15 ms·
AT&T lobbies against nationwide fiber, says 10Mbps uploads are good enough
- techmememe 6y agoHardly! The rest of the world is 100Mbps+... stop lobbying against much needed infrastructure.
- danaris 6y agoBut if they're required to actually spend money upgrading infrastructure (outside of areas with mean income above $500k), they won't be able to make the same kind of obscene profits they do now.
- uncoder0 6y agoHave you ever seen San Francisco internet? It's awful in many populated places and mean income is quite high. I get a gig pretty much anywhere I live in a big Texas metro area.
- danaris 6y agoA good point; I didn't mean to imply that they would always upgrade infrastructure where income was high. Just that they would try to avoid it by any means necessary where income was lower.
- pasttense01 6y agoI think it would be great to have 10 Mbps uploads--unlike the 2 Mbps I currently have! [Luckily I have 25 Mbps downloads.]
- datavirtue 6y agoWe are stuck in a certain paradigm we can't even see our way out of because upload speeds and access are so restrictive. We need massive bandwidth more than ever to stem tide of unchecked centralization and monopolistic platforms. Imagine being able to serve 10000 streaming customers from your home, free of the restrictions of youtube.
- elijahwright 6y agoAT&T doesn't want to spend money they've already taken for broadband infrastructure upgrades.
- brutal_chaos_ 6y agoThey probably don't have it anymore, after spending it all on themselves. As stated elsewhere, time to nationalize the internet in the US.
- airhead969 6y agoGoogle Fiber has been pretty awesome for a few months. 100+ Mbps up and down consistently over wireless and wired. It's supposed to be 1 Gbps, but the fiber is another room and I can't run ethernet to it. So, the Google WiFi APs mesh is what I use.
- aksss 6y agoSurely you can get over 100Mbps over wifi.. Maybe it's fine for what you do, but modern wifi should get you at least a gig half duplex, half that for 2.4Ghz, right? As far as no ethernet, if it were me I'd find a way. A lot of sins can be forgiven or forgotten with a little drywall mud when your lease is up. And full duplex wired speeds are worth sinning for (IMO). :D
- bscphil 6y ago> at least a gig half duplex, half that for 2.4Ghz, right That depends on quite a lot. The quite popular Ubiquiti AC-LITE access point which I use has a max bandwidth of 866.7 Mbps. At 2.4 GHz I can do only about 100 Mbps (there's a lot of traffic), and real-world bandwidth at 5 GHz tops out around 320 Mbps for me (tested with iperf). And the latter only became possible when I enabled 80 MHz channel width, which was somehow disabled on the Unifi firmware. And that's before you get to the issue of what your devices are capable of, especially if they're older. My understanding is that unless you're on WiFi 6, you're limited below 1 Gbps for link speed unless you've got 3 antennas or an extension that can operate with 160 MHz channel width. The first phones that support WiFi 6 are barely two years old. Ubiquiti's first WiFi 6 router still only does 1.5 Gbps, so it's questionable what you'll get in a real world scenario, and the 4x4 MIMO version is still only taking pre-orders.
- lostmsu 6y agoI recently got a new PC, and temporarily moved the old one into a room with no ethernet. It connects to my 4+ years old Archer C1200 wirelessly over 5GHz on another floor in a diagonal room, and speedtest gives 3ms ping, 180Mbps down/164Mbps up. I have a lot of WiFi devices, but this is a single family residence.
- gdubs 6y agoRural internet users keep getting shafted. It seems every time there’s hope on the horizon, the definition of broadband gets shifted. I really hope this time is different. To this argument in particular: the whole idea of providing access to everyone is to level the playing field and create opportunities. It’s the promise of connectivity spurring innovation, changing the landscape, etc.
- WalterSear 6y agoRural? Your point is valid, but 5/10Mbps up/down is the best I can get in San Francisco.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoIn my last place, also in San Francisco I had 20 down 3 up. So better down and worse up. Definitely not a rural only problem. It’s a US problem.
