21 ms·
Missed one point: Extreme winter events like this, now being seen more often in unusual locations, are EXACTLY what was predicted 15-20 years ago in a number o
by walrus01 6y ago
Missed one point:
Extreme winter events like this, now being seen more often in unusual locations, are EXACTLY what was predicted 15-20 years ago in a number of reports and research papers about the coming effects of climate change. Global warming and climate change doesn't just mean "everything is getting hotter everywhere all the time", it also means shifting global wind patterns and unusual weather that breaks previous 100-year records every 5 or 10 years.
And where else in the USA has been a bastion of oil/petrochemical industry climate change denialism, than Texas?
Atmospheric co2 increase over time: https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/ https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/
https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/475891-extreme-weather-in-2019-broke-over-120000-records-in-us-report https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/475891-extreme...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2019/11/26/bleak-report-un-says-drastic-action-is-only-way-avoid-worst-impacts-climate-change/?wpisrc=al_news__alert-world--alert-national&wpmk=1 https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2019/11/2...
https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-49753680 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-49753680
https://globalnews.ca/news/7634414/another-12-new-record-lows-set-in-alberta-amid-prolonged-cold-snap/ https://globalnews.ca/news/7634414/another-12-new-record-low...
- austhrow743 6y agoThe term global warming really did a number on the awareness of climate change.
- Fellshard 6y agoArguably, the term itself was only part of the problem; the ensuing propaganda deluge that followed in its wake also seriously conflicts with the claims. tl;dr: hyped-up panic usually finds itself at odds with findings mere years later. Slow down and step carefully, and you'll find you don't get this kind of whiplash.
- tsimionescu 6y agoBut in this particular case, all signs point to the panic being significantly hyped-down: the world is in a much worse shape than most mainstream predictions, and global warming is accelerating faster than many "worse-case scenarios" even a decade ago. It's also important to remember that this isn't a gradual phenomenon - there are certain break points that, when we'll reach, we won't ever be able to go back. And by all accounts, unless we significantly change the global economy literally today, there is no chance that we won't reach those breaking points in 50-100 years. And even if we did today, there's a good chance it's too late. The mess we're leaving for our children to fix should make all of us feel deeply ashamed.
- Fellshard 6y agoRight, but in the early years of messaging, a lot of media was generated that spoke in volumes without proper scientific understanding; or the actual conclusions were stated publicly before sufficient certainty was had, leading to the average person seeing wildly different narratives begin to conflict, one after another. That's a colossal messaging failure, and what's worse is that politicians tend to get stuck in one of the intermediate messages regardless of how outdated it becomes, using it to drive action in all sorts of wrong directions. See the problem?
- avar 6y agoThat's like saying the term "stunted growth" in children is bad because we keep finding examples of increasingly taller or obese children. "Global warming" always referred to an on-average increase in warming on a global scale. The term wasn't the issue, it was people intentionally deciding they didn't like it for political reasons.
- wernercd 6y agousing unproven science or bad science for political gains is why people don't like "global warming" for political reasons.
- imtringued 6y agoYes the political gains of making sure that we are a little less worse off in the future.
- wernercd 6y agoThe term climate change took over global warming because of how laughable wrong all the "global warming" predictions failed to come true and disastrously so. Like most prophecies by religions do.
- ineedasername 6y agoThe global average temperature is increasing. How is that a failed prediction?
- wrycoder 6y ago15,000 years ago, there was ice a mile thick where I sit. We are still coming out of that glaciation. It is warming. C - catastrophic - there is no evidence in the historic temperature record that anything unusual is happening. A - anthropogenic - the human contribution is small, compared to natural sources. G - global - not local. W - warming - see above. In addition, there is no good evidence that the slight warming in the last 50 years is causing extreme weather events, and there isn’t any good theory to support it, either.
