8 ms·
India may build new coal plants due to low cost despite climate change
- pasttense01 6y agoAnd it was fairly recently I was reading a similar article about Mexico and coal: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/feb/15/mexico-coal-fossil-fuels-climate-crisis-amlo https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/feb/15/mexico-coal-fo... While the Western industrialized countries are starting to make modest progress in fighting climate change, this is not happening in much of the third world.
- echelon 6y agoPeople worldwide need education, healthcare, stable economies, freedom, and economic mobility. We have to solve so many other problems in the world before clean energy really works. Nothing we're doing will matter if the rest of the world keeps dumping carbon into the atmosphere. Nobody will admit this. We're just posturing here. We can't tell these economies to turn green (it doesn't make sense for them to!), yet we're not pouring in money to help fix the structural blockers. We need to put manufacturing, finance, resources, education, and more into developing economies. It's a win-win. Developed nations can benefit from cheap labor while developing nations catch up and get an influx of export activity that spurs their growth. Eventually we'll all reach economic parity and can find consensus on this problem. A wealthy and prosperous nation doesn't want coal and can afford the cost of switching to alternatives.
- makotech222 6y agoYour either ignorant, or racist https://i.redd.it/0yksckaayzt61.png https://i.redd.it/0yksckaayzt61.png Western countries are by far the most polluting, per person, than most all other countries combined. Its westerners who need to get their shit together, not the rest of the world.
- mantas 6y ago.. or economical parity will mean that West becomes poorer to match the rest of the world. And then nobody will care about pollution. It's a wee hard sell to locals in developed nation. Hey, let's move jobs abroad and lets use our resources to prop up other nations. What is left back home? Why bother paying taxes if objective is far away and and far in the future.
- humanafterall 6y agoMMT, basic income, and degrowth economics explore this whole topic
- pmiller2 6y agoWould you rather be poor or face the collapse of global civilization?
- Haga 6y agoBoth at current course. Normally humanity would start a war and science it's way out of dilemmas with a economy research blockades removed.
- oblio 6y agoFor most people it's: A) be poor now versus B) maybe face the collapse of global civilization in 40 years. They'll chose B) everytime.
- blackoil 6y agoDo you have any historical examples of this? As I believe in opposite.
- oblio 6y agoTragedy of the commons is a thing for a reason. Why do you think that a lot of people want "small government"? The state/government is by definition in those "commons". Regarding examples, they're countless. Think of petty tyrants fighting over the remains of the Byzantine Empire just as about the Ottomans were about to conquer it. Almost every falling empire had this behavior going on, selfish people "getting theirs" just before the fall. It's human nature, unfortunately.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoDeveloped countries could pay to build nuclear power in the developing world. Terms being that the foreign country paying has 100% autonomy to build and operate the plants for their lifetime. It’d create good jobs for developed nations workforce that gets sent to build the facilities. It’d create low cost green energy in the developing world. Not to mention tons of new economic activity in the area these get built to serve the foreigners coming in to build the plants.
- ralph84 6y agoWe already tried this. After 40 years of this policy towards China, China is an environmental disaster and burns more coal than the all of the rest of the world combined.
- aiioquip 6y agoNot per capita, though
- pepperonipizza 6y agoChinese citizens emit more CO2 per capita than citizens from the EU, and since 2013. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-29239194.amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/science-enviro...
- thisarticle 6y agoHow much of the CO2 per capita that China emits goes into making products for EU/US citizens? Is that factored in?
- KitDuncan 6y agoProbably not. We want to feel good about ourselves, so we twist the numbers in our favor and can point at China as a "reason" not to change anything here.
- lnsru 6y agoI really hate to write this, but this is outsourced CO2 from EU. EU manufacturing is dead. I look at my home office around me - everything is made in China. Some pieces of furniture are EU made, but the rest - made in China things. Old Tektronix scope is “made in USA”, but it is really old.
- imtringued 6y agoOld numbers from the top of my head: 14% China's emissions can be directly attributed to Chinese exports. The domestic economy is a much bigger source of pollution, unless of course you consider the entirety of China a western colony that only exists to export products to the west. I consider the latter option untenable.
- marsven_422 6y agoPeople need Life, liberty and property! All I see from you greens is rebranded Marxism.
