32 ms·
Nuclear power looks to regain its footing 10 years after Fukushima
- RobertRoberts 6y agoI think there is a targetted campaign to push nuclear... even on this site. The personal attacks start as soon as you start asking the hard questions. Like how much actual permanent storage is required for the most toxic substance humans have ever tried to store, who pays for it, the perpetual risks.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoI see it too. I have an eye for it as a Chernobyl affected. Every other day there is an article downplaying the risks.
- grecy 6y agoI love how the downvotes and lack of meaningful replies on your comment prove your point perfectly.
- partingshots 6y agoA lot of hedge funds don’t really have the ability to find their own investing ideas so they just copy and pile on to existing trades. Nuclear is their attempt at creating something, which I might mention is expressly opposite the vision of something that Tesla with its batteries represent.
- KMag 6y agoCare to expand on this? It sounds like you're saying hedge fund managers are jealous of Elon Musk's creativity, so they decided to push for more nuclear reactors, so they could feel some ownership in the ideas. Am I misunderstanding you?
- partingshots 6y agoPretty much actually. They lost a shit ton of money shorting Tesla. It might surprise you how much ego there is in investing.
- KMag 6y agoI'm still not connecting the dots. If nuclear succeeds, then it makes Elon look bad? Buying nuclear stocks doesn't help the nuclear companies unless they're making secondary offerings. If nuclear success makes Elon look bad, then maybe VC funding would be the way to go, but I'm not sure there's much overlap between people with influence in VC funds and hedge fund managers who were big Tesla shorts. Something really doesn't make sense here, but there aren't enough details in your post to tell if fund managers are really being that irrational, or if the post itself just doesn't make sense.
- partingshots 6y agoThe future that is envisioned in a scenario where Tesla wins is batteries as the base load energy supply. The push for nuclear, with the goal of becoming the base load instead, is meant to subvert and supplant that narrative.
- KMag 6y agoThat part I kind of understand. However, I'm having trouble seeing the strings by which the puppet masters manipulate the marionettes. These hedge fund managers who shorted Tesla... they're trying to bring about a nuclear future... buy buying already issued nuclear-related stocks? Have there been any big secondary stock offerings in the nuclear industry lately? Are the puppet masters buying up corporate debt instruments in large volumes? If they're calling in favors from journalists, why do journalists owe them favors? I'm willing to believe the players on the stage are marionettes, but I need to be told where to look for the strings so I can see them for myself. Exactly how are these sour Tesla shorts pushing nuclear?
- thrower 6y agoLet’s say I believe you. Do you have any proof?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xupybd 6y agoI don't like the idea of attacks, but I would refute the idea that nuclear waste is an unsolvable problem. It is a difficult problem. The long term cost of nuclear has to be weighed against the long term cost of not using it. That cost will be significantly more carbon emissions. Quantifying the magnitude of the problem created by those emissions is hard. Then trying to estimate at what point do affordable renewables backed with good affordable storage options come online. As it would only be in that in between time that nuclear would have a significant impact on carbon emissions. It's not about picking a harmless option, it's about finding the least harmful.
- krasin 6y agoI didn't downvote and not an activist of any kind (even if there's a campaign, I am not a part of it). But I am very pro-nuclear, so would like to respond to the second half of your message: the nuclear waste problem. This is a real problem. Three ways to address. 1. One I don't like, but that's widely deployed: create remote storage facilities and just store it there. This is what's done now, it works, but the costs are pretty high. What's worse, store a tonne once, pay for it forever. 2. One I like a lot and it's getting adoption in Russia: they built light-water reactors that work on nuclear waste ([1]). So, same fuel is used twice and the results are much less dangerous. What's good is that these reactors can run on anyones waste and Russia already imports nuclear waste from Europe. 3. The third option is funny: it might become viable in the next decade. Ship it to the Moon. The math is simple: 1 kg of fuel generates about $5000. If Starship makes the cost of shipping <$500, it would be a no-brainer to ship it all to the Moon. Theoretically, it can also be used as fuel there (see point 2) to generate power for moon bases. In the short term, option 2 looks pretty reasonable to me. 1. https://world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Russia-proposes-new-closed-fuel-cycle https://world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Russia-proposes-new-...
