12 ms·
Cleanliness is booming too, but cleaning persons also live in poverty. It's because: (a) we don't compensate jobs based on their difficulty or the financial s
by coldtea 6y ago
Cleanliness is booming too, but cleaning persons also live in poverty.
It's because:
(a) we don't compensate jobs based on their difficulty or the financial success of the product, but on how hard it is to find people to do them when we need them.
If there were 100 qualified surgeons for every patient needing an operation, and would stampede each other for a chance to work and get paid, we'd pay them $25/hour too.
(b) we allow businesses to profit wildly while not paying enough (by exploiting (a)), because we have the taboo that not meddling with the market is the best course of action. A more englightened society that didn't pay too much attention to economy pundits working for rich people, might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees...
- Retric 6y ago(b) Minimum wage and safe working conditions are a thing in most developed countries. However, enforcement is another story. While Japan's prefectural minimum wages range from ¥714 to ¥932 per hour (6.71+$) for all workers, that’s often ignored.
- throw_m239339 6y ago> , but on how hard it is to find people to do them when we need them. This isn't even the case. Last season in my country fruits were rotting in the fields cause nobody was there to pick them up. Did farmers increase salaries in order to get more fruit pickers? No. Here, I suspect the obvious in the anime industry, like in many entertainment sectors including VFX: salary fixing between studios to keep pays low. > If there were 100 qualified surgeons for every patient needing an operation, and would stampede each other for a chance to work and get paid, we'd pay them $25/hour too. Given how opaque the healthcare industry is when it comes to cost for non elective surgeries, I doubt costs would go down even if you multiplied the number of surgeons by 1000. Case points: there are loads of restaurants yet the hospital will steal bill a meal 20 times what it would cost in the nearby restaurant.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> This isn't even the case. Last season in my country fruits were rotting in the fields cause nobody was there to pick them up. Did farmers increase salaries in order to get more fruit pickers? No. Is the fruit worth picking if salaries need to be increased to get workers? In a lot of cases the answer is no. A lot of work only makes sense at a particular salary. If market salaries are above that, the work just isn't done.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoPeople can pick a lot of fruit per hour. You would need something like 1 cent apples for that to be an issue. At that point it’s not a question of making money, but minimizing losses.
- konjin 6y agoYet there are automated apple pickers. There is no money in agriculture. The only reason why most farms aren't bankrupt is because of subsidies.
- Retric 6y agoIn a competitive market long term subsides don’t actually benefit the industry’s profit margins. Suppose we subsidize toilet paper, suddenly prices drop and people might start using toilet paper for random other stuff if it’s cheap. However, the industry would simply expand until things stayed about the same. Where farm subsides play a role is dampening the boom bust cycle.
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoThere's also a very big national security concern. Each country should be able to grow enough food to support it's people. If it can't, it literally faces the threat of starvation in the event of war or natural disaster.
- anoonmoose 6y agoSalaries for fruit pickers didn't go up because demand for fruit pickers didn't go up. The farmers knew that they were screwed no matter what they did- if they paid the pickers more and tried to pass the costs on, they wouldn't be able to sell the fruit, and if they paid the pickers more but ate the cost, they wouldn't actually net a profit. So they were going to lose money no matter what, and did it in the least-impact way possible (let the fruit rot).
- sigstoat 6y ago> So they were going to lose money no matter what, and did it in the least-impact way possible (let the fruit rot). and at least that option might help fertilize their fields for next season.
- jeffbee 6y agoSo, why didn't the growers offer better wages to get their fruit picked? Were they ambivalent because of insurance? Or perhaps they thought raising wages was futile? Some other reason?
