15 ms·
Why northern Europe is so indebted
- docdeek 6y agoThe first graph is a little hard to read being various shades of grey. The OECD has a color version that is also interactive (select a country, for example): https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-debt.htm https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-debt.htm
- tom_mellior 6y agoAll the graphs in the article are impossible to interpret because axes are not labeled properly.
- Lucasoato 6y agoWhat kind of economic policies could push an European conservative country to this Nordic approach, in order to lower the share of NEETs? Interesting article btw
- sowjetthrowaway 6y agoending the US occupation and US interests in Europe, and creating functional European financial markets.
- amarant 6y agoOne policy that stands out, and makes a lot of intuitive sense is free higher education, and welfare spending targeted towards students. That's what we do in Sweden, and it seems to work well
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoIt's effectively a partial age-limited UBI. You get a subsidy when you're younger. You can use it to educate and train yourself, and/or to experiment with different options. This creates an educated population (good) and the more entrepreneurial types can start businesses without worrying too much about bankruptcy. But permanent studenthood is only a good thing for people with academic talent. So it makes sense to reduce subsidies for the capable as they get older, leaving hardcore welfare support for those can't cope (for various reasons). This kind of mixed approach removes some of the inflationary pressure of full-fat UBI but provides the same social benefits.
- collyw 6y agoThe argument against free higher education is that everyone is subsidising the educated half of society, who will likely be earning more. The poor will be subsidising the middle classes. The UK system is interesting in that you can take out student loans to pay for your education, but you only have to pay it back once you earn a certain amount. If you end up being in a low wage job all your life you never need to pay it back (and you should have probably studied something different).
- phaemon 6y agoExcept, of course, the middle classes are the ones who're paying most of the taxes in the first place, so they're hardly being subsidised by a lower earner who pays very little tax. Also, there is no "UK system" for education. There is an England & Wales system, a Scottish system and a Northern Irish system. They're each managed differently.
- amarant 6y agoOn the contrary, this enables poor people to go to university and stop being poor. As another person noted, where the money is coming from is a separate issue, namely your tax policies. In Sweden the more you earn, the higher percentage of your wages goes to taxes, so at least here it's subsidised by the upper and middle classes more than the lower classes(under a certain wage there is no tax at all, though I can't recall the number right now)
- collyw 6y agoIn what way does the British system I describe stop poor people going to university?
- amarant 6y agoI was mostly answering the first half of your comment, about the poor subsidising the middle class. The UK system is fine, I think subsidies are better, as poor people might feel discouraged to take on more debt, and student debt isn't really desirable for anyone. I don't think people should be in debt by default, neither do I think they should be uneducated by default. That said in Sweden we actually have a combined system of subsidies and special student loans that very much resemble the UK system you describe.
- jusssi 6y agoIn Finland, it's a combination of two things. First, there's near-free education. Second, an under 25yo person is not eligible for unemployment benefit until they have completed a vocational/college/university degree or are participating in a training program. Whether that actually works to useful effect, or just cleans up the NEET statistic, is up for debate.
- weberer 6y agoAlso in Finland, its really common to see people still in university in their late 20's, so that will really drive down the "Neet 15-29" figure. This is because people start later (partially due to military conscription) and because most people go for a master's degree rather than stopping at a bachelor's degree. Compare this to the USA where its standard to be done around age 22. It would be nice to see comparisons between countries for NEET 30+ to see if the differences remain.
- jusssi 6y agoA couple of additions on why people graduate from uni so late here. First, it often takes multiple attempts to get into one. The most popular programs have admission rates of around 10%, but since "it defines the rest of your life", why not try at least once? Then the next year, or year after that, if you're still not in, you can try something more realistic. Second, (my experience, 15 years ago, your mileage may vary), the whole thing is just inefficiently organized. Where I went, there was 4 six week lecture periods per year, each followed by a week or two of exams. Many courses would have mandatory coursework you can only do during the lecture periods. In the end you're left with 28 weeks of crunch time per year, and the remaining 24 weeks to just fill with whatever. Most choose to work that almost half an year, some lucky ones actually find something from their own field, though the odds go up as you're getting more years in. Then at some point you find the job more satisfying (because it's nice to actually get paid) than completing your MSc, which you then finally scrape together before having children at 30-something (if even then; I know I didn't). On topic: I think most people on this trajectory wouldn't settle in the NEET column anyway, at least for extended periods of time.