- belorn 6y agoWe do not grant people permission to cause harm on a national level just because there is a lack of social economic factors like education, health, economy, freedom, and mobility. It is acknowledge that those factors play a part in why people do harm, and providing social support reduces the overall rate of harm, but we still have laws that forbid harm. I don't see any good argument why we should give explicit permission to do harm on a global level. We can and should acknowledge that a lack of education, healthcare, stable economies, freedom, and economic mobility are contributing factors for pollution.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- risfriend 6y agoWhile US is reducing the coal usage at a rapid rate, the current absolute value of coal usage for power in US is similar to that of India as US generates almost 4 times the power of India https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-in-the-us.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_India#Electricity_generation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_India#El...
- dartharva 6y agoIf only India hadn't bent before anti-nuclear-energy protests, this could have been avoided. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_India#Anti-nuclear_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_India#Anti-nu...
- akamhy 6y ago21 new nuclear reactors are expected to be set up by 2031. https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/power/21-new-nuclear-reactors-are-expected-to-be-set-up-by-2031-department-of-atomic-energy/67375201 https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/power/21-ne...
- bpodgursky 6y agoBent, not broke.
- blackoil 6y agoCurrent government isn't known to give value to protests on more grave methods. I don't think these protests would have any impact on plan.
- dartharva 6y agoHappened a few years ago, not under the current govt. This is one of the things I'd like the current govt to go ahead recklessly with as it does other things, though. Interestingly, it was the mostly NDA opposition (current govt) that had then went against nuclear plants as a political jibe.
- brazzy 6y agoIf cost is the driver behind the decision, nuclear wouldn't stand a chance anyway.
- testfoobar 6y agoIt really doesn't matter how cheap wind and solar get; burning coal and oil will always be productive somewhere. Without enforceable global bans, someone will generate GDP by extracting, exporting, importing and burning hydrocarbons.
- foota 6y agoNo? There's very clearly an efficiency past which renewables exceed even the cheapest fossil fuels. Even with falling prices as a result of lowered demand, it's still not free to transport and extract.
- tfehring 6y agoIt’s hard to compare apples-to-apples, though, since the capital efficiency, payback period, and profit pattern are so different. If you have access to limitless, relatively cheap debt, then yeah, there’s absolutely no reason to build fossil fuel plants anymore. Developing countries don’t have that luxury, and even to the extent that they do have borrowing capacity, they may have even higher-IRR things to use that capital for. Not saying any of that is true of India specifically - I’m not familiar enough to have an informed opinion there.
- cpleppert 6y ago>> If you have access to limitless, relatively cheap debt, then yeah, there’s absolutely no reason to build fossil fuel plants anymore. Thats kind of the point. The cost of capital is rightly higher in developing nations. Capital intensive carbon neutral projects just don't make sense for much of the world.
- unglaublich 6y agosources would be nice to have here
- toast0 6y agoI doubt the numbers are anywhere close, but if a coal plant and a wind plant cost the same to build, produce the same power output, and use the same footprint, there's almost no reason someone would build a coal plant unless there was coal someone was paying to get rid of. Assuming you've got some wind to harvest anyway. I'm not sure what kind of sources you're looking for, with such an unbounded hypothetical.
- crowf 6y agoWell, this lowers the (already very low) credibility of the Paris Agreement
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- perryizgr8 6y agoWe need more power yesterday. I fully support utilising the cheapest, fastest way to generate. I hate paying for a backup generator, and then a backup UPS to handle the starting time of the generator. If coal is the cheapest, that means it is the best way to create electricity right now. If western countries feel strongly about this, I welcome their $1T funding to build adequate nuclear and renewable power plants in India over the next decade.
- technocratius 6y agoThanks for sharing your perspective. As somebody living in the west, I wholeheartedly agree. We've known since the 80s our fossil economy is slow-cooking the planet, yet we protest when other countries try to climb out of poverty using the same tools. Indeed, the west should think of ways in leveling the LCOE playing field in the third world through financial and material support.
