14 ms·
Wisconsin has negotiated a dramatically scaled-back deal with Foxconn
- Invictus0 6y agoCan someone explain to me why Foxconn didn't build the plant? Why would they go through the trouble of negotiating this deal, which ended up phenomenally in their favor, just to throw their hands in the air and walk away?
- pen2l 6y agoIn a nutshell, it mistook the nature of labor folks are used to here and its costs. Indeed wildly different from China and elsewhere.
- 1cvmask 6y agoIt’s funny that they are downvoting you for stating the obvious no-brainer explanation. Just curious as I am seeing more of this on HN lately or is it just the Baader Meinhof phenomenon after I read someone else complain about the recent downvoting phenomenon for stating the obvious. Has the readership changed of HN or more specifically the commentariat?
- pen2l 6y agoIt wasn't really my take or opinion, I rather recalled it being cited as the reason by Foxconn itself in multiple instances. Also, I'm from Wisconsin, and an old EECS professor explained this to be the reason from his first-hand knowledge of some conversations with Foxconn. Here is one citation I was able to find quickly: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-foxconn-wisconsin-exclusive-idUSKCN1PO0FV https://www.reuters.com/article/us-foxconn-wisconsin-exclusi... He said the company was still evaluating options for Wisconsin, but cited the steep cost of making advanced TV screens in the United States, where labor expenses are comparatively high. “In terms of TV, we have no place in the U.S.,” he said in an interview. “We can’t compete.” Foxconn has factories in Mexico, Chennai, Malaysia etc. which produce a significant amount of devices but I doubt a factory in US will take off. This article from 2012 about the Steve Jobs "These jobs are not coming back" remark is probably still true: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-and-a-squeezed-middle-class.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-an...
- buran77 6y ago> I rather recalled it being cited as the reason by Foxconn itself in multiple instances. It's more plausible that any company will give the more acceptable, easily digestible explanation, rather than the real one. But really it's the politicians who won, first by banging their chests for all the investments and jobs they created, now for getting an easy out. They can't be blamed for not seeing through any ploy because they can argue Foxconn obviously had good intentions sabotaged by "a misunderstanding" that couldn't have been caught. It's very unlikely (by that I mean close to impossible) that Foxconn just "blundered", went through many rounds of negotiations, and started building, while genuinely not being aware that the US labor market is different from the Chinese one.
- smt88 6y agoYou're being downvoted likely because of how naive it sounds when you take what Foxconn says at face value. Large companies are unlikely to ever tell the truth about their motivations, but they're even less likely to when they were doing something manipulative and dishonest, as Foxconn was here.
- CydeWeys 6y agoYour mistake here is taking a multinational corporation at its word, especially one known for playing games with subsidies in other countries too. These quotes are the cover story from corporate PR, not the truth.
- LargeWu 6y agoThe alternative is that Foxconn is lying, and they never had any intention of actually opening the factory, which I think is a far more likely explanation.
- KZZ 6y agoThe new approach is contract manufacturing for customers who are uncomfortable with manufacturing being performed in China, speaking from first-hand experience. This demand does exist and is what is going to be leveraged in the new park.
- Semaphor 6y ago> Has the readership changed of HN or more specifically the commentariat? My personal impression is, that it got a lot worse since Covid, which I attribute to more people doing home office and/or having more free time. Any discussion forum that grows gets worse. But both my impressions and the 2nd part might be wrong.
- 1cvmask 6y agoI think you nailed it with Covid. Critical thinking requires discourse, and discourse on all the possibilities beyond the dominant narratives or paradigms. Downvoting does not make reality or the “ugly” truth go away. We should be here to discuss and not be afraid to ruffle feathers and have easily offended sensibilities.
- sigmaprimus 6y agoBeat me to it!
- sigmaprimus 6y agoSince You qualified your own statement as being possibly being wrong, I would argue that more engagement alone doesn't result in more down votes. I have observed that any comments criticizing anyone, regardless of wether they are justified or not seem to be recieved poorly on modern forums. I believe this is due to an ongoing effort to make forums safe spaces, somehow honest critical thinking is no longer accepted in the current environment. Right or wrong, it is what it is. So if You are really concerned with the fake points You are accumulating then just tow the line, get with the woke SJW movement or submit articles of interest to balance out the backlash from the mob....I probably better start looking for a good article :P
- 1cvmask 6y agoAnd the downvotes on your comments begin....
