25 ms·
The Virus Changed. Now We Must ‘Get to Zero’ or Face Catastrophe
- plantain 6y agoIt won't happen, because there's no political incentive to do so. The citizens of these beleaguered countries seem quite happy with the government management thus far[1]. I honestly don't know how anyone can look at the UK response thus far and think - more of that please! [1] https://twitter.com/BritainElects/status/1355606835873669126 https://twitter.com/BritainElects/status/1355606835873669126
- throwaway3699 6y agoThe UK is faced with a lack of choice here. My read is that people strongly dislike the current government policies but believe that the cons are "least worst". There's been very little in the way of real opposition, sadly. For instance, when the Tories do make actual fuckups Labour usually resort to off-topic complaints about idpol so the Tories just do whatever they want with no push back.
- eecc 6y agoIdpol?
- throwaway3699 6y agoIdentity politics.
- jasdine817 6y agoThe main issue is a voting system that only allows two parties to compete and makes parties between fractious groups of people with very different views. The Tories for whatever reason are just far better at aligning most of their party to the goal of winning.
- throwaway3699 6y agoThe two-party system is bad, but I do believe Labour are responsible for making themselves unelectable. The last general election they were running some of the most disliked front-benchers in politics: McDonnell, Corbyn and Abbott, as well as making it very clear they were anti-Brexit. (I'm from the North, this is the general sentiment in my local community. More stringent lockdown policy is also incredibly unpopular here.)
- tristanperry 6y agoI agree, but it also doesn't help when the Labour opposition have had a string of weak opposition leaders. Even Keir Starmer seems content to sit back and only critise the Government's response the day or days after a grim milestone/but of news. Why isn't he constantly saying that the UK should totally shut their borders, for example? He should be saying this and nothing else, and directing the rest of Labour to do the same. That's how an effective opposition works. Instead he generally chooses silence.
- djaychela 6y agoI have to say I've been really disappointed in KS - I wanted him to win the leadership, and was expecting a much more robust performance from him. I wouldn't say he chooses silence, but he often sounds a bit whiny and little more.
- threeseed 6y agoI don't understand why Labour doesn't bring up Australia. UK is 2.5x the population of Australia and has 136x the number of deaths.
- djaychela 6y agoAs already said by someone else, I don't think that's the right reading of it. I know it's anecdotal, but I don't know anyone here (I'm in the southern UK) who thinks that the government has handled this even remotely competently, but they also acknowledge that there's not really an ideal way to handle it. The only thing that seems to be going 'to plan' is the vaccine rollout, which has surprised me as I never thought they'd get near the target figures they now look to be going to achieve (i.e. vaccinating the four key groups by Feb 15). You have to make some sacrifices to win the battle, but it seems we've paid a lot of the price (in terms of economic costs as well as deaths), but without the positives that should have come from that. As soon as there's any sign of let-up in any of the statistics, it seems the government wants to remove the measures, which seems to be a bad idea to me, but I'm a chump who's not making the decisions!
- the-dude 6y agoYou are exactly right. The Dutch response has been and still is a shitshow. We are up for election mid-March, the ruling party and PM will be re-elected. The populace will not 'take chances' during crises.
- jl6 6y agoThe UK response has been mediocre rather than awful. * PPE sourcing has been poor. * Track and trace has been poor, and for the money they spent should have been far better. * Lockdowns have been too leaky, and too late. * But the vaccination research and rollout has been excellent. The high UK death toll is only partly due to the above mediocrities, and mainly due to factors that cannot be pinned on the government: * A very highly internationally mobile population that seeded infections everywhere in the country. * A very highly internally mobile population that spread infections everywhere in the country. * A very high density population * Little experience of pandemic management and limited pre-existing testing capacity * No culture of mask wearing * A higher than average aged population * A higher than average obese population * Higher percentage of ethnic minority individuals who have been more susceptible to the disease, even after adjusting for health and income inequalities. * More northerly climate with colder temperatures and higher rates of vitamin D deficiency * Lower public tolerance for restrictions on movement * Insufficient police numbers to enforce lockdown policies No SINGLE cause from the lists above explain the UK's high death rate. It's a perfect storm of all of them.
