13 ms·
The war against money-laundering is being lost
- Proven 6y agoGood. When you make everything that's not permitted and highly taxed illegal, you find yourself in a money laundering war you can't win.
- hanniabu 6y agoI thought this was going to be another crypto slander piece, parroting incorrect propaganda about how it's only used for illicit activity. But what do you know, it's about bank activity! Funny how that all works....
- IntelMiner 6y agoCrypto doesn't need more "slander" pieces when it is demonstrably helping destroy the planet through rampant wasteful electricity usage
- anonporridge 6y agoMeh. Our first world consumption habits are more than adequate to destroy the planet. Just saying mining produces lots of CO2 with current energy generation sources isn't a good enough argument on its own. Internalize the cost of carbon pollution and let the market price out wasteful usage. Demonizing specific energy usage is a waste of time and mindshare. It's little more than moral masturbation.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe correct solution to this is for official banking systems to out-compete cryptocurrency by providing the advantages that it actually has, e.g. pseudonymous accounts that can't be frozen or seized without proving the commission of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law. Obviously this is approximately the opposite of AML, but everybody keeps demonstrating that AML doesn't work. So we're better off to just give it up and take the advantage of a formal financial system with the properties that people will be able to get from cryptocurrency regardless, without the energy waste of Bitcoin et al. Because then people will use the official financial system, cryptocurrency will be less valuable, and less energy will be wasted mining it. Which is more than we're getting from privacy-invasive and ineffective AML rules.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> this is approximately the opposite of AML, but everybody keeps demonstrating that AML doesn't work It's odd to make these claims simultaneously. That one, AML doesn't work. But that two, crypto's value statement is in circumventing AML. Which, per the first claim, doesn't work. I get that the needle can be threaded by holding that an ineffective AML system can still be annoying. But if it's circumventable, that's just a cost. Which means we're comparing transaction costs versus fundamental aspects of differentiation. At the end of the day, most people aren't money laundering. Having everyone who is money laundering self identify on a public ledger might be the solution the problem is looking for.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> It's odd to make these claims simultaneously. That one, AML doesn't work. But that two, crypto's value statement is in circumventing AML. Which, per the first claim, doesn't work. The trouble is that the baseline level of inconvenience doesn't phase a criminal enterprise, because to even exist it already has to incur the cost of operating unlawfully and risk being shut down and compensate employees for the risk of being charged with a crime, regardless of AML. But the AML rules don't only inconvenience people who are really doing something wrong. There are obvious privacy problems with associating every purchase anyone makes with their name, and chilling effects for what people are willing to buy. It creates friction in things that aren't illegal. And since legal activity is so much more common than illegal activity, a little bit of inconvenience multiplied by the entire population is a lot, whereas a little bit of inconvenience multiplied by a couple of outliers is not. So the cost is more than the benefit.
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoI agree that AML is an onerous exercise in security theatre. But a large part of it involves tracking and tracing, not preventing.
- justin66 6y ago> The trouble is that the baseline level of inconvenience doesn't phase a criminal enterprise, because to even exist it already has to incur the cost of operating unlawfully and risk being shut down and compensate employees for the risk of being charged with a crime, regardless of AML. Operating an illegal enterprise in such a manner that cash can make it past AML measures and eventually be spent by the enterprise's owners, and the concomitant problem of structuring the enterprise's bookkeeping and tax reporting so it has enough plausibility to avoid prosecution, is more than an inconvenience. It's the central business problem the owners of those enterprises face. Talking about their business costs and risks "regardless of AML" doesn't really make a lot of sense. > But the AML rules don't only inconvenience people who are really doing something wrong. There are obvious privacy problems with associating every purchase anyone makes with their name, and chilling effects for what people are willing to buy. It creates friction in things that aren't illegal. This problem, the effects of which you're wildly overstating, has little or nothing to do with AML measures. (You mentioned a chilling effect on things that aren't illegal - are we just talking about stuff that people don't want their spouses to see on the credit card bill?) It's true that every purchase you make without cash will have a lot of detail associated with it, stored electronically and held by the banks and credit cards processors. This all predates modern AML rules by decades. You would have to do something very unusual for one of your transactions to "create friction" with your bank under the guise of AML rules. If it has ever happened to you, I'm super curious about the circumstances. Insofar as AML and other more modern, security-related rules might inconvenience ordinary people, they tend to affect people when opening an account, not when transacting.
