13 ms·
Canadian property bubble nears systemic failure
- christkv 6y agoHow much of this price increase is due to money laundering https://financialpost.com/real-estate/billions-in-dirty-cash-helped-fuel-vancouvers-housing-boom https://financialpost.com/real-estate/billions-in-dirty-cash...
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoAnd how much more of it is preparation for the effects of global warming? I'm personally strongly considering buying land in Alaska because the land will be far more livable in just a few decades. It makes sense that people around the globe would start preparing in Canada too.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe major metropolitan areas of Canada are no colder (and often quite warmer) than their neighbouring US cities. Toronto and Chicago are fairly comparable, and Vancouver and Seattle pretty much the same. Alaska and southern Ontario are about as comparable as Vermont and Florida. An argument could be made that people move to Canada for political stability, though.
- lioeters 6y ago> In real estate alone, an estimated $5 billion may have been laundered last year [2018] in the province — equivalent to 4.6 per cent of all transactions by value in that period, according to one of the reports. > In the Vancouver region, where housing prices rose more than 70 per cent in five years, “I certainly believe that money laundering played a part,” James said. > Such a share of transactions is “sufficiently large to have an observable impact on real estate prices,” the report said. > It estimated that dirty money pushed B.C. home prices 3.7 per cent to 7.5 per cent higher than they would be in the absence of laundering.
- anotherhue 6y agoIt's easy to be blinded and think a 30% crash is huge, but in reality it only amounts to rolling back the clock a few years. If property wasn't affordable (by whatever definition you choose) a few years ago, then it still won't be. The interplay of interest rates, QE, life extension, centralisation, and property value amount to generational warfare.
- xwdv 6y agoYup. A 70% crash will be huge, this is nothing.
- mabbo 6y agoMy condo's value has gone up by 58% since I bought it 6 years ago (compared to the sale prices of the same unit on lower floors). A 30% crash would be good news.
- TuringNYC 6y ago>> amount to generational warfare This is such a great comment. It is partly generational warfare, partly class warfare, and partly institutional-vs-retail warfare. Now matter how you look at it though, there are winner and losers and policy-makers have chosen those winners and losers by way of policy. Unfortunately, this is easy which is why it is done -- people feel pain but the network of cause-and-effect is too complex for people to put a finger on the root cause.
- info781 6y agoIn Canada there is no 30 year fixed product. Most people float month to month. Since interest rates have been dropping since 2002 prices will go up. Australia is very similar.
- DeBraid 6y agoMajority of mortgages in Canada are fixed rate and do not float month to month. > 73%: Percentage of mortgage holders with fixed-rate mortgages in 2020 Down from 74% in 2019 > 22%: Percentage of mortgages that have variable or adjustable rates Down from 21% in 2019 https://www.canadianmortgagetrends.com/2021/03/the-state-of-the-mortgage-market-2021/ https://www.canadianmortgagetrends.com/2021/03/the-state-of-...
- woofcat 6y agoHowever that fixed rate is only for normally 5 years. Not like the USA's 30 year fixed rate.
- don_neufeld 6y agoIf you’re American, this statistic can be very deceiving. America is used to things like 30 year term, 30 year amortization. This is an American fixed product. I’m Canada, that doesn’t exist. In Canada, you have things like 5 year term, 25 year amortization. That’s a fixed product (and it’s expensive). After many years of locking terms, I just use floating rates for financing all my Canadian real estate. Huge savings.
- Waterluvian 6y ago5 year fixed 25 year amortization is the standard safe mortgage people obtain here. Though I believe a lot more people are using insured high ratio mortgages given how low the rates are.
- ink_13 6y agoCanadian mortgages are not quite apples-to-apples with US ones. They have similar amortization schedules but the term is only generally 1-5 years (although you can get 7 or 10 year terms at fairly awful rates), after which it can be rolled into another one (at whatever rates are then) or fully paid off without penalty.
- kevmo 6y agoSite is down ;_;
- yzxben01 6y agoIt is down for me too, but amp version works: https://www.google.com/amp/s/betterdwelling.com/canadian-property-bubble-nears-systemic-failure-and-not-even-a-big-crash-can-fix-it/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/betterdwelling.com/canadian-pro...
- lettergram 6y agoIt appears to me, the rise was almost exclusively artificial overseas (likely from China) investments. Basically, Canada is stable and the wealthy in China need a place to park wealth (in a diversified way). Best option is foreign land purchases. This has been occurring in largely west coast US cities as well. The solution(s) are pretty straight forward and I believe Vancouver already initiated a tax on not living in a residence. If the goal is affordability, those policies need to be increased as well as new building efforts (aka change zoning).