- fogihujy 6y agoThat's ridiculously bad! I'm deep in the Finnish country-side and I get 48 down/19 up with a crappy USB 4G modem shared over an access point running on a Rpi4's built-in WiFi chip, in the other side or the house. And we have crappy 4G coverage in this house due to the surrounding terrain. I expected you lot would be able to get cheap 100/100 as a minimum in cities like San Fransisco. Edit: grammar
- WalterSear 6y agoThe technician told me not to saturate my downstream or the upstream will slow to a crawl :(
- jusssi 6y agoThat's not how it works in Finland either. In last 10 years, I've lived in 3 different apartments within 4 km radius from the Helsinki Railway Station. The latest one is the first where a 1000/100 Mbit cable is available, the two others were 24/(0.8-2.4) Mbit ADSL, or mobile that slows to a crawl so that Netflix / Youtube become unwatchable at times you'd be home watching them. Meanwhile, random acquaintances from the deepest Savo report that fiber just dropping to their front porch around 10 years ago.
- datavirtue 6y ago"there is no compelling evidence that those expenditures are justified over the service quality of a 50/10 or 100/20Mbps" How is that for imagination and vision. Thank God it's not their call. It's forever youtube unless users can be empowered with the ability to stream. Right now, the barrier to entry for streaming is huge. Starting off small to prove a concept or boostrap a streaming venture takes a lot of capital and knowledge. Simply increasing upload bandwidth at the home will open up the possibility of starting a business for many. These people have no vision. I'm sure someone else can think of another beneficial knock-on effect or two beside users gaining the freedom to stream--uncensored.
- 908B64B197 6y agoPeer to peer. Has a bad reputation because of copyright infringement but could be used to legally distribute patches. Some users could even get paid for keeping their machine on during off-hours and serving updates. EDIT: Why the downvotes?
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agopeertube all the way
- 10000truths 6y agoAs long as you have to muck about in your router settings to configure port forwarding or disable reflexive ACLs, peer-to-peer will never catch on with the general populace.
- silly-silly 6y agoYou might be young and not know, but this is a solved problem. Everyone and their mum ran napster.
- lstamour 6y agoOr for a younger audience, a Minecraft server...
- cardiffspaceman 6y agoAT&T runs radio ads mocking cable internet and specifically its "slow" upload compared to fiber.
- osigurdson 6y agoIn western Canada, the majority of the run is fibre with the last mile using coax. This seems like a good compromise for delivering gigabit internet. It works well for me.
- jlawer 6y agoAustralia too. About 30% of the National Broadband Network is Hybrid Fibre/Coax (HFC). 100mbps symmetric is available (for business accounts) and many areas can get 250mbps down / 50mbps up. Some limited areas have even been enabled for (Best Effort) gigabit down.
- silly-silly 6y agoJust to add to the story, there are areas in Australia that also can not even get DSL. Daintree in FNQ for example, quite a lot of inner australia. Don't get me wrong... I do understand the complexities of delivery, but it isn't perfect either.
- jlawer 6y agoNo, the NBN is a cluster____. In the cities majority of people are in a decent position (heaven help you if your in a blackspot). For most of the rural areas fixed wireless was to be the answer. However Fixed wireless was under-cooked (technology works, but density makes congestion bad, and high bandwidth plans unavailable). Many cells need to be broken into smaller cells, but that would make the economics even worse.
- danielheath 6y agoIt works okay, but the integration between the fibre and the last mile has cost an absolute fortune - due to custom hardware & software solution with a relatively short production run (which has also meant that new connections had to be paused as they had run out of NTD hardware and the production line to make more had been closed).
- quickthrowman 6y agoT will aggressively protect its ability to pay out that.. [checks notes] 6.8% dividend yield, building out infrastructure really puts a dent in FCF. Not like their customers have a choice anyways!
- gtirloni 6y agoI live in a suburb in a medium city in Latin America and can choose between at least 4 different fiber providers. The situation in the US is quite puzzling.
- ec109685 6y agoHow does the competition work? Are four different companies each laying down independent fiber cables?
- toomanybeersies 6y agoGenerally in a similar way that it's possible to choose your electricity provider without needing 4 separate power lines outside your house. Retail service providers sell plans to consumers, an in turn buy access from wholesalers.
- gtirloni 6y agoYes, they each have different fiber cables. They all share the same poles owned by the power company.
- technofiend 6y ago>The situation in the US is quite puzzling. You'd think we would be leading the world in broadband speeds, right? In reality as long as broadband providers aren't forced to upgrade by either legislation or competition there's no reason to spend money on upgrades for an already captive customer base.