- crypto-skeptic 6y agoWhat they don't mention in the news stories that say "Crypto now uses more electricity than Denmark" is that Youtube still uses more electricity than crypto, or all the electricity used by traditional payment processors and banks. Youtube could be considered more wasteful than crypto (depending who you ask) and it is never mentioned when people talk about "wasteful electricity usage". The conspiratorial part of me wonders why that would be? Is it because it is actually a threat to large payment processors that if crypto were to succeed would make them obsolete in the future? I think that there is a lot of problems with the current crypto market, the electricity usage while concerning isn't the biggest issue with these electronic currencies.
- imtringued 6y agoTranslation: Running an electronic Bitcoin mining army is fine even if it provides no meaningful benefits beyond military spending. I'm honestly surprised that literally every comment that is defending Bitcoin mining energy is always pulling out the same poorly though out argument as if knowing that electricity is being wasted is a recreational activity in its own right. Please come up with better rebuttals. Here is a freebie: The block reward goes down over time and thus the economic incentive to waste energy. The transaction fee goes up to compensate and the transaction fee is directly paid by users who derive value from the platform, otherwise they wouldn't pay the fee in the first place.
- crypto-skeptic 6y ago> Translation: Running an electronic Bitcoin mining army is fine even if it provides no meaningful benefits beyond military spending. No. I never said that. When did I say that. I never said that? I get very bored by people that try to put words in my mouth. Hackernews (this isn't my first account here) is like this. It is horrifically boring. > Please come up with better rebuttals. Here is a freebie: It is a perfectly fine rebuttal. At the moment the only reason anyone is buying crypto is because they think it is going to be worth more in the future. Most aren't buying it for transactions at the moment. If you can somehow so that is false, please do so otherwise don't be an asshat. God I hate this site. It is little better than reddit these days.
- 127 6y agoI suggest you look at how much Youtube and Netflix burn electricity. Not saying these things are fine. Just that Bitcoin is quite unfairly singled out.
- lorenzhs 6y agoLess than bitcoin, while providing actual value? According to Netflix's 2020 ESG report [1], their hardware infrastructure used just under 95 GWh in 2020 (not including data transmission or your TV). All of which was from renewable sources, btw. Including transmission and the end-user's viewing devices, watching Netflix is estimated to use 77W of power [2], for a total estimate of around 1.2 TWh per year. Bitcoin is estimated at 140 TWh per year [3], or 1500 times Netflix's data centre power usage, or a 120 times the likely total energy consumption of watching Netflix. Going further, all data centres in the world use an estimated 200 TWh per year, and data transmission networks are estimated at 250 TWh per year [4], for a total of 3.2 times Bitcoin's energy use. Maybe it's just me, but the value provided by the internet is more than 3.2 times higher than that of Bitcoin. [1] https://s22.q4cdn.com/959853165/files/doc_downloads/2021/03/2020-SASB-Report_FINAL.pdf https://s22.q4cdn.com/959853165/files/doc_downloads/2021/03/... [2] https://www.iea.org/commentaries/the-carbon-footprint-of-streaming-video-fact-checking-the-headlines https://www.iea.org/commentaries/the-carbon-footprint-of-str... [3] https://cbeci.org/ https://cbeci.org/ [4] https://www.iea.org/reports/data-centres-and-data-transmission-networks https://www.iea.org/reports/data-centres-and-data-transmissi...
- 1337biz 6y ago> Less than bitcoin, while providing actual value? Value is subjective. What you call actual value has zero value to others.
- IMTDb 6y agoThe difference is that the energy used by Netflix to stream content is a mean to an end. Find a way to reduce the energy cost and you can provide the same value for less cost. It is possible to both increase the value provided by Netflix and decrease the energy consumed by it. In fact it's even desirable. The energy consumed by Bitcoin is the entire value. Find a way to reduce the energy cost and everyone will mine more and consume more. If they don't the trust in the network decreases and the value of Bitcoin decreases. It is not possible to get a popular situation where bitcoin is valuable and does not consume a lot of energy. The valu of Bitcoin is strictly tied to the amount of electricity people are willing to waste for it.