- TuringNYC 6y ago>> The solution(s) are pretty straight forward and I believe Vancouver already initiated a tax on not living in a residence. If the goal is affordability, those policies need to be increased as well as new building efforts (aka change zoning). Wouldn't simply ONLY building new buildings/housing be more effective? This way, the wealthy can continue to purchase, but the investment would become worse and worse in returns and essentially provide subsidized housing to renters. This is somewhat the case in NYC where rents are far lower than ownership carry for identical units because the units are sometimes treated as stores of value.
- baybal2 6y agoNo, in short term people hoarding apartments will be happy to buy whatever amount of new property built. Probably it will hit people 2, 3 apartments, but not ones with 20+ ones.
- TuringNYC 6y agoI'm sorry if i'm not familiar with the situation in Canada -- but the people hoarding apartments, why do they keep them empty? Why not at least try to rent them for a partial recovery of carry cost? Wouldn't it be irrational to keep apartments empty when you could at least rent them for a bit of money. If they rent for a partial recovery, then isn't that good as renters get a good deal?
- deleted 6y ago
- keenreed 6y agoJapan also had 100 years mortgages. Big crash is 10x price reduction, not 10%.
- magwa101 6y agoHome ownership is now very liquid. People buy/sell/move very easily. Foreign ownership is huge and as mentioned, money laundering is now rife in realestate. Prices in London are estimated to be 10% higher due to laundering. I'm sure that it's much higher in higher priced homes...for a while.
- yanderekko 6y agoAs an economist articles like this strike me as pretty bizarre. Okay, so an asset class is more affordable than it used to be. Why does this indicate the existence of an asset price bubble rather than normal supply/demand dynamics?
- beforeolives 6y agoCan't you look at any bubble and call it supply/demand dynamics?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TuringNYC 6y agoOne sign of a bubble -- to me -- might be purchases which are out of line with income/yield. One could theoretically make growth assumptions, but even with that baked in, sometimes the PEG ratio is irrational and that suggests a bubble.
- 0xfaded 6y agoThese house prices greatly exceed the value provided by a house (basically shelter from the elements, access to employment). An economist would call such margin a rent, and reason that supply would increase to take advantage of the profits to be made. A bubble is driven by price momentum, which in this case is a result of poor policy (zoning), too big to fail dynamics (what would happen to the pension funds in a crash?), and a blind eye to illegal activity (money laundering). Supply is going to have to increase to almost illogical levels to temper this momentum. I could imagine a public construction company tasked with nothing but building new towns outside the cities, complete with universities and subsidized employment opportunities, could begin to make a dent.
- mabbo 6y agoThere's so many articles about the Canadian property bubble popping that I'm starting to feel like it's some sort of concerted effort by the real estate industry to cool down the market. It was just about to pop 6 years ago when I bought my condo. It was about to pop when values stopped increasing so dramatically 3 or 4 years ago. It was about to pop when the COVID-19 pandemic halted most sales. It's about to pop now because everyone is leaving the cities because of WFH rule changes. But it never does. Prices are still high because demand is high and supply isn't keeping up. Demand is high because our financial laws allow criminals to launder money through housing, and because we're a desirable country for wealthy immigrants. Supply is low because cities have too many NIMBY politicians that are against density increases. I wish it would just pop so we can all get on with fixing the root problems.
- zikzak 6y agoAre they trying to cool down demand or are they trying to create a climate where people feel they should list thier home now before the market cools?
- salamandersauce 6y agoThey aren't doing anything. Bank of Canada said they don't want to adjust rates for a couple years, ruling parties have been mum on the whole thing because it benefits a good chunk of voters that are homeowners. Right now it seems like to buy a house you have to offer no conditions, so no housing inspections etc. which is probably going to lead to a good number of screwed people when they find out their 900k home needs an extra 200k in work.
- bradleyjg 6y ago> because it benefits a good chunk of voters that are homeowners. Western nations all deciding to encourage homeownership looks like a bad decision in retrospect. Having a large percentage of voters with a large percentage of their net worth in a particular asset class practically guarantees bad policy with respect to that asset class. The same sort of thing is no happening with pension programs being replaced by investment schemes that encourage widespread stock ownership.
