8 ms·
Could Google Really Leave Australia?
- mianos 6y agoI still can't see why google can't just remove Australian news sites from the index? It should be a very small list for Australia. They already do this for copyright claims.
- conro1108 6y agoThey probably could, but at least at this point they're probably more concerned with discouraging other governments from trying to pass similar laws.
- wussboy 6y agoIn my mind, following through on their threat is the worst thing Google could do. If they leave and Australia’s business and government suffer, other countries are going to make laws to ensure this doesn’t happen to them.
- Kim_Bruning 6y agoThere's no law you can make to force a company to do business within your borders. Especially when they start operating at a net loss. Google is backed into an impossible corner here, and pretty much must leave.
- jazoom 6y agoArs Technica article suggested Australia's new laws also makes that illegal. As an Australian, I think this is silly. Our current government really sucks with technological issues.
- gumby 6y agoI agree. They declared legislation superior to mathematics. Crazy.
- 0xy 6y agoNo, not just current government. Both major parties fully supported metadata retention and the encryption ban. This is not a partisan problem.
- curryst 6y agoNot an Australian, but I don't find it entirely silly. Google delisting Australian news would be the inevitable outcome. It's worth almost nothing to them. They're evening out the playing field. Google can shrug off Australian news, but they're going to have to think carefully about whether they're willing to turn off Search for a first world country. One loophole I'm very curious about is Google creating their own news organization. Not even a news organization, really just a news licenser and republisher. They have access to everyone's Google searches. I would imagine they're capable of creating a piece of software that calculates how much they're paying to news organizations for what keyword searches, then automatically purchasing an article about that from another publisher that scores better for those keywords (putting them above the other publishers in the searches) and publishing it. Bonus points if they don't even pay for it, they have a human write an article summarizing the other articles, and run it through their scoring pipeline so the writer can tweak it until their SEO score is better than the other articles. Then Australian news will really be screwed. Little money from Google, and even fewer clicks than they got before. The one thing I do think was silly is making it adversarial. If you want news agencies to make more money, making Google pay to send them traffic is a bad way to go about that. They should have done something like introducing a tax on Google, and then refunding part of the tax when Google sends people to an Australian news site instead of a foreign one.
- coolspot 6y agoYou can’t seriously call a country where encryption is illegal a first world country.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoFirst world just means USA aligned capitalist country.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jonny_eh 6y ago
- eps 6y agoAs a non-Australian, I somehow have this impression that all your recent governments sucked, and not just with the tech issues.
- mianos 6y agoThe article on Ars suggests that the new law would not allow them to delist one provider and allow another. This is not law yet, this is part of the proposal. I am still looking for some evidence that they are not allowed to delist all news sources. This may be my lack of understanding the legalese. There is maybe some 'poison pill' in just delisting news and they are going the nuclear option in Australia.
- simonblack 6y agoThis is really a fight over money between Rupert Murdoch's Fox/Newscorp Empire and Google. A win-win situation for Australia would be for Google to withdraw from Australia and Rupert to not get any money from Google.
- aaplok 6y agoThe article claims that the ABC would benefit from deals with Google, but wasn't the ABC (and SBS) expressly excluded from the law? It's clear that it is a lobby vs lobby situation. Murdoch is a king maker. He will likely prevail. I am not as optimistic about a positive outcome for Australians.
- joshschreuder 6y agoI believe they were, due to them being publicly funded. Which is to say nothing of the fact that such public funding has been continuously stripped back under Liberal governments (while continuing to give investment to Foxtel, a private company owned by, guess who, old mate Rupert)
- fakedang 6y agoDoes it matter if Rupert doesn't get money from Google? His news assets still have print versions, his channels still have media versions, and if Google exits, they'll just concede the entire Aus market to Bing/DDG. Sure the people won't like it, but the more Google actually goes through with its threat, the more evidence it will provide for an antitrust case back home.
- silexia 6y agoI disagree, Google is not making a threat and is not abusing its market position. A search engine simply cannot exist if it is required to pay for links to content. Rupert Murdoch and his corporations are incredibly damaging to Australia and to the USA. We should oppose his lobbying efforts everywhere we can. I think Google is now no longer a good company, but it is not nearly as bad as Fox News or Comcast or other companies that truly abuse their market position. The one area that Google does actually abuse is Google Ads, the auction system there is basically a scam against small business unfortunately.
- killingtime74 6y agoPlease leave, we’d love it
- rasz 6y agoLike you loved GM leaving?
- eindiran 6y agoGM as in General Motors? Is there some context here I am not aware of?
