14 ms·
Major employers scrap plans to cut back on offices – KPMG
- kjjjjjjjjjjjjjj 6y agoWhatever you say, KPMG.
- dv_dt 6y agoJust in time for the next covid wave brewing with new variants. I've seen system dynamics and epidemiologists refer to western gov't pandemic strategies as yoyo policy. I feel like it's a 50/50 race of vaccines vs variants. And part of it is an irrational level of resistance to change.
- maxharris 6y agoThis reads more like consultants writing their FUD into a press release than actual news. I know that people and companies invested heavily in real estate are disappointed by this, but no amount of astroturfing is going to re-create the world of 2019. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, nonfarm business labor productivity rose by over 10% over the course of 2020, despite the fact that most of us are working from home. (Source: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/prod2.pdf https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/prod2.pdf) Companies that want to waste huge sums of money on offices are going to have to compete with companies that don't abuse their employees, doing the same thing for less. We're obviously not going back to how things were before.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoYeah, but they're surveying CEO's. CEO's want all the little people back in the office so they can have their minions back.
- trhway 6y agoYou look at a multi-day Slack discussion with big architects and PMs without any progress... In the old days it would be a series of important meetings where those important people would be making important face and saying important sounding words. There would still be no progress, yet there would be the feeling like the progress is being made. Slack makes it so obvious. We're definitely going back to offices :)
- helge9210 6y ago> You look at a multi-day Slack discussion with big architects and PMs without any progress... This. Written communication makes it obvious that some people have nothing meaningful to say it have trouble with reading comprehension.
- trhway 6y agoand even more important aspect - without offices there isn't jet-setting across the world nor fat expense accounts. The only thing left for CEOs and all the other execs is to actually do their job which is their least favorite activity and which they usually are hardly capable at performing.
- goatinaboat 6y agoCEO's want all the little people back in the office so they can have their minions back. Management have no idea as noted here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26547499 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26547499
- bhupy 6y ago> According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, nonfarm business labor productivity rose by over 10% over the course of 2020, despite the fact that most of us are working from home. I’d push back on this claim with another piece of relevant data: employee mental health has plunged [1][2]. While it’s true that productivity has increased, it’s not obvious that this is sustainable. [1] https://www.hibob.com/blog/covid-19-employee-wellness-survey/ https://www.hibob.com/blog/covid-19-employee-wellness-survey... [2] https://www.kff.org/policy-watch/both-remote-and-on-site-workers-are-grappling-with-serious-mental-health-consequences-of-covid-19/ https://www.kff.org/policy-watch/both-remote-and-on-site-wor...
- cl0ckt0wer 6y agoSo employers get a productivity boost and cost savings if they sacrifice their employee's mental health? I'd love to believe we live in a world where that would stop them.
- bhupy 6y agoI mean, the technology industry (especially FAANG) aren’t exactly known for sacrificing long-term growth for the sake of short-term penny-pinching in the context of employee happiness. Any company that (pre-COVID) had a proclivity to sacrifice short-term profits by providing free food and other generous onsite perks is probably also a company that might choose to scrap plans to cut back on offices if doing so has a positive impact on their employees’ mental health.
- daggerdrone 6y agoAlso, it is possible that employees were putting in extra effort so that they won't be one getting laid off in case their company decides to do a layoff. It was a scary environment in the beginning with a layoff being announced almost every day.
- jsight 6y agoI'm not sure that I'd correlate remote work with that during a year like this last one.
- 6y ago
- wbl 6y agoThe productivity numbers, unlike inflation, don't compensate for basket shifts. So if people stop putting on low productivity things like plays productivity rises but it isn't real.
- fractionalhare 6y agoYour cited source also shows 10.9% more hours worked and only 0.8% more hourly compensation (and -1.6% real compensation) comparing Q4 2019 to Q4 2020. Does the data show whether people are more productive because they are happier living more flexible lives at home, or because they simply have worse work life balance? Does it show whether these changes are roughly homogenous, or if there are pockets swinging up (down) the mean hours worked (compensation)? What's the variance? You can levy a dozen counterfactuals at the use of BLS data like this to support permanent WFH. The analysis needs to be way more holistic and BLS figures aren't nuanced enough.