- tzs 6y ago> A - anthropogenic - the human contribution is small, compared to natural sources CO2 from burning fossil fuels and burning plants has a different isotope mix than does CO2 from other sources. We can use this to tell how much of the CO2 in the atmosphere comes from that kind of burning. There aren't enough wildfires or other natural sources to account for more than a small fraction of it. Hence, we can prove that most of that type CO2 comes from human sources. And that type account for most of the increase since pre-industrial times.
- tsimionescu 6y ago> C - catastrophic - there is no evidence in the historic temperature record that anything unusual is happening. There is no evidence in the historic temperature record that the Earth has ever been this hot in the past million years. > A - anthropogenic - the human contribution is small, compared to natural sources. The human contribution to CO2 and other greenhouse gases is not small, it is almost the entire quantity. There is very little contribution to greenhouse gas emissions from non-human sources (of course, methane from cows for example is a human source). > G - global - not local. Not sure what you mean here. > W - warming - see above. see above. > In addition, there is no good evidence that the slight warming in the last 50 years is causing extreme weather events, and there isn’t any good theory to support it, either. The brainwashing propaganda from interested science deniers is not better informed than the practically unanimous conclusions of all the earth's climate scientists. The Earth is headed for catastrophe, both ecologically and geopolitically. Sea level rise is already above initial predictions, and that effect alone will displace the 300 million people currently living in one of the lowest plains by the sea in the world, in Bangladesh. The coming migrant crisis at the confluence of India, Pakistan and China, three nuclear power with an uneasy relationship, would be cause for serious concern alone. Of course, the ever increasing droughts and extreme temperatures (including >50C wet-bulb temperatures, which can kill healthy adults outright) in those same regions makes them a literal hotbed for social and political upheaval like the world has never seen. You are simply deluded if you think everything is fine.
- Qwertious 6y agoThe propaganda against climate change did a number on awareness of climate change. Blaming people for not phrasing it perfectly is a secondary cause at most. FWIW a better phrase would be "climate destabilization".
- filoeleven 6y agoThat’s a good name for it. And to your other point, it must be emphasized that oil and coal companies knew about it 40+ years ago, and chose to fund opposition research and disinformation instead. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExxonMobil_climate_change_controversy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExxonMobil_climate_change_co... Exxon knew since the 1970s http://www.climatefiles.com/coal/mining-congress-journal-august-1965-air-pollution-and-the-coal-industry/ http://www.climatefiles.com/coal/mining-congress-journal-aug... Choice quote from this article in a 1966 coal journal: > If the future rate of increase continues as it is at the present, it has been predicted that, because the CO2 envelope reduces radiation, the temperature of the earth’s atmosphere will increase and that vast changes in the climates of the earth will result. Such changes in temperature will cause melting of the polar icecaps, which, in turn, would result in the inundation of many coastal cities, including New York and London.
- dillondoyle 6y agoI like Climate Catastrophe, because that's what we are in. Frank Luntz brags (exaggerates) about changing the vernacular to benefit the GOP/deniers - we should do the same to scare people into accepting and understanding the current reality.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoCatastrophizing doesn't work. It fuels extremism at worst and at best breeds distrust in experts. Covid19 has been a fantastic study on how not to handle global catastrophes.
- dillondoyle 6y agoJust because we can't handle the catastrophe doesn't mean we are not in one (multiple)
- undefined1 6y agoTexas is the leader in wind power in the US, and #2 in solar. https://www.kxan.com/weather/green-energy-report-where-does-texas-rank-in-solar-wind-nuclear-energy/ https://www.kxan.com/weather/green-energy-report-where-does-... If Texas were a country, it would rank fifth in the world: The installed wind capacity in Texas exceeds installed wind capacity in all countries but China, the United States, Germany and India. Texas produces the most wind power of any U.S. state. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Texas
- walrus01 6y agoand yet 85% of their grid power is produced from gas, oil and coal, a tiny portion from nuclear.
