12 ms·
Enter Sandbox: Google is building an internet without cookies
- SimeVidas 6y agoContextual ads don’t need cookies. The sooner publishers realize that, the better for them.
- AznHisoka 6y agoIf I'm reading an article about the pandemic, I probably don't want to see ads selling me face masks. If I'm reading an article about the inauguration, I probably don't want ads selling me inauguration t-shirts. I am however more likely to click on ads selling me home renovation stuff because they know I've recently bought something in Home Depot. Even though I'm not currently on a home renovation website.
- dkdk8283 6y agoI have never clicked on an ad and bought something.
- tux1968 6y agoNeither did anyone watching an ad on television, it's not just about click-through rate.
- AznHisoka 6y agoOk you are extrapolating your experience to millions of others in the world. Nothing wrong with that but it isn’t going to give you universal insights since you’re a special case.
- cratermoon 6y agoAlmost nobody clicks on an ad and buys something based on that. Conversion is a pipe dream, and ad rates are never based on actual click-throughs.
- thaeli 6y agoThe most effective ads on me, in terms of intentional click through rate (not going to count predatory clicks) are contextual ads on specialized sites. This doesn't work well for general stuff like news sites, but webcomics that do their own ads, or a super focused forum like candlepower or head-fi? Contextual ads are ideal there. Second most effective are platform-specicic hypertargeted ads, such as Facebook ads. Lot of misses there too, but their first party targeting is good to the point of actually giving me some interesting content. In practice the third party "contextual" ads mostly are misses for me. Wow, another ad for the home improvement thing I either researched and bought last month, or that I was looking up on a whim and don't have any intention of actually purchasing.
- mcbits 6y agoMaybe some articles just shouldn't have ads at all. That would be refreshing. Sites publishing ad-supported content obviously need to put the ads somewhere, but that doesn't mean every single article needs its own revenue stream to justify its existence.
- AznHisoka 6y agoI agree - that’s a whole separate argument though. If the argument is contextual vs personalized, personalized wins imo
- ubercow13 6y agoYou've just given two bad examples, contrasted with one good example, to prove your point. Pick a good example of a contextual ad and a bad example of a personalised ad (there are many) and the proof is reversed.
- AznHisoka 6y agoExcept that my example is more the more popular scenario. Pageviews of general news site surpass pageviews of niche websites about a specific topic. Just go look at the top visited websites.
- ubercow13 6y agoRight but your example is still intentionally bad, no one is going to put an inaugration t-shirt ad as the contextual ad for a news article. An ad on a general news site can be related to the preferences of the readership of that paper, like how it always worked in print. Or it can even be targeted based on information about you that is gathered first-party, from the patterns in your use of the news website.
- AznHisoka 6y agoI totally agree. But that probably won’t involve programmatic/traditional advertising. It will probably involve first party ads. Which I am definitely in favor of!
- cblconfederate 6y agoThey do. You can turn off personalized ads in adsense, but it still requires cookie consent
- tsimionescu 6y agoThere is nothing your client can do (other than blocking ads entirely) that would stop a company from serving you car ads on a car site - that's contextual ads. Personalized ads are the opposite - you're browsing a fashion site, but you'll get car commercials because you've been visiting car commercials lately.
- input_sh 6y ago> (other than blocking ads entirely) Easily avoidable in such case. You just need to do two things: 1. Serve them from your own domain where the URL pattern isn't obvious (so not something like example.com/ads/ad1). 2. Randomise HTML elements (div names, classes, a random amount of empty divs in between). Voila, ad-blocks are useless now.
- userbinator 6y agoRandomise HTML elements (div names, classes, a random amount of empty divs in between). That can be countered by adaptive element-matching algorithms. Just like with cracking software, it's a cat-and-mouse game, and there are far more mice out there... mice who are willing to work completely for free just to fight back against you.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThat’s an implementation issue. There’s no technical reason why a non-targeted ad needs tracking other than Google still trying to stalk people.
- soared 6y agoTargeting is a piece of the puzzle. As an advertiser I need frequency capping, brand safety, page quality, geo, etc. Ignoring all that.. I still need to measure results.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoYet somehow advertising existed for decades without being able to completely track the full path from viewed ad to purchase. Seriously, the completely f'd up view of advertisers ("Ads won't work unless I can basically track everything about you!!") shows how bonkers the world has become. If your job can't exist without in-depth tracking of how a shown ad influences purchasing behavior, maybe your job shouldn't exist. Seriously, ads would work plenty well enough by just showing the same ads to all users based on the contents of the page (or search query). Honestly, I'd be all for a legal framework that completely outlaws any "personalization" on the internet unless a user clearly and optionally opts in.
