32 ms·
These stories usually spur more enthusiasm for buying cryptocurrency, but ironically those buyers aren’t interested in spending cryptocurrency using their Maste
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
These stories usually spur more enthusiasm for buying cryptocurrency, but ironically those buyers aren’t interested in spending cryptocurrency using their MasterCard.
They’re hoping other people will buy cryptocurrency from these announcements, driving the price up. Or, more likely, they’re just hoping other people will buy cryptocurrency and not use it in these spending systems.
Spending cryptocurrency would result in selling that cryptocurrency, which would drive the price down. That’s not what cryptocurrency investors actually want.
Should also note that MasterCard crypto transactions almost certainly won’t be settled on the blockchain. Not with $8 Bitcoin transaction fees. They’ll just be denominated in cryptocurrency and people can deposit/withdraw in certain cryptocurrencies. MasterCard only needs to buy and sell on the blockchain as needed to provide an FX window. The actual transactions would be stored in traditional database systems (aside from customer deposits/withdrawals, just like Coinbase)
Why? Because MasterCard would get to act as an exchange and collect exchange fees. Exchange fees are a great way to charge consumers for spending their own money in 2021, when normal credit cards actually pay people 1-2% to use them. Cryptocurrency’s inefficiency is their financial upside.
- PretzelPirate 6y agoI’m in the minority in that I’d like to be able to spend my cryptocurrency in a way that: 1. The card handles also selling some off for taxes every transaction and put that in an interest-accruing account. 2. The card tracked my capital gains for each transaction for easy reporting on taxes. 3. The card provider will help manage fees - I’d rather bulk deposit funds to a layer2 and have fee-less payments over having to wonder what the current network fee is. I’d prefer if it wasn’t MasterCard since I use Visa cards, but I can’t complain too much. The reason I want this is that I have a lot of money in cryptocurrencies and I’d rather not sell them into other assets at the moment.
- ValentineC 6y ago> I’d prefer if it wasn’t MasterCard since I use Visa cards, but I can’t complain too much. I'm curious: is this because your preferred bank mainly issues Visa cards, or are there things about MasterCard that you don't like?
- PretzelPirate 6y agoMy bank mainly issues Visa cards. I’ve had multiple cards throughout my life, and I’ve never had a master card before. I’d like to just add this feature to my existing cards that I already have set up for payments. Completely off topic: What I really want in life is: 1. If I could have a virtual credit card that could act as a proxy card and would let me use different cards based on the items I was purchasing (ex: if I’m getting gas, one of my credit cards may give better rewards) 2. A virtual mailing address that would resolve to my current address when used with any shipping provider. I move every few years and hate mail forwarding and updating my address everywhere.
- throwaway1777 6y agoSettle down and have kids. Your problems will be solved.
- Slartie 6y ago> 1. The card handles also selling some off for taxes every transaction and put that in an interest-accruing account. > 2. The card tracked my capital gains for each transaction for easy reporting on taxes. How should it ever do that? It would basically have to limit you to spend Bitcoin that you acquired over that exact same card (like when you buy Bitcoin via PayPal) and that you hold in a virtual wallet provided by that card network operator. Otherwise they'd be unable to tell how many $ you paid to acquire the Bitcoin you just spent. As a related question: how comfortable would you be with a cryptocurrency-backed electronic payment card that would require you to keep your Bitcoin in the wallet of Visa/MasterCard/whatever (or their associated banks or crypto custodians) in order to spend them?
- jkepler 6y ago> Otherwise they'd be unable to tell how many $ you paid to acquire the Bitcoin you just spent. This is a massive reconciliation and record keeping overhead problem if you live in a jurisdiction that taxes crypto transactions for capital gains/losses. Michael Saylor said just recently in his interview with What Bitcoin Did that MicroStrategy plans to only use bitcoin as a treasury reserve asset and not as a transactional currency precisely because of the record keeping overhead.
- oillio 6y agoYou could enter your basis when you transfer coins into the account. This is how it works with other assets. If you transfer stocks between brokerage accounts, they communicate the basis as well.
- PKop 6y agoHow is this not solved by simply selling portions into fiat that cover expected spending needs, i.e. budgeting, and then transferring to bank account which is tied to your current credit card? "Spending" and "transacting" is a solved problem, namely fiat and credit. Why do crypto-assets, specifically Bitcoin, need to solve this problem?