- wryun 6y agoGM closed their Australian factory a few years ago (Holden), and recently stopped selling cars here entirely.
- harry8 6y agoAustralia used to have tariff barriers to support local car manufacturers. Ford, GM, Chrysler/Mitsubishi set up. From that we got a local industry and poor quality, expensive cars. Tariff barriers were removed, GM shut down local production. Is that a good thing now Toyotas are cheaper? Opinions vary. Were the jobs working for GM that were lost made up elsewhere as s result of the end of the tariffs? You guessed it, opinions vary. Google don't pay meaningful tax in Australia so it's hard to like them here.
- rasz 6y agoLet me try again: Like you loved Altium leaving? I didnt mention Toyota because it might seem like a win in some peoples eyes (invaders retreating). Yay for cheaper cars you cant afford because your manufacturing job was moved to Thailand due to half assed half-free trade deals. Sooner or later you will either work in a mine, or in service industry feeding/taking care for the miners. https://theconversation.com/the-curse-of-the-resources-boom-could-our-wealth-be-our-ultimate-weakness-9635 https://theconversation.com/the-curse-of-the-resources-boom-...
- 6y ago
- kalium-xyz 6y agoPlease also leave all other countries I do business with. :)
- 908B64B197 6y agoOne one hand we see some politicians puffing their chest and simply waving goodbye at Google. On the other, I wonder what's the net brain flow coming in and out of Australia, and how that attitude regarding tech affects it.
- Barrin92 6y agoMy suspicion would be that more tech workers leave Australia for the US than move there, and if the government were to combine kicking Google out with domestic industry programs it could have a positive effect on retaining talent.
- thundergolfer 6y agoI’m an Australian that would be delighted to work in public service on ambitious projects. My confidence in the government being able to make it work is essentially zero. It’ll take decades to fix what’s broken in Australia’s public IT sector, and with the Liberal party in power we ain’t starting today. Just having Scott Morrison read The Entrepreneurial State would be a start, but I’m not convinced that the man actually reads books.
- girvo 6y agoAnecdotally most of my developer friends have moved to the US. I prefer Brisbane’s lifestyle so I’m still here.
- wussboy 6y agoI’m curious. What is Brisbane’s lifestyle like? Would love to visit.
- justaguyOOL 6y agoGood riddance, wake up people.
- antonyh 6y agoGoogle has to push back to stop this happening in other countries. In any case, they can negotiate with price on SERP results ads and on the ads they no doubt place on Murdochs sites. Things will balance out if it does go ahead. I wouldn't be surprised to see Google leave briefly to fully illustrate their power in the marketplace - I doubt it's an empty threat. If I ran a AU based business that's dependent on Google I'd be emergency planning right now.
- aynsof 6y agoI'm curious to see what would happen in this case. Would DuckDuckGo or Bing get a boost that Google? Would Google struggle to recover that market share when it inevitably returned? Would public perception of Google take a dip, or would Australians respect someone standing up to the Rupert Murdoch press?
- ptcampbell 6y agoMy guess is Australians would continue to use a non localised version of Google. Bing and by extension DDG is awful for Australian results in my experience.
- sidr 6y agoUnless they block all Australian IPs as well. I don't know about widespread VPN adoption just to have access to Google.
- eps 6y agoOr they could just drop the News tab and be done with it.
- apple_innocent 6y agoFor a lot of folks reading HN, who are trying to excise Google from their lives, if they were in Australia, this would be a dream come true. How do you make Google go away? Force them to pay.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 6y agoI find it obnoxious that they didn't do this in reaction to the A&A Act.
- Havoc 6y agoIf not being able to use other people’s content for free breaks their business model then maybe the business model is indeed a problem.
- sidr 6y agoShowing a link to a site is "using their content"? What's really ridiculous is that this law would not allow them to not show a link to Australian news sites that are demanding payment either. The law is literally forcing Google to "use their content" (as you call it) and forcing them to pay for it.
- Havoc 6y ago>Showing a link to a site is "using their content"? Google does way more than just "showing a link". The top part of search results is basically google ads and content google scraped off other sites. In many cases you can't even SEE a single bonafide link without scrolling below the fold. Featured snippets - scraped content Side bar - scraped content "People also asked" - scraped content
- trestenhortz 6y agoThere are perfectly good alternatives to google. Letting them go would not be such a bad thing. People assume google is unique and irreplaceable. It’s not.
- jonny_eh 6y agoWouldn't remaining search engines be subject to the new law?