- andbberger 6y agoIt's not a real problem. There really isn't that much high-level nuclear waste and we have a problem with classifying too many things as high-level waste in the US. For the little actual high-level waste that is produced it's a pretty viable medium-term solution just to leave it onsite at the power plant. The long-term solution is obvious: you bury it in a deep unmarked hole, duh. This has been done [1]. Say it with me, there is no nuclear waste problem. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repository https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repo...
- pfdietz 6y agoDon't bury it. The biggest problem with that is the heat builds up. Just keep it near the surface, where the heat can be dissipated. In 300 years, the fission products are mostly gone (except for 7 "long lived fission products" with halflives in the 10^5 years or longer), so the waste is much easier to reprocess or otherwise dispose of. The problem then is that the radioactivity has dropped so much that amateur diversion of plutonium becomes a concern.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> the most toxic substance humans have ever tried to store That is actually wrong. We have stores far more deadly stuff such as chemical and biological weapons. In addition, the waste gets less deadly with time. So after a few decades or so, the most deadly waste has decayed. You can actually swim at the top of a nuclear containment pool without much adverse effects. https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/
- Turing_Machine 6y ago> So after a few decades or so, the most deadly waste has decayed. Yes. "Long half-life" = "less radioactive". By definition.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoBut a lot of people don't get that. They hear, "nuclear waste from nuclear plant is highly deadly because it is radioactive. It could kill you in minutes." Then they hear, "Nuclear waste from nuclear plants will be radioactive for thousands of years." They then assume, "Nuclear waste from nuclear plants is highly deadly and could kill you within minutes for thousands of years."
- drran 6y agoYeah, in reality, nuclear waste needs years to kill you. It's predicted that 65 000 people will die by 2005 due to radioactive poisoning by Chornobyl disaster. Radiation is SLOOOOOOOW.
- godelski 6y agoI've always thought that this argument really shows a lack of education more than anything. People do not understand the simple principle that you cannot have a highly radioactive substance and it be long living at the same time (this is because radiation is the process of matter being expelled from the atoms. Higher radiation levels, more matter/energy being expelled). But it also shows that people don't understand that things that things can also be dangerous and have no half life. Like lead and heavy metals don't decay and there are no safe levels of heavy metals.
- yongjik 6y ago> Like how much actual permanent storage is required for the most toxic substance humans have ever tried to store, ... Huh really? Didn't know nuclear waste contains botox! Sorry for the glib answer, but this is the biggest problem with anti-nuclear sentiments. Phrases like "most toxic substance" or "perpetual risks" doesn't mean much unless you quantify exactly how much of this toxic substance we're talking about. Botox is 320,000 times more toxic than plutonium (according to Wikipedia), and we inject it under our skin.
- bamboozled 6y agoYour lips won't melt off and die if you inject botox under your skin though.
- fuoqi 6y agoHave your lips melted down from the last banana which you have ate? Or from water which you have drunk? Surprise! The former contains noticeable amount of radioactive potassium-40 and the latter contains radioactive tritium.
- bamboozled 6y agoBut you know that it's different.
- fuoqi 6y agoHow so? Same as with botox what matters is concentration. And public fear of radiation is significantly overblown compared to what is logically warranted. We can see this induced fear at work in Fukushima, where they can't dump into ocean water which was filtered from all radioactive isotopes but tritium, even though its concentration is relatively small. For example, if you dump all this water into ocean, it's calculated that in one year an average Japanese will get a dose equal to 0.8 µSv, which is approximately equal to how much you regularly get from natural sources in just 3 hours. If anything I think that heavy metal poisoning is much more dangerous and nasty. I am quite sure that it has caused orders of magnitudes more damage to the world's population than all human-created radiation combined (not counting the US nuclear bombing of Japan). But you don't hear much about it compared to the damage caused by radiation, do you?