- dillondoyle 6y agoYikes. I was going to reply this is my biggest question/concern. Cap Gains on btc profit is crazy insane. I guess it's offset if value increases 100% since you bought - but that's still a big tax tax on anything you buy. Maybe you can get lucky and set some type of tax advantage first in first out during down swings to take a loss?
- tehlike 6y agoA friend of mine basically put it this way: bitcoin can't become medium of exchange before it becomes medium of value. You can read this as: if you are holding btc, it's in your best interest to hold more without selling.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIf it’s in your best interest to buy and never sell, why would anyone want to use it for exchange? Bitcoin’s deflationary nature discourages spending and selling, by definition. The high transaction costs discourage it even further.
- T0Bi 6y agoHow is bitcoin deflationary when it (currently) has a fixed inflation?
- edm0nd 6y agogot em
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoContrary to the pop-culture definition, inflation isn’t purely driven by fiscal policy or money supply. Supply and demand (aka cost-push inflation and demand-pull inflation) are the main drivers. Fiscal policy modulates these factors, but inflation existed long before fiscal intervention. Bitcoin adoption is a deflationary process because an increasing number of people are competing over a fixed (ultimately) supply of Bitcoin. If more people want Bitcoin, the price goes up. Why do more people want Bitcoin? Because the price goes up. The cycle reverses when the price starts going down.
- koboll 6y agoIf bitcoin is a currency, then the prices of things in bitcoin have fallen over time. What cost 40,000 BTC a decade ago now costs 1 BTC. But bitcoin is more of an asset than a currency, so speaking of it in terms of inflation / deflation leads to oddities, like this.
- teekert 6y agoYeah, that is basically what all the exchanges do. The blockchain does not support that use case at all.
- liquidify 6y agoSome blockchains don't support that use case. Others do.
- soheil 6y ago> Spending cryptocurrency would result in selling that cryptocurrency, which would drive the price down. That’s not what cryptocurrency investors actually want. Is this necessarily true? If you have a merchant that accepts cryptocurrency why would that drive down the price? (e.g. Tesla [1]) [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/08/tesla-buys-1point5-billion-in-bitcoin.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/08/tesla-buys-1point5-billion-i...
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoWhat do you vendors do with any of the money you pay them? They spend it on paying employees and buying raw materials. It’s getting spent (sold) one way or another. Tesla is no exception.
- soheil 6y agoIt requires a network-effect for it to work, if more and more vendors accept crypto then how is that fundamentally different that fiat currency to buy raw materials and pay employees with?
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIn a hypothetically pure Bitcoin economy, that could work. But If we all switched to Bitcoin, the speculative upside would be exhausted and we’d be stuck with all of Bitcoin’s flaws and limitations. If you think $8 transaction fees are high now, how bad do you think it will be if every transaction was suddenly a Bitcoin transaction? Trick question, because Bitcoin has hard used block size limitations and it literally cannot support transactions at scale. By design. With the speculative upside removed, why would anyone choose to use Bitcoin? Why Bitcoin over any other cryptocurrency with significantly better technology?
- soheil 6y agoI don't understand why you're assuming we need a pure Bitcoin economy for there to be a network effect. If sufficient number of vendors accept Bitcoin that will be enough to create a network effect. Once you have a network effect with a size less than the size of the entire economy there will always be upside to own Bitcoin since that size can continue to grow.
- runeks 6y ago> Should also note that MasterCard crypto transactions almost certainly won’t be settled on the blockchain. Not with $8 Bitcoin transaction fees. They could easily settle merchant balances on the blockchain. An $8 fee is nothing compared to the revenue of a merchant. Assuming e.g. a 1.5% credit card fee, a merchant pays $8 in fees when receiving ~$500 in payments.
- Consultant32452 6y agoIt won't take long before Visa/MasterCard either adopt the Lightning network or create their own layer-2 service to alleviate transaction fees.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoWhy would they use any blockchain when they could get the same job done with a database and legal agreements, like they have been doing for decades?