- soared 6y agoI mean.. so did medicine, buying stuff from the store, and social interaction. That doesn’t mean we stopped innovation when it went slightly awry. Medicine works well enough with leeches, why would improve that. There is a path to achieving similar adtech outcomes that are privacy focused, and that is what google is trying to accomplish. Why hate something that is trying to achieve what you want?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoLol, "innovation". How about this: Every user, when setting up a new device, gets a clearly displayed option as to whether or not they want to be shown personalized ads based on the tracking of their browser history. Basically, a clearly displayed "Yes, I want to be tracked for the purposes of showing me ads" option. How many people do you think with want to opt in if they really had the choice? Heck, why do you think Facebook is going so bananas over Apple just asking people to opt-in to tracking? The only 'innovation' going on is making the tracking difficult for your average, non-technical person to (a) know what is going on and (b) how to opt-out.
- cratermoon 6y agoEveryone in adtech, except perhaps Google, is worried. One non-Google player I know is seriously concerned about what the cookie-less web means or online ads. Essentially the entire online advertising industry, both publishers and advertisers, is built on 3rd-party cookies. The goal: to show you only ads for things you care about and are likely to buy and be influenced by advertising for, is good. But the reality is a mess. Some of the downsides of Google's proposal are obvious, given its position, but there's at least one downside that users might notice: lots more ads targeted only by the demographic of the publication, making the web look more like print media or TV and presenting you and me with a lot more space on our screens wasted showing ads for things you don't care about. As for the "fingerprinting" proposals? Bad. Very Bad. Think digital "facial" recognition bad.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThe goal: to show you only ads for things you care about and are likely to buy and be influenced by advertising for, is good. No, that's bad. The last thing I want is to be influenced by adverts.
- tomComb 6y agoI'd rather be influenced by relevant ads that could possibly be useful than ones that will just annoy me. And I'd rather not make ads less effective because that would mean either more ads or fewer publishers.
- amelius 6y ago> I'd rather be influenced by relevant ads that could possibly be useful than ones that will just annoy me. It's easier to ignore ads that are totally irrelevant. The ads that are targeted are the most distracting. I'd rather see ads about some detergent than about a new SSD drive that will catch my attention and makes me forget what I was looking for in the first place. When I need a new SSD, I will just visit a shop. I don't need ads for that.
- 6y ago
- TLightful 6y agoGood. May be the most important thing google have done in decades. Granted. Ive not read the article, so this could be a steaming pile of ... but I'm hopeful.
- BayAreaEscapee 6y agoI often find that the HN comments are more helpful than the article itself. If I read a bit of an article and it doesn't get to the point quickly, I just close it and start reading the HN comments.
- throw14082020 6y agoI see whats going on here. One ignoramus to another.
- TLightful 6y agoJoin the club. You seem entirely and perfectly suited. I'll get your gold card ready. Best wishes,
- birdyrooster 6y agoWhy wouldn’t services just proxy their vendors cookies for them via another side channel? Then voila your third party cookie problem goes away.
- jedberg 6y agoThe main reason is speed. It ads extra latency that kills ad response rates. Secondly is trust. The third party has no way to verify the first party isn't sending bogus requests to increase their payments from the third party and/or hurt their competitors.
- cratermoon 6y agoAd fraud is real. It goes the other way too, the "proxy" site could serve up a different ad from the one it's supposed to be sending, and it would be hard to know.
- sleavey 6y agoI've wondered this for years. It was the first thing I expected ad networks would start doing once third party cookies were getting blocked widely.
- Dma54rhs 6y agoMainly a trust issue with publishers.
- bpodgursky 6y agoIt only works if you have identified (logged-in) traffic and pass the identifier (ie, email hash) along to the side-channel. Otherwise there's no way to target the ads, it's a first-party cookie but scoped to a single domain so there's no useful targeting data. (and yes, this is the industry plan, but it's TBD whether publishers like media websites can get a workable fraction of their users to log themselves in)
- jedberg 6y agoOk, so basically Chrome will keep a profile on you and send that Google, so as long as the ads on the webpage are Google ads they will be targeted, but any third party provider will not be able to do the same? Sounds like they are finally realizing their vision for making Chrome in the first place -- to sell more ads. I'll stick with Firefox with temporary tabs -- I already an protected from third party cookies because Firefox already isolates every tab, but importantly doesn't send my browsing data anywhere.