- Waterluvian 6y agoIt's all just beyond ridiculous. I make more money alone than both parents did at my age. And I cannot afford even 1/3 of the house they bought when they were my age. And not some Toronto house. Just this thing on the edge of Waterloo. The house is worth 1200% what it was in 1989. Luckily remote work allowed me to move to rural Ontario but even here prices are exploding. At this point I'm expecting my house to be worth a lot less one of these days, but I think it inevitably will appreciate in value long term. Living in or near Toronto isn't even a possibility anymore.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoThis is what doesn't make sense to me. High earners are struggling to buy a place. It's not sustainable generally and political will for ever growing prices will have to shift as demographics age and non-owners grow relative to population. And if interest rates start going north in any real way it's going to be severe with some of the debt load you hear about so many people taking on.
- chii 6y ago> High earners are struggling to buy a place. because there are even higher earners buying, pricing them out. So are they really 'high' earners? I think the lack of supply is the true source of the problem.
- JamisonM 6y agoZoning is largely local though, so the actual political control of the thing that would make this situation unsustainable is held by incumbent owners. There are of course still limitations to the impacts of higher density as well, the desired living conditions of many buyers is yard+reasonable commute, so there is an absolute physical constraint here as well.
- Gustomaximus 6y ago> Zoning is largely local though, so the actual political control of the thing that would make this situation unsustainable is held by incumbent owners. Or a solution that speaks to that. E.g. A progressive tax like income is but in total residential property value. Something like <$1m is 0%. $1-3m is 1%... Etc. Make the top rate untenable to own more than $Xm in residential like 10% + top rate for anything held under obscure ownership structure.... or whatever bands/percentages that seem right. There is an increasing small group of people that own/inherit significant residential ownership. And while there is a physical constraint side of housing, fixing residential as investment vs place to live can take a heap of pressure off and is a much easier/faster point of solution I feel. I cant remember where I heard but someone said residential property can either be good for investors or owner occupiers. Not both. Ultimately the government needs to prioritise occupiers in my view anyway as not just for happy people, but this brings stability and economic benefits to a society.
- AzzieElbab 6y agoI live in Toronto and have to say the real estate prices here have been the puzzle of my life. They are going up even now, still under lockdowns and significantly reduced immigration in-flow. Tiny unliveable condos bought to rent out lost a few percents, everything else keeps going up
- Haegin 6y agoI think with Covid making remote working far far more accessible for a lot of jobs there's going to be a pretty big growth in smaller cities and communities outside of Toronto/Vancouver over the next 10-15 years. My partner and I moved out of Toronto two years ago and bought a detached house for far less than the cheapest tear-down bungalow was being marketed for in the city. In the last year several friends have moved out of the city because house prices are too expensive there and the area we're in has seen house prices go up a lot. This seems to be mainly driven by people in the 25-40 age range moving out from Toronto.
- tincanner 6y agoIt’s not a coincidence that this is happened and I’m sure the government has been well aware—they just make too much money from it to care to slow it down.
- renewiltord 6y agoOut of curiosity, where does the 30% of gross income max sunken come from? Considering that other living expenses don't also rise with more expensive homes, I don't understand why we'd use a flat figure. If it costs $40k to live per year, and you make $80k post tax, then you have $40k left over to spend on a home per year. If you make $100k post tax per year, you have $60k left over. That's a 50% increase for a 25% increase in salary. There's no reason it should be flat.
- dagmx 6y agoI'm not sure where the 30% comes from either. I've seen it often thrown around for housing markets but it seems out of touch, since it doesn't line up with a lot of median incomes of home owners vs median prices in metro areas. It's not uncommon to see many people putting 50% of their income or more to rent, so why would mortgage be different?
- bentlegen 6y agoOn the off chance there are policy makers here, I’m surprised there’s not a bigger focus on land transfer taxes and their impact on home prices. When you purchase a home in Ontario, as a buyer, you are expected to pay an additional 2-5% of the purchase price in taxes. You need to have this money when you close, in addition to your down payment, and it is remitted immediately to the government. This can be the equivalent of 5-10 years in property taxes, depending on the purchase price and how your home was assessed. And you pay it every time you move (and buy a new home)! This pushes the tax burden disproportionately onto new homeowners, and incentivizes folks to stay in their homes for longer (don’t forget the additional 5% paid to agents). It reminds me of Prop 13 in California, which similarly disproportionately taxes new homeowners and incentivizes people to hold onto property forever. (Note: my numbers here are fuzzy, and I’m not a real estate expert, so someone here is welcome to correct me if I’ve incorrectly interpreted all this.) https://www.ratehub.ca/land-transfer-tax https://www.ratehub.ca/land-transfer-tax
- jpambrun 6y agoI believe the purpose of this tax is in part to lower demand thus reducing sale prices. Some municipalities have credits for first home owners to offset that. If anything, to increase accessibility for first owners, the taxes (along with the associated credits) could be increased.