- fire7000 6y agoIt was never about the big scary virus that eradicated the flu for a year
- Barrin92 6y agohow the efficacy of vaccines changes with mutating strains of the virus is I think still out in the open, but I'll second the general tone of the article. Complacency is dangerous. Already are there people who treat the vaccinations themselves as panacea despite the fact that in some countries like the US almost half of all frontline workers aren't even willing to be vaccinated.[1] The pandemic will not magically end because of a miracle cure, but with enough state capacity and social coordination crushing the thing would be possible right now. [1]https://www.forbes.com/sites/tommybeer/2021/01/02/large-numbers-of-health-care-and-frontline-workers-are-refusing-covid-19-vaccine/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/tommybeer/2021/01/02/large-numb...
- wernercd 6y agoor it'll turn into just another cold/flu that we get used too and ignore. How many thousands die a year from the flu and it was all but ignored?
- baq 6y agoI don’t know but before COVID I used to get a flu shot each year. This year wasn’t as important as 1) restrictions also decimated the flu, 2) my country used up all the shots it ordered (which never happens) before I had time to get one myself.
- wernercd 6y agoand even with large swaths having resistances and a new flu vaccine each year? thousands still died "normally" every flu seasons. Which is my point... it was normal. Colds, flu, etc. COVID? not going anywhere... its out and mutating... we'll eventually get used to it.
- jansan 6y agoAs Klaus Schwab clearly said: "The pandemic represents a rare but narrow window of opportunity to reflect, reimagine, and reset our world" Wouldn't it be a shame if the window closed before the goals are reached? Also, I do not trust activist writers.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAnecdotally, the packing of other policy goals into the pandemic response has caused several people I know to believe that it is all a fraud. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/great-reset-trudeau-poilievre-otoole-pandemic-covid-1.5817973 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/great-reset-trudeau-poiliev...
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoSo that's whats causing people to believe it's a fraud? How does policy packing counter all the people that have died and/or gotten sick from COVID-19?
- MattGaiser 6y agoI don't actually know any such people, nor do most of the people I have asked this question. I have yet to know anyone for whom the pandemic is personal in any way. So I think the death toll is just an abstraction to many. Others believe that there is no change in deaths and the government is just re-labelling them.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoSARS-CoV-2 is a zoonotic, (fairly) highly infectious endemic respiratory virus. Eradication is literally impossible, and even if we could wave a magic wand and simultaneously eradicate it from all humans on earth, you still need to worry about it jumping back over from any of the many animal species infected with it. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eradication_of_infectious_diseases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eradication_of_infectious_dise...: > The selection of infectious diseases for eradication is based on rigorous criteria, as both biological and technical features determine whether a pathogenic organism is (at least potentially) eradicable. The targeted organism must not have a non-human reservoir (or, in the case of animal diseases, the infection reservoir must be an easily identifiable species, as in the case of rinderpest), and/or amplify in the environment. This implies that sufficient information on the life cycle and transmission dynamics is available at the time an eradication initiative is programmed. An efficient and practical intervention (such as a vaccine or antibiotic) must be available to interrupt transmission of the infective agent. Studies of measles in the pre-vaccination era led to the concept of the critical community size, the size of the population below which a pathogen ceases to circulate.[2] The use of vaccination programs before the introduction of an eradication campaign can reduce the susceptible population. The disease to be eradicated should be clearly identifiable, and an accurate diagnostic tool should exist. Economic considerations, as well as societal and political support and commitment, are other crucial factors that determine eradication feasibility.[3][4] SARS-CoV-2 satisfies none of these pre-conditions (except for having a vaccine now). It is not only unrealistic but actively delusional/deleterious to argue for “COVID zero”. Don’t fall for it. Remember herd immunity doesn’t mean eradication. The virus stays endemic. Which is fine; over the long run the set of all COVID-19-naive individuals becomes dominated by the very young (infants/toddlers), who have essentially zero risk of COVID-19 mortality.