- Consultant32452 6y agoIf you send me bitcoin in exchange for a widget, I'm eventually going to want to spend that bitcoin and I may not be doing that on the Visa network. At some point they have to offload those transactions back to the blockchain so the coins can actually get to my wallet. If they go the DB route as you suggest, they would basically be creating Visa Bucks, backed by bitcoin (which they'd have to buy), that can only be spent on the Visa network.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> At some point they have to offload those transactions back to the blockchain so the coins can actually get to my wallet. The vast majority of Bitcoin exchange participants choose to keep their coins in the exchange, not their own personal wallet. > If they go the DB route as you suggest, they would basically be creating Visa Bucks, backed by bitcoin (which they'd have to buy), that can only be spent on the Visa network. Every exchange uses a DB backend. They only engage with the blockchain when someone performs a withdrawal to another institution that they don't have an agreement with, such as when you withdraw to your wallet. And you will pay the transaction fees for that blockchain interaction ($8+ currently). If you're not paying transaction fees for other operations on their platform, it's clearly not touching the blockchain. Every exchange operates this way. It isn't a new concept.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 6y ago>Spending cryptocurrency would result in selling that cryptocurrency, which would drive the price down. That’s not what cryptocurrency investors actually want. That's a misunderstanding of how these things work. If selling drove the price down, then the price would never go up! Why? Because nobody can buy without a sale on the other side of the transaction. The common belief that selling lowers the price comes from the fact that if you put out a big sell-now order on a market, it will eat through the asks sitting there already. However in the slightly longer term others will put up new asks, up to the equilibrium where the price is close enough to the perceived value that there's no money to be made, after tax, by going in to move it closer. The phrase "Sell! Sell! Sell!" is based on the idea of selling at any price because you want to get rid of it so badly, but that's not a normal sale. That only happens when a party suddenly realizes that they have too much of something, not when they are doing everything as expected.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoA system for spending Bitcoin would inherently put sell orders in at market price (directly or indirectly). This consumes the highest priced bids and moves the price down. It’s the same story with any currency. Basic foreign exchange concepts.
- whatshisface 6y agoSmart sellers don't sell everything at the market price as soon as they can, because that would cut through the crust of fair asks into the mantle of waiting opportunists. Instead they spread it out, at a rate the ongoing volume can bear.
- ivalm 6y agoIf you sell Bitcoin every time you buy bread then you just sell whenever. It will be a large flow of market orders even if there aren’t enough asks.
- whatshisface 6y ago
- bouncycastle 6y agoI think MasterCard will use a different type of cryptocurrency than you are familiar with, called "stablecoins", like the USDC and/or DAI. These are pegged to the USD and never go up or down. Most likely, they will use things like a "state channels" for the actual transactions. State channels are like pre-paid cards, where the channel gets settled after the entire card is spent. But why? Well, cryptocurrency makes sense over traditional currency, because it's programmable, auditable & composable with many other dapps that exist on the blockchain.
- systemvoltage 6y agoWhat's the point of an unstable, volatile, frantically manipulated currency that is susceptible to social media pump and dump schemes (Elon + Doge)? Currency and its exchange rate needs to be relatively stable for the world to put trust into it. Saying that BTC is stable, but the rest of the world's fiat currency is fluctuating makes no sense. US dollar provides stability and security, I feel confident that a cappuccino will cost me $4. Crypto's volatility deters me from using it, simply put. There is no buffer that you would have with a Treasury. Converting from BTC to coffee makes BTC exchange rate go down.
- scsilver 6y agoThese currencies will inflate in value as their network grows wider. Each new user adds value like a telephone network. Eventually, there will be a point where everyone who wants to be connected is connected, they have bought the bitcoin they want and bitcoin prices reach an steady state. At that point, it should be stable enough to use as a currency.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIt’s fascinating to watch MLM logic sweep the tech world. Get in on the ground floor of this opportunity, then convince all of your friends to buy in, then they convince all of their friends... Once the speculation upside is gone, why would anyone want to buy Bitcoin? That’s the real question.
- centimeter 6y agoMLM dynamics actually do apply to monetized assets in some cases. Cf. “Bubble Theory Of Money”, Gresham’s Law. Once the speculation upside is gone, you would use Bitcoin because it’s the best available reserve and settlement asset. What are your other options? Inflationary USD or Yuan? Few rational actors would prefer to hold those.
- ForHackernews 6y ago> Inflationary USD lolz https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/inflation-rate-cpi https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/infl...
