34 ms·
Ercot nearly at capacity for Texas power grid
- slater 6y agoERCOT: The Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) manages the flow of electric power on the Texas Interconnection that supplies power to more than 25 million Texas customers – representing 90 percent of the state's electric load. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_Reliability_Council_of_Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_Reliability_Council_o...
- mike_d 6y agoHere is a bit more informative article with the background for non-Texans: https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/14/texas-rolling-blackouts/ https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/14/texas-rolling-blacko...
- sam1r 6y agoThanks for posting this! First year here [in HTX] and the weather apparently [for born and raised texan locals] is weird.
- rossdavidh 6y agoTexan here. I tried, on Thursday, to buy a space heater; not only was the hardware store out, they told me a list of other places around town that were also out. Most homes use natural gas for heat, but I think a lot of space heaters are probably turned on right now. I also have to wonder how an everyone-videoconference-from-home society changes electricity usage? Not saying it has a significant impact, just wondering. It is odd for Texas to have peak electricity usage in the winter; especially anywhere other than north Texas, we usually get threatened with rolling blackouts when it's 110 degrees and everyone has their A/C cranked up, not in the middle of the winter.
- ddreier 6y agoSeveral articles have said that only 40% of homes in Texas use natural gas for heat. https://climatecrocks.com/2021/02/14/the-eyes-of-texas-are-on-ercot/ https://climatecrocks.com/2021/02/14/the-eyes-of-texas-are-o...
- enraged_camel 6y agoThat actually makes sense since the lower half of the state rarely gets cold enough to warrant a complex heating setup.
- bob1029 6y agoI have lived in Texas all my life and this figure surprises me. Every home I have ever lived in or rented has had a gas furnace, even if some of the appliances are electric. I've never even lived north of ATX, so this makes even less sense to me. Why would we be building out all these homes in the Houston area with insanely powerful gas furnaces? The home I am in right now could easily get to 80F+ in this current ambient weather if I let the furnace run constantly. But, my 5 ton AC struggles in the summer to pull 30 degrees of delta. This stuff really staggers me sometimes. As a counterpoint, I also have a friend who lives in the downtown area with new construction (completed late 2019) and its a heat pump/resistive setup. He is on griddy and not having a good time right now. Perhaps its some economics thing with home builders and supply chains, rather than rational application of engineering talent.
- Krisjohn 6y ago> I also have to wonder how an everyone-videoconference-from-home society changes electricity usage? Not saying it has a significant impact, just wondering. Well, anecdotally, my office is the only room that doesn't need heating.
- jjeaff 6y agoI'm thinking it must take quite a bit more energy to heat all those big sprawling Texas homes to a comfortable temp during the day than the relative efficiency you can get for heating a building full of tightly packed offices. But this would be more of an issue with cooling since it is hotter mid-day. Whereas with cold, it gets colder at night, and most people are at home at night anyway.
- TylerE 6y agoOTOH, the homes are probably gonna be heated somewhat anyway, even if no one as homes, and if the offices are shutdown, it's probably a net win.
- deniablenexus 6y ago> I also have to wonder how an everyone-videoconference-from-home society changes electricity usage? Not saying it has a significant impact, just wondering I work in the industry in TX and we've seen noticeable changes in both usage patterns and amounts. Most notable in the early morning hours as people are waking up and getting ready to work. A whole lot more people are waking up, checking emails, and keeping lights on at home rather then driving to the office.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoIf you have anything else that can use a significant amount of power (e.g. electric stove/hotplate, kettle, gaming rig, bitcoin miner), it's just as efficient as a space heater. This also means that if your alternative is running a resistive heater, there's no meaningful extra cost to e.g. mining cryptocurrencies with your GPU (assuming you have decent cooling so your components don't get damaged from overheating).
- foxhop 6y agoGet incandescent light bulbs and heat a small room. I use a 200 watt bulb to keep me toasty at my desk in Connecticut Zone 6B
- throwawayboise 6y agoWind farms can't operate in icing conditions.
- pxeboot 6y agoSource? I have personally seen one operating in Alaska during the winter.
- throwawayboise 6y agoIt's not the temperature per se, it's icing. I read it here https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-14/deep-freeze-sends-gas-soaring-to-600-over-the-long-u-s-weekend https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-14/deep-free... “When wind-turbine blades get covered with ice, they need to be shut down,” said Joshua Rhodes, a research associate at The University of Texas at Austin who focuses on energy.
- bombcar 6y agoA windmill is basically a inverse airplane - and airplane wings don’t like icing. I assume you could heat the blades but at some point you’re consuming more energy than you’re making.
- o-__-o 6y agoPlanes have deicing boots. Holes in the leading edge of the wing that has a balloon on the inside. A non freezing gel is usually pumped in which expands the balloon out of the hole and causes the ice to crack. It then retracts and this process repeats keeping the wing clear of ice.
- bearbin 6y agoNot really usable for wind turbines though, the energy cost would be significant first of all (compare the blade area of a wind turbine to a plane!) The bigger issue is maintenance. Wind turbine leading edges are a very hostile environment compared to a plane and even normal materials get abraded very quickly, plus they are expected to last for many years without significant maintenance. Anti-ice systems would just not be economical if they had to be maintained to a working condition at all times.