- gruez 6y agoprice elasticity[1] might be an issue. Fruit picking is seasonal work, so even if the wage were attractive you'll have a tough time finding people willing to quit their current job just so they earn slightly more picking fruits. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_supply
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoTo a first approximation: the value of the labor is a ceiling on how much you can be paid to do it. The availability of laborers determines the floor of the price of labor.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 6y ago> Last season in my country fruits were rotting in the fields cause nobody was there to pick them up. Did farmers increase salaries in order to get more fruit pickers? No. Probably because raising the wages would cost them more than the loss of the harvest since the price per tonne of fruit was already decided by long term contracts and there were no financial penalties for spoilage / mis-harvests in these contracts. Ever since food became a global commodity, the conditions in food manufacturing became a ruthless race to the bottom - with the worst offender being meatpacking. The John Oliver segment last weekend was horrifying to watch, even from an European viewpoint (where we also have a history of exploitation and animal cruelty, but nowhere even close to that).
- mcv 6y agoI think pay is largely a matter of power. Even bad managers get paid well. CEOs that drive their company to bankruptcy often still get massive bonuses on the way out. There are lots of people who want to do that job, and the people doing it aren't always good at it, yet still get paid a ton. The worst paid are always the most powerless. Of course having rare skills that are in high demand also gives you power, but it's one of many kinds of power that can give you more control over your own salary.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- randomdata 6y ago> This isn't even the case. Last season in my country fruits were rotting in the fields cause nobody was there to pick them up. It is the case, but leaves some assumptions on the table. Namely that you understand that price exists to be a deterrent, and when price rises too high you will decide that you don't need something anymore. The fruits rotted in the fields because they weren't worth picking. There was no need to pay anyone to do a job that wasn't deemed worthwhile to do in the first place.
- Veen 6y ago> The fruits rotted in the fields because they weren't worth picking. That may be true, but why weren't they worth picking? In agriculture, large buyers often enforce artificially low prices (monopsony). Even if farmers were willing to pay pickers more, there's no point if the buyers refuse to pay a fair price that accounts for increased wages.
- randomdata 6y ago> but why weren't they worth picking? The exact same reason. As the price rises in the grocery store, you and I stop buying those fruits. When we stop buying them, there is no need to produce even more of what is already not being purchased.
- wilsonrocks 6y ago> This isn't even the case. Last season in my country fruits were rotting in the fields cause nobody was there to pick them up. Did farmers increase salaries in order to get more fruit pickers? No. Sad that this is one of the plot points of The Grapes Of Wrath and is still happening today.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoThis same story is playing out in the Videogame Industry. That industry is arguably booming too, making more than it ever has in the past and growing wildly year over year. And yet game programmers make some of the lowest salaries among all devs, last I checked. Especially at entry level. To me, that entire industry seems geared towards grabbing fresh faced grads who are loaded up on dreams of making games, putting them in infinite crunch, and discarding them later when they are burned out.
- m8s 6y agoNot only do they make some of the lowest salaries in the industry, they work the longest hours as well. Employers that allow people to "work on their passions" use that as a bargaining chip to lower salaries.
- trentnix 6y agoEmployers use the reality that someone equally talented will do it for the same wages or less. It's that simple.
- coldtea 6y ago"If you have large profits you should share more with your employees [1]" could also be a reality encoded into law woth harsh penalties for doing otherwise... ([1] "And don't try to bypass it by building in another country and then come to sell your wares here")
- chongli 6y agoIf you have large profits you should share more with your employees [1]" could also be a reality encoded into law woth harsh penalties for doing otherwise Hollywood is already one step ahead of you [1]. No reason game studios wouldn’t follow suit, given a law like that to incentivize them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- MattGaiser 6y agoAre the animation companies profiting wildly? > They typically pay animation studios a set fee and reserve royalties for themselves. > While the system protects the studios from the risk of a flop, it also cuts them out of the windfalls created by hits.
- Eridrus 6y agoFulfilling/prestigious jobs will also generally get paid less because people will take extra pay cuts to have them.
- cblconfederate 6y agoThere is not an overabundance of quality content. Almost nobody pays a lot more for a "better cleaner". Popular art is not commodity . The problem here clearly is the lack of an easy way to pay .
