12 ms·
Right to Repair off to the races in 2021 with 14 active states
- umvi 6y agoGlad to see my state (Maryland) on the list. But what does this mean for me if the Bill passes? That Apple can't sell iPhones in Maryland without providing access to schematics and parts needed to perform repairs? Surprised California is not on the list, but makes sense if all the big tech companies are heavily opposed.
- r00fus 6y agoCould it be that Apple's latest "repair support" effort was a way to get ahead of these rulings? I wouldn't be surprised if the laws couldn't be adhered by Apple by simply enhancing their repair certification/support process. That or, possibly more ominous, if John Deere/Apple could simply make a brute force effort to have judiciary overturn the laws when they're challenged in court.
- joshspankit 6y agoSome of the arguments against say “Apple will never make truly repairable phones! If we let these laws pass, they’ll just take those sweet sweet phones away and we won’t be able to buy them anymore!” But, realistically it will probably mean that Apple gets some sort of “temporary” thing in place that lets them circumvent the law until such point that they do the bare minimum to be able to convince lawmakers that “See? We’re doing good. Certainly you can change the law just a little so that we’re allowed to do that. Right?”
- astrea 6y agoWhat's not repairable about a modern phone?
- ryanmarsh 6y agoThis is what I can’t figure out.
- cwhiz 6y agoSchematics, availability of parts.
- SturgeonsLaw 6y agoAnything is repairable if you've got the tools and the know-how, but things like glue instead of screws are hostile to user repairs. I've had to open a Surface that wasn't booting to recover data from the SSD and the adhesive on the screen was so strong I had to snap pieces of glass off with a screwdriver to get to it. Even the photos in the iFixit guide showed fractures in the screen. Heat guns only get you so far with some of these glues, and solvents can damage the plastics.
- google234123 6y agoThe glue probably saves so many phones from water damage.
- dvdkon 6y agoA lot of electronics are potted in epoxy or something similar, true, but things like conformal coatings and/or rubber seals are actually much more common. Industrial equipment often needs to be both repairable and water/dustproof and uses these methods.
- OrwellianChild 6y agoScreen assemblies, circuitry, batteries, etc. Both Apple and Samsung have moved to serialized chips/circuits to lock out 3rd party replacement (even if the part is identical). Folks have done swaps of OEM components to different iPhones and they don't just fail - they sporadically glitch. [1] It's categorically anti-consumer behavior. They also often buy up proprietary access to caps, ICs, and other mainboard components so none are available to the 3rd party market. Independent computer repair shops have to tear down old (non-serialized) machines or rely on parts from questionable origin to even be able to attempt repair. [1] https://www.ifixit.com/News/45921/is-this-the-end-of-the-repairable-iphone https://www.ifixit.com/News/45921/is-this-the-end-of-the-rep...
- Dylan16807 6y agoLots of phones have: * designs that have to be cracked open with a significant chance of damage * glue or seals that can't easily be undone/redone * hard to get replacement parts * software lockouts * permanently locked bootloaders even when they stop getting security patches
- astrea 6y agoAside from the last two points, aren't a lot of these the result of progressing the state of the art? To get a fast SOC that has all the gizmos and gadgets and fits in a small, waterproof container you have to make some unsavory design decisions.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI am very confident that Apple would rather make repair schematics available than halt iPhone sales in 14 states.
- gennarro 6y agoGlad to see New York here. Hasn’t been the best year in NY, but the state does largely seem to have its act together.
- mmastrac 6y agoI think you can thank Louis Rossmann for that - he spent a good amount of time traveling around the NE US actively arguing for RtR in front of governments (local and larger)
- at-fates-hands 6y agoLouis is an OG in that regard. He's been lobbying for this for a long time. I'm glad to see all of his hard work has not been in vein and progress is finally being made.