- mimikatz 6y agoTexas is shockingly green when it comes to power. The windmills have frozen and it is the winter when there isn't as much sun. Most people are on a contract with fixed pricing, but some startups like Griddy are hurting people's wallets. We will likely see some retail electric company bankrupcies. Some of the electric providers are paying customers to move to someone else on Monday. The Joke is all the Californians who immigrated brought the blackouts with them.
- ryanmarsh 6y ago>We will likely see some retail electric company bankrupcies. REP's go bankrupt all the time, especially when the weather gets funny. As WallStreetsBets says, "Sir, this is a casino".
- nickysielicki 6y agoGriddy literally emailed every customer yesterday and told them to switch providers asap.
- shiftpgdn 6y agoYep. I was on track for a $5000 electric bill at the end of the week. I got switched over yesterday. Still going to be painful but not horrible.
- slater 6y ago$5k?!?!? How?!
- ev1 6y ago$0.05 to $0.10/kWh seems like normal pricing. Average US house uses ~1100-1200 kWh (I don't actually know this, based on googling, assuming most places in Texas are standalone houses) per month. If prices are $3000-9000 per MW, then ~40 to 60 kWh/day (let's be generous, people are explicitly turning on heat for this extreme cold) for a week... Even $2/kWh (which was exceeded days ago) would demolish peoples' budgets.
- fencepost 6y agoSeems like this is where a generator and appropriate hookup for powering (primarily?) a gas furnace might not be a terrible thing. Unfortunately almost all homes regardless of source will lose heat if the power goes out because of fans and furnace control.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pram 6y agoI was just looking at natural gas powered generators because of this. I've had an accumulative 24 hours of outages in the past month. They don't seem bad, the units themselves are around $6k. Definitely worth considering!
- jounker 6y agoIf you’re just looking for emergence power you can get honda e2200i generator with a gas adapter for around 1500 USD.
- phonebanshee 6y agoMost people around here (Pacific Northwest) do propane. No one wants to store large quantities of gasoline on their property.
- oasisbob 6y agoYup, especially when those tanks of propane work for hot water and cooking too. There's a lot of crossover with RVs, industrial, and even marine when you use propane. The cabin I'm writing this from has a battery bank and a standby generator salvaged from a touring bus.
- ericbarrett 6y agoPropane is quite expensive compared to natural gas, though, especially from a fixed-line utility. Except maybe this weekend!
- walrus01 6y agoIt is kind of weird and worrisome that such a large entity doesn't use https Look at the weird error message... https://www.ercot.com/ https://www.ercot.com/ The rest of the site appears to be http only What's funny is that they do have a valid certificate for their error message page.
- ev1 6y agoThere's a cloudflare-like MITM in the middle that is serving https.
- idlewords 6y agoEncryption uses too much power
- selimthegrim 6y agoSo that’s why Kirk always had to bother poor Scotty
- qwantim1 6y agoAnd so does growing massive amounts of pot and mining bitcoin. Will these things stop? Probably not.
- xxpor 6y ago
- don-code 6y agoSome time ago, I worked for a defunct energy company that provided demand-side relief in exactly this scenario - when total system load outstrips total system capacity, we'd begin taking actions on behalf of end users, not the utility. Lights would turn off, generators would spin up, fridge temperatures would be raised. ERCOT (Texas) is an interesting case in that it can't import power from other states as easily - it has its "own grid" at 60Hz, but not necessarily in phase with either of the other two major grids in the country (there's eastern US, western US, and "most of Texas"). So to import power, it first has to convert grid-scale amounts of energy from AC to DC, then back to AC, which incurs a pretty significant loss.
- cameronh90 6y agoPreface: I know very little about power grids, but had a couple thoughts. In the UK, there is a system of load shedding that is tied to the grid frequency. My understanding is that some industrial users agree terms where they get cheaper rates but if the demand outstrips supply, they are first to be cut. This load shedding is implemented by components that monitor the grid frequency, and if it drops below a fixed value, it disconnects. It seemed a nice system to me as in theory it operates just based on the principles of an AC power supply. Secondly, the UK has its own grid but is linked up to the EU grid with asynchronous HVDC connectors. We get a lot of our energy though those. Is this inefficient?
- martinald 6y agoNo, not really. As far as I'm aware HVDC links are more efficient than AC links (even with AC/DC/AC conversion).
- jcampbell1 6y agoIt looks like a tradeoff. The only place in the world doing a significant amount of long distance transmission is China. Their wind and coal resources are in the west, and demand is in the east, and transporting coal by rail just further increases air quality problems in the east. Based on what they are implementing, HVDC make sense at 800km+, and AC for shorter runs. I think it comes down to HVDC requires less conductor due to the AC skin effect, weighed against cost/loss for DC->AC. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-voltage_electricity_transmission_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-voltage_electricity...
- centimeter 6y agoIt frustrates me how most analysis of wind and solar cost-effectiveness fail to take into account the need to have tons of backup infrastructure that lays fallow most of the time. You need to decide between poor grid reliability or drastically increased capital expenditures. Hopefully storage tech will get better and this will cease to be such a problem.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoYou're right but you're getting downvoted by people who believe anything Big Green tells them. It's just like Big Oil, Big Tobacco, Big Pharma, etc.: all the suckers bought the religion and won't know they're suckers for 40 years. By that time a new, equally unsuspecting generation will mock us while swallowing the next Big Industry talking points uncritically.
