12 ms·
Both Apple and Huawei do R&D in Europe at a massive scale, hiring the top researchers and the best minds from universities, research labs and from the competiti
by ChuckNorris89 6y ago
Both Apple and Huawei do R&D in Europe at a massive scale, hiring the top researchers and the best minds from universities, research labs and from the competition (Nokia, Ericsson, ARM, Imagination, even intelligence services) with top pay to boot.
While Apple is nowhere near as evil as Huawei, it's sad when you think about it, that EUs best and brightest minds, educated with EU money are helping strengthen the Chinese and US tech titans instead of the domestic ones but Europe dug it's own grave here by not funding its domestic tech sector enough and sleeping at the wheel while US and China were stealing their lunch from underneath their nose.
- intev 6y agoCan you elaborate on "Europe dug it's own grave here"?
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoLook at what EU "tech" companies pay vs what FAANG/Huawei pays. A friend finished his PhD in ML and ended up taking a job at a FAANG in the EU as the tech companies from Germany and France were only willing to pay half of that. You can't be at the top if you treat your SW devs and researchers as an IT cost center.
- bogantech 6y agoThey pay worse than even non-FAANG tech companies in Australia too
- moonbug 6y agothere's more to a job than the salary.
- f6v 6y agoAn important mission or great workplace culture don’t pay for mortgage.
- acatton 6y agoBut even if you accept the paycut, it's not like the workplace culture is great: https://www.npr.org/2019/12/20/790101370/french-telecom-company-convicted-of-moral-harassment-after-employee-suicides https://www.npr.org/2019/12/20/790101370/french-telecom-comp...
- sofixa 6y agoOne case at a shitty former-public-becoming-private company. Not really applicable everywhere.
- andi999 6y agoBut this goes hand in hand. If the salary is very high, management will try not to waste your potential. If low they might not care.
- chrisseaton 6y agoRight - I also want my work to be interesting and impactful, my colleagues to be motivated and talented, to get generous time off, etc... and guess what even in Europe the North American companies do better at all these aspects as well!
- _hao 6y agoThere is, but it's the main consideration to be honest...
- ftoscano 6y agoYes, there is more than just the salary. Except that, in Europe, most (if not all) forms of "equity" are proportional: your title, your salary, your ability to decide, etc. It becomes an equivalence: * Since you decide nothing, therefore your salary is low. * Since your salary is low, you therefore decide nothing. This stems fundamentally from a (backward?) European strict view of companies, regardless of how hierarchical/flat their structure may be. And that view is that the corporate environment is split into two groups: * Managers: they decide; * Workers: they do work. This split may have made sense in the Industrial Revolution era but it has shown it's age in this day and age. And yet the model (and the perception, and the values) persist. If you, as a knowledge worker, ever make the mistake of "getting down and get things done" you will have chosen your side.
- sofixa 6y ago> Except that, in Europe, most (if not all) forms of "equity" are proportional: your title, your salary, your ability to decide, etc. It's funny that you completely missed the point ( i think the other person is making). What about time off? Pension? Parental leave? Medical costs? Way of life ( as in, work stops at 6pm or 7pm or whatever, and then it's your free time; weekends are usually off limits; you don't have to own a car and waste hours in traffic depending on where you live, etc.) Furthermore, the rest of what you said is painting hundreds of thousands of business across more than 30 countries with the same brush. I work in a European company, and it's nothing like that. You shouldn't generalise like that.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> What about time off? Pension? Parental leave? Medical costs? For top engineers, that's not really a concern in America.
- kazen44 6y agowhich is not the argument I think is important. I want healthcare for those around me aswell! why is this healthcare not an option for those in society who are less able to work or are good at jobs which are not engineering/high paying? art and education is a good example of this. without either, a society is reduced to nothing. why do these not deserve proper healthcare? because the free market has decided they are not worth it?
- blaser-waffle 6y agoAll of the downvotes are saying a lot about HN, lol.
- intev 6y agoOh wow, I didn't realize there's such a huge discrepancy in salary.