- bruiseralmighty 6y agoBTC generally goes to where electricity is cheapest in order to mine efficiently. In some cases, this electricity would otherwise be wasted if it wasn't being used to mine crypto. So the actual additional electricity being generated in order to facilitate mining is lower than the headline wattage used. Secondly, crypto is not wasteful. It is broadly breaking down the global walls put up by 1st world countries like the US and EU that have plagued every day people in 3rd world countries for decades. It feels wasteful to us since most people near us have unrestricted access to banking and finance. Most of us are not journalists or activists who have to fear one phone call to Chase bank ending our entire operation. Despite recent events, the USG is not about to topple into a third world dictatorship that we would feel the need to flee from. Crypto gives refugees a means of escaping with some of their family wealth. It allows journalists and activist insulation from governments and corporations trying to squeeze them out financially. And finally, it gives every day people across the globe the ability to start investing their money outside their own countries and begin accruing wealth. Here is one example of the usefulness crypto can provide. https://www.reddit.com/r/MakerDAO/comments/de0sys/kyc_is_absolutely_not_acceptable_for_makerdao/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MakerDAO/comments/de0sys/kyc_is_abs... That electricity is being put to far better use than Youtube or Netflix.
- astrange 6y agoBeing used for drugs is pretty legit if you want some drugs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Cristobal36 6y agoThank you for posting that it could be just the thing to give inspiration to someone who needs it! Keep up the great work! https://www.toysruscreditcard.net/ https://www.toysruscreditcard.net/
- vlovich123 6y agoJust goes to show you what moral hazards look like. The DOJ (and perhaps similarly in GB?) has repeatedly preferred to prosecute white collar crimes seeking fines instead of jail time. From their perspective it makes sense. The accused admit their crime, you get a quicker resolution, and the government gets more tax revenue. The problem of course is that everyone bakes it into the “cost of business”. What would the banking industry look like if HSBC executives had been personally indicted for the many money laundering issues they allow to happen? What would it look like if the HSBC’s corporate veil were pierced as a result of their malfeasance? You don’t need conviction numbers to set examples around unacceptable bad behavior. Add enforcement and regular independent audits by regulators with strong regulatory capture protections, and you’ll have a better run system.
- coryrc 6y ago> corporate veil were pierced This refers only to going after shareholders. Employees can always be held responsible for their actions.
- missedthecue 6y agoI don't think there has ever been a case in modern history where shareholders have been criminally tried for a crime committed by the company.
- doctor_eval 6y agoThat’s the point of limited liability companies. Shareholders are able to invest capital without needing to invest anything else (like time) and without worrying that they will go to jail for something the company does, with or without the consent of the shareholders. This is hugely important to VC funding and to the entire share market. Imagine buying shares on the NYSE and next week you’re in prison!! So that is sensible I think. The flip side is that shareholders don’t get to make any material decisions about running the company; that’s the job of the directors (who might not be shareholders). Directors are, in theory, legally liable for the actions of the company they manage. All this would be fine with me, and directors certainly have gone to jail for crimes committed by their company, but it’s incredibly rare, and in Australia where I live, is generally related to trading insolvent, tax avoidance, or other clear and simple legal issues. But go ahead and let your company illegally blow up irreplaceable ancient cave paintings in the outback, and you’ll be fine. In fact, in Australia at least, the corporate regulator ASIC is so toothless that there is no straightforward way to enforce director’s breaches of company constitutions or other governance agreements other than directly with lawyers. This makes enforcement of the governing documents of a company (the documents that the shareholders sign up to) incredibly expensive and intimidating. Even clear breaches of the Corporations Act, the governing law of business in Australia, must be dealt with through civil law. So if you are a minority shareholder in an Australian Pty Ltd company and the directors decide to break their agreements with you - say an agreement to use green energy or to use ethically sourced labour - you’re screwed unless you sue them. If you’re a small time investor or if a significant portion of your wealth is invested in that company, you’re shit out of luck. The directors can do what they like. That’s messed up, because it means that directors can get away with almost anything, even if the minority shareholders disapprove, and there is zero recourse in the justice system. I presume that, as with many things legal, Australia follows the US in this regard, but I don’t know this for certain.
- sombragris 6y agoPaywalled, is there a better link?
- coolspot 6y agohttps://outline.com/EyF99H https://outline.com/EyF99H
- sombragris 6y agoThanks!!
- eurasiantiger 6y agoDrugs are the world’s largest market and we have given control of it to criminal enterprises.
- killtimeatwork 6y ago> Drugs are the world’s largest market Seems extremely unlikely. According to a EU report [1], estimated market for illegal drugs in Europe is 20-30 billion EUR per year. That's not that much, compared to say market for fossil fuels. [1] https://www.emcdda.europa.eu/system/files/publications/3096/Estimating%20the%20size%20of%20main%20drug%20markets.pdf https://www.emcdda.europa.eu/system/files/publications/3096/...