- fghorow 6y ago"...lays fallow most of the time." https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-09-02/tesla-battery-expanded-as-sa-energy-minister-lauds-benefits/12622382 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-09-02/tesla-battery-expande...
- mlyle 6y agoBatteries solve a different problem. They can smooth over daily shortfalls, but aren't so great when you have a week-long aberration. To fix that, you need significant overprovisioning or alternate means of generation. That is, if you depend upon wind and wind is screwed up for a week... batteries aren't going to let you stretch limited solar all night long.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> To fix that, you need significant overprovisioning or alternate means of generation. They have alternate means of generation... natural gas. There is a big problem with wells shutting down due to the same extremes which shut down wind. Which has caused shortages of natural gas which is doubly problematic because it's also used extensively for heating. What do you do when your backup power is vulnerable to the same issues as your primary power? It is arguably a fantastic example of where nuclear power excels. Particularly if you had a nuclear plant which ran well below capacity most of the time and ramped up when we have extreme needs.
- jweir 6y agoERCOT is the only energy market not to have a capacity market. Combine this with a large dependency on wind(unreliable) and you see problems. This is not the first time has happened. Summer of 2019 saw a heat wave with no wind that lasted a week. Energy prices were way up. https://cpowerenergymanagement.com/why-doesnt-texas-have-a-capacity-market/ https://cpowerenergymanagement.com/why-doesnt-texas-have-a-c... Ps - I just checked the prices for northern Hub - day ahead was over $6,500 and real time around $4,500 per MW for 8pm. Last Sunday both prices were around $25.
- hourislate 6y agoFrom what I understand, it's not that there is no wind. 50% of the Turbines have been shut down do to icing. The also have some NatGas suppliers that suffered freezing damage. So it's a combination of things that are adding up. I'm in North Texas and I can't remember temps this low in the last 30 years. It's about 13 degrees (- 10 C) at the moment and it looks like it is going to get a lot colder in the coming days.
- jweir 6y agoCorrect. The summer of 2019 was no wind. Today’s problem is ice.
- grendelt 6y agoI'm guessing ice is such a rare problem the turbines in Texas aren't equipped to handle it. Not that turbines can't de-ice themselves, right? Surely if they can operate in the North Sea, they can operate in West and South Texas, yeah?
- jweir 6y agoI am not familiar with turbine technology. But I do know wind farms is ISO-NE (New England) have shutdown from ice. Just a quick bit of reading describes the challenges - historically the solutions have been expensive and not very good. One article said there is some promising new technology. Here is that article (or press release - I know nothing of the source) https://www.windpowerengineering.com/the-cold-hard-truth-about-ice-on-turbine-blades/ https://www.windpowerengineering.com/the-cold-hard-truth-abo...
- bloaf 6y agoNatural gas prices have been absolutely wild the past few days. https://www.naturalgasintel.com/weekly-natural-gas-prices-soar-as-polar-vortex-unleashes-brutal-cold-on-u-s/ https://www.naturalgasintel.com/weekly-natural-gas-prices-so... If you're not used to their bizarre units of volume the key takaway is this: Quantities of gas that usually sell for ~ $3 were selling for over $300 on Friday/Saturday.
- dehrmann 6y agoHow isolated are different natural gas networks in the US?
- maxerickson 6y agoNot a direct answer, but you can adjust the active layers on https://www.eia.gov/state/maps.php https://www.eia.gov/state/maps.php to show pipelines. It's pretty well interconnected.
- dehrmann 6y agoConnections only halfway answers it capacity is also a big part of this.
- bloaf 6y agoVirtually everything is interconnected [0], but some regions are more connected than others. All the producers and consumers know how much it costs to ship to/from different hubs, including Asia and Europe, and will do so very quickly whenever it becomes economic. As you can probably tell from the wikipedia graph, the gulf is heavily plumbed. In addition to the shipping and processing in the gulf, there are also massive storage caverns [1] that can buffer most swings in demand. Different US regions have their own storage hubs [2] but the reason that lots of natural gas-related prices have "Mont Belvieu" in the name is that Mont Belvieu TX is basically the biggest storage hub and serves as the benchmark for everyone else. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas_pipeline_system_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas_pipeline_system_in... [1] https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/news/2015/10/19/124674/on-edge-of-houston-underground-caverns-store-huge-quantities-of-natural-gas-liquids/ https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/news/2015/10/19/... [2] https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_stor_wkly_s1_w.htm https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_stor_wkly_s1_w.htm Edit: wikipedia has a pretty good overview here, but it is a little dated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas_storage
- adrianmonk 6y agoHere's their news release about it: http://www.ercot.com/news/releases/show/225151 http://www.ercot.com/news/releases/show/225151 That links to this PDF which describes their emergency procedures: http://www.ercot.com/content/wcm/lists/200198/EEA_OnePager_updated_9-4-20.pdf http://www.ercot.com/content/wcm/lists/200198/EEA_OnePager_u... Basically, there are 3 levels of response: (1) Reserves below 2,300 MW: get more power, including from other grids. (2) Reserves below 1,750 MW: interrupt power to industrial customers (who've contractually agreed). (3) Reserves below 1,375 MW: order transmission companies to reduce demand (i.e. rolling blackouts). The reserves are shown on their main page (http://www.ercot.com/ http://www.ercot.com/), and when I've checked today, it has been roughly 3,500-4000 MW. So that sort of sounds promising, but the graphs on the same page (projected capacity and demand) don't look as promising.
