 6y agoAh, I understand. That's really interesting. Thanks for sharing your experience
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Bluecobra 6y agoI don’t give a rat’s behind about free food and entertainment. It’s nice, but being able to avoid the chaos of an open office and a long commute is nicer.
- seedless-sensat 6y agoHonestly, I (childishly) felt dependant on the Google office perks. I didn't want to work anywhere else. It was only after the office closed, I reevaluated my priorities, and subsequently quit Google. WFH will impact Google's retention. It is no longer a differentiated company.
- paxys 6y agoOn the other hand "Google perks" which were once revolutionary are now standard at every tech company in silicon valley. They stopped being the differentiator a long time ago.
- paxys 6y agoThese perks are mostly targeted towards younger employees, who don't want to spend time cooking their own food, want to live in the city and use company shuttles to commute, don't care about getting out of the office early to get back to their kids, want to have more options to socialize.
- compiler-guy 6y agoThe value people find in the Google perks is definitely mixed and vary from person to person, and hard to know what the net-net result is. I personally hate to deal with lunch and breakfast (but cook dinner all the time). So the food was a great bonus for me. I get that this isn't true for everyone.
- threatofrain 6y agoAt least speaking to just cafeterias, if Google can forecast what their employees would've wanted to spend their money on, and then purchase that more efficiently than they could, then that is a way for Google to transfer increased value to their employees.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf the cafeterias were for the employer convenience, they can purchase it more efficiently by 1/(1 - Tm) where Tm is the marginal income tax rate, which for Googlers is generally over 40% (combined federal and state and Medicare). If the lunch is worth $12 to the employee, Google would have had to otherwise pay them $20 to leave them with enough to buy lunch after tax if their marginal rate was 40% combined. Google can probably provide it for $10, which is likely at least 50% deductible to Google.
- tdeck 6y agoAlthough in an odd twist Google catering charged teams $40+/head for a so-so buffet dinner. I assume the ordinary culinary is much more cost effective.
- shaftway 6y agoMan, they forecasted that a *lot* of us wanted to eat kale.
- sdenton4 6y agoThe less obvious nicety of company cafeterias is that employees can talk about confidential things without worrying about being overheard... It's very good for encouraging collaboration.
- beambot 6y agoGoogle may save $1B this year on the P&L, but I can assure you that a large cohort of employees are vastly less effective (especially parents!). Time will tell how wfh pans out in terms of long-term enterprise value creation, after confounding variables (i.e. COVID) are removed. Source: A lot of my Googler friends are itching to get back into the office -- whether parents or people whose social lives centered around work. Ninja Edit: Google has already announced their return to work plans, which involves substantially returning to physical office spaces. From early April: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2021/04/01/google-wants-workers-to-return-to-the-office-ahead-of-schedule-this-looks-like-a-blow-to-the-remote-work-trend/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2021/04/01/google-wan...
- jedberg 6y agoThose parents may be a lot more productive once their kids go back to in person school and after school activities that keep them away from 8-5.
- dougbarrett 6y agoMaybe for older kids that are involved in extracurricular activities, but for younger kids that won't be the case. With a 4 year old starting pre-k this fall, I'll be lucky to have a distraction free work environment from 9-2 daily.
- jedberg 6y agoPre-pandemic I had a 2 and 4 year old. The 4 year old was gone all day between 9 and 2 MWF for preschool, and we had a nanny the rest of the time. I suspect post-pandemic it will be similar. Someone who works at Google can probably afford a nanny. It's just because people aren't comfortable with others in their home right now that it's a problem.
- aaronblohowiak 6y agoThere is a huge nanny crunch / there are much longer lead times for high-end nannies now..
- marmshallow 6y agoIt's hard to quantify the potential loss of productivity or collaboration caused by working from home, though. No way to find out either, unfortunately.