- csunbird 6y agoYup. The average salary for a junior (e.g. with 1 to 3 years experienced) developer is around 45-50k Euro gross. You can get very exceptional and very experienced engineers for 90-100k Euro gross annually.
- 908B64B197 6y agoWhy not simply come to SV?
- dukeyukey 6y agoIt's not that easy. Even if you already work for a US company, and that company is willing to sponsor you, and you win the visa lottery, it can take years to move to the US, and many years after that to get a green card. And at any point something could go wrong, your company screws up paperwork or something, and you get sent back to the start.
- 908B64B197 6y agoLots of talented EU Engineers do it. Maybe some EU countries should look into getting a better deals for their citizen trying to go abroad.
- dukeyukey 6y agoAt a macro level, sure. At a personal level, it's not easy. As far as I know, only Mexico, Canada and Australia have preferred access to US visas for their citizens (though I'm hoping the UK will join them during trade deal negotiations).
- kazen44 6y agobecause leaving behind the people and community around me is not worth the money and work/life balance? also, the US has a political and social problem which make it a place I would not want to live.
- rapsey 6y agoTo be fair funding options for US companies compared to EU ones is absurd. US tech is swimming in money compared to EU tech.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agowhich is what the thread is about - US tech is swimming in money partly because the US supported their tech industry to the point where it became a big monster swimming in money, at which point the brains in EU drain off to the money oceans of the US.
- passivate 6y agoI wonder how much of the easy access to credit in the US is simply the strength of the dollar - we keep printing more $$ but the dollar doesn't devalue as much. Add to the fact that our poor interest rates on savings accounts makes private equity investments the only means to increase wealth.
- rapsey 6y agoThe joys of being a reserve currency.
- 908B64B197 6y agoEU investors are way too conservative.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI did think of working for a FAANG, but they don't really do much in my corner of Europe (there's a group working on Docs and similar in Germany but I don't want to move to Germany), and they are scary in that they seem to aim for the university high-achievers. I don't want to have to learn leetcode for a job interview, knowing full well that leetcode is not the day job there either. Plus I like being (or ok, feeling) productive, instead of spending 99% of my time on politics, analysis and waiting for small code changes.
- smueller1234 6y agoYou seem to have looked at Google specifically (mention of Docs). Google has substantial engineering presence in several european countries. Just a few cities/countries off the top of my head in no specific order: Munich, Zürich, London, Dublin, Warsaw. There's others, IIRC a bit on Stockholm for example, but I think those I named after among the larger presences. Anyway. Not just Germany. There's also SRE, which has a slightly different twang on how we spend our time and then interview makeup. For what it's worth, I'm not a computer science grad at all and I'm doing just fine at Google. Got hired as a senior manager, though, so YMMV. Not trying to convince you of anything, just trying to be helpful. :)
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoOut of curiosity what education/career path did you follow to get to your current position?
- langitbiru 6y agoI think you can replace EU with "the rest of the world". In Asia, we are also jealous of Silicon Valley. Obligatory article: https://alexdanco.com/2021/01/11/why-the-canadian-tech-scene-doesnt-work/ https://alexdanco.com/2021/01/11/why-the-canadian-tech-scene...
- MichaelZuo 6y agoWell I’m sure it’s possible to attract really good folks at low salaries even in SEA/Japan/SK/Taiwan/India/etc. if folks are compensated with significant ownership stakes instead. It’s about what the business owners are willing to do.
- 908B64B197 6y agoWhy doesn't Canada simply... compete? Honestly, bragging your engineers are worth 50K less while pitching for HQ2 won't stop their brain drain.
- newbie578 6y agoI didn't know this, it is quite sad in fact if true. Do you have some more info?
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoIn almost every EU tech hub you will find a Huawei lab and usually a stone throw way from their major western competition (Nokia, Ericsson, ARM, Imagination) and in Paris, Apple hires cryptographers from ANSSI, the French National Cybersecurity Agency (France's NSA) to work on their DRM and Apple Pay.
- pas 6y agoWhy would this be sad? Comparative advantages are useful. If they are doing something we don't like, we have to address that. (Eg. child labor, unsafe work conditions, carbon tariff if they don't have a carbon tax.) In itself there's absolutely no problem with having an R&D hub in the EU for a US or Chinese company.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoWhy is it sad? Global market at work.
