16 ms·
Real estate agent-owned homes are on the market longer and sell for more (2005)
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoAnecdotally, I've seen this. Overpriced real estate that sits, sits, and sits, and then the willing buyer arrives (and it's not FSBO-- so it's probably driving the seller's agent mad). I live in a globally competitive market, and discussion of real estate must always be framed with location context.
- consultutah 6y agoLots of comments about this being the agents’ fault, but I’ve also seen where homeowners just want to get out and aren’t willing to wait even just a little bit.
- gnicholas 6y agoYup, it’s incentive misalignment. The agent wants to sell the house very quickly, whereas the homeowner wants to maximize sale price (subject to timing constraints). It would make much more sense to have a laddered commission, for example: $5k plus 10% of the amount over Threshold1 and an additional 20% of the amount over Threshold2. That way the agent actually cares about squeezing an extra $20k out of the buyer; under the current system they get so little from the extra $20k that they just push their client to eat the $20k difference and sell the house fast. Source: recently sold a home in Silicon Valley and was struck by how badly the incentives are misaligned.
- mdasen 6y agoThe problem is that we don't know what the thresholds should be in advance. With manufactured goods, it's easy to compare. Salesperson A sold 10 Toyota Prius Base models for $18,000 and Salesperson B sold 10 Toyota Prius Base models for $19,000. Houses can't be directly compared. If the seller is in charge of the thresholds, they can just set them unreasonably high. I can look at my house which would be reasonably valued at $500,000 and say that Threshold1 should be $750,000 and Threshold2 should be $800,000. The agent will never be able to meet those thresholds. If the thresholds are with respect to the listing price, it's easy to just list high and then accept a lower offer. If Threshold1 is 5% above listing and Threshold2 is 10% above listing, people will just list their houses higher. With cars, I believe most places do laddered commissions. However, it's easy to know the value of a bunch of manufactured goods that are all comparable. With housing, you can't go by square footage. Some places are nicer than others. Even within a neighborhood, some areas are more desirable and even different sides of the street might get better light. The incentives are definitely misaligned, but I think it's hard to align them given that they're selling a good where we don't actually know what the value is and where each sale is pretty unique.
- dcolkitt 6y agoWe have pretty accurate algorithms for home appraisal that seem to work for most properties, except the very unusual.
- tmpz22 6y agoHow does your company make money? Are the algorithms used to optimize your profits or are they there to optimize the sellers outcome? Or the buyers outcome?
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoAn appraisal company has no financial incentive to "optimize" outcomes for either the seller or the buyer -- their fee isn't a percentage of the sale (or asking) price, but is a flat fee, depending on the kind of appraisal being done. The "algorithm" here is based on "comparables": look for homes in the same or nearby neighborhoods that have sold recently and are as similar to the current home as possible and record what they sold for, making adjustments based on differences between the homes (e.g., if the comparable home is bigger, has another bedroom, comes with newer appliances, etc., adjust its price down; if the home being appraised is the one that's bigger or has the spiffy kitchen or pool or what have you, adjust its price up).
- tmpz22 6y agoThanks I appreciate your answer
- antisthenes 6y agoThe algorithms probably price houses based on comps, to increase the likelihood of the bank giving the buyer a loan for the house. Like the OP said, it's pretty accurate in 99% of cases (reasonably priced single family houses, nothing exotic)
- gnicholas 6y agoLet the market (for agents) decide. If one agent thinks he can get $1.5M for a house, he'd be willing to accept higher thresholds — with higher percentages — than someone who thinks he can only get $1.35M for the house. I'll admit that there would be some additional complication on the front end, where agents and homeowners would haggle over the thresholds and percentages, but a pretty simple web app (honestly even an Excel spreadsheet) could show the homeowner what his net would be with various agents at various prices. Given the amount of money at issue (six figures on a Silicon Valley home), it seems worth the hassle to get everyone's incentives aligned. This might be less important in areas with less-astronomical real estate prices. As to your hypothesis that sellers would set the thresholds too high, agents could just respond with percentages (and the upfront fixed fee) that make sense for them. It's a double opt-in situation — the homeowner can't force the agent to represent him.