- k__ 6y agoYes. But arguing around $1B saved won't be easy.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> But arguing around $1B saved won't be easy. That’s about 0.6% of revenue for Google. Number sounds big until you put it in perspective and realize it’s just noise. If people were even 1% less productive (in terms of producing revenue) then even that $1B saved isn’t profitable. That said, there could be other arguments for expanding WFH but saving less than 1% of expenses is not one of them. It’s likely that the savings are largely due to COVID preventing typical travel anyway, which had nothing to do with WFH.
- missedthecue 6y agoThe $1B is investment. It's not bloat or inefficiency. In theory, that $1B that they were not able to invest this past year has a return greater than a billion dollars.
- f6v 6y agoAnd what are they going to do with that $1B? FAANG has so much cash they don't know how to spend it.
- newsclues 6y agoCan we not judge output?
- aerosmile 6y agoIn all disciplines? No. Take someone who works in branding and is a part of a 20 member team. How long does it really take to come up with a new copy? 20 minutes? 2 hours? 20 hours? And is it really better to incentivize people to spend only 20 mins, or is there value in giving them 20 hours? Finally, how would you measure which option is better when most copy is not A/B tested. I am just using one random example, there are so many out there where performance evaluation is as much about your day to day observations as it is about measurable output.
- guyzero 6y agoThere's a lot of employee travel at big companies. Many times of the year you can hardly book a hotel room around Mountain View/Sunnyvale/Palo Alto. I think the pandemic has shown how non-essential a lot of that really was.
- bredren 6y agoIt will be interesting to see how much previously considered necessary patterns are restored. On site employment, car loans and car payments, expensive rent in poorly managed or unsustainable counties—the potential for behavioral change is enormous.
- bpodgursky 6y agoI think a big question is not how essential it is in a vacuum, but how important sales travel is in a competitive landscape. ie, sales would work equally well if everyone did it via Zoom calls. But if one competitor is willing to send reps in-house for in-person meetings, and the rest are just scheduling Zooms... I can see the industry quickly collapsing back into constant sales travel, if there's even a small marginal gain from face-to-face meetings (or dinners, or drinks, or whatever else sales reps do to close a deal)
- guyzero 6y agoI'm sure there's a lot of sales travel at places like G but I feel like G in particular doesn't have a lot of sales travel. A lot of the travel is just employees working together for whatever internal tasks.
- bpodgursky 6y agoMaybe, but we had GCP reps in-house for days when we were figuring out our cloud strategy. So I do think there's some even at G.
- f6v 6y agoIf AWS is coming to my office to do a "free architecture evaluation" and GCP doesn't, guess which one I'll choose.
- tyingq 6y agoGuessing Google leadership doesn't believe that, since: If employees want to work remotely after Sept. 1, for more than 14 additional days per year, they’ll have to formally apply for it, according to a separate note marked “Need to know.” They can apply for up to 12 months in “the most exceptional circumstances.” The company could, however, call employees back to their assigned office at any point, the note said. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/31/google-speeds-partial-office-reopening-and-puts-limits-on-remote-work.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/31/google-speeds-partial-office...
- Cookingboy 6y ago>Google leadership doesn't believe that What do you mean. Obviously they believe the $1B in cost saving. But what they do also believe is that the value generated by people being in the office will exceed the obvious short term costs.
- erhk 6y agoI think any google leader who read the original post would not believe it, especially given the purely speculative nature
- tyingq 6y agoWell, for one, "primarily as a result of COVID-19" isn't the same as "result of employees working from home". I would guess it intersects some, though I don't know how much.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThe 14 day policy cited in the article is wrong. It is more than 14 days of international remote work.
- throwaways885 6y agoIn one contiguous block too. I think you can do it more than once.
- 6y ago
- melenaboija 6y agoNot sure if this is good or bad. I wonder how affects the economy that this huge players keep making their accounts grow bigger avoiding these massive cash flows reach the street.
- paxys 6y agoGoogle is saving $1 billion per year because of COVID-19, not because employees are working from home. This is literally mentioned in the article, but the headline is twisted (for clicks no doubt): > During the first quarter, Google parent Alphabet Inc. saved $268 million in expenses from company promotions, travel and entertainment, compared with the same period a year earlier, “primarily as a result of COVID-19,” according to a company filing. Even if they hypothetically continue the WFH setting for all employees indefinitely, other costs will still creep back up once the world starts getting back to normal. They will still hold conferences (and send employees to conferences). Team events and corporate retreats will still happen. Launches won't be digital-only. Advertising will pick back up. None of this is related to whether employees are at their desks in the office or not.