- croes 6y ago"who have essentially zero risk of COVID-19 mortality." With current virus, that could change with each mutation.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoViruses generally change to be less deadly and more transmissible. The “new variant” is just more transmissible. It doesn’t make sense to argue “oh what if this virus magically evolves to hurt children”. You need to propose a theoretical mechanism of action. Otherwise spend your time worrying about flu and tuberculosis which kill far more children than COVID-19.
- zpeti 6y agoChina and Vietnam get the virus under control by using centralised quarantines. I wonder how many people supporting the sentiments of this article would be ok with someone arriving at their doorstep, taking you to a prison basically whether you agree or not, and quaranteening you there for at least 10 days with other covid people. Perhaps they also take your family too, in case they are also infected. Are you willing to pay that price?
- baxtr 6y agoThis and all other countries mentioned are Islands (Australia, New Zealand, Taiwan)
- josephg 6y agoJust because she's not an island, Canada can still close her borders. I'm sure it'll be inconvenient, but short and sharp beats long and drawn out.
- baxtr 6y agoYes I agree. Canada has a long border but just with one country. So think it’s in a good position. It’s way more difficult for a European country for example.
- threeseed 6y agoIt's not that difficult for most European countries. People are going to be crossing borders at relatively few and well understood locations. And they could've simply imposed large fines for anyone who tried to sneak through.
- baxtr 6y agoYou obviously don’t live in mainland Europe. I can easily cross borders in a small village, on a field, through a forest. There are no fences. Sometimes you don’t even have a line. It’s a bit like saying New York should close its borders with Pennsylvania
- jensgrud 6y agoDefinitely a report we did not want to hear. Just the the record though, the author is factually wrong about Denmark being one of the jurisdictions that "chose not to stamp out this virus and blithely tolerated high infection rates" and is probably referring to Sweden - see https://www.economist.com/the-world-ahead/2020/11/17/the-nordic-countries-different-approaches-to-covid-19-will-continue https://www.economist.com/the-world-ahead/2020/11/17/the-nor.... We actually wiped out an entire industry of mink farming in the name of stopping the spread of mutations, but that is a topic for an other thread (https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/04/health/covid-mink-mutation.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/04/health/covid-mink-mutatio...).
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoYeah I think the mink culling was an absurd over-reaction and highly unethical. Those poor minks. (Disclosure: I also think the same for the human lockdowns too though)
- threeseed 6y agoLockdowns work. End of story. Melbourne, Australia had a 4-month lockdown which turned an exponentially-rising 500+ cases a day scenario into elimination. Saving thousands of lives. No other place has managed to do something similar and it shows hotel quarantine of foreign arrivals, aggressive contact-tracing, mandatory mask-wearing, social distancing and lockdowns work. The Swedish laissez-faire approach does not.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoNew Zealand did the same.
- gridspy 6y agoYes, but here in NZ we didn't wait until there were 500 infections to act. The lockdown was instituted around the time of <100 active infections being detected and our level 4 lockdown is far more stringent than any US state lockdown.
- Pietertje 6y agoFunny he puts more faith in Astrazeneca vaccin. True it's logistics are easier. But it's efficacy is not... Worse given the higher transmission rates of the new strains it in itself might not be sufficient to prevent further spread. Higher R0 requires higher efficacy to keep R below 1.
- area51org 6y agoNone of the variants so far are any more lethal than the original. Isn't that right? I have heard nothing to the contrary, although this guy seems to think it's already happened.
- EdwardDiego 6y agoYou miss the point - a virus with a 1% death rate of those infected, that mutates into a virus 50% more transmissible, with a 1% death rate of those infected, is obviously likely to kill more people.
- jansan 6y agoIf I look a the infection numbers of South Africa and UK, I completely fail to see how there variants are more infectious. Also, in Brazil, where life seems to go on as usual, there is no exponential growth of cases. Do you have any numbers that prove that the new strains are actually spreading faster in society?
- res0nat0r 6y agohttps://www.politico.com/news/2021/01/25/fauci-uk-coronavirus-462117 https://www.politico.com/news/2021/01/25/fauci-uk-coronaviru... The UK variant which will be the dominant strain in the USA in a couple months is more deadly, and I believe the same is true for the South Africa version. Both more infectious, and both more lethal.