- taf2 6y agoCan you provide some references to where you're seeing this. If anything they are killing off third party cookies just like Apple and Firefox. Also they are making it so even third party Javascript is less likely able to track you - meaning everything has to be first party. IMO this just means there will be a shift in how tracking works. Moving from third party tracking scripts you install on your website to using CDN's to pull code through or host on your own domain. IMO this means you'll be less able to identify when you're being tracked much more like how it works today on native apps, e.g. you can't tell whether that native app is tracking you.
- jedberg 6y agoI'm making some logical leaps. They appear to be killing off 3rd party cookies just like Apple and Firefox. The difference is that Apple and Firefox do not sell an ad product and don't have a reputation for tracking your every move on the internet. Google on the other hand does have a reputation for tracking you through Chrome.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoApple does sell an ad product, although I'm not sure whether it has any presence on the web.
- edoceo 6y agoWhat is it? I don't get it
- tomaszs 6y agoGoogle is building an internet without WWW, that is for sure: "Because data are ultimately transferred to the same businesses, it can be used to create detailed profiles, said academics. If information from a dating app, for example, were shared with the same parent company as data from a banking app, it could be possible to deduce the sexuality of a bank’s customers." https://ig.ft.com/mobile-app-data-trackers/ https://ig.ft.com/mobile-app-data-trackers/
- uniqueid 6y agoWorld Wide Google. If a modern person goes with the flow, they wind up using Google for every facet of their online life: OS, web browser, search, email, youtube watching, personal photos, cloud storage, DNS, address book, chat, office suite, wallet... I wouldn't entrust my best friend with all that data, let alone people over whom I have zero power and have never met.
- tomaszs 6y agoIt gives a really good perspective on the topic.
- sleavey 6y agoWhat's to stop a website gradually querying different API data on each page load to build up a profile with the same amount of information as before? Will browsers only allow the first N API accesses forever more? Oh, interesting... lots of nasty mistakes can be made by websites picking a bad set of APIs early on. However it works, I don't trust it if it's coming from Google. I'll keep my multiple layers of ad blockers enabled.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- soared 6y agoPublishers are allotted a certain amount of api calls per (user?) in theory to prevent that.
- duckfang 6y agoThere is a potential counter here by everybody not google. Run a browser string check, and redirect people to Firefox. Google is being blatantly anticompetitive, and significantly abusing monopoly status to further monopolies elsewhere. And the govt won't come to help in any near future, so it's up to the rest of us to back them off. (Now, why firefox? Well, its not because FF allows better tracking, but instead that nobody gets the tracking benefit. It's not a 'screw users with FF', but 'screw Goog with no metrics'.)
- izacus 6y agoHow does redirecting people to a browser who actively blocks tracking help publishers who want to track the crap out of you? :)
- throw14082020 6y agoLike you rightfully implied in your last paragraph, there is no incentive for websites to ask people to go to firefox. So they won't do it. I see companies siding with Google because they'll need to, to survive or grow, in the short run anyway.
- lmkg 6y agoGoogle wants your Google Account to be the only Identity Signal available on the web. This feature is available right now in Analytics and Ads. It's called "Google Signals." The documentation is publicly available, although it's a little scattered between different product page. I'll summarize: If the user is using Chrome, and is logged into their Google Account, then you can use that instead of cookies. This is used for pulling in demographic information, cross-domain tracking, and cross-device tracking (something even 3rd-party cookies can't do without fingerprinting!). The Privacy Sandbox kills other channels that might be an identity signal. Meaning ones available to parties other than Google. Even as an anti-Google zealot who disapproves of this, I'll admit there are some ancillary benefits. For one, I honestly do believe that Google intends to kill fingerprinting, because it's in their interest to do so. For another, Google does offer a setting "disable personalized advertising" which will centrally let you opt-out of this tracking. But most people are surprised when they find out that things already work this way, which to me already puts it on ethically dubious foundations from a privacy perspective. And, of course, the monopoly issue.
- hrktb 6y agoThat’s interesting, Google > “disable personalized advertising” On this bit, tracking concerns are not just for advertising though. Extending your reading on how they replace cookies with the Google id, I’d see them replacing ad targeting with other uses of the data anything that wouldn’t straight be labelled as “ad” (scoring, black listing, indirect target matching, etc.)