- andbberger 6y agoThere's been a concerted campaign against nuclear energy since its conception that has been incredibly successful and pervades even tech-literate forums such as this one. I think people like me are just very frustrated that negativity about nuclear energy abounds, when there isn't any basis in fact for it and it's pretty much our only hope to make meaningful progress towards limiting climate change. Think of it as akin to anti-maskers. Of course you're going to get a lot of push back. Not only is it wrong, it's an ideology that kills people. Oh, and to answer your question: "The U.S. generates about 2,000 metric tons of used fuel each year This number may sound like a lot, but it’s actually quite small. In fact, the U.S. has produced roughly 83,000 metrics tons of used fuel since the 1950s—and all of it could fit on a single football field at a depth of less than 10 yards." [1] [1] https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-nuclear-fuel https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-...
- calibas 6y agoThe first thing human beings did after discovering nuclear energy was use it for mass murder, and we're still using it to create weapons. Everybody knows this, everybody knows about Chernobyl and Fukushima. I don't know how anybody can believe the resistance to nuclear is purely out of ignorance. That's crossing the line into industry propaganda, not to mention the whole line about nuclear energy being our only hope towards solving climate change... Edit: Might as well mention another huge issue with nuclear power. Why is the waste being buried on Native American reservations, where it's not subject to the same health and safety regulations?
- Turing_Machine 6y ago> The first thing human beings did after discovering nuclear energy was use it for mass murder, and we're still using it to create weapons. Unlike fire, which of course has never been used to kill anybody.
- godelski 6y agoUnlike fertilizer, which of course gas never been used to kill anybody. (FWIW it isn't hard to argue that fertilizer has saved more lives than any other technology. But nitrates are also how you make bombs...)
- random5634 6y agoOne thing that's very striking to me is the anti-nuclear folks have managed to strand something like 400,000 TONS of nuclear waste in temporary facilities. These are often surprisingly high risk (on large time scales) with many other negatives. There is obviously a lot less high level waste, but the point generally holds. Addressing the nuclear waste storage issue has value. Credible science I've seen suggests current approaches are poor relative to almost all other options. I also like repossessing, and other countries do this (most spent US fuel has actually a huge amount of remaining life). US fuel is generally a solid that is more controllable, repossessing can create some high level by products that require vitrification as I understand it and the US doesn't have that as well established. There are folks looking at ultra deep burial, below water tables in rock stable for millions of years. That's also interesting. We are arguably facing a relatively pressing current issue with global warming. Nuclear does not have a lot of GHG emissions relatively. It seems we should be spending reasonable sums at least on research and perhaps very small scale demonstrator plants and waste options to see if anything can be proven out.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoI have felt this for a long time online any time nuclear is brought up. It’s very uncanny valley feeling. I can tell the difference between people that like nuclear and people that are paid to really like nuclear and attack anyone that says otherwise. What entity would pay for this online nuclear army I wonder?
- spfzero 6y agoWhat entity indeed? Is the nuclear industry so flush with excess profits that it could fund a massive propaganda campaign? Or is there an industry, awash with decades of profits, who might be threatened by nuclear because it is carbon free (in comparison) and the only viable, always on, competitor? If there is someone being paid, they are paid by petroleum.
- godelski 6y agoI'm legitimately interested in your conspiracy. Who is pushing this agenda and why? The companies that used to develop power-plants have declared bankruptcy long ago. To me it would make sense that people that actually have money would push their agendas instead. I seriously am interested in your conspiracy, no joke.
- akvadrako 6y agoI don't think it's a conspiracy; most smart people have supported it for decades, it's just taking the public a long time to catch on. However it's easy to imagine groups that would be willing to pay troll farms to bump up support. 1. There are a bunch of companies developing new reactors. 2. There are a lot of people who think fossil fuels are dangerous and see nuclear as the only path forward. 3. Maybe someone just wants to drum up controversy. The thing is buying trolls isn't that expensive. I once got 500 twitter followers for $5. I bet for $500 you could get thousands of fake comments across the web.
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoPretty much any "social media marketing" firm would take money to shill some ideas online. There are many ways to do so, including sock puppet accounts and paid commenters. Every time the topic comes up here different accounts repeat many similar strawman talking points.