- sremani 6y agoTexas grid is about a quarter powered by Wind. Since Wind and Solar are dynamic - there may be variations and how they are measured, but to claim Texas Electric Portfolio is 85% fossil is not right numbers. Coal is almost dead and there is minimal oil for electric generation. Hawaii burns oil more than Texas. I think there are 2 nuclear power plants .. one is Comanche Peak which is south west of DFW, not sure of the other. edit: https://www.eia.gov/state/?sid=TX#tabs-4 https://www.eia.gov/state/?sid=TX#tabs-4 (click the electricity tab)
- arnmac 6y agoOther is the South Texas Nuclear Plant - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Texas_Nuclear_Generating_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Texas_Nuclear_Generating...
- stephenhuey 6y agoLocals call it STP. I’ve looked at the blinking lights on the domes from my aunt’s farmhouse since childhood. It provides power to 2 million homes a couple hundred miles away in central Texas.
- slibhb 6y agoThis is like the left-wing version of "Hurricane Katrina was a punishment for homosexuality". A mix of generalization, moralizing, and I-told-you-so. Just nasty.
- zmj 6y agoNo - predictions are different than post-dictions blaming the people you already didn't like.
- slibhb 6y agoYes, and this is the latter.
- NeutronStar 6y agoDid the homosexuals cause hurricane Katrina to exists? Did the burning of gas increase the likelyhood of climate change? See the difference?
- walrus01 6y agoclimate science is neither "left" nor "right" - If you believe that the IPCC and its various participants' scientific findings is some sort of vast left wing conspiracy, you probably live in an alternate-reality echo chamber. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intergovernmental_Panel_on_Climate_Change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intergovernmental_Panel_on_Cli...
- koolba 6y agoIf we can’t trust the WHO to give us honest answers about the sources and dangers of a pandemic virus, I don’t see why we’d default to trusting a similarly structured organization to give us honest answers about climate change research.
- dane-pgp 6y ago> honest answers about the sources and dangers of a pandemic virus The accuracy of answers about the source of a virus was very much dependent on the level of openness and cooperation from the jurisdiction in which the virus originated. Climate change, on the other hand, does not have a single geographical source, and therefore the IPCC is less limited in the information available to it. Similarly, I suspect that the WHO's early mistakes or inaccuracies in assessing the dangers of the virus were due to the fact that most of the early cases and mortality data were being collected in a single jurisdiction.
- metacritic12 6y agoI understand that global warming models predict more extreme events both hot and cold. However, at some point, empiricists will have to admit that global warming models will have no statistical power. To that end, what evidence of weather patterns would you have to see to believe less in the global warming model? Would years of "less extreme event days" make you believe in the global warming model any less?
- vitus 6y agoI would need to see average global surface temperature being uncoupled from atmospheric CO2 levels, sustained over a long period of time. Given that we have hundreds of thousands of years of climate records [0], that seems like a tall order. One cold spell does not disprove global warming. While Dallas might be experiencing abnormally low temps, Jacksonville's seeing uncharacteristic highs (86F today). [0] https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/global-warming/temperature-change https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/global-warming/temperature-change
- walrus01 6y agoGlobal warming models have no statistical power? I'm sure this well documented increase in atmospheric co2 will have no effect, then. https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/ https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/ If you spend 30 seconds googling you'll see that communities in the high Canadian arctic, alaska and greenland have been setting new temperature records on a regular basis. And the subsidence and melt of coastal permafrost in some areas is increasing at a rate that will soon look like a hockey stick curve on a chart.
- TheCoelacanth 6y ago> To that end, what evidence of weather patterns would you have to see to believe less in the global warming model? Certainly a decreasing average global temperature would do it. However, we are seeing a consistent upward trend in the global average[1] even if some regions have lower than normal temperatures. [1] https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/ https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/
- kryogen1c 6y ago> EXACTLY what was predicted 15-20 years ago a nitpick, but an important point: this is 100% not what was being said 20 years ago - thats why its called global warming and not the destruction of global weather patterns. thats also why all the sources you linked are less than two years old. the initial alarmism really shot itself in the foot by making specific predictions (ice caps melting, sea levels rising). we still arent even remotely close to being able to model the global weather system today. it really delegitimized the movement and slowed humanities reaction. they had to do this awful, awful position change and say "well, we were 100% wrong about all the predicitons we made but we're still right!" it helps explain how we ended up the way we are.