- joefkelley 6y agoI'm a Google engineer who interacts a little bit with this kind of stuff. There are a few settings for this kind of thing. You can take a look at https://myaccount.google.com/data-and-personalization https://myaccount.google.com/data-and-personalization The "Ad personalization" bit is probably what the parent comment is referring to. But it sounds like you're interested in the "Web & App Activity" bit, which will turn off the non-ads usage of your data. To a certain extent at least, since there are some grey areas. For example, I'm on the team that sends Google Shopping emails. If you click a button to track the price of a specific TV, we'll still send you an email if that price drops even if you've opted out of "Web & App Activity". But if you've just been browsing shopping pages for TVs, we won't send you a general email about TV deals if you've opted out. Both of those cases are in some literal sense "web activity" but it's still pretty clear what the user expects. But you might imagine- if you're tracking the price of a specific TV and opted-out of Web & App Activity, should we send you an email if a near-identical TV drops in price? We probably wouldn't, and we don't have anything like this today, but it's not quite as clear. And Google has so many features across different teams, I can imagine there's probably at least one where some privacy reviewer made a different call than what you would have made.
- einpoklum 6y agoAnother reason not to have Google profile and block them as a 3rd-party when relevant, e.g. using EFF Privacy Badger and uBlock Origin. Also, try avoiding Chrome. At least use Chromium, preferably something else.
- figgyc 6y agoI think one thing overlooked is that Google's supposed rationale for providing this service is effectively because they suppose that their plans to "more aggressively block fingerprinting" will leave advertisers with no other choice. Personally I find this highly unlikely. The very nature of fingerprinting makes it difficult to prevent without some pretty severe compromises, and it wouldn't surprise me if advertisers enter an arms race with Google instead of caving in. Of course the economic strategy for Google to avoid that is to reduce the price/limits of this service to so low that this isn't worth doing, but if the effort Google puts into preventing fingerprinting is insufficent then this would lead to a "worst of both worlds" situation - Google gets to pseudonymously track the internet with their "privacy sandbox", and nefarious trackers/advertisers can combine that with fingerprinting to create an even more reliable picture of who's who on the Internet. FYI, this[0] appears to be the explainer of what Privacy Sandbox actually is, and it's quite vague, presumably because the actual implementation details of this would be difficult to determine. [0] https://github.com/michaelkleber/privacy-model https://github.com/michaelkleber/privacy-model
- bobbydreamer 6y agoSo httpOnly and secure flags are not that secure in cookies.
- newbie578 6y agoI actually really like this idea. I trust Google the most out of all the other players, since they have the most to lose... If Apple can have everything built around a single ID and be praised for it's ecosystem, I don't see a reason why Google shouldn't try, especially since there are people who like Google more than Apple.
- 0x011721 6y agoAdvertising company takes steps to strengthen its advertising monopoly and shoulder out the competition. News at 11. Before you say "use firefox", ask yourself why Google donates money to Mozilla. The other aspect of advertising company is spy company. This will give Google better ways to track users across the web. I'm sure there will be no side effects and the information will be used only for good.
- vishwajeetv 6y agoUnfortunately, their own single-sign on services require us to have cookies enabled for client implementations (firebase auth), that remains the only reason to keep using cookies on the webapps I build.
- cccc4all 6y agoAntitrust. That's it. That's the comment.
- IgorPartola 6y agoThe only use for cookies I can see is authentication. There are other ways to authenticate that I have used that have been way less burdened by security issues. Store an auth token in local storage and transmit it as the Authentication header for example: CSRF problems, works with whatever framework you want. Why do we still need cookies at all?
- srfvtgb 6y agoCan you do this without Javascript?
- lima 6y agoNope.
- IgorPartola 6y agoMy argument is that if you need authentication, the browser should have that built in as a first class citizen. And if you don’t want it, then why set cookies?
- Null-Set 6y agoCross site scripting can exfiltrate an auth token stored in local storage. An HttpOnly cookie cannot be stolen this way, and with SameSite=strict, CSRF is not an issue.
- IgorPartola 6y agoIf I am running code on your site as another user, I don’t really need to steal you auth token. But that is true. Which is why browsers should expand support for authentication to provide things like public key authentication, credentials/personas storage, etc. At the very least, an API to store auth tokens (and just auth tokens). Better yet, a standard login UI for logging into any given website. Even better, public key auth so that instead of logging in by typing in a username and password, you would select which persona you use from a drop down and passwords aren’t a thing. Of course that would require a robust and secure mechanism for syncing the personas/keychains across different devices and browsers.
- draklor40 6y agoDamn. Talk about killing your competition off with a monopoly. Break up Big Google.