- godelski 6y ago> I think there is a targetted campaign to push nuclear... even on this site. I'm not trying to call conspiracy but I was a bit surprised that this is the third nuclear post on the front page in the last two weeks. Usually we do like once every few months. I came to this thread wondering why there's so much nuclear talk lately.
- saalweachter 6y agoI assume it's because there's a general impression that the Biden administration is, if not pro-nuclear, a lot more open to the idea of nuclear than a lot of previous administrations. Obviously the President can't just wave his hand a cause a few dozen new reactors to spring up in the US, and four years may not be enough time to make a committed push that can't be quickly reversed by the next administration, but that's what's got everyone who's interested in nuclear so excited. Heck, the URA ETF is up 70% since the election, from the low it had been hanging around since Fukushima.
- dang 6y agoNuclear is a popular topic on HN. Randomness contains sequences that don't feel random. That's all you need to explain three posts in two weeks.
- godelski 6y agoI realized what it was like right after I wrote this commend, anniversary of Fukushima. I didn't think it was a conspiracy (come on, we've talked a few times, I hope you don't think I'm a conspiracy guy). Just was trying to figure out what caused the abnormal uptick and this makes a lot of sense.
- netram88 6y agoI don't see how this can be the case, if you know more than me, please elaborate. My reason for not seeing how this could be the case is that there is no reasonable entity that would be funding this conspiracy. Nuclear has been smeared since Chernobyl, and the nuclear industry barely breaks even. They certainly don't have enough money for something like this. Also, why would this mysterious entity be funding bad faith arguers on internet forums, instead of lobbyists, which would probably be a much more effective way of promoting nuclear.
- CyanBird 6y ago> I don't see how this can be the case, if you know more than me, please elaborate Back in the 70, 80, 90, it was incredibly common for insiders to the energy industry talk of the power pronuclear segments had when it came to dictating policy and how they would use dirty tactics to launder their own image such as with astroturfing or just old media blitz charm campaigns in order to desorient the public when it came to things such as miss management of nuclear plants, or miss management of nuclear waste which continues to this day with rusting tanks holding dangerous waste, and all of this setting aside things like sea dumping of nuclear waste that has wrecked the public face of nuclear energy for the last 50 years
- rurounijones 6y agoThese "hard" questions like vague "What about storage?" are asked and answered so frequently I assume either someone asking them is either not doing any basic research or not asking in good faith. Especially when the questions include language such as "the most toxic substances" and "perpetual" risks. Even more especially when "what about storage" only seems to get asked regarding a small amount of nuclear waste but the _10s of millions_ of annually generated tons of highly toxic coal ash being stored in hilariously unsafe open ponds or landfills seems to be the baseline we are happy with as a society.
- dang 6y agoYou broke the site guidelines badly with this and it set off a flamewar, which is just what we're trying to avoid on this site. I realize it wasn't arson but that was major negligence. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here. They ask you not to post flamebait and specifically not to post insinuations of organized manipulation/astroturfing, unless you have evidence, in which case you should be emailing hn@ycombinator.com so we can look into it. Other people having different views about nuclear power doesn't count as evidence of anything, other than that the topic is controversial, which we all know. I wrote a whole thing about this yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26414518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26414518 - it's not about nuclear, but you can swap in any topic that people feel strongly about. The mechanism is exactly the same.
- RobertRoberts 6y agoI can say in all honesty that I had not intentions of causing a flamewar. Just pointing out that nuclear power is a _non-renewable_ power source gets downvotes on this site. (100% true fact) I re-read the rules and it looks like the #1 comment on this thread appears to also violate the HN rules. c'est la vie
- MrApathy 6y agoNuclear is one notch above dead, though I'm sure it won't officially die for another few decades. As a former proponent it's hard to argue against the significant advances made by renewables over the past few years. Sure, nuclear makes for a better baseline load, but the regulatory and safety requires of nuclear make the economics difficult, almost easier to just build overcapacity into the renewable generation.