- barbacoa 6y agoThe problems Canada is having with real estate values is a good argument for high property taxes on real estate. When home owners have to pay 2-3% the annual property value it creates a strong incentive to use property in the most economically productive way. You don't get stuck in situations like this where homes become like bitcoins for rich chinese who want to park money overseas while buying into a bubble. High property taxes can then be offset by lower income and sales taxes which only affect people who actually live in these cities. The end result is cheaper housing even after taxes.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoI think a progressive tax like income in total residential property value. Numbers off the cuff but something like <$1m is zero. $1-3m is 1%... Etc. Make the top rate untenable to own more than say $50m in residential like 10% + top rate for anything held under obscure ownership structure. This way peeps can own a normal home at no cost, even have an investment property. But the person with 300 apartments who buys another 10 every year is encouraged to move their money to alternate assets.
- KoftaBob 6y agoThat might discourage some of the foreign investor activity, but unfortunately I don't think that will make a significant difference on keeping price increases in line with income. To give you a real world example, NYC's Long Island suburbs are notorious for having some of the highest property taxes in the nation (mostly the school taxes). Despite this, LI home values continue to go up at a pretty high rate, an average/very basic starter home is around $500-600k. This is because despite the high property taxes and not great weather, the demand for homes there highly outpaces supply. In the case of Long Island, the demand is due to things like having easy access to NYC's huge job market and NYC itself, the quality of schools, low crime rate, etc. For you to make property taxes high enough to make a meaningful dent in demand, they'd have to be so high that any decrease in the cost of the home would essentially be cancelled out by the astronomical property taxes. Time and time again, the root cause of high home values has shown to be that the increase of supply isn't keeping up with increase in demand. To fix that, the factors slowing down new supply need to be removed. These factors vary by location, and include things like a slow/expensive permit process, overly restrictive zoning, allowing NIMBY groups to slow down or block new development with constant town hall meetings, etc. In the case of the crown jewel of places that are horrible at keeping up with housing demand, California, all 3 of those are at play simultaneously, and the housing costs there show it.
- imtringued 6y agoIf you spend Canadian dollars on Chinese products then what will happen to those CAD? There is a 50 billion trade deficit with China. The Chinese keep accumulating more and more CAD and they don't buy anything with it... except housing and companies because Canadians aren't producing anything that the Chinese want to buy. Now the obvious thing would be to just do the same thing the Chinese are doing. We buy Chinese products, they produce them. They buy our houses, we produce them. Turns out, we forgot to do that. Of course, this isn't the only factor. There are probably dozens of factors that are causing prices to rise but Chinese investors are highly price insensitive because doing anything with the CAD they have is better than letting them sit around. What else are they supposed to put the money into after all?
- andrewmcwatters 6y agoThere’s an ongoing international failure to protect young people from various investors creating a generation of neoserfdom in the form of REITs, foreign real estate purchases with no intent for the owner to live in the property a minimum of 51-80% of the time to encourage GNI growth, rampant house flipping, the spread of HOAs, and virtually no assistance to first-time prospective home buyers. In my opinion things are so bad, I don’t know how these politicians aren’t getting killed. Maybe young people are too ignorant to know everyone is screwing them and that’s why we have no civil unrest.
- refulgentis 6y agoI'm young enough to fit into your group of people who may be too ignorant to kill politicians. I'm not killing politicians because it's bad
- JamisonM 6y agoThere has always been lots of support out there for 1st time home buyers, some measures have been clawed back on that front because they are obviously ineffective. Everything else you cite here seems to be random arm waving in the general direction of capitalism. The thing about the past was that we built a lot of housing, I think creating an environment where politicians can openly support building a lot more housing would actually address the "capitalism" problems.