- trident5000 6y agoThe company has monopolies within a monopoly at this point. The DOJ is an embarrassment with no power. Theres never been such a concentration of economic activity in corporate America in general. Even the phone companies are about one merger away from being back to their former structure.
- soared 6y agoCorrect. That’s why google is working with Facebook/other major players (or at least acting like it) to create solutions to the problems they’re creating. Not working, because all the other members of the w3c group wrote an open letter saying google is abusing their power/etc.
- iou 6y agoIsn't this all a bit rich from a behavioural advertising company?
- soared 6y agoFWIW these proposals change every month and there are weekly calls with some of the W3C group about this. Nobody in adtech actually believes 3p cookies will be gone by the claimed date.. you can’t rebuild the entire ecosystem in (now) less than a year.
- soared 6y agohttps://github.com/w3c/web-advertising https://github.com/w3c/web-advertising Has more details for a lot of the proposals.
- glandium 6y agoI wonder if the title is an intentional reference to Metallica's song.
- Animats 6y agoFirefox has been blocking third-party cookies by default since 2019. I've had them off myself for about two decades now. Google's "solution" is inferior to what Firefox has now. Google could just follow Firefox in this and turn off third-party cookies.
- fouc 6y agoJust another reason to keep boycotting google & chrome.
- userbinator 6y agoAlways have, always will... but I wonder when someday some important site refuses to service me because I'm not using an "officially supported" (i.e. approved by Big Goog) browser which may no longer run on the hardware I use. It's already started happening. How can the masses fight back against the monopoly?
- kart23 6y agoFaking the user agent gets me past 99% of those 'unsupported browser' warnings.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agohere is a question - is it proper "siloing" , if i browse the web only in FF, using DDG and not logged into any GOOG within FF.... while at the same time logged in to my google account logged with chrome (email) ? Is that compartmentalization actually effective to avoid tracking ? (I am also running HTTPS everywhere, ublock, badger, etc on FF. NOthing from chrome )
- Groxx 6y ago>“We’re in this in-between situation where it’s really not satisfactory because you’ve got consumers not accepting cookies and no solution in place.” Oh my. That sounds awful. You know, I think I actually do want Google to build this into Chrome, wire it up to your Google account for nefarious purposes and/or have the whole thing turn into an example that K-anonymity doesn't work well in practice, and try to ram it down everyone's throats. Perhaps that will finally drive people away, and start up some monopoly investigations with teeth. In the meantime, I'll keep blocking 3rd party cookies, and rejecting on-site ones when undesired.
- coding123 6y agoLol, it sounds like Google is describing the experience you get when switching to FF and using DDG.
- userbinator 6y agoGoogle is building an internet That is the scariest thing about this. Google already has an effective monopoly on information discovery via its search engine, and is rapidly approaching one with what software people use to view information on the Internet. It controls the "web standards" and can change them rapidly with little opposition. Websites that have no business being anything but browser-agnostic, yet are usable only in the latest version of its ever-churning browser (or its not-too-different clones), are already uncomfortably common. For a lot of people, Google is "the Internet". I don't know what the solution is. But there's definitely a problem. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25802366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25802366
- permille42 6y ago1. Google doesn't own or control "the internet". They can change Google Chrome however they want; so long as they are plenty of us who don't want whatever crap they are peddling we can and will continue to use the internet as it has existed for a long time. 2. Web browsing is not "the internet". I get that headlines are all about grabbing attention by basically stating overblown lies and then backtracking in the details, but come on now. 3. Cookies aren't going away. They are necessary for how a majority of websites with login/sessions work. 4. 3rd party cookies are crap, and they may well be limited by most popular browsers. That is fine and doesn't affect normal web users. It affects advertisers to some degree, but no more than adblockers do. 5. So long as Google is involved in it, they are going to try to keep advertising profitable for themselves. So whatever "it's good for everyone" nonsense they are peddling its just them trying to prevent the public from shutting down the crappy internet advertising that most of us internet users have hated since it began. 6. It doesn't sound like they are working to prevent fingerprinting. That is the direction things should go imo; we need to get rid of all ability to identify visitors period. There is no reason why anyone needs to know what websites I visit or why, and I think there are plenty of people who agree with my desire in that regard. 7. I'm on the side of those calling to abandon Google and their nonsense. They can't be trusted any more.
- WhyNotHugo 6y ago> so long as they are plenty of us who don't want whatever crap they are peddling we can and will continue to use the internet as it has existed for a long time. This is why it worries me so much that so many people use Chrome (and the number seems to keep rising).