- Gustomaximus 6y ago> yet we protest when other countries try to climb out of poverty using the same tools. I dont like this view, nor think its fair. ~100 years ago todays developed countries didn't have access to anything like the modern knowledge or scientific consensus about climate change as well as alternate technology / products. Even 30 years ago.... And making this 'but you did it' claim seems cherry picking. These countries take full advantage of the beneficial modern knowledge and equipment like computers. If countries want to justify pouting like the industrial revolution because you did too, then get rid of computers and other tech and have the same journey otherwise accept this is a choice you make today and there is no excuse other than you want to and to hell with the climate science. And lets also recognise power generation solar is increasingly cheaper than coal so there is likely vested interest pushing government down this path even if we disregard the moral/historic side first google (so forgive if not the best) but these studies come up all the time: e.g. https://www.irena.org/newsroom/pressreleases/2020/Jun/Renewables-Increasingly-Beat-Even-Cheapest-Coal-Competitors-on-Cost https://www.irena.org/newsroom/pressreleases/2020/Jun/Renewa... tldr: I dont buy this excuse. It sounds fair as a quick one liner but doesnt fly when you consider the detail
- kumarski 6y agoDecarbonization efforts will slow electrification of developing countries and net out an unprecedented amount of air, water, and soil pollution per a kilowatt hour. Mankind has known about the fact that some gases absorb outgoing radiation of certain wavelengths was known by Fourier since ~1820. Arrhenius discovered if you doubled CO2, you'd get an effect on temp. ~1900. I bought FCG months ago on 2x leverage. Mankind will thirst through natural gas by embracing renewables in a hope of minimizing CO2. The only people who are saying otherwise seem to be unable to answer any sort of real questions about chemistry. A simple example is that you'll find a lot of CS+ Physicist+EE in silicon valley claim that all we need is high voltage transmission lines between renewables corridors in the USA. Hogwash - if you ascribe to minimizing green-house gases, one of the chemicals you use in insulating high voltage lines is sulfur hexafluoride, a chemical with ~22k the global warming potential of CO2 on a 100 year basis. I'm now looking to make a long bet on coal if I can find the right stock or ETF. I think natural gas booms under a decarbonization regime. https://twitter.com/BvddyCorleone/status/1383859373236121611/photo/1 https://twitter.com/BvddyCorleone/status/1383859373236121611... I might have done well on FCG esp. on 2x leverage, I think I'll do far better on coal if I can find the right peg. All developing countries have thirst for steel and nitrogen fertilizer - they will burn coal and natural gas respectively to attain them. They are the ingredients for scaling a civilization.
- 29athrowaway 6y ago"We have this handy fusion reactor in the sky called the sun. You don't have to do anything. It just works. It shows up everyday and produces ridiculous amounts of power." - Elon Musk
- matkoniecz 6y ago> It shows up everyday There are things called clouds that often block it.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoClouds do not cause solar panels to fully stop working. They only make cause them to produce 20% of their output.
- majjgepolja 6y agoElon "your server side code is doing too much" Musk.
- manojlds 6y agoWhen it comes to vaccine, the US is even stopping supply of materials needed to manufacture them and India is struggling to ramp up production because of that. As much as I would like climate change to be treated seriously, if it's going to be we take care of our people first and even then hoard 30m doses that will not be used and also prevent export of materials needed to make vaccines, why should countries like India not look at their own needs first? (If we do have a climate change catastrophic event, it's not like developed world is going to come rushing to help others as we have seen with covid.)
- adrianN 6y agoIt's time we set a reasonable carbon price and levy import tariffs from countries that don't do the same.
- paganel 6y agoThis is a colonialist policy. Unless the wealthy countries decide to share their clean/green technologies for almost free, that is. Their current wealth (which allows them to be green) was built on dirty energy, just look at Norway.
- galkk 6y agoJust look at the story of UK's moth evolving to dark color due to pollution, and back: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peppered_moth_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peppered_moth_evolution
- fy20 6y agoThe import tariffs could be used to fund developing clean energy infrastructure in said countries, so no it isn't necessarily a colonialist policy. I could see the EU doing something like that, not so much the US though.
- adrianN 6y agoI don't think "colonialist" is the right word to use here and it carries unnecessary connotations. All developing (or developed...) countries need to do to not be subject to import tariffs is joining the carbon price club. Of course I support giving away green technology, because I think reducing carbon emissions has much higher priority than making profits.