- throwaway894345 6y agoMy understanding is that DMCA precludes cracking DRM or even sharing information on how to do the same, so in the case of digital repairs, does that mean DMCA takes precedence over right-to-repair if a particularly stubborn OEM applies DRM to their digital systems?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- syshum 6y agoIt would depend on the wording of the Right to Repair law Most of them are placing a burdern on the Manufacturer of the products to release tools, documentations, parts, etc that allow independent repair, this type of right to repair would not in anyway be in conflict with DMCA, as DMCA allows manufacturers to release tools to "circumvent" their own production, what is illegal is a 3rd party releasing a tool with out manufacture/copyright holder agreement Most state level right to repair laws say "Fine if you want to sell a device that does not allow for independent repair you product is not welcome in this state" Thus no conflict with DMCA
- DaiPlusPlus 6y ago> "Fine if you want to sell a device that does not allow for independent repair you product is not welcome in this state" There's still a lot of wiggle-room in there - Apple, for example, could argue that they're fine with "repair" being for things like replacing "dumb" iPhone components like the display and battery, but because the T2 security chip is an encapsulated, irreducible, atomic, component of the phone that being non-repairable is a design feature as that's how it protects the user's private data (and Apple's DRM...) they shouldn't be legally compelled to release the details of the T2 chip. ...or something.
- at-fates-hands 6y ago
- amznthrwaway 6y agoThis is a bad, authoritarian, extreme leftist law, supported by people who fundamentally oppose freedom. I hope that companies figure out how to satisfy the letter of this nonsensical legislation without creating too much cost for typical consumers who do not care about this, and who will be negatively impacted by the selfish, self-righteous, big government loving fools who support it. If self-repair was important to consumers, market forces would have brought it to bear. It is not important to consumers.
- LockAndLol 6y agoSteve Jobs is rolling in his grave. After working so hard to make repairing Apple devices a pain... and all that work is being undone. Do these laws take everything repairable into consideration? Last I read, farmers were getting bent over by their farming equipment makers.
- t-writescode 6y agoThe article points out it farmers as some of the loudest proponents of it.
- voicedYoda 6y agoBecause John Deere hates RtR, and combines cost over 250k, are a sweet profitable business, and JD wants to control their market
- subaquamille 6y agoWhile following the same goal, France's trying a different approach: a repair score [1] that will be stamped on products: Concretely, a grade out of 10 will be added to the labels of washing machines, laptops, smartphones, TVs and lawn mowers. This score will be calculated based on criteria such as: ease of disassembly, price and availability of spare parts and access to repair information. No new market rule but a more informed consumer. I thought you guys would like this "free-market makes-best-decisions" gov lobbying. Hope it won't end as the precedent: we got a "healthy-score" on most food products -which is great- but the cheese lobby put much effort to gets special rules as salt and fat would give them an awful grade [2] 1: https://repair.eu/fr/news/french-repairability-index-what-to-expect-in-january/ https://repair.eu/fr/news/french-repairability-index-what-to... 2: https://www.santepubliquefrance.fr/content/download/150263/file/QR%2520scientifique%2520et%2520technique_EN_271020.pdf https://www.santepubliquefrance.fr/content/download/150263/f...
- pacamara619 6y agoConsidering Apple got a very good score for their newest laptop, this is index is broken my design.
- pacamara619 6y agoEDIT: by instead of my
- CharlesW 6y ago> Considering Apple got a very good score for their newest laptop… Just curious, from who? iFixIt scored the current MacBook Pro design a "1", and the current MacBook Air design a "3".
- OrwellianChild 6y agoThe French repair score system mentioned by OP gave the latest Macbook 16" a repair-ability score of 7/10. This unfortunately makes the French approach pretty much useless.
- giantg2 6y ago$330 per year in savings sounds a bit low to me. I can save that much (or more) just with car repairs or maintenance. Even basic household stuff will typically cost $50-100 just for "the guy" to show up.
- ddingus 6y agoSeriously. I save a grand easy, every year. Pretty much do not have people show up and a whole lot can be ordered.
- herewegoagain2 6y agoBasic household stuff doesn't break every year. And not everybody is qualified to repair that stuff (which happens to be plugged into power outlets). I personally didn't dare to try to repair my washing machine or dishwashers (beyond cleaning clogged pipes), although I know people who do.
- giantg2 6y agoI don't think I've ever had a year where something didn't break or need maintenance. Some things are supposed to be done annually, like flushing your hot water heater. And the anode rod should be replaced as needed too (usually 2-4 years). With the number of devices in most homes, I find it unlikely that something doesn't need maintenance or repair in a year. Not to mention the people with cars. The point of the right to repair bills is that the useful life of products can be extended through repair. So I guess some people who are always buying new replacements and upgrades would be less likely to need those repairs as many repairs happen later in a product's life. I've fixed my washer and dryer before. Even just simple things like replacing the belts or resetting the thermal OL switch can be done by anyone, no qualification needed.