- dataminer 6y agoThere are quite a number of factors which are causing incredible price growth. These cities are immigration destinations, a large number of Canada’s > 300k annual immigrants becomes residents of these cities every year. These immigrants are educated and quite often asset owners in their own countries. So lots of foreign money flows to these cities through immigrant population. Also culturally immigrants invest more in real estate as countries they have come from don’t have great investment alternatives beside real estate. Because interests rates have been falling for last 20 years property prices have increased tremendously. This has created tremendous wealth for property owners, who then learned that they can cheaply get money out through home equity line of credit. This money is then invested in other properties which are rented out to pay for mortgage and expenses, creating a loop which further expands the price growth. At this point property owners are making more money just by living or holding their properties than by working. So its becoming extremely attractive form of investment. All of this is propped up by lax regulation, low housing starts, green belts, few public housing options. It is a dire situation and now young people are getting frustrated. Because the wages haven’t kept up and savings have been inflated away by a government which loves to print money. Now this not even a big city phenomenon, the leverage available has caused prices in small cities to rise tremendously as well. Young local population is getting priced out because numbered companies are hoarding up houses and making them rentals. There are some solutions, like banning non residents to own residential property in Canada. Asking for over 50% downpayment for 2nd residential property, 75% on 3rd. Taxing vacant properties. In the end government needs to realize that residential properties are social assets not financial assets. The goal should be to create vibrant communities, and that cannot be done if people are unable to own a residence.
- voisin 6y agoI wonder why the rise of AirBNB isn’t discussed much more frequently. I’ve lived in pretty desirable areas and found it nearly impossible to find a decent rental because anything good is dedicated to AirBNB during the nice months, so my option is to rent a shitty apartment for 12 months continuously, or a decent apartment for 8 months and then be in disarray for 4 months struggling to find somewhere to live. I think it is complete madness that AirBNB has soaked up so much of the rental and housing stock.
- greenonions 6y agoAirbnb didn't create demand for housing that didn't exist. People really want to rent places that aren't hotels for short periods. Is that madness? Cities trying to clamp down on Airbnb are just shooting themselves in the foot again along with NIMBY housing regulations. There's incredible demand for housing in cities that isn't being met, and the cities which refuse to allow supply to rise will face the same problems and eventually lose out to more dynamic cities.
- voisin 6y agoPeople really want to run hair salons from their house, but zoning regulations prevent it. People really want to run daycares without licenses, but laws prevent it. People really want to house old folks without licenses, but laws prevent it. We have zoning laws, restrictive covenants, and boarding house licensing rules for a reason. If there is demand, then have a public referendum like we’ve seen for cannabis laws, overturn the legislated barriers and allow it. But right now, it is illegal in most places and consequently hammering the market for actual residents.
- greenonions 6y agoI would argue that Airbnb is not illegal in 'most places', and even if it were, it does not take away the demand. Similar to cannabis, it's illegality did not take away the demand. Whether there is demand is not up for debate, as there clearly is. The question lies in how it is handled. Making short-term rentals illegal will almost certainly not work. Allowing short-term rentals, and allowing enough housing to be built to accommodate them, along with those who wish to own is the only solution likely to work.
- iandanforth 6y agoThe predicate of this article is nonsense. The market has not failed, nor is it nearing 'systemic failure' if some people can't afford to buy goods in the market. Is it a housing crisis for young locals? Yes. Is it a market failure? No.
- agentultra 6y agoIt’s funny that most Canadian software companies don’t even offer salaries that meet the median for a “typical home,” which sounds like a small condo for 1 or 2 people. You have to have a dual income to be able to afford the payments, taxes, insurance, and maintenance... and just get by.
- voisin 6y agoThe crazy thing is that this is no longer a Toronto/Vancouver thing. It is everywhere in Canada now. Every province, every small town. There is literally no escaping this bubble now and I do not believe it is related to foreign money - this one is home grown and resulting from monetary policy mismanagement. We never took our medicine after 2008 and everyone has been loading up on debt - individuals, companies, and governments. It’s madness and no one can afford altars hikes. Just wait until the bond vigilantes come and make us atone.
- RocketOne 6y agoMeh. 5 years ago my house in Calgary was worth 380k. I just sold it for 385k. It might have gone up to 400k if I had waited a bit. Its not 'bubbling' everywhere - just the meccas of Toronto and Vancouver and their bedroom communities are going nuts. Move to western Canada and prices are still very reasonable.
- voisin 6y ago"Detached home sales in February amounted to 1,123, up from 678 the year prior, while prices edged up to $572,670 from $526,084 previously." [0] Calgary detached homes are up 9% year over year, in a pandemic, with Alberta's oil industry haemorrhaging jobs. The only way 9% is low is in relation to the rest of Canada. BC (Victoria, Nanaimo, Kelowna, etc, all outside Vancouver) are up 30%. Nova Scotia is up 30%+ even outside Halifax. [0] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-real-estate-board-creb-home-sales-real-estate-1.5932346 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-real-estate-b...