- throwaway1777 6y agoI don’t think it’s colonialist? Hot take, but countries like India and China can take care of themselves. The US and Europe should penalize corporations here too who pollute.
- natchy 6y ago> This is a colonialist policy nations can’t even do some kind of sanction to promote clean tech without some social justice moralisms? It’s so tiresome. The plane is going down. First class goes down with coach.
- runeks 6y agoOf course they will, and who can blame them? When India has a choice between spending capital on more climate-friendly energy production versus improving education/health care/the conditions of the elderly, who can blame them for prioritizing the latter?
- f6v 6y agoThey’re also going to spend the money on fighter jets, tanks, and nukes. Can’t blame them for that either, but anyway.
- Hypocritelefty 6y agoThey can spend their money however they want. Why don't you and your country spend on erasing the carbon footprint up until now.
- cpleppert 6y agoIt isn't just about prioritizing the latter. For india, Money spent on improving the economy or alleviating poverty goes a lot farther than spending on carbon neutral energy. For a rich western nation like germany? Not a lot of low hanging opportunities so might as well spend on green energy.
- madaxe_again 6y agoAs a young person, who will have their health care and conditions negatively impacted by the economic and humanitarian disaster of climate change, I can blame them. They are prioritising older voters over younger ones. This tactic ends with a gerontocracy and ultimately no more humans.
- LifeIsThermal 6y agoThat´s doomsday rhetoric. All doomsday cults have one thing in common, they´ve all been wrong. 100%. The climate doomsday cult is no different.
- 6y ago
- jokoon 6y agoI guess that in the future, the military of the world will track and hunt down any carbon emissions.
- mehulj999 6y agoLet me answer many questions targetting India here: 1. Why spend money on defence: Ans: we have 'peaceful' neighbours like Pakistan and China. 2. Why coal plants when trying to reduce global emissions: Ans: the west was built on using fossil fuels. All your manufacturing is being outsourced here. You want your products to be built here and therefore we need electricity to produce it. You are not giving us money to build nuclear power plants, only agreements and threats after doing most of the damage to the environment yourselves. Link to youtube for a news report that mentions the same: https://youtu.be/NVyM6J2jbAU https://youtu.be/NVyM6J2jbAU
- moh_maya 6y agoIf I were at the negotiating table, I'd say, as India, come preach to me once you (i.e. OECD / NATO / Western Europe) reduce your carbon intensity first. [1] Why should my citizens give up basic development and quality of life when the prime drivers of global warming most recently withdrew from the Paris agreement in a fit of right wing nationalistic self interest, because they felt their lifestyles / livelihoods were threatened? India and China have shown far more maturity than the US in sticking with the agreement and continuing to work with the world to find a path. CN is where most manufacturing is, even though consumption is in again the rich nations. [2] Yes, the impact of global warming will be disproportionately borne by counties such as India and pretty much all of Africa if the worst of climate change isn't mitigated. But I am screwed anyway if I cut my development to meet emission targets. So I'd rather develop rapidly to build the economic and infrastructure wherewithal to withstand the climate change disruption; the biggest producers / consumers of the carbon economy are still driving climate change [3], and those guys (including Australia) aren't too keen on actually making the painful decisions they need to. Why ask me? The US automobile industry still promotes gas guzzling trucks. Ford has completely stopped selling sedans in the US, because sedans, though fuel efficient, are not profitable. Because the US can't be arsed to extend / demand / price for the fuel efficiency standards for trucks. And John Kerry has the temerity to come preach to the rest of the world. China is already the world's largest manufacturer and consumer of electric vehicles. They have a remarkably impressive mass rapid transport system. They are doing more than the US and EU are, at this point [4]. Let us see the US invest in mass rapid transport; in rail networks. I've lived in the US for almost 10 years; while I get that some parts of the vast country are too low in population density to support or justify mass transit, that's simply not the case for the ACELA corridor, or the large cities and economic regions on the coasts. These are hard social changes, and none of the OCED countries have demonstrated the necessary will-power and willingness to accept some disruption to their lives; don't ask others do to what you aren't willing to do first. The EU has started to some limited extent, but there's barely any carbon intensive manufacturing left in the EU: all of it has been outsourced to CN and other developing nations. Once I see them start imposing a carbon consumption tax, then I'll accept they are actually serious about climate change. Come preach / pontificate to me then, or ask me to make my own hard choices in terms of such trade-offs. I didn't create this problem. It is my shared responsibility to solve the problem, because I have benefited from the carbon powered technological and trade innovation. But don't expect me to assume the lion's share of the burden while the countries that drove, still drive climate change, pay lip service to making the hard choices they need to be doing as well. :shrug: [1] https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions [2] https://ourworldindata.org/consumption-based-co2 https://ourworldindata.org/consumption-based-co2 [3] https://ourworldindata.org/share-co2-emissions https://ourworldindata.org/share-co2-emissions [4] https://www.statista.com/statistics/270537/forecast-for-electric-car-production-in-selected-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/270537/forecast-for-elec... Edit: Clarified and expanded on a few points, corrected spelling & grammatical errors.