- jansan 6y ago>The UK variant which will be the dominant strain in the USA in a couple months is more deadly, That's not what is in the article. It says "“there is a realistic possibility that infection with” the country’s dominant Covid-19 variant “is associated with an increased risk of death compared to infection with” other strains of the coronavirus." What they are saying is basically "we do not know".
- T-A 6y ago
- jraby3 6y agoI wonder what the effects of rapidly vaccinating your population would be, like Israel is currently doing. There are still children and people who can’t tolerate a vaccine, but vaccinating 6.5M out of 8.5M people quickly (assuming 2M children and 800k that have or soon will catch COVID) should have a huge effect on the r rate.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe author never says it and probably because he knows the reaction it would cause. "Decisive" lockdown at this point would likely be a troops patrolling the street type of event with extreme restrictions on leaving one's home. I don't see that being anywhere near politically acceptable in many areas of the country.
- pbourke 6y agoThere would be nowhere enough troops to patrol the streets in Canada. They could supply extra reinforcement to ports/borders. A closure order + heavy fines/penalties + economic support would work, along with clear messaging around goals and exit criteria.
- jansan 6y ago>along with clear messaging around goals and exit criteria. This! The lack of clear exit criteria and the continous moving of goalposts convinced me that the pandemic is used as a vehicle for a political agenda and even if it mutated into a mild cough politicians would still try to keep the hysteria alive, at least in the EU and Canada.
- jeofken 6y agoOf course. The board of directors in a company work to make their shareholders re-elect them. The leaders in democracies work to make the populace want them re-elected, or scared enough not to dare select an alternative
- gridspy 6y agoYou only need troops on the street in areas where there is so much unrest that neighbors can't keep "bad actors" in check. I imagine this only being in the heart of cities. The lack of traffic leads to a reduction in crime generally, freeing up police oversight required to keep a lid on that.
- herewegoagain2 6y ago"He notes that a more infectious virus is more dangerous than a more lethal one, “because every new case will infect more people, and each of them will infect more people, such that the number of cases will grow exponentially.”" Oh my god, that sounds horrible - except, that's how EVERY infectious disease works. We have been living with that kind of diseases forever. Also, no, they don't grow exponentially. The population saturates.
- bumbada 6y agoSomething must be said: It is too late. The New Zealand or Taiwan model works because you don't let the virus enter in the first place. Also New Zealand and Australia are in Summer right now. Just 30 seconds of Australia sun radiation now will kill(inactivate) any virus on any surface. Temperature will dry the membrane of any COVID virus that remains on the shadow. People immune system is much stronger in Summer, and people go out, do not live that close together as in Winter. Once you let it enter like the UK, Spain, Italy or US did, it is too late. It took three months for the Spain going "from 1 to 0", and it was the biggest catastrophe for the economy and democracy itself in decades, because it takes time for the spread to halve. And it did not get a real 0 after all the pain. Spanish' Spring and Summer had probably the biggest effect after all. It is not that catastrophic by the way. Once people get infected, they do not get infected away, and just protecting people over 65 years old with vaccine will stop most deads. In fact just going for people over 80 years old have a significant effect on deads. In the US, 15% of the population is over 65 years old and 9% already got the first dose. Next month most of them will be immune.
- mkl 6y agoAustralia did "let" it enter, and had worse per capita infection rates than the UK for a while, and still got control of it and eliminated it. I don't think it's too late, but I (in NZ) think other countries have done pretty soft and ineffective "lockdowns".
- anotherevan 6y agoCan we please stop going on about it being summer. The lockdowns we had in Melbourne that lead to elimination was during our winter.