- nabla9 6y agoSame in the US (Santa Clara CA, Plano TX, and Bridgetwater NJ) They are currently moving their US R&D to their Canada research centre due to sanctions. All international companies have R&D all around the world. ps. It's not stealing when you do R&D in foreign country.
- raverbashing 6y agoI mostly agree, though to be honest several EU companies dug their own graves. How long since you've heard about anything relevant on the market from "Big German electronics manufacturer" (wink)? And from "Big Dutch electronics manufacturer" (though this one seems to be still around in some areas)? And if Huawei pays good salaries then other companies better get on with it, right? Competition is competition. Only management can give the direction, the focus and the urgency needed and the European companies were awful at it.
- i_am_proteus 6y agoASML, a Dutch semiconductor company, is a titan in the fab business. TSMC might be the world leader is chip fabrication, but the kit that they use is Dutch-sourced.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoASML gets mentioned so often as counter example to EU's downfall in tech that all it does it prove the point. One drop of water doesn't mean it's raining.
- mschuster91 6y ago> One drop of water doesn't mean it's raining. The German Mittelstand is famous for their "hidden champions" - in fact, 48% of small-ish "world market leaders" are German, while only 28 of the big "Top 500" are (per https://www.bbc.com/news/business-40796571 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-40796571). The problems with our Mittelstand are a) modern IT technologies (the amount of Mittelstand companies operating on fax-ed POs or with extremely shoddy IT setups is... mind blowing) and b) finding new and competent staff, given that many young people move to cities because the rural areas are unliveable.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoTBH, as a SW engineer who used to work in family owned Mittelstand companies, those places are the worst you can choose to work in and no wonder they can't find employees willing to work for them anymore. Good riddance!
- chrisseaton 6y agoAs a British person, I'm very happy working for North American companies, but it's a bit of a shame that I have to do that to find interesting and reasonably paid work with pleasant conditions. I wish we could generate our own companies with the initiative and ambition of those in North American to do meaningful computer science work. Nobody seems to even be trying. (Don't try to suggest ARM is an option - their pay is really uncompetitive.)
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> Don't try to suggest ARM is an option - their pay is really uncompetitive. Off-topic but: Is that so? For some reason I always thought they were on par with the American high-paying companies.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI'm probably exaggerating in my memory, but I think I recall seeing an internship offer from ARM that was the same daily rate as Oracle were offering hourly.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- consp 6y agoIt's not just ARM, many European companies don't pay well. Especially for engineers and developers. In Europe you have to be management to get payed anything substantial. Though most management is still doing the jobs which any engineer could combine with their work and probably do equally well or better.
- dsnr 6y ago> many European companies don't pay well. Especially for engineers and developers. You have to take into account the fact that in Europe the state takes a big chunk of your gross salary (probably around 50%) in form of social contributions and other taxes, to cover things like healthcare, unemployment, pension, welfare, parental leave and so on. In the US you have to cover these things yourself most of the time. So while most people praise the European system they would like at the same time to earn as much as their US counterparts, which is unrealistic tbh. As the saying goes, "you can't have your cake and..."
- oytis 6y ago> Europe dug it's own grave here by not funding its domestic tech sector enough But nobody was funding Apple. U.S. just created the environment where tech business can thrive and let the competition do the rest. EU market on the contrary is still controlled by century-old companies. From my (not that long) experience with German tech job market, I've got an impression that US-based companies normally have better (more open, more inclusive, more developer-centric) culture and better compensation.
- ginko 6y ago>But nobody was funding Apple. U.S. just created the environment where tech business can thrive and let the competition do the rest. EU market on the contrary is still controlled by century-old companies. The US tech sector is essentially pegged by the petrodollar. Countries have to use the dollar to sell oil and then invest their excess dollars in the US economy.
- oytis 6y agoWhat about Chinese tech sector? Yes, there is a lot of protectionism exercised by the Chinese government, but still Huawei and other big players are not funded by the government, they have to compete really hard to survive.
- ginko 6y ago>but still Huawei and other big players are not funded by the government What makes you think that?