- svnpenn 6y agoUh, were at 1210 mw right now
- milofeynman 6y agoWhen I go to that page I see "Operating Reserves: 3,126 MW"
- nrmitchi 6y agoI suspect the person you're responding to is using the featured link (real-time conditions) and looking at the diff between system capacity and current demand, which doesn't match the current operating reserves on the ercot homepage.
- RNanoware 6y ago1.21 gigawatts? Do you have any idea how much energy that is? The only power source capable triggering that kind of energy is a bolt of lightning. It would have to be a real wall-shaker, big enough to stop a clock! (I mean this as purely a bit of comic relief. Texas is in dire straits right now, and I wish the people and infrastructure all the best in this time.)
- bouncycastle 6y agoI wonder how much this has to do with bitcoin mining?
- CydeWeys 6y agoMiners are being turned off at these electricity prices.
- ncmncm 6y agoExcept in places where the power is being stolen.
- ideamotor 6y agoExample? I'm not sure what you mean by "stolen" but I'm sure there's a ton of mining that is occurring at a statutory or downstream low-rate (as opposed to C&I based on peak or wholesale subject to the real-time market). In those cases, the electric providers should be able to pay them to curtail load but it's frankly a travesty on all accounts.
- sdflhasjd 6y agoI think you're overthinking it. It's just regular stealing, something that would be more historically associated with Marijuana grow-ops. Bypassing your meter, tapping off your neighbours meter, street lighthing, mining in your employers basement without them knowing, etc. Basically using electricity that isn't "yours" without paying for it.
- ncmncm 6y agoThis is easier in countries with more retail corruption, and in some with wholesale. The latter would include Russia, China, and the US; the former, Venezuela, UAE, Nigeria. Retail would tend to be petrochemical power. Nuclear power theft is easier to cover up, so would be preferred where it is common, e.g. Russian military sites and US commercial.
- sjg007 6y agoWeird.. you'd think with the AC demand in the summer they'd have enough capacity for winter..
- ameetgaitonde 6y agoI think the problem is that homes are also designed to cool, efficiently, which is why many a/c and heater units are in the attic with vents in the ceiling. This means that they tend to heat homes more inefficiently than in places that are used to very cold weather.
- AgentOrange1234 6y agoIIRC air conditioning is generally less demanding because you’re ‘only’ trying to drop the temp by ~30F to get back into the 70s on a hot 100F day, whereas for heat you’re trying to increase by a much larger 50-70F on a cold 0-20F day. I’m sure wishing the house was better insulated today (Austin).
- sjg007 6y agoThe insulation thing is weird because better insulation saves you in the summer too. I guess it's just the construction fixed cost. Electric heat seems like a weird compromise though considering the gulf of Mexico..
- maxerickson 6y agoElectric heat is great if you don't use heat consistently. Relatively inexpensive up front, low maintenance, etc.
- eckza 6y agoIt's curious that the current tide of public opinion reckons that we're all going to be in EVs in 10-15 years, when the grid nearly collapses under the weight of everybody plugging in a heater and turning on Netflix at the same time.
- brundolf 6y agoIt's not that the capacity can't be mustered, it's that it can't be mustered overnight.
- chrismcb 6y agoNot exactly public opinion when places like California are manadating it
- toomuchtodo 6y agoWhat is the cost to build power grids to support days of weather a geography doesn’t experience for decades at a time (it has been 30 years since Texas was this cold)? Would people pay more versus suffer through some power outages?
- rtpg 6y ago"Netflix" is not even 10% of a heater. Heating is so much more energy-costly than basically anything you do in your home. Granted, seems like if you're driving ~40-60 miles a day, then you're looking at needing 4kW during the evenings. Not insignificant, but it's like... electric heating for one big room, basically.
- unethical_ban 6y agoWhat's your point? That EV conversion shouldn't be a goal? That because of a freak, instant spike in demand in 2020 means grids and production can't be more robust in 2035? A TV pulls what, 50-100 watts? A space heater pulls 1500W on high. Now think about many people who, for better or worse, are running multiple space heaters in their house. Now imagine millions of households doing that, on two days' notice.
- fogihujy 6y ago
- supernova87a 6y agoProblem is that: 1) People's use of energy is relatively insensitive to price, or they don't know the price, or few people care about the price when it comes time to need it 2) When you need the energy, it's too late to make the equipment/house more efficient, and when you don't need it, people don't think it's important to make it more efficient 3) Mandating that people upgrade their equipment is unpopular, they vote against it, yet when they get hit with the bill for the energy later, they're unhappy with government for not having done more to control it. It's a thankless job, to be sure. Good thing taking away people's incandescent bulbs was recognized as a threat to democracy and stopped.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoDo you still have incandescent bulbs in the US? Its really hard to find them here in Australia. I thought they were banned but I just read that they are not, but have been phased out.