- sigmaprimus 6y ago
- Loughla 6y agoI genuinely don't understand how 'international mega-corporation doesn't understand international labor differences' is a no-brainer. Please explain that to me. That seems like one of the first things that any company should evaluate.
- saalweachter 6y agoHonestly? I assume the people who negotiated the deal are a different department from the people who would have implemented the deal. They went big and went home and now it's someone else's problem.
- bildung 6y agoIs it really a no-brainer that a giant transnational company signed a multi-billion dollar deal without anyone investing half a day looking into the situation of the labor market of the target region?
- DaedPsyker 6y agoYou say stating the obvious and yet it simply isn't. It was a heavily subsidised political stunt that Foxconn could half-ass. They rolled out the red carpet, exempted them from environmental regulations and basically built the infrastructure for them. Even four years ago they said the number of jobs was a wish not a promise, they were BS artists. They weren't some naive tiny company.
- rideontime 6y agoThe downvotes might be coming from people who are actually familiar with the situation and know that the "obvious no-brainer explanation" isn't the correct one.
- AlexandrB 6y agoThis is a take that's wildly generous to FoxConn, painting them as the "aww schucks" kinda honest guys that just didn't know about the challenges of the US labor market. The alternate take is that the whole deal was made in bad faith and FoxConn was hoping to collect subsidies and line its pockets. This version of events has some precedent[1]. It's especially hard to believe that FoxConn didn't know about US labor when this same situation played out in Pennsylvania in 2013[2]. [1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/foxconns-history-of-broken-promises-casts-a-shadow-on-wisconsin-news-2017-07-27 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/foxconns-history-of-broken... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/how-foxconns-broken-pledges-in-pennsylvania-cast-doubt-on-trumps-jobs-plan/2017/03/03/0189f3de-ee3a-11e6-9973-c5efb7ccfb0d_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/how-foxconns...
- Loughla 6y agoYou're 100% spot on. I cannot be convinced a multi-national mega-corp is ignorant of US labor and the challenges in the US labor market. There just is no way that's possible for a company this size, or am I wrong? So that leaves either bad faith, or they are just abjectly incompetent. I can't really see any other options. Or, again, am I way off base?
- chrisjc 6y ago> I cannot be convinced a multi-national mega-corp is ignorant of US labor and the challenges in the US labor market. Especially one that is a specialist in harvesting laborers from all corners of the world. I can only imagine selecting the right labor force has to be their main competences.
- jfb 6y agoI mean, it was bullshit from jump street, but if Wisconsin had poured (more) money into Foxconn's pockets, I'm sure they'd have been happy to put something up.
- KZZ 6y agoFor the record, they have put something up. Currently 1 large empty buildings and 2 medium sized, filled buildings. Also one perplexing glass globe.
- al2o3cr 6y agoShort story shorter: Terry Gou is a serial bullshitter https://www.theverge.com/21507966/foxconn-empty-factories-wisconsin-jobs-loophole-trump https://www.theverge.com/21507966/foxconn-empty-factories-wi...
- Timshel 6y agoGood article on the subject: https://www.theverge.com/21507966/foxconn-empty-factories-wisconsin-jobs-loophole-trump https://www.theverge.com/21507966/foxconn-empty-factories-wi... My take it was probably mainly a political stunt, lcd was never really possible (slump + wages + supply issues) and then they didn't know what to do.
- sandworm101 6y agoPolitics. Political capital. There are international advantages to having the US president endorse you, your project and your company. Those photos were probably worth the hassle.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Frost1x 6y agoNot just the photos but the initial publicity. People remember the beginnings of things if they're broadcasted through mass media. I recall many people claiming this a 'big win' at the time and attributing to the sitting president. I recall also being highly skeptical and suspecting a political stunt but completely forgot about the status until reading this. Meanwhile, people at large don't follow progress of these endeavors. Some journalists may but there's selection bias from the journalist and the news consumer as to what they ultimately see and stay informed of. These stunts are forgotten by most (myself included) in the daily scramble of things we have to keep track of and manage. Did it fail? Did it succeed? Do I even remember it or just the emotion it attributed to something else I actually do remember? Ambiguity hiding in complexity of daily life lets people say and do a lot of things and get away with it. It's often far too difficult and time consuming to unravel the ambiguity and complexity to show if something succeded, failed, or to even have cognitive capacity to keep track of. The end result, as you point out, is political capital people walk away with. The emotional impression at the time is what was sold and stuck to most people. "MAGA", "bringing back manufacturering", links to nostalgic economic golden eras for many workers.