- aabhay 6y agoWhat about office perks, maintenance of space, renovation, staff, commuter credits, office events, snacks, lunches, dinner, equipment, secretaries, and security?
- lamontcg 6y agoThey've been paying rent on their offices the whole time. If they went permanent WFH they could sell/lease those spaces and probably save billions. Not to mention the cost all the employees have to endure for traveling to work, wear on vehicles, gas, repairs, collisions, insurance, medical payouts due to car accidents, etc. Plus just generally the externalities of higher carbon emissions.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThis assumes the presence of enough office demand to replace a Google sized company in the markets they lease in. It’s not clear that this is true. US vacancies are projected to be 19.4% nationally. On top of that, there isn’t exactly another Google-sized employer waiting in the wings over in Mountain View.
- 6y ago
- SN76477 6y agoI have worked from home for 15 years. I’m glad to see it is a serious option now. I know it isn’t for everyone though.
- the_duke 6y agoAlways remember: numbers without context are meaningless. Google had 180bn revenue in 2020. In normal circumstances , even with much more WFH, they'd still pay for regular company get togethers. They'd pay for more satellite offices. They'd pay for conferences because making cross industry connections and promotion is important. These savings don't mean much. Even more so if they lead to a potential dip in efficiency (not arguing that's the case, mind you) or reduced employee retention. Less personal engagement leads to less attachment to the company. The effects of that are barely visible after a year.
- joering2 6y agotwo. billion. dollars. per. day. or $23,000 USD per second. Mostly from advertising, some 87%. Funny to think in their initial whitepaper, Brin and Page were heavily arguing against paid (sponsored) ads in search result of a search engine, as it would skew the results to the point where people would stop using it.
- mike_d 6y agoI think your math is a bit off... they make $5,707 per second. Walmart by comparison makes $17,730 per second.
- unnouinceput 6y ago"Google is saving $1B per year as a result of employees working from home AND losing $1.4B because advertising is less due to COVID" - there, I fixed the title for you. I am pretty sure Google would love to spend 1B to gain back 1.4B, they must be doing something right with those perks.
- B-Con 6y agoThe Q1 earnings statement says ad revenue is way up.
- northerdome 6y agoThat is some very, very back of the envelope math that ignores a lot of factors. For example, the idea that Google will indefinitely suspend promotions is preposterous. And the idea that taking exceptional financial numbers from the beginning of the pandemic and multiply by 4 to get a meaningful "annualized" figure only makes sense in a 4th grade math textbook. I hate click bait headlines that use exceptionally exaggerated facts.
- xbar 6y agoFalse economy.
- mycologos 6y agoI'd never heard of this term. Per Wikipedia [1]: > In economics, a false economy is an action that saves money at the beginning but which, over a longer period of time, results in more money being spent or wasted than being saved. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_economy
- ourmandave 6y agoWas some of the saving from not having to run the Google Tech shuttles? https://www.protocol.com/silicon-valley-tech-shuttles https://www.protocol.com/silicon-valley-tech-shuttles
- kwertyoowiyop 6y agoScale does crazy things. If Google switched to a slightly cheaper salt packet they’d probably save $100M/year.
- catern 6y agoScale isn't everything. If each of 200000 employees used 10 salt packets a week, at a cost of $0.003 per salt packet (from https://www.warehouse115.com/single-serv-flat-salt-packets-poly-bag-0-6-gm.html https://www.warehouse115.com/single-serv-flat-salt-packets-p...), then if they cut their salt expenditures in half they'd save: >>> (200000*10*52*0.003)/2 156000.0 $156,000
- feteru 6y agoStill a lot of money on salt packets, I love these rough approximations compared to our expectations
- jollybean 6y agoThey also 'save' money by jamming people into noisy open office formats. This is the CFO's way of looking at it; it's a data point, but not the big one. Overwhelmingly the issue will boil down to material productivity, not so much 'cost'. Whichever mode of working is more productive is definitely the 'best' option, whether or not it saves or costs a few beans.