- RocketOne 6y agoAnd here's the truth about the 'average' prices in that article. They are heavily skewed by the high end houses, not the ones the average person buys. Ive owned there for 35 years and my two houses have always within 10k of the average price. Now, the average is 160k higher? That'll happen when the high end houses are selling for 10 million when we rarely had a house over 1 million a few years ago. Here's a chart showing the actual average prices: http://www.chpc.biz/uploads/9/7/9/5/9795010/chart-calgary1j_orig.jpg http://www.chpc.biz/uploads/9/7/9/5/9795010/chart-calgary1j_... The top purple line shows single family homes which peaked at about 500k in 07, about 14 years ago. Now they are supposedly about 550k which is only a few percent rise per year. This is totally consistent with my own house values. The CBC article says prices are up 9% from last year. It doesnt bother to mention that they aren't much different than 14 years ago. Edit: I recall about 10 years ago when someone built a house in a nice part of Calgary that was over 3M and people were surprised there was a house that expensive. A quick check shows there are several homes for sale over 10M now and there are over fifty at 3M and up. The high end stuff keeps rising astronomically.
- dagmx 6y agoI've been reading about the impending crash for a decade now. The most that's happened is that the market in Vancouver cooled down with new mortgage rules and regulations on empty homes. However average pricing hasn't really gone down. I bought a town house in 2015, downtown Vancouver. Within a year it went up 50%. For a bit it was even 75% at the peak of the market pre the new regulations. Depending on the time of year it hovers between those two ends. Since it's downtown I'm not worried about a crash affecting it too much. However a crash would benefit us for selling and moving further out to a detached home where prices tend to fluctuate more. That said, again, it's been a decade of people talking about the bubble bursting but I don't see what would cause it? * Vancouver, like San Francisco, is limited in growth by the geography of the area. So it's not like new development will lower the market prices. * We don't have a mortgage issue like the US did for the 2008 recession. In fact mortgage practices have become even stricter. * The distance from the distant suburbs of Vancouver to downtown is paltry compared to commute in the Bay Area or LA. There's room to grow out in that direction. The public transit system is also much better than most American places I've been to. So living further isn't as much of a burden. Point being: yes the market sucks. But I don't see what would cause a crash? Yes it's unaffordable for many. But I don't see that as a metric for a crash either, just a metric for growth outside of the core.
- difosfor 6y agoSounds familiar and seems to come down to a shortage of housing built in desirable places all over the world. The sad thing is that even while investors are getting rich of these artificially rare commodities cities don't significantly build more and higher etc. Spreading out is a way around this, but the increased concentration of cities still seems valuable to me and most people, otherwise prices would drop, so it's not a real solution.
- stevegalla 6y agoThe article is talking about detached housing. In Vancouver I keep seeing the trend of several detached houses in a row being bought, bulldozed, and converted to low-rise condos or townhouses. The supply of housing (condos, townhouses, duplexes) is increasing, it’s just people aren’t too happy with “lowering their living standards” by having to live in a condo or townhouse, or having to move out of their neighborhood to a suburb. Land is an issue in Vancouver. We have mountains to the North, ocean to the West, and farm land to the East and South. What little land is available does get converted to “dense” accommodations, but it could be more dense. For example, in my area 10 years ago there were maybe 3 or 4 detached houses on the land. Now there are 450 condo and townhouse units. This could be significantly more dense by building a high-rise (6+ floors I think) instead of the low-rise (5 or fewer floors). However, we don’t really have the correct road infrastructure to accommodate huge density increases. Pre-pandemic a 20-25 minute drive to work already takes around 1.5-2 hours during the weekday. The detached housing that remains detached is converted from, for example, a 3bed 2 bath rancher to some sort of luxury home with 6 bed 4.5 bath. Doubling or tripling of value is not uncommon. I can’t find it right now, but articles in the local papers have talked about changing communities from being all single family detached to a mix of condos, townhouses, detached. This way new buyers can start at a condo, move to a townhouse, then upgrade to a detached house as equity builds up, the family increases their income, and the family expands. The problem with this is the people who own the detached houses don’t downsize when their kids leave, so these rarely come on the market, or people are buying more house than they need at that point in their life to counteract rising house prices. Yes, people have expanded outwards. For example, my mom and step-dad moved approximately 1.5 hours East of their last house (now a 20 minute commute for my stepdad instead of the previous 60-70 minute commute). The problem here is that the house prices have risen here too for detached houses. Places on my parents street are 650-800k. Go over one block to the next cul-de-sac/ street and they go for 800k - 1.2 million. These are all new detached houses built [edit: on previously vacant land] in the last 3-5 years. Spreading out hasn’t actually caused prices to drop. Spreading out has done the opposite. They call it half-doubling or something here. Half the price for double the house if you move outwards. Who knows what will happen.