- sgtnoodle 6y agoThe beautiful thing with the US is that the natural modern solution is to build huge networks of satellites in low Earth orbit.
- tartoran 6y agoIt’s the same story over again, a powerful group milks their investments without care for the consumer. I remember the cellphone service was lagging, crappy and more expensive than in a lot of other countries in the 00s. Now it’s the broadband. In NYC, a city that should see a lot of competition, almost everywhere you live have one broadband option and if you’re lucky two. And it’s expensive since it was coupled with cable and a lot of people gave up on cable we end up sortof paying virtually for cable, meaning the price went up so much its comparable to cable+broadabnd some years ago. Not to mention that you’re paying rent for the modem like $5-6/month. Ofc if you look into it you can buy your own and not rent theirs but the majority of prople have no idea.
- kristopolous 6y agoWe already give them billions a year ($8 billion in 2016 alone https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/broadband-subsidies-totaled-8-2-billion-last-year/ https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/broadband-subsi...) and we gave them $200 billion to do this in 1996. Nineteen Ninety Six. (http://www.niemanwatchdog.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=ask_this.view&askthisid=186 http://www.niemanwatchdog.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=ask_this....) Instead you have things like this: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20151022/09232532594/fcc-has-to-remind-isps-not-to-spend-taxpayer-subsidies-booze-trips-to-disney-world.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20151022/09232532594/fcc-h... "For example, the companies apparently paid $96,000 so that Hee could receive two-hour massages twice a week; $119,909 for personal expenses, including family trips to Disney World, Tahiti, France, and Switzerland and a four-day family vacation at the Mauna Lani resort; $736,900 for college tuition and housing expenses for Hee’s three children; $1,300,000 for a home in Santa Clara, California for his children’s use as college housing; and $1,676,685 in wages and fringe benefits for his wife and three children." What is this crap from them? "Yeah that thing you have given us hundreds of billions to build over the past 25 years and billions of additional dollars every year, and subsidize rural people $50/month to pay us for, yeah, we aren't going to do it and oh yeah, taxpayer run systems are illegal in 22 states. https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadblocks/ https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadbloc..." They can screw off. Seize the industry and nationalize them. I'm so over it. And I don't want to respond to any FUD about how governments, which have been able to pull this off years ago at a fraction of the cost in every other country "just can't do it" and how we need private industry, which has robbed us blind for a quarter century while failing to deliver is "the only solution". I do not practice your religious dedication to obviously broken systems and I don't care for you quoting liturgical verses from your favorite free market prophet. It's wrong, this is a giant unaccountable money hole. The only time we hear from them is when they need to make an excuse. Unless we are willing to fire them through nationalization they're utterly unaccountable.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y ago> I don't want to respond to any FUD about how governments, which have been able to pull this off for far cheaper in every other country "just can't do it" and how we need private industry Ultimately, everything is an interface between government and private industry. Unless we have government directly employ the people laying fiber in the ground, it's private contractors all around actually implementing this. Even in muni-broadband (of which I am almost universally a fan) private contractors do a bulk of the work. The only distinction is where the definition and interface between government and contract falls. You can obviously give someone $400 billion dollars with a nebulous goal like "deploy broadband" or give someone smaller incremental chunks of money with smaller incremental goals, but, if you're not properly defining the goals and not properly scaling the money to the true benefit and the true work required you're getting poor money for value. Ultimately, I think it speaks to something fundamentally broken about the interface between government and private contractors in the USA.
- theta_d 6y agoThis is crazy. I have AT&T Fiber to my house. Gigabit up and down with NO data cap for only $60/month. I was paying over double that for only 400 down, 25 up from Xfinity with a datacap.
- icod 6y agoPeople in Romania pay about $10 / month, including router and no binding.
- gnicholas 6y agoThere's no need for Comcast to force you into a binding term contract when so many of their customers have no other wired internet options. I live in Menlo Park and it's either Comcast or cellular (which would be quite expensive, even for the relatively modest use in my house).
- ViViDboarder 6y agoAnd, at my place in San Francisco I can pay $70/mo for either 20/5 from AT&T or 1000/300 from Xfinity. No fiber available.
- zten 6y agoIf only it were 300. It’s unfortunately 30. Higher speeds are for Comcast Business.
