7 ms·
Stretch from Boston Dynamics
- tsujp 6y agoI wonder how fast each Stretch can do these movements and how heavy a box they can lift. I assume that if they are able to reasonably grasp heavier boxes then loading/unloading containers full of heavy _stuff_ would fall more into Stretch's domain (less chance for injury, less people needed per box) whereas human workers who can quickly stack light boxes would remain at the top _for now_? It looks like (implied) from the product page (https://www.bostondynamics.com/stretch https://www.bostondynamics.com/stretch) that Stretch could handle things like load-balancing (literally) itself so say when loading a truck the heaviest stuff goes lowest and closest to the cab while also optimising for packing density. Very cool. I could see this replacing some/most workers at packing centres for [insert large company names here] if that was the case.
- csomar 6y agoIt's probably too expensive, and require human intervention (skilled labor) to function. It's much cheaper as it is to hire humans.
- loceng 6y agoUntil you start valuing time as invaluable.
- unishark 6y agoYou could replace multiple minimally-skilled workers with one skilled engineer monitoring multiple robots. This is how manufacturing is going. Robots don't need to be completely autonomous.
- csomar 6y agoIt'll take time until it their "prototype" becomes useful. It took some time for Spot to find a niche and its not clear how viable it is, and what the costs are (contact us?). Paradoxically, raising the minimum wage and giving minimally-skilled workers more rights could play in favor of companies like Boston Dynamics.
- freeflight 6y ago> It took some time for Spot to find a niche and its not clear how viable it is, and what the costs are (contact us?). The Boston Dynamics shop lists prices for the Spot and all the accessories [0] It doesn't for the Enterprise and Academic versions, only offering "contact us", because orders in these fields often consist of larger numbers which might qualify for bulk/education discounts. [0] https://shop.bostondynamics.com/spot https://shop.bostondynamics.com/spot
- bhuirlylg 6y agoRobots won't try to unionize, neither will they piss in bottles and generate a lot of bad press for you.
- m463 6y agoI wonder if they could design a multi-arm version - think of a constantly rotating octopus. Having many arms could get the speed way up, and could help with balance too. multiple arms might even allow repurposing the arms - it could use two or three hands to grasp very odd or heavy objects.
- aogaili 6y agoI've mixed feeling about this new Boston Dynamics robot. The issue here is that global economical systems are already having lots of capital centralized in the hands of a few (the like of Amazon and their shareholders). Politicians asking those companies to raise salaries and provide jobs, meanwhile, new tech is making it easier to replace the workers. This kind of progress without proper economical and social intervention is just a race to the bottom for many workers.. I don't think technological progress can be stopped but economist, politicians and sociologist need to really step up and provide a meaningful future vision.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arketyp 6y ago> I don't think technological progress can be stopped but economist, politicians and sociologist need to really step up and provide a meaningful future vision. No thanks! Providing a meaningful future vision is a task for each and everyone.
- faitswulff 6y agoRight, but we live in a society.
- aogaili 6y agoThen what the point of government, economist, philosophers and entrepreneurs if everyone can do that? I don't think everyone is qualified to come up with a vision, the world is complex and you need certain background to do it.
- krona 6y agoExactly, freedom is dangerous since it means we might have think for ourselves and take responsibility for our own lives. I'd rather have government deciding what to do.
- 6y ago
- Daho0n 6y agoInteresting. I wonder how Hyundai will use those themselves.
- amelius 6y agoYes, this is possible with machine learning today.
- williesleg 6y agoWait till those fuckers get hacked by china.
- iandanforth 6y agoSome things to note here. 1. It's quiet. This is a roboticists way of saying, "Hey, I'm efficient and well made!" 2. There are no 2x/3x/5x disclaimers on the video. This means that these movements are real time. Standard for BD but still a flex in the robotics world. 3. Pinch points, pinch points everywhere. This thing is not inherently safe to be around. If you don't trust the perception and safety software don't get near this thing. Also it could probably smash you. 4. They illustrate the tug capabilities (pulling the extensible conveyor) but omit the bit where a human has to connect the robot to the conveyor. 5. The first bit shows an end-effector with dozens of suction cups picking up fairly heavy loads. That's a lot of vacuum to generate. I'd really like to know the runtime of this thing before it has to recharge.
- bhuirlylg 6y agoThat extensible conveyor looks pretty ghetto. Surely production ones will be more robust and have automatic linkage.
- freeflight 6y agoIt's not ghetto at all, conveyors like that are in use all over the logistics sector.
- jabroni_salad 6y agoEvery walmart in the country has that extensible conveyor for unloading trucks.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shellfishgene 6y agoI assume if they can build a robot to recognize and pick up individual boxes they can find a way to have it find, connect and disconnect itself from the conveyor...
- bobajeff 6y agoWhen watching the video the first thing I noticed was how perfectly stacked and uniform in size and shape the boxes were. It hinted at being able to lift a specific non-box object (spot mini) but I feel it wasn't a realistic representation of actual cargo loads. Also, unloading is only part of the problem. Loading is more like a game of tetris. Only you have to make sure the packages don't crush one another, topple over, and use the space efficiently. Keeping in mind that some packages are heavier/lighter/bigger/smaller than others or oddly shaped (think tires, weights, chair etc.).
- isomorph 6y agoI’m impressed by this thing lifting cardboard boxes by sucking on the top of them. I’m surprised that it works at all, and that the top of the box doesn’t rip off
- thatguy0900 6y agoThese are all preprepared boxes, maybe it wouldn't work so well on a random sampling of Amazon packages
- liamkinne 6y agoMy university won a competition run by Amazon, attacking this exact problem. Mostly it was a computer vision problem over actual handling of goods. https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/industrial-robots/aussies-win-amazon-robotics-challenge https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/industrial-robo...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- motohagiography 6y agoI wonder if you can train/program them by recording a persons movements with a haptic feedback suit and piping the data through a model. Given tech is necessarily an expression of economics, it's not so much the unit price, but the cost of a warehouse replaced by these that they will scale to. They can work 24/7, will probably be leased as deductible opex, carry no legal risk, and even exorbitant repair and support costs will be worth it. There will still be roles for model trainers and ML supervision, just like we have forklift and backhoe operators today, but fewer of them. I've said before if a task can be specified in a collective bargaining agreement, it can be automated. It's not luddism, I think we're really at an inflection point on automation.
- shantara 6y agoStretch looks to be much more mundane and practical than Spot, which while impressive from a technical perspective always struck me more as a tech demo, than a useful product. Warehouse automation industry is booming and BD/Hyundai want a piece of it.
- umeshunni 6y agoBD?
- throwawayffffas 6y agoBoston Dynamics.
- gens 6y agoLooks janky (the whole thing is shaking a lot every time it moves, especially the sensors). If it's cheap, it's good.
- mdorazio 6y agoCan anyone with experience in a warehouse environment comment on the need for this robot to pick up boxes from the top? When I used to pack and ship things for my small business I always lifted heavier boxes from the bottom. The suction cups mechanism seems like it might be somewhat limited to lighter/very smooth boxes, but I'm not sure.
- lawrenceyan 6y agoHumans need not apply.
- BuffaloBagel 6y agoI regularly ship 50lb boxes which are 13x13x13 inches to Amazon fulfillment centers. No way they can be picked up and moved by suction on one side.