- LB232323 6y agoWhite collar crime has always been enabled at the highest levels of governmental authority. The Panama Papers shed some light on the most recent incarnations of this. Governments are inherently the largest criminal actors, they have a monopoly on the enforcement of law. Corruption is a natural consequence of a world governed by profit. What happened when whistleblowers stepped forward on the true extent of international financial crime? Nothing. The question is not how a government can hold itself or its citizens accountable for white collar crime, the question is why and how these structures exist. Look at the money laundering records of the largest banks, their cooperation with organized crime. Look at the slush money and criminal activities of federal law enforcement, military, and intelligence agencies. The answer is that profit governs our global society and holds the greatest sway in political power structures. As long as our world is governed in this way, then the world can be looted and plundered without consequence. Money laundering is just a vehicle for legitimizing these activities.
- bumbada 6y ago>Corruption is a natural consequence of a world governed by profit. Profit is no necessary for corruption to happen. Lenin and Stalin did prosecute profit(and millions starved as a consequence) and their country was extremely corrupt. It is power that corrupts. Humans have a social hierarchy like other social animals and people want to be above and not down. Power is inside our brains not outside. You don't need to teach anything to a horse or a Wolf, or gorillas, they will try to dominate the other horses, Wolves or Gorillas. And Humans, specially dominant Humans want to dominate other humans, and most humans don't like being dominated.
- LB232323 6y agoStalin sold out his country in debt negotiations with foreign banks. He did this because Kulaks destroyed massive amounts of grain in order to maintain profitable prices. Ask a Russian and they will tell you that profit seeking caused the Holodomor. This Animal Farm logic has been digested by most Americans. Russians actually wanted democracy, but this was suppressed by Bolshevism. Most of human history encompasses hunter gatherer societies, a social hierarchy in which the most vital resources are collectively owned.
- triggercut 6y agoThis is very difficult problem when you look at the interplay of information between parties trying to combat this that have very limited means to collaborate: governments, regulators, and the banks. In Australia (at least) banks are given rather descriptive measures to check for by the regulator. Some of these are quite standard but leave some room for the banks to decide what hard values they set in their checks. Every so often the regulator comes in, does an audit of these checks and tells the bank if they think the implementation could be better or not, but it's very arms length. You see, when the detection systems produce a result (live or historical) they are then investigated further by human analysts. How many human analysts do you need to pay? Well, it's a tradeoff between where you set those hard limits and historically how many results you get over periods. You don't want to have a massive backlog, processing time is also a consideration, but how do you know when you're picking up actual money laundering and not just weird human behavior? When you think you've found something, you send it to the regulator and the police who take it from there. You don't get any feedback. It goes into a blackhole. This sounds inefficient but perhaps (not sure if it's been determined) it avoids the case where you start overfitting to particular types of activity at the risk of ignoring others. All banks implement their own checks, so assuming other parameters (customer base, technology, enterprise risk environment etc.) are the same there must be one out of any group that's better than the rest, but the regulator is the only one that could possibly know based on outcomes. Any signal from them will be picked up on by those actors trying to get around this. This is hard, but the transaction is just a record of activity (albeit one of the only ones available to enforcers) usually after the fact. Maybe to achieve any meaningful reduction, you have to stop the flow in the first place, I don't know.
- whoisjuan 6y agoFinancial institutions don’t have incentives to deeply scrutinize all money transactions. If it entails some sophisticated trades with different financial instruments backed by some complex setup of involved parties, then it means that doing a deep due diligence would cost them a lot of money. So of course many financial institutions would just do the standard due diligence, the one for which they have a justifiable cost of business. It’s cheaper to pay one penalty that could or couldn’t come, than to scrutinize your customers and their transactions. That’s why they are losing the war against money laundering. Because the only laundering that is being caught, is the petty one. The one that doesn’t matter. Paradoxically billions of dollars are invested in catching this type of money laundering. It’s the exact same problems of tax evasion. Same reversed incentives, same functional behavior. You could almost say that the money laundering and tax evasion are symmetrical problems.
- disgruntled101 6y agoThere is no actual war on money-laundering just like there is no war on drugs. In the sense that the people that do the most money-laundering are the same people that control the institutions of the state. Invariably people indicted for money-laundering are small fries that do not have the necessary connections to be immune to indictment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- carpedimebagjoe 6y agoIf you want to do money laundering, don't you just: 1. Have a legit company/ies with sufficient revenue. 2. Bill for imaginary goods/services. 3. Receive and deposit dirty cash as payment for them. Any questions, just say "oh, they're foreigners who do everything in cash." 4. Remit clean funds to "investors" as "special profit dividends," minus your take.