- robbmorganf 6y agoSort of a methodological question: why does a crash max out at 30%? The author seems to point out that even a 30% crash wouldn't fix it and therefore no crash would, but I'm wondering why crashes can't be larger than 30%.
- voisin 6y agoRelevant: “ This has the potential to destroy the livability of every major community, create two classes of citizens, cement a wealth divide, disenfranchise an entire cohort, create structural household debt, make shelter unaffordable and hobble the economy as billions a week flow into vaporous housing equity. In short, it’s an epic policy failure. It’s time those who have greased the wheels – realtors, central bankers, political leaders and our federal housing agency – stand accountable.” https://www.greaterfool.ca/2021/03/26/we-are-watching/ https://www.greaterfool.ca/2021/03/26/we-are-watching/
- hourislate 6y agoIf or when it pops, it will wipe out the savings of most of the country. There are so many folks depending on their house to fund their retirements, that there is no possibility the Government would ever allow a meaningful Interest Rate hike or anything that would adversely affect real estate value. I suspect most Canadians know this and understand it is a sure way to make 20% returns on their money (safer than a Canada Savings Bond). My advice is to borrow as much as you can and buy a house in Toronto. It will double in value in the next 5 years. There is absolutely no possibility the Gov will allow your investment to fail. For Canadians that can't buy, I suggest you lobby your Gov to force Corporations to implement mandatory WFH for at least 80% of employees (that can). This should allow you to live in rural Canada somewhere and participate in property ownership. The other solution is to sell millions of acres of Crown Land to Canadians who are first time property owners.
- ChrisArchitect 6y agowhat's the second part about - implementing mandatory WFH? how do you mean that translates to rural opportunity? The rural options are always there in a country the size of Canada, but it's the being disconnected from civilizations/culture/community that keeps everyone close to the southern end.
- ipaddr 6y agoThe calculations of the article is seem wildly not reality based. Most young people buying a home in a big city are getting downpayments from family or they are saving more than 10% a year. Add in the rsp savings, tfs accounts and the actual calulations are more complex. The drop in the condo market because of the drop in airbnb makes that sector an attractive entry for young Canadians. You can get a fairly big house outside of the downtown core (45/50 by 120+) for a fair price or you can get a rundown older house postage stamp close to downtown for 4 times more. I see raises in prices for all detached homes for the next two years followed by a period where people try to move back to major cities causing a price increase in major cities and a drop in cottages / smaller cities.
- JamisonM 6y agoI'd like to say that as a rural grain farmer I would like to live in a condo in a dense and walkable neighbourhood with an excellent range of ethnic cuisine expertly prepared by my diverse neighbours. I consider that desire just as realistic as the desire to live in a fully detached home and work in downtown Toronto. Life is full of compromises, I'd rather not have a lawn to mow, but thems the brakes!
- gajjanag 6y agoI couldn't find a good comment here about how property taxes work in Canada, so I dug up: https://torontoist.com/2016/12/how-property-taxes-work-toronto/ https://torontoist.com/2016/12/how-property-taxes-work-toron... If this is indeed the case, Toronto's housing will not price correct: ultimately, capital from China/wherever needs a place to be parked, and it will flow most to the places where taxes are lowest: hence Toronto (see above), Vancouver (see articles listed in this discussion along with some steps taken to patch the issue), SF Bay Area/California (Prop 13 makes it attractive). I ran through this thought experiment now to understand why East coast real estate (e.g., Boston) as well as Seattle don't see as much absentee buying.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoThere are so many issues besides just saving for a downpayment. How will you keep a job that supports the mortgage? Companies are exceedingly disloyal and looking to cut labor costs whenever possible, whole industries go through huge labor contraction, not to mention accumulating effects of automation. Even if I saved a downpayment, I would not feel comfortable entering into a mortgage like this at all. It just adds stress to your life and you get none of the independence or peace of mind you expect to get from private property ownership.