- cpach 6y agoI don’t really understand how wind and sun could totally replace nuclear. How do we get electricity during the night? How do we get electricity when it’s cloudy but the wind is light at the same time?
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoStore the power. Batteries, pump water up into lakes, melt salt, etc.
- kalleboo 6y agoFrom the numbers we saw during the Texas power outage, the amount of batteries required would be mind-boggling. Lots of places do not have the geography required for pumped storage, or it is already fully exploited (building a new dam is also an environmental disaster) Molten salt also still seems to be in it's infancy. The most practical solution I could see today to live without baseline power would be to build a massive inter-continental HVDC grid. Large grids have a tendency to be fragile and have catastrophic failures though.
- godelski 6y agoTo be honest the best probably would be to get small modular reactors (SMRs) into mass production. That would give economies of scale along with other benefits. But we aren't quite there yet. I'd imagine if SMRs became popular larger reactors would as well too.
- yongjik 6y agoI keep thinking discussions are stacked against nuclear unfairly. It's almost as if there are two different arenas to compete: (1) fossil fuels, which is by definition unsexy and ugly, but grandfathered simply because "we need them" now, and (2) everything else, who has to compete against each other on the criteria of "Fine, so we do have fossil fuels, what now?" For example, in 2019, 80% of US energy consumption was from fossil fuels.[1] Natural gas has actually steadily gained market share.[2] In any objective discussion, this should be considered a massive shortcoming and people should be scrambling to find a better solution. However, because fossil fuels only compete against themselves in public discourse, it's still considered a victory because gas replaced coal. And one of the reason gas became so popular? Because renewables are rapidly improving but they're still less reliable, so people need an energy source they can rapidly fire up when necessary. Enter gas. And when people point out that we could be using nuclear instead of gas, they are shut down saying "Ewww, so it's better than fossil fuels, big deal, who cares about that now? Everybody knows fossil fuels are bad!" Nuclear, just by being non-fossil-fuel, is forced to compete in the "cool arena" against renewables, and loses out because it's old, expensive, and has had a series of memorable accidents. All the while these renewable plants are enjoying complementary relationship with gas plants, which is OK, because gas is just gas. [1] https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/ https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_the_United_States#/media/File:History_of_energy_consumption_in_the_United_States.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_the_United_States#/m...
- legulere 6y agoGermany had 46% renewables and 10% gas for electricity production in 2019. The United States have 40% of electricity production from gas. Renewables have nothing to do with the high use of gas in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_of_the_Unit...
- fuoqi 6y agoDon't forget that Germany is part of the same grid or have HVDC links with other European countries such as France (70% nuclear power), Norway (near 100% hydro, not only generation but also storage), and Poland (72% coal), so you you should not take Germany in isolation in such discussions.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Since then about a third of them have been permanently shut down, and only nine have resumed operation. I dont think this is true. As far as I know they are all shut down still.
- simonCGN 6y agoAnd again the propaganda machine is spinning for nuclear disaster. https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2021-03/atomkraft-fukushima-kraftwerk-kernenergie-klimarettung-bill-gates-5vor8/komplettansicht https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2021-03/atomkraft-fukushima-k...
- danlugo92 6y agoPaywall or somrthing (its in german)
- eternalban 6y agoFuushima happened. Chernobyl happened. It is not disaster propaganda. Japan was hit with a disaster. Same with USSR. Nuclear advocates have a tin ear as far as the fact that nuclear failures don't have a theoretical cap on disaster magnitude. It's a simple enough fact. No theoretical limit to the extent of the damage, beyond "end of life on Earth". Even the dreaded fossil fuel business does its mass extinction events at a more manageable tempo. Arugably, there should be conventions against use of any technology that has potential for irreversible harm to the environment.
- sneeuwpopsneeuw 6y agoIn northern Europe its even more insane. Germany is closing 6 nuclear power plants earlier because of what happend after Fukushima. And they will switch to Lignite / brown coal. The energy companies took the state to court because of potential money loss, and they won 2.4 billion euro in damages. Meanwhile in the Netherlands more and more politicians want nuclear energy in the national energy mix because biomass, wind and solar is not growing fast enough to meet the Paris agreement.