- wolfretcrap 6y agoYes you can get better price if you can wait longer and look for best opportunity but for a real estate agent, each sale happening increases probability of future sales, so it's in their best interest to make market as lively as possible to increase sellers and buyers trust and to prevent backlog. Plus, relying too much on one sale is not a good business, for some people whole point of getting into business is to reduce their dependence on one particular customer.
- WalterBright 6y ago> whereas the homeowner wants to maximize sale price I suspect that most homeowners don't understand the time value of money. Selling it quicker for a lower price may be better for the homeowner, as he can then invest the proceeds. Holding out for a better price means you continue to pay property tax, homeowners insurance, maintenance, repairs, and your money tied up in the house is not making money for you. When I've sold my house, I would slightly underprice it in order for a quick sale, which worked pretty good. That also worked when the buyer would come back with a bunch of inspection complaints, and I'd reply with "it's underpriced, sale is as is", and it'd sell.
- hkmurakami 6y agoProbably depends on the market. In California, holding costs are ~1.5% per year (or less if the home has been held for many years), and purchase prices can certainly fluctuate 5% in a Fairly arbitrary manner. Also, since nearly everyone is leveraged, even a 2% sale price increase will have a bigger effect on return on equity.
- Gustomaximus 6y ago> It would make much more sense to have a laddered commission, for example: $5k plus 10% of the amount over Threshold1 and an additional 20% of the amount over Threshold2 Anything stopping this where you live? I've done this. When they quote a price they will get say sure and your commission halves under this. They have themself cornered as they already told you the price they can sell it (which they generally inflate) so it very hard for them to say 'no' without you countering why would it matter if that is the price that can get. You have the upper hand pre-contract. Agents really want the contract at the beginning + they actually have 2 jobs according to a agent grind if mine; the first is getting a buyer and the second is lowering the sellers expectation to except offers as if often the case. This reduces the second.
- hkmurakami 6y ago+1 there’s nothing preventing a seller from insisting on a graduated commission structure. In hot markets like SV agents love to be the selling agent. In fact given the low probability of a successful purchase with buyer competition, getting listings may even be the #1 skill/attribute of a successful agent. Agents regularly engage in client management. The best agents can manage counterparty agents and get a deal done to close the buyer/seller gap. Clients have a lot of room to perform more stringent agent management in hot (ie liquid) markets.
- sidlls 6y agoReal estate agents shouldn’t be permitted to own anything other than a primary residence in any region they are licensed in. Or they should be required to use another agent that they have no other relationship with to transact on properties they do own.
- shoo 6y agoWhy?
- rubiquity 6y agoFor any reason why the makers of a market shouldn’t be allowed to participate in said market.
- sidlls 6y agoIt’s an inherent conflict of interest. The agent that owns real estate is incentivized and, perhaps more importantly, empowered by virtue of his license, to favor his own property over that of other clients. I should amend my comment though: an agent should not be permitted to practice while he holds property, and he should not be permitted to hold property while he practices.
- plank_time 6y agoThis is a well known phenomenon that was documented in Freakanomics. The agents don’t care about chasing every last dollar they can unless it’s their own house.
- chii 6y agoAgents tend to not have time issues, and so can wait for the best price possible. Sellers usually have some time limit they want to sell by.
- mwnivek 6y agoFor those who did not notice, both Freakonomics and the study being discussed in the linked article are based on the same research, with the same author Steven Levitt.
- flarg 6y agoSeems intuitive because estate agents make bank on a small percentage of the sale, so number of sales is more important that pushing the price by, from their cut's pov, a couple of 100 GBP/USD
- loosetypes 6y ago> Like physicians, automobile mechanics, and attorneys, realtors know more about their area of expertise than the people paying them for advice. In the absence of properly structured incentives, experts can use their specialized knowledge to further their own interests at the expense of those who hire them. Car mechanics can recommend more expensive repairs than are really necessary, attorneys can charge high fees for services that reasonably intelligent consumers could perform themselves, and realtors can give sales advice that maximizes their profit rather than that of the homeowner. Are physicians morally beyond reproach? Why include them in the first sentence if they’re the only group without a follow up. Unrelated to the above but an earnest question: why are real estate agents paid percentage based commissions?