- dkdbejwi383 6y ago> (b) we allow businesses to profit wildly while not paying enough (by exploiting (a)), because we have the taboo that not meddling with the market is the best course of action. A more englightened society that didn't pay too much attention to economy pundits working for rich people, might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees... And because we've been taught that discussing how much you earn is taboo, especially with your colleagues.
- neonological 6y agoAnimators are more rare and much more in demand then programmers relative to the size of the industry IMO. The skill is also harder overall. Drawing and animating the human form in three dimensions is harder then programming. I don’t think it’s a supply side problem. Another phenomenon is happening here. Animators do have the option of unionizing which mitigates these sorts of issues.
- dubcanada 6y agoAnimation is not a difficult task, yes it's difficult in the sense to be amazing you need skill (same with programming) but the rest is actually just copying and pasting with slight tweaks based on someone elses art/direction. But it's also art. Painting, cobbler, pottery, blacksmith, etc have always been sought after jobs and yet are and have been the least paid throughout our history.
- neonological 6y agoNo they don’t do that. Especially for anime. What they have found is that the copy paste and tweak method produces stiff results so no one in the industry does that. It’s a weird phenomenon. Every frame is literally sketched by hand entirely which makes actual skill required. Anime especially given the more realistic human proportions and extensive use of z-axis. For something like sponge bob or South Park in the US it’s much easier... but in Japan the animation is a real skill. Take a look at this: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Yglxt331WoY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Yglxt331WoY . This type of skill of animating is basically non existent now in any place other then japan. Also blacksmiths were not always the least paid. Prior to the industrial revolution it was a common job.
- Arnavion 6y agoYou've cherry-picked examples of big budget scenes. The vast majority of anime is static backgrounds with slow pans and static characters with mouth flaps. The backgrounds and characters often get outsourced and the studio just adds facial features and mouth flaps.
- chadash 6y ago> If there were 100 qualified surgeons for every patient needing an operation, and would stampede each other for a chance to work and get paid, we'd pay them $25/hour too. The number of surgeons is artificially low because of limits on the number of residency spots in this country. So I agree that prices can probably come down, somewhat. However, attorneys are not limited in the same way but can still cost a fortune, because people are willing to pay a lot for perceived value when there's a high stakes outcome. Some things just aren't worth farming out to the lowest bidder.
- blobbers 6y agoThat's not "artificially" low. You need to do a residency to be properly trained to handle all kinds of situations. Your surgeon can't be in a position of "well I've never done this in a supervised setting so let me go find someone to teach me" as the lead surgeon. That's exactly the reason they do a residency.
- chadash 6y agoWhat's artificially low is the number of residency slots. In other words, it's not just that you have to clear a bar to be a surgeon. It's that there are literally X number of slots and if you don't get one of them, you're out, regardless of whether you would qualify. I'd say it's an artificial constraint since there are far more people trying to get into med school (not a specific school... med school generally) than there are slots. With law, for example, you have to go to law school and pass a test, but if you do, you are in. There's a lot of law schools out there, to the point where a large percentage of people graduating don't get good jobs. The same isn't true for medical residency graduates.
- imtringued 6y agoThe idea behind having a privatized healthcare system is that, yes you are massively overcharging for life saving procedures, but that money will then be spent on training more surgeons to lower the price in the future. The end result is an expensive system with superior outcomes. >It's that there are literally X number of slots This is fundamentally incompatible with the idea of a privatized healthcare system. It simply cannot be functional this way. I hope Americans will wake up and realize that this sort of welfare should not exist. It's always sad when I see Americans brag about their highly efficient free market systems when they fail the basic requirements needed for a free market to actually work. Yes it can work and yes you'd be allowed to brag but as it is you haven't figured out how to make it work yet.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoAnd this is why we need to break down the apprenticeship based training system in medicine. The monopoly on knowledge that such a small group of people have is tremendously bad for society and more importantly, progress.