- evan_ 6y agoThere was an incandescent bulb phase out over several years that was supposed to end in 2020, but Trump blocked it because he claimed that LED bulbs were too expensive and made him look orange.[0] You pretty much can’t buy them anymore at stores except for specialty bulbs like oven lamps, but that might vary state-to-state. 0: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/20/climate/trump-light-bulb-rollback.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/20/climate/trump-light-bulb-...
- TheGrim-999 6y agoSo, someone at the Department of Energy that was hired in 2012, under Obama, made a ruling, and that's translated by the NYTimes as the "Trump Administration" doing it, which then gets referenced as "Trump blocked it because they make him look orange". Fake news in action, folks.
- 8ytecoder 6y ago
- chasd00 6y agoi'm in Dallas, power has been stable so far but i made sure i got ye'olde generator out, checked the oil, and got plenty of gas. My house is really old and the cold just slowly creeps in. By Tuesday i bet i can't get it over 60 inside. All of my furnaces run on gas at least but if the power goes they'll probably turn off. I have a little bit of firewood for the fireplace but not enough to heat the whole house that's for sure. i was contemplating just basically evacuating wife and kids to San Antonio or something but the whole state is under a winter storm warning.
- v64 6y agoWe just had two brief blackouts (~15m and ~5m) over here in SW Fort Worth
- Aloha 6y agoI'm in FW right by DFW, and my apartment is cold even when its warm right now. Similarly, I dug my cold man lanterns out and fueled them, just to be sure.
- bombcar 6y agoIf possible shed load on the furnace - close vents in rooms that don't have water pipes in them and close the doors to those rooms - focus the heat on a smaller area. Try to keep rooms that have less "outside wall" area as the main focal point for people and heat. Move computers into the main room, keep people together if possible.
- foxhop 6y agoColocate people into a small room, air mattresses and use incandescent bulb to warm the people and room.
- gwbas1c 6y agoFWIW: I have a Powerwall and solar. My electric company offers no incentive for me to use my powerwall, or to feed into the grid during high demand.
- mmglr 6y agoin these conditions would it make a difference?
- gwbas1c 6y agoYes. It's in the grid's best interest that I store power generated during daylight and trickle it back during the night. Texas's problem has to do with its electric plants inability to operate in cold weather. Fortunately, domestic solar doesn't have that kind of limitation.
- bombcar 6y agoThe incentive comes during an EEA 3 when they simply cut power to your house for 30-45 minutes.
- Aloha 6y agoI knew it was bad, when my electricity provider was raffling off a Tesla for reducing usage.
- austincheney 6y agoRolling blackouts are in effect. What I have noticed is that if you drastically minimize your power consumption you drastically increase your odds of being spared from the blackouts. The observation is based upon neighborhood data posted by various homeowners to our community page.
- bombcar 6y agoThey blackout on a home to home level? In CA it was whole towns
- milofeynman 6y agoThey blackout neighborhoods here I believe. My guess is that neighborhoods that largely heat with natural gas are spared, as they don't use a ton of electricity.
- bombcar 6y agoThat makes sense - if you're going to blackout you want to start with the "highest loads" (perhaps per capita? per household?) so as to reduce the number of blackouts you have to cause. Better 10k people lose power than 50k. Though if 60% of Texas homes are electric heat then you have to consider that, too, and how long it takes a 60º house to get to 40 (any lower and you begin to risk health and water damage). I assume they'd roll the blackouts and no neighborhood would be without power for more than a few hours.
- bombcar 6y agoAh, looking at the EEA 3 alert: http://www.ercot.com/eea_info/show/26464 http://www.ercot.com/eea_info/show/26464 In these situations, each utility is required to lower the demand on its system based on its percentage of the historic ERCOT peak demand. While each utility is responsible for determining how to implement the required demand reduction, most utilities use rotating outages for this purpose. Rotating outages primarily affect residential neighborhoods and small businesses and are typically limited to 10 to 45 minutes before being rotated to another location.
- lgregg 6y agoYeah normally 11 cents per kWh but right now am at $4.24 per kWh.
- jeffbee 6y agoThe main difference between this and California rolling outages last August is the conspicuous lack of ten-thousand-word think-pieces about how it was the inevitable consequence of a failing one-party regime. Climate change is going to result in local excursions in heating and cooling demand. It's just stochastic bad luck.
- jabl 6y agoI'm sure you'll find the usual blowhards explaining how Biden is personally responsible for this.
- macintux 6y agoNah, but I’m sure they’ll be shouting about how wonderful coal is vs that unreliable renewable power.
- imtringued 6y agoAnd gas somehow didn't fail?
- macintux 6y agoI didn’t say it was a cogent argument.
- foxhop 6y agoIt's grand solar minimum, industry not preparing infra for cold snaps, uniformed population who gave up their incandescent bulbs (heaters) for LEDs and power hungry space heaters, people wasting energy. It's not just bad luck.
- gregwebs 6y agoDo power saving recommendations given out here to reduce consumption such as "don't use the oven" help in the winter given that wasted electricity ends up as heat? Or is this given by the electricity company hoping that they have natural gas to heat their house with instead?