- kaczordon 6y agoAnd what happens if a company successfully lobbies to exempt themselves from this? This will just become another form of regulatory capture. It’s not clear to me that there’s a market failure of any kind here.
- matkoniecz 6y agoWell, yes. If regulatory capture happens then it means that regulatory capture happened. Not sure why you think that it is argument against regulation.
- kgin 6y agoAs more and more electronic components are becoming integrated, how does one decide when a right to repair is being honored vs violated? At what level do parts need to be individually replaceable?
- 8bitsrule 6y agoHere in the US, it's sad that this 'campaign' is even necessary. Plenty of people used to make a living doing repairs to TVs, radios, tape and CD players ... "Our new report finds massive cost savings from repair." No shit. That's why that used to be the norm. Until some predators-in-training paid Congress to destroy those businesses. And now we need to struggle? to get back what was once obvious and common sense?? Throw-away culture is a disease.
- detaro 6y agoWho paid congress to destroy TV repair businesses? What did congress do to destroy them?
- andrewmcwatters 6y agoI don't think it's the throwaway culture; it's amazing to me that we have a society that doesn't see a problem with not understanding the concept of "repair" in general. People legitimately think that repairing something means to just replace it. People think this.
- samatman 6y agoI used to hang out in the back of one of those repair shops, so I remember what they were repairing. There were through-hole components and chips with pin mounts, most armatures were pot metal. If you looked inside a TV now, you'd see mostly surface mount components, and molded plastic armatures. There's just not as much to repair anymore, things either work or they don't. I'm not saying it's good or bad, I'm saying there was no conspiracy to drive repair shops out of business, just a general switch to more reliable (yes, more reliable) electronics, which happen to also be less repairable. White goods are a different story, things like washing machines have been built in an increasingly cynical fashion.
- OrwellianChild 6y agoYou'd be surprised, I think, just how much can be fixed by indie shops still... Louis Rossmann [1] is pretty well-known around here since he documents everything, but if you watch, he's replacing capacitors that are fractions of the size of a grain of rice on Macbooks all day long. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBAZCUShuU4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBAZCUShuU4
- rektide 6y agoThere's some meta-analysis, perspective, that I think Cory Doctorow captured very well on this topic, broadly, recently. "Descartes' God has failed and Thompson's Satan rules our computers"[1] is the true fact of the day, describes the hell-hole shit-crap reality we have been forced into via extremely aggressive IP rules & enforcement. Corporatism pushing ever-diminishing legal & ethos-based respect for humanity keeps making victory after victory, against humankind's ability not (just) to repair, but to understand, to be in contact with, to learn about the world about them. Corporate machinehood has permission to dictate that the user know nothing, learn nothing, understand nothing, be merely reduced to an end-user. This is poison, at the deepest level an abject violation of the spirit & virtue of the fundamental birthright of man- the tool maker- to learn & develop & improve their environment. The new equation of computing turns us into animals, mere users of what is. It is vile. A right to repair is such a basic, fundamental expression, of our right to continue, to avoid loss, but the real battle is so much larger, so much about whether corporations are allowed to control & own understanding, or whether mankind is permitted an ongoing say & understanding of the artifacts that fill our world. Man became great upon a backbone of natural science, but science of the artificial is prevented by law. Props to Cory, for, as usual, calibrating us & driving us towards some very common very basic sense. [1] https://pluralistic.net/2020/12/05/trusting-trust/#thompsons-devil https://pluralistic.net/2020/12/05/trusting-trust/#thompsons...
- herewegoagain2 6y ago"the hell-hole shit-crap reality" Yeah, those iPhones and MacBooks are such shit, really. What a hellish world to live in.