- cocoland2 6y agoI think the policy swings from state to state. There are some states that are going big on renewables. In India , Thermal power is provided by NTPC (National Thermal Power Corporation) , when state power supplies dwindle , power is procured from NTPC. The per unit price of this is way higher than the one from local grids. Some power supply companies and the central government now provide subsidies for roof top solar and buy the power into the grid at a fixed price slab (consumer gets it at variable slabs). This is quite good in few states e.g (https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/kseb-plans-to-generate-1000-mw-of-solar-power-by-next-year/article33662950.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/kseb-plans-to-...) , Gujarat (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_Gujarat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_Gujarat , https://theprint.in/india/how-gujarat-is-building-worlds-largest-solar-power-park-close-to-its-border-with-pakistan/634984/ https://theprint.in/india/how-gujarat-is-building-worlds-lar...). Consumer demand is also on the rise , eventually this will balance out with Renewables and Nuclear power (India is one of the largest renewable energy adopters , and there is a good subsidy for this)
- shash 6y agoOK, people please relax. 1. This is a draft policy. 2. Which hasn't even been released, so we can't see the context in which it says this. 3. Article itself says "State-run NTPC Ltd (NTPC.NS), India's top electricity producer, said in September it will not acquire land for new coal-fired projects. Private firms and many run by states across the country have not invested in new coal-fired plants for years saying they were not economically viable.", so at best this is a policy saying "we are open to building coal if necessary". 4. "While suggesting flexible use of coal-fired and natural gas-fired power to ensure grid stability in the coming years, the draft policy lists promoting clean power as its primary objective." Any case, coal is kind of expensive for India - we don't have any good Anthracite, so we import most of it. What we do have is Lignite which is less efficient and therefore more expensive to run. We haven't built new coal in years, and the last series of coal plants got mostly halted in court cases, or were shelved because they were not going to meet their targets. Anyway, when they release the actual document, we can see what they're saying...
- Yizahi 6y agoYou know how people in the "West" countries say that why do we need to pay for green tech today while China is doing blablabla? Well, people in India think exactly the same. And I wager people in China too, only they use some other Boogeyman, Russia maybe. That's why we can't have nice things.
- sleepysysadmin 6y agoMay build? There's about 500,000 MW of coal plants under construction right now in the world. Roughly 30% increase vs operating coal plants. There is no may, there is only will. What are you to build otherwise? Nuclear? Environmentalists are against those as well.
- wtmt 6y agoFWIW, India has been doing a lot in generating power from solar and there is a push (or at least frequent public statements by those in power) for electric vehicles and getting rid of fossil fuel powered vehicles. This will take time, especially with the current pandemic that has crippled a lot of plans and the economy, but India is a power deficit nation and can do a lot more for its people with more energy production. Switching from fossil fuels to electric with the current state of affairs is a huge task. If some developed countries have a problem with this draft policy, they could’ve done a lot more in making nuclear technology and fuel easier to access for a cleaner source. But no, even though a historic deal was signed between the U.S. and India by 2008, there have been a lot of impediments and delays in supplying uranium or getting into deals for supplying uranium. Unlike a couple of its neighbors who have a history of selling such technology and materials to hostile/rogue nations with impunity, India doesn’t do that. With China dumping cheap solar panels and related materials, India has also made it a priority to manufacture these within the country. This will also take time to scale up. Meanwhile, there’s a growing population with growing energy needs.