- gridspy 6y agoAs a citizen of New Zealand I believe a short, sharp lock-down combined with test & contact trace is the only route to zero. I think that this option is far far better than being in "half measures" restrictions for very long periods of time. When a country announces their lock-down measures I feel excited for their populace that they might finally be heading to zero. Then I read the holes in the measures: - Resturants open, even if only for takeout. - People mixing bubbles with friends - Working from an office when WFH is possible - Anything beyond food, health and utilities being considered "essential" and allowed - Lack of financial support so it is not financially feasible to take public health measures (stay home, feed family, get tested, get healthcare). I can't wait for other countries to simply copy the New Zealand quarantine rules and institute an Alert level 4 lockdown, not some half-hearted level 3 / 2 ripoff. Ask for level 4: https://covid19.govt.nz/assets/resources/tables/COVID-19-alert-levels-summary.pdf https://covid19.govt.nz/assets/resources/tables/COVID-19-ale... When all the citizens are in this together, when they all see the shared sacrifice and they have the means to actually take a lock-down together ... it's a huge weight off. It would only take 6 weeks of true level 4 to transform the infection rate of any nation - the virus dies out if it cannot spread.
- rich_sasha 6y agoIn Europe, the conclusion was that you simply cannot do that, physically. It is so integrated, even for essentials such as food or medication, that you have a huge area, requiring delivery/lorry drivers whizzing around, medical staff in hospitals and care homes, etc. Short sharp shock just can’t happen. So then, if you’re stuck in shades of gray, you have to weigh the antiviral benefits of the lockdown with just keeping the lights out. That’s a tough one to balance. Kudos to New Zealand, I’m just not sure it’s a blueprint others can replicate.
- gridspy 6y agoLorry drivers should only live in one city. Anywhere else, they need to "self isolate" - contact-less reception of food, hand-off of documents etc. On return home, they need to assume they became infected en-route and use PPE suitable for that reality. Medical staff already know how to avoid taking disease home. They just need the funding and support to access the right PPE, facilites and reasonable hours. If they are in transit, the need a good reason and well thought out measures. Quarantines don't need to stop all people, just those who are likely to spread the disease.
- thaumaturgy 6y agoI can't find it right now, of course, but somebody -- I think it was Tom Scott -- had a decent video early on in the pandemic that said, "as a pandemic gets bigger, it gets more weird." Coronaviruses mutate, and every single infected human becomes a petri dish for new mutations. The rest is straightforward natural selection: the most efficient covid-19 variants will win. We might get lucky; the most efficient variant might accidentally mutate away all the things that makes it deadly to humans. There might even be some selection pressure for that. But it could also stay about as deadly while changing enough about its spike protein to defeat antibodies in previously infected individuals and get more infectious in the process, and that would be a really bad scenario. I've been stunned for the last 12 months at the volume of the people that are totally okay with this, since we have no way of knowing right now how this might turn out over the next few years.
- gridspy 6y agoWe also don't know the true percentage of infected who actually do recover 100% with no long-term issues.
- ahepp 6y agoLast spring, we were flattening the curve. Last summer, we were waiting for a vaccine. Last fall, we were solving the logistical challenges for production. Now I'm starting to see headlines that "just because there's a vaccine, doesn't mean it's over"? I'm 25. I've spent the last year in a small apartment alone with my dog. If the problem is that we didn't lock down well enough the first time, why should I believe a better job will be done this time? If the CDC says it, I'll do it. But I'm tired of reading "science writers" constantly shitting on the situation. Really makes me wonder why I bothered in the first place. I thought "American science has given us a Lamborghini when what the world needs is a Toyota" was a particular gem in this piece. I could swear six months to a year ago I was reading people like this guy saying we shouldn't expect a vaccine to be discovered soon, if ever.
- josephg 6y agoThe problem is that if 80% of the population do their civic duty and stay home while the remaining 20% carry on with life as usual - go to bars and sporting events, protest, and so on then the numbers won't come down. The reality of covid is that a few selfish people can easily ruin the hard work of everyone else. Here in Australia we tried asking people who were infected to just quarantine in their own homes. Eventually the police went around and started doing spot checks, and found that a bunch of people who had known positive covid tests had gone in to work! No no no - you need strict enforcement to go along with lockdown rules or it just doesn't seem to work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sparrish 6y ago"I prefer dangerous freedom over peaceful slavery." ~ Thomas Jefferson
- dennis_jeeves 6y agoThank you, now try telling that to the peaceful slaves :)
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y ago> Moreover, our politicians have placed their bets on two high-tech, two-shot and costly vaccines, Pfizer and Moderna. They require refrigeration that half the world can’t afford. > American science has given us a Lamborghini when what the world needs is a Toyota There is no Pfizer vaccine ... it's German science from Biontech. The author doesn't even get this detail right. Why should I take his panicky opinion serious? > They actually represent an entirely new pandemic. This is semantics abused for FUD. It's not a new pandemic - period. > And by New Zealand’s or Taiwan’s measure, we look very bad. Did it even occur to this guy that his favorite reference countries are small islands with basically just one major ship and airport? > Be like a zero hero, like New Zealand’s Jacinda Ardern. This whole text is just a cheesy opinion piece - not a scientific view. > No politician wanted to hear that evidence [by Drosten], and many continue to ignore it. Not true - he's been the court scientist of German government since early 2020.