- pjc50 6y ago> Europe dug its own grave here by not funding its domestic tech sector enough Is the argument that (one of): - the EU budget should be expanded to directly subsidise tech companies, or take equity ownership in companies, using taxpayer money - individual EU companies should do the same sort of state capitalism, using taxpayer money, and probably violating EU rules on state aid - EU investment funds should deliberately select less profitable investments for nationalist reasons - the small group of hyper-wealthy globalised investors such as Softbank (Japan) that currently hand out ridiculous sums to SV companies should hand them out to EU companies instead, because .. reasons I have very ambivalent views about this myself, but if you want EU state capitalism to compete with Chinese state capitalism then please say so and we can gang up on the doctrinaire free market lot. The UK is very odd sometimes; I have a half-SV-salary and it puts me in the 97%ile of UK pay. The only people who seem to be well paid are footballers and company directors, yet London house prices are set by the marginal oligarch.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoAnd finance people. Like, when I worked for a FAANG we found it hard to get senior people as the company wouldn't benchmark against finance companies, thus no-one would work for them. Additionally, the late hours necessary in a satellite office don't map well to senior+ people, as they will often have families and children.
- dukeyukey 6y agoHah, my first job out of uni had this problem. We were the UK office of a medium-sized Seattle-headquartered tech company. One of our department heads got a job at a fintech not long after I left, and gradually poached the rest of his team. Despite the salary raise being like 70%, the company refused to benchmark against them, because the were Central London, and we were Outer London. I ended up jumping ship a couple of years later to that fintech, that 70% raise was lovely.
- nisa 6y ago> Europe dug it's own grave here by not funding its domestic tech sector enough and sleeping at the wheel while US and China were stealing their lunch from underneath their nose. IMHO it's not a failure of the technology skills but rather a huge failure of the elites and management (and how management is educated in European universities) - everything was sourced out and lot's of small companies died due to mismanagement - also instead of nurturing the highly educated former east-bloc countries they were crushed by neoliberal politics to avoid having more competition for western european firms. So the whole of eastern europe became a factory hall for management in the west.
- throwaway9870 6y agoI used to work at a large US tech company known for making a lot of acquisitions. One time I was assisting with one and was having drinks with the VP coordinating a lot of this growth and he explained he would never acquire a French company because of the labor laws. Now, he was a German, so take that with a grain of salt :) However, the key point here is the same story we see repeated all the time: simple things such as labor laws protecting employees can backfire in unexpected ways. I am not claiming I have the answer or the French laws are wrong, just presenting a data point. Nevertheless, this is HN, so I expect people how dumb I am and how I have no idea what I am talking about. Fire away.
- oauea 6y agoHow is that a backfire? Sounds like the employees were sufficiently protected from a company that clearly had no intention of following said law.
- throwaway9870 6y agoThe company is a multi-billion dollar company that absolutely follows all employment laws. They just didn't want to deal with the French laws.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoAnd yet Apple, Microsoft, SAP and Facebook have offices in Paris. What's up with that then? This shows that even giant US and German companies can work with French labor laws just fine otherwise they wouldn't be there. So, to me, this whole current push in the west to drive down labor laws in the sake of "staying competitive" is just a big globalization scam on the working class and a backtrack of all the quality of life progress made from years of struggle by previous generations. Good for France for not giving in!
- volkl48 6y agoWhat are the size of those offices? (I don't know the answer to this question). Every multinational company of a sufficient size is going to have "an office" in a major developed country. The question to me is whether or not that office is employing more than the minimum required for the company to sell products in that country. If your "office" is just local sales and support, some lawyers for local legal issues, etc, I don't think that's a strong case. Do they do substantial R&D there? Are there new products that come out developed by "Microsoft Paris"? Etc.
- RGamma 6y agoYou'd hope "European top minds" would have different things on their mind than mere money. (have given up hope for our US friends) Virtually none of the discoveries that fundamentally changed the world were _driven_ by thoughts about that mindnumbing thing. It really kills ingenuity and curiosity
- calgoo 6y agoWell, if you have to worry about money every month because you are living month to month, then yes money is important. This is the situation in many EU countries.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoThere you are, dreaming of this awesome new thing that will be amazeballs while eating ramen in your shitty flat. Then someone comes and offers you a ton of money to go think about some other stuff for a few years. You figure you can always come back to thinking about the awesome thing, but a few years of eating decent food and living in decent housing would be nice.