- pxue 6y agoThere arent any real study on work place transition, productivity, and overall AVERAGE health of employees had been conducted. Even on the smallest scale of sample size, I thrived during the work from home year, yet my SO can't wait to get back to office work where they can socialize with coworkers face to face. Any call for either OR are dramatically overweightted.
- canada_dry 6y agoIt reminds me of how large suit retailers funded "research" regarding 'casual Fridays'. According to them it was just a fad that would soon die. Companies that were quick to embrace open concept office space and cubicles to save expenses are surely going to take advantage of this new paradigm.
- justapassenger 6y agoIt’s not most trustworthy when you accuse someone of lying and then proceeded to cherry pick single statistic, that’s not even from carefully controlled study designed to answer those questions.
- mcclung 6y agoFirst thing I thought was "press hit." (http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html) I've been expecting that certain groups (people who own commercial real estate, for example), were going to want to us all back in our cubicles. Not sure I'm right, of course, but it'll be interesting to see how this plays out over the next couple of years.
- twelve40 6y agoOne question though. Tools to work fully remote have been around for at least 20 years now. Want to work from Montana in 2001? Webex, messengers, version control, DSL internet, everything has been there for decades. We also have precedents of major projects (say, open source) shipped by distributed teams since that long, too. Yet, pre-Covid very, very few companies have actually figured out remote. Why? Is it because companies are slow and stupid? Google doesn't seem stupid. Why have they been paying $500k comp in the Bay Area all this time when Tennessee or India were right there all along? Maybe they took special pleasure in pointlessly overpaying and abusing their employees, as you call it?
- goatinaboat 6y agoTools to work fully remote have been around for at least 20 years now. Want to work from Montana in 2001? Longer. Guy I know was perfectly happily WFH running X11 over dual-bonded ISDN a decade before that!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- helge9210 6y ago> Want to work from Montana in 2001? Webex, messengers, version control, DSL internet, everything has been there for decades I started WFH the moment DSL became available in my area in 2003. Was switching to WFH at every work place over commute became unbearable.
- matwood 6y agoI think it's hard to use FAANGs for general trends like this. Google for example in part hires people to keep them from going elsewhere or building a competing company. One of Google's big perks to lure these people is all of the onsite amenities. Google and the other big tech companies are unique in a lot of ways, and in no way represent the average company in the US or even in tech though. What will be interesting is if WFH (I like to say Freedom of Work) continues to take hold, will companies like Google have to adjust or be ok missing out on employees?
- paleotrope 6y agoI feel like there is something missing from this piece.
- sys_64738 6y agoIt's hard to micromanage if you're working from home.
- Guthur 6y agoIt's difficult to manage full stop. Not necessarily impossible. There is a role for good leadership within a corporation. Part of that is to ensure that organisational system is working together towards the quality achievement of a common aim. This is difficult at the best of times but remote working adds additional challenges and if you thought leaders were struggling before how do you think they'll fair with the additional challenge.
- fireeyed 6y agoThis has gotta be a PR piece by Commercial Real Estate interests. I bet they are offering “multi year lease discounts” to lure the company property divisions. This pandemic has proved and reinforced the notion that all knowledge work can be performed remotely and more efficiently. The other class of workers don’t need offices: manufacturing, food services, maintenance you name it.
- rbranson 6y agoThis is the cited source from KPMG: https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2021/03/ceo-outlook-pulse.html https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2021/03/ceo-outlook-pu...
- kristopolous 6y ago> "Just 17% of chief executives plan to cut back on offices, down from 69% in the last survey in August." Really it's up to us to make that our choice and not theirs.
- SrslyJosh 6y ago> “Either downsizing has already taken place, or plans have changed as the impact of extended, unplanned, remote working has taken a toll on some employees,” KPMG said. So...they don't know which it is. Great article, Reuters.