- wgjordan 6y agoNot to mention that Moderna's vaccine doesn't require special refrigeration that 'half the world can't afford', just the pfizer/biontech vaccine. Moderna's vaccine can be stored in regular refrigeration for up to 30 days.
- cudgy 6y ago“ New Zealand, Australia, Vietnam, Iceland and Taiwan got it right. They went to zero and eliminated the virus. Atlantic Canada and the North got it right, too.” These countries are all islands. How is that representative of the rest of the world and how they can handle it?
- eqdw 6y agoThis author appears to be completely unaware that, in the US anyway, the progress of the pandemic has been completely and totally disconnected from all control measures. San Francisco, where I'm told (and believe, based on having lived there) that they had very strict lockdown measures: https://www.sfdph.org/dph/alerts/coronavirus.asp https://www.sfdph.org/dph/alerts/coronavirus.asp * Population: ~900,000 * Total Cases: 31,111 (3,457 / 100k) * Total Deaths: 324 (36 / 100k) Compare Austin, TX, where I can personally attest that basically everyone has said fuck the rules for almost six months now https://austin.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/39e4f8d4acb0433baae6d15a931fa984 https://austin.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#... * Population: ~2,400,000 * Total Cases: 68,290 (2,845 / 100k) * Total Deaths: 655 (27 / 100k) The stats are virtually identical despite dramatically different policy decisions. So what the hell is the point? As an addendum, to put this into perspective: in 2020, Oakland's murder rate was 23/100k, making it _almost as high as the covid death rate_. Why is it that one year of covid deaths is a world-destroying incident, but _every_ year of Oakland deaths and nobody does anything about it ever? Are Bay Area people really just that racist?
- edoceo 6y agoMy perception, born and raised east-bay, is the Oakland has been a lost cause (for murders) since at least 1985. And more than one mayoral candidate has talked up the issue. But, and this is the terrible part, the murder happens to "the poors". So, IMO,, it's less about racism and more about classism (possibly rooted in racism). It's similar to how we (usa) don't care too much about the covid deaths. It's like Earthican tradition for disease and pestilence to affect poor folks first/more and for the wealthy to just not see it (they simply look the other way).
- lamontcg 6y agoNowhere in the US has really had harsh lockdown measures. SF also has density issues that will drive up the r0 of the virus. While the widely quoted r0 of the virus is around 3.0, the r0 in NYC at the start of the outbreak was estimated to be 5.0 (You could argue about if that was really the r(t) and not r0, but I'm not considering time-dependence or the reaction to the virus, but the actual starting reproduction number in NYC before there was any human reaction to the virus -- that isn't a constant value but depends on the local conditions). Austin has an overall 3,000 people per square mile density, SF has an overall 18,000 people per square mile (and some areas are even more dense than that).
- anotherevan 6y agoCan people in the northern hemisphere stop banging on that the reason it is so easy for us to get a handle on COVID in Australia is because it is summer. We eliminated COVID in Melbourne during winter with wearing masks and real lockdowns. It was not easy. It required a huge effort of societal and political will and cooperation. It involved following the science. Stop blaming the weather.
- username90 6y agoDoes Australia even have winters? I mean, it never gets cold in Melbourne. Your winter is close to my summer.
- flukus 6y agoIt gets cold enough that people spend much more time congregating inside, that's all that matters to the virus.
- anotherevan 6y ago> Your winter is close to my summer. Sucks to live where you do. :-^