- RGamma 6y agoThis sound like you're living in a not-so-developed (part of the) country though? Sorry if that's the case, but from my experience living in Germany you can easily afford decent food (in fact there's little bad food, except the artificial American stuff) and housing while going to uni for free (you might even apply for BaFöG and stipends). This would especially apply to you as a bright person.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoI wasn't really talking about me, more about a hypothetical researcher and the decision they might have to make when faced with this
- RGamma 6y agoMhh fair enough, guess I'm just a fan of ideals in science.
- anovikov 6y agoIt's not about funding, it's about culture. In Europe, no good developer wants to work at a startup - they want to work in a large century-old semi-government company which provides long paid vacations, slow work pace and work-life balance. No one wants to fund a startup either. Almost no way to exit. And whole "industry disruption" thing is even inappropriate to talk about - you are supposed to go with the flow and play by the numerous formal and informal rules and uphold hierarchy.
- nisa 6y agoThe reason is also pretty simple: Most german startups I've seen were some more or less (mostly less) good ideas from rich economics students - and they are looking for developers that are badly paid, get little benefits and have to work out all the issues - as a thank you, they get nothing in return if they are sold or die. Additionally it's extremely hard to get funding - there are some programs like EXIST - www.exist.de but this is also shaped pretty much for economics students and offers little help for a technical startup.
- anovikov 6y agoIt is commonly accepted that it is business people who build businesses, and technical people are replaceable and should be hired as cheaply and easy to dump as possible, and not approached seriously. Sometimes literally lowest bidder gets the job. Same thing in Russia. In almost every startup i saw here in Cy started by Russians, founders have no idea how to code. They mostly siphon off cash from someone rich and dumb enough. Naturally technical part doesn't matter all that much to them.
- jacknews 6y ago"founders have no idea how to code. They mostly siphon off cash from someone rich and dumb enough. " This seem to be common model worldwide.
- dukeyukey 6y agoI can promise you this doesn't hold across at least some of "Europe". Take where I work, London, for example. The stuff places like the BBC and GDS (Government Digital Service) are doing are pretty cool, but companies like Monzo, DeepMind and Revolut are the ones people talk about, plus the financial giants like JP Morgan and Bloomberg.
- chmod775 6y ago>that EUs best and brightest minds, educated with EU money are helping strengthen the Chinese and US tech titans It goes farther than that. Universities in many EU countries are essentially free, even for foreign students. About 30% of students at my university in Berlin are foreign, coming from mostly Asian, Arabian, and American countries. And you know what? I wouldn't change a thing about it. This "us vs. them", or more accurately "US vs. them" attitude needs to stop.
- iorrus 6y agoWill be very interesting to see how these two different ideologies play out over the coming years. According to the article Huawei favours ethnic Chinese over Europeans especially at management level and I’ve heard the same about TikTok so we have a great opportunity to watch how these competing visions play out
- trinix912 6y ago> even for foreign students This is not completely true, it only applies to students from other EU/EEA countries. There are some exceptions for a few other european countries but apart from those, international students still have to pay the tuition.
- trumpeta 6y agocorrect, but the tuition is peanuts compared to US or in some cases places like India.
- chmod775 6y ago> This is not completely true, it only applies to students from other EU/EEA countries. This is incorrect (for Germany) unless you want to go to a university in Baden-Württemberg (one of the 16 states of Germany), which introduced tuition for international students in 2017. Everywhere else you will pay virtually the same fees[1] as a German national (<1k euro/year), except that you may be required to pay into a 'security fund' for international students if you have the means, which helps less-well-off international students or those who have fallen on hard times to pay those same fees. Take the TU Berlin as an example: https://www.tu.berlin/en/studying/studienorganisation/finanzierung/ https://www.tu.berlin/en/studying/studienorganisation/finanz... [1] Note that these fees are not tuition. About half of them pays for a greatly discounted public transport ticket, the other half for an assortment of smaller things.