- nondeveloper 6y agoIt would be interesting if Googlers were presented with this set of options: 1) work from the office with the included perks or 2) work remote and keep the resulting savings to the company as a bonus.
- paxys 6y agoPerks cost a lot less to the employer due to wholesale pricing and the fact that very few employees actually use all of them. Employees opting for the latter option won't get as much as they think.
- cobookman 6y agoand taxes. Buy lunch yourself, its on after-tax wages. Employer buys you lunch, it is a tax write off for the employer. Income tax at the marginal tax rate can reach nearly 40% for some of these workers. So that $10 lunch would require a pay-raise of nearly $17 to break-even.
- aerosmile 6y agoA lot of people bring up the issue of commuting, which I think is a bit thorny. Here's a quote from one of the comments below: > I feel vastly more productive with not spending 2-3 hours every day commuting Your commute is not your company's business. They might try to make it easier by implementing shuttles and flexible work schedules, but at the end of the day you signed up for this commute. If you work for Google, you certainly had the option of working somewhere else closer to home. You chose Google because you liked what they had to offer. They chose you because you seemed really good. They could have chosen someone else who lived closer to their office. I doubt that they take the commutes into their hiring consideration, within reason. So in other words, you thought that the extra time it takes to earn the Google check was worth it. Why bring it up now? Please don't use the "I give my company more of my time now" argument, because nobody believes it. You just simply get up later in the morning and get to see your family earlier in the evening. A more honest statement would be along these lines: > I have reclaimed 2-3 hours from my time that was previously allocated to earning my paycheck, and I now redirect it towards other activities. Those activities range anywhere from 0-100% on the scale of how relevant they are to me being a better employee. (I was inclined to not start at 0% of the range due to the clear benefits of distancing yourself from your work regardless of what you're doing... but then I remembered a consultant I recently met who offered his services while being a full-time employee at Google. When I asked him if he'll be able to perform his service reliably due to his supposedly challenging day job, he grinned and said that WFH has been great for his consulting work. So 0% it is.)
- flukus 6y ago> I have reclaimed 2-3 hours from my time that was previously allocated to earning my paycheck, and I now redirect it towards other activities. Those activities range anywhere from 0-100% on the scale of how relevant they are to me being a better employee. In my case it's more like 2 hours saved, give or take. 50% of that benefits my employer because I'm a morning person and I'm not wasting one of my good hours commuting. 25% I tend to use on another half hour of sleep, being well rested is obviously good for my employer. The remaining 25% is a lot harder to link directly, but it's generally gone into exercise and cooking that make me healthier. > So in other words, you thought that the extra time it takes to earn the Google check was worth it. There's nothing google specific about this, if you don't work there you'd likely be working somewhere else that didn't allow WFH. > Why bring it up now? Because for most of us it's the first time we've experienced the benefits of WFH.
- akomtu 6y agoAnd how much are they losing on their 100B real estate depreciation? Way more than 1B per year.
- Black101 6y agoMaybe they could deliver suprises to employees to make up for it...
- woutr_be 6y agoMy company (a 100,000+ employees bank) also announced they would introduce a new flexible working program, and every employee would receive around US$500 for their workspace at home. Two days after that I read a news article how my company was giving up 3 floors in their HQ, which equals a monthly rent of US$3 million. Guess it all evens out in the end.
- anonytrary 6y agoNot worth it. Saving a small percentage of your revenue per year and taking a larger percentage hit in productivity seems like a bad deal. I think hybrid work model will win, and offices will be required moving forward to support that.
- katbyte 6y agoYou know what WFH is way WAY more for efficient and good for? A employees health, wellbeing and happiness! which imho is more important than profits or the company.
- throwaway3699 6y agoPlease speak for yourself. This is not true for everyone.