- lazide 6y agoWithout actual expenses or a plausible storefront, it’ll get flagged pretty quick and shut down - and that type of ‘hands on’ money laundering usually results in significant jail time. Not looking too hard with complex movement of funds with wires is usually more plausibly deniable.
- tim333 6y agoThere are all sorts of different schemes and they change with time. One I kind of knew about was a lot of drugs in the EU are traded for cash in Amsterdam. The cash was then put into the boot of a car and driven to Marbella where it was used to buy property. It affected me because I have a property there and one day they arrested half the lawyers in the area for facilitating that. I assume they are doing something a little different now.
- orthoxerox 6y agoThat's why it's called money laundering. Laundries, along with cabs, bookies and casinos, provided a 100% legit company front that could easily bill for many small imaginary services that were paid in cash. However, running a single legit company large enough to launder the proceedings of a large criminal enterprise is impossible these days. A big successful company with sufficient revenue to mask laundering would draw attention to itself just by existing.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoDoes anyone know how it is legal to be considered guilty until proven innocent in the financial world? For me it feels like this changed slowly during the past 30 years without anyone noticing it.
- tim333 6y agoI'm not sure it's really "guilty until proven innocent." Having had money held up myself by anti laundering it's more the bank writes to you saying we can't process this until you provide some evidence as to its source. And they're not really that interested as to the source - they just want an appropriate bit of paper in their file so they can say they met regulations.
- encryptluks2 6y agoIt is certainly that way in the credit scoring system. You essentially are negatively impacted until you dispute and prove your innocence.
- adaml_623 6y agoYou mean that you aren't provided the positive benefit of credit until you prove your "credit worthiness"? I don't know you. Why would I lend you money.
- encryptluks2 6y agoCredit score doesn't just impact credit worthiness.
- cleansy 6y agoThe "innocent until proven guilty" principle applies to legal systems, not companies. There is no such thing in the financial- or any industry.
- imagine99 6y ago
- throwaway210222 6y agoMoney-laundering can be significantly reduced if every bank had to: 1. show the "contra" bank account details for every transfer in and out of an account (to show who oaid or who received the funds) 2. provide bank statements in a (standardised) machine readable format 3. provide the statements within a week of request. Such bank statements would make following the trail a lot easier. None of the enormous, listed, multi-national banks where I live can do all three. Most can barely do 3. They are so bad, we have had to conclude that money-laundering is actually a tacit service they offer.
- smitty1e 6y agoIf I'm an "artist", and I draw a horizontal line, and a "buyer" pays 7 figures for my "art", and I sort of know into exactly which account to deposit the payment: is that money laundering? Or just a modern art?
- colinb 6y agoThat is just modern art. But... if in the previous week you paid someone those same 7 figures, or you paid N people 7 figures/N for their creative dance with walnuts, then the tax people might be justified in their curiosity.
- Rochus 6y agoThat was enlightening; now I also understand the need for NFTs.
- pas 6y agoIf you deposit the payment into an account that's not yours, that is where AML (and tax laws!) kick in. Are you simply giving a gift to that person? Are you buying something from them? Are you making a honest mistake? The problem is not that a casino "makes a lot of money" suddenly. Sure, great for them. But then if that money starts to percolate into the other jurisdictions. For example the casino orders dry cleaning from a foreign company. The casino wire transfers the money, the cleaners send the receipts, but no actual cleaning happens (obviously). And this is where banks come in, because they provide the wire transfer. And they are mandated to flag extremely successful dry cleaners and other providers, report it to various government agencies. And ... it turns out that somehow they can't even do plausible deniability properly.
- 02020202 6y agoin EU, governments are removing the "bank secrecy" so they will have access to everyone's bank account pretty soon. don't worry, it's for your own good.
- NVHacker 6y agoMoney-laundering would be less of a problem if private companies (or people) would be allowed to help - for a percentage of what the state recovers.
- Kbelicius 6y agoIsn't that just what IRS does? If your tip leads to IRS collecting some money you get a percentage of that.
- ulzeraj 6y agoAnd just like a real war innocent people are suffering the consequences. There are no shortage of stories of small business owners that were kicked out of the banking system for dealing with so called "high risk activities" like the cannabis industry or cryptocurrencies and there are also no shortage of stories of rich criminals and politicians just getting away with whatever fucked up activity they do. Hell... they even put a literal criminal in charge of the ECB.