- nikanj 6y agoBecause they have to constantly bail out southern Europe.
- bitcharmer 6y agoInteresting. Could you expand on that?
- mrweasel 6y agoIt has nothing to do with the article but in general the people of northern Europe feel like they constantly need to help the struggling economies in the south finans their government budgets. Recently the EU borrowed money collectively for the first time to help coutries like Italy. Italy can not borrow at the same low rates as Germany, or Denmark, but if the EU borrow the money on behalf of Italy then they can piggy back on the excellent credit rating of northen Europe. There’s a grown sense that the southern economies should be allowed to collaps and just deal with their own mess. This is completely ignoring any knock of effect on the rest of the EU and centered on a rather outdate world view, assuming the the economies of the individual EU coutries are completely disconnected.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe EU's model essentially assumes that everyone should be a net exporter, which is clearly insane. It makes no sense at all to expect Portugal or Croatia to compete with the German industrial establishment. It would take massive infrastructure investment to make that even remotely plausible, even if it was a good idea - which it isn't. The reality is that the Southern countries are best suited for tourism, leisure, and agriculture, not industry, and so will never be competitive with FR, NL, and DE on those terms. But there are plenty of mid/long term opportunities for developing Internet and bio/med businesses and related primary research. The EU could do more to encourage those. (It's making some effort, but more is always possible.)
- RobertoG 6y ago
- m12k 6y agoThere's a world of difference between a mortgage (where you own an asset of similar size as the debt) and credit card debt.
- teekert 6y agoYeah, this. Here in the Netherlands mortgage is for most people their only form of debt and many people have "NHG", an insurance that helps them when they can't pay for their house anymore.
- aequitas 6y agoYou're forgetting the student dept almost all students have to get into nowadays. And although credit cards are not as common for household expenses, a lot of retailers offer loans to buy appliances and such. I'm curious as how much people actually use these kind of constructs.
- Leherenn 6y agoIs student debt really in thing in mainland Europe? Certainly some people need to borrow money to cover costs of living, but tuition is very low (from free to a couple thousands a year) in most places I know about.
- Cederfjard 6y agoYou said it, cost of living ain’t free. My experience from Sweden is that few people work alongside studies, and even fewer have expenses paid for by well-off parents. Maybe if you’re from the city where you study you stay living and eating at home, but otherwise it’s very common to take out a (fairly cheap) student loan from the Swedish Board of Student Finance to cover your expenses.
- hellweaver666 6y agoI was so surprised when I moved here how few places in the real world take credit cards, even online you just pay straight from your bank account using iDeal (which is the most stupidly simple online payment system and I freaking love it!). I've been in NL for 9 years and don't have a credit card (recently I did take out an account with Revolut so that I could get a MasterCard Debit for buying filament from Prusa as they don't accept PayPal but that's all I use it for, and I have to pre-transfer money from my local bank to Revolut for this purpose). Debt beyond mortgages doesn't seem to be a thing here.
- Kosirich 6y agoWhat is the effect of countries share of young adults living with parents on debt, specifically mortgage debt? http://appsso.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/nui/submitViewTableAction.do http://appsso.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/nui/submitViewTableActio... https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/EDN-20200812-1 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/E...
- t0r0nat0r 6y agoThese numbers should really be normalized with salary figures.
- stingraycharles 6y agoAt least here in The Netherlands, a reasonable explanation for our high debt is the fact that mortgage interest rates are tax deductible; this effectively means this tax benefit increases the cost of a house (as people have more spending power), and mortgages are thus higher. It’s a silly system, yes, but it’s been like this since forever and it’s slowly being phased out. In addition to this tax deductibility, there’s also NHG which allows people to pay a one-time fee (included in the mortgage) so that a bank is guaranteed to get their money back in case you are unable to pay your debts (resulting in less risk for the bank and thus lower interest rates). Again, this pushes up mortgage prices, but lower overall risk for everybody.