- smileysteve 6y ago> the initial alarmism really shot itself in the foot by making specific predictions (ice caps melting, sea levels rising) Checks notes, checks on venice and miami watches day after tomorrow, looks at Texas from hurricanes to ice Which of the predictions are looking like they're not progressing?
- xyzzyz 6y agoFor example, while we get tons of “extreme weather events” nobody was talking about 20-30 years ago, sea level rise that was announced very loudly and widely, is actually going to be relatively minor: in IPCC report, even in their most catastrophic RCP8.5 scenario, they scientific consensus is that the sea level are highly unlikely to rise by more than a meter by 2100; that’s less than a difference between low and high tide.
- walrus01 6y agoYou say that as if a meter will not have catastrophic impact on the world. Pacific island nation states, and sea level rise of a meter + a major cyclone hitting Bangladesh could set an all time casualty record for a single weather disaster. Even if it's half a meter average rise and not a full meter.
- beaner 6y agoThe point wasn't missed, because the predicate of global warming is not in question here. > And where else in the USA has been a bastion of oil/petrochemical industry climate change denialism, than Texas This is a ridiculous statement.
- walrus01 6y agoIt's factually true - unless you believe the phenomenon of climate change denialism itself does not exist. Follow the money. Who funds it? Primarily Houston headquartered oil and gas companies. Or if not headquartered in Houston, with very significant operations in texas and its oil industry. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dark-money-funds-climate-change-denial-effort/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dark-money-funds-...
- imgabe 6y agoWhat are you hoping to prove with this? In terms of what they are actually doing, it sounds like they're installing a lot of renewable energy. Indeed, more than most places. Do you also expect the Texas government to bust into oil and gas company headquarters and force them to say they believe in global warming? What does it matter who believes what if the real things that are actually happening are that they build a lot of renewable energy sources?
- filoeleven 6y ago> Do you also expect the Texas government to bust into oil and gas company headquarters and force them to say they believe in global warming? Expect them to? No. Wish for it? Yeah, definitely. And then hold them accountable for the decades of gaslighting while they knew that was the case. That’s kind of the role of a government. How is GameStop stock more controversial than climate change denial? GameStop is ephemeral, climate change is existential. The easy thing is to say “bankrupt the fuckers, kill the orgs!” and I feel that. I want to see them suffer for the path they’ve put the whole planet on. The responsible societal thing to do though is probably to mandate renewables, stop petro subsidies, and make them eat the cost for the switch if they (the orgs) want to stay alive. We have the evidence; it’s public knowledge now even if not widely disseminated. They’re adding renewables, but not fast enough because there is still profit to be made in petro even though it fucks us further. That has to stop ASAP. Governments are the place where that happens. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26189551 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26189551
- yspeak 6y agoWhat ?? None of that was mentioned in the article. The above is a summary of the article.
- kova12 6y agoYes you told us, and we didn't listen. You are so right, and we are such fools. We are so sorry.
- JamesBarney 6y agoAll the scientific evidence points to global warming is real and will cause more extreme heat events. But the science that global warming will cause more extreme cold events is on much more tenuous grounds. From the epa "Although the United States has experienced many winters with unusually low temperatures, unusually cold winter temperatures have become less common—particularly very cold nights (lows). Record-setting daily high temperatures have become more common than record lows. The decade from 2000 to 2009 had twice as many record highs as record lows."
- kinjba11 6y agoI recently watched an interesting video* on the phenomena of extreme cold events increased by climate change. To massively simplify, one theory is the jet stream around the Polar vortex is being destabilized by climate change. While the North Pole is warming faster than ever, it is still very cold air, and moving that air further south means unusually cold weather. The jury is still out of course as you mentioned. * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5W84bi9YEGY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5W84bi9YEGY
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoYeah I read a similar one; because of warming, the glaciers and melted ice melt, causing the sea to desalinate a bit, which in turn makes the gulf stream stop. This stops warm water from going north and vice versa, making the north colder and the south warmer. It was implied that this caused the ice in the last ice age to travel southward. I mean I hope it won't happen in my lifetime, there were kilometers of ice on my country.