- cinskiy 6y agoAs John Green once wisely said: "Do not go to war with a noun; you will always lose."
- draw_down 6y agoIf me and my buddies can get rich off the war in the meantime, that’s an acceptable outcome
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rini17 6y agoWill be interesting if digital yuan changes the landscape. It has "controllable anonymity," meaning buyer and seller can be anonymous, but government authorities can readily track suspicious transactions. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26788896 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26788896 (the linked piece is sensationalist and sycophantic but IMO such concept will be irresistible for western politicians too)
- chasd00 6y ago> It has "controllable anonymity," meaning buyer and seller can be anonymous, but government authorities can readily track suspicious transactions. So no anonymity at all.
- swiley 6y agoSince it's being lost anyway maybe leave innocent people alone? AML/KYC kind of sucks.
- fumblebee 6y agoI was in the thickets of “big bank” AML for a few years. The experience left me pessimistic. Tragically, the process is treated entirely as a box ticking exercise. Incumbent AML systems are old and ineffective, and scores of investigators submit thousands of SARs (suspicious activity reports) to central policing authorities that 99.9% of the time are ignored until they help an ongoing case. The process is neglected partly because it doesn’t generate money, it prevents fines, which are tricky to predict and a less obvious priority for upper management. Launderers of any significant amount of money are savvy to the pitfalls of current systems. Best in class solutions can capture some money laundering schemes via watchlist screening and “suspicious looking”transactional patterns - but the limit is the data the company owns. The main issue is that money is spread across multiple institutions in multiple jurisdictions. As systems to tackle money laundering become more effective, so too do the launderers.
- fredgrott 6y agoWe have a real example in the United States called Trump, Get someone to buy a piece of real estate at allow price who does it anonymously and set it up also to support the valuation of the same piece of real estate at a new inflated price. Tada! You have just laundered some Russian money just by refusing to ask money source questions. And they real trick is make sure every single piece of real estate is a separate pass-through-LLC as than the IRS is hampered by not having enough audit staff to even examine it. You think I am joking....not really ask an IRS return examiner. World-wide one of the easiest ways to launder money still remains the real estate buying and selling.
- Veelox 6y agoTrump's out of office, can we please stop spreading unfounded anti-Trump propaganda now?
- electrondood 6y agoFacts aren't unfounded, nor propaganda. Or are you saying an individual shouldn't be responsible for their actions? He sold a $40m for $100m to a Russian oligarch, who promptly demolished it. The overpaying is the point. Real estate is one of the primary means of laundering money out of a country that otherwise restricts it. See: FINCEN [0] [0] https://www.fincen.gov/suspected-money-laundering-and-fraud-residential-real-estate-industry https://www.fincen.gov/suspected-money-laundering-and-fraud-...
- TheButlerian 6y agoGood, fuck AML laws.
- bumbada 6y agoThat is because States are most of the time the dirtiest of all launderers. For example the US financed its South America operations with drugs for a long time. US, Israel, Germany or Russia sells weapons under the table to other countries. Venezuela's leaders are financed by drugs today, like Cuba and Bolivia. US, Saudi Arabia, Russia, Turkey give money or weapons to people that destabilize other countries like Syria , Ukraine or Iran, Iraq or Afghanistan. Osama Bin Laden for example was paid by the US for a long time,like Hillary recognized. In Iran and Congo or Egypt the US simply destroyed democracy killing their leaders in order to loot their countries, just like their predecesors. Talking with Syrian refugees, it was usual for them to see some alien(no Syrians) group enter their villages with the newest weapons and Iphones and do things like killing all Christians or raping all women, they were financed by external powers. If you are Chinese and have lots of money the UK will welcome you in any of their tax havens, of course, while the Chinese have made it illegal. Remember the British Empire financed itself with drugs(opium) and slaves for all its History. If you are Germany Italy or Switzerland and the US imposes you ridiculous sanctions like those to North Stream 2 project, you will find a way to evade the control of foreign powers over your sovereign rights paying on alternative places than those controlled by the foreign power.
- Proven 6y agoTrue, but that isn't money laundering that the article talks about because it is done by the State. The Economist knowingly ignores various crimes by the UK and USA while whining how there's not enough money for the endless illegal wars they support. The more money is hidden from the State and politicians, the better.