- yokaze 6y agoPersonally, I dislike taking the risk of the bank. Assessing the risk and setting the interest rate accordingly is the job of the bank. Taking that risk away eliminates that function of a bank. A one-time fee also seems to be counter-intuitive, if you want to be more social and enable poorer people not to be further disadvantaged by being naturally in a higher risk group on top of not having the capital to pay such a fee on top. Or is there a social component in that fee?
- Bombthecat 6y agoAs far as i understand it reduces interest, but increases the price. Basically a hidden interest increase.. Overall maybe cheaper. But i dont think by much..
- airza 6y agoAlthough I've loved living here and generally am on board politically with the social welfare program, government policy here really seems to be messing with the housing market! Houses almost inevitably go for exactly the mortgage amount the government insures, with cash on top of that. The median income here is ~36,000 euros but this amount is over 300,000 euros! It's baffling. It has the nice effect of making the loan rates just over 1% or whatever, but it doesn't have to be this way... I'm sure DFI is keeping the insane bubble going, but I wish they would make this a priority.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoFrustrating article. The correlations they hint at aren't completely explored. And the first graph is what? Total debt, or per household?
- em500 6y agoI don't know the particulars of the other OECD countries, but in the Netherlands, the vast majority of household debts are mortgages (as alluded to in the article). The main drivers are probably the tax policy: mortgage interest payments were fully deductible (untill the very slow phasing out reforms after the 2008 financial crisis). This sounds similar as in the US, but in the Netherlands/Europe the effect is stronger because marginal tax rates are high (>50%) and the top income tax bracket kicks in much earlier than in the US. It starts around 60k in the Netherlands, so beyond 60k more than half of every extra earned Euro goes to the state. Due to the full deductibility, the common narrative became: if you're in the top tax bracket, the state pays more than half your mortgate interest. For most working households, pensions and mortgages are the only substantial tax relieves, which predictably lead to households maxing out their pensions and mortgages. In the Netherlands, zero-downpayment (or even negative-downpayment), interest-only mortgages are/were the norm. Before the 2008 crisis, it was very common for respectable financial advisors and banks in the Netherlands to advise households to borrow as much as they can on a 30 year mortgage, never pay down the debt and put everything in the stock market. (Incidentally, my distaste for the bad incentives that come with the tax gimics in high public-spending regimes is one of the reasons than I, a European welfare state citizen, am probably more right leaning, cold-hearted fiscal conservative than the median young progressive American tech-forum dweller.)
- archi42 6y agoWait, what?! I recently checked if I can deduce some of the expenses from buying a house, but as long as I buy it myself to live there the state [Germany] says "screw you". If I bought it to rent it out, I could deduce some of the expenses. Now I need to figure out if it makes sensoe to start a housing company to buy a house and rent it out to myself so that I can deduce some of the expenses... (IANAL, but I suppose that might be tax fraud - OTOH I wouldn't be too surprised if it is not).
- galuggus 6y agoWould it be legal to partner with a friend and rent houses to each other ?
- tspduck 6y agoI do not think that this article deserves the 2 place on hackernews front-page. Is it true that the debt-rate in Denmark is high, but that is debt in DKK, which is very importent. The majority of the real-estate is owned by huge pensions funds and institutions which are also danish. As other mentioned the numbers do not seem to be normalized either.
- jdmoreira 6y agoI live in Sweden and though I’m debt free from my understanding most household debt it’s either student loans and/or mortgage. And by student loans I don’t mean the same as US student loans. Education is free and the state lends you money so you can move out of your parents home when you are 18 and can become independent - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_financial_aid_(Sweden) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_financial_aid_(Swede...
- refurb 6y agoSo kind of like US student loans? A lot of US student loans go towards paying for housing and general living expenses. It’s not just tuition.
- ptr 6y agoOne difference is that the student loans in Sweden are controlled by the government and have a very low interest rate (it's 0.05% currently). It'd be foolish not taking that loan.
- refurb 6y agoThat is a big difference!