- kelnos 6y agoAnd you pay out the nose for it. I'm paying Comcast Business around $150/mo for 100/20 (though the 20 is usually more like 15). I don't want to think about what 1000/300 would cost. It's embarrassing that I live in San Francisco of all places and this is the best I can do. Google/WebPass, AT&T fiber, and Sonic all aren't available at my address (a 10-year-old small condo building). Monkeybrains is an option, but they only guarantee 25Mbps, and you only find out if you get something better (but they seem to max out at 80Mbps or so) after they install the antenna on your roof.
- indemnity 6y agoWill StarLink force them to change their tune?
- imposterr 6y agoWhy spend billions on upgrades when you can spend millions on lobbying and setting up legal obstructions?
- jet_32951 6y agoYears ago I had IGN - IBM global network - to complement os/2 and it was flawless although dialup. IBM got out of the consumer market and evidently sold their users to ATT. Which, I found, was a billing company that would occasionally shift some bits. Ever since I have avoided ATT and they are still far more into billing than provisioning (my neighbors) who have max 75 mb down when I am getting 200/15 from a competitor. ATT is a useless dinosaur and should do the honorable thing: but they haven't ever acted anything but self-serving.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoI would love to know what kind of internet AT&T executives and lobbyists have.
- fireeyed 6y agoSimple they bought off all the policy makers and politicians. “It’s a grift that keeps on giving”. I don’t trust a word that comes out of a politicians mouth.
- specialist 6y agoAltruistic AT&T just wants to let the Freedom Markets™ decide.
- bongoman37 6y agoSometimes it is surprising how backward US is, I'm in India and I have 200Mbps uploads for ~20$/month upto a 0.5TB or so and I could have easily gotten a Gbps on a residential connection for a little bit more.
- ashirviskas 6y agoBut you still have data caps and that sounds quite expensive for India. For example in Lithuania I have 1gbps with no limits for 20€.
- chriswitts 6y agoI'm in South Africa, paying ±$73/month for 100Mbps synchronous uncapped (but with a FUP [Fair Usage Policy]). I would love to double my speed and third my costs :(
- bongoman37 6y agoInterestingly, while there are data caps, I've never run into them and they seem to not be applied. After I use 100 GB or so they are topped up without me doing anything, so I think they are mainly for people massively abusing the connection or something.
- treyfitty 6y agoThat’s because your original post says you get capped at 500GB... of course you don’t notice anything if you use just 100GB.
- bongoman37 6y agoI meant the remaining amount is always around 500GB, it seems to reset once I reach 100GB of usage or so.
- Bancakes 6y agoA lot of us need unlimited data so we can bittorrent our linux isos.
- mips_avatar 6y agoI’ve been amazed at how much better Starlink has been compared to my vdsl connection has been. Even with beta downtime it’s more reliable.
- iJohnDoe 6y agoIt’s because AT&T knows their infrastructure cannot handle anything more. It’s been proven over and over that AT&T does not reinvest into their infrastructure. Only certain areas with AT&T have modern gear. The rest is archaic garbage.
- missedthecue 6y agoHmm... Looks like AT&T spends well in excess of $20B a year on reinvesting in their infrastructure, according to government filings.
- Bancakes 6y agoOn the board members' real estate infrastructure?