- bootlooped 6y agoThat's not a universal opinion. All of the people on my team would prefer to be in the office 2 or 3 days a week. Some people find it's positive for their mental health to see and interact with other people, in person, regularly.
- agent008t 6y agoIt is possible they are not telling you the truth.
- oblio 6y agoThat's A) super arrogant, B) completely ignoring the fact that we're social animals and introverts are a minority in the overall population.
- agent008t 6y ago"All of the people on my team would prefer to be in the office 2 or 3 days a week" - I am just pointing out that if people feel like they are expected to be in the office at all, they are unlikely to say anything less than "2 or 3 days a week" regardless of how they feel.
- kalleboo 6y agoWith non-pandemic WFH you can see and interact with other people, in person, regularly, outside of work. Hobbies, cafés, bars, etc.
- sriram_sun 6y agoPeanuts.
- kingsuper20 6y agoI can't say that I'm surprised. It seems to me that the attraction isn't just winnowing out travel or office expenses but just imagine the chance to instrument employees if 100% of their work runs through your pipe. There's opportunities for fine tuning, detection of dead wood, identification of jobs that could be automated. The surveillance workplace might suck but it's good for profits. On a related note, I have to wonder how many companies might realize the lack of value of tradeshows.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vzaliva 6y agoThey could have saved the same amount of money by not providing numerous office perks, limiting employee travel, and cramping employees into smaller offices (I think square footage at average home office is less that at Googlepex). So basicaly they took away some benefits. If this to continue long-term, eventually they would be forced to compensate for these loses to stay competitive in the job market by salary raises or by providing some other perks for work-from-home employees.
- antman 6y agoI would like to hear the story of how Google saved money from promotions due to covid
- notatoad 6y agoIsn't the whole point of a company that spending money is more productive than keeping it in a savings account? Google didn't save $1bn, Google was unable to make use of $1bn in potential spending because of the pandemic. If that counts as a win, they're doing something very wrong.
- lolinder 6y agoWhat makes you think they didn't find something else to spend that money on?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hit8run 6y agoMaybe now pay taxes?
- torgian 6y agoEh, misleading title. I do wonder that, if tech companies ( other than Google ) decide to continue WFH, will they pay a portion of their employees rent, internet, and furniture for their office space?
- varispeed 6y agoI can bet that $1B won't get distributed through salaries, but rather some managers get hefty bonuses and the rest will be reinvested into perfecting manipulation techniques to make us buy products we don't need or want.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- EvilEy3 6y agoWhy should it be distributed through salaries? Making an extra is a one time thing.
- varispeed 6y agoI think I meant as bonuses for employees. I am sorry for the confusion.
- f6v 6y ago> I can bet that $1B won't get distributed through salaries They already have $100B+ in cash on their hands. SV tech companies seem to be left, but not when it comes to distributing money.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eirikma 6y agohttps://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803095725764 https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20...
- cerved 6y ago> notorious Since when is giving employees lavish perks widely regarded as a bad thing?
- Eliezer 6y agoSad to hear the savings are so trivial.
- yitchelle 6y agoWill the company help is funding the home office? I am not talking about the computer equipment here. I am talking about internet cost, a portion of the mortgage / rent, a cost of the furniture etc. AFAIK, these are funded personally.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoExactly a few years ago I was doing dialysis at home (UK) and the supplies took up most of the dining room we got a 25% rebate on our council tax. So should employers start paying a proportion of employees property tax - and that's not counting the fact that employers are using my home network and my BB connection.
- magwa101 6y agoThe large companies rely on a steady firehose of new talent. Onboarding via video is a poor second to onsite. Eventually, these companies will fracture if they have to keep supporting WFH at this scale.
- wolverine876 6y agoGoogle could 'save' even more by firing all its employees and selling all its assets. Expenses are there for a reason; they are investments that earn a return. If you cut the expense, merely to 'save', you are ignorant of a fundamental of business. A similar argument is made about taxes: they are described as only expenses when the issue should be discussed as investments (i.e., 'is the return high enough on this investment of our collective money?'). If these expenses were so obviously unproductive, Google would have cut them already.