- phillipcarter 6y agoI don't share the pessimism over the office that many commenters here share, despite largely preferring home office work. Many people don't prefer remote work, and they have good reasons for it. Even ignoring all people who are impacted by factors they cannot control, some people really just don't so well in a home office environment. The routine and structure of going into the office to do work and coming home to not do work is pleasant for many people. Some folks don't have good control over their work behaviors when they're not in that environment. They thrive more in an in-person environment. I'm willing to bet that's a lot of your coworkers. There's a good chance that you'll need a lot of stuff to support people coming back to the office if it's anything more than a small fraction. If 50% of your workforce actually prefers to come into the office every day, that's a lot of investment! I would naiively expect that to support 50% of your workforce you'd need to invest more than 50% of what you used to invest to support the in-office work environment. I'm thinking bigger firms here, the ones that actually spend a lot of money on this stuff. And lastly I'm just not convinced that businesses actually act based solely on hard figures. The math may point towards it being advantageous to have a more remote or distributed workforce, but the world doesn't run on people following "the math". People are messy and irrational and emotional and, critically, in key leadership roles that drive what the heck their company is actually going to do. Have a handful of executives who can't wait to get back into their comfort zone - the office - and that office spending budget will find a way to get spent.
- ryandrake 6y ago> Many people don't prefer remote work, and they have good reasons for it. It’s almost as if some people prefer one way and others prefer the other way! Which is why WFH advocates just want the option. They aren’t asking for everyone to have to WFH, just for the choice. The back-to-office advocates however want to go back to office and force everyone else to go back to office. This is the difference in approaches. They don’t want people to have a choice—they want it their way for everyone.
- internet2000 6y agoWFH advocates will quickly say they're disadvantaged in career development in a hybrid approach, so no, they want everyone to have to WFH.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe big challenge to remote work is that the types who become managers and make decisions are social types.
- stuaxo 6y agoThere are shit loads of people who own expensive offices, in London that includes Russian oligarchs, no wonder so many stories are out saying people want to come back to the office - they don't.
- dwaltrip 6y agoSpeak for yourself... I want to go back to the office. I would prefer some flexibility to work from home a day or two per week, but I enjoy the structure of working in an office as well as collaborating and socializing in person with colleagues. Perhaps in the future that will change. But for now that is how I feel about the situation. P.S. I didn’t read the article, so I can’t comment on that. I was just reacting to the ridiculous statement that no one wants to work in an office.
- globular-toast 6y agoSocialise in your own time. That's not work and you shouldn't be getting paid for it. I know people like to believe work gets done like the stock photos of diverse people in suits laughing. It doesn't. If work was about laughing literally anyone could do it. Many people go to offices every day and do literally nothing.
- throwaway53453 6y agoSorry, but no. Work is supposed to work for me, as well as me working for it. Some people might be fine with perfect compartmentalization of work, but I would find it soul crushing to just be a corporate machine for 8 hours a day.
- globular-toast 6y agoThen don't work for a big corporation. I work for a small company from home. My work is interesting and varied and I don't have the time to socialise, even if I wanted to. I get to spend more time with my family instead. My company does have an office, though, and I don't live more than an hour away. I will go into the office for some things, like whiteboard planning meetings, training and other things. It's going in every day for the very few times it's actually beneficial that I can't stand.
- baron_harkonnen 6y ago> Most chief executives said they wanted vaccination rates to exceed half the population before they started to encourage staff back to the office - a target which is close to being met in Britain but remains distant in much of Europe. I know we've collectively decided we're done with reality and annoying things like "facts" but that target is no where near met by Britain. The UK has decided to aggressively give everyone first doses of vaccines, and it is true that nearly 50% of the population has their first dose, but a fraction of that has received the second dose, precisely because of the aggressive 1st dose strategy. Sure it's possible that one dose is enough, but my cynical guess is that getting everyone one dose is primary so the UK can show up in statistics like the one quoted above. UK data source for anyone interested [0] 0. https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations
- dghf 6y ago> my cynical guess is that getting everyone one dose is primary so the UK can show up in statistics like the one quoted above. I'm sure that's part of the reason, but there is evidence that a single dose provides substantial protection against getting the disease badly enough to hospitalise or kill you: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/feb/22/scotland-covid-vaccination-drive-linked-to-big-drop-in-hospital-admissions https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/feb/22/scotland-covid... So this may be a case of something that is both politically expedient and genuinely beneficial.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI'm sure many of them signed multiyear leases, bought property and made investments in the workplace that they don't want to see go to waste.