- sct202 6y agoScott Walker, the governor, who signed the deal lost his office a year after it was signed in part due to backlash over the deal. Think about it from Foxconn's perspective, if you got a sweetheart deal and the person who gave it to you got canned for it, are you going to follow thru and put in billions of your dollars on the assumption that you'll still get billions of government subsidies in return?
- analog31 6y agoI wonder if it might have been water. They may have needed more than a sweetheart deal with the state. I think a big reason for the location was the water supply via Lake Michigan. They got a waiver of state environmental laws as part of the deal, but they still had to contend with federal laws, and a treaty with Canada that governs water use in the Great Lakes watershed. There was quite a controversy over the environmental impact of this plant. The "word on the street" is that LCD manufacturing is a dirty industry requiring a lot of water.
- MomoXenosaga 6y agoRealized Americans don't want to live in factory compounds for 10 months doing repetitive labour.
- jerry1979 6y agoI think it shows the idea that "Americans can't do business well", and historically, doing business well has been one thing that Americans pride themselves on. edit I should add that I believe that spreading that kind of message has geopolitical implications, and that groups might want to create that image for strategic reasons.
- jcranmer 6y agoFrom what I can tell, Foxconn never actually intended to build the plant. (I'm getting a lot of this from an interesting long-form article on the history of this deal; unfortunately, I don't remember where I found this article, sorry). Essentially, Foxconn thought that the Wisconsin deal would work more typically as its deals in China went. Glad-hand the government officials, get sweetheart deals on land and investment, and as long as you're not totally incompetent in making use of it, they won't care what you do with it, even if you fail to live up to the original promises. It's not clear to me that Foxconn actually seriously considered producing LCD screens here given this light; the announcement would have been more to make Walker and other government officials ecstatic about the deal than an actual commitment to follow through. The fact that outrage towards the deal would lead to Walker losing reelection and his successor keeping a much closer eye on performance (or lack thereof) seems to me to have caught Foxconn completely off-guard. I think there's another level going here in relation to internal Foxconn politics, but my recollection is too hazy to make a coherent explanation, and I don't want to make any false accusations here, so I won't go into any more detail.
- KZZ 6y agoFor information, the plant has been built. The building is there, just empty.
- aaaaaadsfscxva 6y agoCurious
- aaaaaadsfscxva 6y agoen efecto
- superkuh 6y agoNope. The plant that was promised was never built. They did build some storage warehouses and started a propaganda program where they hired dozens to hundreds of locals to come in to the warehouses, sit around, and do nothing to appear like they were doing something.
- luckylion 6y agoIs it just me or has it become more common for journalists to write about decreases by saying "X-fold" or "x times"? I always get confused, I find it much easier to say "by 97%".
- TheCraiggers 6y agoMany people don't have a clue what "30-fold" even means, and therefore it sounds big and scary. Basically, it's just one of the tools in the sensationalist headlines toolbox.
- afavour 6y ago…is that true? I understand “30-fold” to mean “30x” and I’m pretty sure I have from a very young age. I haven’t checked but I’d be surprised if my peers weren’t the same.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoI think people understand 30-fold to mean 30x, but don't always intuit that "slashed by 30-fold" is equivalent to a reduction by 97% of the original deal. They especially don't understand that the difference between a 20-fold, 30-fold, and 50-fold reduction is the same as a 95%, 97%, and 98% discount. This is especially evident in the mental gymnastics required to understand retail sales pricing. How good is a "Buy two, get one 50% off!!" deal? Brains easily give up on the hard questions and substitute easy answers. "What's it actually worth? Bought one at another store last month, do difficult pricing history memory, or easy answer, the original price is listed right there. How good is the deal? Complicated math, or easy answer, it's at least a good enough deal to merit a big sign, bright colors, and two exclamation points. And it's good for a limited time only? Better not miss out, buy now!" Here, the scope of the reduction is kind of irrelevant. They basically scrapped the old deal and tried to write a new, smaller one. Had they scrapped the megafactory plans and decided to open a fast food franchise it could have been reduced a million fold! The new agreement offers $80M and asks Foxconn to spend only $672M on a factory that will employ only 1,454 people by 2025. The original deal offered Foxconn $2.85B (or $2850M) to spend $10B ($10000M) and hire 13,000 by 2032. Big numbers are hard, but running the math it's now $55k/job and $0.13/dollar of capital investment, it was $220k/job and $0.285/dollar. $80M is 2.8% or a 30-fold reduction from $2.85B, but the full story is they've simultaneously reduced the ratios of the incentives and the scope of the required investment. A complete understanding of what those numbers mean is really hard to develop, and isn't really distilled by a substitution in the headline of 30-fold to 30x. Human brains in general are busy and don't like to work too hard, and whether we use "30 fold" like "four score" in our daily vernacular or they say 97% and 80, the headline's effect is the same. It conveys to readers who don't want to run all the numbers about average salaries and payroll taxes and capital depreciation and so on that the previous administration tried to offer an excessively generous deal but the current government has rolled that back to something a lot smaller, don't worry about exactly how much but just trust that it's a lot.