- axiolite 6y agoBeside natural gas, heat pumps have become popular. Ballpack a heat pump at about 1/3rd as much electricity for a given amount of heat, compared to a resistive heater. Even (larger capacity) hot water heaters come with heat pumps now.
- bombcar 6y agoIf you have GAS you should use the oven and furnace as much as you can and shut off electricity. If you have electric heat it doesn’t really matter either way. (Pro tip - if you have a gas or propane oven but a electric furnace/baseboard now is a great time to run the self cleaning cycle. The oven will get to 500+ degrees and heat your kitchen up real nice.)
- peter_retief 6y agoI am blocked from the site? Access Denied Error 16 www.ercot.com 2021-02-15 05:18:28 UTC
- foepys 6y agoIt seems like someone or some DDoS detection blocked either everything or all foreign IPs.
- p_l 6y agoLooks like the "GDPR doesn't allow to spy on users, let's block anyone who could be covered by it" kind of block.
- jabl 6y agoI've been able to view the ERCOT site before, so probably not. At this point it makes sense for them to prioritize getting information out to residents rather than us foreigners with an idle interest. :)
- nottorp 6y agoYup, guess they turned on some crisis plan. Which is targeted more at those evil hackers outside the US than at an actual capacity problem :)
- cientifico 6y agoSame here. Your IP: 91.64.84.221 Error code: 16 > This request was blocked by the security rules It might be requests from outside the United States. Anyway: * The cache from google: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.ercot.com%2Fcontent%2Fcdr%2Fhtml%2Freal_time_system_conditions.html&oq=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.ercot.com%2Fcontent%2Fcdr%2Fhtml%2Freal_time_system_conditions.html&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i58.2735j0j1&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%... * Arhive.org https://web.archive.org/web/20210215030515/http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/real_time_system_conditions.html https://web.archive.org/web/20210215030515/http://www.ercot....
- killjoywashere 6y agoTexas-affiliated energy businesses holding their customers hostage for the global warming* events they said no one needed to worry about. This would be some world's smallest fiddle shit but for the fact I have family in the state. Global warming means more extreme heat and* more extreme cold.
- xvilka 6y agoA perfect case for the nuclear energy.
- kaibee 6y agoThis is like, the worst possible case for nuclear energy, because this is a random fluctuation that won't be sustained for more than week. Whereas building a nuclear power plant costs billions of dollars and takes multiple decades to pay for itself.
- bob1029 6y agoIndeed - traditional nuclear power plants which cost billions of dollars per reactor unit and are wrapped up in mountains of politics are not the future. I think SpaceX has demonstrated the impact rapid iteration, modularization and standardization can have on billion-dollar+ capex projects. There are SMR technologies that have already passed important phases of regulatory approval. Proposed nuclear technologies, such as from NuScale, will hypothetically be far more responsive to grid conditions than traditional nuclear power plants. Their current design can immediately reject 100% of thermal energy on demand. Power can be added or removed from the grid in increments as small as 77MW with their solution. This level of granularity is easily on-par with existing peaker plant capabilities.
- pfdietz 6y agoNone of those are the capital cost of a simple cycle gas turbine powerplant (maybe $400/kW).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 6y agoI'd guess the insulation in most of the homes down there isn't great? If so, please take a moment to turn on any faucets with pipes that run along an exterior wall. Just do it a tiny bit, so that it drips every few seconds. Otherwise when it gets warmer you may have burst pipes to worry about. Good luck Texas!
- salawat 6y agoYeah... Guess who woke to the rolling blackout tonight and found that the faucets weren't working? Time to get out the heat gun and go frozen pipe hunting I guess... Though god knows how that'll go with PVC...
- diogenescynic 6y agoAnd more and more people keep moving to Texas.
- ranieuwe 6y agoAnd Ercot [1] "has declared an EEA 1. Energy conservation is needed. There are no rotating outages at this time. 00:17:45 150221" [1] https://twitter.com/ERCOT_ISO/status/1361197991659503618 https://twitter.com/ERCOT_ISO/status/1361197991659503618
- WookieRushing 6y agoIt’s now EEA 2
- gonzo 6y agoERCOT just declared EEA-2 at 1:13am local Texas time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 6y agoCan anyone with a voltmeter see if they've cut voltage to 110V or 115V? Ontario Canada regularly does tests for 3% and 5% voltage reductions to see what the effect on demand is (and if the system even works): https://www.energyplus.ca/Modules/News/index.aspx?newsId=b374a340-d936-4458-8c6f-f17b03d46c79&feedId=6ec9e50f-6fea-4bab-984f-0e3ffa644c88,a676efcf-7ad8-4d93-b8ee-ba9b2d633d1c# https://www.energyplus.ca/Modules/News/index.aspx?newsId=b37...
- Scoundreller 6y agoNow at level 3: Situation Critical: "has declared an EEA 3. Energy conservation is critical. Rotating outages are underway to reduce demand on the electric system. We urge Texans to put safety first during this time. Traffic lights and other infrastructure may be temporarily without power. 01:25:40 150221" https://twitter.com/ERCOT_ISO https://twitter.com/ERCOT_ISO "Rotating outages primarily affect residential neighborhoods and small businesses and are typically limited to 10 to 45 minutes before being rotated to another location." http://www.ercot.com/eea_info/show/26464 http://www.ercot.com/eea_info/show/26464
- Rapzid 6y agoI'm curious how they coordinate between the transmissions providers as to what gets cut off when and by whom.