- martin_a 6y agoTo be fair: Wind energy and solar has gained a lot of traction in Germany and is producing more and more energy every year. Sadly "the big four" (energy companies) are influencing politics and are actively halting progress on renewables which leads to really strange effects. My landlord installed a rather big solar system on the roof and due to its size, the energy company can decide to remotely shut it off when there's enough energy in the grid. It's really a shame and a lot of corruption is going on there. Also: Little to no research on energy storage was done in the last 25 years, because of all this corruption.
- bluelu 6y agoThere can't be too much or too less electricity in the grid. So it's normal that the power operators can shut off larger producers, as they can also shut off large consumers. This has nothing to do with corruption.
- martin_a 6y ago> This has nothing to do with corruption. In the end it has. Development and building of energy storage systems of any kind was not in the focus in the last decades because nuclear energy and coal was always "the solution" for energy problems and the big four told us not to worry about anything, so they could do their business as usual.
- speedgoose 6y agoThey have to shutdown production if the demand is not high. Once in a while they pay other countries to get their leftover electricity while they shutdown production.
- rob74 6y ago> accelerated a preexisting plan in Germany to completely phase out nuclear power by the end of 2022 That's a bit misleading. This is how it went: - in 2002, the Social-Democrat/Green (Schröder) government decided to phase out nuclear power by 2021. - in 2010, the Christian-Democrat/Liberal (Merkel) government decided to delay that plan. - in 2011, after Fukushima, they made a U-turn, which led to the current phase-out that will (probably) be completed in 2022. (see https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomgesetz_(Deutschland)#Novellierung_2002 https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomgesetz_(Deutschland)#Novel... - in German) So Fukushima didn't accelerate the plan, it actually forced the Merkel government to return to the preexisting plan...
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoIt didn’t force Merkel to do anything. It was just a cheap opportunity to try and grab a few Green votes.
- rob74 6y agoWell yeah, in a democracy popular opinion will force you to do things if you want to win the next election. If you want proof that Merkel's instinct wasn't entirely wrong, you can take a look at the results of the 2013 election: her party (CDU/CSU) gained 7,7 points to 41,5 percent, while the FDP, who were seen as representing the industrial lobby, dropped a whopping 9,8 points to 4,8 percent (and out of the Bundestag, because a party has to get at least 5% to be represented there).
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>in a democracy popular opinion will force you to do things if you want to win the next election Well, there's the problem with our type of democracy. It boils down to a popularity contest instead of a competence one, so politicians will do or say whatever gets them re-elected instead of what's good for the long term being of the country/voters/society. Much like the focus on the "next quarter" of CEOs, that ends up ruining companies long term at the expense of quick profits short term, politicians in the west focus only on the "next election" instead of major issues like housing, education, pensions, demographics, infrastructure, defense, immigration, all of which require long term planning to get right but nobody cares as they just keep kicking the can down the road and hope they won't be in the office by the time shit really hits the fan. And when the shit does eventually hit the fan, whoever will be in office will just blame the predecessors for knowing X was unsustainable and not having done anything about it. Rinse and repeat.
- pietrovismara 6y agoThe truth is, the discussion on nuclear can't be done only on the technical aspects of it, but needs to face and clear its political aspects too. Nuclear as it is today brings centralization (compared to solar/wind) and many don't like that. For example, nobody wants to live close to a nuclear waste deposit, but governments will just force the decision to build one to local populations. There's also the feeling that it will concentrate the power in the hands of a smaller and smaller technical elite. Another matter is that people don't trust neoliberal governments with a tendency to austerity to correctly handle maintenance of nuclear power plants in the long term. After all, with nuclear you just need to fuck up badly once to cause unrepairable damage. If we want nuclear to be adopted, we have to dispell the (justified) fear people have of it. Discussing about it like techno elitists won't certainly help.