- gameman144 6y agoWhat would be a suitable alternative? Not necessarily against this, but I can say that I'd personally never go to a doctor who hadn't had extensive clinical training as part of their education, at least not for anything serious.
- JamesBarney 6y agoThere are plenty of things I'd go to a doctor for even if they had 90% less medical training. Get prescriptions to variously mostly safe drugs anti depressants/weight loss drugs/blood pressure medicine, dandruff shampoo. Refill any prescription. Those two items are probably 80% of the reason anyone I know goes to a doctor. Now for surgeons. It's true that you want someone with a lot of experience for surgery but there are still ways to get more highly trained surgeons. Throw out undergrad requirements for med school, if the average career for a fully trained surgeon in 16 years we've just increased the supply by ~25%. Allow surgeons from other countries to come practice in the U.S. without completing a full residency. We could easily suck up the worlds surgeons because we pay so much more. Open up/pay for more residency spots.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lc9er 6y ago> Those two items are probably 80% of the reason anyone I know goes to a doctor. This role seems to be increasingly filled by Physicians Assistants and Nurse Practitioners.
- gameman144 6y ago> There are plenty of things I'd go to a doctor for even if they had 90% less medical training. As mentioned below, PAs and NPs already do a lot of these tasks. However, the big value-add I see in MDs as opposed to seeing NPs or PAs with problems is that they have the depth and breadth of training to have first-hand experience with the exceptions to normal circumstances. The standard medical mantra of "if you hear hoof beats, think horses, not zebras" works great for normal scenarios. If there actually is a zebra situation, though, I have far more faith in professionals with extensive clinical training at identifying those situations. > Those two items are probably 80% of the reason anyone I know goes to a doctor. Regarding prescriptions, this may be blind faith in regulatory institutions, but I assume that there is a reason that mostly-safe drugs require a prescription. If the criteria for prescription refills or simple procedures doesn't require the full breadth/depth of clinical training, though, then NPs and PAs already exist to fill that role. > We could easily suck up the worlds surgeons because we pay so much more. I'd argue that this is an explicit non-goal. We don't want to attract the most surgeons/doctors, we want the surgeons/doctors we have to be trained and practiced to an extremely high bar. You're definitely right that there are lots of scenarios which don't require this extremely high bar, and that's the reason why not all medical personnel are doctors. Nurses and physician assistants play a critical role in healthcare specifically because they can tackle those 80% of cases you mentioned, but the way around this isn't to dilute the training of medical doctors, it's to delegate the work that's better performed by others to those others.
- blondin 6y agonot sure i get (a). maybe someone can help me understand. software engineers are one of the best paid people today. i highly doubt that we are hard to find.
- tantalor 6y agoThe software developer shortage (demand minus supply) is 1.4M in the US. https://www.daxx.com/blog/development-trends/software-developer-shortage-us https://www.daxx.com/blog/development-trends/software-develo...
- blondin 6y agocan someone provide a link to the US bureau of labor statistics that has these numbers? (for my own edification) it has been often mentioned but i don't think i have ever seen a link to the report people are quoting.
- MMAesawy 6y agoIf this is the case, how come the entry level job market for CS graduates stink so much?
- tantalor 6y agoMeaning what? > Less than 1 year $103,269 Sounds like it's pretty hot! https://www.indeed.com/career/software-engineer/salaries https://www.indeed.com/career/software-engineer/salaries
- Aerroon 6y ago>A more englightened society that didn't pay too much attention to economy pundits working for rich people, might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees... How would this avoid (a) and (b) though? Your society needs to somehow balance what jobs people do. There is no real way to measure how difficult a job is. You could argue that hard manual labor is a very difficult job, yet there are many people who prefer that to sitting down, learning a lot and then doing a mentally exhausting desk job. The willingness of people to do a job needs to be accounted for when you're deciding whether a job is difficult or not, but this very much depends on the person. How would you account for this without looking at how difficult it is to replace a person doing a specific job?