- bostik 6y agoOn a large scale, it's basic physics. The jet streams are driven by temperature gradient: warm air from equatorial regions flows to the cold poles, warming up the regions inbetween. The planet is not heating up uniformly, poles are heating up more than the equatorial regions. This of course means that the temperature gradient between the hot and cold realms is not as steep as it was. Net result? Weaker jet streams. Now it appears that moving heat from the equator to the (northern) high latitudes was only a part of the equation in keeping these latitudes temperate. Confining the freezing polar vortex to the pole was another. I'm sure there are others, and the population at large is going to learn about them in some very instructive ways in the future.
- refurb 6y agoDoes this storm constitute an unusual weather pattern? If I do a check for record lows in Houston, none of them are 2021. And we set records all the time. Many of them set in the 1800’s when climate change wasn’t an issue. Setting a record is hardly proof.
- tpetry 6y agoIn my opinion naming it global warming was the biggest mistake. People hear it‘s getting hotter, don‘t see this effect and „don‘t believe in it“. Events like this is another point why people don‘t believe in global warming, they see very cold weather outside where this is very untypical and say global warming is bullshit. It should have only been named climate change, drastic wheather change or something incorporating your naming of shifting wheather patterns.
- netflixandkill 6y agoNobody had a problem with it being "global warming" until the mid 90s when political interests made a culture war point. They would have done so regardless of how accurately the phrase described the phenomenon.
- will4274 6y agoIt's a little bit more complicated than that. The primary "extreme weather" predictions I remember from 20 years ago was more hurricanes. We do seem to observe and name more hurricanes (in part, at least, due to much better weather equipment), but fewer hurricanes have made landfall in the United States. https://www.statista.com/statistics/621238/number-of-hurricanes-that-made-landfall-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/621238/number-of-hurrica.... Other extreme weather statistics are similar - we spend a lot of time talking about polar vortexes (vertices?), but many of the cold records are from back in the 1930s. I don't doubt that the world's temperature is rising, but I continue to view the extreme weather predictions as fairly speculative and a distraction from the core issues - temperature rising, ice melting, sea level rising, with unpredictable effects. If you had some more academic (and less click-funded) sources to share related to data demonstrating the extreme weather hypothesis, I'd be interested in taking a look.
- thu2111 6y agoBut the whole point of the article is that these events are not especially unusual, that they have happened quite a few times before, including several times in the last decade alone. One problem with the Texas outages is everyone seems to be trying to cast it in terms of pre-existing viewpoints on environmentalism. None of them really fit. Clearly, the Texas outages weren't really caused by wind farms and attempts to tie them to that require quite indirect arguments of the form, "if they hadn't built wind farms they'd have built more gas plants instead". There might be something in that line of argument if developed further, e.g. if it's easier to 'winterize' gas plants than wind farms. But it's not there yet. At the same time, trying to tie this to CO2 increases is also reaching. People who keep ignoring the poor track record of climatology look increasingly like the true "climate deniers". Here's just one fairly typical example of a prediction, an article from 2011 by a professor of atmospheric sciences: https://www.chron.com/opinion/outlook/article/Texas-is-vulnerable-to-warming-climate-2079164.php https://www.chron.com/opinion/outlook/article/Texas-is-vulne... "It is a particularly appropriate read as we suffer through the hellish summer of 2011. While it is unknown exactly how much human activities are contributing to this summer's unpleasant weather, one lesson from the book is clear: Get used to it. The weather of the 21st century will be very much like the hot and dry weather of 2011." And from the article we're reading now: "The earliest report I could find was from the 2011 winter event in Texas[14]. A very strong cold front hit Texas (and other parts of the south central US) bringing temperatures below freezing for over 4 days and winds over 30 MPH." Maybe the difficulty the US has in funding winterization of the power grid is because professors keep telling them the future will be really hot and really dry all the time? Obviously if you're generous enough to these sorts of predictions then you can find ways to argue they're "nearly right", but it's too often taken to an extreme that leads to unfalsifiability. No matter what happens to the weather, it's always because of CO2.