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoWhile this is an interesting article, it's worth noting that it's (a) from 2005 and (b) using data from the previous decade. So what, it's still relevant, right? Welllll, this summary itself suggests maybe not: > In recent years, the Internet has made it easier for sellers to track house prices. In theory, this would decrease the value of the real-estate agent's specialized knowledge. Indeed, the authors find that when the public was beginning to use the Internet, from 1992 to 1995, the premium on agent-owned homes was 4.9 percent. By 1996 to 1999, as Internet usage was becoming widespread, the premium dropped to 3.2 percent. As the market became more informed, the advantage was going down -- and that was a half a decade before Trulia, Zillow, and Redfin came onto the picture. It's quite likely that if Mr. Freakonomics[1] ran this study now, the "premium" would be lower still. Zillow ain't gonna factor in "this home is owned by a Realtor" into its Zestimate (tm). [1]: Not being flippant here -- look at the first co-author!
- vanviegen 6y agoGiven the misaligned interests, it seems that real estate agents are delivering a negative value in exchange for their fees. I'd feel much more confident doing at least the bargaining part myself.
- ghaff 6y ago>I'd feel much more confident doing at least the bargaining part myself. In general you do. The agent can make recommendations but at the end of the day it's your call as the buyer or seller.
- vanviegen 6y agoYou do, but relying fully on whatever information the agent chooses to give you, regarding the bidder and other interested parties.
- systemvoltage 6y agoWhy can't we get rid of Real-estate agents all together? Snipping off 3% of the house sale price is a ridiculous fee for shuffling some documents around and pretending to be acting in my interest. What's stopping Redfin/Zillow or SV tech scene to disrupt this arcane industry? I haven't purchased a home before, but it seems like most things such as discovering homes, securing loans, touring the place, inspection, sending offers, closing and signing the deed - is very much automation-ready. There must be some reason. Edit: I got a real estate agent to kick off house search from Redfin. We had a zoom call, he looked at what I've added as favorites and basically didn't do anything useful or provided anything more than what's already on Redfin wesbite. We browsed some homes together and had a bit of small talk. I didn't go as far as putting down the offer but why do I need to do this bullshit with a real estate agent? It's frivolous and unnecessary. May be he would be useful later down the process? If you've bought a home, would love to know what parts of that process are ripe for automation.
- chii 6y agonothing, except for momentum and that real estate transactions don't happen enough for people to investigate an app to do it.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoRedfin at least takes a smaller cut than 3%...well they kick some of it back (to the buyer they represent, the seller pays the commission, I think they do something similar when they represent the sell side).
- pope_meat 6y agoThe person who invents a way to save 3% of the house sale price will make 1.5% of the house sale with their automation, while screwing a bunch of people out of an income. and I don't even like real estate agents. Downvote all you want, that just means I hit a nerve.
- matkoniecz 6y agoIf new service would be cheaper and provide the same service then it would be highly beneficial. If you disagree - please pay me 2% of things you buy for providing no useful service.
- aj7 6y agoThe rules regarding real estate transactions are carefully worded to protect the industry. An agent must bring all offers. But her advice about whether to take an offer? Completely unregulated. In general, agents see all transactions, and as marketeers, necessarily develop a better feel for pricing. They learn to avoid “having” to do a transaction, which is not true of the average buyer and seller. Finally, with fixed percentage commissions, the strike price delta is first order for you, but only second order to their commission. This is the underlying reason that legally, both buyer’s and seller’s agent WORK FOR SELLER.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIt is pretty standard in financial markets for speed and price to be inversely correlated: the sooner you complete an order, the worse the price you pay/receive.