- skahthaks 6y agoYes
- lstamour 6y agoHow much of that infrastructure cost is purely cellular or data centre purpose fibre optics, or to support the existing copper infrastructure though? And does it include routine operations and routine maintenance, components that needed to be replaced because of end-of-life? Service contracts? If there was a national effort to roll out fibre optic, I can easily imagine it costing fractions of a trillion in startup costs, but these would be recouped easily if everyone switches over from alternative services. Bell Canada rolled out fibre optic connections to many houses and buildings in big Canadian cities and easily started gaining customers for fibre, though still others stick with incumbent cable companies because they got a deal thanks to the competition (finally!). Sadly, like in the US, the farther you travel from a big city, the harder it is to get any form of connectivity without manually arranging for your own fibre rollout at your own dime. But Bell Canada did say that regardless of how much it cost them to roll out fibre optic, they would make lots of money thanks to reduced maintenance costs and cheaper activation over the next 25 years+. Basically, telcos math tends to be "roll out fibre once, make money for the next 100+ years off the new cables just by replacing infrastructure at each end of the fibre line every X years..." Found a quote from Glen LeBlanc, BCE’s Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer: > Now the benefits that we’re seeing 6 or 7 years down the road. Lower customer churn, higher ARPU per household, we’re seeing significant cost reductions in the network, lower truck rolls, lower calls to the contact centre. Ultimately, when you fast forward through the next decade, we’re going to end up with a very different cost structured telco in the future. There’s no electronics in the field. That’s one thing that I can’t overstate of how important that is. Whether that be a copper network that quite frankly over time in Canada does not age well in humidity and rain in Canadian weather. Or even fibre to the node or networks that have electronics in the field – DSLAMS or nodes. Those nodes ultimately lead to trouble, which leads to service troubles with customers and truck rolls and calls to the call centre. > Fibre is all about elimination of all of that. It’s a glass strand from our office to your home. There are no active electronics in the field. It’s a passive network. The cost savings for that in the long term are very substantial. Payback is 7 to 10 years we would say on average. > ... The numbers we’re seeing from Verizon are absolutely achievable [30% cost expenditure reduction once a city has fibre] and we’re seeing that. But I want to separate the cost savings you see today with the cost savings you ultimately see in the long run. The first cost savings I’ve already alluded to: that’s the lower truck rolls and better customer experience. The network performance savings, lower calls to the call centre. We’re absolutely enjoying that right out of the gate. We see about 40-50% lower truck rolls on a fibre network than our historic fibre to the node network. The great savings – the ultimate euphoria – is when you can shut down your copper network. That’s where I think you see the telco of tomorrow. From https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2016/06/ignorescaretacticsbell/ https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2016/06/ignorescaretacticsbell/
- rektide 6y agoit's worth noting that this is in spite of the Supreme Court dismantled Competitive Local Exchange Carrier legislation for telecomms running fiber, effectively ending the 1996 Telecommunications Act's applicability to modern communications. industry argued that Fiber would be so expensive that it would never ever happen unless they were given local monopolies, but here we are 20 years latter and the same industry is telling us they wont role out fiber even with local monopoly control. this was THE hot battle of the early aughts. the fight for the fiber. Local-loop unbundling[2] was working, there were competitive ISPs in most markets. infrastructure costs were shared, there were reasonable whole-sale rates one could pay to start an local ISP. it was a competitive interesting market. that all came crashing down. fiber did get rolled out, some, but it seems like the telecomm infrastructure in general is ill maintained, not expanding, and is uncompetitive in more places than not now. customers have gotten bounced between different local owners of whatever the likely-decaying local telecomm is, companies giving up not-very-profitable local monopoloies to more ruthless cost-cutting new owners, who will face no competition. stories like this seem so so so far downstream to me. "local heroine junkie having soreness in arm." oh really, you don't say? the competitive spirit in which the internet & ISPs emerged was crushed, ground to bits by a court that opted to side with industry to effectively overturn congressional law. where-as previously a company might invest in infrastructure & build out, & become the local Incumbent Carrier, the whole system of leasing (at wholesale rates) pieces of each other's infrastructure collapsed in the wake of the Supreme Court's dismantling & overriding of the Telecommunications Act. even if a Incumbent Carrier company does offer to lease their infrastucture to a Competitive Carrier, how is the Competitive Carrier ever going to trust that the Incumbent Carrier wont jack up the price? the whole system of fair, reasonable, non-discirminatory ability to serve in this utility market was ruined by the Supreme Court listening to AT&T, listening to Verizon, listening to big carriers, who lied, who all the actual experts decried, but the Courts gave business what they wanted: overturning the Telecommunications Act, overturning Competitive Local Exchange Carriers, ending Local-Loop Unbundling. 2004 was a shit year for internet access, a change into such a worse less-competitive less-investable mode. What we continue to see is a direct, downstream result of that decision. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_local_exchange_carrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_local_exchange_car... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling
- Gokuldas027 6y agoLower upload speed make sure everything stays centralized.
- tehjoker 6y agoThat and IPv4. If we get fast internet and IPv6 (each device gets its own IP, no weird router hierarchies), peer-to-peer will become a lot better.