- neartheplain 6y agoThe massive downward revision of this deal, and of Foxconn's commitment to create jobs in Wisconsin, is hardly a surprise. Foxconn has a history of reneging on promises to build factories, as was widely reported when this deal was first made in 2017: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/foxconns-history-of-broken-promises-casts-a-shadow-on-wisconsin-news-2017-07-27 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/foxconns-history-of-broken... https://boingboing.net/2017/08/09/potemkin-factories.html https://boingboing.net/2017/08/09/potemkin-factories.html https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2017/08/20/op-ed-the-many-broken-promises-of-foxconn/ https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2017/08/20/op-ed-the-many-broken-...
- KingOfCoders 6y agoIt helped Trump, mission accomplished.
- billyhoffman 6y agoDid it? His “8th wonder of the world nonsense” was after he was elected in 2017, and Trump then lost Wisconsin in 2020
- api 6y agoExactly. People like Trump have careers that resemble repeatedly pumped-and-dumped penny stocks. They rise and fall, rise and fall, rise and fall. Basically what they do is build themselves up through something like a social capital pyramid scheme. This eventually collapses when there are no greater fools and when all their promises fail, but the good ones already have the next grift in progress before the first one collapses. Trump is truly one of the greats at this. Not only does he do this very well but he builds the next grift off the previous one. He's IMHO the world's premier expert in "failing up."
- silexia 6y agoBrilliant comment, I think we are going to see this in the future too with Trump. He has gone quiet for now, but he's going to come back and make far more money than he was making prior to the presidency.
- kimar 6y agoThere's a great Reply All podcast about local politics in the town where this plant is to be built. Beware, it's slightly infuriating. https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/wbhjwd https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/wbhjwd
- pchristensen 6y agoMore than slightly!
- josefdlange 6y agoI grew up in Racine County (which contains Mount Pleasant). Let me tell you, SE WI is a strange place. Caught between so many sensibilities and hit so, so hard by economic shifts of the last two decades. I think it suffers, like many places in the American Midwest, the phenomenon of an historically working-class population, who, a few decades ago, would have organized for labor and other rights very vocally and outwardly, but who now are radicalized to the right for no understandable reason. I still like to believe that most of the people around there are good and mean well, but it gets harder and harder every day to believe the willful ignorance they possess of economic, societal, and cultural issues at hand, here and now, will fade. But there's hope. Younger leaders are working their way into local government (hi Greta!), especially over in the formal City of Racine. There's hope that Racine and Racine County might be a leader of progressive values in the area. As an aside, I think there's oodles of opportunity in the SE WI area for younger folks. It really is a beautiful place, is near to Chicago and Milwaukee, and is inexpensive. You get all four seasons, for better or worse. I think it's better than SF's summer and grey-chillier-summer. Some joke that the four seasons are winter, construction, construction, and construction, but that's an exaggeration. Anyway, I think an influx of more diverse people in background and ideology could really stimulate an area like SE WI. Add to that making it worth young people staying around instead of fleeing to the coasts, and suddenly Racine can be a really cool place. This whole Foxconn thing just makes me so sad, and angry.
- justaman 6y agoYou claim to not understand how that group of people can swing right and then proceed to attribute ignorance to that group of people. This doesn't compute. Very partisan and ignorant of you.
- waterheater 6y agoDo not trust Foxconn. I strongly believe they're playing a long-term game here. For example, the Foxconn plant is on a particular tract of land only partially within the Lake Michigan watershed. Anyone living within the watershed must return their water, and it must be cleaned up first. My understanding of the Great Lakes Compact is that Foxconn's land is one of legal ambiguity, that they may draw from Lake Michigan but not return it. I sure hope it doesn't mean they can bottle up Lake Michigan water and ship it elsewhere, but water is set to be more valuable than oil, so I bet they're playing it strategically.