- olalonde 6y agoBitcoin is used as a speculative investment today only because it is so underpriced. Once its value stabilizes, its use in day to day transactions will grow. > Should also note that MasterCard crypto transactions almost certainly won’t be settled on the blockchain. And neither are USD transactions. In fact, USD doesn't even have a blockchain! The great thing with Bitcoin is once you want to cash out your Bitcoin, you can take it with you "on chain" without any intermediary (and it's a bit more convenient than carrying bags of cash).
- steeve 6y agoHow can it stabilize when it has a fixed amount of BTC?
- anm89 6y agoNo currencies are "stable" inflationary, deflationary or neutral. Stabilize means that volatility reduces, not ceases to exist.
- arcticbull 6y agoYes there are, thanks to positive control from central banks. That's the point of central banks. Provide and maintain stability through the active expansion and contraction of supply against an index.
- anm89 6y agoShow me a currency that has the exact same inflation figures every month for a single year and I'll send you a bitcoin. Or alternately, just view a currency index like the DXY to see very closely that nothing comes close to this. Here is what some real inflation data looks like (as viewedin terms of CPI). It can't even decide if it wants to stay positive or negative on a monthly basis. https://tradingeconomics.com/euro-area/inflation-rate-mom https://tradingeconomics.com/euro-area/inflation-rate-mom
- 6y ago
- beaner 6y agoI'm a cryptocurrency holder and I would love it if it were easier to spend.
- simonebrunozzi 6y ago> They’re hoping other people will buy cryptocurrency from these announcements, driving the price up. Mostly right.
- agumonkey 6y agoI wonder what kind of subtle systemic effect will twist the whole crypto thing on its head to the point people will forget what it was in the first place.
- anm89 6y agoAnd the people buying it even though they don't want to spend via mastercard are smart to do so. They understand that it's building up the network effects, creating onramps, and improving the ecosystem. Over the long run I highly doubt mastercard will be a meaningful player in the crypto space but they definitely have the ability to hasten its adoption.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoThere's many ways to value cryptocurrency. One of them is largely driven by network effect, except it's directed edges of accepts and pays in. This is a huge addition to the network with a giant amount of accepts edges.
- devname 6y agoI want people to earn and spend Bitcoin Cash. Almost all bitcoiners want this.
- cheaprentalyeti 6y agoIf all bitcoiners wanted that Bitcoin Cash would be worth more than Bitcoin.
- pmontra 6y ago> Spending cryptocurrency would result in selling that cryptocurrency Not necessarily. I could give you the address of 0.001 BTC over the MasterCard network and you give me something I can eat (I don't know if this is how it will work, but why not?) No BTC is converted in fiat currency. You can hoard you BTCs for years or change them in dollars as soon as you receive them. Your choice. Edit: I must give you the private key too.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoDoesn't work. You can't guarantee that you haven't memorized the private key. You can't guarantee you haven't traded the same key multiple times. The only way the receiver can truly guarantee ownership of the BTC is to put it in a transaction, which costs money.
- pmontra 6y agoThey downvoted you but technically you are right. And yet MasterCard could make it work because double spending those coins would be a fraud and they'll go after their double spending customers. They can guarantee the coins with the weight of their legal department.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoRegardless, "spending" Bitcoin in an economy where Bitcoin isn't the dominant currency will, on average, result in downward price pressure. Unless you restrict the transactions to only be among Bitcoin users, which isn't going to happen because the providers make their money from exchange fees. It's strange that so many commenters are going through mental gymnastics to pretend that the only rational thing to do with Bitcoin is to buy or trade it, but never sell it.
- 3np 6y agoI'm not so sure. A move like this can increase the confidence that the Bitcoin price won't go down in the long-term - that is, someone do wants to spend their bitcoin in the future, and signals of greater market confidence increase the perceived likelihood of that. The more I believe bitcoin is here to stay, the more comfortable I feel allocating savings in it. This time is also a bit different; 2017 was almost entirely retail, this time it's a lot more businesses and institutions driving the BTC market.
- koonsolo 6y agoMastercard just tries to be relevant in an environment where they will not be relevant anymore. Just look at the Nano cryptocurrency for example: 0 fees and <1 second transactions. You can send 0.00001 dollar or 9 billion to anyone in the world at any time. All you need is a phone. Crypto is going to disrupt a lot of things. If it's not clear by now, you will be in for a surprise.