- gigatexal 6y agoYou know there’s an dire need for American ISPs to be regulated hard when they flaunt such BS claims. It’s the largest economy in the world and yet it can’t do anything interesting or bold because lobbyists ruin everything and most politicians are more worried about getting re-elected than governing or doing bold things. I’m hoping Biden’s infrastructure bill opens the door for more competition in this space.
- ec109685 6y agoWhile the investment in Fiber is massive, it seems like the payback can be spread across decades, just like the electric grid. Famous last words, but symmetric gig up and down should be enough for anyone for a long time, and there will likely be ways of increasing the bandwidth through the same pipes beyond that as technology improves.
- Entalpi 6y agoWow, 80$ for 120/20. Got 100/10 for like 10$ here in Sweden.
- C4stor 6y agoI wonder where is the breakpoint in throughput where it become useless to have more. While ATT stance of 50/10 is certainly not enough for common usages, 100/20 starts to be in the range of my small household peak usage and I probably wouldn't notice. In my opinion, the killer feature at some point stops being throughput and becomes latency. On 80% of the web, loading a webpage will fetch 100 1kb file (I'm exaggerating), and it's way more important to have 15 ms latency to the servers serving those files than it is to have 100Mbps, 1Gbps or w/e throughput. The fun fact is that fiber deployments are usually seriously improving latencies over copper ones which is what will get noticed when browsing casually. So I wonder if the american congress could cheekily say "Sure, 100/20 is good enough as long as you ensure a 15ms roundtrip latency to any server located in the US...good luck with hawaii"
- thitcanh 6y agoIt never will be enough. Content will fill the capacity. Video will be streamed lossless. Websites will load 30MB of JavaScript because they can. 56k was enough for text, then came images, then came videos, then came 4K video. We’ll definitely find creative ways to saturate 1Gb connections eventually. But emails will forever have tables.
- C4stor 6y agoBut none of this already fills the capacity. Websites are served on slow as hell aws virtual web servers, delivering their content byte by byte or so it seems. Content is already not filling the capacity 99% of the time apparently : 4K video is 16Mbps, which is less than 2% of a 1Gbps fiber connection capacity. How often does one watch 50 4K videos simulateneously ? When you do the maths, nothing is getting that big in fact, and when it does, either it's served by slow (both in bandwidth and latency) servers anyway, either it's time insensitive in the sense of "it will run over night". I never could for the life of me convince steam/epic/whatever to give me more than roughly 50MBps. I wish I could, but I suppose it's too expensive for them ? (or they don't have correct CDNs in Europe ? I don't know). Seriously, the only sites saturating my connections are... bandwidth checkers. Everything else seems to be happy with 1 to 10% of that. So I'm very not convinced that we'll ever commonly fill 1Gb connection. Also our brains, the ultimate piece in the information transmission chain, can't really make sense of 1Gb of (correctly compressed and packed) information per second anyway. And this hardware part won't get upgraded soon.
- qwerty456127 6y agoI'd say 10 Mbps uploads are good enough to divert subsidies to those who don't have them. Indeed it's not the time to consider them worthlessly obsolete (like below-megabit connections) and necessary to replace yet. Something like d30/u10 still is OK. Investing in anything below gigabit for new cables to households which didn't have any seems an obvious waste though. I would even make sure the cables are capable of conducting 10 or more gigabits per second to make the investment future-proof. By the way, perhaps it's time to stop calling 100 Mbps and slower connection "broadband".
- jcpham2 6y agoHi, we’re AT&T and we already invested in the fiber infrastructure and we’re fine with last-mile service delivery, as it exists now, thanks for contacting us! Have a super swell day!
- tyrion 6y agoMeanwhile, in Italy they started rolling out 10 Gb fiber ... https://www.totaltele.com/509173/Open-Fiber-launches-10-Gbps-service-with-TIM-hot-on-their-heels https://www.totaltele.com/509173/Open-Fiber-launches-10-Gbps...
- mjevans 6y agoPlease remember to Share Your Experience with the FCC's form. https://www.fcc.gov/BroadbandData/consumers https://www.fcc.gov/BroadbandData/consumers Maybe this time they'll mandate competition since it's clear the last two decades haven't had it.
- notthemessiah 6y ago10Mbps is 5 times the upload speed of NASA's Perseverance rover on Mars. Currently, 3Mbps upload qualifies as broadband in the US.