- ryandrake 6y agoMy company has promised to do some nebulous studies about remote work and productivity and decide the WFH / back to office question based on the data, but it’s exceedingly clear from how they are talking that there will only be one conclusion possible from these “studies”: that everyone will be forced to come back to the office. They could find a 50% productivity increase but it won’t matter. All the top execs are utterly dogmatic about in-person and there can be only one conclusion possible.
- pbuzbee 6y agoThis, I feel, is the issue: The decision makers don't want to work from home themselves. It doesn't have the same appeal that it does for individual contributors, and having employees out of sight is almost unthinkable. There are certainly going to be exceptions, but anyone wanting to work remotely permanently will have an uphill battle.
- georgebarnett 6y agoWhat I find most interesting is how people who love working from home can't seem to understand how their own circumstances don't translate for others. This bias seems especially present in a subset of the tech population. If you think offices are going away, you're betting against decades of history where people work together in meatspace. If you think they do that because they can't get their work done virtually, you've fundamentally misunderstood both humans and also many of their own life circumstances. Some people _in some industries_ can work from home. For many, that's not feasible. There is no "one way".
- joe_the_user 6y agoI'm not an advocate for work from home. The thing about covid is that it forced employers and employees to discover what was practical for work-from-home. And you may well find for some employers, work-from-home being practical is enough. Work-from-home doesn't have to be great or even good. Offices are incredibly expensive. Between not paying for office space and being able to hire anyone from around the world, the virtual organization gives the employer a lot of pluses that they can use to offset the negatives. And if in a given circumstances, this only works for some people. Well, they can hire replacements for the people it doesn't work for. It seems like this will happen unless something stops it.
- bobthepanda 6y agoAt least in the US, there has been moaning for a decade going on two about how hard it is to hire qualified people at current salaries in STEM. If you fire all the people who don’t like WFH backfilling them is not going to be easy, and even if you did that’s probably a good chunk of tribal knowledge lost.
- globular-toast 6y agoIt will be easy if they hire people for those salaries from anywhere in the world. The only reason it's hard now is because they require them to live in SV which not everyone can do.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoOur company is still trying to decide, but there clearly is a push to get mostly everyone back in the office. Most recent communication from CEO left a speck of hope for some fully remote positions ( and pre-covid, it was basically treated as a reward for some employees ), but it was very light on details. Both me and my manager love remote and we are both doing what we can to show that remote works for the company. That said, I fully agree it is not for everyone. My wife absolutely hated it. I just wish some middle management practice was not forced upon me, when it is clear it is not needed. They already monitor everything I do with software. Why do they need my physical body?
- flukus 6y agoMy anecdotal and unscientific evidence that the world will go back to offices is that I'm interviewing lately and interviews have started returning to in office. This is in an area that legal office capacity will only return to 100% next week. Interviewing works well remotely and has an incredibly high travel/task ratio it seemed like a no brainer to keep them going remotely but alas.
- alkonaut 6y agoEven if people just go from 5 office days per week to 4, that’s a reduction in office use by say 20% (in reality slightly less because at 4 days/week in office I’d want a personal desk which I wouldn’t at 1-2 days/week, but on the other hand a few days a week I’d be fine with sitting in a shared space as I can focus when I’m at home). The question isn’t how many companies will “go remote”, it’s what fraction of the week people will be remote on average. What happens to the market for office space of demand drops 20% in a year? I think the idea of 100% in office for no other reason than “managers like the idea of seeing people work” is dead. Some companies will keep this policy but those companies will be at a huge disadvantage in recruiting.
- masonic 6y agoa reduction in office use by say 20% Only if people stagger their off days equally across the week. If instead everybody takes Friday off, you still need the same office capacity Monday-Thursday.
- alkonaut 6y agoYes and if people still want personal desks, it's 0% regardless. In reality the figure will be somewhere between 0 and 20%. But 1 day/week sounds very low imo.