- Scoundreller 6y agoThe second link says: "each utility is required to lower the demand on its system based on its percentage of the historic ERCOT peak demand. "each utility is responsible for determining how to implement the required demand reduction, most utilities use rotating outages for this purpose." There's about 25 different utilities, so who knows what each does. I'm surprised voltage reduction isn't used. It's very effective at reducing resistive loads (ie: heaters and incandescent lights).
- JimNasby 6y agoThe grid has basically zero capability to change the voltage; frequency is all that matters. Frequency is so low that in the past hour any power line time base has fallen over 5.5 seconds behind. That’s a massive drop in frequency.
- Scoundreller 6y agoIt's a tool where I am. The grid operator does tests for 3% and 5% reductions: https://www.ieso.ca/Corporate-IESO/Media/News-Releases/2019/07/IESO-to-Conduct-Routine-Voltage-Reduction-Test https://www.ieso.ca/Corporate-IESO/Media/News-Releases/2019/... Would be very effective with the space-heater (or oven?) driven demand right now in Texas. Not effective for A/C-driven demand (motors will draw more current).
- gonzo 6y agoNOW LEVEL 3 https://twitter.com/ERCOT_ISO/status/1361215084010352644?s=20 https://twitter.com/ERCOT_ISO/status/1361215084010352644?s=2...
- bombcar 6y agoTHere is no EEA 4 but I assume as demand continues to increase and supply can't keep up they just have to keep shedding more and more loads. I expect a state of emergency to be declared if it hasn't already. Luckily today is a bit of a holiday.
- Animats 6y ago59.774Hz? That's a huge frequency error. I saw 59.6 go by. 29.5 seconds behind. Those are load-shedding levels. Unusually cold weather and heat pumps. Ouch. Back up to 60.080. They'll run a little fast if they can to make the remaining synchronous clocks catch up.
- bombcar 6y agoUp to 30 seconds behind again, was as low as 10 just recently. 800MW of reserve remains. I wonder what "Current System Inertia" is.
- bob1029 6y agoFrom ERCOT's materials: Power system inertia is defined as the ability of a power system to oppose changes in system frequency due to resistance provided by rotating masses. The level of inertia present in a system at any time is dependent on the amount of kinetic energy stored in rotating masses of synchronously-interconnected machines, including various types of generators as well as synchronously operating motor loads. See: http://www.ercot.com/content/wcm/key_documents_lists/141324/Inertia_Basic_Concepts_Impacts_On_ERCOT_v0.pdf http://www.ercot.com/content/wcm/key_documents_lists/141324/... (you may need a VPN to USA IP to access this) Effectively, this is the amount of kinetic energy in the grid at any given point in time.
- JimNasby 6y agoMore than 4 GW of capacity has gone offline in the last few minutes, based on http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/real_time_system_conditions.html http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/real_time_system_condi.... A significant chunk of load was shed as well. Frequency is swinging pretty wildly.
- bombcar 6y agoDemand went above capacity just now by 100MW - I assume the “ancillary” is doing something. Or Texas is now an over unity device.
- Animats 6y agoThis came close to happening in 2014.[1] They got to stage 2, but not rotating blackout stage 3. And yes, natural gas pipelines can freeze. There's some water in natural gas. Happened in 2011.[2] Search for "freeze-offs". [1] https://rbnenergy.com/the-night-the-lights-almost-went-out-in-texas-polar-vortex-power-markets https://rbnenergy.com/the-night-the-lights-almost-went-out-i... [2] https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=3390 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=3390
- black_puppydog 6y ago> This request was blocked by the security rules I'd guess they have a geoblock for some fucked-up-BS reason or another?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoImperva seems to be offering a "solve GDPR compliance with this checkbox" solution that blocks the EU from accessing your web site.
- black_puppydog 6y agoThat's pretty stupid. Oh well...
- symlinkk 6y agoUnbelievable how fragile our society is. All it takes is a little push (COVID, ice, etc) and everything falls apart. I’d like to see less $ being spent on innovative chat apps in the future and more being spent on innovative food, water, power, and medical systems.
- foxhop 6y agoJoin permaculture tech on matrix
- ulisesrmzroche 6y agoI just got power back. I’ve never seen weather bad as this here. It’s about as bad as it gets in NYC or Toronto. Not prepared whatsoever.
- hoseja 6y agoHow's that reliable solar and wind working out for ya?
- jeffrallen 6y agoEverything's bigger in Texas, except the electricity grid.
- stevespang 6y agoHere below Austin we are warm and toasty, no outages (yet).