- throwaway10110 6y agoHere in Ireland, i am living in a rural location half hour drive from small city (70k people) and have 1000/100mbit fiber to home. Used to be fairly bad "up to" 3mbit wifi wireless, then 70mbit "4g" wireless, with serious contention in evenings and issues everytime wind or rain occurred (which is every day in west of ireland!) The government has a plan to connecting everyone to fiber, this forced the local at&t like company (eir/eircon) to try connect as many people as they could, which they done with surprising speed
- Black101 6y agoAT&T has been knocking on my door for 10 years trying to sell me "fiber", but when I ask them if the fiber will come to my house, they say no (sometimes they even lie about that). The fiber only goes to a main neighborhood box.
- habosa 6y agoImagine being an internet company which spends half its time blasting all citizens with ads about how you have the "fastest nationwide network" and the other half lobbying elected lawmakers to say that nobody really needs fast internet. Imagine being that utterly useless and greedy. Telecom companies really are a special breed.
- croes 6y agoBecause fastest doesn't necessarily mean fast and you easily stay the fastest if nobody gets faster.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bdw5204 6y agoThe issue is that offering halfway decent internet to people in rural areas would cost them lots of money and there's not much evidence they could get away with a huge price increase to compensate since most people don't have any extra money to spend in internet (especially in areas that tend to be low wage/low cost of living). They're also against the government doing it because that would potentially cost them customers. Plus none of their executives would actually choose to live in "flyover country" anyway if they care about quality internet. The problem is that utility companies are natural monopolies that aren't supposed to make profits and also many politicians now subscribe to a laissez-faire ideology that doesn't recognize that natural monopolies exist and that both regulating them and investing public funds in infrastructure in areas they'd neglect are legitimate and necessary functions of government. That's why we have a postmaster general who thinks the post office needs to turn a profit by providing worse service at a higher price who was put into his position by a politician who was supposedly elected by rural America to defend their interests. Infrastructure investment was what made America rich and great and letting it stagnate and crumble to protect short term corporate profits is what is causing this country's decline and opening the door for China's rise.
- willis936 6y ago>The issue is that offering halfway decent internet to people in rural areas would cost them lots of money What did they do with the $100 million they got in 2013? There is a massive (10s of billions at this point) subsidy of internet expansion in the US with no apparent binding contract that has specified deliverables and defined punishment. It’s basically free money. Of course they’re going to pocket it. They probably drafted the bills. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund#Connect_America_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund#Connect...
- baud147258 6y agoI'd like to have 10 Mbps uploads right now
- checkyoursudo 6y agoAs a university researcher who works mostly from home these days, my 3 Mbps upload speed has not been nearly good enough. I am not in the US, so I'm not presuming to say what US users should have, but for anybody anywhere who needs to upload anything of even modest size, even 10 Mbps is terribad. That said, I wish I had 10 Mbps :cryface:
- ElectricMind 6y agoThey forgot to say "LOL" at the end of this, right?
- teekert 6y ago10 Mbps is enough slave!
- bilekas 6y agoIsn't starlink starting from 50Mb/s to 150Mb/s ? You would think that AT&T would like to be competitive in the future. Really strange.
- ksec 6y ago>AT&T admits fiber is most "future-proof" Well light only travels at 2/3 of its speed inside current fiber. I keep wondering when we could have cables coming close to "c" at a affordable price. I know this may sound strange, the faster we move to 5G, the more that is being pushed from Spec to Modem, ( I know HN hate Qualcomm, but they are ready to ship X60 / 3GPP Release 16 Modem this year.) and the more they are forced to upgrade their Network. Someday 5G MNO will start competing with ISP. Which I think is already happening with T-Mobile in US and many other European countries . At the rate things are going, US may end up not having nationwide high speed wired internet for most home at all.
- e-clinton 6y agoSame company that made the term “5G” worthless because it’s cheaper for them to just change the label 4G to 5G than it is to build out their network.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoAT&T is a 20th century company that doesn't see any benefit to advancement. They are fine with their dividends, it will take regulations to drag them into the 21st century. Hopefully we can get some stuff in motion boefore 2022 when the republicans probably come back into power and actually listen to the lobbyists.
- lrvick 6y agoI have to pay AT&T $300/mo just to get 300/300 symmetric in Silicon Valley. It is honestly crazy. Not surprising they are trying to further limit bandwidth.