- catears 6y agoI think the argument goes something like this: if the state lends money to allow more people to educate themselves, then in the future those people will be earning more money and then be paying higher taxes. Therefore the interest on the loan does not need to pay it of, the increased income to the state from taxes need to pay of the loans.
- ecmascript 6y agoAs another commenter wrote, taking a student loan in Sweden is so beneficial that you would take it even if you don't need it because just taking it and buying funds or stock with it would give you free money.
- timwaagh 6y agoI think there are some problems with this. Mortgage debt in the Netherlands is fiscally subsidized through an instrument called 'Hypotheekrenteaftrek'. If we want an explanation for high mortgage debt in the Netherlands, that's the cause. People on welfare can't get a mortgage anyways. So why mortgages would go up because of welfare not only going to pensioners is altogether unexplained. Also I think lumping us in with the Nordics is very questionable. Because although we might fit with the ideal of the 'Nordic model' to a certain extent, it's just easy to leave us out when we don't fit, because we're not a Nordic country geographically or otherwise.
- Glawen 6y agoLatin countries lump you with the nordics as you are closer politically to them than latin countries.
- cromulent 6y agoIn 2016, Sweden limited mortgage terms to 105 years. This was because in 2013, the average term was 140 years. https://www.thelocal.se/20160324/sweden-limits-mortgage-loans-to-105-years/ https://www.thelocal.se/20160324/sweden-limits-mortgage-loan...
- durnygbur 6y agoSweden is among the emptiest countries in Europe, with massive surplusses of wood. How on earth have they managed to create shortage of housing and over century long mortgages? I have an almost certainity that the maybe dozen of aristocratic/oligarch Swedish families owning the economy of the country made a private grange from the entire country.
- gspr 6y agoSince when has the housing market been dictated by available space in a country? Are you not puzzled that house prices in Canada aren't ~0?
- durnygbur 6y agoSweden is more hermetic and not that open to inflow of American, Arab, and Chinese cash into their real estate market. For European rich their real estate market is not that attractive. My hypothesis is that the situation is intentionally designed to be stuffy.
- gspr 6y agoWhy does this matter if the claim is that the availability of space in a country seriously affects housing prices? I agree that in very very constrained countries like Singapore this is the case, but the space available to a country does not matter for housing prices beyond a certain point. The original claim was that it does. Why does it matter that Canada sees more foreign money flowing in? The space is essentially limitless, so prices should drop to zero. Except they don't, because it's not about space. It's about living in small, pleasant regions with a good economy where others also want to live. That drives up the prices, be it Toronto or Stockholm. It doesn't matter that both countries have essentially limitless land elsewhere. Edit: Also, the claim that Sweden is "more hermetic" is also a bit silly. You are aware of freedom of movement in the EU, right?
- wodenokoto 6y agoWhat is the unit on the x-axis of the first plot?
- cromulent 6y agoseems to be percentage of household income
- chrisseaton 6y agoNobody knows and yet here we all are debating an article we can't even interpret!
- jokoon 6y agoCurious about the source of those numbers. Anyhow, I can really say that I have a problem with finance. It's often equating people to numbers, and it's hard to de-obfuscate what is really happening. I don't dislike money as a medium, but I don't like how it seems so opaque and complex, and how it becomes difficult to understand how food/housing/clothing/transport really works at a large scale for a normal citizen. I'm 35, I love math, and last year I learned that a 5% mortgage of 150000 euros over about 15 years would cost around 85000 euros. It feels so crazy to learn something like that so late in life. When climate problems kick in, that's where financial complexity seems impossible for me to understand.
- ricardo81 6y agoFor the UK I always found this presentation interesting https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/mortgageshome/article-5510061/Mortgage-payments-compared-disposable-income-region.html https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/mortgageshome/article-55... It indicates that the previous decade tended to have higher interest rates compared to the past few years. The table shows 2007 vs 2017 that mortgages as a percentage of disposable income have generally went down. IIRC there is a strong correlation with higher household debt and areas with higher housing prices relative to income. The UK government do release quite detailed statistics by region for those who are interested.