- diob 6y agoFollow on to a) Society is also structured in such a way that for the most part every job will have folks clamoring for it. When you are born without capital, you have to take what you can get. Unfortunately I think it's going to keep getting worse as wealth inequality increases. Imagine walking into a monopoly game where each piece is already bought and owned. Try to win at that. Instead, I could imagine you wind up working for someone, and feed them a majority of the profit while you get scraps. I don't have good solutions for how to fix this, other than perhaps universal basic income would alleviate things.
- dystend 6y agoYou should look up the Mondragon Corporation. It's a worker owned cooperative. Highly democratic institution. I'd postulate that by and large due to the nature of it, and with tens of thousands of similar edifices in concert we could excise a great deal of power (wealth) from the government and corporations, placing it in the hands of the people who earned it. Entities like this can't get funding though, since it endangers the contemporary business model and leaves little in the way of profit for banksters since by nature company stock is traded only internally, exchanged between employee and the company to prevent external interlopers from gaining a foothold. Governments would also see a great deal of their power dissolved as a product of the internal democratic processes dealing with social issues. It comes with issues, but with multiplicity, I think the stratification would be greatly remedied. The stratification comes from non-owners participating in the business, they don't have voting rights and they're subject to lower compensation, generally. That's what we're subject to now, generally, in any case. With more companies following this modality, I believe that would be alleviated to a degree where if one was insistent they could always find an opportunity to become a worker-owner.
- merpnderp 6y agoWe don't allow businesses to profit "wildly" because we don't want to pay people more. We allow businesses to profit because it isn't fair to make someone pay X when someone else is very happy to get paid a fraction of X. It's about justice and fairness. I mean I'd love to get paid Silicon Valley programmer wages, but I'm perfectly happy to program for a fraction of those wages. And it would be an injustice for me to be unemployed because my employer was forced to pay Silicon Valley wages. And what are "wild" profits? Because most companies are making far less than 8% of revenue as profits.
- gchamonlive 6y agoI think I understand where you come from. A job is better than no job. But I don't think that is necessarily true nor that things would follow suit if we think like that. I mean, we employ much more people today than in the industrial revolution. Yet, people are paid significantly more, child labor has been abolished, all that working 8-9h a day instead of 14-18 which was common. We are not in a cooperative environment, when it comes to salaries. Companies are legally obligated to show gains to their investors, and if they can cut salaries and keep the profits they will do so. We are in a competitive game against employer, where the balance is found when both parties compromise. But make no mistake, as soon as the working force stop fight for better working conditions, it will not stay the same, only degrade. Don't read that in a personal way. We are in no way personally against the employer, but the employer as an authority figure. The balance is not found through cooperation but rather through clash of professional interests.
- pessimizer 6y ago> And it would be an injustice for me to be unemployed because my employer was forced to pay Silicon Valley wages. No, it would be good, because it would mean that they were more efficiently utilizing their current workforce, probably through technological advancement that should ultimately benefit the entire industry. Technology is almost entirely driven through higher labor costs and dictating better conditions for employees. The benefits of technology improvements are also not zero-sum (equal to their costs to develop or maintain), and are redistributed through those higher salaries and through taxes. If you end up unemployed at that wage level because your skill level has not made the new cut, there are other things you can do. Wanting to program but not being able to find somebody who wants you to program at the minimum wage is no more tragic than wanting to program but not being able to pay your rent doing it.
- rhino369 6y ago>(b) we allow businesses to profit wildly while not paying enough (by exploiting (a)), because we have the taboo that not meddling with the market is the best course of action. A more englightened society that didn't pay too much attention to economy pundits working for rich people, might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees... You have to be careful there because the overwhelming surplus of cheaply acquired goods/services goes to the people who received the goods and services and not the person selling the goods and services. Businesses only capture it when they have a competitive advantage (either because they have no competition or b/c the cost savings can't be matched by a competitor). Grocery clerks are lowly paid. But grocery is a competitive, low margin business. So those low wages mostly mean cheap food.