- CyanBird 6y ago> Venezuela's leaders are financed by drugs today, like Cuba and Bolivia. Do you have a source for this? All the reports I have seen point the opposite, modern current Bolivian Venezuelan govs have seen a dramatic fall on drug trade, there was even an apalling graph from US senate where it showed that the bulk of drug trade left LATAM through Colombia and the Pacific Coast vs Venezuela, but still US gov PR line has been insistent on tarnishing the global reputations of said countries because they oppose US hegemony in the region
- dathinab 6y agoJust an example from the city I live in: The tax office doesn't go after the worst offenders it mainly goes after the ones where they can get the most money out for the least effort. But the worst offenders often have all kind of fallback strategies and good tax lawers so it's costly to get them and you likely never see the money. So instead they go after small one/two/three people companies as they are most likely to make some easy to spot mistake when making taxes which you then can spin out of control. That this often will lead to less taxes earned on the long run due to small tax paying companies going out of business due to a small mistake being turned into a big thing no one cares. This also leads to absurdities that certain kinds of businesses are seldomly tax checked and in turn often used to do massive money laundering.
- nnx 6y agoThere's no such thing as money laundering, it's a recently engineered legal construct that was hoping to help reduce actual crime (the proceeds to launder). It totally failed. Prosecute the actual crime (be it illegal drug distribution, illegal weapons dealing etc) and do old-school police work infiltrating such networks, or even work on the tax evasion angle if needed... instead of increasingly orwellian surveillance on everyone for increasingly small value transfers. The whole AML/KYC experiment has completely failed and has caused billions of damage in added costs for small businesses and people excluded from banking system all over the world [1] Similarly to the war on drugs... it's time to give up on all that craziness and get back to the basics of prosecuting and investigating the actual crimes, not the money transfers... [1] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1725366 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1...
- obenn 6y agoIt's still a crime though right? You can't launder money for a criminal and say you did nothing wrong.
- stickfigure 6y agoIt's worse than that. You can't engage in financial transactions with another person without probing into the details of their life (and reporting everything upstream to the state), or you're a criminal too. The Stasi worked this way.
- mrtksn 6y agoYou don’t report upstream, you don’t probe into their lives and you are not a criminal if you miss something. What you do is to create a process for KYC where you check against lists of threats like known terrorists or sanctioned persons, companies and governments. For example you check if your client lives in Crimea or Cuba, if so the dealings with them need to be limited in accordance of the jurisdiction trade in. You also need to look out for suspicious transactions and block or maybe report those, for example if a local barbershop business is moving a lot of gold, you are supposed to catch that. There are a lot of companies and startups in the area who make tools to streamline this process. Since there’s no standardization across the globe, you need to build systems that can catch names that went through multiple transliterations or create statistical models to detects unusual activity and so on. Source: I know people in the business. I'm sorry to disappoint you but the governmental organisations don't have the thigh grip on citizens that Facebook or Google have on their users. This citizen control business is made of thousands of organisations that often work against each other. Significantly more vibrant space than the internet of 2021, a lot of userbase shifts are happening all the time. Lock-ins are softer than those of Google, visas and migration agreements give space to a lot of user flow between those. There's no monopoly or central organisation to stream peoples lives to.
- baybal2 6y agoI recommend everybody to read this guy https://www.reddit.com/r/MakerDAO/comments/de0sys/kyc_is_absolutely_not_acceptable_for_makerdao/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MakerDAO/comments/de0sys/kyc_is_abs... My experience as a person who also was misfortunate enough to spend a big portion of my childhood in Russia, and get a Russian passport nearly mirror misfortune of this guy. Speaking honestly, the "global mobility" for me is only possible thanks to very same people who enable rather shady people moving money around the world, and contacts with no-nonsense bankers for me probably rank as my most valuable contacts.
- bruiseralmighty 6y agoWoah, this was a good read. I had no idea average people outside of Western countries were so restricted from the global marketplace. This is a system designed to keep you all poor. I am beginning to think that there is no tool more important to ending global poverty and exploitation than decentralized and permissionless finance.
- egorfine 6y agoI live in one the similar shithole countries and money laundering services are a necessity no matter how legit my business is.
- egorfine 6y agoThis isn't upvoted enough, дорогой коллега.
- exabrial 6y agoThe "tools" used to fight crime are being used to levy absurd tax rates against the people. Prosecuting actual crime with violent offenders requires old fashioned police work, followup, attention to detail. The criminal justice system and tax code is being abused to go after normal people to protect what is rightfully theirs (their money and the fruits of their labor). Taxes need to exist in some form to fund minimal state operations, but not in the order of 25%-40%.