- wccrawford 6y agoBefore Covid, we had gone to 1 remote day per week, with half the people on Monday and the other half on Friday. We had 1 fully remote person in IT, and a few in Sales. We had already decided not to go 2 remote days, though we had seriously considered it. That left us somewhat prepared for Covid. I think fully remote has gone better than expected, but I'm pretty sure we'll end up with an office again and 1 remote day.
- sgt101 6y agoWe broke our lease in May, we'll get a new office, but it'll be 1/3 of the size of the old one - and mostly meeting rooms. The open plan will be small, sparsely populated and flexdesks only. We have grown 18% this year.
- imgabe 6y agoI spent most of 2020 working from home, for the first time in 16 years of working. I surprised myself by finding that I don't really like working from home. I have a decent home office setup: dedicated room, nice chair, big monitor, but I still don't get as much done as going to a different physical place that's dedicated to work. I think what I hated was not the office, but the open office, which is truly awful. I started a new job and now I have an office to go. I'm currently sharing with a couple people (who are rarely there) and soon will have a dedicated private office. It's a world of difference. I think most people who hate the office really hate: open offices, long commutes, being required to be there for specific times. If you could get rid of those most people probably wouldn't mind and might even prefer the office.
- mattowen_uk 6y agoI'm struggling with your comment. What's the difference between the dedicated room you have at home, and the dedicated office at work, which you state is mainly empty except for you? Is it a mindset thing? You just can't get into a 'work' mode whilst at home? I'm totally in the other camp - I love working from home, and have been home-based for over 4 years now (dedicated room and set-up etc.). The only difference that covid has brought, is that my partner is now also work-from-home, which interestingly has impacted my productivity somewhat; We prefer to just sit around and chat, than focus on work - It now takes a bit more effort to get my head down and focus. :) All that said, I'd still not want to go back into an office. Here in London, this means over an hour commute each way, on typically standing-room only trains, and then 8 hours in noisy open-plan with tiny desks, and your stuff kept in a locker. Ultimately it's down to choice: Going forwards I'd like to see companies offer the choice of working in the office, or working from home. That way everyone can work in a location that suits them best.
- dagw 6y agoI too have come to realize that I in many ways miss the office. The main thing is the clear separation between home and work both mentally and physically. At work I had my work desk with my work computer and work files and my work stuff. At home I had my home desk and home computer. When at home I could not (easily) access my work computer or work files. When at work I could not access my home computer and home files. It made it easy to compartmentalize the two and stop one bleeding into the other. There was something definitive about walking out of the office for the day that I kind of miss. I also liked my 'commute', which was either a 20 minute bus ride or a 50ish minute walk. It gave me a chance to clear my head, refocus and switch 'modes'. Going forwards I'd like to see companies offer the choice Obviously agree. As much as I really do miss the office, I hope to never again have a job where I am forced to be there 5 days a week.
- midasz 6y agoI love working from home, especially not missing the commute. The only times I've thought 'damn I wish we could be in an office right now' is when: - Refining stories, it's a bit easier to read peoples body language. Not everyone is super outspoken which is required when you're in a videocall. - Retrospectives, also a bit harder to do online - though the tools are genuinely improving. - Working together on architectural issues. Me and a colleague were using draw.io to think up a design and it just wasn't as easy as standing in front of a whiteboard together. I really miss that.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoI save about 2 hours a day by not commuting. I wouldn't mind commuting a day or two during the week, but there's no way I'm going back to 5 days a week in the office.
- Aeolun 6y agoWhat I’ve found is that I really enjoy going to the office, as long as the majority of my co-workers are not there. Now that nobody comes into the office due to COVID, I can finally get something done there, and the view is fantastic. But a little while ago, when 4 people came into the office on the same day, I very quickly found myself longing for home, even though that’s still less than 4% capacity.
- matwood 6y agoHaha. It's weird huh? A noisy office bugs me, but the hum (sound and activity) of a coffee shop puts me into a deep focus.
- blunte 6y agoHere’s an idea - try to allow the worker to work where they feel happiest and most productive. Have a decent office for those who like going in, and allow some to work remotely.
- fx32s 6y agoI'm curious to the longer term effects of companies that move hybrid setups. It would seem to me (although anecdotically) that in this setup working fully remote might hinder career growth due to visibility and being less involved in new projects and ideas. It's also easier to form a bond with colleagues f2f compared to over a VC.