- cryptofistMonk 6y agoAll these articles assume median incomes with 10% savings for a down payment, which to me seems ridiculous and is simply never going to be enough to buy a detached home in a major city. Here's the income data for 25 to 34 year olds in Vancouver: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1110023901&pickMembers%5B0%5D=1.21&pickMembers%5B1%5D=2.4&pickMembers%5B2%5D=3.1&pickMembers%5B3%5D=4.1&cubeTimeFrame.startYear=2015&cubeTimeFrame.endYear=2019&referencePeriods=20150101%2C20190101 https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=111002... We're talking about incomes of only $46k CAD. Is the author really expecting a young couple saving 9k per year to come up with a down payment on a detached home in one of the most expensive cities in the world?
- RocketOne 6y agoAnd once again, for about the 20th time, we are told there is a "Canadian" real estate bubble where in fact, there is a Toronto and Vancouver bubble and surrounding bedroom communities. I know they dont care much, but theres an entire country outside of those two metropolis but welcome to western Canada, where you can buy a very decent 3 bedroom home in Calgary for 400k and and only have to save up for 2.5 years. Very reasonable indeed.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe difference is that this has shifted a whole bunch in the last year. And you have to put Alberta aside because its economy is so tied to oil prices that real estate there took a major hit that it's only really bouncing back from now. (And in a big way, just saw articles this morning about the seller's market in Edmonton. FWIW I grew up there and have family there, so I keep my eye on thing) But with the COVID situation people are moving all over, and smaller communities in rural or small town southern Ontario (like my own) are being hit with real estate practices that used to be just confined to Toronto. Things going way over list, blind bidding, unconditional offers no inspections, rural places that would normally sit for 4-5 months (because of the complications of selling a rural place) off the market in a week, etc. Towns like London and Windsor that have had depressed real estate markets for a long time are suddenly hot. Forget about places like Collingwood that might be considered luxury lifestyle places by some. And then it's spreading out of Ontario; I've seen articles about the Nova Scotia real estate market starting to go crazy as people from Ontario are buying things there sight unseen, etc. Have to admit, we've looked ourselves. Why not work remote from NS? It's super nice there. And forget about B.C. Last year we were browsing homes in Squamish as it was still "relatively" affordable relative to Vancouver. Prices seem a good 30-40% higher than when we looked a year ago. Interior BC is off the charts and not just in Kelowna where it's always been pricey. I've been watching various ski town (Golden, Revelstoke, etc.) prices for a while. They've gone bonkers over the last year. Friends of friends sold their acreage here in Ontario recently (for a ridiculous price) and relocated to Vancouver island hoping to cash out and get out; reportedly they found it really hard to find a place in Victoria and got caught in multiple bidding wars. Buyers in Toronto and Vancouver have Stockholm syndrome in regards to the real estate market. They are used to practices that were just not a thing elsewhere in the country. And as they leave the city they're bringing those practices (and their frankly unethical real estate agents...) with them...
- amarant 6y agoThis issue is pretty much global. It's the same story here in Sweden. As far as root cause goes, I think people are fucking more than they are building. Solutions? It's not easy, and the most effective ones are not going to be popular. We're eventually gonna have to try to make people have fewer babies, I say we start now so that we don't have to do anything so drastic in a couple of decades. It's annoying now when housing is expensive, but when food prices start climbing were gonna have a real problem.
- RealityVoid 6y agoI'm not buying this. Birth rates are down all across the board in developed countries.
- amarant 6y agoSure, but population isn't. Population isn't growing as fast as it was, that is true, but it's still growing too fast, or so I think at least.
- dgudkov 6y agoIn order to predict a crash of the Canadian real estate market one should understand the root cause of the bubble. However, there is no consensus on that.
- ChrisArchitect 6y agoAs someone in Toronto living through this for years it's just so depressing. Seeing no light at end of tunnel on prices, the pandemic obliterating so much of the benefit of the city core itself, and even GTA searches turn up crazy prices and bidding wars. I know the Chinese/foreign money is forever a blame thing that isn't entirely true but that also drifts into the effect on communities that constant churn of buyers/renting etc has on culture and areas. Who wants to live in neighborhoods or condos that every year are getting new tenants who just reno/fix places up and then move on? Also, don't know if anyone or your partners are into HGTV style shows about house hunts and stuff - but man, most of them take place in the states in places like Tennesee, CA, NC etc... and it's like young couples going shopping or doing renos to decide to buy new or sell and they're throwing 100k at something or buying new at 200-400k. That's a shed in Toronto. I know I know, different income levels/rates/healthcare/they're in middle of nowhere developments etc... .but man...just adds to the depression.
- shdh 6y agoLook at software engineer salaries in Vancouver, pretty rough.