- Aachen 6y ago> nobody wants to live close to a nuclear waste deposit I'll repeat what I've said for wind turbines: do my back yard first then. If nobody else wants it, it gotta go somewhere. But I think you're confusing reactors with waste. We want reactors as close to population centres as possible to avoid losses (some distance is fine, but concentrating power generation for Europe in the Sahara would be wasteful, for example), but radioactive waste can be transported just fine. There's very little of it, shipping it to the Sahara isn't a big deal in energy usage terms. Politics is an issue, but there's more uninhabited places we can put it.
- pietrovismara 6y ago> There's very little of it, shipping it to the Sahara isn't a big deal in energy usage terms I wish it was that easy, but that's not a chance in the current political climate. In Italy we're still debating about where to send the waste generated in the '80s. We turned off our last plant in the '87. Every single town involved as a destination for waste storage is in revolt against the decision. Literally nobody wants that waste even dozens of kilometers away from their town. And I totally understand, I don't trust any government (even worse, private contractor), in this economical system and political climate, to correctly maintain such waste storage for the next 300 years. We can barely make consistent plans for the duration of a government.
- Jyaif 6y agoFWIW Jancovici explained the fact that eco "friendly" people dislike nuclear power the following way: The people that are comfortable with progress/technology/industries are usually also comfortable with the idea of nuclear energy. On the other hand people concerned with the environment usually distrust things related to technology and industries, making them distrust nuclear energy.
- Aachen 6y agoSo... I can't like tech and also be worried about the environmental impact of greenhouse gasses? Might this be from a different era, where techies didn't yet know a climate disaster is looming? I don't know who or when this Jancovici was.
- yetihehe 6y agoWhy not liquefy air when electricity is low price, use a heat engine between your liquefied air and your power plant heatsink, then use that now heated/compressed gas as input for a turbine? Plus - you can sell liquefied gases (nitrogen and oxygen).
- rini17 6y agoAir must be filtered and completely desiccated (else the ice clogs everything). Then you need huge cryogenic tank. Also the extra peaker turbine costs something. Efficiency of whole setup is abysmal compared to batteries.
- ggm 6y agoAir storage is actually a thing, drying included. it uses salt domes, or other large underground structures. You can do this when you have the facilities, just as people with thermal can do thermal. Doesn't work everywhere, can work where you have the right conditions. Same for CCS: It can work, with huge if-but-maybe, and is well known to work for oil & gas field injection to increase production. The downsides are fugitive gas release. All attempts at CCS for "clean" coal have turned out to fail, AFAIK (economically, if not practically, but mostly practically: its hard)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kieranmaine 6y agoSee https://www.edie.net/news/8/World-s-biggest-liquid-air-battery-under-construction-in-Greater-Manchester/ https://www.edie.net/news/8/World-s-biggest-liquid-air-batte...
- yetihehe 6y agoExactly, that's what I'm talking about. Batteries are good for just storing electricity, LAES should be even better when you have heat you already need to get rid of (like those big cooling chimneys). In many generators you need to actively get rid of lots of heat, usually it's just dumped. Cogeneration should be much more common.
- sovietmudkipz 6y agoIn my opinion, there are two solutions to USA's energy problem (in relation to climate change). Either... (1) USA bets on nuclear. The real production energy demands can be supplied by nuclear reactors. (2) USA decides to bet on wind and solar. USA then re/opens it's own local rare earth material mines. USA also manufactures all energy collectors locally. All of this is to avoid having to pay the carbon cost of having the raw materials mined in China, and energy collectors shipped over from China to USA. The uninformed opinion doesn't take into consideration raw material extraction, fabrication, and shipping.
- pfdietz 6y agoRenewables don't need rare earths. PV doesn't use them, and wind doesn't require them (there are generators for them that don't use permanent magnets.)