- mempko 6y agoThere is a simple and powerful argument why we should never go back to offices. Climate Change.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoI feel like there's a lot of people here that really hate going back to the office because they already moved out of location and are desperate to avoid any commute if possible. There can be balance.It's not one or the other.
- mavhc 6y agoEveryone worked from home 200 years ago, and worked every day of the week
- benja123 6y agoThis makes a lot of sense. I don’t think offices are going to disappear but instead companies will mostly move to a hybrid approach where you are expected to be in the office 2-3 times a week. Most companies and a large amount of their employees were never able to make the jump to remote work mode. That is, they were trying to recreate the office experience while working remotely. The result of this is employees that are exhausted from being on zoom all day and a complete disappearance of work life balance. Moreover I suspect that the lack of in person meetings has also led to a lot of cases of misalignment and in some cases even conflict between different teams. Management sees this and they also get a lot of requests from employees that want to go back to the office which leads them to the conclusion that remote isn’t the best long term solution. But like I said, this isn’t the fault of remote work but instead the result of companies not adjusting to a remote work mode. With the hybrid approach they will get the best of both worlds. People will be able to have “meeting” days and “maker” days, which should lead to an increase in productivity without burning out the employees. At least that is the theory, only time will tell.
- MereInterest 6y agoI see the hybrid model as being the worst of both worlds. Your house/apartment needs to have a room dedicated to working, just as if you were fully remote. However, you still need to live within commuting distance of the physical office, so you can't take advantage of working from somewhere with a lower cost of living.
- ghaff 6y agoI assume most people will be allowed to come in every day or most days if they want to. On the other hand, if something like a 4 fay home-1 day office model is commonplace, I'd also expect a lot of companies to switch to hoteling type seating arrangements. And an arrangement where you have to come in on a weekly basis is certainly going to be much less attractive for remote workers who want to move to lower cost, mountain town, beach, etc.
- pbuzbee 6y agoI agree. The big appeal of remote work for me personally is the option to move somewhere that I can afford. A hybrid approach doesn't offer that.
- swiley 6y agoMine certainly isn't going back any time soon and it's partly because people would leave if they did.
- dpflan 6y agoThere isn’t much to this article. The ads on that page take up more space than the article. So the comments here are much more useful. They interviewed large firms: what is the breakdown at the industry and country-location levels? These large (publicly traded?) firms need to send messages of confidence and “normalcy”. It’s clear that some types of work are better with fewer people around, some require more people. Collocated people can communicate very well. Whatever helps add predictability to these large firms will be adopted.
- hnedeotes 6y ago"You can't teach an old dog new tricks" - Lassie
- AzzieElbab 6y agoCorporate world is too fragile. Many office towers are used as collateral for loans. Low occupancy can trigger re-evaluations. I can only imagine political pressure in places like nyc and sf
- francisofascii 6y agoMy company put out a survey. (not a software company, but leans toward engineering staff) 5% wanted to return to 5 days, 5% never wanted to come to the office again, most wanted to come in as needed, or 2-3 days a week.
- unixhero 6y agoKPMG is not an authoritative source on this.
- itbeho 6y agoAs the pandemic eases, I suspect we'll see a bigger return to the office than expected. The biggest driver will be human nature. Political machinations that work in person for self gain do not necessarily work with WFH. I'm already hearing some FOMO as people that work in the office are promoted over people working remotely.
- splistud 6y agoI've hired, developed and promoted roughly 300 people in my career (including those who left for a better job at other orgs). I don't mind WFH co-workers, or the extra work that they make for me when it comes to managing them. I can not, however, help them develop their talents as fast as those I can interact with physically. Therefore, I can not promote them as quickly, or perhaps at all. I suspect I'm not alone.
- francisofascii 6y agoWhat extra work are you referring to? The need to setup video calls?
- salmonlogs 6y ago“Either downsizing has already taken place” - direct quote from the article. And they are comparing the reduction between August last year and today. I would conclude this means companies planning to downsize already have done. The companies who were not really planning to are still not going to do it. This also matches my personal experience and that of my friends and professional network.