- nullserver 6y agoSo we want government setting pay rates for anime artist? How about quotas. Government pays on a per episode completed. More content created the more is paid.
- gruez 6y agoSounds like a good way to produce cookie cutter shows for the sole purpose of getting government funding.
- 0xfaded 6y agoLawyers are a counterexample. There are more law graduates than jobs. But starting salaries haven't gone down. David Graeber made this observation, and suggested some sort of class tribalism. Btw, to use cleaning as a specific example, taxation of domestic services is broken in almost every (western?) country and skews how people spend their time and money. Most professionals would happily trade an hour of work for an hour of cleaning services, however, by the time you put income tax (and VAT in my case) on top, your hours need to be about 2.5x times as valuable as your counterparty.
- ForHackernews 6y agoSalaries in law are famously bimodal: https://www.biglawinvestor.com/bimodal-salary-distribution-curve/ https://www.biglawinvestor.com/bimodal-salary-distribution-c... Law is a very status-conscious industry (even more than software) and so most of that oversupply of law graduates are not "in the club". They get paid relatively low wages and have to fight with each other for peanuts. Some much smaller fraction of law graduates from top schools or who otherwise have the right connections get paid extremely high salaries because they are only competing with each other.
- YinglingLight 6y agoJournalism weeds itself of those not "in the club" via unpaid or barely paid internships in the highest COL cities.
- ghaff 6y agoJournalism is quite different in that most journalists don't make all that much. Also credentialing isn't nearly as big a factor. In fact, a lot of people in the industry look down on J-schools. The common career path among the non-freelance journalists I know at more prestigious publications is knocking around trade pubs and (at least formerly) small city papers before getting their break. (But, yes, connections matter too.)
- ForHackernews 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago>(b) we allow businesses to profit wildly while not paying enough (by exploiting (a)), because we have the taboo that not meddling with the market is the best course of action. A more englightened society that didn't pay too much attention to economy pundits working for rich people, might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees... Governments meddle with the economy all the time, there was a short period of laissez faire being the dominant thought in the Western World in 18th and 19th century, but after WWI. Nowadays governments command 30-60% of GDP.
- duxup 6y agoWhen I changed careers and did a coding bootcamp there were a handful of "thought I wanted to make video games but too many other people felt the same way" guys and girls in there.
- ApolloFortyNine 6y ago>Median annual earnings for key illustrators and other top-line talent increased to about $36,000 in 2019 from around $29,000 in 2015 So it would seem this article is truly about the animators responsible for the animation between keyframes. Unfortunately I can't find the article on the making of anime I had once read, but basically, the key frame artists are drawn by those truly responsible for the art style you see. The animation work between frames truly is grunt work (this is the truth, I'm sorry if you find this offensive) that is accomplishable by many. And lets not pretend that shows with good animation are automatically a success. You need a good story, good pacing (direction), and in most cases you need to choose the story from a pile of hundreds of possibilities. And, as is often forgotten when the whole "revenue sharing with employees" is brought up, the employee is staking no capital and can leave at any time. If the anime fails, surely you don't suggest "revenue sharing" that loss with the employees. The vast majority of anime does fail, or only serves as an advertisement for the source. Just look at any given season of anime, the majority of anime is not well received.
- ggreer 6y ago> (b) we allow businesses to profit wildly while not paying enough (by exploiting (a)), because we have the taboo that not meddling with the market is the best course of action. A more englightened society that didn't pay too much attention to economy pundits working for rich people, might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees... The highest profit margin I can find is Toei Animation, which in 2020 made 11.4 billion yen in profit on 54.8 billion yen in sales[1], giving them a 20% profit margin. If every animation studio had that high of a profit margin and 100% of profits went to workers, industry wages would rise 20%. Though if that were the case, the company's profits would be zero and one bad year would end them. 1. https://web.archive.org/web/20200930164251/http://corp.toei-anim.co.jp/files/IR/33_1Q/202103_1Q_keisu.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20200930164251/http://corp.toei-...