- rektide 6y agoIt is dehumanizing to me that we have invented legal & technical systems that reverse the historical trend, of man, the learner, man the toolmaker, man the natural scientist, who understands more & more of the world about them. We have created proprietary knowledge, proprietary systems, that are massively popular, ubiquotously used, that none of us are allowed to nor can understand or learn about. I am in awe, have huge respect for the hight heights of this high technology that we have arisen towards. But, for the first time, it feels like it is captivated wonder. And unlike something complex like a train or airplane, this high tech is deeply deeply fundamental to our everyday life, reshapes our reality immensely. And it is a hell, forever boiling & changing around us, that we can not see, can not understand, have no access to, no ability to learn about these deeply propietary bits of tech that are all around us, that we spend so much time enmeshed in. It is a philosophical violation of the spirit of humankind, of the highest order.
- mrweasel 6y agoWhat if just one state signs a law that says that manufacturer must supply schematics and spare parts to third party repair shops? Wouldn't that essentially make them available across the US? The independent stores would need to get everything via that state of cause, but is there something that would prohibit the movement of parts and schematics across the US?
- herewegoagain2 6y agoPeople just can't get their heads wrapped around the efficiency of industrialization. Repairing stuff is an expert dedicating 30 minutes or more (often more) to your gadget. (sometimes that expert might be you yourself - it still remains true). In the same time, factory drones can produce hundreds of the same gadget. Naturally, the time of the expert is much more expensive than simply buying a new gadget. This "right to repair" is romanticized nonsense, like the idea of everybody growing their own food. Not that I don't like the idea of being able to repair my own things. I even think one should try occasionally, just so that one doesn't become totally stupid. But to claim it is somehow a common good and betterment of society is nonsense. The opposite is true. Devices will now become more expensive for everybody, because companies have to jump through hoops to make them repairable, even though hardly anybody will actually repair them. If you want to tinker, or grow your own food, get a Raspberry Pi or a little tomato plant for your balcony Also, if you are worried about the environment, perhaps recycling laws make more sense, or more specifically, producers being responsible for the proper disposal of their devices. Would have to consider the upsides and downsides, though.
- csours 6y agoI mostly agree, but I do think more could be done for maintainability and repair-ability. I used to work in an automobile assembly plant, and even in the plant it is much better to build the vehicle correctly the first time than it is to repair it. On the assembly line, every thing takes one minute or less (ish, depending on line rate). The alternator is bolted to the engine in a minute [0]. The transmission is bolted to the engine in a minute. The doors go on the car in a minute. etc etc. Very few things take longer than a minute. Meanwhile, if you have to change an engine, the first time you know you will have to change it is at the end of the line, when the vehicle is completely assembled, and it takes several hours to remove and replace the engine. In fact, often times the engine is removed at the end of the line, then the vehicle is sent back down the line to meet up with a freshly assembled engine! So yes, first time production is much, much more time efficient than repair - BUT - Repair and maintenance is a design goal just like any other design goal. Manufacturers care about it some because of warranty costs and resale value and reputation. Consumers asking for more attention to be paid to those design goals is completely reasonable to me. Unfortunately there is no strong signal of repairability at the time of purchase; whereas there is a strong signal of cost, feature set, and initial quality; thus manufacturers concentrate on those design features (among others, like safety and other legal requirements) 0. The alternator person will also have some other tasks like starting some bolts for the next person down the line. The point is that no single step takes longer than a minute. The very few steps that do take longer than a minute are remarkable and you will see things like the line splitting into two, or the 4 of the same process cell working round robin on cars as they go down the line.
- catdawg 6y agoI think this is more of an issue of sustainability. I wish that there would be some system where each product that is put on the market would have to provide a sustainability analysis, and pay more/less taxes depending on this rating. This analysis could be something like "what happens to the materials after it becomes obsolete?", "how long is it going to last under normal usage?", "How biodegradable is the packaging?", etc.. This would force companies to actively look for ways to improve this rating, and hopefully lead to better practices overall. Some products are just too difficult to repair, or just pointless to repair past a certain age as they become obsolete (like a phone). But they can be safely and cost effectively be recycled in bulk.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI'm not sure this issue matters. Open many devices today, and you've damaged their case and compromised any environment-proofing they may have had. And who has the pots of sealant and gasket treatments necessary to restore that? So sure, go ahead and repair your pool pump controller yourself. But be prepared to have it get moisture in the case, have all the contacts turn black and become a wad of worthless corrosion.