- ThaDood 6y agoNot to be a naysayer, but do you have any sort of evidence to substantiate this claim? Any evidence of exceptions to laws regarding the usage of the watershed and lake with specific regards to Foxconn? Or any kind of indication that a bottling facility will be built up?
- jerry1979 6y agoNot the parent, but there does seem to be a fair amount of legal shenanigans related to the Foxconn and the Great Lakes Compact. https://www.wiscontext.org/what-foxconn-means-great-lakes-compact https://www.wiscontext.org/what-foxconn-means-great-lakes-co...
- waterheater 6y agoHard evidence? No. The exact plot of land they chose is not particularly remarkable, so I must wonder why they chose a piece of land straddling the watershed, given that the Compact [1] indirectly applies to corporations. There's a deeper political aspect to Foxconn's presence that I can't trust. I'm from Wisconsin, and the whole Foxconn deal leaves me feeling extremely uneasy. Leaving aside the Wisconsin and USA politicians associated with the deal, Terry Guo briefly ran for president of the Republic of China. Guo and Foxconn made significant donations to UW-Madison. It smells wrong, and all the Wisconsinites I've talked to agree. I'm glad their subsidies were slashed. [1] https://www.gsgp.org/media/1330/great_lakes-st_lawrence_river_basin_water_resources_compact.pdf https://www.gsgp.org/media/1330/great_lakes-st_lawrence_rive...
- mbesto 6y agoNo one saw this coming.
- altendo 6y agoI am always struck at the amount that states and municipalities are willing to write off in order to attract companies. On one hand, I understand that companies want to take the best deal, but on the other hand, at times local governments are willing to give up so much money in tax revenue. I remember reading about the competitions for Google Fiber and Amazon's second HQ - it felt absurd the amount cities and states were willing to drop, financially speaking. I'm glad this one has been renegotiated (especially seeing that the proposed plant never happened), but I'd like to see these deals be more level-headed before they get to this point.
- luckylion 6y agoThey don't have a choice between Amazon HQ or 50 medium sized new businesses, they often have Amazon HQ or nothing new. In that case, whatever they get is more than they have now, isn't it? New jobs that will bring other new businesses and local taxes etc are a bonus.
- wavefunction 6y agoPlaces that were serious contenders for Amazon HQ definitely have other employers and options. There is no way that Amazon HQ is ending up in Sioux Falls or Laramie or something.
- insert_coin 6y agoIt looks that way in the end, with no other alternative but to yield, but at some point there were many options, that is how the town, city, county or state came to be in the first place. The problem is that they gave so many concessions just to get a short term political advantage, that real productive and sustainable jobs couldn't compete with corruption. Now because of the giant snowball made from all the little policy mistakes that sounded insignificant at first, or ever worse, sounded sound! I mean who wouldn't want high paying jobs that barely require any training? the only option in many places is to keep the charade, but at some point politics need to give way to real production, and that only means real competition.
- danhak 6y ago
- whoomp12342 6y agoGOod. kick em out. WI doesnt want foxconn anyways
- notional 6y agoThe absolute hilarity of HN obsession with 'both siding' every story and going back to see how it unraveled over the years. on Jan 22, 2017 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13457176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13457176 on Jan 16, 2018 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16163558 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16163558 on April 14, 2018 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16839542 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16839542 on Oct 29, 2018 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18328772 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18328772 on April 12, 2020 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22850723 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22850723
- seattle_spring 6y agoHN is a large collection of people with diverse opinions, not just one person who decides to swing their opinion one way or the other on a given day.
- bongoman37 6y agoThey should make a law that if a deal is offered to one company, it should be offered to all. That keep the playing field fair and level.
- tfehring 6y agoFor comparison: - The deal negotiated by former governor Scott Walker was expected to cost taxpayers between $172k and $290k in government funding per job created. [0] - $80 million for 1,454 employees, the provisions of the updated deal per TFA, is $55k each. - The US average cost of similar programs is $24k. [0] It's not obvious whether this is a good deal, but unlike the original it's not obviously a bad deal. [0] https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1244&context=reports https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1244...
- 8note 6y agoHopefully those jobs pay more than 55k to the employed, and the government is doing better than just paying people to set up their own factory