- foxhop 6y agoI love my incandescent bulbs. It is a threat to remove them. The heat they produce is amazing in the winter. I use a 100 watt bulb to keep me warm at my desk. Heat bodies not buildings. I've been practicing this since a child and I'm 36 now. To heat yourself, check out: https://youtu.be/3gjvOOlHmsU https://youtu.be/3gjvOOlHmsU For actual good LED lamps (not the crap they push in USA) check out: https://youtu.be/klaJqofCsu4 https://youtu.be/klaJqofCsu4 TLDR most LED lamp are running over spec which cause them to fail and become a commodity rather than infra. I had a rear projection DLP LED TV which ran its red LED over spec and it burned out at least 3 times as fast as the green and blue. https://www.foxhop.net/samsung/HL-T5087SA/red-LED-failure https://www.foxhop.net/samsung/HL-T5087SA/red-LED-failure The heat is not always just a byproduct, sometimes you need or want the heat. Compare this 100 watt bulb to a tiny space heater and you will see the difference in your electricity bill. Buy a "kill a watt" meter to start testing you appliances rather assuming incandescent is evil.
- Schiendelman 6y agoYou also use your incandescent bulbs when it’s warm out. Stop wasting power.
- foxhop 6y agoNice try, I'm an environmentalist. I replace the bulb with LED when it's warm out.
- throwaway9870 6y agoWhat I don't understand is that it sounds like the utilities were unprepared for the cold because the windmills and gas lines froze up. But the same tech is used in Canada fine because it sounds like they plan for the cold and have equipment options designed to deal with ice, etc. So, you might immediately think - ah, climate change strikes again! But then I hear this is only a low temp in the last 30-40yrs. Who doesn't design a system to work at low temps that have occurred in the last 30-40 years? So, the question is - is this system poorly designed? Were corners cut that should not have been?
- bombcar 6y agoPeople may claim to prepare for a once a century event but since it only happens once a century it’s hard to determine if it’s actually prepared for. Half the houses don’t even have gas heat - because it’s never been needed. What we have here is asking to a earthquake hitting the Midwest - sure it’s known it could happen and there are plans for it - but they’ve never been tested.
- throwaway9870 6y agoI just saw something that said these are the lowest temps in the last 30 yrs. That isn't once in a century!
- maxlamb 6y agoI think the combination of the lowest temps in last 30 years, with sustained mucher colder temps than average over last 4-5 days with overcast sky (so there is no residual heat from mild Texas winter day), and that 50% of the state's wind turbines were made inoperable by freezing rain a few days ago might make it a once in a century event.
- sct202 6y agoThere were 3 'once in 500 year' floods in Houston from 2015-2017. It makes no sense.
- manyes 6y agoSo as far as I can gather, there are no generating units (other than wind turbines) that are down for maintenance? There is really only a low pressure problem in the pipeline system that is causing some combustion units to idle?
- BrianOnHN 6y agoDemand has been reading greater than the capacity for some time now.
- Reason077 6y agoBrowsing from the UK, I got: "Access Denied Error 16 www.ercot.com 2021-02-15 14:23:49 UTC If you believe you have a valid business reason for accessing ERCOT resources, please contact the ERCOT HelpDesk at 512-248-6800 or 1-866-870-8124 (USA) or HelpDesk@ercot.com. Your IP: 148.252.xxx.xxx Error code: 16 > This request was blocked by the security rules" Using a VPN with a US IP address, I was able to view the ercot site.
- fluidcruft 6y agoI'm in the US and was blocked because I have firefox set to request https. SSL Not Supported Error 29 www.ercot.com 2021-02-15 14:37:28 UTC If you believe you have a valid business reason for accessing ERCOT resources, please contact the ERCOT HelpDesk at 512-248-6800 or 1-866-870-8124 (USA) or HelpDesk@ercot.com. Please provide the HelpDesk with the information supplied below. Your IP: x.x.x.x Error code: 29 > SSL is not supported Usually you just get an error so that Firefox can let you click through to the http site, but this error thing inhibits that.
- Ajedi32 6y agoI got that message as well. Seems kinda silly given that the error page was delivered over SSL. They even have a valid certificate.
- tamaharbor 6y agoThis is what happens when you let the Regulators plan the system.
- Animats 6y agoAs of Monday afternoon in Texas, it's getting worse, not better. The "rotating outages" have become longer. "Unfortunately, if you are a customer who is currently experiencing an outage, you should be prepared to be without power for at least the rest of the day."[1] Galveston is 95% dark. Tonight's predicted low temp for Houston is 12F. Tuesday may be above freezing. [1] https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-weather/article/Live-weather-updates-Houston-snow-winter-storm-15951522.php https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-weather/articl...
- pdx_flyer 6y agoSome other thoughts: 1) Preventative maintenance on large units is planned 5-6 years out and in Texas typically takes place in the fall/winter as that is the lowest demand. 2) These units cannot be brought up (quickly at least). 3) Severe winters like these in Texas are extremely rare. Homes have been built for the conditions that have existed up to now. For example, I grew up in Houston and then moved to the PNW later in life. I experienced snow a total of two times while living in Houston and they were really more like glorified ice storms. I can remember Dallas and north Texas getting bigger, colder storms but even then they weren't awful.
- exabrial 6y agoOne thing about efficiency: How does one pass the liability of crap insulation onto landlords? I see this as a huge issue. As a tenant, you can't replace the windows, upgrade appliances, etc. We have unbelievable regulations that are choking home owners, but this seems like a much bigger target.
- exabrial 6y agoAnyone have a status page like this for SPP (Southwest Power Pool)? I can't seem to find it on their site despite clicking around for awhile.