- Sargos 6y agoMastercard is a payment support platform. They take the burden off of the business owners and let them focus on their business instead of the minutia of interfacing with the financial system. That doesn't go away with cryptocurrencies. In fact it might be more needed than ever as there are now multiple payment networks with lots of intricacies such as coin storage, keeping track of transactions for taxes, etc. Visa and Mastercard are likely still going to be important in the future just for the sheer fact that business owners will take at least a decade to update their backend stack to be sophisticated enough to handle the various payment APIs, UX problems, etc that crypto brings. With Visa and Mastercard your existing PoS terminals still work (now with crypto) and you can continue focusing on selling books or groceries or whatever else you do instead of being a financial systems engineer.
- koonsolo 6y agoPeople can pay with their phone using a simple QR code. Merchants can check on any computer with a web browser. How complex does Mastercard make it right now? Like I said, it's a dinosaur ready to go extinct.
- Sargos 6y agoThat's from an end users perspective. From a merchant's perspective if they provide that QR code they now have the additional burden of custody of a bunch of crypto assets which means learning about, installing, making a specific bank account to sell the coins, dealing with tax burdens, etc which is a lot of work and risk for someone already overworked and stressed by their primary business. Or they can just use a payment network like Visa or Mastercard and not have to worry about any of that. You pay with BTC or ETH and the merchant receives USD. Everyone's happy. The merchant doesn't have to hire an additional crypto-specialized IT person or spend 6 months diving down the rabbit hole like we did. They just run their business.
- vmception 6y ago> Spending cryptocurrency would result in selling that cryptocurrency, which would drive the price down. That’s not what cryptocurrency investors actually want that’s really assuming a lot a closed loop cryptocurrency transaction does not result in selling mastercard may or may not be offering that capability mastercard offering that capability makes the cryptocurrency proponents vision a reality
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThey're not interested in making the vision of cryptocurrency a reality any more than it enhances their bottom line. Mastercard is offering exchange services. They will collect exchange fees on transactions, just like PayPal and other providers. They won't even bring blockchain into this any more than necessary. They'll handle it in databases like everyone else, only engaging with the blockchain as necessary for deposits and withdrawals.
- tshaddox 6y agoIn fact, for every transaction where a unit of cryptocurrency is bought, that same unit is also sold.
- vmception 6y agoyeah sold for a candy bar and the merchant still has the cryptocurrency and pays their overhead costs in the same cryptocurrency who buy their own candy bars from a different merchant in cryotocurrency Payment networks like mastercard integrating cryptocurrency make this more practical instead of handwaiving a gradual organic adoption idea
- bmurphy1976 6y agoFour or five years ago I mined Dogecoin on a lark using a laptop for a month. I converted that to BTC at some point and it's worth more than I ever anticipated. It won't change my life but I could have some fun with the money. I'm not inclined to transfer it to USD, but I'd happily spend some of it were it easy to do so. Maybe buy some stocks, upgrade my PC, or get a PS5 and some games? Sure, why not! I'm only sitting on it because it's a hassle to use it, not because I believe it's going to suddenly grow 100x in size. If I really cared about the growth I'd immediately move it to some index funds.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> I'm not inclined to transfer it to USD, but I'd happily spend some of it were it easy to do so. Spending it is effectively the same thing as converting it to USD. Why are you hesitant to convert it to USD to buy something, yet you'd be happy to have a 3rd party service handle the BTC-USD conversion in the background and collect their profit on the exchange? There's no free lunch. Mastercard isn't doing this out of a desire to offer free services to the people. They're collecting profit by offering worse exchange rates than you can get on an exchange by yourself. Same story for PayPal and other providers.
- bmurphy1976 6y agoThere's a big difference. Having to find an exchange and hook everything up to my bank account is a hassle (especially when I have no need to do it). Sending BTC to somebody using an Android app isn't and is something I have done frequently (e.g. donating BTC to parties who have helped me or offer something I enjoy). I don't want a world where I have to transfer the BTC to USD to use it, I want a world where I can just use it. MasterCard acting an an intermediary is fine with me, somebody has to bootstrap this.