- jpdus 6y agoI get all the pro-nuclear arguments here and really wish that I could agree. However, what most commenters are missing is the real reason, nuclear came out of fashion: economics. Without enormous direct and indirect subsidies, nuclear (fission) isnt commercially viable anywhere in the world (even China, where security or biases in the population arguably play a minor role, is not building nuclear at scale!) . Heck, you still can't insure a fission plant; a state guarantee is implicit. As I wrote in a smililar thread some time ago: Yes, in theory fission would have been the best option for carbon-free energy. No, in practice humanity never figured out how to safely and efficiently use this power source and now renewables are a way safer and cheaper bet. You won't find any objective economic analysis (that incorporates such indirect subsidies as the implicit state guarantee and realistic building and waste handling/storing costs) that can show otherwise. Renewables are already significantly cheaper, even if you incorporate necessary storage costs or DCS grids. Nuclear is only barely competitive when dismissing everything except the direct construction and operation costs which is very misleading.
- zozin 6y agoThis line of thinking would have never made renewables possible.
- phicoh 6y agoAs far as I know, this is not true. On a small scale wind has been profitable for a long time. In The Netherlands, small scale commercial wind turbines go back a long time. As far as I know there were no subsidies back then.
- manderley 6y agoThere's also hydroelectric power, with a very long history of being economically viable.
- bluGill 6y agoEconomically viable because the costs of the land used behind the dams were not nearly as high. Today most of the good places for hydro are already taken, and we have far more concern for the environmental impacts. There is still room for adding hydro, but it isn't as easy as in the past.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIt's already almost too late to stop climate change. If nuclear wants to be part of that push (and base load without carbon is its only real selling point apart from weapons production), it needs to be ready to turn on in the next 5 years. That doesn't seem likely to me.
- wmiel 6y agoOn the other hand phasing out the existing nuclear in favour of natural gas doesn't seem to solve the problem either.
- pfdietz 6y agoIf you add CCS to the natural gas it would. And that would likely be cheaper than nuclear.
- LatteLazy 6y agoAt this point, it seems really unlikely we will "solve" the problem. I suspect we will go with flood defences, water management projects and geo-engineering. So I think it's safest to take the cheapest option. Right now, that seems to be green energy (wind and solar) plus some gas power to deal with intermittent supply.
- simonCGN 6y agoAnd yet another of this scheduled propaganda articles
- cjdell 6y agoI'm surprised no one has mentioned Thorium reactors yet. My understanding is that the fuel is more abundant and that meltdown is impossible, however the technology is still in its infancy.
- mcot2 6y agoMy bet is on fusion. From our sun. https://youtu.be/DB_zSKJDGpU https://youtu.be/DB_zSKJDGpU
- cybert00th 6y ago>the rise of renewable power Hah, yeah right - subsidised to the gills with government grants and other hand outs, then sure, it's on the rise. And yes, of course I know the energy industry generally gets a lot of subsidies. But like many other fads before them, renewables are the darling of the ruling classes, until the next fad comes alo...oh look, bubbles!
- driverdan 6y agoThe negative externalities of carbon-based energy production dwarf any renewal subsidies. See https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2021-03/uos-tmt030121.php https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2021-03/uos-tmt03012...
- orthecreedence 6y ago> The negative externalities of carbon-based energy production dwarf any renewal subsidies. And incidentally, dwarf the cost of building nuclear plants as well.
- pfdietz 6y ago> And incidentally, dwarf the cost of building nuclear plants as well. This is a false statement.
- ttul 6y agoWhat’s missing from this discussion is a carbon price. If carbon were priced at $200/T, nuclear energy and renewables would both be favored over carbon based energy sources.
- zozin 6y agoAre you including mining costs for the metals to create wind turbines and solar panels? The mining costs to create a battery network large enough to have backup power for billions of households? What about the carbon cost of replacing and recycling the batteries? What about the carbon cost of rebuilding/refurbishing the current electrical networks to allow for this green future? What about creating a supply network for transportation where one basically doesn't exist today? Hydrocarbons are 12-15x more energy dense than what current batteries are able to store. A $1 spent today on hydrocarbon production results in 500-600% more energy produced than $1 spent on solar/wind energy production. Green is sexy, but the physics and economics don't support a massive shift to green.
- orthecreedence 6y agoTake your points and try them against nuclear. It wont work. The original argument is solid: the economics are failing us, so change the economics and suddenly nuclear becomes viable. Then you don't have to deal with battery arrays and other silly things.