- newsclues 6y agoDo we know there is no Hollywood accounting in animation?
- ggreer 6y agoWe can't be completely sure, but the assets, sales, and employee numbers look reasonable to me. The only weird corporate structure I found was Studio Ghibli. Their museum's store (but not the museum itself) is run by Mammayuto Co., Ltd.[1] This company loses 60 million yen a year but has only 1 million yen in liabilities. I'm guessing it's a way for Studio Ghibli to avoid taxes of some kind. https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=ja&u=https://shukatsusoken.com/analysis/studio-ghibli/&prev=search&pto=aue https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=ja&u=https:/...
- rasz 6y ago$25/hour is what Surgeons dream of in Europe east of Germany.
- ehnto 6y agoRaising the minimum wage would help with that. Why would someone clean for $25/hour when they could do something less physically demanding for the same money? Then you would have to pay cleaners more in order to attract them. People would complain about cleaners getting more money than their white collar jobs, but that's classism embeded in part because of the current situation. As soon as people realise job X makes good money, suddenly the stigmas go away.
- cesarvarela 6y agoI think you'll be surprised by how many people would turn to cleaning from white collar jobs if you do that. Mentally demanding is worse that physically demanding for our bodies. All we do is create things to keep us from thinking, GAI being the end goal.
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoI'm sorry, what? Ask anyone in the trades if a 'mentally demanding' job is worse than a physically demanding one. People in tech really are out of touch if they think being a coder is somehow more grueling than being a roofer.
- Nebasuke 6y agoAs someone who has done plenty of physical jobs over the years, I found the physical jobs much more satisfying. This is for someone who is not even in that great a shape. Sure I was very tired afterwards, but at least it was a nice kind of tired. The mental tiredness/stress from coding is much worse in my opinion. If I could earn the same doing a physical job, I would probably switch now. I do want to acknowledge that some of these physical jobs will destroy your body long term.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoMind you, american work ethics is an omnibenevolent angel compared to japanese work ethics. See "Sewayaki kitsune no Senko-san" for an example how people work there.
- smabie 6y agoehh, people are at work a lot in Japan, but no one really does anything.
- heldrida 6y agoIn contrast to your statement, which sounds wise but I doubt it, I find that there's way more programmers, then there are animators; and programmers are usually paid very well. I did some 3d animation in the past, and once in awhile do some 2d animation. I've never met anyone else who does traditional 2d animation in person, in comparison with the zillions of programmers out there in the wild.
- smabie 6y agosupply and demand. Not very many companies do animation.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoUnfortunately 3dpd is all the rage, barely anyone does 2d.
- koonsolo 6y ago> might find a way for better revenue sharing with employees Most people want a steady paycheck at the end of the month and (a feeling of) security. This seems to cost money indeed. At least in Europe, when you are a freelancer, you earn considerably more for doing the same job. Why? Because of the earlier mentioned point. You would think most people would start freelancing because of this, but it's not true. Most prefer the safety.
- closeparen 6y agoWe don't have unlimited capacity for everyone who wants to make a good living doing $X to do be satisfied. They can hustle for a low-paying opportunity or they can just be told "no" by a central planner, hiring hall union, credentialing admissions process, etc. That may solve an observer's concern about profit/exploitation, but it leaves the worker with strictly fewer options. People not getting what they want is just as bad whether or not anyone else is benefitting at the same time.
- CyberRage 6y agoNot relevant at all. Good artists and animators are very hard to find. It is about culture more than anything. Japan is the problem.
- imtringued 6y agoCleaning paying low salaries is mostly a labor surplus problem that permeates the entire economy.