- argvargc 6y ago200% YoY average return, and you'd move it to index funds? https://www.casebitcoin.com/images/stories/charliebilello_returns_btc.png https://www.casebitcoin.com/images/stories/charliebilello_re...
- scotty79 6y agoWhen Visa and MasterCard will warm up to bitcoin they will have ideal product for all the bitcoin millionaires. When you are long on bitcoin you almost don't care about volatility. Because you can't predict the future the only good time to buy bitcoin is when you have too much dollars and the only good time when to sell bitcoins is when you have not enough dollars. Sure, now you have 10 mln dollars in BTC at all tine high, and 2 mln after price drops but in day to day purchases it doesn't matter. MasterCard could offer joint dollar-bitcoin account that works as follows: You have some amount of dollars on that account, whenever you pay for something price is deducted from dollar balance. If dollar balance is insufficient then some portion of bitcoin is sold automatically from your bitcoin balance to give you some multiples of thousands of dollars. You could also have manual trading available if you want to gamble a bit and buy some bitcoins if it dropped to 20% of last ATH or sell some ... I don't know when... when you are drunk and think you can predict the end of the bull run.. Not sure how much bitcoins would someone entrust MasterCard with current bankruptcy law but if it was significant enough amount then all bitcoin millionaires would get to use their fortunes totally hassle free.
- rawtxapp 6y agoThis is very similar to what I'm currently doing, just borrowing against my Bitcoin holdings using MakerDAO, I have good liquidity on a day to day basis and my Bitcoin is still appreciating.
- oillio 6y agoIs this a long term solution? Or do you plan on selling Bitcoin to pay back the loan when you think we are near the top?
- rawtxapp 6y agoAs long as there's no bugs in the smart contract, I don't plan on ever paying down that debt, since I expect the value of BTC to rise much faster than the value of my debt. My liquidation price is very low and if it were to reach that, it would mean a catastrophe anyways.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cableshaft 6y ago> ...ironically those buyers aren’t interested in spending cryptocurrency using their MasterCard. > They’re hoping other people will buy cryptocurrency from these announcements, driving the price up. So what? Does every investor use the products of the companies they invest in? Professional investors don't care about that, they care about how well the company is doing and what they think its trajectory will be (up or down), not whether they personally will use the services offered.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoBitcoin isn't a company, though. It's an asset. Bitcoin itself doesn't do better or worse or grow in value. It's just moving up and down according to supply and demand.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> Spending cryptocurrency would result in selling that cryptocurrency, which would drive the price down. An economy based on BTC would be highly deflationary as no one would want to spend - why buy something today when it'll be cheaper in a week or a month? Scarcity isn't necessarily a good feature for a currency. Ideally supply of a currency should increase as more people enter the economy. Such a currency would aim for stability instead of aiming for the currency itself to increase in value (as happens for BTC or even physical gold).
- emteycz 6y agoFinally some solution for consumerism that could work! Yay Bitcoin!
- nybble41 6y ago> why buy something today when it'll be cheaper in a week or a month? Because you need it today? We already see this all the time in subsets of the market which experience deflating prices. If you wait a year to buy that fancy device you're wanting there will most likely be a better model available at a lower cost. People still buy the current model, though, because there is a cost to waiting which offsets the expected price deflation.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIt's a different situation when the currency itself is deflationary, not the goods being purchased. Instead of thinking in terms of buying a phone, think of this in terms of capital allocation and investment. Deflationary currencies are designed to accrue value to those who don't use them. An economy built on the idea of incentivizing people to not spend any money is not good at all. Everyone knows about the downsides of excessive inflation, but deflationary spirals are a well-known economic problem. In short: Deflation reduces demands for goods, which causes producers to lower production targets, which causes people to be laid off, which further reduces demand for goods and so on. A hypothetical Bitcoin economy rewards early adopters massively at the expense of newcomers. The current wealth situation is already heavily biased toward older generations, even on an age-adjusted basis (see charts: https://www.wealthmanagement.com/client-relations/illustrating-wealth-gap-between-boomers-and-millennials https://www.wealthmanagement.com/client-relations/illustrati... ). If you think that's bad, just imagine a Bitcoin economy where the underlying financial system accrues wealth to the older holders, at the expense of newcomers to the system. People love Bitcoin because they think they're the ones getting in at the ground floor, getting wealthy at the expense of the new arrivals. The love for Bitcoin would flip very quickly as young people realize they're deeply on the losing end of that deal.