- kllvql 6y agoThis isn't quite what you said, as your comment spoke about the energy industry specifically, but I decided to see if there was any data on people's beliefs about climate change by state. I found this interesting site from a program on Climate Change Communication from Yale, and it allows you to view the results on various questions related to climate change by state. My conclusion from clicking through a few of these is that Texas is close to the national average in climate change beliefs. Some numbers: Global warming happening 71% (-1 from Avg), Caused by humans 56% (-1 from Avg), Support regulating CO2 72% (-3 from Avg), Expand offshore drilling 57% (+5 from Avg) https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us/ https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/yc...
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoDue to the broken nature of American politics; what Texans believe on any single issue doesn't really matter unless Texans can organize better than the vested interests paying for climate change denial in policy.
- Shivetya 6y agoTheir last major event was 2011 for Texas so they aren't becoming more common. They did act on many recommendations from that event but no one would have predicted a storm of that magnitude. Similar to how the some Southern states suffered a once in 100 if not 1000 year flood in 2009 that has not reoccurred though similar declarations it was going to be common. Lets not even get into the doom and gloom after Katrina followed by the absolute lack of any storms for years. As in, FUD only ends up defeating arguments because every dire prediction is bound to fail. You get real change by showing people what the benefits are to every day life not based on some biblical level type hysteria. Texas is one of the leaders in wind and solar so I am not sure where you are coming from other than succumbing to the unfortunately common parroting of facts that don't apply to the situation. So summary, Texas and the nation need to have a common and joined grid management program but for reasons of providing stability and growth. Don't lead off with telling people they have to have it because of climate change as too many will tune you out and for good reason, the conversation tends to hysterics and theater more than reality.
- spacedcowboy 6y agoOne of the worst names ever coined is "global warming". To the layman, it simply means things getting hotter, and that's not what it means at all. Earth's climate system is an energy matrix, a complex interoperation between co-operating systems, all driven by energy, all "seeking" lower energy states at the expense of other systems. Some of that energy does indeed go into warming (melting ice, sea temperature rise, ...) but a huge chunk just makes these energetic systems more energetic because of a lack of suitable energy sink. Put a glass beaker full of water on a lab-stirrer, and you're going to get the occasional splash, but replace the 9v battery-driven motor with a Harley Davidson (you know, to force way more energy into the system) and you're going to get a whole lot more splashes. Splashes are bad. Forcing energy into immense, complex, non-linear dynamical chaotic systems that literally govern our existence on this planet is not a good idea if you want to continue to exist on this planet. All you're doing with "global warming" is giving these systems far more phase-space to explore, and we just don't have the knowledge or experience to predict what some of the solutions those systems can explore will do. I still feel it ought to have been christened "energy death of the planet" or similar (akin to the heat-death of the universe". Something that the tabloids could grab hold of and point out disasters as we creep, seemingly inexorably, towards a tipping point we may not recover well from. [sigh]
- exclusiv 6y ago> that's not what it means at all That's exactly what it used to mean. But then it wasn't warming and they had to revisit.
- rsj_hn 6y agoMissed one point: There has not been increase in cold weather events in Texas. Rather, the shift to energy producing technologies that are more susceptible to going offline in cold weather is why Texas is now going offline more often. Back when people burned coal for electricity, it was a lot dirtier but did not suffer the issue of windmills freezing. Attempts to politicize this issue and hijack it for whatever crusade you are waging means that the Texas grid wont be made more reliable, and this is going to be a growing problem in other areas that are beginning to rely more on energy sources that are subject to being disrupted by cold weather.