- throwarayes 6y agoHistorically, US has been a large homogeneous market, compared to Europe where there’s been more separation between French, German, Spanish, UK, markets. This really changes how the market works in Europe. You can simply make one product in the US and be successful marketing to 330 million people. In Europe, however, you find There’s well established brands in each country. Perhaps only in the last 1-2 decades have brands like Easy jet been able to penetrate across Europe to a certain pan-Europe generation. Even there people want to do business in their own native languages and cultures quite often
- raxxorrax 6y agoNot sure if the brightest minds end up at Huawei, because while the pay might be good, bright people might know that they need to expect different standards. Some do it for the money for a few years of course. Often when we talk about tech, we talk about pop-tech. Aside from social media, chip giants like Intel or TSMC are the topic. The machines they use are build in the Netherlands by a company very few people know by name. Sure, the chip design is perhaps the essence, but I believe that US companies are just good at marketing, Chinas companies are good at scale. Europe has many world market leader in the middle class. It is a misconception that you end up with a business titan in such a position. It doesn't generate press, but I believe this is a far better foundation for an economy compared to having some superstars. Although the US has certainly a lot of really good high tech. For example Texas Instruments has incredible tech just in their drawers, but they generate comparatively few headlines.
- sangnoir 6y agoNokia, Siemens and Alcatel were trail-blazing European companies: they went toe-to-toe with Motorola and... I was going to say Nortel, but they were Canadian. Nokia (handset division) and Alcatel were bought-out by American companies (or merged). The EU let American money buy-out their crown jewels.
- lokar 6y agoThey were in serious decline by the time of the buyout.
- 908B64B197 6y agoWhy doesn't Europe simply... compete? Buy tech instead of offering endless (paperwork intensive) subsidies. Harmonize markets so you can just sell everywhere without having to fund the local civil servant union by filling the new-and-special-snowflake paperwork for every country you want to sell to.
- saiya-jin 6y agoEurope is pretty corrupt in this regard. What you suggest would have to be approved by the very same people that massively benefit from this fragmentation and endless debates on every topic where everybody roots only for themselves/their benefactor/their country. Not going to happen, however sad it makes me as european. EU is good for quite a few things, but this ain't one of them.
- stingraycharles 6y agoCould you elaborate more on your “this is because Europe is corrupt” claim? I like to think European politics is not much more flawed than American politics, and would like to see such a claim backed up with some actual evidence. I personally like to think Europe is very different from the US culturally, in that the countries themselves are much less aligned than the US states are. I would never consider corruption to be the cause of this, as much as it’s mostly about the egos of the individual countries and citizens.
- saiya-jin 6y agoCorruption has many faces, it doesn't have to pipe all the money straight to 'Ndrangheta bank accounts. Rooting for sub-optimal solutions (overpriced, subpar quality but company from given state) compared to best one is frequent. Rooting for choices that favor ie large agricultural producers say from France/Spain/Italy, or some multinational based in Netherland and forcing restrictions on all member states is common too. Hardly the best choice for regular citizens who just always foot the extra bill. Heck, we have tons of legal lobbyists in Brusel, what do you think is their sole source of (very good) income? On national level, the more you go to the east, the more corrupt the state themselves are, ie previous government of Slovakia stepped down exactly due to too close ties to Italian mafia (and a murder of journalist+girlfriend who investigated this). Why Italian mafia you may ask? Well to pipe all the money coming from EU dotations into 'friendly' companies that deliver little and take a lot. Classic laundering of dirty money, this time done by state itself. All eastern states within EU have some non-trivial level of this. I wouldn't compare EU and US politics directly, both are corrupt in some aspect and not so much in others (ie US and its 'defensive' market used only very offensively, board members of those companies being former politicians and vice versa). Still better than 3rd world obviously, or places like former soviet republics (not sure if 2nd world countries is the proper term for those).
- gumby 6y agoBut these folks have jobs in the EU, often close to home, and pay their taxes where they live -- isn't that the point of the government spending?