- gt565k 6y agoYou are so wrong. Spending crypto using a card is actually what people want in order to avoid taxes on crypto as it's treated as a security from the IRS tax perspective. Anyone who has made money on crypto would love it if they can just spend the crypto as currency and buy every day things with it and remove the tax liability from having to convert to fiat. 15% tax capital gains, no thanks, let me spend it on food and furniture.
- gnaritas 6y agoYou are wrong, the ability to spend it in no way removes your tax liability. Currency traders still owe taxes on their gains, it doesn't matter what currency it is, if you make gains you owe taxes. You don't owe money because you convert to fiat, you owe money because you made gains.
- martamorena923 6y agoOMG in what country do you live? 15%??? We have to pay 50% on this in Canada, well at least the ones who are in the top earning bracket. I would gladly pay the 15%. I mean how greedy is it to make these kind of gains in crypto and then trying to avoid a measly 15% of tax lol.
- xsmasher 6y agoAre you sure you pay 50% in tax on the profits? A quick google suggests that 50% of the profits counts as income, which is then taxed at your income rate. 50*50 = 25% in the top bracket. In the US long-term cap gains is 0%, 15%, or 20% - not far off from 25%.
- draaglom 6y ago_people_ may believe that but I don't think the IRS does. Spending crypto that has appreciated in value on goods and services is still a taxable event for CGT purposes.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoExactly. "Spending" the cryptocurrency is just convenient UX over the exchange process. Using a credit card that abstracts the details doesn't get you off the hook from paying capital gains tax.
- dalbasal 6y agoWell... Cryptocurrency people are hoping for all sort of things... that's part of why enthusiasm can be currently quantified at a $1trn. While I'm sure you're right for most of the current bets (bitcoin owners are long, after all), there's something to be said for blind, dumb momentum. Connecting more people & financial nodes to the network, however disintermediated, for whatever reason. Maybe the "mastercard model" of denominating in bitcoin and clearing yourself in dollars is an early version of how bitcoin transaction costs actually get to normal. That's not unlike how stocks, bonds, forex & such are exchanged. I know. I know. Irony. Inevitable though, I think. Pretty much all currency & currency-like stuff gets moved around through clearing houses. Direct blockchain transactions are the theoretically ultimate transaction in the same way that NYSE transactions are theoretically ultimate. Actual stock transactions generally happen within a broker, the broker's broker or whoever else is between them and the actual stock market. The logic is similar. TLDR... People are giddy or hypocritical because they're long (or short) on bitcoin. That doesn't mean that momentum isn't momentum.
- Triv888 6y ago> Should also note that MasterCard crypto transactions almost certainly won’t be settled on the blockchain. That is almost certainly wrong... otherwise, they could claim to have bitcoins and would not really need any?
- yarcob 6y ago> Exchange fees are a great way to charge consumers for spending their own money in 2021, when normal credit cards actually pay people 1-2% to use them Credit card companies in the US are a special kind of evil. They charge huge fees, force vendors not to pass the fees on to customers, and then pretend to be the consumer's best friend by returning a bit of the fees to them. They insert themselves between buyer and seller, drive prices up, and their customers think they are saving money.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoPaying with Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency requires the customer to pay the transaction fees. Regardless of what you think about credit card companies, which payment method do you think the average consumer would choose? 1) Pay by credit card, get 2% cash back, reserve option to reverse charges if vendor fails to deliver, don't lose all of your money if you lose your credit card. 2) Pay by Bitcoin, pay $8 transaction fee, wait 10-30 minutes for transaction to be confirmed, resubmit if transaction fee was too low, no recourse if vendor runs away with your money, lose all of your money if you forget your password. Realistically, any crypto-as-payment service will either charge the merchants large fees (to cover risk, volatility, exchange, transaction costs) and/or collect profit on the exchange rate. There's no free lunch, but the lunch is definitely not cheaper on the Bitcoin side for average transactions.