- IndySun 6y agoThe idea that a financial institute would not work right up to the very edge of lawful if it meant losing out to a competitor is laughable. Not lost, just not fought, or more accurately unenforced. But the term money laundering is amorphous in the media. Depending on how they would like to frame the story. The number one issue on the planet is the disparity in the distribution of wealth and power. It is obscene. And this is part of it. And it is not going to change unless they are made to change, or, caught at it.
- dt3ft 6y agoThere was a "war" against money-laundering? I highly doubt that.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoThe collateral damage done by AML laws is absolutely massive: https://www.coindesk.com/money-reimagined-ugly-side-kyc-aml-obsession https://www.coindesk.com/money-reimagined-ugly-side-kyc-aml-... >>At a 2015 blockchain event, Nairobi-based bitcoin pioneer Elizabeth Rossiello answered an audience question about the impact on Somalians of a recent shutdown in remittance inflows after the U.S. government had labeled the country a “high-risk jurisdiction.” The AZA Group CEO’s answer was blunt: “They starve.” Meanwhile, there are some analyses that suggest they have very little impact on crime: https://www.ledgerinsights.com/anti-money-laundering-has-less-than-1-impact-on-crime-at-what-cost/ https://www.ledgerinsights.com/anti-money-laundering-has-les...
- egorfine 6y agoThis is what life looks for a person from the other side of the KYC/AML fence: https://www.reddit.com/r/MakerDAO/comments/de0sys/kyc_is_absolutely_not_acceptable_for_makerdao/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MakerDAO/comments/de0sys/kyc_is_abs...
- jl2718 6y agoWe’re talking about drug money, right? In my residential California neighborhood, there were constant illegal drug dealers racing around in loud mustangs painted with their phone number and web site to deliver orders made on an app, and when I called the police about it because they were intentionally crossing the road to scare cyclists, they wouldn’t even take my statement. So if this KYC/AML crackdown stops those assholes, then great, but I only care that it is reducing the amount of drugs that come into the country, and the profits for individual street deals are getting wiped out, and the gangs are disbanding and violence is decreasing. Otherwise, it seems like it’s just being used to exclude Americans from Coinlist. Money tracing is an extremely valuable tool for criminal investigations. But I think the strategy around it is all wrong. You’re supposed to use the money trace to find more criminals. It seems that all resources have shifted to hunting down financial crime itself. This is based on the kingpin theory, which is questionably valid. In crime and terror, nobody works for anybody. Kingpins are essentially getting paid to increase the efficiency of the network in the highest-risk job. The network doesn’t need them at all; it just works a little better with them taking that risk. And if you think about it that way, you see the futility of simply restricting their ability to spend that money. There will always be somebody ready to take that risk just for the ego boost. Maybe it increases the amount that that position demands, like a small tax on the network. I have experience in this (CO-IN, not drugs, although that’s where a lot of the money came from), and I could easily quantify big statistically-significant drops in violence by going after the physical product, and by local police presence. These operations were simple, cheap, and safe. But all anybody ever got excited about was the person-targeting operations. These are extremely dangerous, and it’s always a risky bet on whether more intel will be discovered in forensics/interrogation, or lost due to the network reorganizing. Another problem with financial crime enforcement is that it’s looking for the money on the wrong side of the violence cycle (right of boom). Crime starts with clean money moving up the pyramid to pay for physical product, and only the top portions are targeted. At that point, it’s nearly irrelevant how it gets spent. Physical seizure is preventative (left of boom), and disrupts the network with real financial losses. Possibly most effective, is physical presence of local police. Story: Alice pays Bill for a legal job. Bill buys drugs from Charlie. Denise kills Charlie for the money. Ellen sells a house to Denise. Who should go to jail?
- 6y ago
- jokoon 6y agoIt's not that I hate capitalism, but the more corrupt it is, the more likely it will lose the trust of people.
- herbst 6y agoDoes anyone even realize that you can open offshore dollar bank accounts for shell companies and use credit cards with someones shell company name on it? That costs a few thousand dollars to do according to google. Whoever thinks Bitcoin and crypto are the single biggest enabler for money loundering is obviously just falling for banking propaganda. Bitcoin also enabled millions of people who are locked out of the banking system for whatever reason to transfer money in a safe and cost efficient way.