- queuep 6y agoNot sure if it's to any interest, but most of these are somewhat open data, and accessible(edit: for sweden). For example, check this https://www.hitta.se/kartan!~55.67224,13.07713,16.647224250750465z/tr!i=DoHBpfOV/tileLayer!l=1/lifestyle!l=55.67224:13.07713?usergeo=1 https://www.hitta.se/kartan!~55.67224,13.07713,16.6472242507... Shows a suburb close to Malmö(3rd largest city in sweden), and their average salary(medelinkomst) and average debt(snittbelåning). Move the map around to see how it differs.
- juusto 6y agoAs many have pointed out the majority of the debt goes into home ownership in the nordics. At least in 3 countries that I have lived. And the prices are eye watering high for what is offered. In the main urban areas Stockholm/Helsinki/Oslo it is easy to find house blocks consisting of buildings with soviet style looks costing close to 500k USD. Weird floor planning and "dry" walls are the norm here. One of the apartments I had did not have a window in the bedroom. How is that okay to build it that way? I don't know. Yes, there are laws against this but it does happen. The construction, while not shoddy, does not justify the price alone and it seems construction companies are doing quite well between the pre-built structures and hiring immigrants to do some of the less qualified jobs. If you can make a parity between salaries price of apartments/buildings in Southern Europe, Portugal/Spain/France, and in the Americas are better built than the ones here. And they come in other colors than brown or beige.
- tokai 6y ago>One of the apartments I had did not have a window in the bedroom. How is that okay to build it that way? What is the issue?
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoThat would be illegal in many countries.
- dagw 6y agoWhat is the issue? It's a fire hazard. At least in Sweden (and I think Norway) building codes require that all bedrooms have a window large enough for you to fit through.
- bluGill 6y agoFire code. in the US all bedrooms must have a window large enough that a human can use to get out in case of fire. You don't need to be able to get to the ground - it is enough that you can wave to the firemen who then bring a ladder to get you out. Firemen are also trained to check rooms with a window first for someone who might still be alive but too far gone to get to the window. Any room without a window is not a safe place to sleep. Sometimes when you are buying real estate you will see "non-conforming bedroom) which means a room that looks like a bedroom and you might use as one at your own risk as you can't get out. (This might also mean it would be a bedroom if there was a closet as well - you have to figure out what it means)
- smcg 6y agoIf the "solution" to unequality is to saddle poor people with debt, then the "solution" is nothing more than creating social categories of lenders and debtors. Another caste system. The real solution to unequality requires much more radical solutions.
- pembrook 6y agoIn addition to the demand side issues of low interest rates leading to bigger mortgages and ballooning real estate values in the nordics, what are the supply side constraints? When visiting Helsinki, Finland, I was amazed to hear a house for a family of 4 can easily cost near 1M euros even when located in the suburbs outside the city. This was even more surprising to me after hearing about average salaries and driving around the capitol area—-there was a ridiculous amount of unused land. 15-30 mins outside Helsinki and you’re basically in a forest. I assumed there must be some sort of strict restrictions on building. Is this the case, or am I assuming too much based on my experience with SF?
- european321 6y agoYeah, in trendy areas near the city, a big, modern house can cost 1M euros. But there are much cheaper ones as well in the suburbs. Also agree that I don't understand who can afford to buy such houses with the average salaries being so low here. I guess those are still must be outliers that pop up more from the average houses. And yes there are a lot of restrictions for building in the city. Overall the "housing code" is quite strict and standards are very high.
- jusssi 6y ago> there was a ridiculous amount of unused land The municipalities have to zone it first, and then build basic infrastructure. Whenever they try, they get bogged down by complaints by NIMBYers who really like their forests and the flying squirrels* that live in them. * Not joking, the environments they live in are protected. And they live almost everywhere where there are enough trees to call a forest and you care to look for them. A lot of zoning plans get cancelled because of flying squirrels.
- simonebrunozzi 6y ago> Figure 1: Quantity of household debt in OECD countries This is so poorly described. 0, 50, 100... What's that number? Should I guess "debt as % of annual household income" ?