- ric2b 6y agoNothing stops you from having Bitcoin credit cards. In fact they already exist. Dollar bills don't have any of the advantages you mentioned either. How fast and secure do you think mailing them to some company is? A lot of these arguments are really just cherry-picking whichever portion of the financial system best suits your argument at the time and pretending they're only possible if they're built on top of pieces of paper.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Dollar bills don't have any of the advantages you mentioned either. How fast and secure do you think mailing them to some company is? No one mails paper dollar bills around. Bitcoin always sounds fantastic when compared to these straw-man alternate universes where everyone is mailing dollar bills around, but let's stick to reality where no one does that. > pretending they're only possible if they're built on top of pieces of paper. USD isn't literally built on top of paper money. Cryptocurrency, however, is literally invented out of thin air by programmers. New cryptocurrencies are released every week. Even Bitcoin gets forked at times.
- me551ah 6y agoI don't get why bitcoin is worth so much.Bitcoin is called a store of value like gold, but gold has inherent uses. If the price of gold went to zero then you could still use it to make jewellery or use it for electrical conductivity. If the price of bitcoin goes to zero then it's worthless. It's also not environmentally friendly and bitcoin mining uses up 0.21% of the world's power supply. And all of this energy is used to calculate billions of hashes per second out of which all but one will be discarded. There is also increased regulatory focus from governments who see it as a threat , with India even going so far as to suggest they would ban it.
- krsdcbl 6y agoI'd argue that the demand for gold jewelry would drop accordingly to the gold price falling to zero. Jewelry is a secondary form of said value store, nothing inherently useful
- OOPMan 6y agoWell, unlike Bitcoins, I can put gold jewellery in a sack and use it as a cosh ;-)
- alantrrs 6y agoWe live in the information age. Information has a lot of value, most software companies' main asset is information. Visa, Mastercard and all the banks are companies that are valued very highly because they provide the infrastructure for managing money. Bitcoin is not just the asset, it is the network and the infrastructure. It's a whole system that works semi autonomously by by aligning the incentives of all of its members. Wouldn't you say that's valuable?
- BTCOG 6y agoDo you typically just copy/paste the same comment on every Bitcoin article rather than think of nuanced commentary? Are you a part of ArcticBull's astroturfing campaign? Edit: I see that you've copy/pasted it once but some other commentary on Bitcoin seems mostly genuine.
- 6y ago
- ca98am79 6y agoI am very interested in spending cryptocurrency using my MasterCard, especially and only if it does not result in a capital gains transaction that I have to report on my taxes. If I have to report each transaction to the IRS, I am not interested and will not spend it. If I do NOT have to report it, I will use it all the time
- dman7 6y agoWe're not actually certain whether Mastercard will include volatile cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin. Reading this article (https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/02/mastercard-will-support-cryptocurrencies-but-not-the-ones-you-think/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/02/mastercard-will-...), their requirements suggest supporting stablecoins (i.e. USDC). These cryptocurrencies are pegged to the dollar and should be backed by a reserve. In that case, your argument about price movements doesn't apply here.
- TylerE 6y agoThat's a rather heavy should. I'd bet dollars to pesos at least some of them are operating fractional reserve schemes, or have the reserve "invested" in crypto.
- dman7 6y agoTrue. I'm mainly referring to the fact that some stablecoins, such as Tether, are not honest about their actual reserves: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25788409 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25788409
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoStablecoins are, in theory, just a cryptocurrency representation of actual money in the bank somewhere. I'm all for it, if it's properly audited and confirmed that the funds are in place. I'm a huge proponent of cryptocurrency technology as long as it doesn't: 1) Depend on wasting ever-increasing amounts of electricity doing arbitrary useless proof-of-work 2) Create a new currency out of thin air, when all we really want is a way to move our existing money around. I don't want to have to buy an arbitrary cryptocurrency from some early adopters at an inflated price just to move my USD from point A to point B.
- michaelmrose 6y agoIf your credit card gives you 1% back but charges walmart 2% and walmart takes this 2% into account when setting their prices then you aren't getting paid to use your credit card you are paying 1%.
- oogetyboogety 6y agoHow will it compare to what Square does? Centralization always occurs at the point of the exchange, I guess. It does seem a little less criminal than what Robinhood was doing.
- oorion 6y agoBitcoin Cash functions as peer to peer electronic currency with low fees. No need for Mastercard when using it.